Identification of a key catalytic intermediate demonstrates that nitrogenase is activated by the reversible exchange of N₂ for H₂

Sulfide release and rebinding in the mechanism for nitrogenase

Nitrogenases are the only enzymes that activate the strong triple bond in N2. The mechanism for the activation has been very difficult to determine in spite of decades of work. In previous modeling studies it has been suggested that the mechanism for nitrogen activation starts out by four pre-activation steps (A0-A4) before catalysis. That suggestion led to excellent agreement with experimental Elecrtron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) observations in the step where N2 becomes protonated (E4). An important part of the pre-activation is that a sulfide is released. In the present paper, the details of the pre-activation are modeled, including the release of the sulfide. Several possible transition states for the release have been obtained. An A4(E0) state is reached which is very similar to the E4 state. For completeness, the steps going back from A4(E0) to A0 after catalysis are also modeled, including the insertion of a sulfide.

Final E5 to E8 Steps in the Nitrogenase Mechanism for Nitrogen Fixation

Nitrogenase converts nitrogen in the air to ammonia. It is often regarded as the second most important enzyme in nature after photosystem II. The mechanism for how nitrogenase is able to perform the difficult task of cleaving the strong bond in N2 is debated. It is known that for every electron that is donated to N2, two ATP are hydrolyzed. In the experimentally suggested mechanism, the activation occurs after four reductions of the ground state, but there is no suggestion for how the enzyme uses the hydrolysis energy to perform catalysis. In the theoretical mechanism, it is suggested that hydrolysis is used to reduce the electron donor. In previous papers, the steps leading to the activation of N2 in the so-called E4 state has been investigated, using both the experimental and theoretical mechanism, showing that only the theoretical one leads to agreement with EPR observations for E4. In the present paper, the four steps following E4, leading to the release of two ammonia molecules, are described using the same methodology as used in the previous studies.

The activating capture of N2 at the active site of Mo-nitrogenase

Dinitrogen is inherently inert. This report describes detailed density functional calculations (with a 485+ atom model) of mechanistic steps by which the enzyme nitrogenase activates unreactive N2 at the intact active site FeMo-co, to form a key intermediate with bound HNNH. This mechanism does not bind N2 first and then add H atoms, but rather captures N2 ('N2-ready') that diffuses in through the substrate channel and enters a strategic gallery of H atom donors in the reaction zone, between Fe2 and Fe6. This occurs at the E4 stage of the complete mechanism. Exploration of possible reactions of N2 in this space leads to the conclusion that the first reaction step is transfer of H on Fe7 to one end of N2-ready, soon followed by Fe-N bond formation, and then a second H transfer from bridging S2BH to the other N. Two H-N bonds and one or two N-Fe bonds are formed, in some cases with a single transition state. The variable positions and orientations of N2-ready lead to various reaction trajectories and products. The favourable products resulting from this capture, judged by the criteria of reaction energies, reaction barriers, and mechanistic competence for further hydrogenation reactions in the nitrogenase cycle, have Fe2-NH-NH bonding. The trajectory of one N2 capture reaction is described in detail, and calculations that separate the H atom component and the 'heavy atom' components of the classical activation energy are described, in the context of possible H atom tunneling in the activation of N2-ready. I present arguments for the activation of N2 by the pathway of concerted hydrogenation and binding of N2-ready, alternative to the commonly assumed pathway of binding N2 first, with subsequent hydrogenation. The active site of nitrogenase is well primed for the thermodynamic and kinetic advantages of N2 capture.

Computational Model Study of the Experimentally Suggested Mechanism for Nitrogenase

The mechanism for N2 activation in the E4 state of nitrogenase was investigated by model calculations. In the experimentally suggested mechanism, the E4 state is obtained after four reductions to the ground state. In a recent theoretical study, results for a different mechanism have been found in excellent agreement with available Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) experiments for E4. The two hydrides in E4 leave as H2 concertedly with the binding of N2. The mechanism suggested differs from the experimentally suggested one by a requirement for four activation steps prior to catalysis. In the present study, the experimentally suggested mechanism is studied using the same methods as those used in the previous study on the theoretical mechanism. The computed results make it very unlikely that a structure obtained after four reductions from the ground state has two hydrides, and the experimentally suggested mechanism does therefore not agree with the EPR experiments for E4. Another structure with only one hydride is here suggested to be the one that has been observed to bind N2 after only four reductions of the ground state.

The energetics of N2 reduction by vanadium containing nitrogenase

The main class of nitrogenases has a molybdenum in its cofactor. A mechanism for Mo-nitrogenase has recently been described. In the present study, another class of nitrogenases has been studied, the one with a vanadium instead of a molybdenum in its cofactor. It is generally believed that these classes use the same general mechanism to activate nitrogen. The same methodology has been used here as the one used for Mo-nitrogenase. N2 activation is known to occur after four reductions in the catalytic cycle, in the E4 state. The main features of the mechanism for Mo-nitrogenase found in the previous study are an activation process in four steps prior to catalysis, the release of a sulfide during the activation steps and the formation of H2 from two hydrides in E4, just before N2 is activated. The same features have been found here for V-nitrogenase. A difference is that five steps are needed in the activation process, which explains why the ground state of V-nitrogenase is a triplet (even number) and the one for Mo-nitrogenase is a quartet (odd number). The reason an additional step is needed for V-nitrogenase is that V3+ can be reduced to V2+, in contrast to the case for Mo3+ in Mo-nitrogenase. The fact that V3+ is Jahn-Teller active has important consequences. N2H2 is formed in E4 with reasonably small barriers.

