Subcellular distribution, chemical forms and thiol synthesis involved in cadmium tolerance and detoxification in Siegesbeckia orientalis L

Cadmium induced changes in rhizosphere microecology to enhance Cd intake by Ligusticum sinense cv. Chuanxiong

As the most famous and widely used traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), Ligusticum sinense cv. Chuanxiong (L. Chuaniong) has been affected by cadmium (Cd) exceeding with high ability of Cd accumulation. There is relatively little research on Cd absorption and storage process in L. Chuanxiong, which is an important reason for the poor remediation efficiency. Hence, this study takes L. Chuanxiong as the point of penetration to explore how L. Chuanxiong affects rhizobacteria through root exudates to alter soil Cd intake, as well as to explore the migration and storage of Cd in its body with 0.10 (T0), 5.00 (T5), 10.00 (T10) mg/kg Cd contaminations. The results showed that the relative abundance of amino acids and phospholipids secreted from L. Chuanxiong root noticeably increased with increasing Cd levels, which directly activated soil Cd or extremely significantly (P < 0.01) recruited bacteria such as Bacillus, Arthrobacter to indirectly increase Cd availability. Under the interaction of root exudates and rhizobacteria, Cd bioavailability increased by 80.00% in rhizosphere soil and Cd accumulation in L. Chuanxiong increased 5.44-6.65 mg/kg. Cd subcellular distribution analysis demonstrated that Cd was mainly stored in the root (10-fold more than in the leaf), whose Cd content was cytoderm>cytoplasm>organelle in tissues. The sequential extraction results found that non-soluble phosphate and protein-chelated Cd dominated (85.00-90.00%) in the cell, while Cd cheated with alcohol soluble protein, amino acid salts, water-soluble organic acid in cell was minimal (5.50%). The phenomenon indicated that L. Chuanxiong fixed Cd in root (the medical part) with low translocation ability. This study can provide theoretical support for the high-quality production of L. Chuanxiong and other root medical plant in heavy metal influenced sites.

Strontium alleviated the growth inhibition and toxicity caused by cadmium in rice seedlings

Cadmium (Cd) contamination of rice is an urgent ecological and agricultural problem. Strontium (Sr) has been shown to promote plant growth. However, the effect of Sr on rice seedlings under Cd stress is currently unclear. In this work hydroponic experiments were used to assess the impact of Sr on rice seedling growth under Cd stress. The findings demonstrated that foliar application of 0.5 mg L-1 Sr had no discernible impact on the development of rice seedlings. However, Sr significantly alleviated growth inhibition and toxicity in rice seedlings when threatened by Cd. Compared with the Cd treatment (Cd, 2.5 mg L-1), the root length, shoot height, and whole plant length of rice seedlings in the Cd + Sr treatment (Cd, 2.5 mg L-1; Sr, 0.5 mg L-1) increased by 4.96 %, 12.47 % and 9.60 %, respectively. The content of Cd in rice decreased by 23.34 % (roots) and 5.79 % (shoots). Sr lessened the degree of membrane lipid peroxidation damage (lower MDA concentration) among the seedlings of rice under Cd stress by controlling the activities of antioxidant enzymes and GSH content. By changing the expression of antioxidant enzyme-encoding genes and downregulating the heavy metal transporter gene (OsNramp5), Sr reduced accumulation and the detrimental effects of Cd on rice seedlings. Our study provides a new solution to the problem of Cd contamination in rice, which may promote the safe production of rice and benefit human health.

Effects of microplastics on the phytoremediation of Cd, Pb, and Zn contaminated soils by Solanum photeinocarpum and Lantana camara

Microplastics are emerging pollutants and have become a global environmental issue. The impacts of microplastics on the phytoremediation of heavy metal-contaminated soils are unclear. A pot experiment was conducted to investigate the effects of four additions (0, 0.1%, 0.5%, and 1% w·w-1) of polyethylene (PE) and cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn) contaminated soil on the growth and heavy metal accumulation of two hyperaccumulators (Solanum photeinocarpum and Lantana camara). PE significantly decreased the pH and activities of dehydrogenase and phosphatase in soil, while it increased the bioavailability of Cd and Pb in soil. Peroxidase (POD), catalase (CAT), and malondialdehyde (MDA) activity in the plant leaves were all considerably increased by PE. PE had no discernible impact on plant height, but it did significantly impede root growth. PE affected the morphological contents of heavy metals in soils and plants, while it did not alter their proportions. PE increased the content of heavy metals in the shoots and roots of the two plants by 8.01-38.32% and 12.24-46.28%, respectively. However, PE significantly reduced the Cd extraction amount in plant shoots, while it significantly increased the Zn extraction amount in the plant roots of S. photeinocarpum. For L. camara, a lower addition (0.1%) of PE inhibited the extraction amount of Pb and Zn in the plant shoots, but a higher addition (0.5% and 1%) of PE stimulated the Pb extraction amount in the plant roots and the Zn extraction amount in the plant shoots. Our results indicated that PE microplastics have negative effects on the soil environment, plant growth, and the phytoremediation efficiency of Cd and Pb. These findings contribute to a better knowledge of the interaction effects of microplastics and heavy metal-contaminated soils.

Cichorium intybus L. is a potential Cd-accumulator for phytoremediation of agricultural soil with strong tolerance and detoxification to Cd

Identifying suitable plants for phytoremediation of Cd (cadmium) contaminated agricultural soil is critical. In this study, whether chicory (Cichorium intybus L.) qualified as an ideal accumulator for phytoremediation was investigated. The hydroponic and pot experiments showed that Cd concentration in chicory leaves exceeded 100 mg kg-1 (BCF >1, TF >1) with 40 mg kg-1 Cd in pot; No significant effects on chicory growth, leaf protein and physiological and biochemical aspects when treated with ≤ 20 μM or 40 mg kg-1 Cd, because chicory could relieve Cd toxicity by increasing activities of photoprotection mechanisms, the reactive oxygen species scavenging system and concentrations of functional groups in plant tissues. In field experiment, 16.2 and 26.6 t ha-1 of chicory leaves was harvested in winter and summer, respectively. The highest Cd concentration in leaves was close to 25.0 mg kg-1 (BCF >1, TF >1) from the acid soil with 0.980 mg kg-1 Cd. Over 320 g ha-1 Cd was extracted from soil by harvesting chicory leaves both in winter and summer, with 9.24% and 12.9% of theoretical phytoremediation efficiency. Therefore, chicory can be as an ideal Cd-accumulator for phytoremediation of slight-to-moderate Cd-contaminated agricultural soil in any season.

