Halothane metabolism: the dihydrolipoamide acetyltransferase subunit of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex molecularly mimics trifluoroacetyl-protein adducts

Autoantibodies in Autoimmune Hepatitis: Can Epitopes Tell Us about the Etiology of the Disease?

Autoimmune hepatitis (AIH), primary biliary cholangitis (PBC), and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC) are serious autoimmune liver diseases that are characterized by a progressive destruction of the liver parenchyma and/or the hepatic bile ducts and the development of chronic fibrosis. Left untreated autoimmune liver diseases are often life-threatening, and patients require a liver transplantation to survive. Thus, an early and reliable diagnosis is paramount for the initiation of a proper therapy with immunosuppressive and/or anticholelithic drugs. Besides the analysis of liver biopsies and serum markers indicating liver damage, the screening for specific autoantibodies is an indispensable tool for the diagnosis of autoimmune liver diseases. Such liver autoantigen-specific antibodies might be involved in the disease pathogenesis, and their epitope specificity may give some insight into the etiology of the disease. Here, we will mainly focus on the generation and specificity of autoantibodies in AIH patients. In addition, we will review data from animal models that aim toward a better understanding of the origins and pathogenicity of such autoantibodies.

The autoimmunity of primary biliary cirrhosis and the clonal selection theory

Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is a chronic cholestatic liver disease in which an immune-mediated injury targets the small intrahepatic bile ducts. PBC is further characterized by highly specific serum antimitochondrial autoantibodies (AMA) and autoreactive T cells, a striking female predominance, a strong genetic susceptibility, and a plethora of candidate environmental factors to trigger the disease onset. For these reasons PBC appears ideal to represent the developments of the clonal selection theory over the past decades. First, a sufficiently potent autoimmunogenic stimulus in PBC would require the coexistence of numerous pre-existing conditions (mostly genetic, as recently illustrated by genome-wide association studies and animal models) to perpetuate the destruction of the biliary epithelium by the immune system via the persistence of forbidden clones. Second, the proposed modifications of mitochondrial autoantigens caused by infectious agents and/or xenobiotics well illustrate the possibility that peculiar changes in the antigen structure and flexibility may contribute to tolerance breakdown. Third, the unique apoptotic features demonstrated for cholangiocytes are the ideal setting for the development of mitochondrial autoantigen presentation to the immune system through macrophages and AMA thus turning the non traditional mitochondrial antigen into a traditional one. This article will review the current knowledge on PBC etiology and pathogenesis in light of the clonal selection theory developments.

Environmental factors and the induction of autoimmunity in primary biliary cirrhosis

Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is a chronic cholestatic disease with an autoimmune pathogenesis and an unknown etiology, predominantly affecting postmenopausal women. The term PBC is a misnomer since most cases currently diagnosed have limited probability to develop cirrhosis. Antimitochondrial autoantibodies, elevated IgM and selective destruction of the intrahepatic bile ducts are the hallmarks of PBC. A permissive genetic background is critical in producing susceptibility despite limited associations with alleles within the MHC. The disease has incomplete concordance in monozygotic twins and its geoepidemiology suggests a role for environmental factors in the induction of PBC. This hypothesis is further supported by clinical (risk factors) and experimental evidence. Some of the factors incriminated model molecular mimicry by infectious agents and xenobiotic chemicals. Additional candidates are being proposed through large screening; all proposed associations ultimately require confirmation in animal models and clinical practice.

The role of environmental factors in primary biliary cirrhosis

The etiology of primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) is enigmatic, although it is clearly related to a combination of genetic predisposition and environmental stimulation. PBC is a chronic autoimmune cholestatic liver disease that occurs throughout the world with a reported latitudinal gradient in prevalence and incidence. PBC is also characterized by a 60% concordance in monozygotic twins and is considered a model autoimmune disease because of several features common to other conditions and the relatively homogeneous serological and biochemical features. Several risk factors have been suggested to be associated with PBC, including exposure to infectious agents and chemical xenobiotics. This review will attempt to place such factors in perspective.

