The estrogen receptor: a structure-based approach to the design of new specific hormone-receptor combinations

Estradiol analogs attenuate autophagy, cell migration and invasion by direct and selective inhibition of TRPML1, independent of estrogen receptors

The cation channel TRPML1 is an important regulator of lysosomal function and autophagy. Loss of TRPML1 is associated with neurodegeneration and lysosomal storage disease, while temporary inhibition of this ion channel has been proposed to be beneficial in cancer therapy. Currently available TRPML1 channel inhibitors are not TRPML isoform selective and block at least two of the three human isoforms. We have now identified the first highly potent and isoform-selective TRPML1 antagonist, the steroid 17β-estradiol methyl ether (EDME). Two analogs of EDME, PRU-10 and PRU-12, characterized by their reduced activity at the estrogen receptor, have been identified through systematic chemical modification of the lead structure. EDME and its analogs, besides being promising new small molecule tool compounds for the investigation of TRPML1, selectively affect key features of TRPML1 function: autophagy induction and transcription factor EB (TFEB) translocation. In addition, they act as inhibitors of triple-negative breast cancer cell migration and invasion.

Design, synthesis, and biological evaluation of steroidal analogs as estrogenic/anti-estrogenic agents

Series of estrone based analogs were synthetically investigated at positions C-9, C-11, C-16, and C-17 positions, to be biologically evaluated via assessment of cell proliferation, cytotoxicity, and estrogenic/anti-estrogenic activity. LA-7 and LA-10 revealed their potential to exhibit inhibitory estrogenic profile. This was further validated by Estrogen Receptor-α (ER-α) and Estrogen Receptor-β (ER-β) competitive binding assays to reveal the high selective affinity of LA-7 towards ER-α at 5.49μM, while LA-10 did not show any binding affinity towards neither ER-α nor ER-β; suggesting another mechanism for inhibition. This was validated by in silico molecular docking simulations of LA-7 to reveal the optimum binding affinity of LA-7 towards ER-α.

Nudging oligodendrocyte intrinsic signaling to remyelinate and repair: Estrogen receptor ligand effects

Demyelination in multiple sclerosis (MS) leads to significant, progressive axonal and neuronal degeneration. Currently existing immunosuppressive and immunomodulatory therapies alleviate MS symptoms and slow, but fail to prevent or reverse, disease progression. Restoration of damaged myelin sheath by replenishment of mature oligodendrocytes (OLs) should not only restore saltatory axon conduction, but also provide a major boost to axon survival. Our previous work has shown that therapeutic treatment with the modestly selective generic estrogen receptor (ER) β agonist diarylpropionitrile (DPN) confers functional neuroprotection in a chronic experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) mouse model of MS by stimulating endogenous remyelination. Recently, we found that the more potent, selective ERβ agonist indazole-chloride (Ind-Cl) improves clinical disease and motor performance. Importantly, electrophysiological measures revealed improved corpus callosal conduction and reduced axon refractoriness. This Ind-Cl treatment-induced functional remyelination was attributable to increased OL progenitor cell (OPC) and mature OL numbers. At the intracellular signaling level, transition of early to late OPCs requires ERK1/2 signaling, and transition of immature to mature OLs requires mTOR signaling; thus, the PI3K/Akt/mTOR pathway plays a major role in the late stages of OL differentiation and myelination. Indeed, therapeutic treatment of EAE mice with various ERβ agonists results in increased brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) and phosphorylated (p) Akt and p-mTOR levels. It is notable that while DPN's neuroprotective effects occur in the presence of peripheral and central inflammation, Ind-Cl is directly neuroprotective, as demonstrated by remyelination effects in the cuprizone-induced demyelination model, as well as immunomodulatory. Elucidating the mechanisms by which ER agonists and other directly remyelinating agents modulate endogenous OPC and OL regulatory signaling is critical to the development of effective remyelinating drugs. The discovery of signaling targets to induce functional remyelination will valuably contribute to the treatment of demyelinating neurological diseases, including MS, stroke, and traumatic brain and spinal cord injury.

