Retinoblastoma with low risk for extraocular relapse

Immunohistochemical expression of TFF1 is a marker of poor prognosis in retinoblastoma

INTRODUCTION

The risk of relapse in retinoblastoma is currently determined by the presence of high-risk histopathologic factors in the enucleated eye. However, the probability of developing metastatic disease is heterogeneous among these patients. Evaluating a biological marker to identify high-risk patients could be useful in clinical setting. This study aims to evaluate whether the expression of TFF1, a surrogate for subtype 2 retinoblastoma, is a prognostic marker for relapse and death.

METHODS

This multicenter cohort study included 273 patients, 48 of whom had extraocular disease. Immunohistochemical staining were performed for CRX, ARR3, TFF1, and Ki67. Tumors were classified as histological subtype 1 (HS1) if they had low or no expression of TFF1 (quick score (QS) ≤ 50) and as histological subtype 2 (HS2) if they expressed TFF1 diffusely (QS > 50). We studied the association between HS classification and outcome.

RESULTS

Of 273 patients, 35.9% were classified as HS1, 59.3% as HS2 and 4.8% were not evaluable. In multivariate analysis, patients with HS2 tumors had a higher probability of relapse and death than those with HS1 (p < .0001 and p = .00020, respectively). We identified a higher-risk subgroup among HS2 tumors, presenting non-mutually exclusive expression of ARR3 and TFF1 and had an increased risk of relapse and death compared with tumors that displayed mutually exclusive expression (p = .012 and p = .027, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Expression of TFF1, especially when it is not-mutually exclusive with ARR3, is an independent significant marker of poor outcome in retinoblastoma.

Study of Unilateral Retinoblastoma With and Without Histopathologic High-Risk Features and the Role of Adjuvant Chemotherapy: A Children's Oncology Group Study

PURPOSE

To prospectively determine the prevalence of high-risk histopathologic features (HRFs) in patients with unilateral retinoblastoma who undergo enucleation and to evaluate the role of chemotherapy in preventing recurrences.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Children newly diagnosed with enucleated unilateral retinoblastoma were enrolled prospectively. After central histopathology review, patients with specific HRFs received chemotherapy; others were observed. Primary end points were event-free survivals (EFS).

RESULTS

Of the 331 patients enrolled during 2005 to 2010, 321 eligible patients had central histopathologic review. Discordance between central review and contributing institutions occurred in 23% of patients with HRFs and in 17% of patients without HRFs. Postlaminar optic nerve involvement was present in 53 patients; 42 had massive posterior uveal invasion (≥ 3 mm); 15 had concomitant peripapillary 3 mm or greater choroid and postlaminar optic nerve involvement; and 15 had focal (< 3 mm) choroidal concomitant with lamina or prelamina optic nerve involvement. Two-year EFS for patients with HRFs requiring adjuvant chemotherapy was 0.96 (95% CI, 0.89 to 0.98), and 2-year EFS for patients without HRFs for which observation was indicated was 0.99 (95% CI, 0.96 to 1.0). The 2-year EFS for all patients was 0.98 (95% CI, 0.96 to 0.99).

CONCLUSION

Adequate handling and interpretation of histopathology of eyes with retinoblastoma is necessary to assign metastatic risk. Concomitant less than 3 mm choroidal and any prelaminar/laminar optic nerve invasion show no recurrence and may warrant no adjuvant chemotherapy. In contrast, concomitant greater than 3 mm peripapillary choroidal invasion and 1.5 mm or greater of postlaminar optic nerve invasion have the poorest outcomes, supporting the need for a more intensive adjuvant chemotherapy regimen for this subgroup. Strict criteria for adjuvant therapy may improve outcomes of children who undergo enucleation at diagnosis and may avoid unnecessary adjuvant chemotherapy for those who are not at risk for recurrence.

