Paper-based lateral flow strip assay for the detection of foodborne pathogens: principles, applications, technological challenges and opportunities

Sensitive Colorimetric Lateral Flow Assays Enabled by Platinum-Group Metal Nanoparticles with Peroxidase-Like Activities

The last several decades have witnessed the success and popularity of colorimetric lateral flow assay (CLFA) in point-of-care testing. Driven by increasing demand, great efforts have been directed toward enhancing the detection sensitivity of CLFA. Recently, platinum-group metal nanoparticles (PGM NPs) with peroxidase-like activities have emerged as a type of promising colorimetric labels for enhancing the sensitivity of CLFA. By incorporating a simple and rapid post-treatment process, the PGM NP-based CLFAs are orders of magnitude more sensitive than conventional gold nanoparticle-based CLFAs. In this perspective, the study begins with introducing the design, synthesis, and characterization of PGM NPs with peroxidase-like activities. The current techniques for surface modification of PGM NPs are then discussed, followed by operation and optimization of PGM NP-based CLFAs. Afterward, opinions are provided on the social impact of PGM NP-based CLFAs. Lastly, this perspective is concluded with an outlook of future research directions in this emerging field, where the challenges and opportunities are discussed.

Advances in enhancement-type signal tracers and analysis strategies driven Lateral flow immunoassay for guaranteeing the agri-food safety

As a classical and continuously developing on-site sensor, Lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) exhibits promising potential for advanced point-of-care testing (POCT). Especially given the significance of agri-food in human dietary structure and the ever-increasing agri-food safety concerns, improved analysis performance of LFIA is urgently required. Recently, flourishing enhancement-type signal tracers (STs) and brilliant enhancement-type analysis strategies have been actively pursued in the development of LFIA because these patterns endow immense feasibility in manufacturing target-oriented sensing platforms. To facilitate further advancements in this field, this review comprehensively examines the recent developments in enhancement-type STs (e.g., load-, green-, recognizable-, Janus-, and dyestuffs-type STs) and enhancement-type analysis strategies (e.g. immuno-network, in-situ growth, nanozymes, multi-signal readout, and software-assisted quantitative analytical strategies) that significantly improve precise analysis efficiency. Moreover, by conducting a comprehensive evaluation of the major advancements and aiming to identify future trends in LFIA-based sensor, the objective of this review is to provide recommendations for future research based on the challenges and opportunities of LFIA.

Lateral flow immunoassay device to detect staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) in durian candy

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB), a potent enterotoxin produced by Staphylococcus aureus, has been implicated in incidences of Staphylococcal food poisoning in the Philippines. The use of lateral flow immunoassay devices to detect this toxin in solid food samples, like durian candy, at the point of sampling is constrained by the requirement for sample purification (e.g. centrifugation). This problem is also true with the other applications of LFIA devices on food samples. To overcome this challenge, a lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) device capable of detecting SEB in unpurified durian candy sample was developed in this study. A modified LFIA device was assembled with three layers of glass fiber pads functioning as sample pads instead of a conventional cellulose fiber pad. Unlike with the cellulose fiber pad, the glass fiber sample pads acted as filter and allowed the flow of a 1:5 dilution of durian candy. The LFIA device applied to spiked 1:5 diluted durian candy samples achieved a visual limit of detection of 5 ng/mL for SEB, which is twofold lower than reported for previous LFIA devices designed to detect SEB in food samples.

Flower-Shaped PCR Scaffold-Based Lateral Flow Bioassay for Bacillus cereus Endospores Detection

Bacillus cereus, a foodborne pathogen, produces resilient endospores that are challenging to detect with conventional methods. This study presents a novel Flower-Shaped PCR Scaffold-based Lateral Flow Biosensor (FSPCRS-LFB), which employs an aptamer-integrated PCR scaffold as capture probes, replacing the traditional streptavidin-biotin (SA-Bio) approach. The FSPCRS-LFB demonstrates high sensitivity and cost-efficiency in detecting B. cereus endospores, with a limit of detection (LOD) of 4.57 endospores/mL a visual LOD of 102 endospores/mL, and a LOD of 6.78 CFU/mL for endospore-cell mixtures. In chicken and tea samples, the platform achieved LODs of 74.5 and 52.8 endospores/mL, respectively, with recovery rates of 82.19% to 97.88%. Compared to existing methods, the FSPCRS-LFB offers a 3.7-fold increase in sensitivity while reducing costs by 26% over the SA-Bio strategy and 87.5% over rolling circle amplification (RCA). This biosensor provides a rapid, sensitive and cost-effective solution for point-of-care testing (POCT) of B. cereus endospores, expanding detection capabilities and offering novel approaches for pathogen detection.

Application of a dual-modality colorimetric analysis method to inkjet printing lateral flow detection of Salmonella typhimurium

Lateral flow assay (LFA) color signal quantification methods were developed by utilizing both International Commission on Illumination (CIE) LAB (CIELAB) color space and grayscale intensity differences. The CIELAB image processing procedure included calibration, test, control band detection, and color difference calculation, which can minimize the noise from the background. The LFA platform showcases its ability to accurately discern relevant colorimetric signals. The rising occurrence of infectious outbreaks from foodborne pathogens like Salmonella typhimurium presents significant economic, healthcare, and public health risks. The study introduces an aptamer-based lateral flow (ABLF) platform by using inkjet printing for specially detecting S. typhimurium. The ABLF utilized gold-decorated polystyrene microparticles, functionalized with specific S. typhimurium aptamers (Ps-AuNPs-ssDNA). The platform demonstrates a detection limit of 102 CFU mL-1 in buffer solutions and 103 CFU mL-1 in romaine lettuce tests. Furthermore, it sustained performance for over 8 weeks at room temperature. The ABLF platform and analysis methods are expected to effectively resolve the low-sensitivity problems of the former LFA systems and to bridge the gap between lab-scale platforms to market-ready solutions by offering a simple, cost-effective, and consistent approach to detecting foodborne pathogens in real samples.

