Utility of hepatic iron index in American patients with hereditary hemochromatosis: a multicenter study

Hyperferritinemia and liver iron content determined with MRI: Reintroduction of the liver iron index

BACKGROUND

Hyperferritinemia is found in around 12 % of the general population. Analyzing the cause can be difficult. In case of doubt about the presence of major iron overload most guidelines advice to perform a MRI as a reliable non-invasive marker to measure liver iron concentration (LIC). In general, a LIC of ≥ 36 µmol/g dw is considered the be elevated however in hyperferritinemia associated with, for example, obesity or alcohol (over)consumption the LIC can be ≥ 36 µmol/g dw in abscence of major iron overload. So, unfortunately a clear cut-off value to differentiate iron overload from normal iron content is lacking. Previously the liver iron index (LII) (LIC measured in liver biopsy (LIC-b)/age (years)), was introduced to differentiate between patients with major (LII ≥ 2) and minor or no iron overload (LII < 2). Based on the good correlation between the LIC-b and LIC determined with MRI (LIC-MRI), our goal was to investigate whether a LII_MRI ≥ 2 is a good indicator of major iron overload, reflected by a significantly higher amount of iron needed to be mobilized to reach iron depletion.

METHODS

We compared the amount of mobilized iron to reach depletion and inflammation-related characteristics in two groups: LII-MRI ≥ 2 versus LII-MRI <2 in 92 hyperferritinemia patients who underwent HFE genotyping and MRI-LIC determination.

RESULTS

Significantly more iron needed to be mobilized to reach iron depletion in the LII ≥ 2 group (mean 4741, SD ± 4135 mg) versus the LII-MRI <2 group (mean 1340, SD ± 533 mg), P < 0.001. Furthermore, hyperferritinemia in LII-MRI < 2 patients was more often related to components of the metabolic syndrome while hyperferritinemia in LII-MRI ≥ 2 patients was more often related to HFE mutations. ROC curve analysis showed good performance of LII =2 as cut-off value. However the calculations showed that the optimal cut-off for the LII = 3.4.

CONCLUSION

The LII-MRI with a cut-off value of 2 is an effective method to differentiate major from minor iron overload in patients with hyperferritinemia. But the LII-MRI = 3.4 seems a more promising diagnostic test for major iron overload.

Serum or plasma ferritin concentration as an index of iron deficiency and overload

BACKGROUND

Reference standard indices of iron deficiency and iron overload are generally invasive, expensive, and can be unpleasant or occasionally risky. Ferritin is an iron storage protein and its concentration in the plasma or serum reflects iron stores; low ferritin indicates iron deficiency, while elevated ferritin reflects risk of iron overload. However, ferritin is also an acute-phase protein and its levels are elevated in inflammation and infection. The use of ferritin as a diagnostic test of iron deficiency and overload is a common clinical practice.

OBJECTIVES

To determine the diagnostic accuracy of ferritin concentrations (serum or plasma) for detecting iron deficiency and risk of iron overload in primary and secondary iron-loading syndromes.

SEARCH METHODS

We searched the following databases (10 June 2020): DARE (Cochrane Library) Issue 2 of 4 2015, HTA (Cochrane Library) Issue 4 of 4 2016, CENTRAL (Cochrane Library) Issue 6 of 12 2020, MEDLINE (OVID) 1946 to 9 June 2020, Embase (OVID) 1947 to week 23 2020, CINAHL (Ebsco) 1982 to June 2020, Web of Science (ISI) SCI, SSCI, CPCI-exp & CPCI-SSH to June 2020, POPLINE 16/8/18, Open Grey (10/6/20), TRoPHI (10/6/20), Bibliomap (10/6/20), IBECS (10/6/20), SCIELO (10/6/20), Global Index Medicus (10/6/20) AIM, IMSEAR, WPRIM, IMEMR, LILACS (10/6/20), PAHO (10/6/20), WHOLIS 10/6/20, IndMED (16/8/18) and Native Health Research Database (10/6/20). We also searched two trials registers and contacted relevant organisations for unpublished studies.

SELECTION CRITERIA

We included all study designs seeking to evaluate serum or plasma ferritin concentrations measured by any current or previously available quantitative assay as an index of iron status in individuals of any age, sex, clinical and physiological status from any country.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

We followed standard Cochrane methods. We designed the data extraction form to record results for ferritin concentration as the index test, and bone marrow iron content for iron deficiency and liver iron content for iron overload as the reference standards. Two other authors further extracted and validated the number of true positive, true negative, false positive, false negative cases, and extracted or derived the sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values for each threshold presented for iron deficiency and iron overload in included studies. We assessed risk of bias and applicability using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies (QUADAS)-2 tool. We used GRADE assessment to enable the quality of evidence and hence strength of evidence for our conclusions.

