Common in vitro substrate specificity and differential Src homology 2 domain accessibility displayed by two members of the Src family of protein-tyrosine kinases, c-Src and Hck

Csk-homologous kinase (Chk) is an efficient inhibitor of Src-family kinases but a poor catalyst of phosphorylation of their C-terminal regulatory tyrosine

BACKGROUND

C-terminal Src kinase (Csk) and Csk-homologous kinase (Chk) are the major endogenous inhibitors of Src-family kinases (SFKs). They employ two mechanisms to inhibit SFKs. First, they phosphorylate the C-terminal tail tyrosine which stabilizes SFKs in a closed inactive conformation by engaging the SH2 domain in cis. Second, they employ a non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism involving direct binding of Csk and Chk to the active forms of SFKs that is independent of phosphorylation of their C-terminal tail. Csk and Chk are co-expressed in many cell types. Contributions of the two mechanisms towards the inhibitory activity of Csk and Chk are not fully clear. Furthermore, the determinants in Csk and Chk governing their inhibition of SFKs by the non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism are yet to be defined.

METHODS

We determined the contributions of the two mechanisms towards the inhibitory activity of Csk and Chk both in vitro and in transduced colorectal cancer cells. Specifically, we assayed the catalytic activities of Csk and Chk in phosphorylating a specific peptide substrate and a recombinant SFK member Src. We employed surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy to measure the kinetic parameters of binding of Csk, Chk and their mutants to a constitutively active mutant of the SFK member Hck. Finally, we determined the effects of expression of recombinant Chk on anchorage-independent growth and SFK catalytic activity in Chk-deficient colorectal cancer cells.

RESULTS

Our results revealed Csk as a robust enzyme catalysing phosphorylation of the C-terminal tail tyrosine of SFKs but a weak non-catalytic inhibitor of SFKs. In contrast, Chk is a poor catalyst of SFK tail phosphorylation but binds SFKs with high affinity, enabling it to efficiently inhibit SFKs with the non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism both in vitro and in transduced colorectal cancer cells. Further analyses mapped some of the determinants governing this non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism of Chk to its kinase domain.

CONCLUSIONS

SFKs are activated by different upstream signals to adopt multiple active conformations in cells. SFKs adopting these conformations can effectively be constrained by the two complementary inhibitory mechanisms of Csk and Chk. Furthermore, the lack of this non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism accounts for SFK overactivation in the Chk-deficient colorectal cancer cells.

Divergent modulation of Src-family kinase regulatory interactions with ATP-competitive inhibitors

Multidomain protein kinases, central controllers of signal transduction, use regulatory domains to modulate catalytic activity in a complex cellular environment. Additionally, these domains regulate noncatalytic functions, including cellular localization and protein–protein interactions. Src-family kinases (SFKs) are promising therapeutic targets for a number of diseases and are an excellent model for studying the regulation of multidomain kinases. Here, we demonstrate that the regulatory domains of the SFKs Src and Hck are divergently affected by ligands that stabilize two distinct inactive ATP-binding site conformations. Conformation-selective, ATP-competitive inhibitors differentially modulate the ability of the SH3 and SH2 domains of Src and Hck to engage in intermolecular interactions and the ability of the kinase–inhibitor complex to undergo post-translational modification by effector enzymes. This surprising divergence in regulatory domain behavior by two classes of inhibitors that each stabilize inactive ATP-binding site conformations is found to occur through perturbation or stabilization of the αC helix. These studies provide insight into how conformation-selective, ATP-competitive inhibitors can be designed to modulate domain interactions and post-translational modifications distal to the ATP-binding site of kinases.

Activation of Src family tyrosine kinases by ferric ions

The Src-family tyrosine kinases (SFKs) are oncogenic enzymes that contribute to the initiation and progression of many types of cancer. In normal cells, SFKs are kept in an inactive state mainly by phosphorylation of a consensus regulatory tyrosine near the C-terminus (Tyr(530) in the SFK c-Src). As recent data indicate that tyrosine modification enhances binding of metal ions, the hypothesis that SFKs might be regulated by metal ions was investigated. The c-Src C-terminal peptide bound two Fe(3+) ions with affinities at pH4.0 of 33 and 252μM, and phosphorylation increased the affinities at least 10-fold to 1.4 and 23μM, as measured by absorbance spectroscopy. The corresponding phosphorylated peptide from the SFK Lyn bound two Fe(3+) ions with much higher affinities (1.2pM and 160nM) than the Src C-terminal peptide. Furthermore, when Lyn or Hck kinases, which had been stabilised in the inactive state by phosphorylation of the C-terminal regulatory tyrosine, were incubated with Fe(3+) ions, a significant enhancement of kinase activity was observed. In contrast Lyn or Hck kinases in the unphosphorylated active state were significantly inhibited by Fe(3+) ions. These results suggest that Fe(3+) ions can regulate SFK activity by binding to the phosphorylated C-terminal regulatory tyrosine.

