Intercluster Redox Coupling Influences Protonation at the H-cluster in [FeFe] Hydrogenases

H-cluster Intermediates and Catalytic Properties of Clostridium pasteurianum [FeFe]-Hydrogenase III

[FeFe]-Hydrogenases are structurally diverse enzymes that catalyze reversible H2 activation at a catalytic cofactor or H-cluster. The H-cluster is a [4Fe-4S] cubane linked by a cysteine thiolate to a diiron subsite containing unique CO, CN-, and dithiomethylamine ligands. The established H-cluster resting state of [4Fe-4S]2+-[FeII-FeI], or Hox, functions in H2 binding and oxidation, or by proton-coupled reduction initiates H2 evolution. In contrast, in Clostridium pasteurianum [FeFe]-hydrogenase III (CpIII) the resting state of the H-cluster is fully oxidized, [4Fe-4S]2+-[FeII-FeII], or Hox+1. To begin to understand if Hox+1 has a role in the mechanism of CpIII, we determined the spectroscopic and redox properties of CpIII H-cluster states under catalytic conditions. CpIII poised in Hox+1 and either equilibrated under 1 atm of H2 or reduced with sodium dithionite, resulted in a mixture of reduced states including Hox (Em8 = -407 mV), Htrans-like [4Fe-4S]+-[FeII-FeII] (Em8 = -418 mV), Hred [4Fe-4S]+-[FeII-FeI], and HredH+ [4Fe-4S]2+-[FeI-FeI] (Em8 = -455-480 mV). Under H2 the population of the Htrans-like state was >20-fold higher than Hox, implicating a role in CpIII catalysis. Unlike other enzymes, there was no spectral evidence of fully reduced states, such as HsredH+ ([4Fe-4S]+-[FeI-FeI]) or Hhyd ([4Fe-4S]+-[FeII-FeII]-H-). Thus, while the H-cluster states of CpIII encompass most of the catalytic intermediates, it is either unable to form HsredH+ and Hhyd, or these states are highly destabilized in CpIII. Thus, these results demonstrate that catalytic intermediates of reduced CpIII differ from the typical intermediates of other catalytic [FeFe]-hydrogenases and may explain the catalytic preference for H2 production.

Three-Electron Uric Acid Oxidation via Interdistance-Dependent Switching Pathways in Correlated Single-Atom Catalysts for Boosting Sensing Signals

The overly simplistic geometric and electronic structures of single-atom catalysts have become a significant bottleneck in the field of single-atom sensing, impeding both the design of highly efficient electrochemical sensors and the establishment of structure-activity relationships. To address these challenges, we present a novel strategy to boost the sensing performance of single-atom catalysts by precisely tuning the single-atomic interdistance (SAD) in correlated single-atom catalysts (c-SACs). A series of Ru-based c-SACs (Rud=6.2 Å, Rud=7.0 Å, and Rud=9.3 Å) are synthesized with predetermined SAD values, which are comprehensively characterized by various techniques. Electrochemical studies on uric acid (UA) oxidation reveal that Rud=6.2 Å demonstrates an extraordinary sensitivity of 9.83 μA μM-1cm-2, which is superior to most of electrochemistry biosensors reported previously. Kinetic analysis and product examination unveil that the 6.2 Å Ru SAD instigates a distinctive three-electron oxidation of UA, with an extra electron transfer compared to the conventional two-electron pathway, which fundamentally enhances its sensitivity. Density functional theory calculations confirm the optimal SAD facilitates dual-site UA adsorption and accelerated charge transfer dynamics. This investigation provides novel insights into the strategic engineering of high-performance SAC-based electrochemical sensors by precisely controlling the atomic-scale structure of active sites.

Indications for a universal hydrogen catalysis mechanism in [FeFe]-hydrogenases of different phylogenetic groups

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are metalloenzymes catalysing bidirectional hydrogen (H2) turnover. These enzymes are generally considered to be extremely efficient and fast catalysts. However, [FeFe]-hydrogenases constitute a very diverse enzyme family that can be divided into several distinct phylogenetic groups, denoted as groups A-G. Very little is known about the properties of [FeFe]-hydrogenases outside of the intensively studied group A, but recent studies on putatively sensory group C and D enzymes have revealed distinct differences in reactivity. The variation in structure, reactivity and physiological function observed between phylogenetic groups raises the question if all [FeFe]-hydrogenases follow the same mechanism for H2 turnover. Here, we provide the first detailed spectroscopic investigation of a slow-acting putatively sensory group D [FeFe]-hydrogenase from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii (TamHydS). Photo-reduction enabled us to characterize redox states in group D [FeFe]-hydrogenase via infrared spectroscopy under catalytic conditions. The sequential population of redox states similar to group A [FeFe]-hydrogenases supports the notion that group A and D [FeFe]-hydrogenases follow a universal catalytic mechanism. However, clear differences between enzymes from different phylogenetic groups become evident when comparing the relative stability and protonation state of suggested key catalytic intermediates. Moreover, the spectroscopic data collected on TamHydS provides new insight into the structure of the reduced active site, lending further support for the notion of a retained bridging CO ligand throughout the entire catalytic cycle.