Application of Circular Dichroism Spectroscopy to the Analysis of the Interaction Between the Estrogen Receptor Alpha and Coactivators: The Case of Calmodulin

The estrogen receptor α ligand-binding domain (ERα-LBD) binds the natural hormone 17β-estradiol (E2) to induce transcription and cell proliferation. This process occurs with the contribution of protein and peptide partners (also called coactivators) that can modulate the structure of ERα, and therefore its specificity of action. As with most transcription factors, ERα exhibits a high content of α helix, making it difficult to routinely run spectroscopic studies capable of deciphering the secondary structure of the different partners under binding conditions. Ca(2+)-calmodulin, a protein also highly structured in α-helix, is a key coactivator for ERα activity. Here, we show how circular dichroism can be used to study the interaction of ERα with Ca(2+)-calmodulin. Our approach allows the determination not only of the conformational changes induced upon complex formation but also the dissociation constant (K d) of this interaction.

Allele-specific chemical genetics: concept, strategies, and applications

The relationship between DNA and protein sequences is well understood, yet because the members of a protein family/subfamily often carry out the same biochemical reaction, elucidating their individual role in cellular processes presents a challenge. Forward and reverse genetics have traditionally been employed to understand protein functions with considerable success. A fundamentally different approach that has gained widespread application is the use of small organic molecules, known as chemical genetics. However, the slow time-scale of genetics and inherent lack of specificity of small molecules used in chemical genetics have limited the applicability of these methods in deconvoluting the role of individual proteins involved in fast, dynamic biological events. Combining the advantages of both the techniques, the specificity achieved with genetics along with the reversibility and tunability of chemical genetics, has led to the development of a powerful approach to uncover protein functions in complex biological processes. This technique is known as allele-specific chemical genetics and is rapidly becoming an essential toolkit to shed light on proteins and their mechanism of action. The current review attempts to provide a comprehensive description of this approach by discussing the underlying principles, strategies, and successful case studies. Potential future implications of this technology in expanding the frontiers of modern biology are discussed.

Impact of linker length on the activity of PROTACs

Conventional genetic approaches have provided a powerful tool in the study of proteins. However, these techniques often preclude selective manipulation of temporal and spatial protein functions, which is crucial for the investigation of dynamic cellular processes. To overcome these limitations, a small molecule-based novel technology termed "PROteolysis TArgeting ChimeraS (PROTACs)" has been developed, targeting proteins for degradation at the post-translational level. Despite the promising potential of PROTACs to serve as molecular probes of complex signaling pathways, their design has not been generalized for broad application. Here, we present the first generalized approach for PROTAC design by fine-tuning the distance between the two participating partner proteins, the E3 ubiquitin ligase and the target protein. As such, we took a chemical approach to create estrogen receptor (ER)-α targeting PROTACs with varying linker lengths and the loss of the ER in cultured cells was monitored via western blot and fluorometric analyses. We found a significant effect of chain length on PROTAC efficacy, and, in this case, the optimum distance between the E3 recognition motif and the ligand was a 16 atom chain length. The information gathered from this experiment may offer a generalizable PROTAC design strategy to further the expansion of the PROTAC toolbox, opening new possibilities for the broad application of the PROTAC strategy in the study of multiple signaling pathways.

Jostling for position: optimizing linker location in the design of estrogen receptor-targeting PROTACs

Estrogen receptor-alpha (ER) antagonists have been widely used for breast cancer therapy. Despite initial responsiveness, hormone-sensitive ER-positive cancer cells eventually develop resistance to ER antagonists. It has been shown that in most of these resistant tumor cells, the ER is expressed and continues to regulate tumor growth. Recent studies indicate that tamoxifen initially acts as an antagonist, but later functions as an ER agonist, promoting tumor growth. This suggests that targeted ER degradation may provide an effective therapeutic approach for breast cancers, even those that are resistant to conventional therapies. With this in mind, we previously demonstrated that proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) effectively induce degradation of the ER as a proof-of-concept experiment. Herein we further refined the PROTAC approach to target the ER for degradation. The ER-targeting PROTACs are composed of an estradiol on one end and a hypoxia-inducing factor 1alpha (HIF-1alpha)-derived synthetic pentapeptide on the other. The pentapeptide is recognized by an E3 ubiquitin ligase called the von Hippel Lindau tumor suppressor protein (pVHL), thereby recruiting the ER to this E3 ligase for ubiquitination and degradation. Specifically, the pentapeptide is attached at three different locations on estradiol to generate three different PROTAC types. With the pentapeptide linked through the C7alpha position of estradiol, the resulting PROTAC shows the most effective ER degradation and highest affinity for the estrogen receptor. This result provides an opportunity to develop a novel type of ER antagonist that may overcome the resistance of breast tumors to conventional drugs such as tamoxifen and fulvestrant (Faslodex).