Optimized detection of Salmonella typhimurium using aptamer lateral flow assay

Salmonella typhimurium, a pathogenic bacterium with significant implications in medicine and the food industry, poses a substantial threat by causing foodborne illnesses such as typhoid fever. Accurate diagnosis of S. typhimurium is challenging due to its overlap symptoms with various diseases. This underscores the need for a precise and efficient diagnostic approach. In this study, we developed a biosensor using the Taguchi optimization method based on aptamer lateral flow assay (LFA) for the detection of S. typhimurium. Therefore, signal probe and nanobioprobe were designed using anti-Salmonella aptamer, conjugated with gold nanoparticles (GNPs), and used in LFA. The strategy of this test is based on a competitive format between the bacteria immobilized on the membrane and the bacteria present in the tested sample. Moreovere, the optimization of various factors affecting the aptamer LFA, including the concentration of bacteria (immobilized and into the sample) and the concentration of nanobioprop, were performed using the Taguchi test designing method. The data showed that the optimal conditions for the LFA reaction was 108 CFU/mL of immobilized bacteria and 1.5 μg/μL of nanobioprop concentration. Then, the visual detection limit of S. typhimurium was estimated as 105 CFU/mL. The reaction results were obtained within 20 min, and there were no significant cross-reactions with other food pathogens. In conclusion, the aptamer-LFA diagnostic method, optimized using the Taguchi approach, emerges as a reliable, straightforward, and accurate tool for the detection of S. typhimurium. Overall, this method can be a portable diagnostic kit for the detection and identification of bacteria.

Detection of sulphur(II) of carbon dots synthesized from Gardenia residue

The detection of anions using carbon dots (CDs) has received less attention compared to cations. Therefore, the present study aimed to develop a fluorescence sensor based on carbon dots (CDs) capable of detecting S2- in real water samples. The CDs were successfully prepared from the residues of a traditional Chinese herb, Gardenia, which emitted green photoluminescence (PL) under ultraviolet light irradiation. The as-prepared CDs were quasi-spherical in shape and ranged in size from 10 to 30 nm. Different detailed analyses proved that the CDs had good morphology, various functional groups, high water solubility, great optical features, and excellent stability under diverse environmental conditions. The ion detection showed that only Ag+ had the strongest fluorescence quenching effect on the CDs, however, the addition of S2- could recover their fluorescence. Based on these results, an "off-on" fluorescence sensor was achieved to selectively detect the concentration of S2- in real water samples with a limit of detection (LOD) of 39 μM, which further expanded the application of residues from traditional Chinese herbal medicine.

Droplet digital molecular beacon-LAMP assay via pico-injection for ultrasensitive detection of pathogens

A pico-injection-aided digital droplet detection platform is presented that integrates loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) with molecular beacons (MBs) for the ultrasensitive and quantitative identification of pathogens, leveraging the sequence-specific detection capabilities of MBs. The microfluidic device contained three distinct functional units including droplet generation, pico-injection, and droplet counting. Utilizing a pico-injector, MBs are introduced into each droplet to specifically identify LAMP amplification products, thereby overcoming issues related to temperature incompatibility. Our methodology has been validated through the quantitative detection of Escherichia coli, achieving a detection limit as low as 9 copies/μL in a model plasmid containing the malB gene and 3 CFU/μL in a spiked milk sample. The total analysis time was less than 1.5 h. The sensitivity and robustness of this platform further demonstrated the potential for rapid pathogen detection and diagnosis, particularly when integrated with cutting-edge microfluidic technologies.

The Evaluation of a Lateral Flow Strip Based on the Covalently Fixed "End-On" Orientation of an Antibody for Listeria monocytogenes Detection

In this study, the covalently fixed "end-on" orientation of a monoclonal Listeria monocytogenes antibody (mAb-Lis) to amino terminated oligo (ethylene glycol)-capped gold nanoparticles (NH2-TEG-AuNPs) was used to fabricate an in-house lateral flow strip (LFS), namely, the fixed "end-on" Lis-mAb-NH-TEG-AuNPs LFS. The aim was to evaluate the performance of the fixed "end-on" Lis-mAb-NH-TEG-AuNPs LFS in detecting L. monocytogenes. The proposed LFS enabled the sensitive detection of L. monocytogenes in 15 min with a visual limit of detection of 102 CFU/mL. Quantitative analysis indicated an LOD at 10 CFU/mL. The fixed "end-on" Lis-mAb-NH-TEG-AuNPs LFS showed no cross-reactivity with other pathogenic bacteria and practical performance across different food matrices, including human blood, milk, and mushroom samples. Furthermore, the clinical performance of the fixed "end-on" Lis-mAb-NH-TEG-AuNPs LFS for detecting L. monocytogenes was evaluated by using 12 clinical samples validated by the hemoculture method. It demonstrated excellent concordance with the reference methods, with no false-positive or false-negative results observed. Therefore, the fixed "end-on" Lis-mAb-NH-TEG-AuNPs LFS serves as a promising candidate for a point-of-care test (POCT), enabling the rapid, precise, and highly sensitive detection of L. monocytogenes in clinical samples and contaminated food.

Optical fiber immunosensors based on surface plasmon resonance for the detection of Escherichia coli

Every year, millions of people suffer some form of illness associated with the consumption of contaminated food. Escherichia coli (E. coli), found in the intestines of humans and other animals, is commonly associated with various diseases, due to the existence of pathogenic strains. Strict monitoring of food products for human consumption is essential to ensure public health, but traditional cell culture-based methods are associated with long waiting times and high costs. New approaches must be developed to achieve cheap, fast, and on-site monitoring. Thus, in this work, we developed optical fiber sensors based on surface plasmon resonance. Gold and cysteamine-coated fibers were functionalized with anti-E. coli antibody and tested using E. coli suspensions with concentrations ranging from 1 cell/mL to 105 cells/mL. An average logarithmic sensitivity of 0.21 ± 0.01 nm/log(cells/mL) was obtained for three independent assays. An additional assay revealed that including molybdenum disulfide resulted in an increase of approximately 50% in sensitivity. Specificity and selectivity were also evaluated, and the sensors were used to analyze contaminated water samples, which verified their promising applicability in the aquaculture field.