Animal models for autoimmune hepatitis

The liver is the target of adverse immune reactions in three putative autoimmune diseases: autoimmune hepatitis (AIH), primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC) and primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). These three diseases can be distinguished by clinical, histological, and immunological features. However, especially on the level of specific antibody formation an overlap can occur, which sometimes complicates diagnosis. In this review, we will concentrate on autoimmune hepatitis and the current state of animal models for this severe disease. AIH is characterized by the presence of interface hepatitis and portal plasma cell infiltration, hypergammaglobulinemia, and autoantibodies. The hallmark of type 2 AIH is the generation of autoantibodies of the LKM-1 type. The major target of these antibodies is the cytochrome P450 isoform 2D6 (CYP2D6). In the past several attempts have been made to develop a reliable animal model that reflects the persistent hepatic destruction that occurs in human AIH. However, most models were only successful in causing a transient form of hepatic damage and often used rather complex ways of disease induction.

Comparative immunoreactivity of anti-trifluoroacetyl (TFA) antibody and anti-lipoic acid antibody in primary biliary cirrhosis: searching for a mimic

Previous studies documenting the existence of cross-reactivity between the lipoated (but not unlipoated) forms of the inner lipoyl domain (E2L2) of PDC-E2 [the major autoantigen in Primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC)] and trifluoroacetylated (TFA) proteins, led us to hypothesize that PBC may be due to an initial insult with an environmental agent that cross-reacts with TFA. Therefore, we performed a comparative study of the reactivity of rabbit anti-TFA antibody and anti-lipoic acid (LA) antibody against the mitochondrial autoantigens of human PBC and various TFA and LA conjugated proteins. Whereas both anti-TFA and anti-LA reacted with PDC-E2, the wild-type lipoated form of E2L2, OGDC-E2, E3-BP and LA-KLH, neither reacted with BCOADC-E2 or the non-lipoated form of E2L2. Of interest was that while anti-TFA reacted with PDC-E2, TFA-RSA and LA-KLH, it failed to inhibit PDC-E2 enzyme function. In contrast, anti-LA demonstrated cytoplasmic and mitochondrial staining, and inhibited PDC enzyme activity. Hence, although considerable cross reactivity exists between anti-TFA and anti-LA, the molecular nature of the interaction is clearly different. One of 14 PBC sera reacted weakly with TFA-albumin, whereas four of 14 PBC sera reacted with LA-KLH. Immunohistochemically, both anti-TFA and anti-LA antibodies reacted focally with periportal hepatocytes and bile ducts in both PBC and controls. However, anti-LA produced much stronger focalized staining of the bile ducts of diseased liver. This study suggests that while anti-TFA antibody recognizes lipoic acid-linked enzymes and proteins, the epitope recognized differs from that of anti-LA antibody and PBC autoantibodies. It is unlikely that a response to TFA is the triggering event in PBC. Anti-LA antibodies share a higher degree of similarity to PBC sera providing suggestive evidence that anti-LA antibodies or anti-LA like antibodies (mimotopes) may help define the initiator of the autoimmune response.

Drug-induced immunotoxicity

Immune-related drug responses are one of the most common sources of idiosyncratic toxicity. A number of organs may be the target of such reactions; however, this review concentrates mostly on the liver. Drug-induced hepatitis is generally divided into two categories: acute hepatitis in which the drug or a metabolite destroys a vital target in the cell; immunoallergic hepatitis in which the drug triggers an adverse immune response directed against the liver. Their clinical features are: a) low frequency; b) dose independence; c) typical immune system manifestations such as fever, eosinophilia; d) delay between the initiation of treatment and onset of the disease; e) a shortened delay upon rechallenge; and f) occasional presence of autoantibodies in the serum of patients. Such signs have been found in cases of hepatitis triggered by drugs such as halothane, tienilic acid, dihydralazine and anticonvulsants. They will be taken as examples to demonstrate the recent progress made in determining the mechanisms responsible for the disease. The following mechanisms have been postulated: 1) the drug is first metabolized into a reactive metabolite which binds to the enzyme that generated it; 2) this produces a neoantigen which, once presented to the immune system, might trigger an immune response characterized by 3) the production of antibodies recognizing both the native and/or the modified protein; 4) rechallenge leads to increased neoantigen production, a situation in which the presence of antibodies may induce cytolysis. Toxicity is related to the nature and amount of neoantigen and also to other factors such as the individual immune system. An effort should be made to better understand the precise mechanisms underlying this kind of disease and thereby identify the drugs at risk; and also the neoantigen processes necessary for their introduction into the immune system. An animal model would be useful in this regard.

