Bis-benzoxaboroles: Design, Synthesis, and Biological Evaluation as Carbonic Anhydrase Inhibitors

Multiple Binding Modes of Inhibitors to Human Carbonic Anhydrases: An Update on the Design of Isoform-Specific Modulators of Activity

Human carbonic anhydrases (hCAs) are widespread zinc enzymes that catalyze the hydration of CO2 to bicarbonate and a proton. Currently, 15 isoforms have been identified, of which only 12 are catalytically active. Given their involvement in numerous physiological and pathological processes, hCAs are recognized therapeutic targets for the development of inhibitors with biomedical applications. However, despite massive development efforts, very few of the presently available hCA inhibitors show selectivity for a specific isoform. X-ray crystallography is a very useful tool for the rational drug design of enzyme inhibitors. In 2012 we published in Chemical Reviews a highly cited review on hCA family (Alterio, V. et al. Chem Rev. 2012, 112, 4421-4468), analyzing about 300 crystallographic structures of hCA/inhibitor complexes and describing the different CA inhibition mechanisms existing up to that date. However, in the period 2012-2023, almost 700 new hCA/inhibitor complex structures have been deposited in the PDB and a large number of new inhibitor classes have been discovered. Based on these considerations, the aim of this Review is to give a comprehensive update of the structural aspects of hCA/inhibitor interactions covering the period 2012-2023 and to recapitulate how this information can be used for the rational design of more selective versions of such inhibitors.

Exploring the binding mode of phenyl and vinyl boronic acids to human carbonic anhydrases

Boronic acids are an interesting but still poorly studied class of carbonic anhydrase inhibitors. Previous investigations proved that derivatives incorporating aromatic, arylalkyl, and arylalkenyl moieties are low micromolar to millimolar inhibitors for several α- and β-CAs involved in pathologic states. Here we report a high-resolution X-ray study on two classes of boronic acids (phenyl and vinyl) in complex with hCA II. Our results unambiguously clarify the binding mode of these molecules to the human carbonic anhydrase active site, which occurs through their tetrahedral anionic form, regardless of the nature of the organic scaffold. Data here presented contribute to the understanding of the inhibition mechanism of boronic acids that can be fruitfully used for the rational design of novel and effective isozyme-specific carbonic anhydrase inhibitors.

Identification, crystallization, and first X-ray structure analyses of phenyl boronic acid-based inhibitors of human carbonic anhydrase-II

Human carbonic anhydrases (hCAs) play a central role in various physiological processes in the human body. HCAs catalyze the reversible hydration of CO2 into HCO3-, and hence maintains the fluid and pH balance. Overexpression of CA II is associated with diseases, such as glaucoma, and epilepsy. Therefore, CAs are important clinical targets and inhibition of different isoforms, especially hCA II is used in treatment of glaucoma, altitude sickness, and epilepsy. Therapeutically used CA inhibitors (CAI) are sulfonamide-based, such as acetazolamide, dichlorphenamide, methazolamide, ethoxzolamide, etc. However, they exhibit several undesirable effects such as numbness, tingling of extremities, malaise, metallic taste, fatigue, renal calculi, and metabolic acidosis. Therefore, there is an urgent need to identify safe and effective inhibitors of the hCAs. In this study, different phenyl boronic acids 1-5 were evaluated against bovine (bCA II) and hCA II. Among all, compound 1 (4-acetylphenyl boronic acid) was found to be active against bCAII and hCA II with IC50 values of 246 ± 0.48 and 281.40 ± 2.8 μM, respectively, while the remaining compounds were found in-active. Compound 1 was identified as competitive inhibitor of hCA II enzyme (Ki = 283.7 ± 0.002 μM). Additionally, compound 1 was found to be non-toxic against BJ Human fibroblast cell line. The X-ray crystal structure for hCA II in-complex with compound 1 was evaluated to a resolution of 2.6 Å. In fact, this the first structural analysis of a phenyl boron-based inhibitor bound to hCA II, allowing an additional structure-activity analysis of the compounds. Compound 1 was found to be directly bound in the active site of hCA II by interacting with His94, His119, and Thr199 residues. In addition, a bond of 3.11 Å between the zinc ion and coordinated boron atom of the boronic acid moiety of compound 1 was also observed, contributing to binding affinity of compound 1 for hCA II. PDB ID: 8IGF.