Recent Advances in Biosensor Development for the Detection of Viral Particles in Foods: A Comprehensive Review

Viral foodborne diseases cause serious harm to human health and the economy. Rapid, accurate, and convenient approaches for detecting foodborne viruses are crucial for preventing diseases. Biosensors integrating electrochemical and optical properties of nanomaterials have emerged as effective tools for the detection of viruses in foods. However, they still face several challenges, including substantial sample preparation and relatively poor sensitivity due to complex food matrices, which limit their field applications. Hence, the purpose of this review is to provide an overview of recent advances in biosensing techniques, including electrochemical, SERS-based, and colorimetric biosensors, for detecting viral particles in food samples, with emerging techniques for extraction/concentration of virus particles from food samples. Moreover, the principle, design, and advantages/disadvantages of each biosensing method are comprehensively described. This review covers the recent development of rapid and sensitive biosensors that can be used as new standards for monitoring food safety and food quality in the food industry.

Enzymatic Catalysis in Size and Volume Dual-Confined Space of Integrated Nanochannel-Electrodes Chip for Enhanced Impedance Detection of Salmonella

Nanochannel-based confinement effect is a fascinating signal transduction strategy for high-performance sensing, but only size confinement is focused on while other confinement effects are unexplored. Here, a highly integrated nanochannel-electrodes chip (INEC) is created and a size/volume-dual-confinement enzyme catalysis model for rapid and sensitive bacteria detection is developed. The INEC, by directly sandwiching a nanochannel chip (60 µm in thickness) in nanoporous gold layers, creates a micro-droplet-based confinement electrochemical cell (CEC). The size confinement of nanochannel promotes the urease catalysis efficiency to generate more ions, while the volume confinement of CEC significantly enriches ions by restricting diffusion. As a result, the INEC-based dual-confinement effects benefit a synergetic enhancement of the catalytic signal. A 11-times ion-strength-based impedance response is obtained within just 1 min when compared to the relevant open system. Combining this novel nanoconfinement effects with nanofiltration of INEC, a separation/signal amplification-integrated sensing strategy is further developed for Salmonella typhimurium detection. The biosensor realizes facile, rapid (<20 min), and specific signal readout with a detection limit of 9 CFU mL-1 in culturing solution, superior to most reports. This work may create a new paradigm for studying nanoconfined processes and contribute a new signal transduction technique for trace analysis application.

Simultaneous and Visual Detection of KPC and NDM Carbapenemase-Encoding Genes Using Asymmetric PCR and Multiplex Lateral Flow Strip

Carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae (CRE) infections constitute a threat to public health, and KPC and NDM are the major carbapenemases of concern. Rapid diagnostic tests are highly desirable in point-of-care (POC) and emergency laboratories with limited resources. Here, we developed a multiplex lateral flow assay based on asymmetric PCR and barcode capture probes for the simultaneous detection of KPC-2 and NDM-1. Biotinylated barcode capture probes corresponding to the KPC-2 and NDM-1 genes were designed and cast onto two different sensing zones of a nitrocellulose membrane after reacting with streptavidin to prepare a multiplex lateral flow strip. Streptavidin-coated gold nanoparticles (SA-AuNPs) were used as signal reporters. In response to the target carbapenemase genes, biotin-labelled ssDNA libraries were produced by asymmetric PCR, which bond to SA-AuNPs via biotin and hybridise with the barcode capture probe via a complementary sequence, thereby bridging SA-AuNPs and the barcode capture probe to form visible red lines on the detection zones. The signal intensities were proportional to the number of resistance genes tested. The strip sensor showed detection limits of 0.03 pM for the KPC-2 and 0.07 pM for NDM-1 genes, respectively, and could accurately distinguish between KPC-2 and NDM-1 genes in CRE strains. For the genotyping of clinical isolates, our strip exhibited excellent consistency with real-time fluorescent quantitative PCR and gene sequencing. Given its simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and rapid analysis accomplished by the naked eye, the multiplex strip is promising auxiliary diagnostic tool for KPC-2 and NDM-1 producers in routine clinical laboratories.

"Lock-and-key" recognizer-encoded lateral flow assays toward foodborne pathogen detection: An overview of their fundamentals and recent advances

In light of severe health risks of foodborne pathogenic bacterial diseases, the potential utility of point-of-care (POC) sensors is recognized for pathogens detection. In this regard, lateral flow assay (LFA) is a promising and user-friendly option for such application among various technological approaches. This article presents a comprehensive review of "lock-and-key" recognizer-encoded LFAs with respect to their working principles and detection performance against foodborne pathogenic bacteria. For this purpose, we describe various strategies for bacteria recognition including the antibody-based antigen-antibody interactions, nucleic acid aptamer-based recognition, and phage-mediated targeting of bacterial cells. In addition, we also outline the technological challenges along with the prospects for the future development of LFA in food analysis. The LFA devices built based upon many recognition strategies are found to have great potential for rapid, convenient, and effective POC detection of pathogens in complex food matrixes. Future developments in this field should emphasize the development of high-quality bio-probes, multiplex sensors, and intelligent portable readers.

Multiplex Detection of Infectious Diseases on Microfluidic Platforms

Infectious diseases contribute significantly to the global disease burden. Sensitive and accurate screening methods are some of the most effective means of identifying sources of infection and controlling infectivity. Conventional detecting strategies such as quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR), DNA sequencing, and mass spectrometry typically require bulky equipment and well-trained personnel. Therefore, mass screening of a large population using conventional strategies during pandemic periods often requires additional manpower, resources, and time, which cannot be guaranteed in resource-limited settings. Recently, emerging microfluidic technologies have shown the potential to replace conventional methods in performing point-of-care detection because they are automated, miniaturized, and integrated. By exploiting the spatial separation of detection sites, microfluidic platforms can enable the multiplex detection of infectious diseases to reduce the possibility of misdiagnosis and incomplete diagnosis of infectious diseases with similar symptoms. This review presents the recent advances in microfluidic platforms used for multiplex detection of infectious diseases, including microfluidic immunosensors and microfluidic nucleic acid sensors. As representative microfluidic platforms, lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) platforms, polymer-based chips, paper-based devices, and droplet-based devices will be discussed in detail. In addition, the current challenges, commercialization, and prospects are proposed to promote the application of microfluidic platforms in infectious disease detection.