Immunotoxicology of the liver: adverse reactions to drugs

Liver is a frequent target for drug-induced hepatitis. They can be classified in two categories: the hepatitis in which the drug or a metabolite reach a vital target in the cell and the hepatitis in which the drug triggers an adverse immune response directed against the liver. We will discuss essentially this second kind of disease. They have key clinical features such as the low frequency, the dose independence, the delay between the beginning of drug intake and the triggering of the disease, the shortening of the delay upon rechallenge and very often the presence of autoantibodies in the serum of the patients. Such signs were found in hepatitis triggered by drugs such as halothane, tienilic acid, dihydralazine, anticonvulsants. They will be taken as examples to show the recent progress in the understanding of the mechanisms leading to the disease. It has been postulated that the drug is metabolised into a reactive metabolite binding to the enzyme which generated it; therefore the neoantigen might trigger an immune response characterised by the production of antibodies recognising the native and or the modified protein. Most of these steps were proven in the cases of halothane, tienilic acid and dihydralazine. Several points seem important in the development of the disease; the equilibrium between toxication and detoxication pathways, the nature and amount of neoantigen, the individual immune response. However, many points remain unclear: for instance, the reason for the very low frequency of this kind of disease; the precise mechanism of the adverse immune response; the risk factors for developing such adverse reactions. Efforts should be made to better understand the mechanisms of this kind of disease: for instance, an animal model, tests to identify drugs at risk for such reactions, the role of these drugs in the processing of P450s and the processing of the neoantigens for their presentation to the immune system.

Cytochromes P450 and UDP-glucuronosyl-transferases as hepatocellular autoantigens

Autoantibodies directed against cytochromes P450 or UDP-glucuronosyl-transferases (UGTs) are detected in hepatitis of different aetiology: drug-induced hepatitis autoimmune hepatitis type 2, hepatitis associated with the autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1 (APS1) and virus-induced autoimmunity. Autoantibodies directed against cytochrome P450 2C9 are induced by tienilic acid, and anti-P450 1A2 autoantibodies by dihydralazine. Potential mechanisms involved may be metabolic activation of the drugs by cytochromes P450, adduct formation and circumvention of T cell tolerance. In contrast, little is known about the aetiology of autoimmune hepatitis type 2. This disease is characterized by marked female predominance, hypergammaglobulinaemia, circulating autoantibodies and benefit from immunosuppression. Patients with HLA B8, DR3 or DR4 are over-represented. The major target of autoimmunity in this disease is cytochrome P450 2D6. The autoantibodies were shown to be directed against at four short linear epitopes. In addition, about 10% of the patient sera form an additional autoantibody that detects a conformational epitope on UGTs of family 1. The phenomenon of virus-associated autoimmunity is found in chronic infections with hepatitis C and D. In chronic hepatitis C the major target of the autoantibodies again is cytochrome P450 2D6. Some linear and a high proportion of conformational epitopes are recognized. The LKM3 autoantibody is found in 13% of patients with chronic hepatitis D. The target proteins are UGTs of family 1 and, in some sera also, low titres of anto-antibodies directed against UGTs of family 2 are found. The epitopes detected are conformational. In contrast to the patients suffering from autoimmune hepatitis, patients with hepatitis as part of the autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1 recognize cytochrome P450 1A2. Interestingly, in APS1 patients also, autoantibodies directed against cytochromes P450 c21, P450 scc and P450 c17a may be detected; these autoantibodies are associated with adrenal and ovarian failure.

