Idealization of the hydrophobic segment of the alkaline phosphatase signal peptide

SignalP: The Evolution of a Web Server

SignalP ( https://services.healthtech.dtu.dk/services/SignalP-6.0/ ) is a very popular prediction method for signal peptides, the intrinsic signals that make proteins secretory. The SignalP web server has existed since 1995 and is now in its sixth major version. In this historical account, we (three authors who have taken part in the entire journey plus the first author of the latest version) describe the differences between the versions and discuss the various decisions taken along the way.

Strategies to Enhance Periplasmic Recombinant Protein Production Yields in Escherichia coli

Main reasons to produce recombinant proteins in the periplasm of E. coli rather than in its cytoplasm are to -i- enable disulfide bond formation, -ii- facilitate protein isolation, -iii- control the nature of the N-terminus of the mature protein, and -iv- minimize exposure to cytoplasmic proteases. However, hampered protein targeting, translocation and folding as well as protein instability can all negatively affect periplasmic protein production yields. Strategies to enhance periplasmic protein production yields have focused on harmonizing secretory recombinant protein production rates with the capacity of the secretory apparatus by transcriptional and translational tuning, signal peptide selection and engineering, increasing the targeting, translocation and periplasmic folding capacity of the production host, preventing proteolysis, and, finally, the natural and engineered adaptation of the production host to periplasmic protein production. Here, we discuss these strategies using notable examples as a thread.

The Principles of Protein Targeting and Transport Across Cell Membranes

The past several decades have witnessed tremendous growth in the protein targeting, transport and translocation field. Major advances were made during this time period. Now the molecular details of the targeting factors, receptors and the membrane channels that were envisioned in Blobel's Signal Hypothesis in the 1970s have been revealed by powerful structural methods. It is evident that there is a myriad of cytosolic and membrane associated systems that accurately sort and target newly synthesized proteins to their correct membrane translocases for membrane insertion or protein translocation. Here we will describe the common principles for protein transport in prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Enhancing Recombinant Protein Yields in the E. coli Periplasm by Combining Signal Peptide and Production Rate Screening

Proteins that contain disulfide bonds mainly mature in the oxidative environment of the eukaryotic endoplasmic reticulum or the periplasm of Gram-negative bacteria. In E. coli, disulfide bond containing recombinant proteins are often targeted to the periplasm by an N-terminal signal peptide that is removed once it passes through the Sec-translocon in the cytoplasmic membrane. Despite their conserved targeting function, signal peptides can impact recombinant protein production yields in the periplasm, as can the production rate. Here, we present a combined screen involving different signal peptides and varying production rates that enabled the identification of more optimal conditions for periplasmic production of recombinant proteins with disulfide bonds. The data was generated from two targets, a single chain antibody fragment (BL1) and human growth hormone (hGH), with four different signal peptides and a titratable rhamnose promoter-based system that enables the tuning of protein production rates. Across the screen conditions, the yields for both targets significantly varied, and the optimal signal peptide and rhamnose concentration differed for each protein. Under the optimal conditions, the periplasmic BL1 and hGH were properly folded and active. Our study underpins the importance of combinatorial screening approaches for addressing the requirements associated with the production of a recombinant protein in the periplasm.

Multidrug-Resistant Acinetobacter baumannii Chloramphenicol Resistance Requires an Inner Membrane Permease

Acinetobacter baumannii is a Gram-negative organism that is a cause of hospital-acquired multidrug-resistant (MDR) infections. A. baumannii has a unique cell surface compared to those of many other Gram-negative pathogens in that it can live without lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and it has a high content of cardiolipin in the outer membrane. Therefore, to better understand the cell envelope and mechanisms of MDR A. baumannii, we screened a transposon library for mutants with defective permeability barrier function, defined as a deficiency in the ability to exclude the phosphatase chromogenic substrate 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolylphosphate (XP). We identified multiple mutants with mutations in the ABUW_0982 gene, predicted to encode a permease broadly present in A. baumannii isolates with increased susceptibility to the ribosome-targeting antibiotic chloramphenicol (CHL). Moreover, compared to other known CHL resistance genes, such as chloramphenicol acyltransferase genes, we found that ABUW_0982 is the primary determinant of intrinsic CHL resistance in A. baumannii strain 5075 (Ab5075), an important isolate responsible for severe MDR infections in humans. Finally, studies measuring the efflux of chloramphenicol and expression of ABUW_0982 in CHL-susceptible Escherichia coli support the conclusion that ABUW_0982 encodes a single-component efflux protein with specificity for small, hydrophobic molecules, including CHL.

Improving the Secretion Yield of the β-Galactosidase Bgal1-3 in Pichia pastoris for Use as a Potential Catalyst in the Production of Prebiotic-Enriched Milk

In this study, three kinds of milk were treated with the β-galactosidase Bgal1-3 (4 U/mL), resulting in 7.2-9.5 g/L galactooligosaccharides (GOS) at a lactose conversion of 90-95%. Then, Bgal1-3 was secreted from Pichia pastoris X33 under the direction of an α-factor signal peptide. After cultivation for 144 h in a flask culture with shaking, the extracellular activity of Bgal1-3 was 4.4 U/mL. Five more signal peptides (HFBI, apre, INU1A, MF4I, and W1) were employed to direct the secretion, giving rise to a more efficient signal peptide, W1 (11.2 U/mL). To further improve the secretion yield, recombinant strains harboring two copies of the bgal1-3 gene were constructed, improving the extracellular activity to 22.6 U/mL (about 440 mg/L). This study successfully constructed an engineered strain for the production of the β-galactosidase Bgal1-3, which is a promising catalyst in the preparation of prebiotic-enriched milk.