A facile, click chemistry-based approach to assembling fluorescent chemosensors for protein tyrosine kinases

A group of fluorophore-labeled peptide substrates of Src kinases have been synthesized with the aid of click chemistry. Some of the generated peptides exhibit an increase in fluorescence upon phosphorylation and are capable of detecting Src kinases with high sensitivity and specificity. Their availability permits real-time activity measurement of aberrantly activated oncogenic Src kinases in the crude lysate of chronic myelogenous leukemia cells. These new chemosensor peptides are highly useful tools that can be used for high-throughput screening to search for small molecule inhibitors of Src kinases as potential therapeutics for cancer treatment.

Optimization of a homogeneous assay for kinase inhibitors in plant extracts

To identify natural and original kinase inhibitors from plant extracts, we have developed and compared a heterogeneous enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and a homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence (HTRF, Cisbio International, Bagnols/Cèze, France) assay. Kinase affinity for the ATP substrate was determined in both assays, and the same [ATP]/ATP Km ratio was used in each case to enable the identification of ATP competitive and noncompetitive inhibitors. Assays were then used to screen the same collection of chemical compounds and plant extracts. The intra-assay correlation analysis of each technology showed a very good screening precision in HTRF and an acceptable one in ELISA. When the two methods were compared, a poor correlation was obtained with a higher hit rate in the ELISA. We then performed a detailed study of the ELISA hits and showed that they also presented a strong antioxidant activity, associated with high adsorption into microplate wells, which interfered with the horseradish peroxidase-based detection system. These hits were then flagged as false-positives. We also showed that many plant extracts presented this kind of activity and that this interference could explain the lack of correlation between the assays. These findings suggest that assay design should be carefully adapted to the substances to be screened and that interferences should be extensively considered before any assay development process and comparison studies. In spite of a few interferences, our results showed that a homogeneous-phase assay like the HTRF assay could be more efficiently used for plant extract screening than a heterogeneous-phase assay like ELISA.

C-terminal Src kinase-homologous kinase (CHK), a unique inhibitor inactivating multiple active conformations of Src family tyrosine kinases

The Src family of protein kinases (SFKs) mediates mitogenic signal transduction, and constitutive SFK activation is associated with tumorigenesis. To prevent constitutive SFK activation, the catalytic activity of SFKs in normal mammalian cells is suppressed mainly by two inhibitors called C-terminal Src kinase (CSK) and CSK-homologous kinase (CHK), which inactivate SFKs by phosphorylating a consensus tyrosine near the C terminus of SFKs (Y(T)). The phosphorylated Y(T) intramolecularly binds to the SH2 domain of SFKs. This interaction, known as pY(T)/SH2 interaction, together with binding between the SH2 kinase linker and the SH3 domain of SFKs (linker/SH3 interaction) stabilizes SFKs in a "closed" inactive conformation. We previously discovered an alternative mechanism CHK employs to inhibit SFKs. This mechanism, referred to as the non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism, involves tight binding of CHK to SFKs; the binding alone is sufficient to inhibit SFKs. Herein, we constructed multiple active conformations of an SFK member, Hck, by systematically disrupting the two inhibitory interactions. We found that CHK employs the non-catalytic mechanism to inactivate these active conformations of Hck. However, CHK does not bind Hck when it adopts the inactive conformation in which both inhibitory interactions are intact. These data indicate that binding of CHK to SFKs via the non-catalytic mechanism is governed by the conformations of SFKs. Although CSK is also an inhibitor of SFKs, it does not inhibit SFKs by a similar non-catalytic mechanism. Thus, the non-catalytic inhibitory mechanism is a unique property of CHK that allows it to down-regulate multiple active conformations of SFKs.