MAIN RESULTS

Our search was conducted initially in 2014 and updated in 2017, 2018 and 2020 (10 June). We identified 21,217 records and screened 14,244 records after duplicates were removed. We assessed 316 records in full text. We excluded 190 studies (193 records) with reasons and included 108 studies (111 records) in the qualitative and quantitative analysis. There were 11 studies (12 records) that we screened from the last search update and appeared eligible for a future analysis. We decided to enter these as awaiting classification. We stratified the analysis first by participant clinical status: apparently healthy and non-healthy populations. We then stratified by age and pregnancy status as: infants and children, adolescents, pregnant women, and adults. Iron deficiency We included 72 studies (75 records) involving 6059 participants. Apparently healthy populations Five studies screened for iron deficiency in people without apparent illness. In the general adult population, three studies reported sensitivities of 63% to 100% at the optimum cutoff for ferritin, with corresponding specificities of 92% to 98%, but the ferritin cutoffs varied between studies. One study in healthy children reported a sensitivity of 74% and a specificity of 77%. One study in pregnant women reported a sensitivity of 88% and a specificity of 100%. Overall confidence in these estimates was very low because of potential bias, indirectness, and sparse and heterogenous evidence. No studies screened for iron overload in apparently healthy people. People presenting for medical care There were 63 studies among adults presenting for medical care (5042 participants). For a sample of 1000 subjects with a 35% prevalence of iron deficiency (of the included studies in this category) and supposing a 85% specificity, there would be 315 iron-deficient subjects correctly classified as having iron deficiency and 35 iron-deficient subjects incorrectly classified as not having iron deficiency, leading to a 90% sensitivity. Thresholds proposed by the authors of the included studies ranged between 12 to 200 µg/L. The estimated diagnostic odds ratio was 50. Among non-healthy adults using a fixed threshold of 30 μg/L (nine studies, 512 participants, low-certainty evidence), the pooled estimate for sensitivity was 79% with a 95% confidence interval of (58%, 91%) and specificity of 98%, with a 95% confidence interval of (91%, 100%). The estimated diagnostic odds ratio was 140, a relatively highly informative test. Iron overload We included 36 studies (36 records) involving 1927 participants. All studies concerned non-healthy populations. There were no studies targeting either infants, children, or pregnant women. Among all populations (one threshold for males and females; 36 studies, 1927 participants, very low-certainty evidence): for a sample of 1000 subjects with a 42% prevalence of iron overload (of the included studies in this category) and supposing a 65% specificity, there would be 332 iron-overloaded subjects correctly classified as having iron overload and 85 iron-overloaded subjects incorrectly classified as not having iron overload, leading to a 80% sensitivity. The estimated diagnostic odds ratio was 8.

AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS

At a threshold of 30 micrograms/L, there is low-certainty evidence that blood ferritin concentration is reasonably sensitive and a very specific test for iron deficiency in people presenting for medical care. There is very low certainty that high concentrations of ferritin provide a sensitive test for iron overload in people where this condition is suspected. There is insufficient evidence to know whether ferritin concentration performs similarly when screening asymptomatic people for iron deficiency or overload.

ACG Clinical Guideline: Hereditary Hemochromatosis

Hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) is one of the most common genetic disorders among persons of northern European descent. There have been recent advances in the diagnosis, management, and treatment of HH. The availability of molecular diagnostic testing for HH has made possible confirmation of the diagnosis for most patients. Several genotype-phenotype correlation studies have clarified the differences in clinical features between patients with the C282Y homozygous genotypes and other HFE mutation patterns. The increasing use of noninvasive tests such as MRI T2* has made quantification of hepatic iron deposition easier and eliminated the need for liver biopsy in most patients. Serum ferritin of <1,000 ng/mL at diagnosis remains an important diagnostic test to identify patients with a low risk of advanced hepatic fibrosis and should be used routinely as part of the initial diagnostic evaluation. Genetic testing for other types of HH is available but is expensive and generally not useful in most clinical settings. Serum ferritin may be elevated among patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and in those with alcoholic liver disease. These diagnoses are more common than HH among patients with elevated serum ferritin who are not C282Y homozygotes or C282Y/H63D compound heterozygotes. A secondary cause for liver disease should be excluded among patients with suspected iron overload who are not C282Y homozygotes. Phlebotomy remains the mainstay of therapy, but emerging novel therapies such as new chelating agents may have a role for selected patients.

Vibration Controlled Transient Elastography (Fibroscan®) in sickle cell liver disease - could we strike while the liver is hard?

Vibration controlled transient elastography (VCTE) is validated for the evaluation of hepatic fibrosis in different liver diseases. Sickle cell liver disease (SCLD) results from a cumulative hepatic injury and its lifelong and progressive nature raises the need for a non-invasive tool for fibrosis evaluation. Fifty patients, aged between 23 and 59 years with sickle cell disease and suspected SCLD underwent a VCTE followed by a liver biopsy. Biopsies were evaluated for various scores of liver disease that were then correlated to VCTE score. 90% of our patients had an Ishak Fibrosis (IF) score between 0-2 (Group A-minimal to no fibrosis) and 10% of the patients had IF score between 3-6 (Group B-advanced fibrosis). The median Transient Elastography (TE) for patients in Groups A and B was 4·8 kilopascals (kPa) and 17·6 kPa, respectively. A positive correlation was shown between TE and IF score, R = 0·0·68 (P = <0·0001); a positive correlation was also shown with Histology Activity Index fibrosis score, R = 0·64 (P = <0·0001). This study emphasises the need for further studies of non-invasive tools and their utility in liver fibrosis evaluation of patients with SCLD.

Convergence of hepcidin deficiency, systemic iron overloading, heme accumulation, and REV-ERBα/β activation in aryl hydrocarbon receptor-elicited hepatotoxicity

Persistent aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AhR) agonists elicit dose-dependent hepatic lipid accumulation, oxidative stress, inflammation, and fibrosis in mice. Iron (Fe) promotes AhR-mediated oxidative stress by catalyzing reactive oxygen species (ROS) production. To further characterize the role of Fe in AhR-mediated hepatotoxicity, male C57BL/6 mice were orally gavaged with sesame oil vehicle or 0.01-30μg/kg 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) every 4days for 28days. Duodenal epithelial and hepatic RNA-Seq data were integrated with hepatic AhR ChIP-Seq, capillary electrophoresis protein measurements, and clinical chemistry analyses. TCDD dose-dependently repressed hepatic expression of hepcidin (Hamp and Hamp2), the master regulator of systemic Fe homeostasis, resulting in a 2.6-fold increase in serum Fe with accumulating Fe spilling into urine. Total hepatic Fe levels were negligibly increased while transferrin saturation remained unchanged. Furthermore, TCDD elicited dose-dependent gene expression changes in heme biosynthesis including the induction of aminolevulinic acid synthase 1 (Alas1) and repression of uroporphyrinogen decarboxylase (Urod), leading to a 50% increase in hepatic hemin and a 13.2-fold increase in total urinary porphyrins. Consistent with this heme accumulation, differential gene expression suggests that heme activated BACH1 and REV-ERBα/β, causing induction of heme oxygenase 1 (Hmox1) and repression of fatty acid biosynthesis, respectively. Collectively, these results suggest that Hamp repression, Fe accumulation, and increased heme levels converge to promote oxidative stress and the progression of TCDD-elicited hepatotoxicity.