Low-temperature trapping of N2 reduction reaction intermediates in nitrogenase MoFe protein-CdS quantum dot complexes

The biological reduction of N2 to ammonia requires the ATP-dependent, sequential delivery of electrons from the Fe protein to the MoFe protein of nitrogenase. It has been demonstrated that CdS nanocrystals can replace the Fe protein to deliver photoexcited electrons to the MoFe protein. Herein, light-activated electron delivery within the CdS:MoFe protein complex was achieved in the frozen state, revealing that all the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) active E-state intermediates in the catalytic cycle can be trapped and characterized by EPR spectroscopy. Prior to illumination, the CdS:MoFe protein complex EPR spectrum was composed of a S = 3/2 rhombic signal (g = 4.33, 3.63, and 2.01) consistent with the FeMo-cofactor in the resting state, E0. Illumination for sequential 1-h periods at 233 K under 1 atm of N2 led to a cumulative attenuation of E0 by 75%. This coincided with the appearance of S = 3/2 and S = 1/2 signals assigned to two-electron (E2) and four-electron (E4) reduced states of the FeMo-cofactor, together with additional S = 1/2 signals consistent with the formation of E6 and E8 states. Simulations of EPR spectra allowed quantification of the different E-state populations, along with mapping of these populations onto the Lowe-Thorneley kinetic scheme. The outcome of this work demonstrates that the photochemical delivery of electrons to the MoFe protein can be used to populate all of the EPR active E-state intermediates of the nitrogenase MoFe protein cycle.

Nitrogenase beyond the Resting State: A Structural Perspective

Nitrogenases have the remarkable ability to catalyze the reduction of dinitrogen to ammonia under physiological conditions. How does this happen? The current view of the nitrogenase mechanism focuses on the role of hydrides, the binding of dinitrogen in a reductive elimination process coupled to loss of dihydrogen, and the binding of substrates to a binuclear site on the active site cofactor. This review focuses on recent experimental characterizations of turnover relevant forms of the enzyme determined by cryo-electron microscopy and other approaches, and comparison of these forms to the resting state enzyme and the broader family of iron sulfur clusters. Emerging themes include the following: (i) The obligatory coupling of protein and electron transfers does not occur in synthetic and small-molecule iron-sulfur clusters. The coupling of these processes in nitrogenase suggests that they may involve unique features of the cofactor, such as hydride formation on the trigonal prismatic arrangement of irons, protonation of belt sulfurs, and/or protonation of the interstitial carbon. (ii) Both the active site cofactor and protein are dynamic under turnover conditions; the changes are such that more highly reduced forms may differ in key ways from the resting-state structure. Homocitrate appears to play a key role in coupling cofactor and protein dynamics. (iii) Structural asymmetries are observed in nitrogenase under turnover-relevant conditions by cryo-electron microscopy, although the mechanistic relevance of these states (such as half-of-sites reactivity) remains to be established.

Cryo-annealing of Photoreduced CdS Quantum Dot-Nitrogenase MoFe Protein Complexes Reveals the Kinetic Stability of the E4(2N2H) Intermediate

A critical step in the mechanism of N2 reduction to 2NH3 catalyzed by the enzyme nitrogenase is the reaction of the four-electron/four-proton reduced intermediate state of the active-site FeMo-cofactor (E4(4H)). This state is a junction in the catalytic mechanism, either relaxing by the reaction of a metal bound Fe-hydride with a proton forming H2 or going forward with N2 binding coupled to the reductive elimination (re) of two Fe-hydrides as H2 to form the E4(2N2H) state. E4(2N2H) can relax to E4(4H) by the oxidative addition (oa) of H2 and release of N2 or can be further reduced in a series of catalytic steps to release 2NH3. If the H2 re/oa mechanism is correct, it requires that oa of H2 be associative with E4(2N2H). In this report, we have taken advantage of CdS quantum dots in complex with MoFe protein to achieve photodriven electron delivery in the frozen state, with cryo-annealing in the dark, to reveal details of the E-state species and to test the stability of E4(2N2H). Illumination of frozen CdS:MoFe protein complexes led to formation of a population of reduced intermediates. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy identified E-state signals including E2 and E4(2N2H), as well as signals suggesting the formation of E6 or E8. It is shown that in the frozen state when pN2 is much greater than pH2, the E4(2N2H) state is kinetically stable, with very limited forward or reverse reaction rates. These results establish that the oa of H2 to the E4(2N2H) state follows an associative reaction mechanism.