Site-saturation mutagenesis of mutant l-asparaginase II signal peptide hydrophobic region for improved excretion of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase

The excretion of cyclodextrin glucanotransferase (CGTase) into the culture medium offers significant advantages over cytoplasmic expression. However, the limitation of Escherichia coli is its inability to excrete high amount of CGTase outside the cells. In this study, modification of the hydrophobic region of the N1R3 signal peptide using site-saturation mutagenesis improved the excretion of CGTase. Signal peptide mutants designated M9F, V10L and A15Y enhanced the excretion of CGTase three-fold and demonstrated two-fold higher secretion rate than the wild type. However, high secretion rate of these mutants was non-productive for recombinant protein production because it caused up to a seven-fold increase in cell death compared to the wild type. Our results indicated that the excretion of CGTase is highly dependent on hydrophobicity, secondary conformation and the type and position of amino acids at the region boundary and core segment of the h-region.

Enhancing full-length antibody production by signal peptide engineering

Background

Protein secretion to the periplasm of Escherichia coli offers an attractive route for producing heterologous proteins including antibodies. In this approach, a signal peptide is fused to the N-terminus of the heterologous protein. The signal peptide mediates translocation of the heterologous protein from the cytoplasm to the periplasm and is cleaved during the translocation process. It was previously shown that optimization of the translation initiation region (TIR) which overlaps with the nucleotide sequence of the signal sequence improves the production of heterologous proteins. Despite the progress, there is still room to improve yields using secretion as a means to produce protein complexes such as full-length monoclonal antibodies (mAbs).

Results

In this study we identified the inefficient secretion of heavy chain as the limitation for full-length mAb accumulation in the periplasm. To improve heavy chain secretion we investigated the effects of various signal peptides at controlled TIR strengths. The signal peptide of disulfide oxidoreductase (DsbA) mediated more efficient secretion of heavy chain than the other signal peptides tested. Mutagenesis studies demonstrated that at controlled translational levels, hydrophobicity of the hydrophobic core (H-region) of the signal peptide is a critical factor for heavy chain secretion and full-length mAb accumulation in the periplasm. Increasing the hydrophobicity of a signal peptide enhanced heavy chain secretion and periplasmic levels of assembled full-length mAbs, while decreasing the hydrophobicity had the opposite effect.

Conclusions

This study demonstrates that under similar translational strengths, the hydrophobicity of the signal peptide plays an important role in heavy chain secretion. Increasing the hydrophobicity of the H-region and controlling TIR strengths can serve as an approach to improve heavy chain secretion and full-length mAb production in E. coli.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12934-016-0445-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Recognition of a signal peptide by the signal recognition particle

Targeting of proteins to appropriate sub-cellular compartments is a crucial process in all living cells. Secretory and membrane proteins usually contain an N-terminal signal peptide, which is recognised by the signal recognition particle (SRP) when nascent polypeptide chains emerge from the ribosome. The SRP-ribosome nascent chain complex is then targeted through its GTP-dependent interaction with SRP-receptor to the protein-conducting channel on endoplasmic reticulum membrane in eukaryotes or plasma membrane in bacteria. A universally conserved component of SRP1, 2, SRP54 or its bacterial homolog, fifty-four homolog (Ffh), binds the signal peptides which have a highly divergent sequence divisible into a positively charged n-region, an h-region commonly containing 8-20 hydrophobic residues and a polar c-region 3-5. No structure has been reported that exemplified SRP54 binding of any signal sequence. We have produced a fusion protein between Sulfolobus solfataricus SRP54 and a signal peptide connected via a flexible linker. This fusion protein oligomerises in solution, through interaction between the SRP54 and signal peptide moieties belonging to different chains, and it is functional, able to bind SRP RNA and SRP-receptor FtsY. Here we present the crystal structure at 3.5 Å resolution of an SRP54-signal peptide complex in the dimer, which reveals how a signal sequence is recognised by SRP54.

Alteration in the IL-2 signal peptide affects secretion of proteinsin vitro andin vivo

BACKGROUND

Although hundreds of different signal peptides have now been identified, few studies have examined the factors enabling signal peptides to augment secretion of mature proteins. Signal peptides, located at the N-terminus of nascent secreted proteins, characteristically have three domains: (1) a basic domain at the N-terminus, (2) a central hydrophobic core, and (3) a carboxy-terminal cleavage region. In this study, we investigated whether alterations in the basic and/or the hydrophobic domains of a commonly used signal peptide from interleukin-2 (IL-2) affected secretion of two proteins: placental alkaline phosphatase (AP) and endostatin.

METHODS

A series of modifications in the basic and/or hydrophobic domains of the IL-2 signal peptide were made by polymerase chain reaction with endostatin or AP plasmids as templates. Transfection of wild-type or modified IL-2 signal peptides fused in-frame with endostatin or AP were done with Superfect in vitro or by the hydrodynamic method in vivo.

