Optimization of Tissue-Engineered Vascular Graft Design Using Computational Modeling

Modulating biomechanical and integrating biochemical cues to foster adaptive remodeling of tissue engineered matrices for cardiovascular implants

Cardiovascular disease remains one of the leading causes of mortality in the Western world. Congenital heart disease affects nearly 1 % of newborns, with approximately one-fourth requiring reconstructive surgery during their lifetime. Current cardiovascular replacement options have significant limitations. Their inability to grow poses particular challenges for pediatric patients. Tissue Engineered Matrix (TEM)-based in situ constructs, with their self-repair and growth potential, offer a promising solution to overcome the limitations of current clinically used replacement options. Various functionalization strategies, involving the integration of biomechanical or biochemical components to enhance biocompatibility, have been developed for Tissue Engineered Vascular Grafts (TEVG) and Tissue Engineered Heart Valves (TEHV) to foster their capacity for in vivo remodeling. In this review, we present the current state of clinical translation for TEVG and TEHV, and provide a comprehensive overview of biomechanical and biochemical functionalization strategies for TEVG and TEHV. We discuss the rationale for functionalization, the implementation of functionalization cues in TEM-based TEVG and TEHV, and the interrelatedness of biomechanical and biochemical cues in the in vivo response. Finally, we address the challenges associated with functionalization and discuss how interdisciplinary research, especially when combined with in silico models, could enhance the translation of these strategies into clinical applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Cardiovascular disease remains one of the leading causes of mortality, with current replacements being unable to grow and regenerate. In this review, we present the current state of clinical translation for tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVG) and heart valves (TEHV). Particularly, we discuss the rationale and implementation for functionalization cues in tissue engineered matrix-based TEVGs and TEHVs, and for the first time we introduce the interrelatedness of biomechanical and biochemical cues in the in-vivo response. These insights pave the way for next-generation cardiovascular implants that promise better durability, biocompatibility, and growth potential. Finally, we address the challenges associated with functionalization and discuss how interdisciplinary research, especially when combined with in silico models, could enhance the translation of these strategies into clinical applications .

Constrained optimization of scaffold behavior for improving tissue engineered vascular grafts

Tissue engineered vascular grafts can offer long-term benefits in matching the geometry, properties, and function of native blood vessels. Yet, choosing appropriate design parameters for biodegradeable scaffolds such that they evolve into neovessels with favorable characteristics is challenging with iterative experimental testing alone. Herein, we present an in silico framework for constrained optimization of scaffold microstructure, mechanical behavior, and degradation kinetics. Our approach combines a biomechanical model of growth and remodeling informed by large animal experiments with numerical optimization to identify design parameters that limit clinically relevant failure modes, including stenosis and dilatation, and improve functional matching to native vessel compliance. Towards this end, constraints on geometry were introduced as a straightforward way to prevent adverse remodeling outcomes and shown to be useful in shaping desired outcomes in graft remodeling. Our simulations of long-term graft evolution suggest the need for a modest initial immune response to ensure graded load transfer from polymer to neotissue and to prevent extreme changes in diameter. Optimized designs showed less sensitivity to simulated variability in their design parameters, which could limit subject-to-subject variability. Together, these findings highlight the utility of computational modeling in identifying candidate designs for improved outcomes in tissue engineered vascular grafts - elimination of stenosis/aneurysm, better compliance matching, and consistent changes in behavior over time.

Biomechanical insights into the development and optimization of small-diameter vascular grafts

Small-diameter vascular grafts (SDVGs; inner diameter ≤6 mm) offer transformative potential for treating cardiovascular diseases, yet their clinical application remains limited due to high rates of complications such as acute thrombosis and intimal hyperplasia (IH), which compromise long-term patency. While advancements in biological and material science have driven progress, the critical role of biomechanical factors-such as hemodynamic forces and mechanical mismatch-in graft failure is often overlooked. This review presents insights from recent clinical trials of SDVG products and summarizes biomechanical contributors to failure, including disturbed flow patterns, mechanical mismatch, and insufficient mechanical strength. We outline essential mechanical performance criteria (e.g., compliance, burst pressure) and evaluation methodologies to assess SDVG performance. Furthermore, we present optimization strategies based on biomechanical principles: (1) graft morphological design optimization to improve hemodynamic stability, (2) structural, material, and fabrication innovations to achieve compliance matching with native arteries, and (3) biomimetic approaches to mimic vascular tissue and promote endothelialization. By systematically addressing these biomechanical challenges, next-generation SDVGs may achieve superior patency, accelerating their clinical translation. This review highlights the necessity of considering biomechanical compatibility in SDVG development, thereby providing initial insights for the clinical translation of SDVG. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Small-diameter vascular grafts (SDVGs) offer transformative potential for cardiovascular disease treatment but face clinical limitations. While significant progress has been made in biological and material innovations, the critical role of biomechanical factors in graft failure has often been underestimated. This review highlights the importance of biomechanical compatibility in SDVG design and performance, emphasizing the need to address disturbed flow patterns, mechanical mismatch, and inadequate mechanical strength. By proposing optimization strategies based on biomechanical principles, such as graft morphological design, compliance matching, and biomimetic approaches, this work provides a roadmap for developing next-generation SDVGs with improved patency. These advancements have the potential to overcome current limitations, accelerate clinical translation, ultimately benefiting patients worldwide.