A [FeFe] Hydrogenase-Rubrerythrin Chimeric Enzyme Functions to Couple H2 Oxidation to Reduction of H2O2 in the Foodborne Pathogen Clostridium perfringens

[FeFe] hydrogenases are a diverse class of H2-activating enzymes with a wide range of utilities in nature. As H2 is a promising renewable energy carrier, exploration of the increasingly realized functional diversity of [FeFe] hydrogenases is instrumental for understanding how these remarkable enzymes can benefit society and inspire new technologies. In this work, we uncover the properties of a highly unusual natural chimera composed of a [FeFe] hydrogenase and rubrerythrin as a single polypeptide. The unique combination of [FeFe] hydrogenase with rubrerythrin, an enzyme that functions in H2O2 detoxification, raises the question of whether catalytic reactions, such as H2 oxidation and H2O2 reduction, are functionally linked. Herein, we express and purify a representative chimera from Clostridium perfringens (termed CperHydR) and apply various electrochemical and spectroscopic approaches to determine its activity and confirm the presence of each of the proposed metallocofactors. The cumulative data demonstrate that the enzyme contains a surprising array of metallocofactors: the catalytic site of [FeFe] hydrogenase termed the H-cluster, two [4Fe-4S] clusters, two rubredoxin Fe(Cys)4 centers, and a hemerythrin-like diiron site. The absence of an H2-evolution current in protein film voltammetry highlights an exceptional bias of this enzyme toward H2 oxidation to the greatest extent that has been observed for a [FeFe] hydrogenase. Here, we demonstrate that CperHydR uses H2, catalytically split by the hydrogenase domain, to reduce H2O2 by the diiron site. Structural modeling suggests a homodimeric nature of the protein. Overall, this study demonstrates that CperHydR is an H2-dependent H2O2 reductase. Equipped with this information, we discuss the possible role of this enzyme as a part of the oxygen-stress response system, proposing that CperHydR constitutes a new pathway for H2O2 mitigation.

Blue-light photodegradation of ferricyanide under protein relevant conditions

Ferricyanide is commonly used as a reoxidant in photochemical studies of redox proteins including cytochromes, photosystem II and flavoproteins. A low-spin d5 complex, [Fe(III)(CN)6]3- is a powerful electron acceptor which efficiently reoxidises photo-generated radical species. Unfortunately, ferricyanide itself absorbs strongly in the blue and a better understanding of its own photochemistry is required. Here, we present a combined UV/Vis and infrared spectroscopic study of the blue light photo-induced degradation of ferricyanide under conditions commonly employed in photochemical studies of proteins. Clear differences are observed in the photochemistry in pure water, Tris buffer and 20% glycerol solution, which are interpreted in terms of solvent-ligand exchange and ligand to metal charge transfer. The implications for photochemical studies of proteins employing ferricyanide as a reoxidant are discussed.

Probing the Influence of the Protein Scaffold on H-Cluster Reactivity via Gain-of-Function Studies─Improved H2 Evolution and O2 Tolerance through Rational Design of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases make up a structurally diverse family of metalloenzymes that catalyze proton/dihydrogen interconversion. They can be classified into phylogenetically distinct groups denoted A-G, which differ in structure and reactivity. Prototypical Group A hydrogenases have high turnover rates and remarkable energy efficiency. As compared to Group A enzymes, the putatively sensory Group D hydrogenase from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii (TamHydS) has a thousand-fold lower H2 evolution rate and a high overpotential requirement to drive catalysis (irreversible) but shows increased inhibitor tolerance. This divergence in structure and activity between hydrogenases makes them ideal models for studying second (active-site environment) and outer (e.g., substrate transport) coordination sphere effects on metal cofactors. Herein, we generated three TamHydS-based variants, each mimicking proposed key structural features of Group A hydrogenase: the "active site" (AS), "proton-transfer pathway" (PTP), and "combined" (CM = AS + PTP) variant. A fourth single-point variant, A137C, which introduces a proposed critical cysteine in the active site, was characterized as a reference. No change in isolation resulted in Group A-like behavior; i.e., no positive impact on catalytic performance was observed. The CM variant, however, showed increased H2 evolution activity but retained the overpotential requirement. Additionally, the CM variant improved the already relatively high stability of TamHydS against O2 and CO inhibition. These findings show that activity rates, (ir)reversibility, and susceptibility to gaseous inhibitors are decoupled. Moreover, the results highlight the importance of exploring hydrogenase diversity as a path toward understanding the structural factors that enable the outstanding catalytic properties of [FeFe] hydrogenases.

Secondary structure changes as the potential H2 sensing mechanism of group D [FeFe]-hydrogenases

[FeFe]-hydrogenases function as both H2 catalysts and sensors. While catalysis is well investigated, details regarding the H2 sensing mechanism are limited. Here, we relate protein structure changes to H2 sensing, similar to light-driven bio-sensors. Our results highlight how identical cofactors incorporated in alternative protein scaffolds serve different functions in nature.

The missing pieces in the catalytic cycle of [FeFe] hydrogenases

Hydrogen could provide a suitable means for storing energy from intermittent renewable sources for later use on demand. However, many challenges remain regarding the activity, specificity, stability and sustainability of current hydrogen production and consumption methods. The lack of efficient catalysts based on abundant and sustainable elements lies at the heart of this problem. Nature's solution led to the evolution of hydrogenase enzymes capable of reversible hydrogen conversion at high rates using iron- and nickel-based active sites. Through a detailed understanding of these enzymes, we can learn how to mimic them to engineer a new generation of highly active synthetic catalysts. Incredible progress has been made in our understanding of biological hydrogen activation over the last few years. In particular, detailed studies of the [FeFe] hydrogenase class have provided substantial insight into a sophisticated, optimised, molecular catalyst, the active site H-cluster. In this short perspective, we will summarise recent findings and highlight the missing pieces needed to complete the puzzle.

