Indirect Emissions from Organophosphite Antioxidants Result in Significant Organophosphate Ester Contamination in China

Aqueous secondary formation substantially contributes to hydrophilic organophosphate esters in aerosols

Chemicals of emerging concern (CECs), like organophosphate esters (OPEs), are toxic substances threatening human and wildlife health. Yet the atmospheric transformation of CECs remains poorly understood. Here we combine field measurements and partitioning models to reveal that OPEs could be enhanced by aqueous-phase processes in aerosols. We show that hydrophobic OPEs are absorbed favorably into the organic phase, whereas hydrophilic OPEs preferably partition into the aqueous phase. We provide field evidence that enhanced aqueous secondary formation of OPEs occurs in winter, and its magnitude is strongly dependent on aerosol water content. We suggest that dissolved inorganic salts and transition metals in aerosols positively impact the formation of particle-bound hydrophilic OPEs, by facilitating aqueous partitioning and/or oxidation. Our findings highlight the important role of aqueous oxidation chemistry for the fate of CECs in the atmosphere, urging better consideration of transformation products in future risk assessment and chemical management.

Traditional and novel organophosphate esters in atmosphere of greenhouse covered with mulch films: Seasonal variations, partitioning and exposure risks

Mulch films play a critical role in the accumulation of organophosphate esters (OPEs) in greenhouse soils. However, their impact on the occurrence, partitioning and health risks of atmospheric OPEs is unclear. This study fully investigated multi-media distributions of eleven traditional OPEs and four novel OPEs in greenhouses covered with degradable mulch films. The atmospheric concentrations exhibited substantial variability, ranging from 539 to 14821 pg/m³ in the gas phase and from 242 to 8320 pg/m³ in the particle phase, with summer levels higher than winter levels. Significant correlations (p < 0.05) were detected between OPE concentrations in mulch films and in air, indicating mulch films as a major source. First-order kinetic model effectively characterized the release patterns of dominant congeners including triphenyl phosphate and tris(2,4-ditert-butylphenyl) phosphate from degradable films. The Li-Ma-Yang model showed superior predictive capability for gas-particle partitioning than the Harner-Bidleman model. Total concentrations of OPEs in uncoated soils were at a range of 274-955 μg/kg. Soil-air exchange behaviors of OPEs governed by inherent volatility exhibited a seasonal dependence. While non-carcinogenic risks of OPEs for greenhouse farmers via air inhalation and dermal contact were negligible, holistic health assessments should integrate other uptake pathways and consider transformation products of OPEs.

Strategies to Reduce Uncertainties from the Best Available Physicochemical Parameters Used for Modeling Novel Organophosphate Esters across Multimedia Environments

Organophosphate esters (OPEs) raise growing environmental and human health concerns globally. However, numerous novel OPEs lack data on physicochemical properties, which are essential for assessing environmental fate, exposure, and risks. This study predicted water solubility (Sw), vapor pressure (Vp), octanol-water partition coefficient (Kow), and octanol-air partition coefficient (Koa) at 25 °C for 46 novel OPEs by identifying optimal in silico tools and establishing prediction strategies based on molecular weights (MWs). Prediction discrepancies between in silico tools increased with MWs and structural complexity. Method evaluations for compounds with MWs > 450 g/mol suggest that COSMOtherm is advantageous in predicting Sw and Vp for alkyl-OPEs, while SPARC is better for predicting Vp for aryl- and halogenated-OPEs. For compounds with MWs > 500 g/mol, COSMOtherm and SPARC are recommended for Kow and Koa prediction, respectively. For smaller OPEs, average values from the top three of COSMOtherm, SPARC, EPI Suite, and OPERA, ranked by validation on traditional flame retardants, are recommended. Using improper software could cause deviations in multimedia distribution and overall persistence in the environment by up to 83 and 350%, respectively. The present data and prediction strategy are useful to enhance the reliability of environmental fate, exposure, and risk assessments of various OPEs and emerging contaminants.