Hydrogen peroxide mediates cadmium accumulation in the root of a high cadmium-accumulating rice (Oryza sativa L.) line

Hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) is a vital signaling molecule in response to cadmium (Cd) stress in plants. However, the role of H₂O₂ on Cd accumulation in root of different Cd-accumulating rice lines remains unclear. Exogenous H₂O₂ and 4-hydroxy-TEMPO (H₂O₂ scavenger) were applied to investigate the physiological and molecular mechanisms of H₂O₂ on Cd accumulation in the root of a high Cd-accumulating rice line Lu527-8 through hydroponic experiments. Interestingly, it was found Cd concentration in the root of Lu527-8 increased significantly when exposed to exogenous H₂O₂, while reduced significantly when exposed to 4-hydroxy-TEMPO under Cd stress, proving the role of H₂O₂ in regulating Cd accumulation in Lu527-8. Lu527-8 showed more Cd and H₂O₂ accumulation in the roots, along with more Cd accumulation in cell wall and soluble fraction, than the normal rice line Lu527-4. In particular, more pectin accumulation, especially low demethylated pectin, was observed in the root of Lu527-8 when exposed to exogenous H₂O₂ under Cd stress, resulting in more negative functional groups with greater capacity to binding Cd in the root cell wall of Lu527-8. It indicated that H₂O₂-induced cell wall modification and vacuolar compartmentalization contributes greatly to more Cd accumulation in the root of the high Cd-accumulating rice line.

Biochar and nano-ferric oxide synergistically alleviate cadmium toxicity of muskmelon

Cadmium is toxic to plants. The accumulation of cadmium in edible plants such as muskmelon may affect the safe production of crops and result in human health problem. Thus effective measures are urgently needed for soil remediation. This work aims to investigate the effects of nano-ferric oxide and biochar alone or mixture on muskmelon under cadmium stress. The results of growth and physiological indexes showed that compared with the application of cadmium alone, the composite treatment (biochar and nano-ferric oxide) decreased malondialdehyde content by 59.12% and ascorbate peroxidase activity increased by 276.6%. Their addition can increase the stress resistance of plants. The results of soil analysis and cadmium content determination in plants showed that the composite treatment was beneficial to reduce the cadmium content in various parts of muskmelon. In the presence of high concentration of cadmium, the Target Hazard Quotient value of peel and flesh of muskmelon in the composite treatment was less than 1, which means the edible risk was greatly reduced. Furthermore, the addition of composite treatment increased the content of effective components; the contents of polyphenols, flavonoids, and saponins in the flesh of the compound treatment were increased by 99.73%, 143.07%, and 18.78% compared with the cadmium treatment. The results provide a technical reference for the further application of biochar combined with nano-ferric oxide in the field of soil heavy metal remediation, and provide a theoretical basis for further research on reducing the toxicity of cadmium to plants and improving the edible quality of crops.

Activation and tolerance of Siegesbeckia Orientalis L. rhizosphere to Cd stress

This experiment investigated the changes of rhizosphere soil microenvironment for hyperaccumulation-soil system under Cd stress in order to reveal the mechanism of hyperaccumulation and tolerance. Thus, Cd fractions, chemical compositions, and biochemical characteristics in rhizosphere soil of Siegesbeckia orientalis L. under Cd stress conditions of 0, 5, 10, 25, 50, 100, and 150 mg kg-1 were investigated through a root bag experiment, respectively. As a result, Cd induced the acidification of S. orientalis rhizosphere soil, and promoted the accumulation of dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and readily oxidizable organic carbon (ROC), which increased by 28.39% and 6.98% at the maximum compared with control. The percentage of labile Cd (acid-soluble and reducible Cd) in soil solution increased significantly (P < 0.05) from 31.87% to 64.60% and from 26.00% to 34.49%, respectively. In addition, rhizosphere microenvironment can alleviate the inhibition of Cd on soil microorganisms and enzymes compare with bulk soils. Under medium and low concentrations of Cd, the rhizosphere soil microbial biomass carbon (MBC), basal respiration, ammonification and nitrification were significantly increased (P < 0.05), and the activities of key enzymes were not significantly inhibited. This suggests that pH reduction and organic carbon (DOC and ROC) accumulation increase the bioavailability of Cd and may have contributed to Cd accumulation in S. orientalis. Moreover, microorganisms and enzymes in rhizosphere soils can enhance S. orientalis tolerance to Cd, alleviating the nutrient imbalance and toxicity caused by Cd pollution. This study revealed the changes of physicochemical and biochemical properties of rhizosphere soil under Cd stress. Rhizosphere soil acidification and organic carbon accumulation are key factors promoting Cd activation, and microorganisms and enzymes are the responses of Cd tolerance.

Subcellular distribution, chemical forms of cadmium and rhizosphere microbial community in the process of cadmium hyperaccumulation in duckweed

Duckweed is a newly reported Cd hyperaccumulator that grow rapidly; however, little is known about its tolerance and detoxification mechanisms. In this study, we investigated the tissue, subcellular, and chemical form distribution of the Cd in duckweed and studied the influences of Cd on duckweed growth, ultrastructure, and rhizosphere microbial community. The results showed that Cd could negatively affect the growth of duckweed and shorten the root length. More Cd accumulated in the roots than in the leaves, and Cd was transferred from the roots to the leaves with time. During 12-24 h, Cd mainly existed in the cell wall fraction (2.05 %-95.52 %) and the organelle fraction (5.03 %-97.80 %), followed the soluble fraction (0.14 %-16.98 %). Over time, the proportion of Cd in the organelles increased (46.64 %-92.83 %), exceeding that in the cell wall (6.79 %-66.23 %), which indicated that duckweed detoxification mechanism may be related to the retention of cell wall and vacuole. The main chemical form of Cd was the NaCl-extracted state (30.15 %-88.66 %), which was integrated with pectate and protein. With increasing stress concentration and time, the proportion of the HCl-extracted state and HAc-extracted state increased, and they were low-toxic Cd oxalate and Cd phosphate, respectively. Cd damaged the ultrastructure of cells such as chloroplasts and mitochondria and inhibited the diversity of microbial communities in the duckweed rhizosphere; however, the dominant populations that could tolerate heavy metals increased. It was speculated that duckweed distributed Cd in a less toxic chemical form in a less active location, mainly through retention in the root cell wall and sequestration in the leaf vacuoles, and is dynamically adjusted. The rhizosphere microbial communities tolerate heavy metals may also be one of the mechanisms by which duckweed can tolerate Cd. This study revealed the mechanism of duckweed tolerance and detoxification of Cd at the molecular level and provides a theoretical basis for further development of duckweed.