Marked differences in the structures and protein associations of lymphocyte and monocyte CD4: resolution of a novel CD4 isoform

The structures, molecular interactions and functions of CD4 in a subset of T lymphocytes have been well characterized. The CD4 receptors of other cell types have, however, been poorly documented. We have previously shown that lymphocytes and monocytes/macrophages differ in their expression of CD4 monomers and dimers. In the present study, we have shown further significant differences. Variability in the blocking of CD4 mAb binding by sulfated polyanions indicated differences in exofacial CD4 structures. In contrast to the well-documented 55 kDa monomers in lymphocytic cells, monocytic cells were found to coexpress two monomer isoforms: the 55 kDa form and a novel 59 kDa species. Experimental uncoupling of CD4 disulfides indicated that the oxidized 55 kDa monomer could be converted to the 59 kDa form. This was achieved by chemical reduction of purified native or recombinant CD4, or in cell transfection experiments by mutation of cysteine to alanine in domain 1 (D1) (Cys16 or Cys84) and in domain 4 (D4) (Cys303 or Cys345). All of these modifications promote CD4 distension on SDS-PAGE analysis and indicate that, when CD4 inter-beta-sheet disulfides in the D1 and D4 Ig folds are disrupted, there is an unravelling of the oxidized form to an extended 59 kDa unfolded state. We hypothesize that this may be a transition-state, structural-intermediate in the formation of disulfide-linked homodimers. Also identified were CD4-tyrosine kinase dissimilarities in which lymphocyte CD4 associated with Lck, but monocyte CD4 associated with HcK. These findings show that there is complex heterogeneity in structures and interactions in the CD4 of T lymphocytes and monocytes.

The v-Src and c-Src tyrosine kinases immunoprecipitated from Rous sarcoma virus-transformed cells display different peptide substrate specificities

In the cells transformed by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), two Src proteins are expressed: the ubiquitous tyrosine kinase c-Src and the v-Src, the product of the transforming gene of the virus. Using three synthetic peptide substrates widely used for testing Src kinase activity, we show that they are phosphorylated with different efficiencies by the v-Src and c-Src tyrosine kinases immunoprecipitated from the tumor cell line H19. The v-Src displays higher efficiency (Vmax/Km ratio) toward all three peptides used, but the Vmax of v-Src is much lower than Vmax of c-Src with two peptides out of three. This difference in substrate specificity, if ignored, may cause misestimation of the amounts of active c-Src and v-Src in RSV-transformed cells. On the other hand, the different peptide substrate specificities may also reflect different protein substrate specificities of the v-Src and c-Src kinases in vivo.

A novel non-catalytic mechanism employed by the C-terminal Src-homologous kinase to inhibit Src-family kinase activity

Although C-terminal Src kinase (CSK)-homologous kinase (CHK) is generally believed to inactivate Src-family tyrosine kinases (SFKs) by phosphorylating their consensus C-terminal regulatory tyrosine (Tyr(T)), exactly how CHK inactivates SFKs is not fully understood. Herein, we report that in addition to phosphorylating Tyr(T), CHK can inhibit SFKs by a novel non-catalytic mechanism. First, CHK directly binds to the SFK members Hck, Lyn, and Src to form stable protein complexes. The complex formation is mediated by a non-catalytic Tyr(T)-independent mechanism because it occurs even in the absence of ATP or when Tyr(T) of Hck is replaced by phenylalanine. Second, the non-catalytic CHK-SFK interaction alone is sufficient to inactivate SFKs by inhibiting the catalytic activity of autophosphorylated SFKs. Third, CHK and Src co-localize to specific plasma membrane microdomains of rat brain cells, suggesting that CHK is in close proximity to Src such that it can effectively inactivate Src in vivo. Fourth, native CHK.Src complex exists in rat brain, and recombinant CHK.Hck complex exists in transfected HEK293T cells, implying that CHK forms stable complexes with SFKs in vivo. Taken together, our findings suggest that CHK inactivates SFKs (i) by phosphorylating their Tyr(T) and (ii) by this novel Tyr(T)-independent mechanism involving direct binding of CHK to SFKs. It has been documented that autophosphorylated SFKs can still be active, in some cases even when their Tyr(T) is phosphorylated. Thus, the ability of the Tyr(T)-independent mechanism to suppress the activity of both non-phosphorylated and autophosphorylated SFKs represents a fail-safe measure employed by CHK to down-regulate SFK signaling under all circumstances.