The Fe Protein Cycle Associated with Nitrogenase Catalysis Requires the Hydrolysis of Two ATP for Each Single Electron Transfer Event

A central feature of the current understanding of dinitrogen (N₂) reduction by the enzyme nitrogenase is the proposed coupling of the hydrolysis of two ATP, forming two ADP and two Pi, to the transfer of one electron from the Fe protein component to the MoFe protein component, where substrates are reduced. A redox-active [4Fe-4S] cluster associated with the Fe protein is the agent of electron delivery, and it is well known to have a capacity to cycle between a one-electron-reduced [4Fe-4S]¹⁺ state and an oxidized [4Fe-4S]²⁺ state. Recently, however, it has been shown that certain reducing agents can be used to further reduce the Fe protein [4Fe-4S] cluster to a super-reduced, all-ferrous [4Fe-4S]⁰ state that can be either diamagnetic (S = 0) or paramagnetic (S = 4). It has been proposed that the super-reduced state might fundamentally alter the existing model for nitrogenase energy utilization by the transfer of two electrons per Fe protein cycle linked to hydrolysis of only two ATP molecules. Here, we measure the number of ATP consumed for each electron transfer under steady-state catalysis while the Fe protein cluster is in the [4Fe-4S]¹⁺ state and when it is in the [4Fe-4S]⁰ state. Both oxidation states of the Fe protein are found to operate by hydrolyzing two ATP for each single-electron transfer event. Thus, regardless of its initial redox state, the Fe protein transfers only one electron at a time to the MoFe protein in a process that requires the hydrolysis of two ATP.

The binding of reducible N2 in the reaction domain of nitrogenase

The binding of N₂ to FeMo-co, the catalytic site of the enzyme nitrogenase, is central to the conversion to NH₃, but also has a separate role in promoting the N₂-dependent HD reaction (D₂ + 2H⁺ + 2e^- → 2HD). The protein surrounding FeMo-co contains a clear channel for ingress of N₂, directly towards the exo-coordination position of Fe2, a position which is outside the catalytic reaction domain. This led to the hypothesis [I. Dance, Dalton Trans., 2022, 51, 12717] of 'promotional' N₂ bound at exo-Fe2, and a second 'reducible' N₂ bound in the reaction domain, specifically the endo-coordination position of Fe2 or Fe6. The range of possibilities for the binding of reducible N₂ in the presence of bound promotional N₂ is described here, using density functional simulations with a 486 atom model of the active site and surrounding protein. The pathway for ingress of the second N₂ through protein, past the first N₂ at exo-Fe2, and tumbling into the binding domain between Fe2 and Fe6, is described. The calculations explore 24 structures involving 6 different forms of hydrogenated FeMo-co, including structures with S2BH unhooked from Fe2 but tethered to Fe6. The calculations use the most probable electronic states. End-on (η¹) binding of N₂ at the endo position of either Fe2 or Fe6 is almost invariably exothermic, with binding potential energies ranging up to -18 kcal mol^-1. Many structures have binding energies in the range -6 to -14 kcal mol^-1. The relevant entropic penalty for N₂ binding from a diffusible position within the protein is estimated to be 4 kcal mol^-1, and so the binding free energies for reducible N₂ are suitably negative. N₂ binding at endo-Fe2 is stronger than at endo-Fe6 in three of the six structure categories. In many cases the reaction domain containing reducible N₂ is expanded. These results inform computational simulation of the subsequent steps in which surrounding H atoms transfer to reducible N₂.

Can the E1 state in nitrogenase tell if there is an activation process prior to catalysis?

Model calculations have been performed for the singly reduced ground state of Mo-nitrogenase, usually termed E₁. Contradictory conclusions have been reached in two recent experimental studies. In a study based on EPR, it was concluded that there is a bridging hydride in E₁, while in an X-ray study it was concluded that there is no hydride in E₁. Therefore, the EPR study implies that there is an oxidation of the cofactor going from E₀ to E₁, the X-ray study implies a reduction. DFT methods have here been used, which have previously been benchmarked on a set of redox enzymes that led to the conclusion that the accuracy is about 3 kcal mol^-1 in all cases, even for redox transitions. The methodology should therefore be adequate for resolving the question of the hydride presence in E₁. As a comparison, calculations are performed on both Mo- and V-nitrogenase with the same conclusion. The conclusion from the calculations has far reaching consequences for the mechanism of nitrogenase.

Biological nitrogen fixation in theory, practice, and reality: a perspective on the molybdenum nitrogenase system

Nitrogenase is the sole enzyme responsible for the ATP-dependent conversion of atmospheric dinitrogen into the bioavailable form of ammonia (NH₃ ), making this protein essential for the maintenance of the nitrogen cycle and thus life itself. Despite the widespread use of the Haber-Bosch process to industrially produce NH₃ , biological nitrogen fixation still accounts for half of the bioavailable nitrogen on Earth. An important feature of nitrogenase is that it operates under physiological conditions, where the equilibrium strongly favours ammonia production. This biological, multielectron reduction is a complex catalytic reaction that has perplexed scientists for decades. In this review, we explore the current understanding of the molybdenum nitrogenase system based on experimental and computational research, as well as the limitations of the crystallographic, spectroscopic, and computational techniques employed. Finally, essential outstanding questions regarding the nitrogenase system will be highlighted alongside suggestions for future experimental and computational work to elucidate this essential yet elusive process.