Engineering a GPCR-ligand pair that simulates the activation of D(2L) by Dopamine

In the past decade, engineered G-protein-coupled receptors activated solely by synthetic ligands (RASSLs) have been implemented as a new means to study neurotransmission, which is controlled by G-protein-coupled receptors in vitro and in vivo. In this study, we report an engineered dopamine receptor D(2L) F390(6.52)W, which is the first identified RASSL for the dopamine receptor family. The mutant receptor is characterized by a disrupted ligand binding and complete loss of efficacy for the endogenous ligand, dopamine, which is putatively due to a sterically induced perturbation of H-bonding with conserved serine residues in TM5. Based on this model, we rationally developed an aminoindane-derived set of agonists. Because these agonists forgo analogous H-bonding functionalities, their binding energy does not depend on the respective interactions. Binding affinity and potency were optimized by ligand modifications bearing molecular appendages that obviously interact with a secondary recognition site provided by four hydrophobic residues in TM2 and TM3. Thus, the ferrocenyl carboxamide 5b (FAUC 185) was identified as a synthetic agonist that is able to stimulate the mutant receptor in a manner similar to that by which endogenous dopamine activates the D(2L) wild-type receptor. The engineered dopamine receptor D(2L) F390(6.52)W in combination with FAUC 185 (5b) provides a new tool to probe GPCR functions selectively in specific cell populations in vitro and in vivo.

Development and validation of an improved inducer-regulator protein complex in the pBRES-regulated expression system

Widespread adaptation of small molecule-regulated expression systems requires the development of selective inducer molecules that do not have any significant side effects on the endogenous receptors from which the regulated expression system is derived. Here we report the identification and in vitro validation of a novel inducer-receptor pair for the single-plasmid regulated expression system termed pBRES, which contains the ligand-binding domain from the human progesterone receptor (hPR). A small molecule inducer, BLX-913, has been identified as having a 30-fold lower IC(50) for the human progesterone receptor than mifepristone (MFP), the previously best characterized inducer for pBRES. Using modeling-guided protein engineering, compensatory mutations were installed at positions W755 and V729 (hPR numbering) in the ligand-binding pocket of the pBRES regulator protein (pBRES RP) to accommodate the new inducer and allow induction of transgene expression to levels previously seen with MFP. The improved inducer-pBRES RP complex was validated in vitro by monitoring the induction of luciferase, murine secreted alkaline phosphatase, and human interferon beta transgenes in mouse skeletal muscle cells. The engineered pBRES demonstrated low levels of transgene expression in the absence, and high expression levels in the presence, of the new BLX-913 inducer. Findings presented here allow induction of the pBRES-regulated gene expression system by a compound with markedly lower anti-hPR activity than MFP, the previously best characterized inducer.

Investigation on the interaction of tetrachloride fluorescein–bovine serum albumin-β-cyclodextrin and the determination of protein by flow injection analysis

In this paper, a simple and sensitive flow injection analysis (FIA) for the determination of protein with spectroscopic probe was developed. This method was based on the investigation of the interaction of tetrachloride fluorescein (2,4,5,7-tetrachloro-3,6-fluorandiol)-bovine serum albumin (BSA), the coupling reaction of protein with tetrachloride fluorescein (TCFS) which was used as a spectroscopic probe in the presence of beta-cyclodextrin (beta-CD). The interaction mechanism and the main factors affecting the determination were investigated in details. Under the optimum conditions, the linear range and detection limit were 0.0-28.0 microg mL(-1) and 0.76 microg mL(-1), respectively. The proposed method has been used to determine albumin in serum albumin with satisfactory results.

Neoceptors: reengineering GPCRs to recognize tailored ligands

Efforts to model and reengineer the putative binding sites of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) have led to an approach that combines small-molecule 'classical' medicinal chemistry and gene therapy. In this approach, complementary structural changes (e.g. based on novel ionic or H-bonds) are made in the receptor and ligand for the selective enhancement of affinity. Thus, a modified receptor (neoceptor) is designed for activation by tailor-made agonists that do not interact with the native receptor. The neoceptor is no longer activated by the native agonist, but rather functions as a scaffold for the docking of novel small molecules (neoligands). In theory, the approach could verify the accuracy of GPCR molecular modeling, the investigation of signaling, the design of small molecules to rescue disease-related mutations, and small-molecule-directed gene therapy. The neoceptor-neoligand pairing could offer spatial specificity by delivering the neoceptor to a target site, and temporal specificity by administering neoligand when needed.