RESULTS

Increasing both the basicity and hydrophobicity of the signal peptide augmented the secretion of AP and endostatin by approximately 2.5- and 3.5-fold, respectively, from MDA-MB-435 cells in vitro. Over a range of DNA concentrations and times, the most effective IL-2 signal peptide increased AP levels in the medium compared to the wild-type IL-2 signal peptide. Comparable results from these modified IL-2 signal peptides were found to increase AP levels in the medium from bovine aortic endothelial cells. Moreover, the combined changes in basic and hydrophobic domains of the IL-2 signal peptide augmented serum levels of endostatin and placental AP by 3-fold when the optimal plasmid constructs were injected in vivo.

CONCLUSIONS

Modification of the IL-2 signal peptide augments protein secretion both in vitro and in vivo. As a result, optimizing the signal peptide should be considered for increasing the therapeutic levels of secreted proteins.

Is Ffh required for export of secretory proteins?

In Escherichia coli, protein export from the cytoplasm may occur via the signal recognition particle (SRP)-dependent pathway or the Sec-dependent pathway. Membrane proteins utilize the SRP-dependent route, whereas many secretory proteins use the cytoplasmic Sec machinery. To examine the possibility that signal peptide hydrophobicity governs which targeting route is utilized, we used a series of PhoA signal sequence mutants which vary only by incremental hydrophobicity changes. We show that depletion of SRP, but not trigger factor, affects all the mutants examined. These results suggest secretory proteins with a variety of signal sequences, as well as membrane proteins, require SRP for export.

Dopamine beta-monooxygenase signal/anchor sequence alters trafficking of peptidylglycine alpha-hydroxylating monooxygenase

Dopamine beta-monooxygenase (DBM) and peptidylglycine alpha-hydroxylating monooxygenase (PHM) are essential for the biosynthesis of catecholamines and amidated peptides, respectively. The enzymes share a conserved catalytic core. We studied the role of the DBM signal sequence by appending it to soluble PHM (PHMs) and expressing the DBMsignal/PHMs chimera in AtT-20 and Chinese hamster ovary cells. PHMs produced as part of DBMsignal/PHMs was active. In vitro translated and cellular DBMsignal/PHMs had similar masses, indicating that the DBM signal was not removed. DBMsignal/PHMs was membrane-associated and had the properties of an intrinsic membrane protein. After in vitro translation in the presence of microsomal membranes, trypsin treatment removed 2 kDa from DBMsignal/PHMs while PHMs was entirely protected. In addition, a Cys residue in DBMsignal/PHMs was accessible to Cys-directed biotinylation. Thus the chimera adopts the topology of a type II membrane protein. Pulse-chase experiments indicate that DBMsignal/PHMs turns over rapidly after exiting the trans-Golgi network. Although PHMs is efficiently localized to secretory granules, DBMsignal/PHMs is largely localized to the endoplasmic reticulum in AtT-20 cells. On the basis of stimulated secretion, the small amount of PHMs generated is stored in secretory granules. In contrast, the expression of DBMsignal/PHMs in PC12 cells yields protein that is localized to secretory granules.

An artificial transmembrane segment directs SecA, SecB, and electrochemical potential-dependent translocation of a long amino-terminal tail

Many integral membrane proteins contain an amino-terminal segment, often referred to as an N-tail, that is translocated across a membrane. In many cases, translocation of the N-tail is initiated by a cleavable, amino-terminal signal peptide. For N-tail proteins lacking a signal peptide, translocation is initiated by a transmembrane segment that is carboxyl to the translocated segment. The mechanism of membrane translocation of these segments, although poorly understood, has been reported to be independent of the protein secretion machinery. In contrast, here we describe alkaline phosphatase mutants containing artificial transmembrane segments that demonstrate that translocation of a long N-tail across the membrane is dependent upon SecA, SecB, and the electrochemical potential in the absence of a signal peptide. The corresponding mutants containing signal peptides also use the secretion machinery but are less sensitive to inhibition of its components. We present evidence that inhibition of SecA by sodium azide is incomplete even at high concentrations of inhibitor, which suggests why SecA-dependent translocation may not have been detected in other systems. Furthermore, by varying the charge around the transmembrane segment, we find that in the absence of a signal peptide, the orientation of the membrane-bound alkaline phosphatase is dictated by the positive inside rule. However, the presence of a signal peptide is an overriding factor in membrane orientation and renders all mutants in an Nout-Cin orientation.

Triplet repeat variability in the signal peptide sequence of the Xmrk receptor tyrosine kinase gene in Xiphophorus fish

Trinucleotide repeats in several human genes have been found to undergo spontaneous variation in repeat numbers in succeeding generations. Expansion of the repeat beyond a certain length causes specific pathological disorders. So far, a naturally occurring triplet repeat instability of transcribed sequences has been reported only from humans. However, the signal peptide encoding region of the receptor tyrosine kinase gene Xmrk from fish of the genus Xiphophorus contains a CTG repeat that differs in length even between closely related individuals. The consequence of this variability is signal peptides with shorter or longer hydrophobic core regions reaching, in some individuals, the critical maximum length for functional protein export or even exceeding it. In one stock, animals that are homozygous for such an allele were extremely rare, indicating that the triplet repeat length variability of the Xmrk gene of Xiphophorus may indeed have an influence on the function of the gene product and, under certain conditions, may affect the fitness of the individual.