Calculating the chemical mechanism of nitrogenase: new working hypotheses

The enzyme nitrogenase converts N₂ to NH₃ with stoichiometry N₂ + 8H⁺ + 8e^- → 2NH₃ + H₂. The mechanism is chemically complex with multiple steps that must be consistent with much accumulated experimental information, including exchange of H₂ and N₂ and the N₂-dependent hydrogenation of D₂ to HD. Previous investigations have developed a collection of working hypotheses that guide ongoing density functional investigations of mechanistic steps and sequences. These include (i) hypotheses about the serial provision of protons and their conversion to H atoms bonded to S and Fe atoms of the FeMo-co catalytic site, (ii) the migration of H atoms over the surface of FeMo-co, (iii) the roles of His195, (iv) identification of three protein channels, one for the ingress of N₂, a separate pathway for the passage of exogenous H₂ (D₂) and product H₂ (HD), and a hydrophilic pathway for egress of product NH₃. Two additional working hypotheses are described in this paper. N₂ passing along the N₂ channel approaches and binds end-on to the exo coordination position of Fe2, with favourable energetics when FeMo-co is pre-hydrogenated. This exo-Fe2-N₂ is apparently not reduced but has a promotional role by expanding the reaction zone. A second N₂ can enter via the N₂ ingress channel and bind at the endo-Fe6 position, where it is surrounded by H atom donors suitable for the N₂ → NH₃ conversion. It is proposed that this endo-Fe6 position is also the binding site for H₂ (generated or exogenous), accounting for the competitive inhibition of N₂ reduction by H₂. The HD reaction occurs at the endo-Fe6 site, promoted by N₂ at the exo-Fe2 site. The second hypothesis concerns the most stable electronic states of FeMo-co with ligands bound at Fe2 and Fe6, and provides a protocol for management of electronic states in mechanism calculations.

A Mechanism for Nitrogenase Including Loss of a Sulfide

Nitrogenase is the only enzyme in nature that can fix N₂ from the air. The active cofactor of the leading form of this enzyme contains seven irons and one molybdenum connected by sulfide bridges. In several recent experimental studies, it has been suggested that the cofactor is very flexible, and might lose one of its sulfides during catalysis. In this study, the possible loss of a sulfide has been investigated by model calculations. In previous studies, we have shown that there should be four activation steps before catalysis starts, and this study is based on that finding. It was found here that, after the four reductions in the activation steps, a sulfide will become very loosely bound and can be released in a quite exergonic step with a low barrier. The binding of N₂ has no part in that release. In our previous studies, we suggested that the central carbide should be protonated three times after the four activation steps. With the new finding, there will instead be a loss of a sulfide, as the barrier for the loss is much lower than the ones for protonating the carbide. Still, it is suggested here that the carbide will be protonated anyway, but only with one proton, in the E₃ to E₄ step. A very complicated transition state for H₂ formation involving a large structural change was obtained. The combined step, with a loss of H₂ and binding of N₂ , is calculated to be endergonic by +2.3 kcal mol^-1 ; this is in excellent agreement with experiments in which an easily reversible step has been found.

Structures and reaction dynamics of N2 and H2 binding at FeMo-co, the active site of nitrogenase

The chemical reactions occurring at the Fe₇MoS₉C(homocitrate) cluster, FeMo-co, the active site of the enzyme nitrogenase (N₂ → NH₃), are enigmatic. Experimental information collected over a long period reveals aspects of the roles of N₂ and H₂, each with more than one type of reactivity. This paper reports investigations of the binding of H₂ and N₂ at intact FeMo-co, using density functional simulations of a large 486 atom relevant portion of the protein, resulting in 27 new structures containing H₂ and/or N₂ bound at the exo and endo coordination sites of the participating Fe atoms, Fe2 and Fe6. Binding energies and transition states for association/dissociation are determined, and trajectories for the approach, binding and separation of H₂/N₂ are described, including diffusion of these small molecules through proximal protein. Influences of surrounding amino acids are identified. FeMo-co deforms geometrically when binding H₂ or N₂, and a procedure for calculating the energy cost involved, the adaptation energy, is introduced here. Adaptation energies, which range from 7 to 36 kcal mol^-1 for the reported structures, are influenced by the protonation state of the His195 side chain. Seven N₂ structures and three H₂ structures have negative binding free energies, which include the estimated entropy penalties for binding of N₂, H₂ from proximal protein. These favoured structures have N₂ bound end-on at exo-Fe2, exo-Fe6 and endo-Fe2 positions of FeMo-co, and H₂ bound at the endo-Fe2 position. Various postulated structures with N₂ bridging Fe2 and Fe6 revert to end-on-N₂ at endo positions. The structures are also assessed via the calculated potential energy barriers for association and dissociation. Barriers to the binding of H₂ range from 1 to 20 kcal mol^-1 and barriers to dissociation of H₂ range from 3 to 18 kcal mol^-1. Barriers to the binding of N₂, in either side-on or end-on mode, range from 2 to 18 kcal mol^-1, while dissociation of bound N₂ encounters barriers of 3 to 8 kcal mol^-1 for side-on bonding and 7 to 18 kcal mol^-1 for end-on bonding. These results allow formulation of mechanisms for the H₂/N₂ exchange reaction, and three feasible mechanisms for associative exchange and three for dissociative exchange are identified. Consistent electronic structures and potential energy surfaces are maintained throughout. Changes in the spin populations of Fe2 and Fe6 connected with cluster deformation and with metal-ligand bond formation are identified.

