SAR by (Protein-Observed) 19F NMR

Fluorine Labeling and 19F NMR Spectroscopy to Study Biological Molecules and Molecular Complexes

High-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy represents a key methodology for studying biomolecules and their interplay with other molecules. Recent developments in labeling strategies have made it possible to incorporate fluorine into proteins and peptides reliably, with manageable efforts and, importantly, in a highly site-specific manner. Paired with its excellent NMR spectroscopic properties and absence in most biological systems, fluorine has enabled scientists to investigate a rather wide range of scientific objectives, including protein folding, protein dynamics and drug discovery. Furthermore, NMR spectroscopic experiments can be conducted in complex environments, such as cell lysate or directly inside living cells. This review presents selected studies demonstrating how 19F NMR spectroscopic approaches enable to contribute to the understanding of biomolecular processes. Thereby the focus has been set to labeling strategies available and specific NMR experiments performed to answer the underlying scientific objective.

The synthesis of specifically isotope labelled fluorotryptophan and its use in mammalian cell-based protein expression for 19F-NMR applications

19F nuclei serve as versatile sensors for detecting protein interactions and dynamics in biomolecular NMR spectroscopy. Although various methods have been developed to incorporate fluorine-containing aromatic residues into proteins using E. coli or cell-free expression techniques, similar approaches for protein production in mammalian cell lines remain limited. Here, we present a cost-effective synthetic route to obtain selectively deuterated, carbon-13 labeled fluorotryptophan and demonstrate its use in introducing 19F-13C spin pairs into carbonic anhydrase 2 and superoxide dismutase, following an expression protocol utilizing HEK cells.

Characterization of conformational states of the homodimeric enzyme fluoroacetate dehalogenase by 19F-13C two-dimensional NMR

Tryptophan plays a critical role in proteins by contributing to stability, allostery, and catalysis. Using fluorine (19F) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), protein conformational dynamics and structure-activity relationships (SARs) can be studied via fluorotryptophan reporters. Tryptophan analogs such as 4-, 5-, 6-, or 7-fluorotryptophan can be routinely incorporated into proteins during heterologous expression by arresting endogenous tryptophan biosynthesis. Building upon the large 19F chemical shift dispersion associated with 5-fluorotryptophan, we introduce an approach to the incorporation of 13C-enriched 5-fluorotryptophan using a direct biosynthetic precursor, 5-fluoroanthranilic acid-(phenyl-13C6). The homodimeric enzyme fluoroacetate dehalogenase (FAcD), a thermophilic alpha/beta hydrolase responsible for the hydrolysis of a C-F bond in fluoroacetate, was expressed and biosynthetically labeled with (phenyl-13C6) 5-fluorotryptophan. The resulting two-dimensional 19F-13C (transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy) TROSY heteronuclear correlation spectra provide complete resolution of all 9 tryptophan residues in the apo enzyme and FAcD saturated with the substrate analog bromoacetate. The (19F,13C) correlation spectra also reveal a multitude of minor resonances in the apo sample. The role of each tryptophan residue in allosteric communication was validated with computational rigidity transmission allostery analysis, which in this case explores the relative interprotomer communication between all possible tryptophan pairs.

19F-NMR Probing of Ion-Induced Conformational Changes in Detergent-Solubilized and Nanodisc-Reconstituted NCX_Mj

Consecutive interactions of 3Na+ or 1Ca2+ with the Na+/Ca2+ exchanger (NCX) result in an alternative exposure (access) of the cytosolic and extracellular vestibules to opposite sides of the membrane, where ion-induced transitions between the outward-facing (OF) and inward-facing (IF) conformational states drive a transport cycle. Here, we investigate sub-state populations of apo and ion-bound species in the OF and IF states by analyzing detergent-solubilized and nanodisc-reconstituted preparations of NCX_Mj with 19F-NMR. The 19F probe was covalently attached to the cysteine residues at entry locations of the cytosolic and extracellular vestibules. Multiple sub-states of apo and ion-bound species were observed in nanodisc-reconstituted (but not in detergent-solubilized) NCX_Mj, meaning that the lipid-membrane environment preconditions multiple sub-state populations toward the OF/IF swapping. Most importantly, ion-induced sub-state redistributions occur within each major (OF or IF) state, where sub-state interconversions may precondition the OF/IF swapping. In contrast with large changes in population redistributions, the sum of sub-state populations within each inherent state (OF or IF) remains nearly unchanged upon ion addition. The present findings allow the further elucidation of structure-dynamic modules underlying ion-induced conformational changes that determine a functional asymmetry of ion access/translocation at opposite sides of the membrane and ion transport rates concurring physiological demands.

Controlling the incorporation of fluorinated amino acids in human cells and its structural impact

Fluorinated aromatic amino acids (FAAs) are promising tools when studying protein structure and dynamics by NMR spectroscopy. The incorporation FAAs in mammalian expression systems has been introduced only recently. Here, we investigate the effects of FAAs incorporation in proteins expressed in human cells, focusing on the probability of incorporation and its consequences on the 19 F NMR spectra. By combining 19 F NMR, direct MS and x-ray crystallography, we demonstrate that the probability of FAA incorporation is only a function of the FAA concentration in the expression medium and is a pure stochastic phenomenon. In contrast with the MS data, the x-ray structures of carbonic anhydrase II reveal that while the 3D structure is not affected, certain positions lack fluorine, suggesting that crystallization selectively excludes protein molecules featuring subtle conformational modifications. This study offers a predictive model of the FAA incorporation efficiency and provides a framework for controlling protein fluorination in mammalian expression systems.