Conformational and topological requirements of cell-permeable peptide function

Cell-permeable peptide import recently was developed to deliver synthetic peptides into living cells for studying intracellular protein functions. This import process is mediated by an N-terminal carrier sequence which is the hydrophobic region of a signal peptide. In this study, the conformational consequence of the interaction of cell-permeable peptides with different mimetic membrane environments was investigated by circular dichroism analysis. We showed that cell-permeable peptides adopted alpha-helical structures in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles or aqueous trifluoroethanol (TFE). The potency of these peptides in forming helical structures is higher in an amphiphilic environment (SDS) than in a hydrophobic environment (TFE), suggesting that some hydrophilic molecules associated with the cell membrane may be involved in peptide import. We also studied topological requirements of cell-permeable peptide function. We demonstrated that peptides containing the carrier sequence in their C-termini can also be imported into cells efficiently. This important discovery can avoid repetitious synthesis of the membrane-translocating sequence for peptides with different functional cargoes and is potentially useful for developing a cell-permeable peptide library. Finally, we showed that, when a retro version of the carrier sequence was used, the peptide lost its translocating ability despite retaining a high content of alpha-helical structure in mimetic membrane environments. This suggests that the propensity of peptides to adopt a helical conformation is required but not sufficient for cellular import and that other structural factors such as the side-chain topology of the carrier sequence are also important. Our studies together contribute to the more rational design of useful cell-permeable peptides.

Identification of a sequence motif that confers SecB dependence on a SecB-independent secretory protein in vivo

SecB is a cytosolic chaperone which facilitates the transport of a subset of proteins, including membrane proteins such as PhoE and LamB and some periplasmic proteins such as maltose-binding protein, in Escherichia coli. However, not all proteins require SecB for transport, and proteins such as ribose-binding protein are exported efficiently even in SecB-null strains. The characteristics which confer SecB dependence on some proteins but not others have not been defined. To determine the sequence characteristics that are responsible for the SecB requirement, we have inserted a systematic series of short, polymeric sequences into the SecB-independent protein alkaline phosphatase (PhoA). The extent to which these simple sequences convert alkaline phosphatase into a SecB-requiring protein was evaluated in vivo. Using this approach we have examined the roles of the polarity and charge of the sequence, as well as its location within the mature region, in conferring SecB dependence. We find that an insert with as few as 10 residues, of which 3 are basic, confers SecB dependence and that the mutant protein is efficiently exported in the presence of SecB. Remarkably, the basic motifs caused the protein to be translocated in a strict membrane potential-dependent fashion, indicating that the membrane potential is not a barrier to, but rather a requirement for, translocation of the motif. The alkaline phosphatase mutants most sensitive to the loss of SecB are those most sensitive to inhibition of SecA via azide treatment, consistent with the necessity for formation of a preprotein-SecB-SecA complex. Furthermore, the impact of the basic motif depends on location within the mature protein and parallels the accessibility of the location to the secretion apparatus.

The hydrophobic domains in the carboxyl-terminal signal for GPI modification and in the amino-terminal leader peptide have similar structural requirements

Proteins having a glycosyl-phosphatidylinositol (GPI) membrane anchor are synthesized with a carboxyl-terminal signal that is cleaved in the endoplasmic reticulum prior to GPI modification. The signal is characterized by a moderately hydrophobic domain downstream from the cleavage/modification site. The essential features of this domain were characterized using a truncated version of folate receptor (FR) type beta (FR-beta delta 5) in which its five carboxyl-terminal amino acid residues were deleted without affecting the efficiency of GPI modification. The amino acids at various positions in the hydrophobic domain were systematically altered and the extent of GPI modification of the recombinant proteins was determined by measuring [3H]folic acid binding at the cell surface, by Western blot analysis and from the sensitivity of the proteins to phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC). The results indicate that a threshold level of hydrophobicity exists at a single position below which the efficiency of GPI modification decreases with increasing hydrophilicity. Further, the hydrophobic domain is characterized by a hydrophobicity profile and not merely a minimum overall hydrophobicity. Thus, a leucine-rich core hydrophobic segment of six to eight amino acid residues is more sensitive to relatively small hydrophilic substitutions compared to its flanking regions and such mutations could be compensated by a hydrophobic substitution elsewhere within this core segment. Such a hydrophobicity profile is characteristic of the amino-terminal leader peptide. When the entire hydrophobic domain of the leader peptide of FR-beta (12 amino acid residues) was substituted with the hydrophobic domain of the GPI signal (13 amino acids), it was possible to obtain expression of FR-beta on the cell surface. In this construct, point mutations in the core hydrophobic segment and in the flanking regions within the substituting peptide produced a similar pattern of effects on the cell surface receptor expression compared to the corresponding mutations in the GPI signal of FR-beta. The results suggest that common principles may govern interactions of the hydrophobic domains of the GPI signal and the leader peptide with the endoplasmic reticulum.