A computational framework to optimize the mechanical behavior of synthetic vascular grafts

The failure of synthetic small-diameter vascular grafts has been attributed to a mismatch in the compliance between the graft and native artery, driving mechanisms that promote thrombosis and neointimal hyperplasia. Additionally, the buckling of grafts results in large deformations that can lead to device failure. Although design features can be added to lessen the buckling potential (e.g., reinforcing coil), the addition is detrimental to decreasing compliance. Herein, we developed a novel finite element (FE) framework to inform vascular graft design by evaluating compliance and resistance to buckling. A batch-processing scheme iterated across the multi-dimensional design parameter space, which included three parameters: coil thickness, modulus, and spacing - generating 100 unique designs. FE models were created for each coil-reinforced graft design to simulate pressurization, axial buckling, and bent buckling, and results were analyzed to quantify compliance, buckling load, and kink radius, respectively. Validation of the FE models demonstrated that model predictions agreed with experimental observations for compliance (r = 0.99), buckling load (r = 0.89), and kink resistance (r = 0.97). Model predictions demonstrated a broad range of values for compliance (1.1-7.9 %/mmHg × 10-2), buckling load (0.28-0.84 N), and kink radius (6-10 mm) across the design parameter space. Subsequently, data for each design parameter combination were optimized (i.e., minimized) to identify candidate graft designs with promising mechanical properties. Our model-directed framework successfully elucidated the complex mechanical determinants of graft performance, established structure-property relationships, and identified vascular graft designs with optimal mechanical properties, potentially improving clinical outcomes by addressing device failure.

Computational methods for biofabrication in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine - a literature review

This literature review rigorously examines the growing scientific interest in computational methods for Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine biofabrication, a leading-edge area in biomedical innovation, emphasizing the need for accurate, multi-stage, and multi-component biofabrication process models. The paper presents a comprehensive bibliometric and contextual analysis, followed by a literature review, to shed light on the vast potential of computational methods in this domain. It reveals that most existing methods focus on single biofabrication process stages and components, and there is a significant gap in approaches that utilize accurate models encompassing both biological and technological aspects. This analysis underscores the indispensable role of these methods in understanding and effectively manipulating complex biological systems and the necessity for developing computational methods that span multiple stages and components. The review concludes that such comprehensive computational methods are essential for developing innovative and efficient Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine biofabrication solutions, driving forward advancements in this dynamic and evolving field.

Multiscale homogenized constrained mixture model of the bio-chemo-mechanics of soft tissue growth and remodeling

Constrained mixture models have successfully simulated many cases of growth and remodeling in soft biological tissues. So far, extensions of these models have been proposed to include either intracellular signaling or chemo-mechanical coupling on the organ-scale. However, no version of constrained mixture models currently exists that includes both aspects. Here, we propose such a version that resolves cellular signal processing by a set of logic-gated ordinary differential equations and captures chemo-mechanical interactions between cells by coupling a reaction-diffusion equation with the equations of nonlinear continuum mechanics. To demonstrate the potential of the model, we present 2 case studies within vascular solid mechanics: (i) the influence of angiotensin II on aortic growth and remodeling and (ii) the effect of communication between endothelial and intramural arterial cells via nitric oxide and endothelin-1.

Hemodynamics and Wall Mechanics of Vascular Graft Failure

Blood vessels are subjected to complex biomechanical loads, primarily from pressure-driven blood flow. Abnormal loading associated with vascular grafts, arising from altered hemodynamics or wall mechanics, can cause acute and progressive vascular failure and end-organ dysfunction. Perturbations to mechanobiological stimuli experienced by vascular cells contribute to remodeling of the vascular wall via activation of mechanosensitive signaling pathways and subsequent changes in gene expression and associated turnover of cells and extracellular matrix. In this review, we outline experimental and computational tools used to quantify metrics of biomechanical loading in vascular grafts and highlight those that show potential in predicting graft failure for diverse disease contexts. We include metrics derived from both fluid and solid mechanics that drive feedback loops between mechanobiological processes and changes in the biomechanical state that govern the natural history of vascular grafts. As illustrative examples, we consider application-specific coronary artery bypass grafts, peripheral vascular grafts, and tissue-engineered vascular grafts for congenital heart surgery as each of these involves unique circulatory environments, loading magnitudes, and graft materials.

Computational approaches for mechanobiology in cardiovascular development and diseases

The cardiovascular development in vertebrates evolves in response to genetic and mechanical cues. The dynamic interplay among mechanics, cell biology, and anatomy continually shapes the hydraulic networks, characterized by complex, non-linear changes in anatomical structure and blood flow dynamics. To better understand this interplay, a diverse set of molecular and computational tools has been used to comprehensively study cardiovascular mechanobiology. With the continual advancement of computational capacity and numerical techniques, cardiovascular simulation is increasingly vital in both basic science research for understanding developmental mechanisms and disease etiologies, as well as in clinical studies aimed at enhancing treatment outcomes. This review provides an overview of computational cardiovascular modeling. Beginning with the fundamental concepts of computational cardiovascular modeling, it navigates through the applications of computational modeling in investigating mechanobiology during cardiac development. Second, the article illustrates the utility of computational hemodynamic modeling in the context of treatment planning for congenital heart diseases. It then delves into the predictive potential of computational models for elucidating tissue growth and remodeling processes. In closing, we outline prevailing challenges and future prospects, underscoring the transformative impact of computational cardiovascular modeling in reshaping cardiovascular science and clinical practice.