Abnormal liver test results on routine screening

Primary care physicians are often the first healthcare professionals to see abnormalities that show up in routine serum liver testing--results that may indicate liver disease. In this article, Drs Mallory, Lee, and Kowdley offer a practical approach to evaluating abnormal levels of markers of hepatocellular injury, cholestasis, and liver synthetic function. They also explore the considerations that might prompt physicians to request a liver biopsy.

Phlebotomy-mobilized iron as a surrogate for liver iron content in hemochromatosis patients

We sought to establish the relationship of quantitative hepatic iron measurements and phlebotomy-mobilized iron in a large sample of HFE C282Y homozygotes with a hemochromatosis phenotype. Thus, we analyzed data from 79 unrelated C282Y homozygotes from treatment centers in Rochester, NY and Birmingham, AL who had undergone liver biopsy with measurement of hepatic iron content and who had achieved iron depletion (serum ferritin <25 ng/l) with quantitative phlebotomy. The sample consisted of 57 men and 22 women; their median age at diagnosis was 47 years (range 23-76 years). Sixty-three of 79 (79.7%) had hepatic iron index (HII; μmol/g dry weight of liver divided by age in years) ≥1.9, a conventional phenotypic definition of hemochromatosis. The mean quantity of phlebotomy-mobilized iron (± 1 sd) was 6.4 g (±4.0 g) in men (range 2.0-18.0 g) and 6.2 g (±5.8) in women (range 0.7-22.5 g). There was a significant positive correlation of liver iron levels with phlebotomy-mobilized iron in this patient sample (Pearson coefficient 0.75; R<PRE>2</PRE>=55.5%). This relationship was also demonstrable when data from males and females were analyzed separately. We calculated a phlebotomy-mobilized iron index (MII: phlebotomy-mobilized iron in mg divided by age in years) using the corresponding regression equations and evaluated its use as a surrogate for HII. Thus, a phlebotomy-mobilized iron of 3.5 g corresponds to liver iron levels of 80 μmol/g dry weight, and a MII of 80 corresponds to HII of 1.9. Forty-six of 79 subjects met all four phenotypic criteria for hemochromatosis (liver iron levels ≥80 μmol/g, HII≥1.9, phlebotomy-mobilized iron ≥3.5 g and MII≥80). Of the 20 subjects with MII<80, 9 had a HII≥1.9. Conversely, 5 of 16 subjects with HII<1.9 had MII≥80 and 8 had phlebotomy-mobilized iron ≥3.5 g. Most patients with a hemochromatosis phenotype and evidence of moderate or severe iron overload (>80%) are homozygous for the common HFE missense mutation C282Y. Thus, clinicians rely increasingly on HFE mutation analysis to diagnose hemochromatosis and on quantitative phlebotomy to estimate the severity of iron overload in many cases. Liver biopsy is now employed in selected patients to visualize fibrosis or cirrhosis and to identify coincidental hepatic disease. We conclude that the use of the MII permits a retrospective estimation of the age-adjusted severity of iron overload that has a diagnostic value similar to that of the HII in hemochromatosis patients with C282Y homozygosity.

Diagnosis and management of hereditary hemochromatosis

Hereditary hemochromatosis is a rare genetic disorder that can have significant clinical consequences. Hemochromatosis is associated with iron overload, and can initially be recognized through laboratory testing for serum ferritin and transferrin saturation. Genetic testing for the HFE mutation can be performed in patients with elevated iron indices and a suspicion for hemochromatosis or liver disease. The main pathway resulting in iron overload is through altered hepcidin levels. Treatment of patients with the clinical phenotype of hereditary hemochromatosis is commonly through phlebotomy for removal of excess iron stores. This article highlights the current information and data regarding the diagnosis and management of hemochromatosis.

Diagnosis and treatment of hereditary hemochromatosis: an update

Hereditary hemochromatosis is an inherited iron overload disorder caused by inappropriately low hepcidin secretion leading to increased duodenal absorption of dietary iron, most commonly in C282Y homozygous individuals. This can result in elevated serum ferritin, iron deposition in various organs and ultimately end-organ damage, although there is incomplete biochemical and clinical penetrance and variable phenotypic expression of the HFE mutation in hereditary hemochromatosis. An elevated SF >1000 mg/l [corrected] is associated with an increased risk of cirrhosis and mortality in C282Y homozygotes.Conversely, a SF <1000 µg/l is associated with a very low likelihood of cirrhosis, making liver biopsy unnecessary among C282Y homozygotes in the absence of concomitant risk factors for liver disease. Phlebotomy remains the mainstay of treatment and new treatments being studied include erythrocytapheresis and 'mini-hepcidins'. Iron overload is being recognized to play a carcinogenic role in hepatocellular carcinoma and other cancers, possibly supporting iron depletion in these patients.

Iron overload: accuracy of in-phase and out-of-phase MRI as a quick method to evaluate liver iron load in haematological malignancies and chronic liver disease

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate the accuracy of in-phase and out-of-phase imaging to assess hepatic iron concentration in patients with haematological malignancies and chronic liver disease.

METHODS

MRI-based hepatic iron concentration (M-HIC, μmol g(-1)) was used as a reference standard. 42 patients suspected of having iron overload and 12 control subjects underwent 1.5 T in- and out-of-phase and M-HIC liver imaging. Two methods, semi-quantitative visual grading made by two independent readers and quantitative relative signal intensity (rSI) grading from the signal intensity differences of in-phase and out-of-phase images, were used. Statistical analyses were performed using the Spearman and Kruskal-Wallis tests, receiver operator curves and κ coefficients.