Perspectives on Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy in Drug Discovery Research

The drug discovery landscape has undergone a significant transformation over the past decade, owing to research endeavors in a wide range of areas leading to strategies for pursuing new drug targets and the emergence of novel drug modalities. NMR spectroscopy has been a technology of fundamental importance to these research pursuits and has seen its use expanded both within and outside of traditional medicinal chemistry applications. In this perspective, we will present advancement of NMR-derived methods that have facilitated the characterization of small molecules and novel drug modalities including macrocyclic peptides, cyclic dinucleotides, and ligands for protein degradation. We will discuss innovations in NMR spectroscopy at the chemistry and biology interface that have broadened NMR's utility from hit identification through lead optimization activities. We will also discuss the promise of emerging NMR approaches in bridging our understanding and addressing challenges in the pursuit of the therapeutic agents of the future.

Ligand-Based Competition Binding by Real-Time 19F NMR in Human Cells

The development of more effective drugs requires knowledge of their bioavailability and binding efficacy directly in the native cellular environment. In-cell nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is a powerful tool for investigating ligand-target interactions directly in living cells. However, the target molecule may be NMR-invisible due to interactions with cellular components, while observing the ligand by 1H NMR is impractical due to the cellular background. Such limitations can be overcome by observing fluorinated ligands by 19F in-cell NMR as they bind to the intracellular target. Here we report a novel approach based on real-time in-cell 19F NMR that allows measuring ligand binding affinities in human cells by competition binding, using a fluorinated compound as a reference. The binding of a set of compounds toward Hsp90α was investigated. In principle, this approach could be applied to other pharmacologically relevant targets, thus aiding the design of more effective compounds in the early stages of drug development.

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy: The Diverse Roles That Fluorine Can Play within Amino Acid Side Chains

Side chain-fluorinated amino acids are useful tools in medicinal chemistry and protein science. In this review, we outline some general strategies for incorporating fluorine atom(s) into amino acid side chains and for elaborating such building blocks into more complex fluorinated peptides and proteins. We then describe the diverse benefits that fluorine can offer when located within amino acid side chains, including enabling 19F NMR and 18F PET imaging applications, enhancing pharmacokinetic properties, controlling molecular conformation, and optimizing target-binding.

19F: A small probe for a giant protein

Herein we describe a method for the efficient production (∼90% fluorination) of 5-F-Trp human H ferritin via the selective incorporation of ¹⁹F into the side chain of W93 using 5-fluoroindole as the fluorinated precursor of the amino acid. Human H ferritin is a nanocage composed of 24 identical subunits, each containing a single Trp belonging to a loop exposed on the external surface of the protein nanocage. This makes 5-F-Trp a potential probe for the study of intermolecular interactions in solution by exploiting its intrinsic fluorescence. More interestingly, albeit the large size of the cage (12 nm external diameter, ∼500 kDa molecular mass) we observe a broad but well defined NMR ¹⁹F resonance that can be used for the dual purpose of detecting solution intermolecular interactions via chemical shift perturbation mapping and monitoring the uptake of ferritin by cells treated with ferritin-based drug carriers, the latter being an application area of increasing importance.

Single-molecule fingerprinting of protein-drug interaction using a funneled biological nanopore

In drug discovery, efficient screening of protein-drug interactions (PDIs) is hampered by the limitations of current biophysical approaches. Here, we develop a biological nanopore sensor for single-molecule detection of proteins and PDIs using the pore-forming toxin YaxAB. Using this YaxAB nanopore, we demonstrate label-free, single-molecule detection of interactions between the anticancer Bcl-xL protein and small-molecule drugs as well as the Bak-BH3 peptide. The long funnel-shaped structure and nanofluidic characteristics of the YaxAB nanopore enable the electro-osmotic trapping of diverse folded proteins and high-resolution monitoring of PDIs. Distinctive nanopore event distributions observed in the two-dimensional (ΔI/I_o-versus-I_N) plot illustrate the ability of the YaxAB nanopore to discriminate individual small-molecule drugs bound to Bcl-xL from non-binders. Taken together, our results present the YaxAB nanopore as a robust platform for label-free, ultrasensitive, single-molecule detection of PDIs, opening up a possibility for low-cost, highly efficient drug discovery against diverse drug targets.

Targeted F 19 - tags to detect amino acids in complex mixtures using NMR spectroscopy

Nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of fluorine-19 nucleus ( F 19 -NMR) emerges as a powerful tool because of the high sensitivity due to its high natural abundance, broad spectral range, and the simplicity of a spin-half system. However, it is still seldom utilized in the chemistry classroom or research. This article thus aims to demonstrate the power of NMR by investigating the kinetics when a F 19 - tag reacts with individual amino acids (AA) and eventually utilizing the approach to identify and quantify various AAs from a complex mixture such as a metabolomics sample. The F 19 - tag named 2,5-dioxopyrrolidin-1-yl-2-(trifluoromethyl)benzoate was synthesized following a previously established method. The reaction kinetics of the tag was then continuously measured using F 19 NMR in the presence of selected AAs. The estimated reaction rate constants to form the F 19 - tags with each AA differ, which could be used as an identification tool. The tag formations were typically completed in 24-48 h in water for all the samples. These demonstrations suggest that F 19 - tags could form the basis for chemical kinetics and AA detection using F 19 -NMR.