Molecular mimicry in halothane hepatitis: biochemical and structural characterization of lipoylated autoantigens

Exposure of human individuals to halothane causes, in about 20% of all cases, a mild transient form of hepatotoxicity. A small subset of exposed individuals, however, develops a potentially severe and life-threatening form of hepatic damage, coined halothane hepatitis. Halothane hepatitis is thought to have an immunological basis. Sera of afflicted individuals contain a wide variety of autoantibodies against hepatic proteins, in both trifluoroacetylated form (CF3CO-proteins) and, at least in part, in native form. CF3CO-proteins are elicited in the course of oxidative biotransformation of halothane, and include the trifluoroacetylated forms of protein disulfide isomerase, microsomal carboxylesterase, calreticulin, ERp72, GRP 78, and ERp99. Current evidence suggests that CF3CO-proteins arise in all halothane-exposed individuals; however, the vast majority of individuals appear to immunochemically tolerate CF3CO-proteins. The lack of immunological responsiveness of these individuals towards CF3CO-proteins might be due to tolerance, induced through the occurrence of structures in the repertoire of self-determinants, which immunochemically and structurally mimic CF3CO-proteins very closely. In fact, lipoic acid, the prosthetic group of the constitutively expressed E2 subunits of the family of mammalian 2-oxoacid dehydrogenase complexes and of protein X, was shown by immunochemical and molecular modelling analysis to be a perfect structural mimic of N6-trifluoroacetyl-L-lysine (CF3 CO-Lys), the major haptenic group of CF3CO-proteins. As a consequence of molecular mimicry, autoantibodies in patients' sera not only recognize CF3CO-proteins, but also the E2 subunit proteins of the 2-oxoacid dehydrogenase complexes and protein X, as autoantigens associated with halothane hepatitis. Furthermore, a fraction of patients with halothane hepatitis exhibit irregularities in the hepatic expression levels of these native, not trifluoroacetylated autoantigens. Collectively, these data suggest that molecular mimicry of CF3CO-Lys by lipoic acid, or the impairment thereof, might play a role in the susceptibility of individuals for the development of halothane hepatitis.

Idiosyncratic liver toxicity of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs: molecular mechanisms and pathology

This review explores the clinical hepatic pathology associated with the use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), possible cellular and molecular mechanisms of injury, and future challenges. NSAIDs comprise a group of widely used compounds that have been associated with rare adverse reactions in the liver, including fulminant hepatitis and cholestasis. These reactions are idiosyncratic, mostly independent of the dose administered, and host-dependent. The mechanisms responsible for the initiation and perpetuation of NSAID-induced hepatotoxicity remain poorly understood and have been largely inferred from clinical manifestation. A mounting body of evidence, however, indicates that many acidic NSAIDs are metabolized to reactive acyl glucuronides that can form covalent adducts with plasma proteins and hepatocellular proteins. In hepatocytes cocultured with lymphocytes, these NSAID-altered proteins can become antigenic. Thus, long-lived, drug-altered proteins may act as immunogens and produce cytotoxic T-cell-mediated or antibody-dependent, cell-mediated toxicity in susceptible patients. Alternatively, individual abnormalities in metabolism or disposition of some NSAIDs may lead to the formation or accumulation of toxic metabolites. Additional work with transgenic animal models is needed to permit better understanding of the general and specific risk factors involved in the pathogenesis of the idiosyncratic liver injuries related to NSAIDs and other drugs.

Formation of trifluoroacetylated protein antigens in cultured rat hepatocytes exposed to halothane in vitro