RESULTS

The correlations between M-HIC and visual gradings of Reader 1 (r = 0.9534, p < 0.0001) and Reader 2 (r = 0.9456, p < 0.0001) were higher than the correlations of the rSI method (r = 0.7719, p < 0.0001). There was excellent agreement between the readers (weighted κ = 0.9619). Both visual grading and rSI were similar in detecting liver iron overload: rSI had 84.85% sensitivity and 100% specificity; visual grading had 85% sensitivity and 100% specificity. The differences between the grades of visual grading were significant (p < 0.0001) and the method was able to distinguish different degrees of iron overload at the threshold of 151 μmol g(-1) with 100% positive predictive value and negative predictive value.

CONCLUSION

Detection and grading of liver iron can be performed reliably with in-phase and out-of-phase imaging. Liver fat is a potential pitfall, which limits the use of rSI.

The transplant iron score as a predictor of stem cell transplant survival

Recent studies have suggested that the presence of iron overload prior to stem cell transplantation is associated with decreased survival. Within these studies, the criteria used to define iron overload have varied considerably. Given the lack of consensus regarding the definition of iron overload in the transplant setting, we sought to methodically examine iron status among transplant patients. We studied 78 consecutive patients at risk for transfusion-related iron overload (diagnoses included AML, ALL, MDS, and aplastic anemia) who received either autologous or allogeneic stem cell transplant. Multiple measures of iron status were collected prior to transplantation and examined for their association with survival. Using this data, three potentially prognostic iron measures were identified and incorporated into a rational and unified scoring system. The resulting Transplant Iron Score assigns a point for each of the following variables: (1) greater than 25 red cell units transfused prior to transplantation; (2) serum ferritin > 1000 ng/ml; and (3) a semi-quantitative bone marrow iron stain of 6+. In our cohort, the score (range 0 to 3) was more closely associated with survival than any available single iron parameter. In multivariate analysis, we observed an independent effect of iron overload on transplant survival (p = 0.01) primarily attributable to an increase in early treatment-related deaths (p = 0.02) and lethal infections. In subgroup analysis, the predictive power of the iron score was most pronounced among allogeneic transplant patients, where a high score (> or = 2) was associated with a 50% absolute decrease in survival at one year. In summary, our results lend further credence to the notion that iron overload prior to transplant is detrimental and suggest iron overload may predispose to a higher rate of lethal infections.

Iron overload, hematopoietic cell transplantation, and graft-versus-host disease

Many patients who undergo hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) present with anemia and have received red blood cell transfusions before HCT. As a result, iron overload is frequent and appears to be particularly prominent in patients with myelodysplastic syndromes. There is evidence that peritransplant events contribute to further iron accumulation, although the mechanism that disrupts normal iron homeostasis remains to be determined. Recent studies suggest that iron overload, as determined by ferritin levels, a surrogate marker for iron, is a risk factor for increased non-relapse mortality after HCT. Iron overload is associated with an increased rate of infections, in particular with fungal organisms. Furthermore anecdotal data suggest that increased hepatic iron may mimic the clinical picture of (chronic) graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD). Whether excess iron contributes to GVHD and whether iron depletion, be it by phlebotomy or chelation, reduces the post-transplantation complication rate and improves transplant outcome is yet to be determined.

[Hereditary hemochromatosis, alpha-1-antitrypsin deficiency and Wilson's disease. Pathogenesis, clinical findings and pathways to diagnosis]

Primary hemochromatosis, alpha-1-antitrypsin (AAT) deficiency, and Wilson's disease are the most common hereditary causes of unclear hepatopathy. Classical primary hemochromatosis (type I) on the basis of a homozygous mutation of the HFE gene, usually presents in adults with increasing hepatocellular siderosis and chronic progressive necroinflammatory liver disease. Homozygous AAT deficiency type PiZZ becomes manifest in newborns as a giant cell hepatitis or findings similar to bile duct atresia, in adults as chronic hepatitis or "cryptogenic cirrhosis". The heterozygous PiZ mutation can lead to PAS-positive hepatocellular AAT deposits increasing over the life time. Immunohistochemical detection of AAT deposits by specific PiZ antibodies is a highly sensitive and specific supplementary method. Molecular analysis of AAT and HFE genes in paraffin-embedded tissue or blood can confirm the diagnosis and allows the zygosity status to be defined. Wilson's disease has to be considered in children and young adults with unexplained histologic findings of chronic hepatitis or steatohepatitis. Rhodanin staining is the most effective histochemical method to detect free copper deposits, but negative staining results do not exclude Wilson's disease. In cases suspected of Wilson's disease further clinical exploration must be initiated. The diagnosis is based on a combination of clinical and biochemical findings, which can be supplemented by mutation analysis of the ATP7B gene.

Pathways underlying iron accumulation in human nonalcoholic fatty liver disease

BACKGROUND

Mild iron overload is frequently observed in nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD).

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to study putative pathways underlying iron accumulation in NAFLD.

DESIGN

Hepatic and duodenal expression of critical iron molecules in NAFLD patients with (n = 32) and without (n = 29) iron overload, hereditary hemochromatosis (n = 10), and controls (n = 20) were investigated. Phlebotomy treatment was performed in 14 NAFLD patients.

RESULTS

The hepatic expressions of the iron-export protein ferroportin-1 (FP-1) and of the iron-sensing molecule hemojuvelin (HJV) were significantly lower in NAFLD patients. The mRNA expression of the iron-regulatory peptide hepcidin was increased in NAFLD patients with iron overload, which was paralleled by low duodenal FP-1 expression. Hepatic mRNA and serum protein concentrations of tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) were increased in NAFLD patients and were inversely correlated with both liver FP-1 and HJV mRNA and positively associated with body mass index and hepatic hepcidin mRNA. Accordingly, TNF-alpha inhibited the FP-1 and HJV mRNA formation in HepG2 cells. Phlebotomy treatment of NALFD patients reduced serum ferritin, transferrin saturation, and TNF-alpha concentrations and improved liver function tests.