Development of a single culture E. coli expression system for the enzymatic synthesis of fluorinated tyrosine and its incorporation into proteins

Current experiments that rely on biosynthetic metabolic protein labeling with ¹⁹F often require fluorinated amino acids, which in the case of 2- and 3-fluorotyrosine can be expensive. However, using these amino acids has provided valuable insight into protein dynamics, structure, and function. Here, we develop a new in-cell method for fluorinated tyrosine generation from readily available substituted phenols and subsequent metabolic labeling of proteins in a single bacterial expression culture. This approach uses a dual-gene plasmid encoding for a model protein BRD4(D1) and a tyrosine phenol lyase from Citrobacter freundii, which catalyzes the formation of tyrosine from phenol, pyruvate, and ammonium. Our system demonstrated both enzymatic fluorotyrosine production and expression of ¹⁹F-labeled proteins as analyzed by ¹⁹F NMR and LC-MS methods. Further optimization of our system should provide a cost-effective alternative to a variety of traditional protein-labeling strategies.

Overexpression of recombinant proteins containing non-canonical amino acids in Vibrio natriegens: p-azido-L-phenylalanine as coupling site for 19F-tags

Vibrio natriegens is the fastest growing organism identified so far. The minimum doubling time of only 9.4 min, the ability to utilize over 60 different carbon sources and its non-pathogenic properties make it an interesting alternative to E. coli as a new production host for recombinant proteins. We investigated the ability of the engineered V. natriegens strain, Vmax™ Express, to incorporate the non-canonical amino acid (ncAA) p-azido-L-phenylalanine (AzF) into recombinant proteins for NMR applications. AzF was incorporated into enhanced yellow fluorescent protein (EYFP) and MlaC, an intermembrane transport protein, by stop codon suppression. AzF incorporation into EYFP resulted in an improved suppression efficiency (SE) of up to 35.5 ± 0.8% and a protein titer of 26.7 ± 0.7 mg/L. The expression levels of MlaC-AzF even exceeded those of E. coli BL21 cells. For the recording of 1H-15N and 19F NMR spectra, EYFP-AzF was expressed and isotopically labeled in minimal medium and the newly introduced azido-group was used as coupling site for NMR sensitive 19F-tags. Our findings show that Vmax is a flexible expression host, suitable for the incorporation of ncAAs in recombinant proteins with the potential to surpass protein yields of E. coli. The presented method suggests the implementation of V. natriegens for expression of isotopically labeled proteins containing ncAAs, which can be chemically modified for the application in protein-observed 19F-NMR.

19F-NMR Unveils the Ligand-Induced Conformation of a Catalytically Inactive Twisted Homodimer of tRNA-Guanine Transglycosylase

Understanding the structural arrangements of protein oligomers can support the design of ligands that interfere with their function in order to develop new therapeutic concepts for disease treatment. Recent crystallographic studies have elucidated a novel twisted and functionally inactive form of the homodimeric enzyme tRNA-guanine transglycosylase (TGT), a putative target in the fight against shigellosis. Active-site ligands have been identified that stimulate the rearrangement of one monomeric subunit by 130° against the other one to form an inactive twisted homodimer state. To assess whether the crystallographic observations also reflect the conformation in solution and rule out effects from crystal packing, we performed ¹⁹F-NMR spectroscopy with the introduction of 5-fluorotryptophans at four sites in TGT. The inhibitor-induced conformation of TGT in solution was assessed based on ¹⁹F-NMR chemical shift perturbations. We investigated the effect of C(4) substituted lin-benzoguanine ligands and identified a correlation between dynamic protein rearrangements and ligand-binding features in the corresponding crystal structures. These involve the destabilization of a helix next to the active site and the integrity of a flexible loop-helix motif. Ligands that either completely lack an attached C(4) substituent or use it to stabilize the geometry of the functionally competent dimer state do not indicate the presence of the twisted dimer form in the NMR spectra. The perturbation of crucial structural motifs in the inhibitors correlates with an increasing formation of the inactive twisted dimer state, suggesting these ligands are able to shift a conformational equilibrium from active C2-symmetric to inactive twisted dimer conformations. These findings suggest a novel concept for the design of drug candidates for further development.

New strategies for combating fungal infections: Inhibiting inositol lipid signaling by targeting Sec14 phosphatidylinositol transfer proteins

Virulent fungi represent a particularly difficult problem in the infectious disease arena as these organisms are eukaryotes that share many orthologous activities with their human hosts. The fact that these activities are often catalyzed by conserved proteins places additional demands on development of pharmacological strategies for specifically inhibiting target fungal activities without imposing undesirable secondary effects on the host. While deployment of a limited set of anti-mycotics has to date satisfied the clinical needs for treatment of fungal infections, the recent emergence of multi-drug resistant fungal 'superbugs' now poses a serious global health threat with rapidly diminishing options for treatment. This escalating infectious disease problem emphasizes the urgent need for development of new classes of anti-mycotics. In that regard, Sec14 phosphatidylinositol transfer proteins offer interesting possibilities for interfering with fungal phosphoinositide signaling with exquisite specificity and without targeting the highly conserved lipid kinases responsible for phosphoinositide production. Herein, we review the establishment of proof-of-principle that demonstrates the feasibility of such an approach. We also describe the lead compounds of four chemotypes that directly target fungal Sec14 proteins. The rules that pertain to the mechanism(s) of Sec14 inhibition by validated small molecule inhibitors, and the open questions that remain, are discussed - as are the challenges that face development of next generation Sec14-directed inhibitors.