A glass matrices-assisted quantum dots-based biosensor for selective capturing and detection of Escherichia coli

Bacterial contamination of water and food is a grave health concern rendering humans quite vulnerable to disease(s), and proving, at times, fatal too. Exploration of the novel diagnostic tools is, accordingly, highly called for to ensure rapid detection of the pathogenic bacteria, particularly Escherichia coli. The current manuscript, accordingly, reports the use of silane-functionalized glass matrices and antibody-conjugated cadmium telluride (CdTe) quantum dots (QDs) for efficient detection of E. coli. Synthesis of QDs (size: 5.4-6.8 nm) using mercaptopropionic acid (MPA) stabilizer yielded stable photoluminescence (∼62%), corroborating superior fluorescent characteristics. A test sample, when added to antibody-conjugated matrices, followed by antibody-conjugated CdTe-MPA QDs, formed a pathogen-antibody QDs complex. The latter, during confocal microscopy, demonstrated rapid detection of the selectively captured pathogenic bacteria (10 microorganism cells/10 μL) with enhanced sensitivity and specificity. The work, overall, encompasses establishment and design of an innovative detection platform in microbial diagnostics for rapid capturing of pathogens in water and food samples.

Development of efficient, sensitive, and specific detection method for Encephalomyocarditis virus based on CRISPR/Cas13a

The Encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) is one of the major zoonosis pathogens, and it can cause acute myocarditis in young pigs or reproductive failure in sows. EMCV has been recognized as a pathogen infecting many species and causes substantial economic losses worldwide. Therefore, the development of a rapid, sensitive, and accurate detection of this virus is essential for the diagnosis and control of the EMCV-induced disease. The RNA-guiding, RNA-targeting CRISPR effector CRISPR/Cas13a (Cas13a, previously known as C2c2) exhibits a "collateral effect" of promiscuous RNase activity upon the target recognition. When the crRNA of LwCas13a binds to the target RNA, the collateral cleavage activity of LwCas13a is activated to degrade the non-targeted RNA. In this study, we developed an efficient, sensitive, and specific EMCV detection method based on the collateral cleavage activity of LwCas13a by combining recombinase-aided amplification (RAA) and a lateral flow strip. This method was an isothermal detection at 37 °C, which allowed visual observation by the naked eyes. We also optimized the reaction conditions of this method, and the detection result could be obtained within 60 min. The sensitivity of our method reached up to 10¹ copies/µL. Furthermore, no cross-reactions with other 8 major swine viruses were observed, indicating the excellent specificity of this method. At the same time, the assay had a 100 % coincidence rate with qPCR detection of the EMCV in 37 clinical samples. In addition, our developed method requires only 2-step operations and basic equipment, and thus it is simple and inexpensive. Overall, CRISPR/Cas13a-based detection has a great application potential for the EMCV detection.

Nanozyme-encoded luminescent detection for food safety analysis: An overview of mechanisms and recent applications

With the rapid growth in global food production, delivery, and consumption, reformative food analytical techniques are required to satisfy the monitoring requirements of speed and high sensitivity. Nanozyme-encoded luminescent detections (NLDs) integrating nanozyme-based rapid detections with luminescent output signals have emerged as powerful methods for food safety monitoring, not only because of their preeminent performance in analysis, such as rapid, facile, low background signal, and ultrasensitive, but also due to their strong attractiveness for future sensing research. However, the lack of a full understanding of the fundamentals of NLDs for food safety detection technologies limits their further application. In this review, a systematic overview of the mechanisms of NLDs and their applications in the food industry is summarized, which covers the nanozyme-mimicking types and their luminescent signal generation mechanisms, as well as their applications in monitoring common foodborne contaminants. As demonstrated by previous studies, NLDs are bridging the gap to practical-oriented food analytical technologies and various opportunities to improve their food analytical performance to be considered in the future are proposed.

Flap Endonuclease-Induced Steric Hindrance Change Enables the Construction of Multiplex and Versatile Lateral Flow Strips for DNA Detection

A lateral flow strip (LFS) is an ideal tool for point-of-care testing (POCT), but traditional LFSs cannot be used for multiplex detection. Herein, a multiplex and versatile LFS based on flap endonuclease 1 (FEN1)-induced steric hindrance change (FISH-LFS) is proposed. In this method, multiplex PCR coupled with cascade invasive reactions was employed to yield single-stranded flaps, which were target-specific but independent of target sequences. Then, the amplicons were applied for FISH-LFS, and the single-stranded flaps would be efficiently captured by the complementary LFS-probes at different test lines. As flaps were cleaved from the specially designed hairpin probes, competition among flaps and hairpin probes would occur in capturing the probes at test lines. We enabled the hairpin probes to flow through the test lines while the flaps to stay at the test lines by making use of the difference in steric hindrance between hairpin probes and flaps. The assay is able to detect as low as two copies of blood pathogens (HBV, HCV, and HIV), to pick up as low as 0.1% mutants from wild-type gDNA, and to genotype 200 copies of SARS-CoV-2 variants α and β within 75 min at a conventional PCR engine. As the method is free of dye, a portable PCR engine could be used for a cost-effective multiplex detection on site. Results using an ultrafast mobile PCR system for FISH-LFS showed that as fast as 30 min was achieved for detecting three pathogens (HBV, HCV, and HIV) in blood, very suitable for POCT of pathogen screening. The method is convenient in operation, simple in instrumentation, specific in genotyping, and very easy in setting up multiplex POCT assays.