Multi-target analyses of persistent organic pollutants, halogenated natural products, and organophosphate esters in bivalves from Seto Inland Sea, Japan: Residue levels, profiles, and spatial trends

Comprehensive monitoring studies on the multiple exposure status to persistent organic pollutants (POPs), halogenated natural products (HNPs), and organophosphate esters (OPEs) of coastal biota are quite limited worldwide, especially for wild sessile bivalves. The present study performed multi-target analyses of POPs, HNPs, and OPEs in mussel and oyster samples collected in 2017 and 2019 from the coastal areas of Seto Inland Sea, the largest semi-enclosed sea in Japan. For OPEs, we established a highly accurate analytical method applicable for bivalve soft tissue samples, with minimal blank contamination. Multi-target analyses based on gas and liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry revealed the ubiquity of not only legacy but also emerging compounds in the coastal areas of Seto Inland Sea. However, clear differences in the spatial distribution patterns of POPs, HNPs, and OPEs were observed, indicating the presence of compound-specific local emission sources in the coastal environment. Interestingly, several aryl- and chlorinated-OPEs, including triphenyl phosphate (TPHP), tricresyl phosphate (TMPP), tris(2-chloroisopropyl) phosphate (TCIPP), and tris(1,3-dichloroisopropyl) phosphate (TDCIPP), were found in the bivalve samples with detection frequencies >50 %, and the residue levels of these OPE compounds were higher than those of the major hexabromocyclododecanes and polybrominated diphenyl ethers at almost all the sampling points. These results might be attributed to the increasing demand of OPEs as alternatives after the regulation of such hazardous brominated flame retardants (BFRs). Especially, considering that TCIPP has the lowest log octanol/water partition coefficient (log Kow) and thus the lowest bioaccumulation potential among the above OPEs and BFRs, but still accumulate at relatively higher concentrations in the bivalves, substantial amount of TCIPP input into the coastal areas of Seto Inland Sea and subsequent exposure for organisms can be suggested.

A Novel Organophosphate Ester, Tris(2,4-ditert-butylphenyl) Phosphate, Induced Reproductive Toxicity in Male Zebrafish at Environmentally Relevant Concentrations

As a novel organophosphate ester (NOPE), tris(2,4-ditert-butylphenyl) phosphate (TDtBPP) has attracted significant attention due to its unexpectedly high detection in natural environments. However, the ecological toxic effects of environmentally relevant concentrations of TDtBPP in organisms remain entirely unknown. In this study, 1 month old zebrafish were exposed to 0, 50, 500, or 5000 ng/L TDtBPP for 150 days, and the reproductive toxicity in male fish was evaluated. Results demonstrated that TDtBPP exposure significantly inhibited the maturation of spermatozoa and thus decreased spermatogenesis. Furthermore, abnormal sperm morphology and decreased sperm motility were also observed. The decrease in sperm quantity and quality eventually resulted in the declining fecundity. Moreover, TDtBPP exposure downregulated the expression of hsd3b1 in vivo and in vitro and subsequently inhibited the synthesis of androgens in zebrafish testes and Leydig cells. This inhibition of androgen synthesis appeared to be responsible for the observed reproductive toxicity in male fish. Molecular docking and dual-luciferase reporter gene experiments elucidated that TDtBPP inhibited the promotion of vitamin D on hsd3b1 transcription by the vitamin D receptor and thus downregulated the expression of hsd3b1. Our findings provide first time evidence that TDtBPP poses a risk to male fish reproduction at environmentally relevant levels.