Mechanical modeling of the maturation process for tissue-engineered implants: Application to biohybrid heart valves

The development of tissue-engineered cardiovascular implants can improve the lives of large segments of our society who suffer from cardiovascular diseases. Regenerative tissues are fabricated using a process called tissue maturation. Furthermore, it is highly challenging to produce cardiovascular regenerative implants with sufficient mechanical strength to withstand the loading conditions within the human body. Therefore, biohybrid implants for which the regenerative tissue is reinforced by standard reinforcement material (e.g. textile or 3d printed scaffold) can be an interesting solution. In silico models can significantly contribute to characterizing, designing, and optimizing biohybrid implants. The first step towards this goal is to develop a computational model for the maturation process of tissue-engineered implants. This paper focuses on the mechanical modeling of textile-reinforced tissue-engineered cardiovascular implants. First, an energy-based approach is proposed to compute the collagen evolution during the maturation process. Then, the concept of structural tensors is applied to model the anisotropic behavior of the extracellular matrix and the textile scaffold. Next, the newly developed material model is embedded into a special solid-shell finite element formulation with reduced integration. Finally, our framework is used to compute two structural problems: a pressurized shell construct and a tubular-shaped heart valve. The results show the ability of the model to predict collagen growth in response to the boundary conditions applied during the maturation process. Consequently, the model can predict the implant's mechanical response, such as the deformation and stresses of the implant.

Towards Realistic 3D Models of Tumor Vascular Networks

For reliable in silico or in vitro investigations in, for example, biosensing and drug delivery applications, accurate models of tumor vascular networks down to the capillary size are essential. Compared to images acquired with conventional medical imaging techniques, digitalized histological tumor slices have a higher resolution, enabling the delineation of capillaries. Volume rendering procedures can then be used to generate a 3D model. However, the preparation of such slices leads to misalignments in relative slice orientation between consecutive slices. Thus, image registration algorithms are necessary to re-align the slices. Here, we present an algorithm for the registration and reconstruction of a vascular network from histologic slices applied to 169 tumor slices. The registration includes two steps. First, consecutive images are incrementally pre-aligned using feature- and area-based transformations. Second, using the previous transformations, parallel registration for all images is enabled. Combining intensity- and color-based thresholds along with heuristic analysis, vascular structures are segmented. A 3D interpolation technique is used for volume rendering. This results in a 3D vascular network with approximately 400-450 vessels with diameters down to 25-30 µm. A delineation of vessel structures with close distance was limited in areas of high structural density. Improvement can be achieved by using images with higher resolution and or machine learning techniques.

Preparation and Microscopic Mechanical Characterization of L-Methionine-Based Polyphosphazene Fibrous Mats for Vascular Tissue Engineering

This study investigates the mechanical properties, degradation behavior, and biocompatibility of poly[(α-amino acid ester) phosphazene] electrospun fibers based on the ethyl ester of L-methionine (PαAPz-M), a material with potential applications in tissue engineering. We utilized atomic force microscopy (AFM) to evaluate the fiber mechanical characteristics and calculate its Young's modulus, revealing it to closely mimic the stiffness of a natural extracellular matrix (ECM). We also studied the degradation behavior of PαAPz-M scaffolds over 21 days, showing that they maintain the highly porous structure required for tissue engineering. Further evaluation of mesenchymal multipotent 10T1/2 cell and mesenchymal stem cell (MSC) behavior on the scaffolds demonstrated significant cell viability, proliferation, and successful MSC differentiation into smooth muscle cells. Expression of collagen and elastin by MSCs on the fiber mats highlighted potential ECM formation during scaffold degradation, confirming PαAPz-M as a promising material for vascular tissue engineering.

Reducing retraction in engineered tissues through design of sequential growth factor treatment

Heart valve disease is associated with high morbidity and mortality worldwide, resulting in hundreds of thousands of heart valve replacements each year. Tissue engineered heart valves (TEHVs) have the potential to overcome the major limitations of traditional replacement valves; however, leaflet retraction has led to the failure of TEHVs in preclinical studies. Sequentially varying growth factors over time has been utilized to promote maturation of engineered tissues and may be effective in reducing tissue retraction, yet it is difficult to predict the effects of such treatments due to complex interactions between the cells and the extracellular matrix (ECM), biochemical environment, and mechanical stimuli. We hypothesize that sequential treatments of fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2) and transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGF-β1) can be used to minimize cell-generated tissue retraction by decreasing active cell contractile forces exerted on the ECM and by inducing the cells to increase the ECM stiffness. Using a custom culturing and monitoring system for 3D tissue constructs, we designed and tested various TGF-β1 and FGF-2 based growth factor treatments, and successfully reduced tissue retraction by 85% and increased the ECM elastic modulus by 260% compared to non-growth factor treated controls, without significantly increasing the contractile force. We also developed and verified a mathematical model to predict the effects of various temporal variations in growth factor treatments and analyzed relationships between tissue properties, the contractile forces, and retraction. These findings improve our understanding of growth factor-induced cell-ECM biomechanical interactions, which can inform the design of next generation TEHVs with reduced retraction. The mathematical models could also potentially be applied toward fast screening and optimizing growth factors for use in the treatment of diseases including fibrosis.

Combining Cell Technologies With Biomimetic Tissue Engineering Applications: A New Paradigm for Translational Cardiovascular Therapies

Cardiovascular disease is a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide and, to date, the clinically available prostheses still present several limitations. The design of next-generation regenerative replacements either based on cellular or extracellular matrix technologies can address these shortcomings. Therefore, tissue engineered constructs could potentially become a promising alterative to the current therapeutic options for patients with cardiovascular diseases. In this review, we selectively present an overview of the current tissue engineering tools such as induced pluripotent stem cells, biomimetic materials, computational modeling, and additive manufacturing technologies, with a focus on their application to translational cardiovascular therapies. We discuss how these advanced technologies can help the development of biomimetic tissue engineered constructs and we finally summarize the latest clinical evidence for their use, and their potential therapeutic outcome.