The Potential Benefit of Three vs. Six Cycles of Carboplatin, Etoposide, and Vincristine in Postenucleation High-Risk Patients with IRSS Stage I Retinoblastoma

PURPOSE

To compare the clinical effects of different cycles of carboplatin, etoposide, and vincristine (CEV) regimens of adjuvant chemotherapy in postenucleation high-risk patients with IRSS Stage I retinoblastoma (RB).

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of 53 RB patients hospitalized in the Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center of Sun Yat-sen University was performed. All patients had unilateral involvement, received enucleation treatment, were diagnosed as RB by pathology, and had high-risk pathological factors. Patients either refused postoperative chemotherapy or received three or six cycles of CEV regimen chemotherapy. The clinical information, treatment, and results of patients in all groups were compared.

RESULTS

A total of 19 cases refused postenucleation chemotherapy, 18 cases received three cycles, and 16 cases received six cycles of the CEV regimen chemotherapy. The 5-year disease-free survival rate and the overall survival (OS) rate in the chemotherapy group were higher than those in the non-chemotherapy group (97.1% vs. 63.2%, p = 0.001) and were not different between the three-cycle chemotherapy group and the six-cycle chemotherapy group (94.4% vs. 100%, p = 0.35).

CONCLUSION

After eye enucleation for patients with high-risk unilateral RB, the CEV regimen chemotherapy was associated with a higher survival rate. The three-cycle CEV regimen adjuvant chemotherapy was effective and is expected to replace the six-cycle CEV regimen chemotherapy.

Risk definition and management strategies in retinoblastoma: current perspectives

This manuscript focuses on high-risk factors of metastatic disease in retinoblastoma and evaluation of the current treatments of retinoblastoma. Presence of histopathologic high-risk factors is associated with a higher risk of local recurrence and systemic metastasis. Currently, globe-sparing therapies, including systemic chemotherapy, intra-arterial chemoreduction, intravitreal chemotherapy, focal consolidation, and combination therapies, are being used and investigated actively. Major advances are being made in the diagnosis and management of retinoblastoma that will lead to improved morbidity and mortality rates in patients with retinoblastoma. By saving the globes, fronting with some high-risk factors for metastasis would be inevitable. International multi-institutional prospective studies could resolve current uncertainties regarding the main tumor treatment regimens for each patient and indications for chemoprophylaxis for high-risk-factor-bearing retinoblastoma cases.

Retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma is the most common neoplasm of the eye in childhood, and represents 3% of all childhood malignancies. Retinoblastoma is a cancer of the very young; two-thirds are diagnosed before 2 years of age and 95% before 5 years. Retinoblastoma presents in 2 distinct clinical forms: (1) a bilateral or multifocal, heritable form (25% of all cases), characterized by the presence of germline mutations of the RB1 gene; and (2) a unilateral or unifocal form (75% of all cases), 90% of which are nonhereditary. The treatment of retinoblastoma is multidisciplinary and is designed primarily to save life and preserve vision.

Retinoblastoma. Fifty years of progress. The LXXI Edward Jackson Memorial Lecture

PURPOSE

To review the progress made in understanding the genetic basis, molecular pathology, and treatment of retinoblastoma since the previous Jackson lecture on the topic was published 50 years ago.

DESIGN

Perspective based on personal experience and the literature.

METHODS

The literature regarding retinoblastoma was reviewed since 1963. Advances in understanding the biology and treatment of retinoblastoma provided context through the author's clinical, pathologic, and research experiences.

RESULTS

Retinoblastoma was first identified in the 1500s and defined as a unique clinicopathologic entity in 1809. Until the mid-1900s, knowledge advanced sporadically, with technological developments of ophthalmoscopy and light microscopy, and with the introduction of surgical enucleation, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy. During the last 50 years, research and treatment have progressed at an unprecedented rate owing to innovations in molecular biology and the development of targeted therapies. During this time period, the retinoblastoma gene was discovered; techniques for genetic testing for retinoblastoma were developed; and plaque brachytherapy, chemoreduction, intra-arterial chemotherapy, and intraocular injections of chemotherapeutic agents were successfully introduced.