The Rise of Boron-Containing Compounds: Advancements in Synthesis, Medicinal Chemistry, and Emerging Pharmacology

Boron-containing compounds (BCC) have emerged as important pharmacophores. To date, five BCC drugs (including boronic acids and boroles) have been approved by the FDA for the treatment of cancer, infections, and atopic dermatitis, while some natural BCC are included in dietary supplements. Boron's Lewis acidity facilitates a mechanism of action via formation of reversible covalent bonds within the active site of target proteins. Boron has also been employed in the development of fluorophores, such as BODIPY for imaging, and in carboranes that are potential neutron capture therapy agents as well as novel agents in diagnostics and therapy. The utility of natural and synthetic BCC has become multifaceted, and the breadth of their applications continues to expand. This review covers the many uses and targets of boron in medicinal chemistry.

Boron-containing carbonic anhydrases inhibitors

Over the last decades, the medicinal chemistry of boron-based compounds has been extensively explored, designing valuable small molecule drugs to tackle diseases and conditions, such as cancer, infections, inflammatory and neurological disorders. Notably, boron has proven to also be a valuable element for the development of inhibitors of the metalloenzymes carbonic anhydrases (CAs), a class of drug targets with significant potential in medicinal chemistry. Incorporating boron into carbonic anhydrase inhibitors (CAIs) can modulate the ligand ability to recognize the target and/or influence selectivity towards different CA isoforms, using the tail approach and boron-based tails. The electron-deficient nature of boron and its associated properties have also led to the discovery of novel zinc-binding CAIs, such as boronic acids and the benzoxaboroles, capable of inhibiting the CAs upon a Lewis acid-base mechanism of action. The present manuscript reviews the state-of-the-art of boron-based CAIs. As research in the applications of boron compounds in medicinal chemistry continues, it is anticipated that new boron-based CAIs will soon expand the current array of such compounds. However, further research is imperative to fully unlock the potential of boron-based CAIs and to advance them towards clinical applications.

Potent carbonic anhydrase I, II, IX and XII inhibition activity of novel primary benzenesulfonamides incorporating bis-ureido moieties

A novel series of twelve aromatic bis-ureido-substituted benzenesulfonamides was synthesised by conjugation of aromatic aminobenzenesulfonamides with aromatic bis-isocyanates. The obtained bis-ureido-substituted derivatives were tested against four selected human carbonic anhydrase isoforms (hCA I, hCA II, hCA IX and hCA XII). Most of the new compounds showed an effective inhibitory profile against isoforms hCA IX and hCA XII, also having some selectivity with respect to hCA I and hCA II. The inhibition constants of these compounds against isoforms hCA IX and XII were in the range of 6.73-835 and 5.02-429 nM, respectively. Since hCA IX and hCA XII are important drug targets for anti-cancer/anti-metastatic drugs, these effective inhibitors reported here may be considered of interest for cancer related studies in which these enzymes are involved.