Tissue Engineering of Vascular Grafts: A Case Report From Bench to Bedside and Back

For over 25 years, our group has used regenerative medicine strategies to develop improved biomaterials for use in congenital heart surgery. Among other applications, we developed a tissue-engineered vascular graft (TEVG) by seeding tubular biodegradable polymeric scaffolds with autologous bone marrow-derived mononuclear cells. Results of our first-in-human study demonstrated feasibility as the TEVG transformed into a living vascular graft having an ability to grow, making it the first engineered graft with growth potential. Yet, outcomes of this first Food and Drug Administration-approved clinical trial evaluating safety revealed a prohibitively high incidence of early TEVG stenosis, preventing the widespread use of this promising technology. Mechanistic studies in mouse models provided important insight into the development of stenosis and enabled advanced computational models. Computational simulations suggested both a novel inflammation-driven, mechano-mediated process of in vivo TEVG development and an unexpected natural history, including spontaneous reversal of the stenosis. Based on these in vivo and in silico discoveries, we have been able to rationally design strategies for inhibiting TEVG stenosis that have been validated in preclinical large animal studies and translated to the clinic via a new Food and Drug Administration-approved clinical trial. This progress would not have been possible without the multidisciplinary approach, ranging from small to large animal models and computational simulations. This same process is expected to lead to further advances in scaffold design, and thus next generation TEVGs.

Strategies to counteract adverse remodeling of vascular graft: A 3D view of current graft innovations

Vascular grafts are widely used for vascular surgeries, to bypass a diseased artery or function as a vascular access for hemodialysis. Bioengineered or tissue-engineered vascular grafts have long been envisioned to take the place of bioinert synthetic grafts and even vein grafts under certain clinical circumstances. However, host responses to a graft device induce adverse remodeling, to varied degrees depending on the graft property and host's developmental and health conditions. This in turn leads to invention or failure. Herein, we have mapped out the relationship between the design constraints and outcomes for vascular grafts, by analyzing impairment factors involved in the adverse graft remodeling. Strategies to tackle these impairment factors and counteract adverse healing are then summarized by outlining the research landscape of graft innovations in three dimensions-cell technology, scaffold technology and graft translation. Such a comprehensive view of cell and scaffold technological innovations in the translational context may benefit the future advancements in vascular grafts. From this perspective, we conclude the review with recommendations for future design endeavors.

Computer Model-Driven Design in Cardiovascular Regenerative Medicine

Continuing advances in genomics, molecular and cellular mechanobiology and immunobiology, including transcriptomics and proteomics, and biomechanics increasingly reveal the complexity underlying native tissue and organ structure and function. Identifying methods to repair, regenerate, or replace vital tissues and organs remains one of the greatest challenges of modern biomedical engineering, one that deserves our very best effort. Notwithstanding the continuing need for improving standard methods of investigation, including cell, organoid, and tissue culture, biomaterials development and fabrication, animal models, and clinical research, it is increasingly evident that modern computational methods should play increasingly greater roles in advancing the basic science, bioengineering, and clinical application of regenerative medicine. This brief review focuses on the development and application of computational models of tissue and organ mechanobiology and mechanics for purposes of designing tissue engineered constructs and understanding their development in vitro and in situ. Although the basic approaches are general, for illustrative purposes we describe two recent examples from cardiovascular medicine-tissue engineered heart valves (TEHVs) and tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs)-to highlight current methods of approach as well as continuing needs.

Haemodynamic performance of 16-20-mm extracardiac Goretex conduits in adolescent Fontan patients at rest and during simulated exercise

OBJECTIVES

To date, it is not known if 16-20-mm extracardiac conduits are outgrown during somatic growth from childhood to adolescence. This study aims to determine total cavopulmonary connection (TCPC) haemodynamics in adolescent Fontan patients at rest and during simulated exercise and to assess the relationship between conduit size and haemodynamics.

METHODS

Patient-specific, magnetic resonance imaging-based computational fluid dynamic models of the TCPC were performed in 51 extracardiac Fontan patients with 16-20-mm conduits. Power loss, pressure gradient and normalized resistance were quantified in rest and during simulated exercise. The cross-sectional area (CSA) (mean and minimum) of the vessels of the TCPC was determined and normalized for flow rate (mm2/l/min). Peak (predicted) oxygen uptake was assessed.

RESULTS

The median age was 16.2 years (Q1-Q3 14.0-18.2). The normalized mean conduit CSA was 35-73% smaller compared to the inferior and superior vena cava, hepatic veins and left/right pulmonary artery (all P < 0.001). The median TCPC pressure gradient was 0.7 mmHg (Q1-Q3 0.5-0.8) and 2.0 (Q1-Q3 1.4-2.6) during rest and simulated exercise, respectively. A moderate-strong inverse non-linear relationship was present between normalized mean conduit CSA and TCPC haemodynamics in rest and exercise. TCPC pressure gradients of ≥1.0 at rest and ≥3.0 mmHg during simulated exercise were observed in patients with a conduit CSA ≤ 45 mm2/l/min and favourable haemodynamics (<1 mmHg during both rest and exercise) in conduits ≥125 mm2/l/min. Normalized TCPC resistance correlated with (predicted) peak oxygen uptake.

CONCLUSIONS

Extracardiac conduits of 16-20 mm have become relatively undersized in most adolescent Fontan patients leading to suboptimal haemodynamics.

