Extrachromosomal eukaryotic DNA substrates for switch recombination: analysis of isotype and cell specificity

Current insights into the mechanism of mammalian immunoglobulin class switch recombination

Immunoglobulin (Ig) class switch recombination (CSR) is the gene rearrangement process by which B lymphocytes change the Ig heavy chain constant region to permit a switch of Ig isotype from IgM to IgG, IgA, or IgE. At the DNA level, CSR occurs via generation and joining of DNA double strand breaks (DSBs) at intronic switch regions located just upstream of each of the heavy chain constant regions. Activation-induced deaminase (AID), a B cell specific enzyme, catalyzes cytosine deaminations (converting cytosines to uracils) as the initial DNA lesions that eventually lead to DSBs and CSR. Progress on AID structure integrates very well with knowledge about Ig class switch region nucleic acid structures that are supported by functional studies. It is an ideal time to review what is known about the mechanism of Ig CSR and its relation to somatic hypermutation. There have been many comprehensive reviews on various aspects of the CSR reaction and regulation of AID expression and activity. This review is focused on the relation between AID and switch region nucleic acid structures, with a particular emphasis on R-loops.

AID to overcome the limitations of genomic information by introducing somatic DNA alterations

The immune system has adopted somatic DNA alterations to overcome the limitations of the genomic information. Activation induced cytidine deaminase (AID) is an essential enzyme to regulate class switch recombination (CSR), somatic hypermutation (SHM) and gene conversion (GC) of the immunoglobulin gene. AID is known to be required for DNA cleavage of S regions in CSR and V regions in SHM. However, its molecular mechanism is a focus of extensive debate. RNA editing hypothesis postulates that AID edits yet unknown mRNA, to generate specific endonucleases for CSR and SHM. By contrast, DNA deamination hypothesis assumes that AID deaminates cytosine in DNA, followed by DNA cleavage by base excision repair enzymes. We summarize the basic knowledge for molecular mechanisms for CSR and SHM and then discuss the importance of AID not only in the immune regulation but also in the genome instability.

Nucleic acid structures and enzymes in the immunoglobulin class switch recombination mechanism

Class switch recombination is the gene rearrangement process by which our B lymphocytes change from IgM production to IgG, IgA, or IgE. Unlike the well-characterized V(D)J recombination, the mechanism of class switch recombination has been largely enigmatic until very recent progress has begun to shed light on this gene rearrangement process. Progress has been made on the enzymes involved in leading to the DNA cleavage events and on identifying the unusual DNA structures that those enzymes recognize.

Molecular mechanism of class switch recombination: linkage with somatic hypermutation

Class switch recombination (CSR) and somatic hypermutation (SHM) have been considered to be mediated by different molecular mechanisms because both target DNAs and DNA modification products are quite distinct. However, involvement of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) in both CSR and SHM has revealed that the two genetic alteration mechanisms are surprisingly similar. Accumulating data led us to propose the following scenario: AID is likely to be an RNA editing enzyme that modifies an unknown pre-mRNA to generate mRNA encoding a nicking endonuclease specific to the stem-loop structure. Transcription of the S and V regions, which contain palindromic sequences, leads to transient denaturation, forming the stem-loop structure that is cleaved by the AID-regulated endonuclease. Cleaved single-strand tails will be processed by error-prone DNA polymerase-mediated gap-filling or exonuclease-mediated resection. Mismatched bases will be corrected or fixed by mismatch repair enzymes. CSR ends are then ligated by the NHEJ system while SHM nicks are repaired by another ligation system.