Aromatic Diboronic Acids as Effective KPC/AmpC Inhibitors

Over 30 compounds, including para-, meta-, and ortho-phenylenediboronic acids, ortho-substituted phenylboronic acids, benzenetriboronic acids, di- and triboronated thiophenes, and pyridine derivatives were investigated as potential β-lactamase inhibitors. The highest activity against KPC-type carbapenemases was found for ortho-phenylenediboronic acid 3a, which at the concentration of 8/4 mg/L reduced carbapenems' MICs up to 16/8-fold, respectively. Checkerboard assays revealed strong synergy between carbapenems and 3a with the fractional inhibitory concentrations indices of 0.1-0.32. The nitrocefin hydrolysis test and the whole cell assay with E. coli DH5α transformant carrying blaKPC-3 proved KPC enzyme being its molecular target. para-Phenylenediboronic acids efficiently potentiated carbapenems against KPC-producers and ceftazidime against AmpC-producers, whereas meta-phenylenediboronic acids enhanced only ceftazidime activity against the latter ones. Finally, the statistical analysis confirmed that ortho-phenylenediboronic acids act synergistically with carbapenems significantly stronger than other groups. Since the obtained phenylenediboronic compounds are not toxic to MRC-5 human fibroblasts at the tested concentrations, they can be considered promising scaffolds for the future development of novel KPC/AmpC inhibitors. The complexation of KPC-2 with the most representative isomeric phenylenediboronic acids 1a, 2a, and 3a was modeled by quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics calculations. Compound 3a reached the most effective configuration enabling covalent binding to the catalytic Ser70 residue.

Squaramide-Tethered Sulfonamides and Coumarins: Synthesis, Inhibition of Tumor-Associated CAs IX and XII and Docking Simulations

(1) Background: carbonic anhydrases (CAs) are attractive targets for the development of new anticancer therapies; in particular, CAs IX and XII isoforms are overexpressed in numerous tumors. (2) Methods: following the tail approach, we have appended a hydrophobic aromatic tail to a pharmacophore responsible for the CA inhibition (aryl sulfonamide, coumarin). As a linker, we have used squaramides, featured with strong hydrogen bond acceptor and donor capacities. (3) Results: Starting from easily accessible dimethyl squarate, the title compounds were successfully obtained as crystalline solids, avoiding the use of chromatographic purifications. Interesting and valuable SARs could be obtained upon modification of the length of the hydrocarbon chain, position of the sulfonamido moiety, distance of the aryl sulfonamide scaffold to the squaramide, stereoelectronic effects on the aromatic ring, as well as the number and type of substituents on C-3 and C-4 positions of the coumarin. (4) Conclusions: For sulfonamides, the best profile was achieved for the m-substituted derivative 11 (Ki = 29.4, 9.15 nM, CA IX and XII, respectively), with improved selectivity compared to acetazolamide, a standard drug. Coumarin derivatives afforded an outstanding selectivity (Ki > 10,000 nM for CA I, II); the lead compound (16c) was a strong CA IX and XII inhibitor (Ki = 19.2, 7.23 nM, respectively). Docking simulations revealed the key ligand-enzyme interactions.

Boron-Containing heterocycles as promising pharmacological agents

The incorporation of the "magic" boron atom has been established as an important new strategy in the field of medicinal chemistry as boron compounds have been shown to form various bonds with their biological targets. Currently, a number of boron-based drugs (e.g. bortezomib, crisaborole, and tavaborole) have been FDA approved and are in the clinic, and several other boron-containing compounds are in clinical trials. Boron-based heterocycles have an incredible potential in the ongoing quest for new therapeutic agents owing to their plethora of biological activities and useful pharmacokinetic profiles. The present perspective is intended to review the pharmacological applications of boron-based heterocycles that have been published. We have classified these compounds into groups exhibiting shared pharmacological activities and discussed their corresponding biological targets focusing mainly on the most potent therapeutic compounds.

Applications of the Reversible Boronic Acids/Boronate Switch to Nucleic Acids

Over the last decades, boron and nucleic acids chemistries have gained a lot of attention for biological, medicinal and analytical applications. Our laboratory has a long-standing interest in both chemistries and owing to the ability of boronic acids to react with cis-diol function in aqueous media we developed over the years a variety of applications ranging from molecular recognition and sensing to the development of reversible dynamic systems in which the natural phosphodiester linkage was replaced by a boronate. In this account, we summarize research results from our group from our preliminary studies on molecular recognition of ribonucleosides to the dynamic assembly of functional DNAzymes. In particular, the various parameters influencing the dynamic nature of these reversible covalent bonds able to respond to external stimuli are discussed. Finally, current challenges and opportunities for boron-based nucleic acids are also addressed.