In vivo development of tissue engineered vascular grafts: a fluid-solid-growth model

Methods of tissue engineering continue to advance, and multiple clinical trials are underway evaluating tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs). Whereas initial concerns focused on suture retention and burst pressure, there is now a pressing need to design grafts to have optimal performance, including an ability to grow and remodel in response to changing hemodynamic loads. Toward this end, there is similarly a need for computational methods that can describe and predict the evolution of TEVG geometry, composition, and material properties while accounting for changes in hemodynamics. Although the ultimate goal is a fluid-solid-growth (FSG) model incorporating fully 3D growth and remodeling and 3D hemodynamics, lower fidelity models having high computational efficiency promise to play important roles, especially in the design of candidate grafts. We introduce here an efficient FSG model of in vivo development of a TEVG based on two simplifying concepts: mechanobiologically equilibrated growth and remodeling of the graft and an embedded control volume analysis of the hemodynamics. Illustrative simulations for a model Fontan conduit reveal the utility of this approach, which promises to be particularly useful in initial design considerations involving formal methods of optimization which otherwise add considerably to the computational expense.

The Potential Role of Regenerative Medicine on the Future Management of Hypoplastic Left Heart Syndrome

The development and translation of regenerative medicine approaches for the treatment of hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) provides a promising alternative to the current standard of care. We review the strategies that have been pursued to date and those that hold the greatest promise in moving forward. Significant challenges remain. Continued scientific advances and technological breakthroughs will be required if we are to translate this technology to the clinic and move from palliative to curative treatment.

Model-Directed Design of Tissue Engineering Scaffolds

Scaffold-based tissue engineering requires a resorbable scaffold that can restore function and guide regeneration. Recent advances in material fabrication have expanded our control of compositional and architectural features to approach the complexity of native tissue. However, iterative scaffold design to balance multiple design targets toward optimizing regenerative performance remains both challenging and time-consuming. The number of design parameter combinations for scaffold manufacturing to achieve target properties is nearly limitless. Although a trial-and-error experimental approach may lead to a favorable scaffold design, the time and costs associated with such an approach are enormous. Computational optimization approaches are well suited to sample such a multidimensional design space and streamline the identification of target scaffold parameters for experimental evaluation. In this computational biomechanics approach, target fabrication parameters are identified by using a computational model to iterate across design parameter combinations (input) and predict the resulting graft properties (output). Herein, we describe the three key stages of this model-directed scaffold design: (1) model development, verification, and validation; (2) in silico optimization; and (3) model-directed scaffold fabrication and testing. Although there are several notable examples that have demonstrated the potential of this approach, additional accurate and physiologically appropriate computational simulations are needed to expand its utility across the field. In addition, continued advances in material fabrication are needed to provide the requisite control and resolution to produce the model-directed design. Finally, and most importantly, active collaboration between experts in materials science and computational modeling are critical to realize the full potential of this approach to accelerate scaffold development.

3D Tissue-Engineered Vascular Drug Screening Platforms: Promise and Considerations

Despite the efforts devoted to drug discovery and development, the number of new drug approvals have been decreasing. Specifically, cardiovascular developments have been showing amongst the lowest levels of approvals. In addition, concerns over the adverse effects of drugs to the cardiovascular system have been increasing and resulting in failure at the preclinical level as well as withdrawal of drugs post-marketing. Besides factors such as the increased cost of clinical trials and increases in the requirements and the complexity of the regulatory processes, there is also a gap between the currently existing pre-clinical screening methods and the clinical studies in humans. This gap is mainly caused by the lack of complexity in the currently used 2D cell culture-based screening systems, which do not accurately reflect human physiological conditions. Cell-based drug screening is widely accepted and extensively used and can provide an initial indication of the drugs' therapeutic efficacy and potential cytotoxicity. However, in vitro cell-based evaluation could in many instances provide contradictory findings to the in vivo testing in animal models and clinical trials. This drawback is related to the failure of these 2D cell culture systems to recapitulate the human physiological microenvironment in which the cells reside. In the body, cells reside within a complex physiological setting, where they interact with and respond to neighboring cells, extracellular matrix, mechanical stress, blood shear stress, and many other factors. These factors in sum affect the cellular response and the specific pathways that regulate variable vital functions such as proliferation, apoptosis, and differentiation. Although pre-clinical in vivo animal models provide this level of complexity, cross species differences can also cause contradictory results from that seen when the drug enters clinical trials. Thus, there is a need to better mimic human physiological conditions in pre-clinical studies to improve the efficiency of drug screening. A novel approach is to develop 3D tissue engineered miniaturized constructs in vitro that are based on human cells. In this review, we discuss the factors that should be considered to produce a successful vascular construct that is derived from human cells and is both reliable and reproducible.

Are ovine and porcine carotid arteries equivalent animal models for experimental cardiac surgery: A quantitative histological comparison

BACKGROUND

Coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) is a common cardiac surgery. Manufacturing small-diameter (2-5mm) vascular grafts for CABG is important for patients who lack first-choice autologous arterial, or venous conduits. Ovine and porcine common carotid arteries (CCAs) are used as large animal models for in vivo testing of newly developed tissue-engineered arterial grafts. It is unknown to what extent these models are interchangeable and whether the left and right arteries of the same subjects can be used as experimental controls. Therefore, we compared the microscopic structure of paired left and right ovine and porcine CCAs in the proximodistal direction and compared these animal model samples to samples of human coronary arteries (CAs) and human internal thoracic arteries (ITAs).