Advances in magnetic nanoparticles for the separation of foodborne pathogens: Recognition, separation strategy, and application

Foodborne pathogens contamination is one of the main sources of food safety problems. Although the existing detection methods have been developed for a long time, the complexity of food samples is still the main factor affecting the detection time and sensitivity, and the rapid separation and enrichment of pathogens is still an objective to be studied. Magnetic separation strategy based on magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) is considered to be an effective tool for rapid separation and enrichment of foodborne pathogens in food. Therefore, this study comprehensively reviews the development of MNPs in the separation of foodborne pathogens over the past decade. First, various biorecognition reagents for identification of foodborne pathogens and their modifications on the surface of MNPs are introduced. Then, the factors affecting the separation of foodborne pathogens, including the size of MNPs, modification methods, separation strategies and separation forms are discussed. Finally, the application of MNPs in integrated detection methods is reviewed. Moreover, current challenges and prospects of MNPs for the analysis of foodborne pathogens are discussed. Further research should focus on the design of multifunctional MNPs, the processing of large-scale samples, the simultaneous analysis of multiple targets, and the development of all-in-one small analytical device with separation and detection.

Research progress on detection techniques for point-of-care testing of foodborne pathogens

The global burden of foodborne disease is enormous and foodborne pathogens are the leading cause of human illnesses. The detection of foodborne pathogenic bacteria has become a research hotspot in recent years. Rapid detection methods based on immunoassay, molecular biology, microfluidic chip, metabolism, biosensor, and mass spectrometry have developed rapidly and become the main methods for the detection of foodborne pathogens. This study reviewed a variety of rapid detection methods in recent years. The research advances are introduced based on the above technical methods for the rapid detection of foodborne pathogenic bacteria. The study also discusses the limitations of existing methods and their advantages and future development direction, to form an overall understanding of the detection methods, and for point-of-care testing (POCT) applications to accurately and rapidly diagnose and control diseases.

Colorimetric Systems for the Detection of Bacterial Contamination: Strategy and Applications

Bacterial contamination is a public health concern worldwide causing enormous social and economic losses. For early diagnosis and adequate management to prevent or treat pathogen-related illnesses, extensive effort has been put into the development of pathogenic bacterial detection systems. Colorimetric sensing systems have attracted increasing attention due to their simple and single-site operation, rapid signal readout with the naked eye, ability to operate without external instruments, portability, compact design, and low cost. In this article, recent trends and advances in colorimetric systems for the detection and monitoring of bacterial contamination are reviewed. This article focuses on pathogen detection strategies and technologies based on reaction factors that affect the color change for visual readout. Reactions used in each strategy are introduced by dividing them into the following five categories: external pH change-induced pH indicator reactions, intracellular enzyme-catalyzed chromogenic reactions, enzyme-like nanoparticle (NP)-catalyzed substrate reactions, NP aggregation-based reactions, and NP accumulation-based reactions. Some recently developed colorimetric systems are introduced, and their challenges and strategies to improve the sensing performance are discussed.

When smartphone enters food safety: A review in on-site analysis for foodborne pathogens using smartphone-assisted biosensors

Pathogens are one of the supreme threats for the public health around the world in food supply chain. The on-site monitoring is an emerging trend for screening pathogens during the food processing and preserving. Traditional analytical tools have been unable to satisfy the current demands. Smartphones have enormous potentials for achieving on-site detection of foodborne pathogens, with intrinsic advantages such as small size, high accessibility, fast processing speed, and powerful imaging capacity. This review aims to synthesize the current advances in smartphone-assisted biosensors (SABs) for sensing foodborne pathogens, and briefly put forward the problem that consist in the research. We present the role of nanotechnology and recognition modes targeting foodborne pathogens in SABs, and discuss the signal conversion platforms coupling with smartphone. The challenges and perspectives in SABs are also proposed. The smartphone analytics area is moving forward, and it much be subject to careful quality standards and validation.

Colloidal silver-based lateral flow immunoassay for detection of profenofos pesticide residue in vegetables

A colloidal silver nanoparticle (AgNP)-based lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA) was evaluated in terms of the rapid detection of profenofos (PEO) pesticide residue in vegetables. Colloidal AgNPs, of a diameter of approximately 20 nm, were surface-modified with trisodium citrate dehydrate (TSC) in order to improve their stability and dispersion. An anti-profenofos polyclonal antibody (pAb) was successfully immobilized on the surface of the AgNPs by ionic interaction and characterized using UV-vis, SEM, TEM, FTIR and XPS analyses. Surface modification of Ag-pAb conjugates of varying pH, pAb content and cross-reactivity was employed to design and prepare labels for use in an LFIA to examine whether these factors affect the performance of the assay. The visible detection limit and optical detection limit of the PEO test strip were 0.20 and 0.01 ppm, respectively, in PEO standard solution. This assay showed no cross-reaction with omethoate, methamidophos or pyraclofos. Finally, the PEO test strip was effectively applied for the detection of PEO in liquid vegetables A and B, with optical detection limits of 0.09 and 0.075 ppm, respectively.

High-Sensitive Detection and Quantitative Analysis of Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone Using Gold-Nanoshell-Based Lateral Flow Immunoassay Device

Au nanoparticles (AuNPs) have been used as signal reporters in colorimetric lateral flow immunoassays (LFAs) for decades. However, it remains a major challenge to significantly improve the detection sensitivity of traditional LFAs due to the low brightness of AuNPs. As an alternative approach, we overcome this problem by utilizing 150 nm gold nanoshells (AuNSs) that were engineered by coating low-density silica nanoparticles with a thin layer of gold. AuNSs are dark green, have 14 times larger surface area, and are approximately 35 times brighter compared to AuNPs. In this study, we used detection of thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) in a proof-of-concept assay. The limit of detection (LOD) with AuNS-based LFA was 0.16 µIU/mL, which is 26 times more sensitive than the conventional colorimetric LFA that utilizes AuNP as a label. The dynamic range of the calibration curve was 0.16−9.5 µIU/mL, making it possible to diagnose both hyperthyroidism (<0.5 µIU/mL) and hypothyroidism (>5 µIU/mL) using AuNS-based LFA. Thus, the developed device has a strong potential for early screening and diagnosis of diseases related to the thyroid hormone.

