Second malignancies in thyroid cancer patients: a population-based survey of 3658 cases from Norway

Breast Cancer After Treatment of Differentiated Thyroid Cancer With Radioiodine in Young Females: What We Know and How to Investigate Open Questions. Review of the Literature and Results of a Multi-Registry Survey

Published studies on the risk of radiation-induced second primary malignancy (SPM) after radioiodine treatment (RAI) of differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) refer mainly to patients treated as middle-aged or older adults and are not easily generalizable to those treated at a younger age. Here we review available literature on the risk of breast cancer as an SPM after RAI of DTC with a focus on females undergoing such treatment in childhood, adolescence, or young adulthood. Additionally, we report the results of a preliminary international survey of patient registries from academic tertiary referral centers specializing in pediatric DTC. The survey sought to evaluate the availability of sufficient patient data for a potential international multicenter observational case-control study of females with DTC given RAI at an early age. Our literature review identified a bi-directional association of DTC and breast cancer. The general breast cancer risk in adult DTC survivors is low, ~2%, slightly higher in females than in males, but presumably lower, not higher, in those diagnosed as children or adolescents than in those diagnosed at older ages. RAI presumably does not substantially influence breast cancer risk after DTC. However, data from patients given RAI at young ages are sparse and insufficient to make definitive conclusions regarding age dependence of the risk of breast cancer as a SPM after RAI of DTC. The preliminary analysis of data from 10 thyroid cancer registries worldwide, including altogether 6,449 patients given RAI for DTC and 1,116 controls, i.e., patients not given RAI, did not show a significant increase of breast cancer incidence after RAI. However, the numbers of cases and controls were insufficient to draw statistically reliable conclusions, and the proportion of those receiving RAI at the earliest ages was too low.In conclusion, a potential international multicenter study of female patients undergoing RAI of DTC as children, adolescents, or young adults, with a sufficient sample size, is feasible. However, breast cancer screening of a larger cohort of DTC patients is not unproblematic for ethical reasons, due to the likely, at most slightly, increased risk of breast cancer post-RAI and the expected ~10% false-positivity rate which potentially produced substantial "misdiagnosis."

Second Primary Cancer Risk among Kidney Cancer Patients in Korea: A Population-Based Cohort Study

PURPOSE

Secondary primary cancers (SPCs) commonly arise in patients with renal cell carcinoma (RCC). We designed the present study to estimate the SPC incidence in Korean patients with RCC.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study cohort was population-based and consisted of 40,347 individuals from the Korean Central Cancer Registry who were diagnosed with primary renal cancer between 1993 and 2013. Standardized incidence ratios (SIRs) for SPCs were estimated for different ages at diagnosis, latencies, diagnostic periods, and treatments.

RESULTS

For patients with primary RCC, the risk of developing a SPC was higher than the risk of developing cancer in the general population (SIR, 1.13; 95% confidence interval, 1.08 to 1.18). Most cancer types showed higher incidences in patients with RCC than in the general population. However, the relative incidence of gastric cancer as an SPC varied by age. Gastric cancer incidence was elevated in young patients (< 30 years) with RCC, but reduced in older (≥ 30) patients with RCC. Patients with advanced RCC died prematurely, regardless of SPC development. In contrast, those with early-stage RCC survived for longer periods, although SPC development affected their post-RCC survival. After SPC development, women had better survival than men.

CONCLUSION

In Korean patients with primary RCC, the incidence of SPC was 13% higher than the incidence of cancer in the general population. These findings may play important roles in the conduct of follow-up evaluations and education for patients with RCC.

Risk of Second Primary Malignancy after Radioactive Iodine Treatment for Differentiated Thyroid Carcinoma

Objectives:

The association between second primary malignancy (SPM) and radioactive iodine (RAI) is controversial. We examined the association between RAI and SPM after treatment of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) using a large cohort from a national cancer database.

Methods:

From the Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Results (SEER) database, all index cases of DTC (papillary or follicular) were extracted for the years 1988 to 2001. Two cohorts were constructed: 1) patients with DTC who were not treated with RAI, and 2) patients with DTC who were treated with RAI. For each cohort, we tabulated all subsequent malignancies for each patient, identifying patients in each group with 1 or more SPMs.