The hydrophobic region of signal peptides is involved in the interaction with membrane-bound SecA

The positive charges of signal peptides are important for the interaction with SecA, a translocation ATPase. To examine whether or not the hydrophobic region of signal peptides also interacts with SecA, we constructed model preproteins, proOmpF-Lpps, possessing no positively charged amino acid residues at the amino-terminus and different numbers of alanine/leucine residues in the hydrophobic region of signal peptides. When the hydrophobic stretch was sufficiently long, amino-terminal positively charged residues were not required for the translocation of preproteins across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli both in vitro and in vivo. Chemical cross-linking between SecA and preproteins possessing no positively charged residues at the amino-terminus was observed only in the presence of liposomes containing acidic phospholipids. The degree of cross-linking increased as the length of the hydrophobic stretch increased irrespective of whether positively charged residues were present or not. A preprotein possessing no positively charged residues at the amino-terminus, which is competent in the presence of liposomes, competitively inhibited the cross-linking of wild-type proOmpF-Lpp with SecA under the same conditions. It is concluded that both the amino-terminal positive charges and central hydrophobic domains are involved in the interaction with SecA in the initial stage of translocation in addition to their possible roles in transmembrane movement of preproteins.

Cloning and sequencing of the gene encoding the high potential iron-sulfur protein (HiPIP) from the purple sulfur bacterium Chromatium vinosum

The gene encoding the high potential iron-sulfur protein (HiPIP) of Chromatium vinosum strain D (DSM 180T) was cloned from an EcoRI-HindIII digest of genomic DNA. A nucleotide sequence of 648 bp length was determined which contained the coding region and putative promoter and termination sites. The gene codes for a 122 residue 12761 Da protein. The C-terminal 85 residues are those of the previously biochemically determined sequence, whereas the N-terminal 37 residues constitute a leader peptide which shows characteristics of the double arginine signal sequences of complex cofactor containing periplasmic proteins.

Competition between functional signal peptides demonstrates variation in affinity for the secretion pathway

We have developed a system for examining the relative affinity of two different signal peptides for the protein secretion pathway in Escherichia coli. This system involves the expression of a modified alkaline phosphatase which possesses two signal peptides arranged in tandem. When both signal peptides have the wild-type sequence, cleavage after the first and cleavage after the second occur with nearly equal frequency. In both cases the remainder of the protein is transported to the periplasm. Thus both signal peptides effectively compete with each other for entrance to the secretion pathway. When the hydrophobicity of the second signal peptide is altered by small increments, we find that the more hydrophobic signal peptide is preferentially utilized. Thus, a more hydrophobic signal peptide can outcompete even an efficient wild-type signal sequence. The crossover point, for utilization of the second to the first signal peptide, is marked and occurs over a very small change in hydrophobicity. Our results suggest that the small differences in the hydrophobicity of wild-type signal peptides may have critical consequences: preproteins with the more hydrophobic signals could dominate one pathway, leaving those with only slightly less hydrophobic signals to require additional factors such as chaperonins, SecB, and other binding proteins.

The amino-terminal charge and core region hydrophobicity interdependently contribute to the function of signal sequences

We have constructed a series of signal sequence mutants that contain negatively charged amino termini and simplified core regions of varying hydrophobicity levels. This series provides a means of exploring the relative roles of the amino terminus and the hydrophobic core region during transport. The signal peptides with highly hydrophobic core regions support a rapid rate of transport in the presence of a negatively charged amino terminus. We have found that these negatively charged mutants are secreted in a manner similar to the wild-type signal sequence; sodium azide and carbonyl cyanide 3-chlorophenylhydrazone treatments indicate that the negatively charged mutants depend on SecA and the protonmotive force, respectively. These same mutants also demonstrate reduced competition with coexpressed beta-lactamase, reflecting the lower overall affinity for the transport pathway due to the net negative charge at the amino terminus. In addition, the pronounced effects of introducing three negative charges support the conclusion that the two regions function in a concerted manner.

Protein transport via amino-terminal targeting sequences: common themes in diverse systems

Many proteins that are synthesized in the cytoplasm of cells are ultimately found in non-cytoplasmic locations. The correct targeting and transport of proteins must occur across bacterial cell membranes, the endoplasmic reticulum membrane, and those of mitochondria and chloroplasts. One unifying feature among transported proteins in these systems is the requirement for an amino-terminal targeting signal. Although the primary sequence of targeting signals varies substantially, many patterns involving overall properties are shared. A recent surge in the identification of components of the transport apparatus from many different systems has revealed that these are also closely related. In this review we describe some of the key components of different transport systems and highlight these common features.

Physical and conformational properties of synthetic idealized signal sequences parallel their biological function

Transported proteins often contain an extension sequence called the signal peptide. The alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) signal sequence represents a typical signal peptide for comparison to idealized sequences both in vivo and in vitro. We have designed a series of idealized signal sequences which vary in amino terminal charge and core region hydrophobicity with minimal variation in amino acid composition. The idealized core regions contain different proportions of leucine and alanine residues, effectively producing hydrophobicities above and below the threshold level required for efficient secretion. The flanking amino and carboxyl termini were designed to maintain the general features and relative hydrophobicity of their counterparts in the wild-type PhoA signal sequence. Using the phoA gene, the signal peptide region was modified to generate mutants corresponding to the model sequences. Transport studies in Escherichia coli confirmed that completely idealized signal sequences, which lack a helix-breaking proline or glycine residue, can be functional if the core region is sufficiently hydrophobic and that one positively charged residue in the amino terminus is adequate for efficient transport. The corresponding peptides were chemically synthesized and exhibited HPLC retention times that reflect the relative hydrophobicities of the sequences. Structural analyses of the isolated peptides by circular dichroism demonstrate solvent dependence and exceptionally stable alpha-helix formation by the functional signal peptides in trifluoroethanol. Although leucine and alanine residues are often predicted to have similar propensities for forming an alpha-helix, considerably higher alpha-helical content is observed in the signal peptides which contain predominantly polyleucine core regions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Artificial transmembrane segments. Requirements for stop transfer and polypeptide orientation

