Epitope mapping of factor VIII inhibitor antibodies of Chinese origin

Phage display broadly identifies inhibitor-reactive regions in von Willebrand factor

BACKGROUND

Correction of von Willebrand factor (VWF) deficiency with replacement products containing VWF can lead to the development of anti-VWF alloantibodies (i.e., VWF inhibitors) in patients with severe von Willebrand disease (VWD).

OBJECTIVE

Locate inhibitor-reactive regions within VWF using phage display.

METHODS

We screened a phage library displaying random, overlapping fragments covering the full-length VWF protein sequence for binding to a commercial anti-VWF antibody or to immunoglobulins from three type 3 VWD patients who developed VWF inhibitors in response to treatment with plasma-derived VWF. Immunoreactive phage clones were identified and quantified by next-generation DNA sequencing (NGS).

RESULTS

Next-generation DNA sequencing markedly increased the number of phages analyzed for locating immunoreactive regions within VWF following a single round of selection and identified regions not recognized in previous reports using standard phage display methods. Extending this approach to characterize VWF inhibitors from three type 3 VWD patients (including two siblings homozygous for the same VWF gene deletion) revealed patterns of immunoreactivity distinct from the commercial antibody and between unrelated patients, though with notable areas of overlap. Alloantibody reactivity against the VWF propeptide is consistent with incomplete removal of the propeptide from plasma-derived VWF replacement products.

CONCLUSION

These results demonstrate the utility of phage display and NGS to characterize diverse anti-VWF antibody reactivities.

Molecular Mechanisms of Inhibitor Development in Hemophilia

The development of neutralizing antibodies in hemophilia is a serious complication of factor replacement therapy. These antibodies, also known as “inhibitors”, significantly increase morbidity within the hemophilia population and lower the quality of life for these patients. People with severe hemophilia A have an overall 25–40% lifetime risk of inhibitor development, compared to that of 5–15% lifetime risk in those with moderate/mild hemophilia A. The risk is lower in hemophilia B population (about 1–5%) and occurrence of inhibitors is almost only seen in patients with severe hemophilia B. The understanding of the pathophysiological mechanism leading to the development of inhibitors in patients with hemophilia has improved considerably over the last 2 decades. Identification of early biomarkers which predict inhibitor development in previously untreated patients with hemophilia will assist in risk identification and possible early intervention strategies. In this review, we aim to summarize the molecular mechanisms of inhibitor development in hemophilia and to identify potential areas in need of further investigation.

FVIII inhibitors: pathogenesis and avoidance

The pathogenesis of inhibitory antibodies has been the focus of major scientific interest over the last decades, and several studies on underlying immune mechanisms and risk factors for formation of these antibodies have been performed with the aim of improving the ability to both predict and prevent their appearance. It seems clear that the decisive factors for the immune response to the deficient factor are multiple and involve components of both a constitutional and therapy-related nature. A scientific concern and obstacle for research in the area of hemophilia is the relatively small cohorts available for studies and the resulting risk of confounded and biased results. Careful interpretation of data is recommended to avoid treatment decisions based on a weak scientific platform. This review will summarize current concepts of the underlying immunological mechanisms and risk factors for development of inhibitory antibodies in patients with hemophilia A and discuss how these findings may be interpreted and influence our clinical management of patients.

Mapping of FVIII inhibitor epitopes using cellulose-bound synthetic peptide arrays

Epitope mapping using antibodies against factor VIII (FVIII) has been performed using blotting techniques with truncated and/or digested FVIII molecules. Here, we focused on the precise mapping of affinity purified IgG from patients with an immune response against blood clotting FVIII using synthetic peptide arrays on cellulose membranes comprising the entire sequence of FVIII. The aim was to elucidate the epitope profile from different inhibitors and possibly detect new epitopes, which have not been described before. The epitope patterns from five patients showed reactivity with all domains in the FVIII molecule, but were different between various patients. These results included epitopes usually buried within the folded protein. However, in competition assays using FVIII as competitive agent in a mixture with inhibitor IgG, the most immunogenic regions were located in the FVIII light chain. Our results show that the C1 domain was the region with highest immunogenicity in all patients. Here, we demonstrate that the SPOT method is very well suited for the precise location of epitopes in the core of the protein, which usually cannot be detected by other methods.

T cell recognition of the A2 domain of coagulation factor VIII in hemophilia patients and healthy subjects

Hemophilia A patients treated with coagulation factor VIII (FVIII), and also some healthy subjects, may develop anti-FVIII antibodies (Ab), whose synthesis is driven by FVIII-specific CD4+ T cells. Some Ab block the procoagulant function of FVIII (inhibitors). Many inhibitors recognize epitopes on the FVIII A2 domain. Here, we have sought to identify A2 epitopes recognized by CD4+ T cells. We tested the proliferative response of CD4+ blood lymphocytes (BL) from hemophilia patients and healthy subjects, to overlapping synthetic peptides spanning the A2 domain sequence. Many A2 peptides induced proliferative responses of CD4+ BL from one or more subjects. The peptide-induced responses were strongest in hemophilia patients with inhibitors, weakest in healthy subjects. A2 peptides comprising residues 371-400, 621-650 and 671-690 elicited frequent and strong responses in hemophilia A patients, and especially in those with inhibitors. Healthy subjects recognized frequently only the sequence 371-400. A three-dimensional model of the A2 domain suggests that these CD4+ epitope sequences have structural features typical of 'universal' CD4+ T epitopes.

Impact of inhibitor epitope profile on the neutralizing effect against plasma-derived and recombinant factor VIII concentrates in vitro

The inhibitory capacity of plasma samples from 24 patients with severe haemophilia A and high-responding inhibitors were evaluated in a concentrate-based assay using two plasma-derived (Haemate and Monoclate-P) and three recombinant (Helixate, Recombinate and ReFacto) factor VIII concentrates and correlated with the corresponding epitope profile. In most, but not all, inhibitor plasmas with a relatively low reactivity against the von Willebrand-containing product Haemate, the main epitopes were located in the FVIII light chain. The reactivities within the group of recombinant products varied in that the reactivity against the B-domain deleted ReFacto was in general higher than that against Recombinate and Helixate. This difference did not correlate with any particular epitope profile and indicates that the B-domain, type of formulation and/or purification procedures may have an impact on the inhibitor reactivity in vitro. The ratio between the inhibitor titres in the concentrate-based assay and the Bethesda assay was dependent on the inhibitor plasma and concentrate used. Taken together, our results show that the reactivity of inhibitor plasmas varies considerably between different FVIII concentrates and that it does not fully correlate with the epitope profile. Potential clinical implications of the observed differences in inhibitor reactivity are discussed.