Results:

According to inclusion criteria, 18,882 cases of DTC treated without RAI (mean follow-up, 55.5 months) and 10,349 cases treated with RAI (mean follow-up, 61.8 months) were identified. The most common SPM sites were breast or prostate followed by colon or lung for both groups. On univariate analysis, SPMs developed in 6.7% of patients without RAI versus 4.8% of those with RAI (p > .001, univariate χ2). However, on multivariate analysis, only age and male gender had statistically significant hazard ratios (1.052 and 1.438, respectively; p > .001); follicular carcinoma histology and use of RAI did not influence occurrence of SPM after DTC (p = .180 and p = .789, respectively).

Conclusions:

Use of RAI does not elevate the risk of SPM. Concern about SPM induction should not adversely affect the decision to administer RAI for DTC.

Incidence of second primary malignancies during a long-term surveillance of patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma in relation to radioiodine treatment

PURPOSE

Controversies remain over the actual risk of developing a second primary malignancy (SPM) as a consequence of I-131 treatment in patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC). The objective of this study was to evaluate the adjusted rate and risk estimate of SPM in radioiodine-treated patients after controlling for confounding factors.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted on 973 cases randomly selected from a population of 9550 radioiodine-treated DTC patients. The cases with prior or coincident nonthyroid malignancies and those with SPM during the first 3 years of the initial I-131 treatment were not included. Age-standardized rate of SPM and its 95% confidence interval (CI) during a median of 6 (3-26) years follow-up in DTC patients was compared with that of the general population. A logistic multivariable analysis was also conducted to identify the potential covariate factors that might influence the risk of SPM.

RESULTS

Eleven patients from 7370 person-years at risk developed an SPM. The standardized rate ratio of nonthyroid malignancy was 0.81 (95% CI, 0.57-1.04) for the studied patients relative to the general population. The cumulative dose of I-131 more than 40 GBq (1.08 Ci) was the sole factor associated with increased odds of SPM, after adjusting for age, follow-up duration, histology of DTC, presence of metastasis, and history of external radiotherapy (odds ratio, 113; 95% CI, 8.6-1495.6; P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

The overall rate of SPMs was not significantly increased after a minimum interval of 3 years from the first I-131 treatment; however, the chance of this event may be radically increased in patients who had received a cumulative activity of I-131 exceeding 40 GBq (1.08 Ci).

Can we reduce the incidence of second primary malignancies occurring after radiotherapy? A critical review

Second primary malignancies (SPMs) occurring after oncological treatment have become a major concern during the past decade. Their incidence has long been underestimated because most patients had a short life expectancy after treatment or their follow-up was shorter than 15 years. With major improvement of long-term survival, longer follow-up, cancer registries and end-result programs, it was found that the cumulative incidence of SPM could be as high as 20% of patients treated by radiotherapy. This cumulative proportion varies with several factors, which ought to be studied more accurately. The delay between irradiation and solid tumor emergence is seldom shorter than 10 years and can be as long as half a century. Thus, inclusion in a cohort of patients with a short follow-up leads to an underestimation of the proportion of SPM caused by treatment, unless actuarial cumulative incidence is computed. The incidence varies with the tissue and organs, the age of the patient at treatment, hereditary factors, but also, and probably mainly, with dose distribution, size of the irradiated volume, dose, and dose-rate. An effort toward a reduction in their incidence is mandatory. Preliminary data suggest that SPMs are mainly observed in tissues having absorbed doses above 2 Gy (fractionated irradiation) and that their incidence increases with the dose. However, in children thyroid and breast cancers are observed following doses as low as 100 mGy, and in adults lung cancers have been reported for doses of 500 mGy, possibly due to interaction with tobacco. The dose distribution and the dose per fraction have a major impact. However, the preliminary data regarding these factors need confirmation. Dose-rates appear to be another important factor. Some data suggest that certain patients, who could be identified, have a high susceptibility to radiocancer induction. Efforts should be made to base SPM reduction on solid data and not on speculation or models built on debatable hypotheses regarding the dose-carcinogenic effect relationship. In parallel, radiation therapy philosophy must evolve, and the aim of treatment should be to deliver the minimal effective radiation therapy rather than the maximal tolerable dose.