Transmembrane segments of proteins generally consist of a long stretch of hydrophobic amino acids, which can function to initiate membrane insertion (start-stop sequences), initiate translocation (signal-anchor sequences), or stop further translocation of the following polypeptide chain (stop-transfer sequences). In this study, we have taken Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase, a transported and water-soluble protein, and examined the requirements for converting it into a transmembrane protein with particular orientation. Since the wild type enzyme is transported, there is no predisposition against membrane translocation, yet it is not a membrane protein, so it does not possess any intrinsic membrane topogenic preferences. A series of potential transmembrane segments was introduced into an internal position of the enzyme to test the ability of each to initiate translocation, stop translocation, and adopt a particular orientation. For this purpose, cassette mutagenesis was used to incorporate new structural segments composed of polymers of alanines and leucines. The threshold value of hydrophobicity required to function as a stop-transfer sequence was determined. For a transmembrane segment of typical length (21 residues), this value is equivalent to the hydrophobicity of 16 alanines and 5 leucines. Interestingly, much shorter segments will also suffice to stop translocation, but these must be composed of more highly hydrophobic residues (e.g. 11 leucines). When the wild type amino-terminal signal peptide is deleted or made dysfunctional, sufficiently hydrophobic internal segments can initiate translocation of the following polypeptide and function as a signal anchor. Furthermore, in so doing, the orientation of the protein is changed from N(out)-C(in) to N(in)-C(out).

Inverse relationship of cotranslational translocation with the hydrophobic moment of the bovine preproparathyroid hormone signal sequence

To investigate the dependence of transmembrane translocation on the hydrophobic moment of the hydrophobic core of the preproparathyroid hormone signal sequence, amino acids were switched to maximize or minimize the hydrophobic moment without changing the length or overall hydrophobicity of the core. As assayed in an in vitro translation system with microsomal membranes, the efficiency of translocation of these mutants was inversely related to the hydrophobic moment, indicating the hydrophobic moment or a related property may contribute to translocational activity.

Effect of alteration of charged residues at the N termini of signal peptides on protein export in Bacillus subtilis

The role of positively charged residues at the N termini of signal peptides in protein export has been studied in Bacillus subtilis. Bacillus signal peptides (alkaline protease [Apr] and neutral protease [Npr] from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens) were altered and fused to mature levansucrase (Lvs). The effects of the various alterations on the export of Lvs in B. subtilis were determined. The replacement of positively charged residues with neutral residues in both Apr and Npr signal peptides resulted in a slight defect in the export of Lvs from B. subtilis. Introduction of a negatively charged residue (aspartic acid) at the N terminus of Npr signal peptide blocked the export of Lvs. However, Apr signal peptide with a net charge of -3 (three aspartic acid residues) was still functional.

Signal peptides: exquisitely designed transport promoters

Prokaryotic proteins destined for transport out of the cytoplasm typically contain an N-terminal extension sequence, called the signal peptide, which is required for export. It is evident that many secretory proteins utilize a common export system, yet the signal sequences themselves display very little primary sequence homology. In attempting to understand how different signal peptides are able to promote protein secretion through the same pathway, the physical features of natural signal sequences have been extensively examined for similarities that might play a part in function. Experimental data have confirmed statistical analyses which highlighted dominant features of natural signal sequences in Escherichia coli: a net positive charge in the N-terminus increases efficiency of transport; the core region must maintain a threshold level of hydrophobicity within a range of length limitations; the central portion adopts an alpha-helical conformation in hydrophobic environments; and the signal cleavage region is ideally six residues long, with small side-chain amino acids in the -1 and -3 positions. This review focuses on the parallels between signal peptide physical features and their functions, which emerge when the results of a variety of experimental approaches are combined. The requirement for each property may be ascribed to a potential interaction that is critical for efficient protein export. The summation of the key physical features produces signal peptides with the flexibility to function in multiple roles in order to expedite secretion. In this way, nature has indeed evolved exquisitely tuned signal sequences.

Signal peptide hydrophobicity is finely tailored for function

In order to titrate the dependence of individual steps in protein transport on signal peptide hydrophobicity, we have examined a series of mutants which involve replacement of the hydrophobic core segment of the Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase signal peptide. The core regions vary in composition from 10:0 to 0:10 in the ratio of alanine to leucine residues. Thus, a nonfunctional polyalanine-containing signal peptide is titrated with the more hydrophobic residue, leucine. Analysis of this series identified a midpoint for rapid precursor processing between alanine to leucine ratios of 6:4 and 5:5 [Doud et al. (1993): Biochemistry 32:1251-1256]. Examination of precursors that are processed more slowly indicates a lower limit of signal peptide hydrophobicity that permits membrane association and translocation. Analysis of precursors that are processed rapidly defines an intermediate range of hydrophobicity that is optimum; above this level precursors become insensitive to transport inhibitors such as sodium azide and carbonyl cyanide 3-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) in parallel with substantial inhibition of beta-lactamase processing. Our data indicate that there is a surprisingly narrow range of signal peptide hydrophobicity which both supports transport of the protein to which it is attached and which does not have such a high affinity for the transport pathway that it disrupts the appropriate balance of other secreted proteins.