Chemical biology of steroid and nuclear hormone receptors

The nuclear hormone receptors are ligand-gated transcription factors that modulate gene expression by directly acting upon genomic DNA, and have been of profound interest across all biological disciplines. Recent advancements in this area have included the expansion of transgene activation through ligand-receptor engineering, drug development from structural design and the exploitation of innate ligand-specific associations towards developing novel conditional protein-based recombinant and diagnostic tools. These advancements come on the heels of exciting new modes of hormone action that challenge and expand upon the classic paradigms of hormone receptor function.

A functionally orthogonal ligand-receptor pair created by targeting the allosteric mechanism of the thyroid hormone receptor

Nuclear receptors are ligand-dependent transcription factors that are of interest as potential tools to artificially regulate gene expression. Ligand binding induces a conformational change involving helix-12 which forms part of the dimerization interface used to bind transcriptional coactivators. When triiodothyronine (T3) binds the thyroid hormone receptor (TR) it indirectly contacts helix-12 through intermediary residues His(435) and Phe(451) termed a His-Phe switch. The mutant TRbeta(H435A) is nonresponsive to physiological concentrations of T3 but can be activated by the synthetic hormone analogue QH2 which potently activates His435-->Ala mutant at concentrations that do not activate the wild-type receptors TRalpha and TRbeta. QH2 does not show antagonist behavior with the wild-type TRs. QH2's functionally orthogonal behavior with TRbeta(H435A) is preserved on the three consensus thyroid hormone response elements.

Orthogonal activation of the reengineered A3 adenosine receptor (neoceptor) using tailored nucleoside agonists

An alternative approach to overcome the inherent lack of specificity of conventional agonist therapy can be the reengineering of the GPCRs and their agonists. A reengineered receptor (neoceptor) could be selectively activated by a modified agonist, but not by the endogenous agonist. Assisted by rhodopsin-based molecular modeling, we pinpointed mutations of the A(3) adenosine receptor (AR) for selective affinity enhancement following complementary modifications of adenosine. Ribose modifications examined included, at 3': amino, aminomethyl, azido, guanidino, ureido; and at 5': uronamido, azidodeoxy. N(6)-Variations included 3-iodobenzyl, 5-chloro-2-methyloxybenzyl, and methyl. An N(6)-3-iodobenzyl-3'-ureido adenosine derivative 10 activated phospholipase C in COS-7 cells (EC(50) = 0.18 microM) or phospholipase D in chick primary cardiomyocytes, both mediated by a mutant (H272E), but not the wild-type, A(3)AR. The affinity enhancements for 10 and the corresponding 3'-acetamidomethyl analogue 6 were >100-fold and >20-fold, respectively. 10 concentration-dependently protected cardiomyocytes transfected with the neoceptor against hypoxia. Unlike 10, adenosine activated the wild-type A(3)AR (EC(50) of 1.0 microM), but had no effect on the H272E mutant A(3)AR (100 microM). Compound 10 was inactive at human A(1), A(2A), and A(2B)ARs. The orthogonal pair comprising an engineered receptor and a modified agonist should be useful for elucidating signaling pathways and could be therapeutically applied to diseases following organ-targeted delivery of the neoceptor gene.

A functionally orthogonal estrogen receptor-based transcription switch specifically induced by a nonsteroid synthetic ligand

It is highly desirable to design ligand-dependent transcription regulation systems based on transactivators unresponsive to endogenous ligands but induced by synthetic small molecules unable to activate endogenous receptors. Using molecular modeling and yeast selection, we identified an estrogen receptor ligand binding domain double mutant (L384M, M421G) with decreased affinity to estradiol and enhanced binding to compounds inactive on estrogen receptors. Nonresponsiveness to estrogen was achieved by additionally adding the G521R substitution while introducing an "antagonistic-type" side chain in the compound, as in 4-hydroxytamoxifen. The triple-substituted ligand binding domain is insensitive to physiological concentrations of estradiol and has nanomolar affinity for the ligand. In this binary system, both receptor and ligand are, therefore, reciprocally specific. The mutated variant in the context of a chimeric transcription factor provides tight, ligand-dependent regulation of reporter gene expression.