The Cd sequestration effects of rice roots affected by different Si management in Cd-contaminated paddy soil

The application of exogenous silicon (Si) reportedly is one of the eco-friendly practices to mitigate cadmium (Cd) phytotoxicity and regulate the chemical behaviors of Cd in the soil-rice system. But the efficiency of Si on the Cd retention by rice root varies with the Si fertilizer management. The objective of this paper was to interpret the differences in Cd immobilization by rice roots and relevant mechanisms under different ways of Si application (T-Si, supplied at transplanting stage; TJ-Si, split at transplanting and jointing stage with the ratio of 50 % to 50 %; J-Si, supplied at jointing stage and CK, none of Si application) in Cd-contaminated paddy soils. The results showed that the Cd-retention capacity of rice root was increased by 0.60 % ~ 3.06 % under different Si management when compared to CK. The concentrations of monosilicic acid in soils and in apoplast and symplast of roots were increased significantly by Si application, while Cd concentrations in apoplast and symplast of root were decreased by 28.50 % (T-Si), 40.64 % (TJ-Si) and 30.26 % (J-Si), respectively. The distribution of Cd in rice cell wall was increased significantly by TJ-Si. The Cd concentrations of inert fractions (F3, F4 and F6) in root of TJ-Si were raised obviously. Si application downregulated the expression of OsIRT2 and OsNramp5 while upregulated OsHMA3, and the expression of OsHMA3 treated by TJ-Si was obviously higher than CK and J-Si. The distributions of the passive Cd in roots bound with thiol compounds (NPT, GSH and PCs) and polysaccharide components (pectin, hemicelluloses 1 and hemicellulose 2) were raised much more by TJ-Si than by T-Si and J-Si. On the whole, compared with T-Si and J-Si, TJ-Si could more easily replenish soil available Si and enhance Cd sequestration in roots as the result of the decrease of Cd transport factor in roots. This study unravels some mechanisms about different Si management on increasing Cd retention and decreasing Cd migration in rice roots, and TJ-Si is worthy of being recommended.

The positive effects of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi inoculation and/or additional aeration on the purification efficiency of combined heavy metals in vertical flow constructed wetlands

Inoculation with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) and additional aeration (AA), as two approaches to improve the functioning of treatment wetlands, can further promote the capacity of wetlands to purify pollutants. The extent to which, and mechanisms by which, AMF and AA purify wetlands polluted by combined heavy metals (HMs) are not well understood. In this study, the effects and mechanisms of AMF and/or AA on combined HMs removal in vertical flow constructed wetlands (VFCWs) with the Phragmites australis (reeds) were investigated at different HMs concentrations. The results showed that (1) AA improved the AMF colonization in VFCWs and AMF accumulated the combined HMs in their structures; (2) AMF inoculation and/or AA significantly promoted the reeds growth and antioxidant enzymes activities, thereby alleviating oxidative stress; (3) AMF inoculation and AA significantly enhanced the removal rates of Pb, Zn, Cu, and Cd under the stress of high combined HMs concentrations comparing to the control check (CK) treatment (autoclaved AMF inoculation and no aeration), which increased by 22.72%, 30.31%, 12.64%, and 50.22%, respectively; (4) AMF inoculation and/or AA significantly promoted the combined HMs accumulation in plant roots and substrates and altered the distribution of HMs at the subcellular level. We therefore conclude that AMF inoculation and/or AA in VFCWs improves the purification of combined HM-polluted water, and the VFCWs-reeds-AMF/AA associations exhibit great potential for application in remediation of combined HM-polluted wastewater.

Characteristics of cadmium translocation and isotope fractionation in Ricinus communis seedlings: Effects from split/cut-root and limited nutrients

Studying cadmium (Cd) transport in plants will improve the current understanding of Cd tolerance mechanisms. Due to the influence of analytical techniques, the application of Cd isotopes in plants is still in its early stages. Therefore, the relationships between Cd isotope fractionation and Cd translocation in plants remain unclear. In this study, we cultured Ricinus communis in hydroponic solutions during split/cut-root experiments and limited and infinite nutrient experiments. To understand the Cd transport process, the Cd²⁺ and other ion concentrations in different tissues (i.e., roots, stems, and leaves) and nutrient solutions, Cd isotope composition and the soluble protein in tissues were measured. The results showed that although significant effects were evident in the top leaves, the principal roots had less pronounced effects on Cd²⁺ translocation in the stems. Moreover, Cd underwent homolateral transport before it was translocated from the principal roots to the leaves on the side without Cd. It was apparent that the stems were responsible for translocating Cd²⁺ in plants. In addition, the continuous supply of high Cd²⁺ concentrations inhibited the growth of the top leaves, while in low Cd²⁺ concentrations, it was gradually transferred to the top leaves. Moreover, the tissues of R. communis were enriched with lighter Cd isotopes compared with the solutions. The clear differences between the Cd isotope fractionation of leaves under infinite and limited nutrient experiments may be attributed to plant growth and Cd uptake rates. This study provides important information for understanding Cd²⁺ translocation in R. communis and furthers our understanding of its tolerance and hyperaccumulation.