CONCLUSIONS

Iron accumulation in NAFLD may result from an impaired iron export due to down-regulation of FP1 and ineffective hepatic iron sensing, as indicated by low HJV expression. TNF-alpha appears to play a role in exerting these regulatory changes. Increased hepcidin formation in iron-overloaded NAFLD patients, however, results in decreased duodenal FP-1 expression, whereas a reduction in liver FP-1 may perpetuate hepatic iron retention. Phlebotomy offers a safe and efficient therapy for these metabolic disturbances.

Liver biopsy: evolving role in the new millennium

Since the origination of the liver biopsy, the technique has evolved into an essential diagnostic tool, with very few complications. In addition to the percutaneous approach, a liver biopsy can also be obtained via transjugular, laparoscopic, or intraoperative approach. While in the early 1960s and 1970s the liver biopsy was used for making a diagnosis in cases of clinically suspected medical liver disease, today it is more often performed to assess disease prognosis and evaluate therapeutic strategies. As a result, indications for the liver biopsy have evolved over the past 2 decades. However with advances in serologic diagnosis of viral/autoimmune hepatitis and laboratory tests for genetic disorders, the role of liver biopsy in certain clinical settings is currently debated. This review discusses the technique, indications, contraindications, and the changing role of liver biopsy in some of the common disorders and the associated controversies.

Hepatic iron loading in patients with compound heterozygous HFE mutations

AIM

To assess the severity of hepatic iron loading in patients with a compound heterozygous C282Y/H63D HFE genotype.

METHODS

A total of 246 patients were referred to the Hepatology Clinic at a tertiary hospital for HFE genotyping and further assessment of elevated serum transferrin saturation and/or ferritin results, either with or without abnormal liver function tests. Subjects of the study were 19 patients compound heterozygous for HFE who had liver biopsy, quantitative liver iron estimation and liver histopathology.

RESULTS

Mild iron overload [hepatic iron concentration between 30 and 100 micromol/g dry weight], was present in 16/19 compound heterozygous patients, three patients had values within the reference range. As well as the compound heterozygous HFE genotype, 18/19 patients were found to have had at least one additional risk factor for developing either iron loading or liver disease.

CONCLUSION

Compound heterozygous patients show no more than mild liver iron loading. The decision whether or not to recommend liver biopsy in C282Y/H63D patients with abnormal serum iron indices and/or liver function tests should be based on the need to evaluate liver damage rather than solely to assess liver iron loading.

Pilot study of the relationship between histologic progression and hepatic iron concentration in chronic hepatitis C

Hepatic iron deposition is common in patients with chronic hepatitis C (HCV) and may play a role in progression of liver disease. This pilot study examines the relationship between hepatic iron concentration (HIC) and histologic progression over time in patients with HCV. HIC was retrospectively measured in 14 patients with HCV who had 2 serial liver biopsies prior to the era of interferon therapy. The mean interval between biopsies was 56 +/- 46 months. Mean Knodell score worsened between first and second biopsies (10.0 +/- 2.8 versus 12.4 +/- 3.3; P = 0.007). There was increased portal inflammation (3.2 +/- 0.4 versus 3.6 +/- 0.5; P = 0.028) and fibrosis (1.8 +/- 1.3 versus 2.7 +/- 1.2; P = 0.002), but no significant change in piecemeal necrosis or lobular degeneration. There was no significant change in HIC between first and second biopsy (P = 0.66). However, HIC was noted to increase significantly among patients with cirrhosis on initial biopsy or those who progressed to cirrhosis (P = 0.009). In this pilot study, histologic progression in patients with precirrhotic HCV was not associated with an increase in HIC, whereas hepatic iron accumulation was observed in 3 patients once cirrhosis was present. The interaction between progression of hepatitis C and iron deposition warrants further study.

Review article: haemochromatosis

Hereditary haemochromatosis is the prototype disease for primary iron overload. The disorder is very common, especially amongst subjects of Northern European extraction. It is characterized by an autosomal recessive mode of inheritance, and most cases are homozygous for the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene. Haemochromatosis is now recognized to be a complex genetic disease with probable significant environmental and genetic modifying factors. The early diagnosis of individuals at risk for the development of haemochromatosis is important, because survival and morbidity are improved if phlebotomy therapy is instituted before the development of cirrhosis. The cost-effectiveness and utility of large-scale screening for haemochromatosis have been questioned given that many individuals with the homozygous C282Y mutation do not have iron overload or end-organ damage. However, the use of phenotypic tests, such as serum transferrin-iron saturation, for initial screening avoids the problem of the identification of non-expressing homozygotes. Liver biopsy remains important in management to determine the presence or absence of cirrhosis, particularly amongst patients with serum ferritin levels greater than 1000 ng/mL or elevated liver enzymes. Those with non-HFE haemochromatosis who cannot be identified on genotypic testing should have a liver biopsy to establish diagnosis. Patients with end-stage liver disease may develop liver failure or primary liver cancer, and liver transplantation may be required. Liver transplantation for haemochromatosis is associated with a poorer outcome compared with other indications because of infections and cardiac complications.

Non-transferrin-bound iron in untreated and ribavirin-treated chronic hepatitis C patients

BACKGROUND

In patients with chronic hepatitis C, elevations in serum iron levels, hepatic iron content and oxidative stress-related molecules have been reported. Treatment with ribavirin induces an increase in hepatic iron concentration. In situations of iron overload, non-transferrin-bound iron can appear. Therefore, we determined non-transferrin-bound iron levels in untreated chronic hepatitis C patients and in patients during interferon-ribavirin treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In 10 untreated and 19 interferon-ribavirin-treated chronic hepatitis C patients, we examined non-transferrin-bound iron levels by a colorimetric method using nitrilotriacetic acid as a ligand and sodium triscarbonatecobalt (III) to block free iron binding sites on transferrin.