METHODS

We compared the histological composition of whole CCAs of sheep (n=22 animals) with whole porcine CCAs (n=21), segments of human CAs (n=21), and human ITAs (n=21). Using unbiased sampling and stereological methods, we quantified the fractions of elastin, total collagen, type I collagen, type III collagen, smooth muscle actin (SMA) and chondroitin sulfate (CS) A, B, and C. We also quantified the densities and distributions of nuclear profiles, nervi vasorum and vasa vasorum as well as the thickness of the intima-media and total wall thickness.

RESULTS

The differences between the paired samples of left and right CCAs in sheep were substantially greater than the differences in laterality in porcine CCAs. The right ovine CCAs had a smaller fraction of elastin (p<0.001), greater fraction of SMA (p<0.01), and greater intima-media thickness (p<0.001) than the paired left side CCAs. In pigs, the right CCAs had a greater fraction of elastin (p<0.05) and a greater density of vasa vasorum in the media (p<0.001) than the left-side CCAs. The fractions of elastin and CS decreased and the fraction of SMA increased in the proximodistal direction in both the ovine (p<0.001) and porcine (p<0.001) CCAs. Ovine CCAs had a muscular phenotype along their entire length, but porcine CCAs were elastic-type arteries in the proximal segments but muscular type arteries in middle and distal segments. The CCAs of both animals differed from the human CAs and ITAs in most parameters, but the ovine CCAs had a comparable fraction of elastin and CS to human ITAs.

CONCLUSIONS

From a histological point of view, ovine and porcine CCAs were not equivalent in most quantitative parameters to human CAs and ITAs. Left and right ovine CCAs did not have the same histological composition, which is limiting for their mutual equivalence as sham-operated controls in experiments. These differences should be taken into account when designing and interpreting experiments using these models in cardiac surgery. The complete morphometric data obtained by quantitative evaluation of arterial segments were provided to facilitate the power analysis necessary for justification of the minimum number of samples when planning further experiments. The middle or distal segments of ovine and porcine CCAs remain the most realistic and the best characterized large animal models for testing artificial arterial CABG conduits.

Tissue engineering: Relevance to neonatal congenital heart disease

Congenital heart disease (CHD) represents a large clinical burden, representing the most common cause of birth defect-related death in the newborn. The mainstay of treatment for CHD remains palliative surgery using prosthetic vascular grafts and valves. These devices have limited effectiveness in pediatric patients due to thrombosis, infection, limited endothelialization, and a lack of growth potential. Tissue engineering has shown promise in providing new solutions for pediatric CHD patients through the development of tissue engineered vascular grafts, heart patches, and heart valves. In this review, we examine the current surgical treatments for congenital heart disease and the research being conducted to create tissue engineered products for these patients. While much research remains to be done before tissue engineering becomes a mainstay of clinical treatment for CHD patients, developments have been progressing rapidly towards translation of tissue engineering devices to the clinic.

Mechano-regulated cell-cell signaling in the context of cardiovascular tissue engineering

Cardiovascular tissue engineering (CVTE) aims to create living tissues, with the ability to grow and remodel, as replacements for diseased blood vessels and heart valves. Despite promising results, the (long-term) functionality of these engineered tissues still needs improvement to reach broad clinical application. The functionality of native tissues is ensured by their specific mechanical properties directly arising from tissue organization. We therefore hypothesize that establishing a native-like tissue organization is vital to overcome the limitations of current CVTE approaches. To achieve this aim, a better understanding of the growth and remodeling (G&R) mechanisms of cardiovascular tissues is necessary. Cells are the main mediators of tissue G&R, and their behavior is strongly influenced by both mechanical stimuli and cell-cell signaling. An increasing number of signaling pathways has also been identified as mechanosensitive. As such, they may have a key underlying role in regulating the G&R of tissues in response to mechanical stimuli. A more detailed understanding of mechano-regulated cell-cell signaling may thus be crucial to advance CVTE, as it could inspire new methods to control tissue G&R and improve the organization and functionality of engineered tissues, thereby accelerating clinical translation. In this review, we discuss the organization and biomechanics of native cardiovascular tissues; recent CVTE studies emphasizing the obtained engineered tissue organization; and the interplay between mechanical stimuli, cell behavior, and cell-cell signaling. In addition, we review past contributions of computational models in understanding and predicting mechano-regulated tissue G&R and cell-cell signaling to highlight their potential role in future CVTE strategies.

Tissue engineered vascular grafts transform into autologous neovessels capable of native function and growth

Background

Tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) have the potential to advance the surgical management of infants and children requiring congenital heart surgery by creating functional vascular conduits with growth capacity.

Methods

Herein, we used an integrative computational-experimental approach to elucidate the natural history of neovessel formation in a large animal preclinical model; combining an in vitro accelerated degradation study with mechanical testing, large animal implantation studies with in vivo imaging and histology, and data-informed computational growth and remodeling models.

Results

Our findings demonstrate that the structural integrity of the polymeric scaffold is lost over the first 26 weeks in vivo, while polymeric fragments persist for up to 52 weeks. Our models predict that early neotissue accumulation is driven primarily by inflammatory processes in response to the implanted polymeric scaffold, but that turnover becomes progressively mechano-mediated as the scaffold degrades. Using a lamb model, we confirm that early neotissue formation results primarily from the foreign body reaction induced by the scaffold, resulting in an early period of dynamic remodeling characterized by transient TEVG narrowing. As the scaffold degrades, mechano-mediated neotissue remodeling becomes dominant around 26 weeks. After the scaffold degrades completely, the resulting neovessel undergoes growth and remodeling that mimicks native vessel behavior, including biological growth capacity, further supported by fluid-structure interaction simulations providing detailed hemodynamic and wall stress information.

Conclusions

These findings provide insights into TEVG remodeling, and have important implications for clinical use and future development of TEVGs for children with congenital heart disease.