Unraveling the effects of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on cadmium uptake and detoxification mechanisms in perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne)

Cadmium (Cd) is a major environmental pollutant and one of the most toxic metals in the environment. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) assisted phytoremediation can be used to remove Cd from polluted soils but the role of AMF, which mediate in Cd accumulation and tolerance, remains poorly understood. Here we inoculated Lolium perenne with two different AMF species (Glomus etunicatum and Glomus mosseae). Mycorrhizal L. perenne and non-mycorrhizal controls were exposed to Cd stress and we tested the effects of AMF mycorrhization on Cd uptake and subsequent tolerance, as well as the underlying mechanisms. Mycorrhizal infection increased root Cd²⁺ uptake and we observed that net Cd²⁺ influx was coupled with net Ca²⁺ influx. The inactivation of Ca²⁺ transporter channels decreased Cd²⁺ uptake in non-inoculated roots to a greater extent than in inoculated roots, indicating that AMF activates additional ion transport channels. In consequence, inoculated plants exhibited higher Cd accumulation in both roots and shoots than non-inoculated controls. However, AMF-inoculated plants showed higher chlorophyll concentrations, photosynthesis, and growth under Cd, indicating lower Cd toxicity in AMF-inoculated plants, despite the increase in Cd uptake. We observed that AMF-inoculated favored the isolation of Cd within cell walls and vacuoles, and had higher concentrations of superoxide dismutase activity and glutathione concentration in roots than non-inoculated plants, consequently experiencing less stress upon Cd exposure. Our results highlight the potential and mechanism of AMF for enhancing phytoremediation of L. perenne in heavy metal contaminated environments.

Effect of exogenous silicon and methyl jasmonate on the alleviation of cadmium-induced phytotoxicity in tomato plants

In the present study, a hydroponic experiment was performed to evaluate the effect of exogenous silicon (Si) and methyl jasmonate (MeJA) on the mitigation of Cd toxicity in tomato seedlings. The results revealed that Cd-stressed plants exhibited growth inhibition, increased lipid peroxidation, and impaired photosynthetic pigment accumulation. However, Si and MeJA applied alone or in combination significantly ameliorated the above-mentioned adverse effects induced by Cd. Among all treatments, Cd+Si+MeJA treatment elevated the dry mass of roots, stems, and leaves by 317.39%, 110.85%, and 119.71%, respectively. The chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, and carotenoid contents in Cd+Si+MeJA-treated group were dramatically elevated (p < 0.05). Meanwhile, the malondialdehyde content in roots and shoots were reduced by 32.24% and 69.94%, respectively. The Si and MeJA applied separately or in combination also resulted in a prominent decrease of Cd influxes in tomato roots; therefore, a reduction of Cd content in tomato tissues were detected, and the Cd concentration in tomato roots were decreased by 27.19%, 25.18%, and 17.51% in Cd+Si, Cd+MeJA and Cd+Si+MeJA-treated plants, respectively. Moreover, in Cd+Si+MeJA-treated group, the percentage of Cd in cell wall fraction was enhanced while that in organelle fraction was decreased as compared with Cd-stressed plants. Collectively, our findings indicated that Si and MeJA application provide a beneficial role in enhancing Cd tolerance and reducing Cd uptake in tomato plants.

Physiological responses involved in cadmium tolerance in a high-cadmium-accumulating rice (Oryza sativa L.) line

The disparity of tolerance in plants in response to Cd stress is associated with multiple physiological processes. A pot experiment was conducted to investigate the physiological properties involved in Cd tolerance of a high-cadmium (Cd)-accumulating rice line (Lu527-8) in comparison with a normal rice line (Lu527-4) under different levels of Cd exposure. Lu527-8 showed higher biomass and Cd concentrations compared with Lu527-4. The tolerance index (TI), bioconcentration factor (BCF), and translocation factor (TF) of Lu527-8 could be up to 3.08, 1.48, and 4.50 times these of Lu527-4, respectively. The two rice lines owned a uniform strategy to reduce Cd toxicity in root and stem by Cd deposition in cell wall and compartmentalization in vacuoles instead of keeping Cd in organelles. For Lu527-8, the higher distribution proportions of Cd combined with cell wall in leaf was linked to its higher Cd tolerance in comparison with Lu527-4. Lu527-8 showed a lower decline in membrane stability, antioxidation, photosynthetic parameters, and pigments than Lu527-4 when exposed to Cd stress. Taken together, the results demonstrated that higher Cd tolerance in high-Cd-accumulating rice Lu527-8 is closely linked to its greater abilities of cell wall fixation in leaf, oxidation resistance, as well as osmotic regulation and photosynthesis.

Cabbage cultivars influence transfer and toxicity of cadmium in soil-Chinese flowering cabbage Brassica campestris-cutworm Spodoptera litura larvae

We executed a pot experiment to examine the differences of absorption, chemical forms, subcellular distribution, and toxicity of Cd between two cultivars of Chinese flowering cabbage Brassica campestris [Lvbao701 (low-Cd cultivar) and Chicaixin No.4 (high-Cd cultivar)]. Compared to Chicaixin No.4, the presence of Lvbao701 enhanced the proportion of insoluble Cd forms in soil, Lvbao701 roots and leaves had higher proportion of Cd converted into insoluble phosphate precipitates and pectate-or protein-bound forms and lower proportion of inorganic Cd, which result in low accumulation and toxicity of Cd to Lvbao701 and cutworm Spodoptera litura fed on Lvbao701 leaves. Instead of total Cd, Cd transfer and toxicity in B. campestris-S. litura system depend on chemical Cd forms in soil and cabbages and subcellular Cd distributions in cabbages and insects, and the proportions of them were not the highest among all chemical forms and subcellular distributions of Cd. Although exchangeable Cd was major Cd chemical form in cabbage planted soil, Cd bound to iron and manganese oxides and to organic matter were significantly correlated with growth indices and photosynthesis parameters of cabbages. Despite major part of Cd was precipitated in cell wall of roots, Cd in organelle fraction was closely associated with the fitness of cabbages. Metal-rich granules, not cytosolic fraction (the major subcellular Cd distribution), affected the food utilization of S. litura. Therefore, cabbage cultivars significantly affected Cd transfer and toxicity in B. campestris-S. litura system, and the use of Lvbao701 in Cd polluted soil could reduce potential risks for Cd entering food chains.