An Overview for the Nanoparticles-Based Quantitative Lateral Flow Assay

The development of the lateral flow assay (LFA) has received much attention in both academia and industry because of their broad applications to food safety, environmental monitoring, clinical diagnosis, and so forth. The user friendliness, low cost, and easy operation are the most attractive advantages of the LFA. In recent years, quantitative detection has become another focus of LFA development. Here, the most recent studies of quantitative LFAs are reviewed. First, the principles and corresponding formats of quantitative LFAs are introduced. In the biomaterial and nanomaterial sections, the detection, capture, and signal amplification biomolecules and the optical, fluorescent, luminescent, and magnetic labels used in LFAs are described. The invention of dedicated strip readers has drawn further interest in exploiting the better performance of LFAs. Therefore, next, the development of dedicated reader devices is described and the usefulness and specifications of these devices for LFAs are discussed. Finally, the applications of LFAs in the detection of metal ions, biotoxins, pathogenic microorganisms, veterinary drugs, and pesticides in the fields of food safety and environmental health and the detection of nucleic acids, biomarkers, and viruses in clinical analyses are summarized.

Surface enhanced Raman scattering for the multiplexed detection of pathogenic microorganisms: towards point-of-use applications

Surface enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) is a technique that demonstrates a number of advantages for the rapid, specific and sensitive detection of pathogenic microorganisms. In this review, an overview of label-free and label-based SERS approaches, including microfluidics, nucleic acid detection and immunoassays, for the multiplexed detection of pathogenic bacteria and viruses from the last decade will be discussed, as well as their transition into promising point-of-use detection technologies in industrial and medical settings.

Application of microfluidic paper-based analytical device (μPAD) to detect COVID-19 in energy deprived countries

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) has spread all across the world. Low- and medium-income countries are more affected economically and socially compared to developed countries due to the lack of a rapid, robust, and affordable testing infrastructure. Furthermore, the high cost of real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) system, sophisticated user-handling procedure, and high expense of the conventional clinical tests are the root causes of the less accessibility of the testing systems to the users. In this study, a COVID-19 Point-of-Care (POC) ecosystem model is proposed for the low- and medium-income countries (or energy deprived countries) that will facilitate the technological development with locally available fabrication components. In addition, the nontechnological development phases have also been discussed, which encompasses the collaboration among academia, local as well as government bodies, and entrepreneurial ventures. In addition, a hypothetical design of a microfluidic paper-based analytical (μPADs) POC platform is proposed to detect COVID-19 analyte using unprocessed patient-derived saliva, which is a miniaturized form-factor of conventional real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) technique. The device contains four major reaction zones, which are sample zone, buffer zone, loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) Master Mix zone, Ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) zone, and sensor zone. To obtain quicker test results and easier operation, a handheld image acquisition technique is introduced in this study. It is hypothesized that in a remote setting, the proposed design could be used as an initial guideline to develop a POC COVID-19 testing system, which may be simple, easy-to-use, and cost-effective.

Disposable Paper-Based Biosensors for the Point-of-Care Detection of Hazardous Contaminations-A Review

The fast detection of trace amounts of hazardous contaminations can prevent serious damage to the environment. Paper-based sensors offer a new perspective on the world of analytical methods, overcoming previous limitations by fabricating a simple device with valuable benefits such as flexibility, biocompatibility, disposability, biodegradability, easy operation, large surface-to-volume ratio, and cost-effectiveness. Depending on the performance type, the device can be used to analyze the analyte in the liquid or vapor phase. For liquid samples, various structures (including a dipstick, as well as microfluidic and lateral flow) have been constructed. Paper-based 3D sensors are prepared by gluing and folding different layers of a piece of paper, being more user-friendly, due to the combination of several preparation methods, the integration of different sensor elements, and the connection between two methods of detection in a small set. Paper sensors can be used in chromatographic, electrochemical, and colorimetric processes, depending on the type of transducer. Additionally, in recent years, the applicability of these sensors has been investigated in various applications, such as food and water quality, environmental monitoring, disease diagnosis, and medical sciences. Here, we review the development (from 2010 to 2021) of paper methods in the field of the detection and determination of toxic substances.

Current State of Development of Biosensors and Their Application in Foodborne Pathogen Detection

ABSTRACT

Foodborne disease outbreaks continue to be a major public health and food safety concern. Testing products promptly can protect consumers from foodborne diseases by ensuring the safety of food before retail distribution. Fast, sensitive, and accurate detection tools are in great demand. Therefore, various approaches have been explored recently to find a more effective way to incorporate antibodies, oligonucleotides, phages, and mammalian cells as signal transducers and analyte recognition probes on biosensor platforms. The ultimate goal is to achieve high specificity and low detection limits (1 to 100 bacterial cells or piconanogram concentrations of toxins). Advancements in mammalian cell-based and bacteriophage-based sensors have produced sensors that detect low levels of pathogens and differentiate live from dead cells. Combinations of biotechnology platforms have increased the practical utility and application of biosensors for detection of foodborne pathogens. However, further rigorous testing of biosensors with complex food matrices is needed to ensure the utility of these sensors for point-of-care needs and outbreak investigations.

HIGHLIGHTS

Rapid detection of extended spectrum β-lactamase producing Escherichia coli isolated from fresh pork meat and pig cecum samples using multiplex recombinase polymerase amplification and lateral flow strip analysis

The emergence and dissemination of extended-spectrum β-lactamase (ESBL)-producing Escherichia coli is a global health issue. Food-producing animals, including pigs, are significant reservoirs of antimicrobial resistance (AMR), which can be transmitted to humans. Thus, the rapid detection of ESBLs is required for efficient epidemiological control and treatment. In this study, multiplex recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) combined with a single-stranded tag hybridization chromatographic printed-array strip (STH-PAS), as a lateral flow strip assay (LFA), was established for the rapid and simultaneous detection of multiple bla genes in a single reaction. Visible blue lines, indicating the presence of the bla_CTX-M, bla_SHV, and bla_OXA genes, were observed within 10 min by the naked eye. The limit of detection of all three genes was 2.5 ng/25 μL, and no cross-reactivity with seven commensal aerobic bacteria was observed. A total of 93.9% (92/98) and 96% (48/50) of the E. coli isolates from pork meat and fecal samples, respectively, expressed an ESBL-producing phenotype. Nucleotide sequencing of the PCR amplicons showed that bla_CTX-M was the most prevalent type (91.3–95.83%), of which the main form was bla_CTX-M-55. The sensitivity and specificity of the RPA-LFA were 99.2% and 100%, respectively, and were in almost perfect agreement (κ = 0.949–1.000) with the results from PCR sequencing. Thus, the RPA-LFA is a promising tool for rapid and equipment-free ESBL detection and may facilitate clinical diagnosis in human and veterinary medicine, as well as AMR monitoring and surveillance.