CONCLUSIONS

Nearly all patients with retinoblastoma in developed countries can now be cured of their primary cancer--a remarkable achievement for a childhood cancer that once was uniformly fatal. Much of this success is owed to deciphering the role of the Rb gene, and the benefits of targeted therapies, such as chemoreduction with consolidation as well as intra-arterial and intravitreal chemotherapies. Going forward, the main challenge will be ensuring that access to care is available for all children, particularly those in developing countries.

Establishment of the relationship between tumor size and range of histological involvement to evaluate the rationality of current retinoblastoma management

Purpose

To determine whether tumor size correlates with histopathological involvement and hence evaluate the rationality of conservative treatment for retinoblastoma.

Methods

We retrospectively studied 221 patients (221 eyes) treated for retinoblastoma with enucleation in the Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center of Sun Yat-sen University, China, from October 1995 to December 2004. Histopathological data included involvement of the anterior chamber, sclera, choroids, and optic nerve. Tumor size was measured by B-ultrasound examination.

Results

Tumor invasion of the optic nerve correlated with the Reese-Ellsworth (R-E) staging system and the International Classification for Retinoblastoma (ICRB): optic nerve involvement was significantly more frequent in R-E stage V (P = 0.009) and ICRB Group E (P = 0.002) cases. However, 19.1% of patients with R-E stage I, II and III, and 16.7% of patients with ICRB Group B and C disease showed histopathological involvement of the postlaminar optic nerve. Extraocular involvement was observed in 17.7% of tumors ≤15 mm in diameter. Tumors >15 mm in diameter showed greater extraocular involvement, including the optic nerve (P = 0.000) and sclera (P = 0.032), than tumors ≤15 mm in diameter. Postlaminar optic nerve invasion was observed in 19.6% of tumors ≤10 mm in thickness. Tumors >10 mm in thickness had sclera involvement more frequently than tumors ≤10 mm in thickness (P = 0.029). Postlaminar optic nerve invasion was noted in 17.1% of patients with tumors ≤15 mm in diameter and ≤10 mm in thickness.

Conclusions

Medium-sized retinoblastomas frequently invade outside the globe. Thus, indications for conservative treatment need improvement.

A study of pathologic risk factors in postchemoreduced, enucleated specimens of advanced retinoblastomas in a developing country

CONTEXT

Advanced cases of retinoblastoma are treated with chemoreduction followed by enucleation. Further adjuvant therapy is recommended in patients with known pathologic risk factors (PRFs).

OBJECTIVES

To determine the PRFs in enucleated specimens after chemoreduction and their association for adverse events of recurrence, metastasis, or death.

DESIGN

This was a retrospective study of 77 enucleation specimens from patients treated between January 2000 and September 2008 with prior chemoreduction that were accessioned in the pathology department of a tertiary referral cancer center with an average follow-up of 24 months. Various PRFs were noted and their association with the development of an adverse event was recorded.

RESULTS

Of 77 patients, (male to female ratio, 51∶26), the incidence of overall PRF was 51.9%, and retrolaminar optic nerve invasion (32.5%), optic nerve cut margin (12.9%), massive choroidal invasion (26%), scleral invasion (23.4%), vitreous seedings (44.2%), and anterior segment invasion (20.8%). Undifferentiated tumor (>60%) was seen in 60.3% of cases (41 of 68 patients with differentiation available). Adverse event occurred in 18 of 72 patients with available follow-up (25%). Retrolaminar optic nerve invasion, optic nerve cut margin involvement, and scleral invasion were independent prognostic factors predicting the occurrence of an adverse event. Undifferentiated tumor (>60%) was a significant risk factor in univariate analysis, which is the unique feature in this study.

CONCLUSIONS

Classic PRF with the addition of a predominant presence from the undifferentiated component were associated with adverse outcomes in retinoblastoma treated with anterior chemotherapy. The latter may represent chemoresistant clones and more intensive adjuvant chemotherapy may be warranted in these patients.