The risk of second primary malignancies up to three decades after the treatment of differentiated thyroid cancer

BACKGROUND

The 10-yr survival rate of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer exceeds 90%. These patients may be at elevated risk for secondary cancers.

METHODS

The risk of nonthyroid second primary malignancies after differentiated thyroid cancer was determined in 30,278 patients diagnosed between 1973 and 2002 from centers participating in the National Cancer Institute's Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results program. Median follow-up was 103 months (range, 2-359 months). Risk was further assessed for the addition of radioisotope therapy, gender, latency to development of secondary cancer, and age at thyroid cancer diagnosis.

RESULTS

There were 2158 patients who developed a total of 2338 nonthyroid second primary malignancies, significantly more than that expected in the general population [observed/expected (O/E) = 1.09; 95% confidence interval (CI), 1.05-1.14; P < 0.05; absolute excess risk per 10,000 person-years (AER) = 6.39]. A significantly greater risk of second primary malignancies over that expected in the general population was for patients treated with radioisotopes (O/E = 1.20; 95% CI, 1.07-1.33; AER = 11.8) as well as for unirradiated patients (O/E = 1.05; 95% CI, 1.00-1.10; AER = 3.53). However, the increased risk was greater for the irradiated vs. the unirradiated cohort (relative risk = 1.16; 95% CI, 1.05-1.27; P < 0.05). Gender did not affect risk. The greatest risk of second primary cancers occurred within 5 yr of diagnosis and was elevated for younger patients.

CONCLUSIONS

The overall risk of second primary malignancies is increased for thyroid cancer survivors and varies by radioisotope therapy, latency, and age at diagnosis.

Second primary malignancy risk in thyroid cancer survivors: a systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

To determine the risk of second primary malignancies (SPMs) in thyroid cancer survivors.

DESIGN

We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis examining the standardized incidence ratios (SIRs) of SPMs in thyroid cancer survivors (compared to individuals without thyroid cancer). Two independent reviewers screened citations and reviewed all full-text papers deemed potentially relevant. Final consensus was reached on inclusion of papers in the review. Data were pooled using fixed effects models.

MAIN OUTCOMES

Thirteen full-text papers were included. The incidence of SPMs in thyroid cancer survivors was increased with an SIR of 1.20 (95% confidence interval 1.17, 1.24) (based on pooled data from six studies of 70,844 thyroid cancer survivors). The SIR of the following SPMs was significantly increased: salivary gland, stomach, colon/colorectal, breast, prostate, kidney, brain/central nervous system, soft tissue sarcoma, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, multiple myeloma, leukemia, bone/joints, and adrenal. A significantly reduced risk of lung and cervical cancers was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Thyroid cancer survivors are at increased risk of SPMs, which may be related to disease-specific treatments or genetic predisposition.

Second primary cancers in thyroid cancer patients: a multinational record linkage study

CONTEXT

Increasing incidence and improved prognosis of thyroid cancer have led to concern about the development of second primary cancers, especially after radioiodine treatment. Thyroid cancer can also arise as a second primary neoplasm after other cancers.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to assess the risk of second primary cancer after thyroid cancer and vice versa.

DESIGN

This was a multinational record linkage study.

SETTING

The study was conducted at 13 population-based cancer registries in Europe, Canada, Australia, and Singapore.

PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS

A cohort of 39,002 people (356,035 person-yr of follow-up) with primary thyroid cancer were followed up for SPN for up to 25 yr, and 1,990 cases of thyroid cancer were diagnosed after another primary cancer.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

To assess any possible excess of second primary neoplasms after thyroid cancer, the observed numbers of neoplasms were compared with expected numbers derived from age-, sex-, and calendar period-specific cancer incidence rates from each of the cancer registries, yielding standardized incidence ratios (SIRs). The SIR of second primary thyroid cancer after various types of cancer was also calculated.