Practical Considerations and Guidelines for Spectral Referencing for Fluorine NMR Ligand Screening

Fluorine (¹⁹F) NMR strategies are increasingly being employed for evaluating ligand binding to macromolecules, among many other uses. ¹⁹F NMR offers many advantages as a result of its sensitive spin 1/2 nucleus, 100% natural abundance, and wide chemical shift range. Moreover, because of its absence from biological samples, one can directly monitor ligand binding without background interference from the macromolecule. Therefore, all these aforementioned features make it an attractive approach for screening compounds. However, the detection of ligand binding, especially those with weak affinities, can require interpretations of minor changes in chemical shifts. Thus, chemical shift referencing is critical for accurate measurements and interpretations. Unfortunately, one cannot rely on spectrometer indirect referencing alone, and internal chemical references have sample-dependent issues. Here, we evaluated 10 potential candidate compounds that could serve as ¹⁹F NMR chemical references. Multiple factors were systematically evaluated for each candidate to monitor the suitability for ¹⁹F NMR screening purposes. These factors include aqueous solubility, buffer compatibility, salt compatibility, aqueous stability, tolerability to pH changes, temperature changes, and compound pooling. It was concluded that there was no ideal candidate, but five compounds had properties that met the screening requirements.

Relaxation optimized double acquisition (RODA) as an alternative for virtual decoupling of NMR spectra

We introduce an alternative way for spin-state selection, RODA, which yields higher sensitivity for spin systems exhibiting a TROSY effect. With RODA, the TROSY component of a doublet is recorded twice using a double acquisition scheme. RODA works by simple addition of consecutive NMR signals, and does not require any special processing. Thus, this pulse sequence element can seamlessly be integrated into existing experiments. We demonstrate the broad applicability of RODA with several systems exhibiting a TROSY effect on ¹⁵N-¹H, ¹⁹F-¹³C or ¹H-¹³C moieties. Further, we show that virtual decoupling with increased sensitivity is possible in a single double acquisition experiment in situations as encountered with dissolution DNP.

Synthesis of fluorinated leucines, valines and alanines for use in protein NMR

Efficient syntheses of fluorinated leucines, valines and alanines are described. The synthetic routes provide expedient access to various ¹³C/¹⁵N/D isotopologues requiring solely readily available and inexpensive isotope containing reagents such as NaBD₄, carbon-¹³C dioxide and sodium azide-1-¹⁵N. The lightly fluorinated leucines and valines were found to be good substrates for cell-free protein expression and even 3-fluoroalanine, which is highly toxic to bacteria in vivo, could be incorporated into proteins this way. ¹⁹F-NMR spectra of the protein GB1 produced with these amino acids showed large chemical shift dispersions. Particularly high incorporation yields and clean ¹⁹F-NMR spectra were obtained for GB1 produced with valine residues, which had been synthesized with a single fluorine substituting a hydrogen stereospecifically in one of the methyl groups.

Non-canonical Amino Acid Substrates of E. coli Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases

In this comprehensive review, I focus on the twenty E. coli aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and their ability to charge non-canonical amino acids (ncAAs) onto tRNAs. The promiscuity of these enzymes has been harnessed for diverse applications including understanding and engineering of protein function, creation of organisms with an expanded genetic code, and the synthesis of diverse peptide libraries for drug discovery. The review catalogues the structures of all known ncAA substrates for each of the 20 E. coli aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases, including ncAA substrates for engineered versions of these enzymes. Drawing from the structures in the list, I highlight trends and novel opportunities for further exploitation of these ncAAs in the engineering of protein function, synthetic biology, and in drug discovery.

Ferritin-Like Proteins: A Conserved Core for a Myriad of Enzyme Complexes

Ferritin-like proteins share a common fold, a four α-helix bundle core, often coordinating a pair of metal ions. Although conserved, the ferritin fold permits a diverse set of reactions, and is central in a multitude of macromolecular enzyme complexes. Here, we emphasize this diversity through three members of the ferritin-like superfamily: the soluble methane monooxygenase, the class I ribonucleotide reductase and the aldehyde deformylating oxygenase. They all rely on dinuclear metal cofactors to catalyze different challenging oxygen-dependent reactions through the formation of multi-protein complexes. Recent studies using cryo-electron microscopy, serial femtosecond crystallography at an X-ray free electron laser source, or single-crystal X-ray diffraction, have reported the structures of the active protein complexes, and revealed unprecedented insights into the molecular mechanisms of these three enzymes.

Lanmodulin Remains Unfold and Fails to Interact with Lanthanide Ions in Escherichia coli Cells

We report the conformation of a newly discovered specific lanthanide ions (Ln3+) binding protein, Lanmodulin (LanM), and its inteaction with Ln3+ in Escherichia coli cells using In-cell NMR. We found...

Resolution of chemical shift anisotropy in 19F ENDOR spectroscopy at 263 GHz/9.4 T

Pulsed ¹⁹F ENDOR spectroscopy provides a selective method for measuring angstrom to nanometer distances in structural biology. Here, the performance of ¹⁹F ENDOR at fields of 3.4 T and 9.4 T is compared using model compounds containing one to three ¹⁹F atoms. CF₃ groups are included in two compounds, for which the possible occurrence of uniaxial rotation might affect the distance distribution. At 9.4 T, pronounced asymmetric features are observed in many of the presented ¹⁹F ENDOR spectra. Data analysis by spectral simulations shows that these features arise from the chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) of the ¹⁹F nuclei. This asymmetry is also observed at 3.4 T, albeit to a much smaller extent, confirming the physical origin of the effect. The CSA parameters are well consistent with DFT predicted values and can be extracted from simulation of the experimental data in favourable cases, thereby providing additional information about the geometrical and electronic structure of the spin system. The feasibility of resolving the CSA at 9.4 T provides important information for the interpretation of line broadening in ENDOR spectra also at lower fields, which is relevant for developing methods to extract distance distributions from ¹⁹F ENDOR spectra.