Retinoblastoma: one world, one vision

Retinoblastoma is curable when diagnosed early and treated appropriately; however, the prognosis is dismal when the basic elements of diagnosis and treatment are lacking. In developing countries, poor education, lower socioeconomic conditions, and inefficient health care systems result in delayed diagnosis and suboptimal care. Furthermore, the complexity of multidisciplinary care required is seldom possible. Whereas ocular salvage is a priority in the Western world, death from retinoblastoma is still a major problem in developing countries. To bring the 2 ends of this spectrum together and provide a forum for discussion, the "One World, One Vision" symposium was organized, at which clinicians and researchers from various cultural, geographic, and socioeconomic backgrounds converged to discuss their experiences. Strategies for early diagnosis in developing countries were discussed. Elements of the development of retinoblastoma centers in developing countries were discussed, and examples of successful programs were highlighted. An important component in this process is twinning between centers in developing countries and mentor institutions in high-income countries. Global initiatives by nongovernmental organizations such as the International Network for Cancer Treatment and Research, Orbis International, and the International Agency for Prevention of Blindness were presented. Treatment of retinoblastoma in developing countries remains a challenge; however, it is possible to coordinate efforts at multiple levels, including public administrations and nonprofit organizations, to improve the diagnosis and treatment of retinoblastoma and to improve the outcome for these children.

Risk factors for extraocular relapse following enucleation after failure of chemoreduction in retinoblastoma

OBJECTIVE

To assess the outcome and determine risk factors for extraocular relapse in patients with retinoblastoma who had been enucleated after failure of chemoreduction.

METHODS

Retrospective study (1995-2002) at three institutions. Pathological risk factors (PRF) were defined as invasion of the anterior segment, choroid, post-laminar optic nerve, subarachnoid space, or sclera according to the local pathology report. Extraocular relapse was defined as an event.

RESULTS

One hundred twenty-two patients were included (17 had bilateral enucleation). Chemoreduction included vincristine, carboplatin, and etoposide (n=80, 65.6%), vincristine, and carboplatin (n=17, 13.9%), or carboplatin (n=25, 20.5%). Thirty-five also received external beam radiotherapy (28.7%). PRF included: 39 with choroidal involvement, 9 with anterior segment, 9 with scleral, and 2 with post-laminar optic nerve with subarachnoid invasion. Adjuvant chemotherapy was given to eight patients (6.5%) because of scleral invasion. Four patients had an extraocular relapse after enucleation, two of whom survive after intensive treatment including stem cell rescue. Five-year probability of event-free survival is 0.96. Only scleral invasion and bilateral enucleation were significantly associated with extraocular relapse.

CONCLUSIONS

The risk of extraocular relapse is low after enucleation following failure of chemoreduction. Patients who underwent bilateral enucleation and those with scleral invasion are at higher risk of extraocular relapse.

Extensively necrotic retinoblastoma is associated with high-risk prognostic factors

CONTEXT

Retinoblastoma is the most common malignant intraocular tumor in children. It has been shown that adjuvant therapy following enucleation in patients with high-risk histopathologic features significantly decreases the mortality. We describe the association of extensive necrosis of tumor and intraocular structures with 2 of the major risk factors: optic nerve invasion and choroidal invasion. This may alert the pathologist who makes the observation of extensive necrosis to carefully search for histologic features associated with adverse outcome.

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether extensively necrotic retinoblastoma is associated with high-risk histologic prognostic factors for metastatic disease and patient survival.

DESIGN

Retrospective case series. Forty-three eyes of 43 patients with retinoblastoma who underwent enucleation between 1990 and 2001 were evaluated. Medical records, histopathology specimens, pathology reports, and clinical photographs were reviewed. Tumors were designated as exhibiting extensive necrosis if more than 95% of tumor cells and intraocular tissues were necrotic. The main outcome measure was the association of extensive tumor necrosis with 3 high-risk histopathologic features: extraocular extension, optic nerve invasion, or choroidal invasion. Metastatic disease, patient survival, and associations with pathologic findings were also analyzed.