RESULTS

Despite the presence of high serum iron saturation and ferritin levels, non-transferrin-bound iron was absent in the majority of hepatitis C virus patients (25/29, 86%). There was no difference in non-transferrin-bound iron levels between untreated and treated patients. Four patients with high non-transferrin-bound iron levels were distinguished by higher serum iron levels. In two of these patients, hepatocytic iron was present on liver biopsy.

CONCLUSIONS

In the majority of chronic hepatitis C patients, non-transferrin-bound iron levels are normal. Treatment with ribavirin does not induce high non-transferrin-bound iron levels. Non-transferrin-bound iron levels are only higher than normal in hepatitis C patients with higher serum iron levels.

Role of liver biopsy in the diagnosis of hepatic iron overload in the era of genetic testing

We studied hepatic iron overload (HIOL) patterns in 32 patients who underwent liver biopsies and testing for HFE mutations (C282Y, H63D). Iron-stained biopsy specimens were examined for patterns of iron deposits: hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) pattern or non-HH pattern. Visual iron grade based on amount of cellular and lobular iron was evaluated. We found the HH pattern in 17 biopsy specimens (53%) and the non-HH pattern in 6 specimens (19%). HH with superimposed non-HH was noted in 9 cases (28%). In 25 patients with HFE mutations, HH alone and combined with non-HH patterns was noted in 22 specimens (88%). Visual iron grade correlated approximately with the hepatic iron index. Heavy HIOL was noted in C282Y homozygotes and 1 patient with cirrhosis without either HFE mutation. Mild steatohepatitis was found in 21 specimens (66%); it was associated with the non-HH pattern in 80% (12/15) and the HH pattern in 62% (16/26) of cases. Liver biopsy can identify pattern and grade of HIOL and associated pathology for diagnosis and management of patients with abnormal iron studies and elevated liver function test results. Genetic tests for HFE mutations and liver biopsies are complementary in the workup of these patients.

Excess alcohol greatly increases the prevalence of cirrhosis in hereditary hemochromatosis

BACKGROUND & AIMS

The progression of fibrosis to cirrhosis is the most significant prognostic factor in hereditary hemochromatosis. We aimed to determine the range of hepatic iron concentration associated with cirrhosis in the absence of alcohol and other pro-fibrogenic cofactors and to quantify the contribution of excess alcohol consumption to the development of cirrhosis.

METHODS

Liver biopsy data were evaluated on 224 C282Y homozygous hemochromatosis subjects. To determine the effect of alcohol alone on the development of fibrosis, subjects with viral hepatitis or nonalcoholic steatohepatitis were excluded. Subjects were divided into those who consumed less than 60 g alcohol per day and those who consumed 60 g per day or more.

RESULTS

Seven percent of subjects who consumed less than 60 g per day had severe fibrosis/cirrhosis compared with 61% of excess alcohol consumers.

CONCLUSIONS

Hemochromatosis subjects who drink more than 60 g alcohol per day are approximately 9 times more likely to develop cirrhosis than those who drink less than this amount, and the range of hepatic iron concentration associated with cirrhosis in the absence of cofactors was 233-675 micromol/g dry weight.

Hereditary haemochromatosis: detection and management

Hereditary haemochromatosis is common, affecting one in 200 Australians of Anglo-Celtic descent; it results in iron overload affecting many organs, including the liver, heart, endocrine and musculoskeletal system. Diagnosis requires a high index of suspicion, as presenting symptoms and signs may be non-specific. Once suspected, hereditary haemochromatosis can be readily diagnosed by measurement of serum transferrin saturation and ferritin level, followed by genetic assessment. Homozygosity for the C282Y mutation in the HFE gene accounts for most cases in people of Anglo-Celtic descent in Australia; a genetic test for this mutation is widely available. Liver biopsy is advocated only in selected individuals at risk of cirrhosis or with an unclear diagnosis. Therapeutic phlebotomy remains the treatment and, if instituted early, will prevent many of the organ-specific complications.

Serum iron indices as a measure of iron deposits in chronic hepatitis C

Serum iron indices are believed to be elevated in patients with hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection in connection to the presence of hepatic inflammation, though this hypothesis has never been formally tested. We studied 69 consecutive, unselected anti HCV antibody positive patients, aged 14 to 70 years. Iron, transferrin saturation and ferritin were measured in fasting serum samples. Histologically detectable iron (HDI) as well as histologic grading and staging were estimated semiquantitatively in liver biopsy samples. The median values for serum iron, transferrin saturation and serum ferritin were 24 micromol/l (range, 8-61), 29 percent (range, 6-77) and 170 microg/l (range, 1-954), respectively. At univariate analysis, all three serum iron indices were positively correlated with grading and staging scores, as well as with HDI in the liver; only serum iron was positively correlated with transaminases. At multivariate analysis, independent associations were found between serum iron and the grading score; ferritin and sinusoidal and portal HDI; transferrin saturation and total hepatic HDI. In conclusion, in hepatitis C, serum iron reflects the degree of current hepatic inflammation and necrosis, whereas the extent of progressive deposition of iron in sites of fibrosis is best reflected by serum ferritin. Transferrin saturation is the best predictor of the status of hepatic iron deposits.

Genetic liver disease in adults. Early recognition of the three most common causes

The most common clinically important genetic diseases leading to liver dysfunction in adults are Wilson's disease, HHC, and alpha 1AT deficiency. Advances in molecular biology have led to the identification and characterization of the genetic defects in these conditions. Consequently, genetic testing for disease-causing mutations is now available for most of these disorders. However, it is important to understand the strengths and limitations of such testing. Genetic testing is probably most helpful in HHC because of the high frequency of the homozygous C282Y mutation among patients of northern European descent and the relatively high penetrance of the mutation with regard to clinical expression. Genetic testing is much less helpful in the other genetic liver diseases because of the high number of possible mutations and variable clinical expression. However, noninvasive phenotype-based screening tests and specific treatments are available for most genetic liver diseases. Appropriate use of screening tests in routine clinical practice can assist in early identification of genetic liver diseases and prevent development of end-organ damage.