Paper-based colorimetric detection of pathogenic bacteria in food through magnetic separation and enzyme-mediated signal amplification on paper disc

Herein, we report a colorimetric sensing system for the detection of highly virulent bacteria, Escherichiacoli O157:H7, in sausage by utilizing magnetic separation and enzyme-mediated signal amplification on paper disc. For magnetic separation, Poly-l-lysine coated starch magnetic particles (PLL@SMPs) were synthesized and utilized for the separation and concentration of the bacteria in sample suspension. Horseradish peroxidase-conjugated antibody (HRP-Antibody) and 3,3',5,5'- tetramethylbenzidine (TMB) were employed for the specific signal amplification in the presence of target bacteria. The synthesized PLL@SMPs showed an excellent capture efficiency (>90%) for the pathogenic bacteria in large volume sample suspension. The intrinsic problems associated with the non-specific binding of sensing components that lead to the high background signal and low sensitivity in colorimetric detection was successfully resolved by employing hyaluronic acid as a blocking agent. The effective separation and concentration of target bacteria by PLL@SMPs and target-specific signal amplification with exceptionally high signal to noise ratio enabled the detection of target bacteria with a detection limit in the single digit regime. The sensing system proposed in this study was successfully used for the detection of the target pathogenic bacteria, E. coli O157:H7, in sausage sample with the limit of detection (LOD) as low as 30.8 CFU/mL with 95% probability. The simple nature of paper-based detection system with a great sensitivity and specificity would provide an effective means of evaluating the safety of food and environmental samples.

Molecularly imprinted polymer-enhanced biomimetic paper-based analytical devices: A review

The popularization of paper-based analytical devices (PADs) in analytical science has fostered research on enhancing their analytical performance for accurate and sensitive assays. With their superb recognition capability and structural stability, molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) have been extensively employed as biomimetic receptors for capturing target analytes in various complex matrices. The integration of MIPs as recognition elements with PADs (MIP-PADs) has opened new opportunities for advanced analytical devices with elevated selectivity and sensitivity, as well as a shorter assay time and a lower cost. This review covers recent advances in MIP-PAD fabrication and engineering based on multifarious signal transduction systems such as colorimetry, fluorescence, electrochemistry, photoelectrochemistry, and chemiluminescence. The application of MIP-PADs in the fields of biomedical diagnostics, environmental analysis, and food safety monitoring is also reviewed. Further, the advantages, challenges, and perspectives of MIP-PADs are discussed.

Recent advances in sensitivity enhancement for lateral flow assay

Conventional lateral flow assay (LFA) is typically performed by observing the color changes in the test lines by naked eyes, which achieves considerable commercial success and has a significant impact on the fields of food safety, environment monitoring, disease diagnosis, and other applications. However, this qualitative detection method is not very suitable for low levels of disease biomarkers' detection. Although many nanomaterials are used as new labels for LFA, additional readers limit their application to some extent. Fortunately, a lot of work has been done for improving the sensitivity of LFA. In this review, currently reported LFA sensitivity enhancement methods with an objective evaluation are summarized, such as sample pretreatment, the change of flow rate, and label evolution, and future development direction and challenges of LFAs are discussed.

Modular design of paper based switches for autonomous lab-on paper micro devices

This paper presents a new approach towards the design of paper based autonomous microfluidic devices. Autonomy in the device operation is achieved through the incorporation of mechanically actuated microfluidic switches that are versatile in their design and may be configured to be simple time triggered ON or OFF switches or more complex switches that can be timed to be in multiple states (timed ON, followed by timed OFF). These switches are self-contained and require no external power for their operation, deriving their functionality solely through stored elastic energy. This paper presents the design and fabrication of these switches as fluidic analogs of electronic transistors, and their integration into microfluidic paper based circuit demonstrating their operation as a programmable paper-based microfluidic device.

Immunoassay Biosensing of Foodborne Pathogens with Surface Plasmon Resonance Imaging: A Review

Surface plasmon resonance imaging (SPRi) has been increasingly used in the label-free detections of various biospecies, such as organic toxins, proteins, and bacteria. In combination with the well-developed microarray immunoassay, SPRi has the advantages of rapid detection in tens of minutes and multiplex detection of different targets with the same biochip. Both prism-based and prism-free configurations of SPRi have been developed for highly integrated portable immunosensors, which have shown great potential on pathogen detection and living cell imaging. This review summarizes the recent advances in immunoassay biosensing with SPRi, with special emphasis on the multiplex detections of foodborne pathogens. Additionally, various spotting techniques, surface modification protocols, and signal amplification methods have been developed to improve the specificity and sensitivity of the SPRi biochip. The challenges in multiplex detections of foodborne pathogens in real-world samples are addressed, and future perspectives of miniaturizing SPRi immunosensors with nanotechnologies are discussed.