Properties of the iron-sulfur cluster electron transfer relay in an [FeFe]-hydrogenase that is tuned for H2 oxidation catalysis

[FeFe]-hydrogenases catalyze the reversible oxidation of H2 from electrons and protons at an organometallic active site cofactor named the H-cluster. In addition to the H-cluster, most [FeFe]-hydrogenases possess accessory FeS cluster (F-cluster) relays that function in mediating electron transfer with catalysis. There is significant variation in the structural properties of F-cluster relays among the [FeFe]-hydrogenases; however, it is unknown how this variation relates to the electronic and thermodynamic properties, and thus the electron transfer properties, of enzymes. Clostridium pasteurianum [FeFe]-hydrogenase II (CpII) exhibits a large catalytic bias for H2 oxidation (compared to H2 production), making it a notable system for examining if F-cluster properties contribute to the overall function and efficiency of the enzyme. By applying a combination of multifrequency and potentiometric electron paramagnetic resonance, we resolved two electron paramagnetic resonance signals with distinct power- and temperature-dependent properties at g = 2.058 1.931 1.891 (F2.058) and g = 2.061 1.920 1.887 (F2.061), with assigned midpoint potentials of -140 ± 18 mV and -406 ± 12 mV versus normal hydrogen electrode, respectively. Spectral analysis revealed features consistent with spin-spin coupling between the two [4Fe-4S] F-clusters, and possible functional models are discussed that account for the contribution of coupling to the electron transfer landscape. The results signify the interplay of electronic coupling and free energy properties and parameters of the FeS clusters to the electron transfer mechanism through the relay and provide new insight as to how relays functionally complement the catalytic directionality of active sites to achieve highly efficient catalysis.

Switching Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution Pathways through Electronic Tuning of Copper Porphyrins

The electronic structure of metal complexes plays key roles in determining their catalytic features. However, controlling electronic structures to regulate reaction mechanisms is of fundamental interest but has been rarely presented. Herein, we report electronic tuning of Cu porphyrins to switch pathways of the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Through controllable and regioselective β-oxidation of Cu porphyrin 1, we synthesized analogues 2-4 with one or two β-lactone groups in either a cis or trans configuration. Complexes 1-4 have the same Cu-N4 core site but different electronic structures. Although β-oxidation led to large anodic shifts of reductions, 1-4 displayed similar HER activities in terms of close overpotentials. With electrochemical, chemical and theoretical results, we show that the catalytically active species switches from a CuI species for 1 to a Cu0 species for 4. This work is thus significant to present mechanism-controllable HER via electronic tuning of catalysts.

Facile electrocatalytic proton reduction by a [Fe-Fe]-hydrogenase bio-inspired synthetic model bearing a terminal CN- ligand

An azadithiolate bridged CN- bound pentacarbonyl bis-iron complex, mimicking the active site of [Fe-Fe] H2ase is synthesized. The geometric and electronic structure of this complex is elucidated using a combination of EXAFS analysis, infrared and Mössbauer spectroscopy and DFT calculations. The electrochemical investigations show that complex 1 effectively reduces H+ to H2 between pH 0-3 at diffusion-controlled rates (1011 M-1 s-1) i.e. 108 s-1 at pH 3 with an overpotential of 140 mV. Electrochemical analysis and DFT calculations suggests that a CN- ligand increases the pKa of the cluster enabling hydrogen production from its Fe(i)-Fe(0) state at pHs much higher and overpotential much lower than its precursor bis-iron hexacarbonyl model which is active in its Fe(0)-Fe(0) state. The formation of a terminal Fe-H species, evidenced by spectroelectrochemistry in organic solvent, via a rate determining proton coupled electron transfer step and protonation of the adjacent azadithiolate, lowers the kinetic barrier leading to diffusion controlled rates of H2 evolution. The stereo-electronic factors enhance its catalytic rate by 3 order of magnitude relative to a bis-iron hexacarbonyl precursor at the same pH and potential.

Evidence of Atypical Structural Flexibility of the Active Site Surrounding of an [FeFe] Hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinkii

[FeFe] hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinkii (CbHydA1) is an unusual hydrogenase in that it can withstand prolonged exposure to O₂ by reversibly converting into an O₂-protected, inactive state (H_inact). It has been indicated in the past that an atypical conformation of the "SC₃₆₇CP" loop near the [2Fe]_H portion of the six-iron active site (H-cluster) allows the Cys367 residue to adopt an "off-H⁺-pathway" orientation, promoting a facile transition of the cofactor to H_inact. Here, we investigated the electronic structure of the H-cluster in the oxidized state (H_ox) that directly converts to H_inact under oxidizing conditions and the related CO-inhibited state (H_ox-CO). We demonstrate that both states exhibit two distinct forms in electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. The ratio between the two forms is pH-dependent but also sensitive to the buffer choice. Our IR and EPR analyses illustrate that the spectral heterogeneity is due to a perturbation of the coordination environment of the H-cluster's [4Fe4S]_H subcluster without affecting the [2Fe]_H subcluster. Overall, we conclude that the observation of two spectral components per state is evidence of heterogeneity of the environment of the H-cluster likely associated with conformational mobility of the SCCP loop. Such flexibility may allow Cys367 to switch rapidly between off- and on-H⁺-pathway rotamers. Consequently, we believe such structural mobility may be the key to maintaining high enzymatic activity while allowing a facile transition to the O₂-protected state.

Binding of exogenous cyanide reveals new active-site states in [FeFe] hydrogenases

[FeFe] hydrogenases are highly efficient metalloenyzmes for hydrogen conversion. Their active site cofactor (the H-cluster) is composed of a canonical [4Fe-4S] cluster ([4Fe-4S]_H) linked to a unique organometallic di-iron subcluster ([2Fe]_H). In [2Fe]_H the two Fe ions are coordinated by a bridging 2-azapropane-1,3-dithiolate (ADT) ligand, three CO and two CN^- ligands, leaving an open coordination site on one Fe where substrates (H₂ and H⁺) as well as inhibitors (e.g. O₂, CO, H₂S) may bind. Here, we investigate two new active site states that accumulate in [FeFe] hydrogenase variants where the cysteine (Cys) in the proton transfer pathway is mutated to alanine (Ala). Our experimental data, including atomic resolution crystal structures and supported by calculations, suggest that in these two states a third CN^- ligand is bound to the apical position of [2Fe]_H. These states can be generated both by "cannibalization" of CN^- from damaged [2Fe]_H subclusters as well as by addition of exogenous CN^-. This is the first detailed spectroscopic and computational characterisation of the interaction of exogenous CN^- with [FeFe] hydrogenases. Similar CN^--bound states can also be generated in wild-type hydrogenases, but do not form as readily as with the Cys to Ala variants. These results highlight how the interaction between the first amino acid in the proton transfer pathway and the active site tunes ligand binding to the open coordination site and affects the electronic structure of the H-cluster.