Creating new specific ligand-receptor pairs for transgene regulation

The creation of specifically matched ligand-receptor pairs that are orthogonal to naturally present interacting pairs is essential for the development of small molecule-regulated gene expression systems for biotechnological applications. However, for many years this task has represented a significant challenge for synthetic chemists and protein engineers. Recently, Doyle and colleagues demonstrated that highly specific ligand-receptor pairs can be engineered in a rapid fashion by creating large libraries of protein variants and applying a selection scheme to identify variants with improved activation by the target synthetic ligand.

Directed evolution of specific receptor-ligand pairs for use in the creation of gene switches

Despite their versatility and power in controlling gene regulation in nature, nuclear hormone receptors (NHRs) have largely eluded utility in heterologous gene regulation applications such as gene therapy and metabolic engineering. The main reason for this void is the pleiotropic interference of the receptor-ligand combination with regulatory networks in the host organism. In recent years, numerous strategies have been developed to engineer ligand-receptor pairs that do not cross-interact with host regulatory pathways. However, these strategies have either met with limited success or cannot be readily extended to other ligand-receptor pairs. Here, we present a simple, effective, and readily generalizable strategy for reengineering NHRs to respond specifically to a selected synthetic ligand. The method involves generation of genetic diversity by stepwise individual site saturation mutagenesis of a fixed set of ligand-contacting residues and random point mutagenesis, followed by phenotypic screening based on a yeast two-hybrid system. As a test case, this method was used to alter the specificity of the NHR human estrogen receptor alpha in favor of the synthetic ligand 4,4'-dihydroxybenzil, relative to the natural ligand 17beta-estradiol, by >10(7)-fold. The resulting ligand-receptor pair is highly sensitive to the synthetic ligand in human endometrial cancer cells and is essentially fully orthogonal to the wild-type receptor-natural ligand pair. This method should provide a powerful, broadly applicable tool for engineering receptors/enzymes with improved or novel ligand/substrate specificity.

A neoceptor approach to unraveling microscopic interactions between the human A2A adenosine receptor and its agonists

Strategically mutated neoceptors, e.g., with anionic residues in TMs 3 and 7 intended for pairing with positively charged amine-modified nucleosides, were derived from the antiinflammatory A(2A) adenosine receptor (AR). Adenosine derivatives functionalized at the 5', 2, and N(6) positions were synthesized. The T88D mutation selectively enhanced the binding of the chain-length-optimized 5'-(2-aminoethyl)uronamide but not 5'-(2-hydroxyethyl)uronamide, suggesting a critical role of the positively charged amine. Combination of this modification with the N(6)-(2-methylbenzyl) group enhanced affinity at the Q89D- and N181D- but not the T88D-A(2A)AR. Amino groups placed near the 2- or N(6)-position only slightly affected the binding to mutant receptors. The 5'-hydrazide MRS3412 was 670- and 161-fold enhanced, in binding and functionally, respectively, at the Q89D-A(2A)AR compared to the wild-type. Thus, we identified and modeled pairs of A(2A)AR-derived neoceptor-neoligand, which are pharmacologically orthogonal with respect to the native species.

Photo-caged agonists of the nuclear receptors RARgamma and TRbeta provide unique time-dependent gene expression profiles for light-activated gene patterning

Light-activated gene expression systems hold promise as new tools for studying spatial and temporal gene patterning in multicellular systems. Photo-caged forms of nuclear receptor agonists have recently been shown to mediate photo-dependent transcription in mammalian cells, however, because intracellularly released agonists can rapidly diffuse out of cells, the photo-initiated transcription response is only transient and limited to only a few hours in reported examples. Herein we describe a photo-caged thyroid hormone receptor agonist that provides a robust 36 h transcription response to a single irradiation event. These findings are in contrast to a closely related system, which uses a caged retinoic acid receptor agonist, which provides only a short transcription response. Comparison of the two systems, show that the duration of transcription response is not controlled by the rate of diffusion of free ligand out of the cell, but perhaps by the duration of ligand-induced transcription/stability of the active transcription complex.