Novel organophosphate esters and their transformation products in offshore sediment from Eastern China: Occurrence, temporal trend, and risk assessment

Offshore sediment serves as an important sink for traditional organophosphate esters (TOPEs) originating from terrestrial sources. However, the contamination characteristics of novel OPEs (NOPEs) and their hydrolyzed and hydroxylated transformation products (Di- and OH-OPEs) in marine sediment are still unknown. In this study, 34 OPE-associated contaminants were measured in six offshore sediment cores (71 samples) collected from Eastern China. The total concentrations of Σ15TOPEs, Σ3NOPEs, Σ9Di-OPEs, and Σ7OH-OPEs in surface sediments were 3.16-73.4, n.d.-16.3, 4.48-21.4, and 0.14-0.42 ng g-1, respectively. NOPE compounds, such as tris(2,4-di-tert-butylphenyl) phosphate and its diester product, exhibited high contamination levels, primarily due to their high hydrophobicity and extensive industrial applications. Additionally, atmospheric transportation, along with wet and dry deposition and ocean currents, plays a crucial role in their distribution in offshore sediment. The location conditions and historical usage also influenced the vertical distributions of OPE-associated contaminants in sediment cores. Notably, a concentration peak of bis(2,4-di-tert-butylphenyl) phosphate (B2,4DtBPP) was dating back to 1940s, indicating the early usage of antioxidant tris(2,4-di-tert-butylphenyl) phosphite. Furthermore, a risk quotient (RQ) model was employed to assess the ecological risks posed by OPEs. Generally, the acute toxicity-based predicted no-effect concentrations for studied compounds were 1 to 2 orders of magnitude lower than those based on chronic toxicity. NOPEs and B2,4DtBPP exhibited high ecological risks, with maximum RQ values of 1570-4877 based on acute toxicity and 93.4-197 based on chronic toxicity. Notably, ΣRQ values for NOPEs were significantly higher than those of TOPEs (Mann-Whitney U test, p < 0.001), indicating their severe ecological risks in offshore sediment. Therefore, given the continuous input and considerable persistence of NOPEs in offshore sediment, their toxic effects and mechanisms warrant thorough investigation. This study provides the first evidence for the occurrence, temporal trends, and potential risks of NOPEs in marine sediment environment.

Nationwide profiling and source identification of organophosphate esters in Korean surface waters using target, suspect, and non-target HRMS analysis

Organophosphate esters (OPEs) are emerging contaminants that serve as alternatives to regulated substances in aquatic environments. A nationwide large-scale assessment for OPEs, including point sources, remains insufficient. To address this issue, we aimed to investigate OPEs occurrence and novel OPEs via comprehensive target, suspect and non-target analysis. Among the 11 target OPEs, 10 were detected at sampling sites distributed evenly nationwide. The highest mean concentrations were measured for tris-(2-butoxyethyl) phosphate (TBOEP) and tris(2-chloroisopropyl) phosphate (TCIPP). The multivariate statistical analysis revealed that TBOEP and TCIPP are essential components for assessing total OPEs pollution. The systematic risk assessment results evaluated the overall risk contribution of TBOEP and the significant risk impact of 2-ethylhexyl diphenyl phosphate. Promising suspect and non-target analysis enabled frequent detection and identification of 6 antioxidant transformation products (TPs), as well as the tentative identification of 14 OPEs and TPs, including 3 di-OPEs. Based on sampling site classification, we confirmed that major OPEs are significantly discharged near point sources. We believe that this is the first attempt to assess the nationwide risk and potential sources of OPEs in Korean surface waters, providing insights that could support further prioritization and regulation efforts.

Effect of nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides to triphenyl phosphate degradation and cytotoxicity on surface of different transition metal salts

Nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides, as the dominant toxic gases in the atmosphere, can induce severe human health problems under the composite pollutant conditions. Currently the effect of nitrogen or sulfur oxides in atmospheric environment to the degradation and cytotoxicity of triphenyl phosphate (TPhP) on atmospheric particle surfaces still remain poorly understood. Hence, laboratory simulation methods were used in this study to investigate the effect and related mechanism. First, particle samples were prepared with the TPhP coated on MnSO4, CuSO4, FeSO4 and Fe2(SO4)3 surface. The results showed that, when nitrogen or sulfur oxides were present, more significant TPhP degradation on all samples can be observed under both light and dark conditions. The results proved nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides were the vital influence factors to the degradation of TPhP, which mainly promoted the OH generation in the polluted atmosphere. The mechanism study indicated that diphenyl hydrogen phosphate (DPhP) and OH-DPhP were two main stable degradation products. These degradation products originated from the phenoxy bond cleavage and hydroxylation of TPhP caused by hydroxyl radicals. In addition, no TPhP related organosulfates (OSs) or organic nitrates (ON) formation were observed. Regarding the cytotoxicity, all the particles can induce more significant cellular injury and apoptosis of A549 cells, which may be relevant to the adsorbed nitrogen oxides or sulfur oxides on particles surfaces. The superfluous reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation was the possible reason of cytotoxicity. This research can supply a comprehensive understanding of the promoting effect of nitrogen and sulfur oxides to TPhP degradation and the composite cytotoxicity of atmospheric particles.

Global Gridded Emission Inventory of Organophosphate Flame Retardants from 2010 to 2020

As a substitute for brominated flame retardants, organophosphate flame retardants (OPFRs) have become a global concern due to their high toxicity and bioaccumulation. To paint an overall picture of OPFRs in the global environment, the present study develops a gridded global emission inventory of OPFRs on a spatial resolution of 1 × 1° from 2010 to 2020. Revealing a 3.31% average annual increase in emissions, totaling 21,324.42 tons. The production process is the primary source, accounting for 55.43% of emissions, with consumption processes making up the rest. Major sources are in Asia, North America, and Europe. The inventory is verified by implementing emission data into a global atmospheric transport model to predict OPFR concentrations in the global environment and comparing modeled concentrations with field sampled data. The results indicate that the inventory is reliable except for the pristine polar region, where the emission inventory and modeled concentrations underestimate OPFR levels in the atmosphere, likely resulting from ignorance of chemical reactions and the secondary derivative of parent OPFRs during their global long-distance atmospheric transport in the model. This comprehensive data set aids in formulating OPFR emission control policies and assessing health risks.

Integration of Nontarget Screening and QSPR Models to Identify Novel Organophosphate Esters of High Priority in Aquatic Environment

With the development of large numbers of novel organophosphate esters (OPEs) alternatives, it is imperative to screen and identify those with high priority. In this study, surface water, biofilms, and freshwater snails were collected from the flow-in rivers of Taihu Lake Basin, China. Screened by target, suspect, and nontarget analysis, 11 traditional and 14 novel OPEs were identified, of which 5 OPEs were first discovered in Taihu Lake Basin. The OPE concentrations in surface water ranged from 196 to 2568 ng/L, with the primary homologue tris(2,4-ditert-butylphenyl) phosphate (TDtBPP) being newly identified, which was likely derived from the transformation of tris(2,4-ditert-butylphenyl) phosphite. The majority of the newly identified OPEs displayed substantially higher bioaccumulation and biomagnification potentials in the biofilm-snail food chain than the traditional ones. Quantitative structure-property relationship models revealed both hydrophobicity and polarity influenced the bioaccumulation and biomagnification of the OPEs, while electrostatic attraction also had a contribution to the bioaccumulation in the biofilm. TDtBPP was determined as the utmost priority by toxicological priority index scheme, which integrated concentration, bioaccumulation, biomagnification, acute toxicity, and endocrine disrupting potential of the identified OPEs. These findings provide novel insights into the behaviors of OPEs and scientific bases for better management of high-risk pollutants in aquatic ecosystem.