Structure, reactivity, and spectroscopy of nitrogenase-related synthetic and biological clusters

The reduction of dinitrogen (N2) is essential for its incorporation into nucleic acids and amino acids, which are vital to life on earth. Nitrogenases convert atmospheric dinitrogen to two ammonia molecules (NH3) under ambient conditions. The catalytic active sites of these enzymes (known as FeM-cofactor clusters, where M = Mo, V, Fe) are the sites of N2 binding and activation and have been a source of great interest for chemists for decades. In this review, recent studies on nitrogenase-related synthetic molecular complexes and biological clusters are discussed, with a focus on their reactivity and spectroscopic characterization. The molecular models that are discussed span from simple mononuclear iron complexes to multinuclear iron complexes and heterometallic iron complexes. In addition, recent work on the extracted biological cofactors is discussed. An emphasis is placed on how these studies have contributed towards our understanding of the electronic structure and mechanism of nitrogenases.

Comparing Molecular Mechanisms in Solar NH3 Production and Relations with CO2 Reduction

Molecular mechanisms for N2 fixation (solar NH3) and CO2 conversion to C2+ products in enzymatic conversion (nitrogenase), electrocatalysis, metal complexes and plasma catalysis are analyzed and compared. It is evidenced that differently from what is present in thermal and plasma catalysis, the electrocatalytic path requires not only the direct coordination and hydrogenation of undissociated N2 molecules, but it is necessary to realize features present in the nitrogenase mechanism. There is the need for (i) a multi-electron and -proton simultaneous transfer, not as sequential steps, (ii) forming bridging metal hydride species, (iii) generating intermediates stabilized by bridging multiple metal atoms and (iv) the capability of the same sites to be effective both in N2 fixation and in COx reduction to C2+ products. Only iron oxide/hydroxide stabilized at defective sites of nanocarbons was found to have these features. This comparison of the molecular mechanisms in solar NH3 production and CO2 reduction is proposed to be a source of inspiration to develop the next generation electrocatalysts to address the challenging transition to future sustainable energy and chemistry beyond fossil fuels.

Defining Intermediates of Nitrogenase MoFe Protein during N2 Reduction under Photochemical Electron Delivery from CdS Quantum Dots

Coupling the nitrogenase MoFe protein to light-harvesting semiconductor nanomaterials replaces the natural electron transfer complex of Fe protein and ATP and provides low-potential photoexcited electrons for photocatalytic N₂ reduction. A central question is how direct photochemical electron delivery from nanocrystals to MoFe protein is able to support the multielectron ammonia production reaction. In this study, low photon flux conditions were used to identify the initial reaction intermediates of CdS quantum dot (QD):MoFe protein nitrogenase complexes under photochemical activation using EPR. Illumination of CdS QD:MoFe protein complexes led to redox changes in the MoFe protein active site FeMo-co observed as the gradual decline in the E₀ resting state intensity that was accompanied by an increase in the intensity of a new "g_eff = 4.5" EPR signal. The magnetic properties of the g_eff = 4.5 signal support assignment as a reduced S = 3/2 state, and reaction modeling was used to define it as a two-electron-reduced "E₂" intermediate. Use of a MoFe protein variant, β-188^Cys, which poises the P cluster in the oxidized P⁺ state, demonstrated that the P cluster can function as a site of photoexcited electron delivery from CdS to MoFe protein. Overall, the results establish the initial steps for how photoexcited CdS delivers electrons into the MoFe protein during reduction of N₂ to ammonia and the role of electron flux in the photochemical reaction cycle.

A dinuclear Mo2H8 complex supported by bulky C5H2tBu3 ligands

Hydride-bridged transition metal complexes have been found to serve as suitable precursors for the activation of small molecules without the use of reducing agents. In this study, we synthesized a dinuclear Mo2H8 complex supported by bulky C5H2tBu3 (Cp‡) ligands, Cp‡2Mo2H8 (1), from the reaction of Cp‡MoCl4 with KC8 under H2. The hydrides of complex 1 can be replaced with benzene at 60 °C to afford a μ-benzene complex Cp‡2Mo2H2(μ-C6H6) (2).

Synthesis of Dinuclear Mo-Fe Hydride Complexes and Catalytic Silylation of N2

Two transition-metal atoms bridged by hydrides may represent a useful structural motif for N₂ activation by molecular complexes and the enzyme active site. In this study, dinuclear Mo^IV -Fe^II complexes with bridging hydrides, Cp^R Mo(PMe₃ )(H)(μ-H)₃ FeCp* (2 a; Cp^R =Cp*=C₅ Me₅ , 2 b; Cp^R =C₅ Me₄ H), were synthesized via deprotonation of Cp^R Mo(PMe₃ )H₅ (1 a; Cp^R =Cp*, 1 b; Cp^R =C₅ Me₄ H) by Cp*FeN(SiMe₃ )₂ , and they were characterized by spectroscopy and crystallography. These Mo-Fe complexes reveal the shortest Mo-Fe distances ever reported (2.4005(3) Å for 2 a and 2.3952(3) Å for 2 b), and the Mo-Fe interactions were analyzed by computational studies. Removal of the terminal Mo-H hydride in 2 a-2 b by [Ph₃ C]⁺ in THF led to the formation of cationic THF adducts [Cp^R Mo(PMe₃ )(THF)(μ-H)₃ FeCp*]⁺ (3 a; Cp^R =Cp*, 3 b; Cp^R =C₅ Me₄ H). Further reaction of 3 a with LiPPh₂ gave rise to a phosphido-bridged complex Cp*Mo(PMe₃ )(μ-H)(μ-PPh₂ )FeCp* (4). A series of Mo-Fe complexes were subjected to catalytic silylation of N₂ in the presence of Na and Me₃ SiCl, furnishing up to 129±20 equiv of N(SiMe₃ )₃ per molecule of 2 b. Mechanism of the catalytic cycle was analyzed by DFT calculations.