New developments in hereditary hemochromatosis

The iron content of the body is normally tightly controlled by regulation of iron absorption. In hereditary hemochromatosis, mutation of an HLA class 1 gene, designated HFE, results in excessive iron absorption. Over many years, accumulating iron produces tissue damage, most notably cirrhosis, cardiomyopathy, diabetes, and arthropathies. Hereditary hemochromatosis is the most common hereditary disease of Northern Europeans with a prevalence of approximately 5 per 1000. The most sensitive screening test for hemochromatosis is saturation of the transferrin with iron; a fasting value greater than 50% is strongly suggestive of the disease. Confirmation of increased iron storage can be achieved most readily by serial phlebotomy. We do not regard liver biopsy to be indicated, except in unusual circumstances. Early diagnosis and treatment by phlebotomy before tissue damage has occurred is essential, because life span seems to be normal in treated patients but markedly shortened in those who are not. Therefore, genetic counseling with evaluation of first-degree relatives is mandatory.

Population-based screening for hemochromatosis using phenotypic and DNA testing among employees of health maintenance organizations in Springfield, Missouri

BACKGROUND

Hemochromatosis reportedly affects 3 to 8 persons per 1,000 and is associated with an elevated risk of morbidity and mortality. We sought to ascertain its prevalence in a community and to assess the association between phenotype and genotype.

METHODS

All health maintenance organization employees were invited to participate in hemochromatosis screening using a repeated elevation of the transferrin saturation test as the case definition (> or = 50% in women and > or = 60% in men with no other cause). Iron overload from hemochromatosis was defined as serum ferritin concentration > or = 95th percentile and mobilizable iron > or = 99th percentile for age and sex, or hepatic iron index > or = 1.9. The HFE gene was analyzed for mutations.

RESULTS

Participation among employees was 28% (1,653 of 6,000); 83% were women. The prevalence of hemochromatosis was 8 per 1,000 (13 of 1,653), and the prevalence of iron overload from hemochromatosis was 4 per 1,000 (5 of 1,653). Compared with those who had no HFE mutation, the relative risk (RR) for hemochromatosis was greatest for C282Y homozygotes (RR = 147), compound heterozygotes (RR = 19), and H63D homozygotes (RR = 9). Overall, 38% of participants had at least one HFE mutation. Screening based on an initial elevated transferrin saturation test had the best sensitivity, whereas DNA testing offered the best specificity and predictive value positive for iron overload disease.

CONCLUSIONS

In this population, we found a greater than expected prevalence of hemochromatosis and demonstrated a clear association with the HFE genotype. Promotion of screening is complicated by controversies in case definition and the large number of persons who will be detected before they have clinically significant iron loading, in whom the risk of clinical disease is unknown. Larger screening studies in more diverse populations are necessary to characterize the burden of disease and to follow those at risk (based on HFE or iron status measures) to establish the natural history of hemochromatosis.

A genotypic study of 217 unrelated probands diagnosed as "genetic hemochromatosis" on "classical" phenotypic criteria

BACKGROUND/AIMS

The HFE gene is a crucial candidate gene for hemochromatosis. The aims of this study were to assess the HFE genotypic profile in a large series of unrelated probands diagnosed as having phenotypic hemochromatosis, to characterize the sub-group of patients who were not homozygous for the major C282Y mutation, and to report the iron status of the detected HFE-identical siblings.

METHODS

In 217 patients, the phenotypic diagnosis of hemochromatosis was based on strict bioclinical and/or histological criteria, and their genotypic profile (C282Y and H63D mutations) was determined.

RESULTS

1) 209 of the 217 probands were C282Y +/+. In 33 cases, an HFE-identical sibling was identified. Two of them had neither a clinical nor a biochemical phenotypic profile of hemochromatosis in the absence of any external factor which might have attenuated this expression. 2) Eight patients (seven males) were not C282Y +/+. Their genotypic profiles were: (C282Y +/-): six cases (four were H63D +/- and two H63D -/-); (C282Y -/-): two cases (one was H63D +/+, one H63D +/-). Phenotypic expression consisted of six cases of mild liver siderosis (among whom were the four compound heterozygotes and one case of alcoholic cirrhosis) and two severe cases of hepatic iron overload (one with alcoholic cirrhosis). Three HFE-identical siblings were identified, none of them presenting with iron excess.

CONCLUSIONS

In our population: 1) The classical phenotypic criteria fitted, in 96.3% of cases, with a homogeneous genotypic entity defined by homozygosity for the C282Y mutation. Incomplete penetrance of the homozygous status was shown by the absence of the hemochromatosis phenotypic profile in 6% of the HFE-identical siblings. 2) A minority (3.7%) were not homozygous for C282Y. These were essentially men with mild iron overload, and might present with distinct iron overload entity(ies) as suggested by the presence in three of an HFE-identical sibling with absence of iron overload.

Quantitative Study of the Variability of Hepatic Iron Concentrations

Background: The hepatic iron concentration (HIC) is widely used in clinical practice and in research; however, data on the variability of HIC among biopsy sites are limited. One aim of the present study was to determine the variability of HIC within both healthy and cirrhotic livers.

Methods: Using colorimetric methods, we determined HIC in multiple large (microtome) and small (biopsy-sized) paraffin-embedded samples in 11 resected livers with end-stage cirrhosis. HIC was also measured in multiple fresh samples taken within 5 mm of each other (“local” samples) and taken at sites 3–5 cm apart (“remote” samples) from six livers with end-stage cirrhosis and two healthy autopsy livers.

Results: The within-organ SD of HIC was 13–1553 μg/g (CV, 3.6–55%) for microtome samples and 60–2851 μg/g (CV, 15–73%) for biopsy-sized samples. High variability of HIC was associated with mild to moderate iron overload, because the HIC SD increased with increasing mean HIC (P &lt;0.002). Livers with mean HIC &gt;1000 μg/g exhibited significant biological variability in HIC between sites separated by 3–5 cm (remote sites; P &lt;0.05). The SD was larger for biopsy-sized samples than for microtome samples (P = 0.02).