Differential responses of thiol metabolism and genes involved in arsenic detoxification in tolerant and sensitive genotypes of bioenergy crop Ricinus communis

Castor, a non-food, dedicated bioenergy crop, has immense potential to be used for phytoremediation/revegetation of heavy metal contaminated sites. In the previous study, we identified arsenate [As(V)]-tolerant (WM) and As(V)-sensitive (GCH 2) genotypes of castor (Ricinus communis L.) with differential accumulation and tolerance of arsenic [As]. The role of thiols in As(V) toxicity and tolerance mechanism in the castor plant is not fully understood. On the one hand, thiol-dependent reduction of As(V) to As(III) by arsenate reductase (AR) makes it capable of reacting with thiol groups of protein leading to disturbed metabolic pathways; on the other hand, reduction of As(V) to arsenite [As(III)] by AR and then complexation of As(III) with phytochelatins (PCs) and compartmentalization of As(III)-PC complex are considered as the major detoxification mechanisms of As(V). In our study, the expression of RcAR increased in leaves and roots of As(V)-tolerant castor genotype WM but decreased in sensitive genotype GCH 2 due to 200 μM As(V) treatment. The activity of glutathione reductase (GR) increased significantly in the tolerant genotype, whereas it remained same in the sensitive genotype. GSH/GSSH ratio declined substantially in the sensitive genotype. The increased expression of phytochelatin synthase 1 isoform 1 (RcPCS1X1) in roots, RcPCS1X2 and metallothionein type 2 (RcMT2) in leaves, and c-type ABC transporter (RcABCC) in roots and leaves of WM was observed, but the expression of these genes declined or remained the same in GCH 2. Overall, our results suggest the essential roles of GR, RcAR, RcPCS1, RcMT2, and RcABCC in the tolerance of WM castor genotype to As(V) toxicity.

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi-induced mitigation of heavy metal phytotoxicity in metal contaminated soils: A critical review

The heavy metal pollution is a worldwide problem and has received a serious concern for the ecosystem and human health. In the last decade, remediation of the agricultural polluted soil has attracted great attention. Phytoremediation is one of the technologies that effectively alleviate heavy metal toxicity, however, this technique is limited to many factors contributing to low plant growth rate and nature of metal toxicities. Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) assisted alleviation of heavy metal phytotoxicity is a cost-effective and environment-friendly strategy. AMF have a symbiotic relationship with the host plant. The bidirectional exchange of resources is a hallmark and also a functional necessity in mycorrhizal symbiosis. During the last few years, a significant progress in both physiological and molecular mechanisms regarding roles of AMF in the alleviation of heavy metals (HMs) toxicities in plants, acquisition of nutrients, and improving plant performance under toxic conditions of HMs has been well studied. This review summarized the current knowledge regarding AMF assisted remediation of heavy metals and some of the strategies used by mycorrhizal fungi to cope with stressful environments. Moreover, this review provides the information of both molecular and physiological responses of mycorrhizal plants as well as AMF to heavy metal stress which could be helpful for exploring new insight into the mechanisms of HMs remediation by utilizing AMF.

Synergistic effect of silicon and selenium on the alleviation of cadmium toxicity in rice plants

Silicon (Si) and selenium (Se), two beneficial elements that alleviate cadmium (Cd) toxicity, are important for agricultural production and human health. However, the effects and related mechanisms of Si-Se interaction on Cd toxicity alleviation are still poorly understood. Herein, a hydroponic experiment was employed to evaluate the effects of Si and Se alone and together, on the growth, Cd content, and biochemical parameters of Cd-treated rice plants. The results revealed that both Si and Se can effectively alleviate Cd toxicity, and a strong synergistic effect of Si and Se was observed. Simultaneous use of Si and Se significantly promoted rice plant growth, decreased malondialdehyde (MDA) content in both the roots and shoots, and reduced Cd translocation factor leading to a significant 73.2 % decrease in shoot Cd content. Additionally, Si-Se interaction increased glutathione (GSH) content, phytochelatin (PC) content and Cd distribution in root cell walls and organelles. Furthermore, the relative expression of OsHMA2 was down-regulated, while those of OsNramp1 and OsMHA3 were up-regulated. The above findings suggest that synergistic effect of Si and Se on Cd toxicity amelioration occurs mainly via regulating gene expression, sequestering Cd in the root cell walls and organelles, and reducing Cd transfer to the shoots.

Chemical forms governing Cd tolerance and detoxification in duckweed (Landoltia punctata)

Duckweed (Landoltia punctata) is an ideal species to restore cadmium (Cd)-polluted waters due to its fast growth and easy harvesting. To understand its tolerance and detoxification mechanism, the Cd stress responses, subcellular Cd distribution and chemically bound Cd forms (especially protein-bound Cd) were surveyed in this study. L. punctata, a potential Cd bioremediation plant, was cultured hydroponically with Cd concentrations of 0.0, 0.5, 2.0, and 5.0 mg L^-1 for 5 days. The results showed that the Cd content in L. punctata increased significantly as the Cd content increased. The majority of Cd was localized in the soluble fraction (23-55%) and the cell wall fraction (21-54%), and only 14-23% of Cd was located in cell organelles. Analysis of the Cd chemical forms demonstrated that the largest portion of Cd was found in 1 M NaCl extracts, followed by d-H₂O and 2% HAc extracts, indicating that Cd was mainly bound to different proteins. Albumin- and globulin-bound Cd forms were predominant, together accounting for over 80% of the total protein-bound Cd in L. punctata. These results indicate that cell wall immobilization and vacuolar dissociation of Cd are possible primary strategies for Cd biosorption and detoxification in L. punctata, which occur mainly through chemical forms changes, especially the binding of Cd to proteins.

Cadmium accumulation, subcellular distribution and chemical fractionation in hydroponically grown Sesuvium portulacastrum [Aizoaceae]

Sesuvium portulacastrum is a well-known halophyte with considerable Cd accumulation and tolerance under high Cd stress. This species is also considered as a good candidate of Cd phytoremediation in the polluted soils. However, the mechanism of Cd accumulation, distribution and fractionation in different body parts still remain unknown. Seedlings of Sesuvium portulacastrum were studied hydroponically under exposure to a range of Cd concentrations (50 μM or μmol/L to 600 μM or μmol/L) for 28 days to investigate the potential accumulation capability and tolerance mechanisms of this species. Cd accumulation in roots showed that the bio-concentration factor was > 10, suggesting a strong ability to absorb and accumulate Cd. Cd fractionation in the aboveground parts showed the following order of distribution: soluble fraction > cell wall > organelle > cell membrane. In roots, soluble fraction was mostly predominant than other fractions. Cd speciation in leaves and stems was mainly contained of sodium chloride and deionised water extracted forms, suggesting a strong binding ability with pectin and protein as well as with organic acids. In the roots, inorganic form of Cd was dominant than other forms of Cd. It could be suggested that sodium chloride, deionised water and inorganic contained form of Cd are mainly responsible for the adaption of this plant in the Cd stress environment and alleviating Cd toxicity.