Aryl-n-hexanamide linked enaminones of usnic acid as promising antimicrobial agents

Lichen secondary metabolites are well explored medicinal agents with diverse pharmacological properties. One of the important antibiotic lichen secondary metabolites is usnic acid. Its diverse medicinal profiles prompted us to explore it as a potential antitubercular molecule. Towards this direction, continuing our efforts on the discovery and development of new analogs with potent antitubercular properties we designed, synthesized, and evaluated a set of 37 usnic acid enaminone-coupled aryl-n-hexanamides (3-39). The study yielded a 3,4-dimethoxyphenyl compound (13, 5.3 µM) as the most active anti-TB molecule. The docking studies were performed on 7 different enzymes to better understand the binding modes, where it was observed that compound 13 bound strongly with glucose dehydrogenase (Gscore: - 9.03). Further antibacterial investigations revealed compound 2 with potent inhibition on Salmonella typhi and Bacillus subtilis (MIC 3 µM) and MIC values of 7 and 14 µM on Streptococcus mutans and Escherichia coli respectively. Compound 19 (3-F-5-CF₃-phenyl) displayed encouraging antibacterial profiles against E. coli, S. typhi and S. mutans with MIC values of 10 µM respectively. Interestingly, compound 20 (2,6-difluorophenyl) also displayed good antibacterial activity against E. coli with an MIC value of 6 µM. These encouraging pharmacological results will help for better designing and developing usnic acid-based semi-synthetic derivatives as potential antimicrobial agents. A set of 37 new usnic acid enaminone-coupled aryl-n-hexanamides were synthesized and evaluated as potential antimicrobial agents. Compound 13 was identified as the most active antitubercular molecule. 13 was further docked against 7 different enzymes of tuberculosis. The molecule displayed maximum binding energy with the enzyme Glucose dehydrogenase (Gscore: - 9.03), indicating that these hexanamides possibly act by inhibiting the glucose metabolic pathway of the bacterium. Surprisingly, the intermediate hexanoic acid 2 was identified as potent antibacterial agent, acting on both gram-positive and gram-negative bacterial strains (3-14 μM). The active compounds may be subjected to structural iterations to develop further leads.

The Boron Advantage: The Evolution and Diversification of Boron’s Applications in Medicinal Chemistry

In this review, the history of boron’s early use in drugs, and the history of the use of boron functional groups in medicinal chemistry applications are discussed. This includes diazaborines, boronic acids, benzoxaboroles, boron clusters, and carboranes. Furthermore, critical developments from these functional groups are highlighted along with recent developments, which exemplify potential prospects. Lastly, the application of boron in the form of a prodrug, softdrug, and as a nanocarrier are discussed to showcase boron’s emergence into new and exciting fields. Overall, we emphasize the evolution of organoboron therapeutic agents as privileged structures in medicinal chemistry and outline the impact that boron has had on drug discovery and development.

Coumarin-benzimidazole hybrids: A review of developments in medicinal chemistry

Coumarin and benzimidazole are privileged structures in medicinal chemistry and are widely used in drug discovery and development due to their vast biological properties. The pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties of the individual scaffolds can be improved by developing coumarin-benzimidazole chimeric molecules via molecular hybridization approach. The three major classes of coumarin-benzimidazole hybrids are merged, fused and spacer-linked hybrids. Depending on the substitution position, fused hybrids and spacer-linked hybrids can be further classified as coumarin-C3 hybrids, coumarin-C4 hybrids and coumarin-C5/6/7/8 hybrids. Most of the coumarin-benzimidazole hybrid molecules exhibited potent anticancer, antiviral, antimicrobial, antitubercular, anthelmintic, anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, anticonvulsant and carbonic anhydrase inhibitory activities. The fused coumarin-C3 hybrid (2), thiomethylene-linked coumarin-C3 hybrid (45), N-glucoside substituted thiomethylene-linked coumarin-C3 hybrid (37c), amide-linked coumarin-C3 hybrid (50a), and sulfonylmethylene-linked coumarin-C4 hybrid (63) were identified as the representative potent anticancer, antimicrobial, antiviral, antioxidant and antitubercular agents respectively. The biological properties of the different classes of coumarin-benzimidazole hybrids with their structure-activity relationship studies and the mechanism of action studies were presented in this review, aiming to help the researchers across the globe to generate future hybrid molecules as potential drug candidates.