Tutorial: design and fabrication of nanoparticle-based lateral-flow immunoassays

Lateral-flow assays (LFAs) are quick, simple and cheap assays to analyze various samples at the point of care or in the field, making them one of the most widespread biosensors currently available. They have been successfully employed for the detection of a myriad of different targets (ranging from atoms up to whole cells) in all type of samples (including water, blood, foodstuff and environmental samples). Their operation relies on the capillary flow of the sample throughout a series of sequential pads, each with different functionalities aiming to generate a signal to indicate the absence/presence (and, in some cases, the concentration) of the analyte of interest. To have a user-friendly operation, their development requires the optimization of multiple, interconnected parameters that may overwhelm new developers. In this tutorial, we provide the readers with: (i) the basic knowledge to understand the principles governing an LFA and to take informed decisions during lateral flow strip design and fabrication, (ii) a roadmap for optimal LFA development independent of the specific application, (iii) a step-by-step example procedure for the assembly and operation of an LF strip for the detection of human IgG and (iv) an extensive troubleshooting section addressing the most frequent issues in designing, assembling and using LFAs. By changing only the receptors, the provided example procedure can easily be adapted for cost-efficient detection of a broad variety of targets.

Gold Nanoparticle-Coated Starch Magnetic Beads for the Separation, Concentration, and SERS-Based Detection of E. coli O157:H7

Here, we report gold nanoparticle-coated starch magnetic beads (AuNP@SMBs) that were prepared by in situ synthesis of AuNPs on the surface of SMBs. Upon functionalization of the surface with a specific antibody, the immuno-AuNP@SMBs were found to be effective in separating and concentrating the target pathogenic bacteria, Escherichia coli O157:H7, from an aqueous sample as well as providing a hotspot for surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS)-based detection. We employed a bifunctional linker protein, 4× gold-binding peptide-tagged Streptococcal protein G (4GS), to immobilize antibodies on AuNP@SMBs and AuNPs in an oriented form. The linker protein also served as a Raman reporter, exhibiting a strong and unique fingerprint signal during the SERS measurement. The amplitude of the SERS signal was shown to have a good correlation with the concentration of target bacteria ranging from 10⁰ to 10⁵ CFU/mL. The detection limit was determined to be as low as a single cell, and the background signals derived from nontarget bacteria were negligible due to the excellent specificity and colloidal stability of the immuno-AuNP@SMBs and SERS tags. The highly sensitive nature of the SERS-based detection system will provide a promising means to detect the pathogenic microorganisms in food or clinical specimen.

Paper-Based Radial Chromatographic Immunoassay for the Detection of Pathogenic Bacteria in Milk

Here, a paper-based radial flow chromatographic immunoassay (RFCI) employing gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) as chromatic agents was developed for the detection of Escherichia coli O157:H7 in whole milk. A 4-repeated gold-binding peptide-tagged (4GBP) streptococcal protein G (SPG) fusion protein was constructed as a bifunctional linker to immobilize antibodies on the surface of AuNPs with a well-oriented form based on the specific affinity of GBP and SPG to the gold and Fc portion of the antibody, respectively. 4GS@AuNPs prepared with the bifunctional linker protein exhibited excellent colloidal stability even at high salt concentrations of up to 500 mM, which is a critical requirement for its application to a broad range of biological and food samples. The enhanced colloidal stability and excellent binding capability of the immuno-4GS@AuNPs toward target bacteria lowered the detection limit of RFCI for target pathogenic bacteria in whole milk as low as 10³ CFU/mL, which is by an order of magnitude lower than that of conventional immuno-AuNPs prepared with physical adsorption of antibodies. The RFCI pattern could also be converted into a grayscale value by simple image processing for quantitative determination of target pathogenic bacteria. This paper-based detection system would provide an effective means of monitoring the presence of food-borne pathogens in real food samples with naked eyes.

A sample-to-answer, portable platform for rapid detection of pathogens with a smartphone interface

Emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases pose global threats to human health. Although several conventional diagnostic methods have been widely adopted in the clinic, the long turn-around times of "gold standard" culture-based techniques, as well as the limited sensitivity of lateral-flow strip assays, thwart medical progress. In this study, a smartphone-controlled, automated, and portable system was developed for rapid molecular diagnosis of pathogens (including viruses and bacteria) via the use of a colorimetric loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) approach on a passive, self-driven microfluidic device. The system was capable of 1) purifying viral or bacterial samples with specific affinity reagents that had been pre-conjugated to magnetic beads, 2) lysing pathogens at low temperatures, 3) executing isothermal nucleic acid amplification, and 4) quantifying the results of colorimetric assays for detection of pathogens with an integrated color sensor. The entire, 40 min analytical process was automatically performed with a novel punching-press mechanism that could be controlled and monitored by a smartphone. As a proof of concept, the influenza A (H1N1) virus and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus bacteria were used to characterize and optimize the device, and the limits of detection were experimentally found to be 3.2 × 10^-3 hemagglutinating units (HAU) per reaction and 30 colony-forming units (CFU) per reaction, respectively; both such values represent high enough sensitivity for clinical adoption. Moreover, the colorimetric assay could be both qualitative and quantitative for detection of pathogens. This is the first instance of an easy-to-use, automated, and portable system for accurate and sensitive molecular diagnosis of either viruses or bacteria, and it is envisioned that this smartphone-controlled apparatus may serve as a platform for clinical, point-of-care pathogen detection, particularly in resource-limited settings.

Effect of Lecithin on the Spontaneous Crystallization of Enzymatically Synthesized Short-Chain Amylose Molecules into Spherical Microparticles

Here, we report a facile and effective one-pot approach to prepare uniform amylose-based polymeric microparticles (PMPs) through enzymatic synthesis of short-chain amylose (SCA) followed by spontaneous self-assembly of the SCA in the presence of lecithin. The effect of lecithin on nucleation and growth kinetics of amylose microparticles was investigated by monitoring the turbidity of reaction solution and the size of particles over the course of the self-assembly process. The results suggest that lecithin played a critical role in controlling the self-assembly kinetics to form uniform amylose microparticles through steric stabilization of the growing particles and diffusion-limited growth effect. The crystallinity of amylose microparticles was not affected by lecithin, implying that lecithin did not disrupt the crystal structure within the particle and would mainly be present on the surface of the microparticles. Considering its biodegradable and biocompatible nature, the amylose-based microparticles would find a range of useful applications in the area of food, cosmetics, medicine, chromatography and other related materials sciences.