Conformational behavior of Escherichia coli OmpA signal peptides in membrane mimetic environments

Nuclear magnetic resonance and circular dichroism (CD) studies of isolated peptides corresponding to WT and mutant OmpA signal sequences are reported; all of the peptides adopt substantial amounts of alpha-helical structure both in 1:1 (v/v) trifluoroethanol (TFE)/water and in sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) micelles. In TFE/water, the helix begins after the positively charged N-terminal residues and is most stable in the hydrophobic core, which correlates with results obtained previously for other signal sequences. The helix is weaker between the hydrophobic core and the C-terminus; such a break in the helix appears to be common to other signal peptides studied previously and could be of functional importance. No clear correlation could be established between the helicity of the peptides in TFE/water and their in vivo activities. All the peptides have a higher alpha-helix content in SDS than in TFE/water, and there is a good correlation between helix content in SDS and in vivo activity. Helicity in SDS for the functional peptides increases both at the N-terminus and in the hydrophobic core, and is driven by a strong association of the core with the hydrophobic chains of the detergent. The extension of the helix toward the N-terminus may be a result of neutralization of the N-terminal positive charges by the headgroups of the micelles, which removes unfavorable electrostatic interactions with the helix dipole. All these comparisons were facilitated by the use of upfield shifts of H alpha protons in helical regions relative to random coil chemical shifts, which also yielded estimates of helical content that correlated well with the CD results.

Titration of protein transport activity by incremental changes in signal peptide hydrophobicity

A systematic series of mutants has been generated which provides a means for titrating the dependence of protein transport activity on signal peptide hydrophobicity. These mutants involve replacement of the hydrophobic core segment of the Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase signal peptide while maintaining the natural amino- and carboxyl-terminal segments and the overall length. The new core regions vary in composition from 10:0 to 0:10 in the ratio of alanine to leucine residues. Thus, a nonfunctional polyalanine-containing signal peptide is titrated with the more hydrophobic residue, leucine. Using precursor processing to quantify transport activity, we observe a clear, nonlinear dependence on hydrophobicity. At ratios of alanine to leucine of less than or equal to 8:2, the signal peptide is essentially nonfunctional; at ratios greater than or equal to 3:7, the signal peptide functions efficiently. The midpoint is between alanine to leucine ratios of 6:4 and 5:5. Signal peptides with hydrophobicity just below the midpoint show substantial, additional precursor processing over time while the others do not. The data are consistent with a simple model involving a two-state equilibrium between the untransported and transported species and a change in the delta G of -0.85 kcal/mol for every alanine to leucine conversion.

Characterization of the secretion efficiency of a plant signal peptide in Bacillus subtilis

The ability of the Bacillus subtilis secretion machinery to interact with a heterologous signal peptide was studied using a plant (wheat alpha-amylase) signal peptide. The plant signal peptide was capable of mediating secretion of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase and B. amyloliquefaciens levansucrase from B. subtilis. This secretion was dependent on the plant signal peptide, as deletion of five amino acids from the hydrophobic core resulted in a block of secretion. Attempts to improve the efficiency of the plant signal peptide in B. subtilis were made by increasing the length of the hydrophobic core from 10 to 16 residues by insertion of 2, 4, 5 or 6 amino acids. None of the alterations improved the secretion efficiency relative to the wild-type plant signal peptide.

Production of an enzymatically inactive analog of phospholipase D from Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis

The gene pld, encoding the phospholipase D (PLD) of Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis, was mutagenized using formic acid and then expressed in Escherichia coli. Mutagenesis was targeted at the coding region of pld, so as to produce only one or a limited number of point mutations. Transformants were screened for the enzymatic and immunological properties of their PLD products. One clone was found to produce a protein which was enzymatically inactive, but which was comparable to the wild-type PLD in size and antigenicity. The sequence of the pld mutant revealed a single base change. As a consequence, the codon for His20 was converted to Tyr. These results suggest that His20 forms part of the active site of the PLD molecule. If this protein is immunogenic in sheep, it would form the basis of a genetically inactivated vaccine.

Signal sequences containing multiple aromatic residues

Using homopolymeric units of either phenylalanine or tryptophan to replace the natural core segment of the Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase signal peptide, the hydrophobicity requirements for protein export and processing were further explored. The mutant signal peptide containing polyphenylalanine functioned at least as efficiently as the wild-type, while the signal incorporating polytryptophan was dysfunctional. The transport properties of these mutants confirm our work with sequences rich in aliphatic residues; namely that a high mean hydrophobicity per residue is critical for complete and rapid precursor processing and for translocation of the protein. The efficient transport properties of the polyphenylalanine-containing signal peptide demonstrate that neither the bulky, aromatic nature of phenylalanine nor the unusually high hydrophobicity of this mutant peptide adversely alters function. This study also suggests that the low occurrence of phenylalanine in natural signal sequences is not of functional consequence but probably reflects the low number of DNA codons for this residue. The polytryptophan-containing precursor was membrane inserted but not translocated. This type of transport defect suggests that this is a weakly hydrophobic signal peptide, consistent with hydropathy scales, which indicate that tryptophan is comparable to alanine. This application of polymeric sequences provides a function-based assay for the evaluation of amino acid hydrophobicity.