Conclusion: Ideally, multiple hepatic sites would be sampled to obtain a representative mean HIC.

Screening for hemochromatosis. A public health perspective

CONTEXT

The discovery of the HFE gene in 1996 has introduced DNA testing as a possible tool for screening and diagnosis of hemochromatosis and increased interest in the disorder. Population screening using transferrin saturation has been advocated by experts to permit early detection and treatment with phlebotomy before the onset of clinical disease.

METHODS

Based on a literature review, we consider the relative risks and merits of two screening tests as part of a broader look at the evidence required for the recommendation of universal screening for hemochromatosis.

RESULTS

Several questions must be answered before universal screening can be recommended. Uncertainties remain about the penetrance and preventable disease burden, laboratory standardization, and optimal strategies to minimize potential risks of screening for hemochromatosis.

CONCLUSIONS

As a common genetic disorder with simple, effective therapy, hemochromatosis offers a model for other genetically influenced chronic diseases that some day may have interventions to improve prognosis. Resolution of questions related to prevention of chronic diseases from hemochromatosis, therefore, will have broad usefulness in the future.

Hereditary hemochromatosis in liver transplantation

A candidate gene, HFE, was recently described in patients with hereditary hemochromatosis (HH) and found to contain a missense mutation leading to a cysteine to tyrosine substitution (C282Y). A second mutation, H63D, was also found in the gene. This study was undertaken to determine the HFE genotype in liver transplant recipients clinically diagnosed with HH and those incidentally found to have increased iron deposition in their explanted livers and to evaluate whether biochemical or histological hepatic iron indices (HIIs) correlated with homozygosity for the C282Y mutation. We identified 15 patients clinically diagnosed with various liver disorders other than HH who had increased liver iron deposits among 918 adult patients who underwent liver transplantation from 1988 to 1995. Four additional patients were clinically diagnosed as having HH. Archival explant liver tissue was evaluated for the histological HII according to the method of Deugnier et al, in which an index greater than 0.15 suggests homozygosity for HH. The HII was computed according to established methods, with a value greater than 1.9 suggesting homozygosity for HH. A portion of liver tissue was subjected to DNA genotyping using polymerase chain reaction-amplified products. Two of 4 patients with clinically suspected HH were homozygous for C282Y, and 2 patients had neither mutation. One of the 15 patients not suspected to have HH was a C282Y homozygote, 1 was a C282Y heterozygote, 6 were H63D heterozygotes, and 7 had neither mutation. The histological HII was consistent with HH in 13 patients, whereas the HII was consistent with HH in 6 patients. Thus, in patients with end-stage liver disease, despite fulfilling the established clinical criteria for HH using biochemical and histological parameters, only a minority of patients were homozygous for the C282Y mutation. Hepatic iron overload may result from other causes, and in end-stage liver disease, an elevated HII may not accurately predict HH. Other factors that either control or lead to iron absorption may explain iron overload in these patients.

Noninvasive prediction of fibrosis in C282Y homozygous hemochromatosis

BACKGROUND & AIMS

The diagnosis of hemochromatosis is now possible for C282Y homozygous patients using noninvasive molecular genetic tests. The aim of this study was to define noninvasive factors predictive of severe fibrosis (bridging fibrosis or cirrhosis) to avoid unnecessary liver biopsies in such patients.

METHODS

Clinical and biological data were recorded at the time of diagnosis in 197 French C282Y homozygous patients, 52 (26%) of whom had severe fibrosis. Variables significantly linked to severe fibrosis using univariate analysis were entered into a multivariate stepwise analysis. These variables were combined to obtain a simple index allowing for prediction of severe fibrosis.

RESULTS

Serum ferritin, hepatomegaly, and serum aspartate aminotransferase were selected using multivariate analysis. Their combination applied to the 96 patients with ferritin level of </=1000 microgram/L, normal aspartate aminotransferase values, and absence of hepatomegaly showed that no severe fibrosis was encountered in this subgroup of patients. The results were validated in 113 C282Y homozygous patients in Canada with a good reproducibility of negative prediction but a poor reproducibility of the positive prediction of severe fibrosis.

CONCLUSIONS

In C282Y homozygous patients, the diagnosis of severe fibrosis relies on liver biopsy, but absence of severe fibrosis can be accurately predicted in most patients on the basis of simple clinical and biochemical variables.

Clinical management of iron overload

HHC is a common inherited disorder, characterized by iron accumulation in the liver, heart, pancreas, and other organs. The clinical consequences of systemic iron loading are diverse and not always improved with iron reduction therapy. The most important prognostic factor at the time of diagnosis is the presence or absence of hepatic fibrosis or cirrhosis. Those without significant hepatic fibrosis may be expected to have a normal life expectancy with phlebotomy therapy. The availability of genetic testing for HHC has significantly changed the diagnostic approach to this disorder. Although liver biopsy remains vital to determining prognosis, genetic testing is increasingly used in the diagnosis and family screening of patients with HHC.

Haemochromatosis

Primary, hereditary or genetic haemochromatosis is one of the most common inherited disorders in a Caucasian populations with a disease frequency of 1:300-400 and a carrier frequency of approximately 10%. The basic genetic defect remains unknown, although the haemochromatosis gene has now been cloned and is known to be a member of the MHC non-classical class I family. Many factors--environmental, genetic and non-genetic in nature--influence the degree of iron loading in affected individuals. In particular, pathological and physiological blood loss influence iron stores in haemochromatosis. The iron concentration in the liver is an important determinant of survival because a hepatic iron concentration in excess of 400 mumol/g dry weight is usually associated with cirrhosis. Patients with cirrhosis secondary to haemochromatosis are at risk of hepatocellular carcinoma. The combination of improved awareness of the disease and the appropriate use of genetic testing for the common C282Y mutation should lead to earlier diagnosis and therapy.