A personal account on 25 years of scientific literature on [FeFe]-hydrogenase

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are gas-processing metalloenzymes that catalyze H₂ oxidation and proton reduction (H₂ release) in microorganisms. Their high turnover frequencies and lack of electrical overpotential in the hydrogen conversion reaction has inspired generations of biologists, chemists, and physicists to explore the inner workings of [FeFe]-hydrogenase. Here, we revisit 25 years of scientific literature on [FeFe]-hydrogenase and propose a personal account on 'must-read' research papers and review article that will allow interested scientists to follow the recent discussions on catalytic mechanism, O₂ sensitivity, and the in vivo synthesis of the active site cofactor with its biologically uncommon ligands carbon monoxide and cyanide. Focused on-but not restricted to-structural biology and molecular biophysics, we highlight future directions that may inspire young investigators to pursue a career in the exciting and competitive field of [FeFe]-hydrogenase research.

Anaerobic Infrared Spectroelectrochemical Methods for Studying Oxygen-Sensitive [FeFe] Hydrogenases

[FeFe] hydrogenases comprise an important class of H₂ evolving enzymes; however, these proteins are often oxygen sensitive and require anaerobic environments for characterization. Understanding the electrochemical relationships between various active and inactive states of these enzymes is instrumental in uncovering the reaction mechanisms of the complex six-iron active center of [FeFe] hydrogenases called H-cluster. Since states of the H-cluster exhibit distinct fingerprint-like spectra in the mid-IR range, IR spectroelectrochemical experiments provide a powerful methodological framework for this goal. This chapter describes protocols for performing Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroelectrochemical experiments on [FeFe] hydrogenases under anaerobic conditions. Topics included experimental design, data acquisition, and data analysis.

Increasing the O2 Resistance of the [FeFe]-Hydrogenase CbA5H through Enhanced Protein Flexibility

The high turnover rates of [FeFe]-hydrogenases under mild conditions and at low overpotentials provide a natural blueprint for the design of hydrogen catalysts. However, the unique active site (H-cluster) degrades upon contact with oxygen. The [FeFe]-hydrogenase fromClostridium beijerinckii (CbA5H) is characterized by the flexibility of its protein structure, which allows a conserved cysteine to coordinate to the active site under oxidative conditions. Thereby, intrinsic cofactor degradation induced by dioxygen is minimized. However, the protection from O₂ is only partial, and the activity of the enzyme decreases upon each exposure to O₂. By using site-directed mutagenesis in combination with electrochemistry, ATR-FTIR spectroscopy, and molecular dynamics simulations, we show that the kinetics of the conversion between the oxygen-protected inactive state (cysteine-bound) and the oxygen-sensitive active state can be accelerated by replacing a surface residue that is very distant from the active site. This sole exchange of methionine for a glutamate residue leads to an increased resistance of the hydrogenase to dioxygen. With our study, we aim to understand how local modifications of the protein structure can have a crucial impact on protein dynamics and how they can control the reactivity of inorganic active sites through outer sphere effects.

The Contribution of Proton-Donor pKa on Reactivity Profiles of [FeFe]-hydrogenases

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases are enzymes that catalyze the reversible activation of H2 coupled to the reduction-oxidation of electron carriers. Members of the different taxonomic groups of [FeFe]-hydrogenases display a wide range of preference, or bias, for H2 oxidation or H2 production reactions, despite sharing a common catalytic cofactor, or H-cluster. Identifying the properties that control reactivity remains an active area of investigation, and models have emerged that include diversity in the catalytic site coordination environments and compositions of electron transfer chains. The kinetics of proton-coupled electron transfer at the H-cluster might be expected to be a point of control of reactivity. To test this hypothesis, systematic changes were made to the conserved cysteine residue that functions in proton exchange with the H-cluster in the three model enzymes: CaI, CpII, and CrHydA1. CaI and CpII both employ electron transfer accessory clusters but differ in bias, whereas CrHydA1 lacks accessory clusters having only the H-cluster. Changing from cysteine to either serine (more basic) or aspartate (more acidic) modifies the sidechain pKa and thus the barrier for the proton exchange step. The reaction rates for H2 oxidation or H2 evolution were surveyed and measured for model [FeFe]-hydrogenases, and the results show that the initial proton-transfer step in [FeFe]-hydrogenase is tightly coupled to the control of reactivity; a change from cysteine to more basic serine favored H2 oxidation in all enzymes, whereas a change to more acidic aspartate caused a shift in preference toward H2 evolution. Overall, the changes in reactivity profiles were profound, spanning 105 in ratio of the H2 oxidation-to-H2 evolution rates. The fact that the change in reactivity follows a common trend implies that the effect of changing the proton-transfer residue pKa may also be framed as an effect on the scaling relationship between the H-cluster di(thiolmethyl)amine (DTMA) ligand pKa and E m values of the H-cluster. Experimental observations that support this relationship, and how it relates to catalytic function in [FeFe]-hydrogenases, are discussed.