Experimental and computational models for tissue-engineered heart valves: a narrative review

Valvular heart disease is currently a common problem which causes high morbidity and mortality worldwide. Prosthetic valve replacements are widely needed to correct narrowing or backflow through the valvular orifice. Compared to mechanical valves and biological valves, tissue-engineered heart valves can be an ideal substitute because they have a low risk of thromboembolism and calcification, and the potential for remodelling, regeneration, and growth. In order to test the performance of these heart valves, various animal models and other models are needed to optimise the structure and function of tissue-engineered heart valves, which may provide a potential mechanism responsible for substantial enhancement in tissue-engineered heart valves. Choosing the appropriate model for evaluating the performance of the tissue-engineered valve is important, as different models have their own advantages and disadvantages. In this review, we summarise the current state-of-the-art animal models, bioreactors, and computational simulation models with the aim of creating more strategies for better development of tissue-engineered heart valves. This review provides an overview of major factors that influence the selection and design of a model for tissue-engineered heart valve. Continued efforts in improving and testing models for valve regeneration remain crucial in basic science and translational researches. Future research should focus on finding the right animal model and developing better in vitro testing systems for tissue-engineered heart valve.

Silk biomaterials for vascular tissue engineering applications

Vascular tissue engineering is a rapidly growing field of regenerative medicine, which strives to find innovative solutions for vascular reconstruction. Considering the limited success of synthetic grafts, research impetus in the field is now shifted towards finding biologically active vascular substitutes bestowing in situ growth potential. In this regard, silk biomaterials have shown remarkable potential owing to their favorable inherent biological and mechanical properties. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the progressive development of silk-based small diameter (<6 mm) tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs), emphasizing their pre-clinical implications. Herein, we first discuss the molecular structure of various mulberry and non-mulberry silkworm silk and identify their favorable properties at the onset of vascular regeneration. The emergence of various state-of-the-art fabrication methodologies for the advancement of silk TEVGs is rationally appraised in terms of their in vivo performance considering the following parameters: ease of handling, long-term patency, resistance to acute thrombosis, stenosis and aneurysm formation, immune reaction, neo-tissue formation, and overall remodeling. Finally, we provide an update on the pre-clinical status of silk-based TEVGs, followed by current challenges and future prospects. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Limited availability of healthy autologous blood vessels to replace their diseased counterpart is concerning and demands other artificial substitutes. Currently available synthetic grafts are not suitable for small diameter blood vessels owing to frequent blockage. Tissue-engineered biological grafts tend to integrate well with the native tissue via remodeling and have lately witnessed remarkable success. Silk fibroin is a natural biomaterial, which has long been used as medical sutures. This review aims to identify several favorable properties of silk enabling vascular regeneration. Furthermore, various methodologies to fabricate tubular grafts are discussed and highlight their performance in animal models. An overview of our understanding to rationally improve the biological activity fostering the clinical success of silk-based grafts is finally discussed.

Constrained Mixture Models of Soft Tissue Growth and Remodeling - Twenty Years After

Soft biological tissues compromise diverse cell types and extracellular matrix constituents, each of which can possess individual natural configurations, material properties, and rates of turnover. For this reason, mixture-based models of growth (changes in mass) and remodeling (change in microstructure) are well-suited for studying tissue adaptations, disease progression, and responses to injury or clinical intervention. Such approaches also can be used to design improved tissue engineered constructs to repair, replace, or regenerate tissues. Focusing on blood vessels as archetypes of soft tissues, this paper reviews a constrained mixture theory introduced twenty years ago and explores its usage since by contrasting simulations of diverse vascular conditions. The discussion is framed within the concept of mechanical homeostasis, with consideration of solid-fluid interactions, inflammation, and cell signaling highlighting both past accomplishments and future opportunities as we seek to understand better the evolving composition, geometry, and material behaviors of soft tissues under complex conditions.

Hemodynamic performance of tissue-engineered vascular grafts in Fontan patients

In the field of congenital heart surgery, tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) are a promising alternative to traditionally used synthetic grafts. Our group has pioneered the use of TEVGs as a conduit between the inferior vena cava and the pulmonary arteries in the Fontan operation. The natural history of graft remodeling and its effect on hemodynamic performance has not been well characterized. In this study, we provide a detailed analysis of the first U.S. clinical trial evaluating TEVGs in the treatment of congenital heart disease. We show two distinct phases of graft remodeling: an early phase distinguished by rapid changes in graft geometry and a second phase of sustained growth and decreased graft stiffness. Using clinically informed and patient-specific computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, we demonstrate how changes to TEVG geometry, thickness, and stiffness affect patient hemodynamics. We show that metrics of patient hemodynamics remain within normal ranges despite clinically observed levels of graft narrowing. These insights strengthen the continued clinical evaluation of this technology while supporting recent indications that reversible graft narrowing can be well tolerated, thus suggesting caution before intervening clinically.