A convenient method for the computer-aided molecular design of carborane containing compounds

Computer-aided molecular design (CAMD) of carborane containing compounds is of growing interest for scientists involved in boron neutron capture therapy (BNCT) and other pharmaceutical applications. However, the complex organo-metallic structures of carboranes pose difficulties in modeling and docking of these structures. This is the first report of a new strategy for modeling and docking of carborane containing molecules with the readily available software packages HyperChem, SYBYL and FlexX. It is intended as a guide for boron chemists interested in using CAMD of carborane containing agents for medical applications such as BNCT.

The completed human genome: implications for chemical biology

The recently completed human genome sequence represents an enormous opportunity to understand biology and accelerate the development of new therapeutics. However, it also presents equally large logistical, scientific and paradigmatic challenges to efficiently translate the enormous cache of sequence data into functional information that will be the precursor of new drug development. Small-molecule chemical biology applied on a genomic scale promises to speed this translation to novel therapeutics.

A highly efficient and sensitive screening method for trans-activation activity of estrogen receptors

We describe a highly efficient and sensitive yeast-based screening method for isolating human estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) mutants with altered trans-activation activity. This method takes advantage of the fact that estrogen receptor is a ligand-activated transcription factor, and links the transactivation activity of estrogen receptor to the growth rate of yeast cells. We used this method to screen a library of human ERalpha mutants created by random mutagenesis of the ligand binding domain of human ERalpha in the presence of ligand 17beta-estradiol (E(2)). We isolated several human ERalpha mutants with significantly altered trans-activation activity toward E(2) in yeast cells. We also used this method to screen a library of chemical compounds and showed that it can be used to rapidly identify estrogenic compounds and the different cell growth rates for these estrogenic compounds correlated well with their relative binding affinities. Thus, this method is suitable for selecting novel estrogenic compounds and estrogen receptor mutants. In principle, this method might also be used to isolate mutants of any nuclear receptors with altered trans-activation activity, which may greatly facilitate their structural and functional studies.

Selective inhibition of engineered receptors via proximity-accelerated alkylation

A new approach for creating allele-specific inhibitors is demonstrated. In this approach, a receptor and ligand are engineered to contain complementary reactive groups that form a covalent bond via a proximity-accelerated reaction upon formation of the receptor-ligand complex, irreversibly modulating the biological function of the receptor. This approach is demonstrated in the cyclophilin-cyclosporin receptor-ligand system by introducing thiol and acrylamide functional groups in the receptor and ligand, respectively.

Synthesis and SAR of alpha-acylaminoketone ligands for control of gene expression

A lead discovery library and a follow-up focused library of alpha-acylaminoketones were designed based on known dibenzoylhydrazine ecdysone agonists, including GS(TM)-E. The compounds were assayed in mammalian cells expressing the ecdysone receptor from Bombyx mori for their ability to cause expression of a reporter gene downstream of an ecdysone response element. The most potent alpha-acylaminoketones were comparable to GS(TM)-E in this assay.

Augmenting vitamin D to combat genetic disease

Vitamin D-resistant rickets is a genetic disease that causes severe bone underdevelopment due to mutations in the vitamin D receptor. Orthogonal analogs of vitamin D were recently identified that correct defects in the ligand binding pocket of a mutant receptor associated with this disease.

Novel chemical genetic approaches to the discovery of signal transduction inhibitors

Concurrent advances in both high-throughput chemistry and genomics have given rise to the field of chemical genetics as a discipline for elucidating and validating drug targets, and generating novel therapeutics. Indeed, chemical genetic approaches to drug discovery have now been applied to several important drug target classes, especially those involved in signal transduction. Chemical genetics is distinct from the broader term "chemogenomics" which is defined as the description of all possible drugs against all possible targets (reviewed in [1]). This review covers several "orthogonal" chemical genetic approaches and focuses on a unique analog sensitive kinase technology and its applications to kinase drug discovery.

(4R,5S)/(4S,5R)-4,5-Bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)-2-imidazolines: ligands for the estrogen receptor with a novel binding mode