Investigating the role of the strong field ligands in [FeFe] hydrogenase: spectroscopic and functional characterization of a semi-synthetic mono-cyanide active site

Artificial maturation of hydrogenases provides a path towards generating new semi-synthetic enzymes with novel catalytic properties. Here enzymes featuring a synthetic asymmetric mono-cyanide cofactor have been prepared using two different hydrogenase scaffolds. Their structure and reactivity was investigated in order to elucidate the design rationale behind the native di-cyanide cofactor, and by extension the second coordination sphere of the active-site pocket. Surprisingly, the choice of host enzyme was found to have a dramatic impact on reactivity. Moreover, the study shows that synthetic manipulations of the active-site can significantly increase inhibitor tolerance, as compared to native [FeFe] hydrogenase, while retaining the enzyme's native capacity for reversible catalysis.

Bioinorganic Chemistry on Electrodes: Methods to Functional Modeling

One of the major goals of bioinorganic chemistry has been to mimic the function of elegant metalloenzymes. Such functional modeling has been difficult to attain in solution, in particular, for reactions that require multiple protons and multiple electrons (nH⁺/ne^-). Using a combination of heterogeneous electrochemistry, electrode and molecule design one may control both electron transfer (ET) and proton transfer (PT) of these nH⁺/ne^- reactions. Such control can allow functional modeling of hydrogenases (H⁺ + e^- → 1/2 H₂), cytochrome c oxidase (O₂ + 4 e^- + 4 H⁺ → 2 H₂O), monooxygenases (RR'CH₂ + O₂ + 2 e^- + 2 H⁺ → RR'CHOH + H₂O) and dioxygenases (S + O₂ → SO₂; S = organic substrate) in aqueous medium and at room temperatures. In addition, these heterogeneous constructs allow probing unnatural bioinspired reactions and estimation of the inner- and outer-sphere reorganization energy of small molecules and proteins.

Stability of the H-cluster under whole-cell conditions-formation of an Htrans-like state and its reactivity towards oxygen

Hydrogenases are metalloenzymes that catalyze the reversible oxidation of molecular hydrogen into protons and electrons. For this purpose, [FeFe]-hydrogenases utilize a hexanuclear iron cofactor, the H-cluster. This biologically unique cofactor provides the enzyme with outstanding catalytic activities, but it is also highly oxygen sensitive. Under in vitro conditions, oxygen stable forms of the H-cluster denoted Htrans and Hinact can be generated via treatment with sulfide under oxidizing conditions. Herein, we show that an Htrans-like species forms spontaneously under intracellular conditions on a time scale of hours, concurrent with the cells ceasing H2 production. Addition of cysteine or sulfide during the maturation promotes the formation of this H-cluster state. Moreover, it is found that formation of the observed Htrans-like species is influenced by both steric factors and proton transfer, underscoring the importance of outer coordination sphere effects on H-cluster reactivity.

Enzymatic X-ray absorption spectroelectrochemistry

The ability to observe the changes that occur at an enzyme active site during electrocatalysis can provide very valuable information for understanding the mechanism and ultimately aid in catalyst design. Herein, we discuss the development of X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) in combination with electrochemistry for operando studies of enzymatic systems. XAS has had a long history of enabling geometric and electronic structural insights into the catalytic active sites of enzymes, however, XAS combined with electrochemistry (XA-SEC) has been exceedingly rare in bioinorganic applications. Herein, we discuss the challenges and opportunities of applying operando XAS to enzymatic electrocatalysts. The challenges due to the low concentration of the photoabsorber and the instability of the protein in the X-ray beam are discussed. Methods for immobilizing enzymes on the electrodes, while maintaining full redox control are highlighted. A case study of combined XAS and electrochemistry applied to a [NiFe] hydrogenase is presented. By entrapping the [NiFe] hydrogenase in a redox polymer, relatively high protein concentrations can be achieved on the electrode surface, while maintaining redox control. Overall, it is demonstrated that the experiments are feasible, but require precise redox control over the majority of the absorber atoms and careful controls to discriminate between electrochemically-driven changes and beam damage. Opportunities for future applications are discussed.

Harnessing selenocysteine to enhance microbial cell factories for hydrogen production

Hydrogen is a clean, renewable energy source, that when combined with oxygen, produces heat and electricity with only water vapor as a biproduct. Furthermore, it has the highest energy content by weight of all known fuels. As a result, various strategies have engineered methods to produce hydrogen efficiently and in quantities that are of interest to the economy. To approach the notion of producing hydrogen from a biological perspective, we take our attention to hydrogenases which are naturally produced in microbes. These organisms have the machinery to produce hydrogen, which when cleverly engineered, could be useful in cell factories resulting in large production of hydrogen. Not all hydrogenases are efficient at hydrogen production, and those that are, tend to be oxygen sensitive. Therefore, we provide a new perspective on introducing selenocysteine, a highly reactive proteinogenic amino acid, as a strategy towards engineering hydrogenases with enhanced hydrogen production, or increased oxygen tolerance.

Electrochemical control of [FeFe]-hydrogenase single crystals reveals complex redox populations at the catalytic site

Elucidating the distribution of intermediates at the active site of redox metalloenzymes is vital to understanding their highly efficient catalysis. Here we demonstrate that it is possible to generate, and detect, the key catalytic redox states of an [FeFe]-hydrogenase in a protein crystal. Individual crystals of the prototypical [FeFe]-hydrogenase I from Clostridium pasteurianum (CpI) are maintained under electrochemical control, allowing for precise tuning of the redox potential, while the crystal is simultaneously probed via Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) microspectroscopy. The high signal/noise spectra reveal potential-dependent variation in the distribution of redox states at the active site (H-cluster) according to state-specific vibrational bands from the endogeneous CO and CN- ligands. CpI crystals are shown to populate the same H-cluster states as those detected in solution, including the oxidised species Hox, the reduced species Hred/HredH+, the super-reduced HsredH+ and the hydride species Hhyd. The high sensitivity and precise redox control offered by this approach also facilitates the detection and characterisation of low abundance species that only accumulate within a narrow window of conditions, revealing new redox intermediates.