The Spectroscopy of Nitrogenases

Nitrogenases are responsible for biological nitrogen fixation, a crucial step in the biogeochemical nitrogen cycle. These enzymes utilize a two-component protein system and a series of iron-sulfur clusters to perform this reaction, culminating at the FeMco active site (M = Mo, V, Fe), which is capable of binding and reducing N2 to 2NH3. In this review, we summarize how different spectroscopic approaches have shed light on various aspects of these enzymes, including their structure, mechanism, alternative reactivity, and maturation. Synthetic model chemistry and theory have also played significant roles in developing our present understanding of these systems and are discussed in the context of their contributions to interpreting the nature of nitrogenases. Despite years of significant progress, there is still much to be learned from these enzymes through spectroscopic means, and we highlight where further spectroscopic investigations are needed.

Reduction of Substrates by Nitrogenases

Nitrogenase is the enzyme that catalyzes biological N₂ reduction to NH₃. This enzyme achieves an impressive rate enhancement over the uncatalyzed reaction. Given the high demand for N₂ fixation to support food and chemical production and the heavy reliance of the industrial Haber-Bosch nitrogen fixation reaction on fossil fuels, there is a strong need to elucidate how nitrogenase achieves this difficult reaction under benign conditions as a means of informing the design of next generation synthetic catalysts. This Review summarizes recent progress in addressing how nitrogenase catalyzes the reduction of an array of substrates. New insights into the mechanism of N₂ and proton reduction are first considered. This is followed by a summary of recent gains in understanding the reduction of a number of other nitrogenous compounds not considered to be physiological substrates. Progress in understanding the reduction of a wide range of C-based substrates, including CO and CO₂, is also discussed, and remaining challenges in understanding nitrogenase substrate reduction are considered.

Carbon substrate re-orders relative growth of a bacterium using Mo-, V-, or Fe-nitrogenase for nitrogen fixation

Biological nitrogen fixation is catalyzed by the molybdenum (Mo), vanadium (V) and iron (Fe)‐only nitrogenase metalloenzymes. Studies with purified enzymes have found that the ‘alternative’ V‐ and Fe‐nitrogenases generally reduce N₂ more slowly and produce more byproduct H₂ than the Mo‐nitrogenase, leading to an assumption that their usage results in slower growth. Here we show that, in the metabolically versatile photoheterotroph Rhodopseudomonas palustris, the type of carbon substrate influences the relative rates of diazotrophic growth based on different nitrogenase isoforms. The V‐nitrogenase supports growth as fast as the Mo‐nitrogenase on acetate but not on the more oxidized substrate succinate. Our data suggest that this is due to insufficient electron flux to the V‐nitrogenase isoform on succinate compared with acetate. Despite slightly faster growth based on the V‐nitrogenase on acetate, the wild‐type strain uses exclusively the Mo‐nitrogenase on both carbon substrates. Notably, the differences in H₂:N₂ stoichiometry by alternative nitrogenases (~1.5 for V‐nitrogenase, ~4–7 for Fe‐nitrogenase) and Mo‐nitrogenase (~1) measured here are lower than prior in vitro estimates. These results indicate that the metabolic costs of V‐based nitrogen fixation could be less significant for growth than previously assumed, helping explain why alternative nitrogenase genes persist in diverse diazotroph lineages and are broadly distributed in the environment.

A model for dinitrogen binding in the E4 state of nitrogenase

Molybdenum nitrogenase is one of the most intriguing metalloenzymes in nature, featuring an exotic iron-molybdenum-sulfur cofactor, FeMoco, whose mode of action remains elusive. In particular, the molecular and electronic structure of the N2-binding E4 state is not known. In this study we present theoretical QM/MM calculations of new structural models of the E4 state of molybdenum-dependent nitrogenase and compare to previously suggested models for this enigmatic redox state. We propose two models as possible candidates for the E4 state. Both models feature two hydrides on the FeMo cofactor, bridging atoms Fe2 and Fe6 with a terminal sulfhydryl group on either Fe2 or Fe6 (derived from the S2B bridge) and the change in coordination results in local lower-spin electronic structure at Fe2 and Fe6. These structures appear consistent with the bridging hydride proposal put forward from ENDOR studies and are calculated to be lower in energy than other proposed models for E4 at the TPSSh-QM/MM level of theory. We critically analyze the DFT method dependency in calculations of FeMoco that has resulted in strikingly different proposals for this state. Importantly, dinitrogen binds exothermically to either Fe2 or Fe6 in our models, contrary to others, an effect rationalized via the unique ligand field (from the hydrides) at the Fe with an empty coordination site. A low-spin Fe site is proposed as being important to N2 binding. Furthermore, the geometries of these states suggest a feasible reductive elimination step that could follow, as experiments indicate. Via this step, two electrons are released, reducing the cofactor to yield a distorted 4-coordinate Fe2 or Fe6 that partially activates N2. We speculate that stabilization of an N2-bound Fe(i) at Fe6 (not found for Fe2 model) via reductive elimination is a crucial part of N2 activation in nitrogenases, possibly aided by the apical heterometal ion (Mo or V). By using protons from the sulfhydryl group (to regenerate the sulfide bridge between Fe2 and Fe6) and the nearby homocitrate hydroxy group, we calculate a plausible route to yield a diazene intermediate. This is found to be more favorable with the Fe6-bound model than the Fe2-bound model; however, this protonation is uphill in energy, suggesting protonation of N2 might occur later in the catalytic cycle or via another mechanism.