RESULTS

Optic nerve head invasion (P < .001), post-lamina-cribrosal invasion (P < .001), and choroidal invasion by tumor (P = .004) were observed more frequently in eyes with extensive necrosis compared with eyes without extensive necrosis. Two of the 11 patients with extensively necrotic intraocular retinoblastoma died from metastatic disease (P = .06). None of the 32 patients without extensive necrosis developed metastatic disease or died.

CONCLUSIONS

Extensive ocular tissue and tumor necrosis is associated with histologic high-risk prognostic factors for tumor metastasis and mortality.

Diagnosis and current management of retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma represents the prototypic model for inherited cancers. The RB1 gene was the first tumor suppressor gene to be identified. It represents the most frequent primary eye cancer in children under 15 years old, habitually occurring in infancy, even in utero, but can be observed in older children or young adults. Many other retinal lesions may also simulate retinoblastoma. The two major presenting signs are leukocoria and strabismus, but other ocular or general signs may be observed. A highly malignant tumor, retinoblastoma can nowadays be cured. The heritable form, however, carries a high risk of second nonocular tumors. Treatment in the early stages of disease holds a good prognosis for survival and salvage of visual function. In very late stages, however, the prognosis for ocular function and even survival is jeopardized.

More aggressive bone marrow screening in retinoblastoma patients is not indicated: the memorial Sloan-Kettering cancer center experience

BACKGROUND

Bone marrow involvement in retinoblastoma patients is rare in the more industrialized nations. The purpose of the current study was to determine the frequency of bone marrow involvement in our series of retinoblastoma patients and to investigate whether the use of four bone marrow aspirates (BMA) and two bone marrow biopsies (BMB) has greater sensitivity for the detection of metastatic disease compared to what has been previously reported.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of the charts of 54 patients with retinoblastoma was performed. We performed 265 BMA, 134 BMB (4 aspirates and 2 biopsies per evaluation), and 67 lumbar punctures (LPs) in 54 patients with retinoblastoma.

RESULTS

There were no patients found with bone marrow or cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) involvement at the time of the initial diagnosis. Although no patient died of distant metastases, two patients developed metastatic disease at recurrence, involving the bone marrow and other sites. For these two patients all four aspirates and two biopsies were positive for disease at the time of recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the use of four BMA and two BMB (as opposed to one bone marrow aspirate that is routinely performed in other centers), the detection of patients with metastatic disease was similar to what has been previously reported. Based on these data more aggressive evaluation of the bone marrow in retinoblastoma patients with clinically limited disease using four aspirates and two biopsies cannot be supported.

Retinoblastoma patients with high risk ocular pathological features: who needs adjuvant therapy?

AIMS

To describe the outcome of patients with non-metastatic unilateral retinoblastoma with high risk histopathological features after primary enucleation, and to clarify the need and results of adjuvant therapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From 1980 to 2001 adjuvant therapy was recommended only to patients with scleral involvement, post-laminar optic nerve involvement (PLONI) with either a positive margin or associated choroidal involvement, or (before 1994) isolated PLONI.

RESULTS

108 of 224 patients had at least one high risk feature (choroidal, scleral, anterior chamber, and/or PLONI). Patients with isolated choroidal (n = 55) or anterior chamber (n = 2) invasion, and most with PLONI without other risk factors (n = 21) were not treated; three relapsed but are long term survivors after intensive therapy. Four with isolated PLONI received adjuvant chemotherapy and none relapsed. Three of 11 with PLONI and concomitant choroidal or scleral involvement who received adjuvant therapy relapsed, versus two of four not treated. Two of five with scleral disease relapsed. All 12 with cut end involvement received adjuvant treatment and none relapsed. In the total group, all four patients who relapsed after adjuvant therapy died.