A Beginner’s Guide to Thermodynamic Modelling of [FeFe] Hydrogenase

[FeFe] hydrogenases, which are considered the most active naturally occurring catalysts for hydrogen oxidation and proton reduction, are extensively studied as models to learn the important features for efficient H2 conversion catalysis. Using infrared spectroscopy as a selective probe, the redox behaviour of the active site H-cluster is routinely modelled with thermodynamic schemes based on the Nernst equation for determining thermodynamic parameters, such as redox midpoint potentials and pKa values. Here, the thermodynamic models usually applied to [FeFe] hydrogenases are introduced and discussed in a pedagogic fashion and their applicability to additional metalloenzymes and molecular catalysts is also addressed.

Catalytic bias in oxidation-reduction catalysis

Cataytic bias refers to the propensity of a reaction catalyst to effect a different rate acceleration in one direction versus the other in a chemical reaction under non-equilibrium conditions. In biocatalysis, the inherent bias of an enzyme is often advantagous to augment the innate thermodynamics of a reaction to promote efficiency and fidelity in the coordination of catabolic and anabolic pathways. In industrial chemical catalysis a directional cataltyic bias is a sought after property in facilitating the engineering of systems that couple catalysis with harvest and storage of for example fine chemicals or energy compounds. Interestingly, there is little information about catalytic bias in biocatalysis likely in large part due to difficulties in developing tractible assays sensitive enough to study detailed kinetics. For oxidation-reduction reactions, colorimetric redox indicators exist in a range of reduction potentials to provide a mechanism to study both directions of reactions in a fairly facile manner. The current short review attempts to define catalytic bias conceptually and to develop model systems for defining the parameters that control catalytic bias in enzyme catalyzed oxidation-reduction catalysis.

[FeFe]-Hydrogenases: maturation and reactivity of enzymatic systems and overview of biomimetic models

[FeFe]-hydrogenases recieved increasing interest in the last decades. This review summarises important findings regarding their enzymatic reactivity as well as inorganic models applied as electro- and photochemical catalysts.

Biochemical and artificial pathways for the reduction of carbon dioxide, nitrite and the competing proton reduction: effect of 2nd sphere interactions in catalysis

Reduction of oxides and oxoanions of carbon and nitrogen are of great contemporary importance as they are crucial for a sustainable environment.

Temperature Dependence of Structural Dynamics at the Catalytic Cofactor of [FeFe]-hydrogenase

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are nature's blueprint for efficient hydrogen turnover. Understanding their enzymatic mechanism may improve technological H₂ fuel generation. The active-site cofactor (H-cluster) consists of a [4Fe-4S] cluster ([4Fe]_H), cysteine-linked to a diiron site ([2Fe]_H) carrying an azadithiolate (adt) group, terminal cyanide and carbon monoxide ligands, and a bridging carbon monoxide (μCO) in the oxidized protein (Hox). Recently, the debate on the structure of reduced H-cluster states was intensified by the assignment of new species under cryogenic conditions. We investigated temperature effects (4-280 K) in infrared (IR) and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) data of [FeFe]-hydrogenases using fit analyses and quantum-chemical calculations. IR data from our laboratory and literature sources were evaluated. At ambient temperatures, reduced H-cluster states with a bridging hydride (μH^-, in Hred and Hsred) or with an additional proton at [4Fe]_H (Hred') or at the distal iron of [2Fe]_H (Hhyd) prevail. At cryogenic temperatures, these species are largely replaced by states that hold a μCO, lack [4Fe]_H protonation, and bind an additional proton at the adt nitrogen (HredH⁺ and HsredH⁺). XAS revealed the atomic coordinate dispersion (i.e., the Debye-Waller parameter, 2σ²) of the iron-ligand bonds and Fe-Fe distances in the oxidized and reduced H-cluster. 2σ² showed a temperature dependence typical for the so-called protein-glass transition, with small changes below ∼200 K and a pronounced increase above this "breakpoint". This behavior is attributed to the freezing-out of larger-scale anharmonic motions of amino acid side chains and water species. We propose that protonation at [4Fe]_H as well as ligand rearrangement and μH^- binding at [2Fe]_H are impaired because of restricted molecular mobility at cryogenic temperatures so that protonation can be biased toward adt. We conclude that a H-cluster with a μCO, selective [4Fe]_H or [2Fe]_H protonation, and catalytic proton transfer via adt facilitates efficient H₂ conversion in [FeFe]-hydrogenase.

The Laser-Induced Potential Jump: A Method for Rapid Electron Injection into Oxidoreductase Enzymes

Oxidoreductase enzymes often perform technologically useful chemical transformations using abundant metal cofactors with high efficiency under ambient conditions. The understanding of the catalytic mechanism of these enzymes is, however, highly dependent on the availability of well-characterized and optimized time-resolved analytical techniques. We have developed an approach for rapidly injecting electrons into a catalytic system using a photoactivated nanomaterial in combination with a range of redox mediators to produce a potential jump in solution, which then initiates turnover via electron transfer (ET) to the catalyst. The ET events at the nanomaterial-mediator-catalyst interfaces are, however, highly sensitive to the experimental conditions such as photon flux, relative concentrations of system components, and pH. Here, we present a systematic optimization of these experimental parameters for a specific catalytic system, namely, [FeFe] hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1). The developed strategies can, however, be applied in the study of a wide variety of oxidoreductase enzymes. Our potential jump system consists of CdSe/CdS core-shell nanorods as a photosensitizer and a series of substituted bipyridinium salts as mediators with redox potentials in the range from -550 to -670 mV (vs SHE). With these components, we screened the effect of pH, mediator concentration, protein concentration, photosensitizer concentration, and photon flux on steady-state photoreduction and hydrogen production as well as ET and potential jump efficiency. By manipulating these experimental conditions, we show the potential of simple modifications to improve the tunability of the potential jump for application to study oxidoreductases.