Reducing Cd accumulation in rice grain with foliar application of glycerol and its mechanisms of Cd transport inhibition

Excessive cadmium (Cd) in rice grain has become a major global public health problem. Here, the effect of foliar glycerol application on Cd accumulation in brown rice was examined. Various spraying concentrations of glycerol between 0.4mM and 50mM were investigated and the results showed that 0.8 mM was the best application concentration for decreasing Cd content in brown rice. After different application period experiment, filling stage was considered as the optimal spraying time. 0.4mM-5mM glycerol application one time at the filling stage could significantly reduce Cd concentration in brown rice by 28.5%-60.4%. Cd transport factors (the ratio of brown rice and flag leaf/node) were decreased by 48.5% and 27.3%, respectively, with glycerol application. Glycerol application also significantly increased Cd concentration in soluble fraction in flag leaf while reduced inorganic Cd and water-soluble Cd in both flag leaf and stem. Our results showed foliar spraying glycerol inhibited Cd transport to brown rice through Cd compartmentalisation in the vacuole and transformation of cadmium chemical form. This study may provide a new method to effectively alleviate the problem of excessive Cd in rice.

Cadmium tolerance and detoxification in Myriophyllum aquaticum: physiological responses, chemical forms, and subcellular distribution

Submerged macrophytes have been found to be promising in removing cadmium (Cd) from aquatic ecosystems; however, the mechanism of Cd detoxification in these plants is still poorly understood. In the present study, Cd chemical forms and subcellular distributing behaviors in Myriophyllum aquaticum and the physiological mechanism underlying M. aquaticum in response to Cd stress were explored. During the study, M. aquaticum was grown in a hydroponic system and was treated under different concentrations of Cd (0, 0.01, 0.05, 0.25, and 1.25 mg/L) for 14 days. The differential centrifugation suggested that most Cd was split in the soluble fraction (57.40-66.25%) and bound to the cell wall (24.92-38.57%). Furthermore, Cd in M. aquaticum was primarily present in NaCl-extractable Cd (51.76-91.15% in leaves and 58.71-84.76% in stems), followed by acetic acid-extractable Cd (5.17-22.42% in leaves and 9.54-16.56% in stems) and HCl-extractable Cd (0.80-12.23% in leaves and 3.56-18.87% in stems). The malondialdehyde (MDA) and hydrogen peroxide (H₂O₂) concentrations in M. aquaticum were noticeably increased under each Cd concentration. The activities of catalase (CAT), guaiacol peroxidase (POD), and superoxide dismutase (SOD) in leaves were initially increased under relatively low concentrations of Cd but were decreased further with the increasing concentrations of Cd. The ascorbate (AsA), glutathione (GSH), and nitric oxide (NO) concentrations in stems increased with increasing Cd concentrations. Taken together, our results indicate that M. aquaticum can be used successfully for phytoremediation of Cd-contaminated water, and the detoxification mechanisms in M. aquaticum include enzymatic and non-enzymatic antioxidants, subcellular partitioning, and the formation of different chemical forms of Cd.

The hybridization between Sphagneticola trilobata (L.) Pruski and Sphagneticola calendulacea (L.) Pruski improved the tolerance of hybrid to cadmium stress

Hybridization is common between invasive and native species and may be accompanied by invasive evolution. The hybrid of Sphagneticola trilobata (alien invasive species) and Sphagneticola calendulacea (indigenous congener) was found in South China. According to previous studies, the hybrid performed weak environmental adaptability in comparison with parents. However, based on the results from this study, the hybridization significantly improved the tolerance of the hybrid to cadmium (Cd) stress (200 μmol L^-1). Under Cd stress, the hybrid lines showed lowest level of oxidative damage and the highest level of photosynthetic efficiency. Compared with the parents, the hybrid utilized more active detoxification strategies, such as the cell walls of the leaves and roots adsorbed 88% and 95% Cd, respectively, reducing the amount of Cd entering cells; moreover, most of the Cd that entered cells was transformed into less toxic chemical forms through the reduction of the highly toxic chemical forms; furthermore, it accumulated a large number of phytochelatins to bind Cd²⁺ and reduced the damage of organelles by Cd²⁺. The results demonstrate that hybridization between S. trilobata and S. calendulacea improved the adaptability of the new hybrid species to Cd stress and may pose a greater threat to the survival of the native parent species in the presence of serious water and soil pollution.

Metabolomics reveals the "Invisible" detoxification mechanisms of Amaranthus hypochondriacus at three ages upon exposure to different levels of cadmium

To decipher the Cd hyperaccumulation and tolerance mechanisms of plants and increase phytoremediation efficiency, in this study, the physiological effects induced by environmentally relevant concentrations (0, 25 and 200 mg/kg) of Cd were characterized in Amaranthus hypochondriacus (K472) at three growth stages using LC/MS-based metabolomics. Metabolomic analysis identified 31, 29 and 30 significantly differential metabolites (SDMs) in K472 exposed to Cd at the early, intermediate and late stages of vegetative growth, respectively. These SDMs are involved in nine metabolic pathways responsible for antioxidation, osmotic balance regulation, energy supplementation and the promotion of metabolites that participate in phytochelatin (PC) synthesis. K472 at the intermediate stage of vegetative growth had the strongest tolerance to Cd with the combined action of Ala, Asp and Glu metabolism, purine metabolism, Gly, Ser and Thr metabolism and Pro and Arg metabolism. Among these crucial metabolic biomarkers, purine metabolism could be the primary regulatory target for increasing the Cd absorption of K472 for the restoration of Cd-contaminated soil.

Transcriptome analysis revealed cadmium accumulation mechanisms in hyperaccumulator Siegesbeckia orientalis L

Siegesbeckia orientalis L. was identified as a novel Cd-hyperaccumulator and valuable phytoremediation material. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying Cd accumulation in S. orientalis are largely unknown. In this study, RNA-Seq analysis was performed to study the Cd-accumulating mechanisms in its roots with or without Cd treatment. The RNA-seq analysis generated 312 million pairs of clean reads and 78G sequencing data. De novo transcriptome assembly produced 355,070 transcripts with an average length of 823.59 bp and 194,207 unigenes with an average length of 605.68 bp. Comparative transcriptome analyses identified a large number of differentially expressed genes in roots under Cd stress, and functional annotation suggested that S. orientalis utilizes various biological pathways involving many gene networks working simultaneously to cope with the stress. This study revealed that four biological pathways were mainly involved in S. orientalis tolerance to Cd stress, including reactive oxygen species scavenging, phenylpropanoid biosynthesis pathway, Cd absorption and transport, and ABA signaling pathway. The genes related to photosynthesis and heavy metal transport are likely the potential candidates and could be further investigated to determine their roles in Cd tolerance in S. orientalis roots. These findings will be useful to understand the Cd accumulation mechanisms in S. orientalis and facilitate the study of phytoremediation at the molecular level in plants.