CONCLUSIONS

Relapsing patients can be rescued with intensive therapy. Those with isolated choroidal or PLONI have a good prognosis without adjuvant therapy. Patients with PLONI with a positive margin have a good prognosis if treated with combined therapy. Those with scleral involvement or PLONI with concomitant choroid disease may benefit from adjuvant therapy.

Results of a prospective study for the treatment of retinoblastoma

BACKGROUND

The objectives of this prospective study were to avoid adjuvant treatment for patients with intraocular disease and patients with postlaminar optic nerve invasion (PL-ONI) without full choroidal or scleral invasion. Adjuvant chemotherapy (Regimen 1) was given to patients with scleral invasion, PL-ONI without cut section, and full choroidal and/or scleral invasion. A more intensive regimen of higher dose intravenous chemotherapy (Regimen 2) and local radiotherapy was given to patients with PL-ONI and compromise at the cut end and to patients with overt extraocular disease.

METHODS

Six-month intravenous chemotherapy included carboplatin plus etoposide alternating with cyclophosphamide plus vincristine (Regimen 1) and the same drugs at higher dosage plus idarubicin (Regimen 2). Chemoreduction with carboplatin and vincristine with or without etoposide was given to selected patients (n = 39 patients).

RESULTS

From 1994 to 2001, 169 patients were evaluable at the Hospital Garrahan (Buenos Aires, Argentina). One hundred eighteen patients with intraocular disease had a 5-year disease free survival (DFS) rate of 0.98, including 54 patients with choroidal invasion. None of 22 patients with isolated PL-ONI developed recurrent disease, whereas 2 of 8 patients with concomitant risk factors had tumor recurrences and died. Three of 5 patients with scleral invasion survived, and 7 of 10 patients with cut-end ONI survived. The only patient with metastatic disease that survived (n = 6) had only lymph node invasion.

CONCLUSIONS

Adjuvant therapy can be avoided in patients with intraocular and isolated PL-ONI. Patients with PL-ONI who also had other risk factors required intensive adjuvant therapy, such as patients with cut-end and overt extraocular disease. Metastatic disease was not found to be curable with this approach.

Tumour angiogenesis as a prognostic factor for disease dissemination in retinoblastoma

AIM

To evaluate tumour angiogenesis as a predictor of prognosis in retinoblastoma.

METHODS

This was a retrospective, non-randomised comparative clinicopathological study. The histopathology from 24 cases of Reese-Ellsworth (RE) group V unilateral retinoblastoma treated by enucleation alone was reviewed. Group I consisted of five patients (four RE group Vb and one group Va) who developed disseminated disease at a mean of 10.4 months after enucleation. The remaining 19 patients constitute group II (18 RE group Vb and 1 group Va), none of whom had developed metastatic disease with a mean follow up of 54 months. None of the 24 patients had evidence of extraocular disease at enucleation. The surgical specimens from patients with unilateral retinoblastoma treated by enucleation at Hospital do Cancer AC Camargo between January 1992 and December 1995 were identified, reviewed and the clinical data recorded. Two subsequent histological sections were prepared. One stained with haematoxylin and eosin for assessment of choroidal and optic nerve invasion, and the other for immunoreaction with an endothelium specific marker (antibody anti-CD 34). The main outcome measures were choroidal and/or optic nerve invasion and quantification of the tumour's relative vascular area (TRVA) obtained by Chalkley counting.

RESULTS

Choroidal invasion was present in three eyes of group I (all massive) and six eyes of group II (two focal and four massive). Optic nerve invasion was found in two eyes of group I (all post-laminar) and four eyes of group II (three prelaminar and one post-laminar). There was no statistical difference regarding choroidal or optic nerve between the two groups. The TRVA was the only independent variable found to predict disease dissemination (p = 0.008 by Cox analysis). A TRVA equal to or greater than 3.9% had 100% sensitivity and 79% specificity in predicting disease dissemination.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantification of angiogenesis, through measurement of the TRVA, can help to identify patients with retinoblastoma at high risk for disease dissemination after enucleation.