Time-Resolved EPR Study of H2 Reductive Elimination from the Photoexcited Nitrogenase Janus E4(4H) Intermediate

Nitrogenase is activated for N₂ reduction through the accumulation of four reducing equivalents at the active-site FeMo-cofactor (FeMo-co: Fe7S9MoC; homocitrate) to form the key Janus intermediate, denoted E₄(4H), whose lowest-energy structure contains two [Fe-H-Fe] bridging hydrides and two protons bound to the sulfurs that also bridge the Fe pairs. In the critical step of catalysis, a H₂ complex transiently produced by reductive elimination (re) of the hydrides of E₄(4H), denoted E₄(H₂;2H), undergoes H₂ displacement by N₂, which then undergoes the otherwise energetically unfavorable cleavage of the N≡N triple bond. In pursuing the study of the re activation process, we have employed a photochemical approach to obtaining its atomic-level details. Continuous 450 nm irradiation of the ground state of the dihydride Janus intermediate, denoted E₄(4H)^a, in an EPR cavity at cryogenic temperatures causes photoinduced re of H₂ to generate E₄(H₂;2H). We here extend this photochemical approach with time-resolved EPR studies of the photolysis process on the ns time scale. These studies reveal an additional intermediate in the catalytic reductive elimination process, an isomer of the E₄(4H) FeMo-co metal-ion core that is formed prior to E₄(H₂;2H) and is thought to be created by breaking an Fe-SH bond, thus further integrating the calculational and structural studies into the experimentally determined mechanism by which nitrogenase is activated to cleave the N≡N triple bond.

Light Enhanced Fe-Mediated Nitrogen Fixation: Mechanistic Insights Regarding H2 Elimination, HER, and NH3 Generation

Despite their proposed accumulation at the Fe sites of the FeMo-cofactor of MoFe-nitrogenase, the presence of hydride ligands in molecular model systems capable of the nitrogen reduction reaction (N₂RR) appears to diminish the catalytic N₂-to-NH₃ conversion. We find that for an iron-based system bearing the trisphosphine ligand P₂P^Ph, a dramatic difference in yields is observed for N₂RR catalyzed by precatalysts with zero, one, or two hydride ligands; however, irradiating the three different catalysts with a mercury lamp results in similar yields. Although the efficacy for N₂RR versus the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) is modest for this system by comparison to certain iron (and other metal) catalysts, the system provides an opportunity to study the role of hydrides in the selectivity for N₂RR versus HER, which is a central issue in catalyst design. Stochiometric reactions with hydride containing precatalysts reveal a hydrogen evolution cycle in which no nitrogen fixation occurs. Irradiation of the dihydride precatalysts, observed during turnover, results in H₂ elimination and formation of (P₂P^Ph)Fe(N₂)₂, which itself is unreactive with acids at low temperature. N₂ functionalization does occur with acids and silyl electrophiles for the reduced species [(P₂P^Ph)Fe(N₂)]^- and [(P₂P^Ph)Fe(N₂)]^2-, which have been characterized independently. The requirement of accessing such low formal oxidation states explains the need for strong reductants. The low selectivity of the system for functionalization at N_β versus Fe creates off-path hydride species that participate in unproductive HER, helping to explain the low selectivity for N₂RR over HER. The data presented here hence lends further insight into the growing understanding of the selectivity, activity, and required driving force relevant to iron (and other) N₂RR catalysts.

Dinitrogen Activation and Functionalization using β-Diketiminate Iron Complexes

Iron catalysts are adept at breaking the N-N bond of N₂, as exemplified by the iron-catalyzed Haber-Bosch process and the iron-containing clusters at the active sites of nitrogenase enzymes. This Minireview summarizes recent work that has identified a well-characterized set of multi-iron complexes that are capable of breaking and functionalizing N₂, and are amenable to detailed mechanistic studies. We discuss the redox balancing, the potential intermediates during N₂ activation, the variation of alkali metal reductant, the reversibility of N₂ cleavage, and the formation of N-H and N-C bonds from N₂.