RESULTS

During the observation period, there were 2821 second primary cancers (all sites combined) after initial diagnosis of thyroid cancer, SIR of 1.31 (95% confidence interval 1.26-1.36) with significantly elevated risks for many specific cancers. Significantly elevated risks of second primary thyroid cancer were also seen after many types of cancer.

CONCLUSION

Pooled data from 13 cancer registries show a 30% increased risk of second primary cancer after thyroid cancer and increased risks of thyroid cancer after various primary cancers. Although bias (detection, surveillance, misclassification) and chance may contribute to some of these observations, it seems likely that shared risk factors and treatment effects are implicated in many. When following up patients who have been treated for primary thyroid cancer, clinicians should maintain a high index of suspicion for second primary cancers.

Elevation of thyroid cancer risk among cutaneous melanoma survivors

Recent molecular studies have identified recurrent BRAF mutations in both cutaneous melanoma and thyroid malignancies. This relatively selective shared genetic vulnerability raises the possibility that these 2 tumors are connected through a common undisclosed pathogenic mechanism. To assess for possible associations between these 2 genetically related tumors at the population level, we calculated standardized incidence ratios (SIRs) for thyroid cancer (TC) among cutaneous melanoma (CM) survivors and CM among TC survivors using the National Cancer Institute's Surveillance, Epidemiology and End Result (SEER) database. Between 1973 and 2000, there were 73,274 and 27,138 cases of CM and TC cases, respectively. Overall, we found a 2.17-fold increase (p < 0.0000001) in the risk of TC after a diagnosis of CM. This augmented risk of TC is somewhat higher for males, for those diagnosed more recently and for the first 3 years after the CM diagnosis. We also detected a considerably smaller and borderline significant increased risk of CM (25%, p = 0.063) among the post-TC survivors. Of note, TC patients who received radiation therapy had a 57% increased risk of a subsequent CM (p = 0.034). Our study documents a strong unilateral risk of TC after CM. More studies are clearly needed to better delineate this mechanism.

Thyroid cancer and multiple primary tumors in the SEER cancer registries

Thyroid cancer incidence rates have increased steadily in the United States and elsewhere. Radiation exposure at a young age is a strong risk factor, but otherwise the etiology is unclear. To explore etiologic clues, we studied the risk of thyroid cancer after an earlier primary cancer, as well as the risk of developing multiple primaries after an earlier thyroid cancer in the U.S. Surveillance, Epidemiology and End-Results (SEER) cancer registries program (1973-2000). In 2,036,597 patients diagnosed with any invasive cancer who survived for a minimum of 2 months, we observed a 42% increased risk compared to the general population for second thyroid cancer based on 1,366 cases (95% confidence interval (CI) = 35-50%; excess absolute risk (EAR) = 0.38/10,000 person-years (PY)). Elevated risks were observed after most cancer sites studied. The most pronounced excess (observed/expected (O/E) = 2.86) was seen for second thyroid cancers detected in the year after diagnosis of the first cancer. Among 29,456 2-month thyroid cancer survivors, 2,214 second cancers occurred (O/E = 1.11, 95% CI = 1.06-1.15; EAR = 7.64/10,000 PY). Again, the highest risk was seen in the first year (O/E = 1.26). Patients <40 years of age at diagnosis of thyroid cancer had a 39% increased risk of a second cancer, whereas for older patients the risk was elevated 6%. We observed consistently increased risks for cancers of the breast, prostate, and kidney, and a likely radiation treatment-related excess of leukemia. Based on small numbers of cases, cancers of the salivary glands, trachea, scrotum, adrenal glands, and brain and central nervous system (CNS) also occurred in excess. A decreased risk was observed for smoking-related malignancies. Thyroid cancer is associated with primary cancers of many different organs. Although enhanced medical surveillance likely plays a role, 2-way, positive associations between thyroid cancer and cancers of the breast, prostate, kidney, salivary glands, brain and CNS, scrotum, and leukemia suggest etiologic similarities and possible treatment effects.