Two new isotype-specific switching activities detected for Ig class switching

Ig class switch recombination (CSR) occurs by an intrachromosomal deletional process between switch (S) regions in B cells. To facilitate the study of CSR, we derived a new B cell line, 1.B4.B6, which is uniquely capable of mu --> gamma3, mu --> epsilon, and mu --> alpha, but not mu --> gamma1 CSR at its endogenous loci. The 1.B4.B6 cell line was used in combination with plasmid-based isotype-specific S substrates in transient transfection assays to test for the presence of trans-acting switching activities. The 1.B4.B6 cell line supports mu --> gamma3, but not mu --> gamma1 recombination, on S substrates. In contrast, normal splenic B cells activated with LPS and IL-4 are capable of plasmid-based mu --> gamma1 CSR and demonstrate that this S plasmid is active. Activation-induced deaminase (AID) was used as a marker to identify existing B cell lines as possible candidates for supporting CSR. The M12 and A20 cell lines were identified as AID positive and, following activation with CD40L and other activators, were found to differentially support mu --> epsilon and mu --> alpha plasmid-based CSR. These studies provide evidence for two new switching activities for mu --> gamma1 and mu --> epsilon CSR, which are distinct from mu --> gamma3 and mu --> alpha switching activities previously described. AID is expressed in all the B cell lines capable of CSR, but cannot account for the isotype specificity defined by the S plasmid assay. These results are consistent with a model in which isotype-specific switching factors are either isotype-specific recombinases or DNA binding proteins with sequence specificity for S DNA.

Linking class-switch recombination with somatic hypermutation

The recent discovery of a molecular link between two apparently different genetic alteration events--class-switch recombination and somatic hypermutation--has led to the idea that the recognition and cleavage of target DNA in these two events might be mediated by similar or identical molecules to those involved in RNA editing. This could mean that the complexity of mammalian genetic information may be enriched by an interplay between RNA editing and DNA modification.

Stable RNA/DNA hybrids in the mammalian genome: inducible intermediates in immunoglobulin class switch recombination

Although it is well established that mammalian class switch recombination is responsible for altering the class of immunoglobulins, the mechanistic details of the process have remained unclear. Here, we show that stable RNA/DNA hybrids form at class switch sequences in the mouse genome upon cytokine-specific stimulation of class switch in primary splenic B cells. The RNA hybridized to the switch DNA is transcribed in the physiological orientation. Mice that constitutively express an Escherichia coli ribonuclease H transgene show a marked reduction in RNA/DNA hybrid formation, an impaired ability to generate serum immunoglobulin G antibodies, and significant inhibition of class switch recombination in their splenic B cells. These data provide evidence that stable RNA/DNA hybrids exist in the mammalian nuclear genome, can serve as intermediates for physiologic processes, and are mechanistically important for efficient class switching in vivo.

Evidence for class-specific factors in immunoglobulin isotype switching

Immunoglobulin class switch recombination (SR) occurs by a B cell-specific, intrachromosomal deletional process between switch regions. We have developed a plasmid-based transient transfection assay for SR to test for the presence of transacting switch activities. The plasmids are novel in that they lack a eukaryotic origin of DNA replication. The recombination activity of these switch substrates is restricted to a subset of B cell lines that support isotype switching on their endogenous loci and to mitogen-activated normal splenic B cells. The factors required for extrachromosomal plasmid recombination are constitutively expressed in proliferating splenic B cells and in B cell lines capable of inducibly undergoing immunoglobulin SR on their chromosomal genes. These studies suggest that mitogens that induce switching on the chromosome induce accessibility rather than switch recombinase activity. Finally, we provide evidence for two distinct switching activities which independently mediate mu-->alpha and mu-->gamma3 SR.

Sensitive analysis of recombination activity using integrated cell surface reporter substrates

BACKGROUND

Recombination processes play a crucial role in the functioning of the immune system and are also involved in mutation events that result in various malignancies. So far the study of recombination activity has frequently relied on the use of reporter substrates that are limited by low sensitivity as well as tedious and distorting readout procedures.

METHODS

Immunoglobulin class switch recombination substrates were generated which, upon recombination, resulted in the surface expression of human CD4 or murine MHC class I H-2K(k) and thus allowed for cytometric evaluation.

RESULTS

Recombining cells harboring integrated reporter substrates were analyzed by immunofluorescence and flow cytometry and could easily be isolated by high-gradient magnetic cell sorting (MACS). The analysis was not influenced by cloning efficiencies, as would be the case after drug selection, or prokaryotic recombination that might occur after analysis of recovered substrates in bacteria. In addition, cytometric readout is much faster, as it can be performed immediately after recombination. The substrate exhibited properties compatible with the detection of immunoglobulin class switch recombination and permitted the detection of recombination events down to 10(-5) per cell and generation.