Survey of the Geometric and Electronic Structures of the Key Hydrogenated Forms of FeMo-co, the Active Site of the Enzyme Nitrogenase: Principles of the Mechanistically Significant Coordination Chemistry

The enzyme nitrogenase naturally hydrogenates N2 to NH3, achieved through the accumulation of H atoms on FeMo-co, the Fe7MoS9C(homocitrate) cluster that is the catalytically active site. Four intermediates, E1H1, E2H2, E3H3, and E4H4, carry these hydrogen atoms. I report density functional calculations of the numerous possibilities for the geometric and electronic structures of these poly-hydrogenated forms of FeMo-co. This survey involves more than 100 structures, including those with bound H2, and assesses their relative energies and most likely electronic states. Twelve locations for bound H atoms in the active domain of FeMo-co, including Fe–H–Fe and Fe–H–S bridges, are studied. A significant result is that transverse Fe–H–Fe bridges (transverse to the pseudo-threefold axis of FeMo-co and shared with triply-bridging S) are not possible geometrically unless the S is hydrogenated to become doubly-bridging. The favourable Fe–H–Fe bridges are shared with doubly-bridging S. ENDOR data for an E4H4 intermediate trapped at low temperature, and interpretations in terms of the geometrical and electronic structure of E4H4, are assessed in conjunction with the calculated possibilities. The results reported here yield a set of 24 principles for the mechanistically significant coordination chemistry of H and H2 on FeMo-co, in the stages prior to N2 binding.

The mechanism for nitrogenase including all steps

Nitrogen in the air is turned into biologically useful ammonia by the nitrogenase enzyme. The leading member of this group has a cofactor with one molybdenum and seven irons linked together by sulfurs. The structure that binds N₂ has a triply protonated carbide and a rotated homocitrate. Both these structural changes are necessary for the activation.

Kinetic Understanding of N2 Reduction versus H2 Evolution at the E4(4H) Janus State in the Three Nitrogenases

The enzyme nitrogenase catalyzes the reduction of N₂ to ammonia but also that of protons to H₂. These reactions compete at the mechanistically central 'Janus' intermediate, denoted E₄(4H), which has accumulated 4e^-/4H⁺ as two bridging Fe-H-Fe hydrides on the active-site cofactor. This state can lose e^-/H⁺ by hydride protonolysis (HP) or become activated by reductive elimination ( re) of the two hydrides and bind N₂ with H₂ loss, yielding an E₄(2N2H) state that goes on to generate two NH₃ molecules. Thus, E₄(4H) represents the key branch point for these competing reactions. Here, we present a steady-state kinetic analysis that precisely describes this competition. The analysis demonstrates that steady-state, high-electron flux turnover overwhelmingly populates the E₄ states at the expense of less reduced states, quenching HP at those states. The ratio of rate constants for E₄(4H) hydride protonolysis ( k_HP) versus reductive elimination ( k_re) provides a sensitive measure of competition between these two processes and thus is a central parameter of nitrogenase catalysis. Analysis of measurements with the three nitrogenase variants (Mo-nitrogenase, V-nitrogenase, and Fe-nitrogenase) reveals that at a fixed N₂ pressure their tendency to productively react with N₂ to produce two NH₃ molecules and an accompanying H₂, rather than diverting electrons to the side reaction, HP production of H₂, decreases with their ratio of rate constants, k _re/ k_HP: Mo-nitrogenase, 5.1 atm^-1; V-nitrogenase, 2 atm^-1; and Fe-nitrogenase, 0.77 atm^-1 (namely, in a 1:0.39:0.15 ratio). Moreover, the lower catalytic effectiveness of the alternative nitrogenases, with more H₂ production side reaction, is not caused by a higher k_HP but by a significantly lower k _re.

ENDOR Characterization of (N2)FeII(μ-H)2FeI(N2)-: A Spectroscopic Model for N2 Binding by the Di-μ-hydrido Nitrogenase Janus Intermediate

The biomimetic diiron complex 4-(N₂)₂, featuring two terminally bound Fe-N₂ centers bridged by two hydrides, serves as a model for two possible states along the pathway by which the enzyme nitrogenase reduces N₂. One is the Janus intermediate E₄(4H), which has accumulated 4[e-/H+], stored as two [Fe-H-Fe] bridging hydrides, and is activated to bind and reduce N₂ through reductive elimination (RE) of the hydride ligands as H₂. The second is a possible RE intermediate. ¹H and ¹⁴N 35 GHz ENDOR measurements confirm that the formally Fe(II)/Fe(I) 4-(N₂)₂ complex exhibits a fully delocalized, Robin-Day type-III mixed valency. The two bridging hydrides exhibit a fully rhombic dipolar tensor form, T ≈ [- t, + t, 0]. The rhombic form is reproduced by a simple point-dipole model for dipolar interactions between a bridging hydride and its "anchor" Fe ions, confirming validity of this model and demonstrating that observation of a rhombic form is a convenient diagnostic signature for the identification of such core structures in biological centers such as nitrogenase. Furthermore, interpretation of the ¹H measurements with the anchor model maps the g tensor onto the molecular frame, an important function of these equations for application to nitrogenase. Analysis of the hyperfine and quadrupole coupling to the bound ¹⁴N of N₂ provides a reference for nitrogen-bound nitrogenase intermediates and is of chemical significance, as it gives a quantitative estimate of the amount of charge transferred between Fe and coordinated N, a key element in N₂ activation for reduction.

Control of electron transfer in nitrogenase

The bacterial enzyme nitrogenase achieves the reduction of dinitrogen (N₂) to ammonia (NH₃) utilizing electrons, protons, and energy from the hydrolysis of ATP. Building on earlier foundational knowledge, recent studies provide molecular-level details on how the energy of ATP hydrolysis is utilized, the sequencing of multiple electron transfer events, and the nature of energy transduction across this large protein complex. Here, we review the state of knowledge about energy transduction in nitrogenase.