Immune responses to novel, halothane metabolite-modified protein antigens (tri-fluoroacetylated proteins; TFA-proteins) have been implicated in the pathogenesis of halothane hepatitis. The aim of the present study was to investigate and characterize expression of TFA-proteins in cultures of rat hepatocytes which were exposed to halothane in vitro. Following exposure to halothane, the hepatocytes were harvested, then subcellular fractions were prepared and were analysed by immunoblotting for expression of antigens recognized by a rabbit anti-TFA antiserum, and by antibodies in sera from two patients with halothane hepatitis. Hepatocytes exposed to halothane in vitro were shown to express novel microsomal protein antigens, which exhibited molecular masses that were identical to the molecular masses of the major TFA-protein antigens expressed in vivo, in livers of halothane-treated rats (100, 80 and 60 kDa). Experiments in which hepatocytes were exposed to halothane in the presence of SKF-525A, or were exposed to deuterated halothane in place of halothane, confirmed that these novel antigens were TFA-modified proteins whose generation required cytochrome P450-mediated metabolism of halothane. The maximal levels of TFA-antigens expressed in vitro were about 30% of the levels expressed in halothane-treated rats in vivo. Maximal expression of the TFA-antigens in vitro occurred when hepatocytes were exposed to halothane at doses which yielded concentrations of the drug in culture medium of about 13 microM. Expression of the antigens in vitro occurred slowly, with an apparent half-time of about 8 hr. Overall, these results demonstrate that the properties of the TFA-antigens expressed in cultured hepatocytes in vitro closely resemble the properties exhibited by the antigens expressed in vivo, in livers of halothane-treated rats.

Identification of the dihydrolipoamide acetyltransferase subunit of the human pyruvate dehydrogenase complex as an autoantigen in halothane hepatitis. Molecular mimicry of trifluoroacetyl-lysine by lipoic acid

Trifluoroacetylated (CF3CO-) proteins, elicited upon exposure of animals or humans to halothane, were recognized by anti-CF3CO antibody, monospecific for the hapten derivative N6-trifluoroacetyl-L-lysine. Anti-CF3CO antibodies cross-reacted with the dihydrolipoamide acetyltransferase (E2 subunit) of pyruvate dehydrogenase, indicating that epitopes on the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase molecularly mimic those on CF3CO-proteins. Lipoic acid, the prosthetic group of the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase was essential in this process, in that only the lipoylated form of the recombinantly expressed inner lipoyl domain of the human E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase, but not the unlipolyated form, was recognized by anti-CF3CO antibody. Furthermore, based on a high degree of structural relatedness, both CF3CO-Lys and (6RS)-lipoic acid, as well as the lipoylated peptide ETDK(lipoyl)ATIG specifically inhibited the recognition by anti-CF3CO antibody of the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase, of trifluoroacetylated rabbit serum albumin and of human liver CF3CO-proteins. In sera of patients with halothane hepatitis, autoantibodies with properties identical to those of anti-CF3CO antibody were identified which could not discriminate between CF3CO-proteins and the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase. These data suggest that the E2 subunit pyruvate of dehydrogenase is an autoantigen in halothane hepatitis and that molecular mimicry of CF3CO-proteins by the E2 subunit of pyruvate dehydrogenase is due to the similar structures of CF3CO-Lys and lipoic acid.

Mechanisms of halothane toxicity: novel insights

Exposure of individuals to halothane causes, in 20% of patients, a mild form of hepatotoxicity. In contrast, a very small subset of individuals only develops halothane hepatitis, which is thought to have an immunological basis. Sera of halothane hepatitis patients contain antibodies directed against some discrete liver trifluoroacetyl (TFA)-protein adducts, which arise upon oxidative biotransformation of halothane and include protein disulfide isomerase, microsomal carboxylesterase, calreticulin, ERp72, GRP 78 and ERp99. No immune response occurs in the majority of human individuals, although evidence suggests that TFA-protein adducts arise in all halothane-exposed individuals. The lack of immunological responsiveness of individuals might be due to tolerance, induced by a presumed repertoire of self-peptides that molecularly mimic TFA-protein adducts. Thus, constitutively expressed proteins of 52 and 64 kDa have been identified that confer molecular mimicry of TFA-protein adducts. The 64 kDa protein corresponds to the E2 subunit of the mitochondrial pyruvate dehydrogenase complex. Lipoic acid, the prosthetic group of the E2 subunit, is involved in the molecular mimicry process. A fraction of halothane hepatitis patients exhibit irregularities in the expression levels of the 52 kDa protein and the E2 subunit protein. Molecular mimicry of TFA-protein adducts by the 52 kDa protein and the E2 subunit protein might play a role in the susceptibility of individuals to development of halothane hepatitis.