(4R,5S)/(4S,5R)-4,5-Bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)-2-imidazolines 1-7 were synthesized by the reaction of the methoxy-substituted (1R,2S)/(1S,2R)-1,2-diarylethylenediamines 1b-7b with triethyl orthoformate and subsequent ether cleavage with BBr(3). All compounds were tested for estrogen receptor (ER) binding in a competition experiment with [(3)H]-estradiol and for gene activation in a luciferase assay using ER positive MCF-7-2a breast cancer cells stably transfected with the plasmid ERE(wtc)luc. The relative binding affinities of the 2-imidazolines were very low (RBA < 0.1%). Nevertheless, 4-7 possessed full agonistic activity in the luciferase assay. The relative transcription potency increased in the order 5 (2,2'-I) < 6 (2,6-Cl(2), 2'-F) < 4 (2,2'-Cl) < 7 (2,6-Cl(2), 2'-Cl). These data together with spectroscopic and molecular modeling studies were used to investigate the preferred binding mode adopted by the imidazoline ligands. The 1,2-diarylethane pharmacophor takes a Z-stilbene-like structure with pseudoaxially oriented phenyl rings at the planar heterocyclic ring. Because of this unusual spatial structure, the (4R,5S)/(4S,5R)-4,5-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)-2-imidazolines have to be assigned to a second class of estrogenically active compounds (type II estrogens). In contrast to type I estrogens, e.g., estradiol (E2), diethylstilbestrol (DES), and meso-hexestrol (HES), which are connected to His 524 in the binding site, type II estrogens are very likely H-bonded to Asp 351 in a hydrophobic side pocket.

Functionally orthogonal ligand-receptor pairs for the selective regulation of gene expression generated by manipulation of charged residues at the ligand-receptor interface of ER alpha and ER beta

The reengineering of protein-small molecule interfaces represents a powerful tool of chemical biology. For many applications it is necessary to engineer receptors so that they do not interact with their endogenous ligands but are highly responsive to designed ligand analogues, which in turn do not interact with endogenous proteins. The chemical design strategy used to reengineer protein-small molecule interfaces is particularly challenging for interfaces involving relatively plastic receptor binding sites and therefore presents a unique challenge in molecular design. In this study we explore the scope and limitations of a new strategy for manipulating polar/charged residues across the ligand receptor interface of estradiol (E2) and the estrogen receptor (ER). Carboxylate-functionalized E2 analogues can activate ER alpha(Glu353-->Ala) and ER beta(Glu305-->Ala) with very large selectivites, demonstrating that this design strategy is extendable to other members of the steroid hormone receptor family. Neutral E2 analogues were found to complement ER alpha(E353A) with similar potencies but with generally lower selectivities. This suggests that the high selectivity observed with ligand-receptor pairs generated by exchanging charged residues across ligand-receptor interfaces is only due in part to their complementary shapes and that appropriate introduction of charged functionality on the ligand can provide substantial enhancement of selectivity by decreasing the engineered ligands affinity for the endogenous receptor. Attempts to modify the cationic residues by complementing Arg394-->Ala or Arg394-->Glu were not successful.

Engineering selectivity and discrimination into ligand-receptor interfaces

The reengineering of protein-ligand (or enzyme-substrate) interfaces using a combination of chemical and genetic methods has become an increasingly common technique to create new tools to manipulate and study biological systems. Many applications of ligand receptor engineering require that the engineered ligand and receptor function independently of endogenous ligands and receptors. Engineered ligands must selectively interact with modified receptors, and modified receptors must effectively discriminate against endogenous ligands. A variety of chemical design strategies have been used to reengineer ligand-receptor interfaces. The advantages and limitations of various strategies, which involve the manipulation of hydrophobic, polar, and charged residues, are compared. New design strategies and potential applications of ligand-receptor engineering are also discussed.

Engineering orthogonal ligand-receptor pairs from "near drugs"

Cell-permeable small molecules are powerful tools for unraveling complex cellular pathways. We demonstrate that nuclear hormone receptors can be engineered through mutagenesis to create orthogonal ligand-receptor pairs to control transcription. Mutated residues in the retinoid X receptor (RXR) were chosen from structural analysis of RXR and the retinoic acid receptor (RAR) ligand binding domains. The potential ligands screened for activation of variant receptors are "near drugs"--compounds synthesized during structure-activity studies that are structurally similar to an approved drug yet inactive on the wild-type receptor. One variant, Q275C;I310M;F313I, is poorly activated by ligands for the wild-type receptor but is activated by a "near drug", fulfilling the criteria of an orthogonal ligand-receptor pair. These experiments demonstrate that nuclear hormone receptors are well suited to supply orthogonal ligand-receptor pairs for experimental biology, biotechnology, and gene therapy. Our findings also demonstrate the general principle that inactive compounds synthesized during drug discovery can be combined with mutant proteins to rapidly create new tools for controlling cellular processes.