CONCLUSIONS

The high sensitivity of this system allows precise detection of very rare recombination events and thus permits the study of cell types with extremely low recombination activities.

An extrachromosomal switch recombination substrate reveals kinetics and substrate requirements of switch recombination in primary murine B cells

Ig class switch recombination occurs in B lymphocytes upon activation, and is targeted to distinct switch (S) regions by cytokine-mediated induction of switch transcripts spanning the entire S region and the adjacent constant region gene segments. Using a novel type of switch recombination substrate, constructed according to the intron-exon structure of the IgH locus, but with heterologous elements, we here have tested the structural requirements for targeting and the kinetics of switch recombination in activated primary murine B cells. When transfected at various times after activation, up to 10% of the transfected B cells perform recombination of the substrate within 12 h. Switch recombination in primary B cells is restricted to the first 72 h after onset of activation, then rapidly decreases to background levels, as obtained in plasmacytoma cells or with substrates carrying no S region sequences. In terms of structural requirements, switch recombination is targeted to any transcription unit that contains an intronic S region and depends on processing of the primary transcript by splicing.

Processing of switch transcripts is required for targeting of antibody class switch recombination

Antibody class switching is mediated by somatic recombination between switch regions of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene locus. Targeting of recombination to particular switch regions is strictly regulated by cytokines through the induction of switch transcripts starting 5' of the repetitive switch regions. However, switch transcription as such is not sufficient to target switch recombination. This has been shown in mutant mice, in which the I-exon and its promoter upstream of the switch region were replaced with heterologous promoters. Here we show that, in the murine germline targeted replacement of the endogenous gamma1 promoter, I-exon, and I-exon splice donor site by heterologous promoter and splice donor sites directs switch recombination in activated B lymphocytes constitutively to the gamma1 switch region. In contrast, switch recombination to IgG1 is inhibited in mutant mice, in which the replacement does not include the heterologous splice donor site. Our data unequivocally demonstrate that targeting of switch recombination to IgG1 in vivo requires processing of the Igamma1 switch transcripts. Either the processing machinery or the processed transcripts are involved in class switch recombination.

Target specificity of immunoglobulin class switch recombination is not determined by nucleotide sequences of S regions

We describe a model system for class switch recombination (CSR) using CH12F3-2 cells transfected with a DNA construct containing two S sequences transcribed by different promoters and separated by a viral thymidine kinase (TK) gene. Recombination observed using this system shares key properties with physiological CSR: deletion of DNA between two S regions, requirement for cytokine stimulation, and nonhomologous and no consensus breakpoint sequences. Studies on transfectants with variants of this construct led us to the following conclusions: (1) two S sequences are required for CSR; (2) isotype specificity of recombination is not determined by nucleotide sequences of S regions; (3) S sequences are not strand-specific; and (4) induction of recombination activity requires cytokine stimulation.

Asymmetric mutation around the recombination break point of immunoglobulin class switch sequences on extrachromosomal substrates

Junctions at class switch recombination sites in the genome are characterized by a unique sequence feature. Nucleotide substitutions and small deletions are common on either of the two sides of the switch junction, but not on both together. We have previously reported an extrachromosomal substrate assay system for analyzing the recombination of class switch sequences. Here we have sequenced nine junctions on each side of the break point and compared these to 17 recombination junctions of control substrates from the same cells. Five of the nine switch recombination junctions have nucleotide substitutions and deletions, with multiple nucleotide changes being more common. Furthermore, mutations were found only on a single side of the junction, just as for the recombination of switch sequences in the genome. In contrast, only one of 17 control substrate junctions had a mutation, and this was a single nucleotide insertion. This difference is highly significant (P < 0.00007) and indicates that the fundamental recombination mechanism is likely to be similar for switch sequences in the chromosome and on minichromosome substrates.

Immunoglobulin class switching

Antibody class switching is induced by B-cell activators in the presence of cytokines. The identity of the heavy-chain class to which a B cell is switched is regulated by cytokines and B-cell activators at the level of transcription of unrearranged heavy chain constant genes. Gene-targeting experiments in mice have proved the essential role of these transcripts in switch recombination. Their possible functions are discussed in the context of a model for the mechanisms of class switching.