Second primary malignancies in thyroid cancer patients

The late health effects associated with radioiodine ((131)I) given as treatment for thyroid cancer are difficult to assess since the number of thyroid cancer patients treated at each centre is limited. The risk of second primary malignancies (SPMs) was evaluated in a European cohort of thyroid cancer patients. A common database was obtained by pooling the 2-year survivors of the three major Swedish, Italian, and French cohorts of papillary and follicular thyroid cancer patients. A time-dependent analysis using external comparison was performed. The study concerned 6841 thyroid cancer patients, diagnosed during the period 1934-1995, at a mean age of 44 years. In all, 17% were treated with external radiotherapy and 62% received (131)I. In total, 576 patients were diagnosed with a SPM. Compared to the general population of each of the three countries, an overall significantly increased risk of SPM of 27% (95% CI: 15-40) was seen in the European cohort. An increased risk of both solid tumours and leukaemias was found with increasing cumulative activity of (131)I administered, with an excess absolute risk of 14.4 solid cancers and of 0.8 leukaemias per GBq of (131)I and 10(5) person-years of follow-up. A relationship was found between (131)I administration and occurrence of bone and soft tissue, colorectal, and salivary gland cancers. These results strongly highlight the necessity to delineate the indications of (131)I treatment in thyroid cancer patients in order to restrict its use to patients in whom clinical benefits are expected.

Cytological and immunocytochemical evaluation of thyroid and breast masses in patients with a previous neoplasm: case reports

The diagnosis of secondary tumours represents one of the most important fields in the application of fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). We studied two patients, one with a history of breast cancer and one with a previous tumour of the thyroid, who showed a second mass, in the thyroid and in the breast, respectively, during follow up. The aim of our study was to evaluate if cytology, performed on FNAC smears, may distinguish a metastatic lesion from a second primary tumour, or if further immunocytochemistry should be performed. Our data demonstrate that, while cytology may be indicative of a second primary tumour, the histotype should be confirmed by immunocytochemical staining.

Second thyroid neoplasms after prophylactic cranial irradiation for acute lymphoblastic leukemia

An understanding of the pathogenesis of second cancers may help in their prevention. We report on two children who were treated for acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), with an exclusively cranial prophylactic irradiation (18 Gy) and who presented with a thyroid carcinoma (TC) 12 and 13 years later. From a thorough review of the literature of TC after ALL and of radiation-induced TC, a strong case can be made that these tumors are caused by late effects of scattered radiation. The risk is at its highest in small children. After cranial irradiation, patients require clinical monitoring of the thyroid and cervical area for nodules, continued indefinitely. We suggest that, in most cases, an alternative form of neuromeningeal prophylaxis should be offered in small children with ALL.

Second primary neoplasms in thyroid cancer patients

To determine risk patterns for second primary neoplasms after the occurrence of thyroid cancer, we conducted a retrospective cohort study of 3321 thyroid cancer patients who were operated and histologically confirmed at the Noguchi Thyroid Clinic and Hospital Foundation between 1946 and 1985. They were followed from the date of operation through the end of 1990 with an observation period from 45 to 5 years. The average observation period of the patients was 13.4 years and the follow-up rate reached 98%. The standardized mortality ratio (SMR) was computed to assess possible risk increase by cancer site. In this computation, the time period less than 5 years after operation was omitted to reduce the influence of deaths related to the original thyroid cancer. A total of 103 deaths from malignant neoplasms other than thyroid cancer were observed during this time period (SMR = 1.6, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.3-2.0). Analyses of site-specific cancer mortality revealed significantly elevated risks for the central nervous system (SMR = 16.1, CI = 5.2-37.6) and respiratory organs (SMR = 2.6, CI = 1.5-4.1). Based on a review of available medical records with histological findings, we concluded that the risk increases for these sites were most likely to be attributable to second primary neoplasms. Whether or not the patients had received radiotherapy was not significantly associated with elevated risk. Further investigations are needed to clarify the risk factors responsible for the above findings.