Cadmium and lead mixtures are less toxic to the Chinese medicinal plant Ligusticum chuanxiong Hort. Than either metal alone

Agricultural production of Ligusticum chuanxiong Hort. is often affected by heavy metal pollution in soil, especially mixtures of cadmium (Cd) and lead (Pb). We assessed metal-induced phytotoxicity in L. chuanxiong by exposing the plants to soil treated with Cd, Pb, or Cd/Pb mixtures. A combined Cd/Pb treatment alleviated the inhibition in plant growth, photosynthesis, and secondary metabolite generation seen in single-metal exposures in three of the four combinations. Most combined Cd/Pb treatments resulted in preferential uptake of magnesium, copper, and nitrogen in underground plant parts and accumulation of phosphorus and calcium in aboveground plant parts, thereby leading to improvements in photosynthetic potential. Compared with single-metal exposures, combined Cd/Pb treatment significantly decreased the contents of Cd by 16.67%-40.12% and Pb by 10.68%-21.70% in the plant, respectively. At the subcellular level, the Pb presence increased the Cd percentage associated with cell wall from 64.79% to 67.93% in rhizomes and from 32.76% to 45.32% in leaves, while Cd reduced Pb contents by 9.36%-46.39% in the subcellular fractions. A combined Cd/Pb treatment decreased the contents of water- and ethanol-extractable metal forms and increased the contents of acetic acid- and hydrochloric acid-extractable forms. The lower toxic effects of the Cd/Pb mixture in L. chuanxiong were associated with photosynthetic potential, subcellular distribution, the chemical forms of Cd and Pb, and synthesis of secondary metabolites. These findings are useful for plant production strategies in soils contaminated by heavy metals.

Different strategies for lead detoxification in dwarf bamboo tissues

Dwarf bamboo Sasa argenteostriata (Regel) E.G. Camus is considered as potential plants for metal phytoremediation in previous filed observations. However, the mechanisms of lead (Pb) detoxification has not been described. The objective of this study was to explore the difference strategies or mechanisms of Pb detoxification in plant tissues. In this regard, four Pb treatments with hydroponics including 0 (control), 300, 600, and 900 mg L^-1 were conducted to examine subcellular compartmentalization, Pb accumulation/species and antioxidant-assisted chelation. Our findings showed the retention of Pb by the whip-root system is one of its detoxification mechanisms to avoid damage the shoots. In addition, the cell wall retention is the dominant detoxification strategy of whips, new roots, old roots and new/old stems, while vacuolar compartmentalization is for new/old leaves. Interestingly, four low-mobility/-toxicity Pb species (i.e., FNaCl, FHAc, FHCl and FR) are distributed in roots, whips and stems, while two high-mobility/-toxicity Pb species (FE and FW) in leaves. The conversion of Pb to low-toxicity/-migration is a Pb-detoxification strategy in roots, whips and stems but not in leaves. Besides, the new/old roots and leaves can alleviate Pb damage through the synthesis of non-protein thiol, glutathione and phytochelatins. Among these, phytochelatins play a leading role in the detoxification in new/old roots, while glutathione is in new/old leaves. This study provides the first comprehensive evidence regarding the different strategies for Pb detoxification in dwarf bamboo tissues from physiological to cellular level, supporting that this plant could be rehabilitated for phytoremediation in Pb-contaminated media.

Physiological and transcriptomic analyses of cadmium stress response in Dendrobium officinale seedling

Dendrobium officinale is an economically important Chinese herb with ornamental and medicinal values. However, the mechanisms by which D. officinale adapts to cadmium (Cd) stress is unknown. Here, physiological changes in D. officinale roots and leaves exposed to increasing levels of Cd stress (CdSO₄ concentration of 2, 5, 9, 14 mg L^-1) were analyzed at 7, 15, 30, and 45 days after treatment. The Cd stress of 14 mg L^-1 significantly increased the levels of antioxidants and induced malondialdehyde and proline accumulation (P < 0.05). Cd subcellular distribution showed that Cd sequestration into soluble fraction is the major detoxification mechanism in D. officinale roots. Subsequently, the transcriptome profile of D. officinale roots treated with 14 mg L^-1 Cd for 15 and 30 days was analyzed. Compared to control, 2,469 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) were identified, comprising 1,486 up-regulated genes and 983 down-regulated genes. The DEGs associated with metabolic pathways for Cd uptake, transportation and detoxification were analyzed. Several processes such as metal transporter, sulfate glutathione metabolism, cell wall metabolism, phenylpropanoid metabolism were identified to be important for Cd stress adaptation. More genes were expressed at 15 days after treatment compared to 30 days. WRKY, Trihelix, NF-YC, MYB, bZIP and bHLH transcription factors were over-expressed at both time points. Furthermore, candidate genes from the glutathione metabolism pathway were identified, and qRT-PCR analysis of ten DEGs indicated a high coorelation with RNA-seq expression profiles. Our findings provide significant information for further research of Cd stress responsive genes functions in D. officinale, especially the genes from the glutathione metabolism pathway.

Subcellular distribution, chemical forms and physiological responses involved in cadmium tolerance and detoxification in Agrocybe Aegerita

A pot experiment was conducted to investigate the detoxification mechanism of Agrocybe aegerita (A. aegerita). The physiological responses, subcellular distribution and chemical forms of cadmium (Cd) in A. aegerita grown in Cd stress were analyzed. The results showed that the biomass was decreased under Cd stress, while the production of malonaldehyde, thiols, and low-molecular-weight organic acids (LWMOAs) as well as the antioxidant enzymes in A. aegerita was increased compared with control group. The HPLC results showed that nine LWMOAs were found in A. aegerita with critic acid as the dominant and they played important role in the detoxification and accumulation of Cd in A. aegerita. More Cd was accumulated in pileus than in stipe. Differential centrifugation technique showed that the majority of Cd was compartmentalized in the soluble fraction (53-75%) and bound to the cell wall (19-42%). The proportion of Cd in the cell wall increased with the increase of the accumulation of Cd in the fruiting body, but in the soluble fraction showed an opposite trend. Furthermore, most of the Cd in A. aegerita was mainly in the forms of NaCl- (29-49%) and ethanol-extractable Cd (20-40%). The ethanol- and water-extractable Cd in stipe (60-66%) was higher than in pileus (43-49%). Thus intracellular detoxification mechanisms of Cd in A. aegerita is related to subcellular partitioning and chemical forms of Cd and well-coordinated physiological responses.