Through-Space Scalar 19F-19F Couplings between Fluorinated Noncanonical Amino Acids for the Detection of Specific Contacts in Proteins

Fluorine atoms are known to display scalar ¹⁹F-¹⁹F couplings in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectra when they are sufficiently close in space for nonbonding orbitals to overlap. We show that fluorinated noncanonical amino acids positioned in the hydrophobic core or on the surface of a protein can be linked by scalar through-space ¹⁹F-¹⁹F (^TSJ_FF) couplings even if the ¹⁹F spins are in the time average separated by more than the van der Waals distance. Using two different aromatic amino acids featuring CF₃ groups, O-trifluoromethyl-tyrosine and 4-trifluoromethyl-phenylalanine, we show that ¹⁹F-¹⁹F TOCSY experiments are sufficiently sensitive to detect ^TSJ_FF couplings between 2.5 and 5 Hz in the 19 kDa protein PpiB measured on a two-channel 400 MHz NMR spectrometer with a regular room temperature probe. A quantitative J evolution experiment enables the measurement of ^TSJ_FF coupling constants that are up to five times smaller than the ¹⁹F NMR line width. In addition, a new aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase was identified for genetic encoding of N⁶-(trifluoroacetyl)-l-lysine (TFA-Lys) and ¹⁹F-¹⁹F TOCSY peaks were observed between two TFA-Lys residues incorporated into the proteins AncCDT-1 and mRFP despite high solvent exposure and flexibility of the TFA-Lys side chains. With the ready availability of systems for site-specific incorporation of fluorinated amino acids into proteins by genetic encoding, ¹⁹F-¹⁹F interactions offer a straightforward way to probe the spatial proximity of selected sites without any assignments of ¹H NMR resonances.

(R)-α-Trifluoromethylalanine as a 19 F NMR Probe for the Monitoring of Protease Digestion of Peptides

Fluorinated non-natural amino acids are useful tools for improving the bioavailability of peptides but can also serve as fluorinated probes in ¹⁹ F NMR-based enzymatic assays. We report herein that the use of the non-natural α-quaternarized (R)-α-trifluoromethylalanine ((R)-α-TfmAla) provides convenient and accurate monitoring of trypsin proteolytic activity and increases resistance towards pepsin degradation.

19F NMR viewed through two different lenses: ligand-observed and protein-observed 19F NMR applications for fragment-based drug discovery

19F NMR has emerged as a powerful tool in drug discovery, particularly in fragment-based screens. The favorable magnetic resonance properties of the fluorine-19 nucleus, the general absence of fluorine in biological settings, and its ready incorporation into both small molecules and biopolymers, has enabled multiple applications of 19F NMR using labeled small molecules and proteins in biophysical, biochemical, and cellular experiments. This review will cover developments in ligand-observed and protein-observed 19F NMR experiments tailored towards drug discovery with a focus on fragment screening. We also cover the key advances that have furthered the field in recent years, including quantitative, structural, and in-cell methodologies. Several case studies are described for each application to highlight areas for innovation and to further catalyze new NMR developments for using this versatile nucleus.

Opportunity knocks for uncovering the new function of an understudied nucleosome remodeling complex member, the bromodomain PHD finger transcription factor, BPTF

Nucleosome remodeling provides access to genomic DNA for recruitment of the transcriptional machinery to mediate gene expression. The aberrant function of nucleosome remodeling complexes has been correlated to human cancer, making them emerging therapeutic targets. The bromodomain PHD finger transcription factor, BPTF, is the largest member of the human nucleosome remodeling factor NURF. Over the last five years, BPTF has become increasingly identified as a protumorigenic factor, prompting investigations into the molecular mechanisms associated with BPTF function. Despite a druggable bromodomain, small molecule discovery is at an early stage. Here we highlight recent investigations into the biology being discovered for BPTF, chemical biology approaches used to study its function, and small molecule inhibitors being designed as future chemical probes and therapeutics.

Soluble Methane Monooxygenase Component Interactions Monitored by 19F NMR

Soluble methane monooxygenase (sMMO) is a multicomponent metalloenzyme capable of catalyzing the fissure of the C-H bond of methane and the insertion of one atom of oxygen from O2 to yield methanol. Efficient multiple-turnover catalysis occurs only in the presence of all three sMMO protein components: hydroxylase (MMOH), reductase (MMOR), and regulatory protein (MMOB). The complex series of sMMO protein component interactions that regulate the formation and decay of sMMO reaction cycle intermediates is not fully understood. Here, the two tryptophan residues in MMOB and the single tryptophan residue in MMOR are converted to 5-fluorotryptophan (5FW) by expression in defined media containing 5-fluoroindole. In addition, the mechanistically significant N-terminal region of MMOB is 19F-labeled by reaction of the K15C variant with 3-bromo-1,1,1-trifluoroacetone (BTFA). The 5FW and BTFA modifications cause minimal structural perturbation, allowing detailed studies of the interactions with sMMOH using 19F NMR. Resonances from the 275 kDa complexes of sMMOH with 5FW-MMOB and BTFA-K15C-5FW-MMOB are readily detected at 5 μM labeled protein concentration. This approach shows directly that MMOR and MMOB competitively bind to sMMOH with similar KD values, independent of the oxidation state of the sMMOH diiron cluster. These findings suggest a new model for regulation in which the dynamic equilibration of MMOR and MMOB with sMMOH allows a transient formation of key reactive complexes that irreversibly pull the reaction cycle forward. The slow kinetics of exchange of the sMMOH:MMOB complex is proposed to prevent MMOR-mediated reductive quenching of the high-valent reaction cycle intermediate Q before it can react with methane.