Characterization of a putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenase provides new insight into the role of the active site architecture

[FeFe]-hydrogenases are known for their high rates of hydrogen turnover, and are intensively studied in the context of biotechnological applications. Evolution has generated a plethora of different subclasses with widely different characteristics. The M2e subclass is phylogenetically distinct from previously characterized members of this enzyme family and its biological role is unknown. It features significant differences in domain- and active site architecture, and is most closely related to the putative sensory [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Here we report the first comprehensive biochemical and spectroscopical characterization of an M2e enzyme, derived from Thermoanaerobacter mathranii. As compared to other [FeFe]-hydrogenases characterized to-date, this enzyme displays an increased H2 affinity, higher activation enthalpies for H+/H2 interconversion, and unusual reactivity towards known hydrogenase inhibitors. These properties are related to differences in active site architecture between the M2e [FeFe]-hydrogenase and "prototypical" [FeFe]-hydrogenases. Thus, this study provides new insight into the role of this subclass in hydrogen metabolism and the influence of the active site pocket on the chemistry of the H-cluster.

Investigation of the Unusual Ability of the [FeFe] Hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinckii to Access an O2-Protected State

[FeFe] hydrogenases are enzymes capable of producing and oxidizing H₂ at staggering submillisecond time scales. A major limitation in applying these enzymes for industrial hydrogen production is their irreversible inactivation by oxygen. Recently, an [FeFe] hydrogenase from Clostridium beijerinckii (CbHydA1) was reported to regain its catalytic activity after exposure to oxygen. In this report, we have determined that artificially matured CbHydA1 is indeed oxygen tolerant in the absence of reducing agents and sulfides by means of reaching an O₂-protected state (H_inact). We were also able to generate the H_inact state anaerobically via both chemical and electrochemical oxidation. We use a combination of spectroscopy, electrochemistry, and density functional theory (DFT) to uncover intrinsic properties of the active center of CbHydA1, leading to its unprecedented oxygen tolerance. We have observed that reversible, low-potential oxidation of the active center leads to the protection against O₂-induced degradation. The transition between the active oxidized state (H_ox) and the H_inact state appears to proceed without any detectable intermediates. We found that the H_inact state is stable for more than 40 h in air, highlighting the remarkable resilience of CbHydA1 to oxygen. Using a combination of DFT and FTIR, we also provide a hypothesis for the chemical identity of the H_inact state. These results demonstrate that CbHydA1 has remarkable stability in the presence of oxygen, which will drive future efforts to engineer more robust catalysts for biofuel production.

Spectroscopic and Computational Evidence that [FeFe] Hydrogenases Operate Exclusively with CO-Bridged Intermediates

[FeFe] hydrogenases are extremely active H₂-converting enzymes. Their mechanism remains highly controversial, in particular, the nature of the one-electron and two-electron reduced intermediates called H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺. In one model, the H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺ states contain a semibridging CO, while in the other model, the bridging CO is replaced by a bridging hydride. Using low-temperature IR spectroscopy and nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy, together with density functional theory calculations, we show that the bridging CO is retained in the H_sredH⁺ and H_redH⁺ states in the [FeFe] hydrogenases from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and Desulfovibrio desulfuricans, respectively. Furthermore, there is no evidence for a bridging hydride in either state. These results agree with a model of the catalytic cycle in which the H_redH⁺ and H_sredH⁺ states are integral, catalytically competent components. We conclude that proton-coupled electron transfer between the two subclusters is crucial to catalysis and allows these enzymes to operate in a highly efficient and reversible manner.

Spectroscopic and biochemical insight into an electron-bifurcating [FeFe] hydrogenase

Abstract

The heterotrimeric electron-bifurcating [FeFe] hydrogenase (HydABC) from Thermotoga maritima (Tm) couples the endergonic reduction of protons (H⁺) by dihydronicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) (∆G⁰ ≈ 18 kJ mol⁻¹) to the exergonic reduction of H⁺ by reduced ferredoxin (Fd_red) (∆G⁰ ≈ − 16 kJ mol⁻¹). The specific mechanism by which HydABC functions is not understood. In the current study, we describe the biochemical and spectroscopic characterization of TmHydABC recombinantly produced in Escherichia coli and artificially maturated with a synthetic diiron cofactor. We found that TmHydABC catalyzed the hydrogen (H₂)-dependent reduction of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD⁺) in the presence of oxidized ferredoxin (Fd_ox) at a rate of  ≈17 μmol NADH min⁻¹ mg⁻¹. Our data suggest that only one flavin is present in the enzyme and is not likely to be the site of electron bifurcation. FTIR and EPR spectroscopy, as well as FTIR spectroelectrochemistry, demonstrated that the active site for H₂ conversion, the H-cluster, in TmHydABC behaves essentially the same as in prototypical [FeFe] hydrogenases, and is most likely also not the site of electron bifurcation. The implications of these results are discussed with respect to the current hypotheses on the electron bifurcation mechanism of [FeFe] hydrogenases. Overall, the results provide insight into the electron-bifurcating mechanism and present a well-defined system for further investigations of this fascinating class of [FeFe] hydrogenases.