The activation and subsequent regulatory roles of Lyn and CD19 after B cell receptor ligation are independent

The cell surface glycoprotein CD19 and the Src-related protein tyrosine kinase Lyn are key mediators of, respectively, positive and negative signaling in B cells. Despite the apparent opposition of their regulatory functions, a recent model of the biochemical events after B cell receptor (BCR) ligation intimately links the activation of Lyn and CD19. We examined the biochemical consequences of BCR ligation in mouse B cells lacking either Lyn or CD19 for evidence of interaction or codependence. In contrast to published results, we found CD19 phosphorylation after BCR ligation to be unaffected by the absence of Lyn, yet dependent on Src family protein tyrosine kinases as it was inhibited fully by PP2, an Src family-specific inhibitor. Consistent with normal CD19 phosphorylation in lyn(-/-) B cells, the recruitment of phosphoinositide-3 kinase to CD19 and the ability of CD19 to enhance both intracellular calcium flux and extracellular signal-regulated kinase 1/2 activation after coligation with the BCRs were intact in the absence of Lyn. Similarly, unique functions of Lyn were found to be independent of CD19. CD19(-/-) B cells were normal for increased Lyn kinase activity after BCR ligation, inhibition of BCR-mediated calcium flux after CD22 coligation, and inhibition of extracellular signal-regulated kinase phosporylation after FcgammaRIIB coligation. Collectively, these data show that the unique functions of Lyn do not require CD19 and that the signal amplification mediated by CD19 is independent of Lyn. We conclude that the roles of Lyn and CD19 after BCR ligation are independent and opposing, one being primarily inhibitory and the other stimulatory.

Modulation of the catalytic activity of the Src family tyrosine kinase Hck by autophosphorylation at a novel site in the unique domain

Autophosphorylation is a key event in the activation of protein kinases. In this study, we demonstrate that autophosphorylation of the recombinant Src family kinase Hck leads to a 20-fold increase in its specific enzymatic activity. Hck was found to autophosphorylate readily to a stoichiometry of 1.3 mol of phosphate per mol of enzyme, indicating that the kinase autophosphorylated at more than one site. Solid phase sequencing and two-dimensional mapping of the phosphopeptide fragments derived from the autophosphorylated enzyme revealed that the kinase can undergo autophosphorylation at the following two sites: (i) Tyr-388, which is located to the consensus autophosphorylation site commonly found in the activation loop of many protein kinases, and (ii) Tyr-29, which is located in the unique domain of Hck. Hck purified from mouse bone marrow-derived macrophages could also autophosphorylate in vitro at both Tyr-388 and Tyr-29, indicating that naturally occurring Hck can also autophosphorylate at Tyr-29. Furthermore, Hck transiently expressed in human embryonic kidney 293T cells was found to be phosphorylated at Tyr-29 and Tyr-388, proving that Hck can also undergo autophosphorylation at both sites in vivo. The recombinant enzyme carrying the mutation of Tyr-388 to Phe was also able to autophosphorylate at Tyr-29, albeit at a significantly slower rate. A 2-fold increase in the specific enzymatic activity was seen with this mutant despite the stoichiometry of autophosphorylation only approaching 0.2 mol of phosphate per mol of enzyme. This indicates that autophosphorylation of Tyr-29 contributes significantly to the activation of Hck. Regulation of the catalytic activity by phosphorylation of Tyr-29 in the unique domain may represent a new mechanism of regulation of Src family tyrosine kinases.

The SH3 and SH2 domains are capable of directing specificity in protein interactions between the non-receptor tyrosine kinases cSrc and cYes

The c-src and c-yes proto-oncogenes encode 60 000 and 62 000 Dalton non-receptor tyrosine kinases of the Src family, pp60c-src and pp62c-yes, respectively. These kinases are over 80% homologous outside of their unique amino termini, yet several studies suggest that differences exist in the regulation, activation, and function of cSrc and cYes. The determinants of specificity in signaling between these proteins, however, remain unclear. In order to investigate the roles of the Src Homology (SH) 3 and 2 domains in mediating signaling specificity between cSrc and cYes, chimeras were created in which the SH3 and/or SH2 domains of cSrc or the fully activated variant Src527F were replaced by the corresponding domains of cYes. These constructs were used to assess the effects of the Yes SH3 and SH2 domains on the ability of Src to form stable complexes with and induce tyrosine phosphorylation of Src SH3 and SH2 domain binding partners in vivo. Both the Yes SH3 and SH2 domains were found to alter the capacity of Src to form stable associations with heterologous proteins. The Yes SH3 domain was unable to affinity absorb the Src SH3/SH2 binding partner AFAP-110 from COS-1 cell lysates, and chimeric constructs of Src527F containing the cYes SH3 domain were unable to efficiently co-immunoprecipitate with AFAP-110 from chicken embryo fibroblasts. Interactions with the Src SH2 domain binding partner pp130cas were unaffected. Additionally, only chimeras containing the cYes SH2 domain were able to co-immunoprecipitate with an unidentified 87 kDa tyrosine-phosphorylated protein. These results indicate that the SH3 and SH2 domains are capable of directing specificity in substrate binding between Src and Yes, suggesting potential mechanisms for generating specificity in signaling between these two highly related non-receptor tyrosine kinases.