Synthesis of 13C/19F/2H labeled indoles for use as tryptophan precursors for protein NMR spectroscopy

Synthesis of indoles labeled with 13C-1H and 13C-19F spin pairs is described. All syntheses utilize inexpensive carbon-13C dioxide as the 13C isotope source. Ruthenium-mediated ring-closing metathesis is the key step in construction of the 13C containing indole carbocycle. Fluorine is introduced via electrophilic fluorination at the 7-position and via palladium-mediated cross-coupling at the 4-position. Indole and fluoroindoles are viable tryptophan precursors for in vivo protein expression. We show that they are viable also in in vitro protein synthesis using standard E. coli S30 extracts. Incorporation of the synthesized 13C-1H and 13C-19F spin pair labeled tryptophans into proteins enables high-resolution and high-sensitivity nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy.

Fragment-Based Ligand Discovery Using Protein-Observed 19F NMR: A Second Semester Organic Chemistry CURE Project

Curriculum-based undergraduate research experiences (CUREs) have been shown to increase student retention in STEM fields and are starting to become more widely adopted in chemistry curricula. Here we describe a 10-week CURE that is suitable for a second-semester organic chemistry laboratory course. Students synthesize small molecules and use protein-observed ¹⁹F (PrOF) NMR to assess the small molecule's binding affinity to a target protein. The research project introduced students to multistep organic synthesis, structure-activity relationship studies, quantitative biophysical measurements (measuring K_d from PrOF NMR experiments), and scientific literacy. Docking experiments could be added to help students understand how changes in a ligand structure may affect binding to a protein. Assessment using the CURE survey indicates self-perceived skill gains from the course that exceed gains measured in a traditional and an inquiry-based laboratory experience. Given the speed of the binding experiment and the alignment of the synthetic methods with a second-semester organic chemistry laboratory course, a PrOF NMR fragment-based ligand discovery lab can be readily implemented in the undergraduate chemistry curriculum.

Using NMR Spectroscopy in the Fragment-Based Drug Discovery of Small-Molecule Anticancer Targeted Therapies

Against the challenge of providing personalized cancer care, the development of targeted therapies stands as a promising approach. The discovery of these agents can benefit from fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD) methods that help guide ligand design and provide key structural information on the targets of interest. In particular, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy is a promising biophysical tool in fragment discovery due to its detection capabilities and versatility. This review provides an overview of FBDD, describes the basis of NMR-based fragment screening, summarizes some exciting technical advances reported over the past decades, and closes with a discussion of selected case studies where this technique has been used as part of drug discovery campaigns to produce lead compounds towards the design of anti-cancer targeted therapies.

Perfluorocarbons in Chemical Biology

Perfluorocarbons, saturated carbon chains in which all the hydrogen atoms are replaced with fluorine, form a separate phase from both organic and aqueous solutions. Though perfluorinated compounds are not found in living systems, they can be used to modify biomolecules to confer orthogonal behavior within natural systems, such as improved stability, engineered assembly, and cell-permeability. Perfluorinated groups also provide handles for purification, mass spectrometry, and 19 F NMR studies in complex environments. Herein, we describe how the unique properties of perfluorocarbons have been employed to understand and manipulate biological systems.

Quantifying the Selectivity of Protein-Protein and Small Molecule Interactions with Fluorinated Tandem Bromodomain Reader Proteins

Multidomain bromodomain-containing proteins regulate gene expression via chromatin binding, interactions with the transcriptional machinery, and by recruiting enzymatic activity. Selective inhibition of members of the bromodomain and extra-terminal (BET) family is important to understand their role in disease and gene regulation, although due to the similar binding sites of BET bromodomains, selective inhibitor discovery has been challenging. To support the bromodomain inhibitor discovery process, here we report the first application of protein-observed fluorine (PrOF) NMR to the tandem bromodomains of BRD4 and BRDT to quantify the selectivity of their interactions with acetylated histones as well as small molecules. We further determine the selectivity profile of a new class of ligands, 1,4-acylthiazepanes, and find them to have ≥3-10-fold selectivity for the C-terminal bromodomain of both BRD4 and BRDT. Given the speed and lower protein concentration required over traditional protein-observed NMR methods, we envision that these fluorinated tandem proteins may find use in fragment screening and evaluating nucleosome and transcription factor interactions.

Fluorine NMR functional screening: from purified enzymes to human intact living cells

The substrate- or cofactor-based fluorine NMR screening, also known as n-FABS (n fluorine atoms for biochemical screening), represents a powerful method for performing a direct functional assay in the search of inhibitors or enhancers of an enzymatic reaction. Although it suffers from the intrinsic low sensitivity compared to other biophysical techniques usually applied in functional assays, it has some distinctive features that makes it appealing for tackling complex chemical and biological systems. Its strengths are represented by the easy set-up, robustness, flexibility, lack of signal interference and rich information content resulting in the identification of bona fide inhibitors and reliable determination of their inhibitory strength. The versatility of the n-FABS allows its application to either purified enzymes, cell lysates or intact living cells. The principles, along with theoretical, technical and practical aspects, of the methodology are discussed. Furthermore, several applications of the technique to pharmaceutical projects are presented.