The signal sequence of the p62 protein of Semliki Forest virus is involved in initiation but not in completing chain translocation

So far it has been demonstrated that the signal sequence of proteins which are made at the ER functions both at the level of protein targeting to the ER and in initiation of chain translocation across the ER membrane. However, its possible role in completing the process of chain transfer (see Singer, S. J., P. A. Maher, and M. P. Yaffe. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 1987. 84:1015-1019) has remained elusive. In this work we show that the p62 protein of Semliki Forest virus contains an uncleaved signal sequence at its NH2-terminus and that this becomes glycosylated early during synthesis and translocation of the p62 polypeptide. As the glycosylation of the signal sequence most likely occurs after its release from the ER membrane our results suggest that this region has no role in completing the transfer process.

Function of Semliki Forest virus E3 peptide in virus assembly: replacement of E3 with an artificial signal peptide abolishes spike heterodimerization and surface expression of E1

The Semliki Forest virus spike glycoproteins E1 and p62 form a heterodimeric complex in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and are transported as such to the cell surface. In the mature virus particle, the heterodimeric association of E1 and E2 (the cleavage product of p62) is maintained, but as a more labile and acid-sensitive oligomer than the E1-p62 complex. The E3 peptide forms the N-terminal part of the p62 precursor and carries the signal for the translocation of p62 into the lumen of the ER. The question of whether E3 is also important in the formation and stabilization of the E1-p62 heterodimer has been addressed here with the aid of an E3 deletion mutant cDNA. In this construct, the entire E3 was replaced with a cleavable, artificial signal sequence which preserved the membrane topology of an authentic E2. The E3 deletion, when expressed via a recombinant vaccinia virus, abolished heterodimerization of the spike proteins. It also resulted in the complete retention of E1 in the ER and almost total inhibition of E2 transport to the plasma membrane. The oligomerization and transport defect of E1 expressed from the E3 deletion mutant could be complemented with a wild-type p62 provided from a separate coding unit in double infections. These results point to a central role of E3 in complex formation and transport of the viral structural components to the site of budding. In conjunction with earlier work (M. Lobigs and H. Garoff, J. Virol. 64:1233-1240, 1990; J. Wahlberg, W. A. M. Boere, and H. Garoff, J. Virol. 63:4991-4997, 1989), the data support a model of spike protein oligomerization control of Semliki Forest virus assembly and disassembly which may be mediated by the presence of E3 in the uncleaved p62 precursor and release of E3 after cleavage.

Signal peptide mutants of Escherichia coli

Numerous secretory proteins of the Gram-negative bacteria E. coli are synthesized as precursor proteins which require an amino terminal extension known as the signal peptide for translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane. Following translocation, the signal peptide is proteolytically cleaved from the precursor to produce the mature exported protein. Signal peptides do not exhibit sequence homology, but invariably share common structural features: (1) The basic amino acid residues positioned at the amino terminus of the signal peptide are probably involved in precursor protein binding to the cytoplasmic membrane surface. (2) A stretch of 10 to 15 nonpolar amino acid residues form a hydrophobic core in the signal peptide which can insert into the lipid bilayer. (3) Small residues capable of beta-turn formation are located at the cleavage site in the carboxyl terminus of the signal peptide. (4) Charge characteristics of the amino terminal region of the mature protein can also influence precursor protein export. A variety of mutations in each of the structurally distinct regions of the signal peptide have been constructed via site-directed mutagenesis or isolated through genetic selection. These mutants have shed considerable light on the structure and function of the signal peptide and are reviewed here.

Export of the periplasmic maltose-binding protein of Escherichia coli

The export of the maltose-binding protein (MBP), the malE gene product, to the periplasm of Escherichia coli cells has been extensively investigated. The isolation of strains synthesizing MalE-LacZ hybrid proteins led to a novel genetic selection for mutants that accumulate export-defective precursor MBP (preMBP) in the cytoplasm. The export defects were subsequently shown to result from alterations in the MBP signal peptide. Analysis of these and a variety of mutants obtained in other ways has provided considerable insight into the requirements for an optimally functional MBP signal peptide. This structure has been shown to have multiple roles in the export process, including promoting entry of preMBP into the export pathway and initiating MBP translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane. The latter has been shown to be a late event relative to synthesis and can occur entirely posttranslationally, even many minutes after the completion of synthesis. Translocation requires that the MBP polypeptide exist in an export-competent conformation that most likely represents an unfolded state that is not inhibitory to membrane transit. The signal peptide contributes to the export competence of preMBP by slowing the rate at which the attached mature moiety folds. In addition, preMBP folding is thought to be further retarded by the binding of a cytoplasmic protein, SecB, to the mature moiety of nascent preMBP. In cells lacking this antifolding factor, MBP export represents a race between delivery of newly synthesized, export-competent preMBP to the translocation machinery in the cytoplasmic membrane and folding of preMBP into an export-incompetent conformation. SecB is one of three E. coli proteins classified as "molecular chaperones" by their ability to stabilize precursor proteins for membrane translocation.