Aggravating Pollution of Emerging Aryl Organophosphate Esters in Urban Estuarine Sediments of South China

Emerging aryl organophosphate esters (aryl-OPEs) have been employed as substitutes for organohalogen flame retardants in recent years; however, their environmental occurrence and associated impacts in urban estuarine sediments have not been adequately investigated, impeding regulatory decision-making. Herein, field-based investigations and modeling based on surface sediment and sediment core analysis were employed to uncover the historical pollution and current environmental impacts of aryl-OPEs in the Pearl River Estuary, South China. Our results revealed a substantial increase in aryl-OPE emission, particularly emerging aryl-OPEs, through sediment transport to the estuary since the 2000s. The emerging aryl-OPEs comprised 83% of the total annual input in the past decade, with an average annual input of 155,000 g. Additionally, the emerging-to-traditional aryl-OPE concentration ratios increased with decreasing distance from the shore, peaking in the highly urbanized riverine outlets. These findings indicate that inventories of emerging aryl-OPEs are likely increasing in estuarine sediments and their emissions are surpassing those of traditional aryl-OPEs. Our risk-based priority screening approach indicates that some emerging aryl-OPEs, particularly bisphenol A bis(diphenyl phosphate), can pose a higher environmental risk than traditional aryl-OPEs in estuarine sediments. Overall, our study highlights the importance of recognizing the environmental impacts of emerging aryl-OPEs.

Contamination Status of Novel Organophosphate Esters Derived from Organophosphite Antioxidants in Soil and the Effects on Soil Bacterial Communities

The contamination status of novel organophosphate esters (NOPEs) and their precursors organophosphite antioxidants (OPAs) and hydroxylated/diester transformation products (OH-OPEs/di-OPEs) in soils across a large-scale area in China were investigated. The total concentrations of the three test NOPEs in soil were 82.4-716 ng g-1, which were considerably higher than those of traditional OPEs (4.50-430 ng g-1), OPAs (n.d.-30.8 ng g-1), OH-OPEs (n.d.-0.49 ng g-1), and di-OPEs (0.57-21.1 ng g-1). One NOPE compound, i.e., tris(2,4-di-tert-butylphenyl) phosphate (AO168 = O) contributed over 65% of the concentrations of the studied OPE-associated contaminants. A 30-day soil incubation experiment was performed to confirm the influence of AO168 = O on soil bacterial communities. Specific genera belonging to Proteobacteria, such as Lysobacter and Ensifer, were enriched in AO168 = O-contaminated soils. Moreover, the ecological function of methylotrophy was observed to be significantly enhanced (t-test, p < 0.01) in soil treated with AO168 = O, while nitrogen fixation was significantly inhibited (t-test, p < 0.01). These findings comprehensively revealed the contamination status of OPE-associated contaminants in the soil environment and provided the first evidence of the effects of NOPEs on soil microbial communities.

Discovering Novel Organophosphorus Compounds in Wastewater Treatment Plant Effluents through Suspect Screening and Nontarget Analysis

Limited knowledge on the structure of emerging organophosphorus compounds (OPCs) hampers our comprehensive understanding of their environmental occurrence and potential risks. Through suspect and nontarget screening, combining data-dependent acquisition, data-independent acquisition, and parallel reaction monitoring modes, we identified 60 OPCs (17 traditional and 43 emerging compounds) in effluents of 14 wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) in Beijing and Qinghai, China. These OPCs comprise 26 organophosphate triesters, 17 organophosphate diesters, 6 organophosphonates, 7 organothiophosphate esters, and 4 other OPCs. Notably, 14 suspect OPCs were newly identified in WWTP effluents, and 16 nontarget OPCs were newly discovered in environmental matrices. Specifically, the cyclic phosphonate, (5-ethyl-2-methyl-1,3,2-dioxaphosphorinan-5-yl)methyl dimethyl phosphonate P-oxide (PMMMPn), consistently appeared in all WWTP effluents, with semiquantitative concentrations ranging from 44.4 to 282 ng/L. Its analogue, di-PMMMPn, presented in 93% of wastewater samples. Compositional differences between the WWTP effluents of two cities were mainly attributed to emerging OPCs. Hazard and ecological risk assessment underscored the substantial contribution of chlorinated organophosphate esters and organothiophosphate esters to overall risks of OPCs in WWTP effluents. This study provides the most comprehensive OPC profiles in WWTP effluents to date, highlighting the need for further research on their occurrence, fate, and risks, particularly for chlorinated OPCs.