Solution NMR readily reveals distinct structural folds and interactions in doubly 13C- and 19F-labeled RNAs

RNAs form critical components of biological processes implicated in human diseases, making them attractive for small-molecule therapeutics. Expanding the sites accessible to nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy will provide atomic-level insights into RNA interactions. Here, we present an efficient strategy to introduce ¹⁹F-¹³C spin pairs into RNA by using a 5-fluorouridine-5'-triphosphate and T7 RNA polymerase-based in vitro transcription. Incorporating the ¹⁹F-¹³C label in two model RNAs produces linewidths that are twice as sharp as the commonly used ¹H-¹³C spin pair. Furthermore, the high sensitivity of the ¹⁹F nucleus allows for clear delineation of helical and nonhelical regions as well as GU wobble and Watson-Crick base pairs. Last, the ¹⁹F-¹³C label enables rapid identification of a small-molecule binding pocket within human hepatitis B virus encapsidation signal epsilon (hHBV ε) RNA. We anticipate that the methods described herein will expand the size limitations of RNA NMR and aid with RNA-drug discovery efforts.

The precious fluorine on the ring: fluorine NMR for biological systems

The fluorine-19 nucleus was recognized early to harbor exceptional properties for NMR spectroscopy. With 100% natural abundance, a high gyromagnetic ratio (83% sensitivity compared to 1H), a chemical shift that is extremely sensitive to its surroundings and near total absence in biological systems, it was destined to become a favored NMR probe, decorating small and large molecules. However, after early excitement, where uptake of fluorinated aromatic amino acids was explored in a series of animal studies, 19F-NMR lost popularity, especially in large molecular weight systems, due to chemical shift anisotropy (CSA) induced line broadening at high magnetic fields. Recently, two orthogonal approaches, (i) CF3 labeling and (ii) aromatic 19F-13C labeling leveraging the TROSY (Transverse Relaxation Optimized Spectroscopy) effect have been successfully applied to study large biomolecular systems. In this perspective, we will discuss the fascinating early work with fluorinated aromatic amino acids, which reveals the enormous potential of these non-natural amino acids in biological NMR and the potential of 19F-NMR to characterize protein and nucleic acid structure, function and dynamics in the light of recent developments. Finally, we explore how fluorine NMR might be exploited to implement small molecule or fragment screens that resemble physiological conditions and discuss the opportunity to follow the fate of small molecules in living cells.

Combined Protein- and Ligand-Observed NMR Workflow to Screen Fragment Cocktails against Multiple Proteins: A Case Study Using Bromodomains

As fragment-based drug discovery has become mainstream, there has been an increase in various screening methodologies. Protein-observed ¹⁹F (PrOF) NMR and ¹H CPMG NMR are two fragment screening assays that have complementary advantages. Here, we sought to combine these two NMR-based assays into a new screening workflow. This combination of protein- and ligand-observed experiments allows for a time- and resource-efficient multiplexed screen of mixtures of fragments and proteins. PrOF NMR is first used to screen mixtures against two proteins. Hit mixtures for each protein are identified then deconvoluted using ¹H CPMG NMR. We demonstrate the benefit of this fragment screening method by conducting the first reported fragment screens against the bromodomains of BPTF and Plasmodium falciparum (Pf) GCN5 using 467 3D-enriched fragments. The hit rates were 6%, 5% and 4% for fragments binding BPTF, PfGCN5, and fragments binding both proteins, respectively. Select hits were characterized, revealing a broad range of affinities from low µM to mM dissociation constants. Follow-up experiments supported a low-affinity second binding site on PfGCN5. This approach can be used to bias fragment screens towards more selective hits at the onset of inhibitor development in a resource- and time-efficient manner.

Fast Rescoring Protocols to Improve the Performance of Structure-Based Virtual Screening Performed on Protein-Protein Interfaces

Protein-protein interactions (PPIs) are attractive targets for drug design because of their essential role in numerous cellular processes and disease pathways. However, in general, PPIs display exposed binding pockets at the interface, and as such, have been largely unexploited for therapeutic interventions with low-molecular weight compounds. Here, we used docking and various rescoring strategies in an attempt to recover PPI inhibitors from a set of active and inactive molecules for 11 targets collected in ChEMBL and PubChem. Our focus is on the screening power of the various developed protocols and on using fast approaches so as to be able to apply such a strategy to the screening of ultralarge libraries in the future. First, we docked compounds into each target using the fast "pscreen" mode of the structure-based virtual screening (VS) package Surflex. Subsequently, the docking poses were postprocessed to derive a set of 3D topological descriptors: (i) shape similarity and (ii) interaction fingerprint similarity with a co-crystallized inhibitor, (iii) solvent-accessible surface area, and (iv) extent of deviation from the geometric center of a reference inhibitor. The derivatized descriptors, together with descriptor-scaled scoring functions, were utilized to investigate possible impacts on VS performance metrics. Moreover, four standalone scoring functions, RF-Score-VS (machine-learning), DLIGAND2 (knowledge-based), Vinardo (empirical), and X-SCORE (empirical), were employed to rescore the PPI compounds. Collectively, the results indicate that the topological scoring algorithms could be valuable both at a global level, with up to 79% increase in areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve for some targets, and in early stages, with up to a 4-fold increase in enrichment factors at 1% of the screened collections. Outstandingly, DLIGAND2 emerged as the best scoring function on this data set, outperforming all rescoring techniques in terms of VS metrics. The described methodology could help in the rational design of small-molecule PPI inhibitors and has direct applications in many therapeutic areas, including cancer, CNS, and infectious diseases such as COVID-19.