Targeting Metalloenzymes by Boron-Containing Metal-Binding Pharmacophores

Metalloenzymes have critical roles in a wide range of biological processes and are directly involved in many human diseases; hence, they are considered as important targets for therapeutic intervention. The specific characteristics of metal ion(s)-containing active sites make exploitation of metal-binding pharmacophores (MBPs) critical to inhibitor development targeting metalloenzymes. This Perspective focuses on boron-containing MBPs, which display unique binding modes with metalloenzyme active sites, particularly via mimicking native substrates or tetrahedral transition states. The design concepts regarding boron-containing MBPs are highlighted through the case analyses on five distinct classes of clinically relevant nucleophilic metalloenzymes from medicinal chemistry perspectives. The challenges (e.g., selectivity) faced by some boron-containing MBPs and possible strategies (e.g., bioisosteres) for metalloenzyme inhibitor transformation are also discussed.

Benzoxaboroles: New Potent Inhibitors of the Carbonic Anhydrases of the Pathogenic Bacterium Vibrio cholerae

A series of urea/thiourea substituted benzoxaboroles was investigated for the inhibition of the three carbonic anhydrases encoded by Vibrio cholerae (VchCAα, VchCAβ, and VchCAγ). In particular, benzoxaborole derivatives were here first assayed for the inhibition of a γ-class CA, extending the panel of CA classes that benzoxaboroles efficiently target beyond α and β. Inhibition profiles demonstrated that VchCAα was significantly more inhibited compared to VchCAγ and, in turn, more efficiently modulated than VchCAβ. Among the many selective benzoxaborole ligands detected against VchCAα over the off-target hCA II, compound 18, a p-NO₂-phenylthiourea derivative, even exhibited a fully selective inhibition profile against the three VchCAs over hCA II. A comprehensive ligand/target interaction study was performed in silico for all three VchCA isoforms providing the first molecular modeling investigation with inhibitors of a γ-class CA to the best of our knowledge. The present study reinforces the rationale behind the use of benzoxaboroles as innovative antibacterial agents with a new mechanism of action, furnishing suggestions for the rational design of new potent and selective inhibitors targeting V. cholerae CAs over human off-target ones.

Mechanochemical synthesis of antifungal bis(benzoxaboroles)

Several piperazine bis(benzoxaboroles) have been obtained both in solution as well as in the solid state. The environmentally friendly mechanochemical approach – hitherto not applied for the preparation of benzoxaboroles – was particularly beneficial in the case of two products afforded in low yields in solution. The in vitro studies showed high potential of the studied bis(fluorobenzoxaboroles) as antifungal agents, highlighting also the influence of the fluorine substituent position on their microbiological activity. The highest activity against A. niger, A. terreus, P. ochrochloron, C. tenuis and C. albicans was displayed by the analogue of the known benzoxaborole antifungal drug Kerydin® (Tavaborole).

Several piperazine bis(benzoxaboroles) have been obtained mechanochemically – two of them have been shown to display high antifungal activity.

Dimeric benzoboroxoles for targeted activity against Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Dimeric benzoboroxoles that are covalently linked by a short scaffold enhance selective anti-tubercular activity. These multimeric benzoboroxole compounds are capable of engaging the specific extracellular Mycobacterium tuberculosis glycans, do not lead to the evolution of resistance and bypass the need to cross the impermeable mycobacterial cell envelope barrier.