Graphic abstract

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1007/s00775-019-01747-1) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Tuning Catalytic Bias of Hydrogen Gas Producing Hydrogenases

Hydrogenases display a wide range of catalytic rates and biases in reversible hydrogen gas oxidation catalysis. The interactions of the iron-sulfur-containing catalytic site with the local protein environment are thought to contribute to differences in catalytic reactivity, but this has not been demonstrated. The microbe Clostridium pasteurianum produces three [FeFe]-hydrogenases that differ in "catalytic bias" by exerting a disproportionate rate acceleration in one direction or the other that spans a remarkable 6 orders of magnitude. The combination of high-resolution structural work, biochemical analyses, and computational modeling indicates that protein secondary interactions directly influence the relative stabilization/destabilization of different oxidation states of the active site metal cluster. This selective stabilization or destabilization of oxidation states can preferentially promote hydrogen oxidation or proton reduction and represents a simple yet elegant model by which a protein catalytic site can confer catalytic bias.

Asymmetry in the Ligand Coordination Sphere of the [FeFe] Hydrogenase Active Site Is Reflected in the Magnetic Spin Interactions of the Aza-propanedithiolate Ligand

[FeFe] hydrogenases are very active enzymes that catalyze the reversible conversion of molecular hydrogen into protons and electrons. Their active site, the H-cluster, contains a unique binuclear iron complex, [2Fe]_H, with CN^- and CO ligands as well as an aza-propane-dithiolate (ADT) moiety featuring a central amine functionality that mediates proton transfer during catalysis. We present a pulsed ¹³C-ENDOR investigation of the H-cluster in which the two methylene carbons of ADT are isotope labeled with ¹³C. We observed that the corresponding two ¹³C hyperfine interactions are of opposite sign and corroborated this finding using density functional theory calculations. The spin polarization in the ADT ligand is shown to be linked to the asymmetric coordination of the distal iron site with its terminal CN^- and CO ligands. We propose that this asymmetry is relevant for the enzyme reactivity and is related to the (optimal) stabilization of the iron-hydride intermediate in the catalytic cycle.

Oxygen-Tolerant H2 Production by [FeFe]-H2ase Active Site Mimics Aided by Second Sphere Proton Shuttle

The instability of [FeFe]-H₂ases and their biomimetics toward O₂ renders them inefficient to implement in practical H₂ generation (HER). Previous investigations on synthetic models as well as natural enzymes proved that reactive oxygen species (ROS) generated on O₂ exposure oxidatively degrades the 2Fe subcluster within the H-cluster active site. Recent electrochemical studies, coupled with theoretical investigations on [FeFe]-H₂ase suggested that selective O₂ reduction to H₂O could eliminate the ROS, and hence, tolerance against oxidative degradation could be achieved ( Nat. Chem. 2017, 9, 88-95). We have prepared a series of 2Fe subsite mimics with substituted arenes attached to bridgehead N atoms in the S to S linker, (μ-S₂(CH₂)₂NAr)[Fe(CO)₃]₂. Structural analyses find the nature of the substituent on the arene offers steric control of the orientation of bridgehead N atoms, affecting their proton uptake and translocation ability. The heterogeneous electrochemical studies of these complexes physiadsorbed on edge plane graphite (EPG) electrode show the onset of HER activity at ∼180 mV overpotential in pH 5.5 water. In addition, bridgehead N-protonation and subsequent H-bonding capability are established to facilitate the O-O bond cleavage resulting in selective O₂ reduction to H₂O. This allows a synthetic [FeFe]-H₂ase model to reduce protons to H₂ unabated in the presence of dissolved O₂ in water at nearly neutral pH (pH 5.5); i.e., O₂-tolerant, stable HER activity is achieved.

Sulfide Protects [FeFe] Hydrogenases From O2

[FeFe] hydrogenases catalyze proton reduction and hydrogen oxidation with high rates and efficiency under physiological conditions, but are highly oxygen sensitive. The [FeFe] hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio desulfuricans ( DdHydAB) can be purified under air in an oxygen stable inactive state H_ox^air. The formation of the H_ox^air state in vitro allows the handling of hydrogenases in air, making their implementation in biotechnological applications more feasible. Here, we report a simple and robust protocol for the formation of the H_ox^air state in DdHydAB and the [FeFe] hydrogenase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, which is based on high potential inactivation in the presence of sulfide.

CO-Bridged H-Cluster Intermediates in the Catalytic Mechanism of [FeFe]-Hydrogenase CaI

The [FeFe]-hydrogenases ([FeFe] H₂ases) catalyze reversible H₂ activation at the H-cluster, which is composed of a [4Fe-4S]_H subsite linked by a cysteine thiolate to a bridged, organometallic [2Fe-2S] ([2Fe]_H) subsite. Profoundly different geometric models of the H-cluster redox states that orchestrate the electron/proton transfer steps of H₂ bond activation have been proposed. We have examined this question in the [FeFe] H₂ase I from Clostridium acetobutylicum (CaI) by Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy with temperature annealing and H/D isotope exchange to identify the relevant redox states and define catalytic transitions. One-electron reduction of H_ox led to formation of H_redH⁺ ([4Fe-4S]_H²⁺-Fe^I-Fe^I) and H_red' ([4Fe-4S]_H¹⁺-Fe^II-Fe^I), with both states characterized by low frequency μ-CO IR modes consistent with a fully bridged [2Fe]_H. Similar μ-CO IR modes were also identified for H_redH⁺ of the [FeFe] H₂ase from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (CrHydA1). The CaI proton-transfer variant C298S showed enrichment of an H/D isotope-sensitive μ-CO mode, a component of the hydride bound H-cluster IR signal, H_hyd. Equilibrating CaI with increasing amounts of NaDT, and probed at cryogenic temperatures, showed H_redH⁺ was converted to H_hyd. Over an increasing temperature range from 10 to 260 K catalytic turnover led to loss of H_hyd and appearance of H_ox, consistent with enzymatic turnover and H₂ formation. The results show for CaI that the μ-CO of [2Fe]_H remains bridging for all of the "H_red" states and that H_redH⁺ is on pathway to H_hyd and H₂ evolution in the catalytic mechanism. These results provide a blueprint for designing small molecule catalytic analogs.