New inhibitors for the BPTF bromodomain enabled by structural biology and biophysical assay development

Bromodomain-containing proteins regulate transcription through protein-protein interactions with chromatin and serve as scaffolding proteins for recruiting essential members of the transcriptional machinery. One such protein is the bromodomain and PHD-containing transcription factor (BPTF), the largest member of the nucleosome remodeling complex, NURF. Despite an emerging role for BPTF in regulating a diverse set of cancers, small molecule development for inhibiting the BPTF bromodomain has been lacking. Here we cross-validate three complementary biophysical assays to further the discovery of BPTF bromodomain inhibitors for chemical probe development: two direct binding assays (protein-observed 19F (PrOF) NMR and surface plasmon resonance (SPR)) and a competitive inhibition assay (AlphaScreen). We first compare the assays using three small molecules and acetylated histone peptides with reported affinity for the BPTF bromodomain. Using SPR with both unlabeled and fluorinated BPTF, we further determine that there is a minimal effect of 19F incorporation on ligand binding for future PrOF NMR experiments. To guide medicinal chemistry efforts towards chemical probe development, we subsequently evaluate two new BPTF inhibitor scaffolds with our suite of biophysical assays and rank-order compound affinities which could not otherwise be determined by PrOF NMR. Finally, we cocrystallize a subset of small molecule inhibitors and present the first published small molecule-protein structures with the BPTF bromodomain. We envision the biophysical assays described here and the structural insights from the crystallography will guide researchers towards developing selective and potent BPTF bromodomain inhibitors.

Protein-observed 19F NMR of LecA from Pseudomonas aeruginosa

The carbohydrate-binding protein LecA (PA-IL) from Pseudomonas aeruginosa plays an important role in the formation of biofilms in chronic infections. Development of inhibitors to disrupt LecA-mediated biofilms is desired but it is limited to carbohydrate-based ligands. Moreover, discovery of drug-like ligands for LecA is challenging because of its weak affinities. Therefore, we established a protein-observed 19F (PrOF) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to probe ligand binding to LecA. LecA was labeled with 5-fluoroindole to incorporate 5-fluorotryptophanes and the resonances were assigned by site-directed mutagenesis. This incorporation did not disrupt LecA preference for natural ligands, Ca2+ and d-galactose. Following NMR perturbation of W42, which is located in the carbohydrate-binding region of LecA, allowed to monitor binding of low-affinity ligands such as N-acetyl d-galactosamine (d-GalNAc, Kd = 780 ± 97 μM). Moreover, PrOF NMR titration with glycomimetic of LecA p-nitrophenyl β-d-galactoside (pNPGal, Kd = 54 ± 6 μM) demonstrated a 6-fold improved binding of d-Gal proving this approach to be valuable for ligand design in future drug discovery campaigns that aim to generate inhibitors of LecA.

Comprehensive and High-Throughput Exploration of Chemical Space Using Broadband 19 F NMR-Based Screening

Fragment-based lead discovery has become a fundamental approach to identify ligands that efficiently interact with disease-relevant targets. Among the numerous screening techniques, fluorine-detected NMR has gained popularity owing to its high sensitivity, robustness, and ease of use. To effectively explore chemical space, a universal NMR experiment, a rationally designed fragment library, and a sample composition optimized for a maximal number of compounds and minimal measurement time are required. Here, we introduce a comprehensive method that enabled the efficient assembly of a high-quality and diverse library containing nearly 4000 fragments and screening for target-specific binders within days. At the core of the approach is a novel broadband relaxation-edited NMR experiment that covers the entire chemical shift range of drug-like ¹⁹ F motifs in a single measurement. Our approach facilitates the identification of diverse binders and the fast ligandability assessment of new targets.

Rapid Quantification of Protein-Ligand Binding via 19F NMR Lineshape Analysis

Fluorine incorporation is ideally suited to many NMR techniques, and incorporation of fluorine into proteins and fragment libraries for drug discovery has become increasingly common. Here, we use one-dimensional 19F NMR lineshape analysis to quantify the kinetics and equilibrium thermodynamics for the binding of a fluorine-labeled Src homology 3 (SH3) protein domain to four proline-rich peptides. SH3 domains are one of the largest and most well-characterized families of protein recognition domains and have a multitude of functions in eukaryotic cell signaling. First, we showe that fluorine incorporation into SH3 causes only minor structural changes to both the free and bound states using amide proton temperature coefficients. We then compare the results from lineshape analysis of one-dimensional 19F spectra to those from two-dimensional 1H-15N heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectra. Their agreement demonstrates that one-dimensional 19F lineshape analysis is a robust, low-cost, and fast alternative to traditional heteronuclear single quantum coherence-based experiments. The data show that binding is diffusion limited and indicate that the transition state is highly similar to the free state. We also measured binding as a function of temperature. At equilibrium, binding is enthalpically driven and arises from a highly positive activation enthalpy for association with small entropic contributions. Our results agree with those from studies using different techniques, providing additional evidence for the utility of 19F NMR lineshape analysis, and we anticipate that this analysis will be an effective tool for rapidly characterizing the energetics of protein interactions.

What does fluorine do to a protein? Thermodynamic, and highly-resolved structural insights into fluorine-labelled variants of the cold shock protein

Fluorine labelling represents one promising approach to study proteins in their native environment due to efficient suppressing of background signals. Here, we systematically probe inherent thermodynamic and structural characteristics of the Cold shock protein B from Bacillus subtilis (BsCspB) upon fluorine labelling. A sophisticated combination of fluorescence and NMR experiments has been applied to elucidate potential perturbations due to insertion of fluorine into the protein. We show that single fluorine labelling of phenylalanine or tryptophan residues has neither significant impact on thermodynamic stability nor on folding kinetics compared to wild type BsCspB. Structure determination of fluorinated phenylalanine and tryptophan labelled BsCspB using X-ray crystallography reveals no displacements even for the orientation of fluorinated aromatic side chains in comparison to wild type BsCspB. Hence we propose that single fluorinated phenylalanine and tryptophan residues used for protein labelling may serve as ideal probes to reliably characterize inherent features of proteins that are present in a highly biological context like the cell.