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi alleviate Cd phytotoxicity by altering Cd subcellular distribution and chemical forms in Zea mays

Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus (AMF) can relieve Cd phytotoxicity and improve plant growth, but the mechanisms involved in this process have still been not completely known. In the present work, a pot experiment was conducted to examine productions of glutathione (GSH) and phytochelatins (PCs), and absorption, chemical forms and subcellular distribution of Cd in maize (Zea mays) inoculated with or without AMF (Rhizophagus intraradices (Ri) and Glomus versiforme (Gv)) in Cd-amended soils (0, 1 and 5 mg Cd kg^-1 soil). In general, both Ri and Gv inoculation dramatically enhanced biomass production and reduced Cd concentrations in shoots and roots of maize when compared to the non-mycorrhizal treatment. Moreover, both Ri and Gv symbiosis obviously increased contents of GSH and PCs, both in shoots and roots. Subcellular distribution of Cd in maize indicated that most of Cd (more than 90%) was accumulated in cell wall and soluble fraction. In addition, Cd proportions in soluble fractions in shoots of maize inoculated with Gv or Ri were considerably increased, but reduced in cell wall fractions compared to non-mycorrhizal maize, indicating that mycorrhizal symbiosis promoted Cd transfer to vacuoles. Furthermore, proportions of Cd in inorganic and water-soluble forms were declined, but elevated in pectates and proteins-integrated forms in mycorrhizal maize, which suggested that Gv and Ri could convert Cd into inactive forms. These observations could provide a further understanding of potential Cd detoxification mechanism in maize inoculated with AMF.

Subcellular distribution, chemical forms, and physiological response to cadmium stress in Hydrilla verticillata

This study investigated the subcellular distribution and chemical forms of cadmium (Cd) in Hydrilla verticillata and the physiological mechanism underlying H. verticillata responses to Cd stress. Hydrilla verticillata was grown in a hydroponic system and was treated with various Cd concentrations (0, 10, 50, 100, 125, and 150 µM) for 7 days. Cadmium analysis of the leaves at the subcellular level showed that Cd was mainly stored in the soluble fraction (77.98-83.62%) and in smaller quantities in the cell wall fraction (11.99-17.30%) and the cell organelles (4.30-4.88%). The Cd taken up by H. verticillata was in different chemical forms. In the leaves and stems, the Cd was mostly extracted using 1 M NaCl and smaller amounts of Cd were extracted using 2% acetic acid. The malondialdehyde content significantly increased at all Cd concentrations, which indicated oxidative stress. The superoxide dismutase, guaiacol peroxidase, and catalase activities were enhanced. The proline, ascorbate, and glutathione contents increased at lower Cd concentrations, but decreased consistently as the Cd concentration rose. These results suggest that H. verticillata can be successfully used in the phytoremediation of Cd-contaminated water.

Exogenous spermidine elevating cadmium tolerance in Salix matsudana involves cadmium detoxification and antioxidant defense

In this study, exogenous spermidine role on Salix matsudana tolerance to cadmium was evaluated. Spermidine and cadmium presented antagonistic effects on the biomass, copper and zinc concentrations in S. matsudana. cadmium mainly distributed in the cell wall of subcellular fraction; 46.97%-60.43% of cadmium existed in a sodium chloride-extracted form. Cadmium contents in roots, leaves, and twigs ranged from 2002.67 to 3961.00, 111.59 to 229.72, and 102.56 to 221.27 mg/kg, respectively. Spermidine application elevated cadmium concentrations in the roots, cuttings, and cell wall and the ratio of deionized water-extracted cadmium, but decreased cadmium levels in the twigs and leaves and the fractions of cadmium extracted by ethanol and sodium chloride, respectively. Putrescine and malondialdehyde were important indicators of cadmium-induced oxidative damage. Exogenous spermidine alleviated the accumulation of superoxide anion, hydrogen peroxide, malondialdehyde via promoting the levels of spermidine, soluble protein, superoxide dismutase, reductive ascorbate, glutathione reductase, and glutathione peroxidase in S. matsudana leaves under the corresponding cadmium stress. The results indicated that S. matsudana was a candidate for cadmium rhizoremediation and extraction in leaves; the spermidine application enhanced the cadmium tolerance of S. matsudana through promoting cadmium accumulation in roots, cell wall, and less bioactive chemical forms and the antioxidative ability.

The Response of Duckweed (Lemna minor L.) Roots to Cd and Its Chemical Forms

The response of duckweed (Lemna minor L.) roots to Cd and its chemical forms was investigated. The relative root growth rate and concentrations of Cd and its different chemical forms in the root, that is, ethanol-extractable (FE-Cd), HCl-extractable (FHCl-Cd), and residual fractions (Fr-Cd), were quantified. Weibull model was used to unravel the regression between the relative root elongation (RRL) with chemical forms of Cd. Parameters assessed catalase (CAT), peroxidases (POD), and superoxide dismutase (SOD), as well as malondialdehyde (MDA) and total antioxidant capacity (A-TOC). Our results show that both the relative root growth rate and relative frond number were affected by Cd concentrations. The chemical forms of Cd were influenced by Cd content in the medium. Relative root elongation (RRL) showed a significant correlation with chemical forms of Cd. Additionally, POD and SOD increased at lower Cd concentrations followed by a decrease at higher Cd concentrations (at more than 5 μM Cd). Moreover, MDA and A-TOC increased and CAT decreased with increasing Cd exposure. Furthermore, CAT showed a significant correlation with FHCl-Cd. Taken together, it can be concluded that the chemical forms of Cd are statistically significant predictors of Cd toxicity to duckweed and to the other similar aquatic plants.