Spontaneous reversal of stenosis in tissue-engineered vascular grafts

We developed a tissue-engineered vascular graft (TEVG) for use in children and present results of a U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved clinical trial evaluating this graft in patients with single-ventricle cardiac anomalies. The TEVG was used as a Fontan conduit to connect the inferior vena cava and pulmonary artery, but a high incidence of graft narrowing manifested within the first 6 months, which was treated successfully with angioplasty. To elucidate mechanisms underlying this early stenosis, we used a data-informed, computational model to perform in silico parametric studies of TEVG development. The simulations predicted early stenosis as observed in our clinical trial but suggested further that such narrowing could reverse spontaneously through an inflammation-driven, mechano-mediated mechanism. We tested this unexpected, model-generated hypothesis by implanting TEVGs in an ovine inferior vena cava interposition graft model, which confirmed the prediction that TEVG stenosis resolved spontaneously and was typically well tolerated. These findings have important implications for our translational research because they suggest that angioplasty may be safely avoided in patients with asymptomatic early stenosis, although there will remain a need for appropriate medical monitoring. The simulations further predicted that the degree of reversible narrowing can be mitigated by altering the scaffold design to attenuate early inflammation and increase mechano-sensing by the synthetic cells, thus suggesting a new paradigm for optimizing next-generation TEVGs. We submit that there is considerable translational advantage to combined computational-experimental studies when designing cutting-edge technologies and their clinical management.

Quantitative Evaluation of Mechanical Stimulation for Tissue-Engineered Blood Vessels

Functional small-diameter tissue-engineered blood vessels (TEBVs) have been developed in silico using biodegradable polymeric scaffolds under pulsatile perfusion. Accurate simulation of physiological mechanical stimulations in vitro is a crucial factor in vascular engineering. However, little is known about the patterns of mechanical stimulation on silicone tubes. This study aimed to determine the optimal mechanical conditions required for inducing circumferential deformations in silicone tubes during in vitro vascular development under pulsatile perfusion. For this purpose, we established a data acquisition (DAQ) system with a laser micrometer and pressure transducers to evaluate changes in the diameter of silicone tubes in response to pulsatile flow and validated the results on cultured TEBVs. The established DAQ system showed satisfactory reproducibility for measuring diameter variation in the in silico model. Furthermore, the hardness and thickness of the silicone tubes affected the mechanical conditioning in the three-dimensional culture system under different working pressures, frequencies, and circumferential deformations. We demonstrated a simple and reliable approach to quantify the circumferential strain and deformations to ensure optimal mechanical stimulation of the cultured TEBVs under pulsatile perfusion. Based on the results, we were able to dynamically culture dense cellularized small-diameter TEBVs. This study highlights the importance of mechanical stimulation in vascular tissue engineering. Impact statement This study demonstrated a direct and noncontact data acquisition system for quantifying the strain on the supporting silicone medium during three-dimensional tissue-engineered blood vessel culture, which can help optimize the mechanical parameters for vascular tissue engineering.

Machine learning approaches to surrogate multifidelity Growth and Remodeling models for efficient abdominal aortic aneurysmal applications

Computational Growth and Remodeling (G&R) models have been widely used to capture the pathological development of arterial diseases and have shown promise for aiding clinical diagnosis, prognosis prediction, and staging classification. However, due to the high complexity of the arterial adaptation mechanism, high-fidelity arterial G&R simulation usually takes hours or even days, which hinders its application in clinical practice. To remedy this problem, we develop a computationally efficient arterial G&R simulation framework that comprehensively combines the physics-based G&R simulations and data-driven machine learning approaches. The proposed framework greatly enhances the computational efficiency of arterial G&R simulations, thereby enabling more time-consuming arterial applications, including personalized parameter estimation and arterial disease progression prediction. In particular, we achieve significant computational cost reduction mainly through two methods: (1) constructing a Multifidelity Surrogate (MFS) to approximate multifidelity G&R simulations by using a cokriging approach and (2) developing a novel iterative optimization algorithm for personalized parameter estimation. The proposed framework is demonstrated by estimating G&R model parameters and predicting individual aneurysm growth using follow-up CT images of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysms (AAAs) from 21 patients. Results show that the personalized parameters are satisfactorily estimated and the growth of AAAs is predicted within the clinically relevant time frame, i.e., less than 2 h, without a loss of accuracy.

Sex and Tamoxifen confound murine experimental studies in cardiovascular tissue engineering

Tissue engineered vascular grafts hold promise for the creation of functional blood vessels from biodegradable scaffolds. Because the precise mechanisms regulating this process are still under investigation, inducible genetic mouse models are an important and widely used research tool. However, here we describe the importance of challenging the baseline assumption that tamoxifen is inert when used as a small molecule inducer in the context of cardiovascular tissue engineering. Employing a standard inferior vena cava vascular interposition graft model in C57BL/6 mice, we discovered differences in the immunologic response between control and tamoxifen-treated animals, including occlusion rate, macrophage infiltration and phenotype, the extent of foreign body giant cell development, and collagen deposition. Further, differences were noted between untreated males and females. Our findings demonstrate that the host-response to materials commonly used in cardiovascular tissue engineering is sex-specific and critically impacted by exposure to tamoxifen, necessitating careful model selection and interpretation of results.

Changing compliance of poly(vinyl alcohol) tubular scaffold for vascular graft applications through modifying interlayer adhesion and crosslinking density

Poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) is a water-soluble polymer and forms a hydrogel that has been studied as a potential small-diameter (<6 mm) vascular graft implant. The PVA hydrogel crosslinked using sodium trimetaphosphate (STMP) has been shown to have many beneficial properties such as bioinert, low-thrombogenicity, and easy surface modification. Compared to conventional synthetic vascular graft materials, PVA has also shown to possess better mechanical properties; however, the compliance and other mechanical properties of PVA grafts are yet to be optimized compared to the native blood vessels. Mechanical compliance has been an important parameter to be studied for small-diameter vascular grafts, as compliance has been proposed to play an important role in intimal hyperplasia formation. PVA grafts are made using dip-casting a cylindrical mold into crosslinking solution. The number of dipping can be used to control the wall thickness of the resulting PVA grafts. In this study, we hypothesized that the number of dip layer and wall thickness, the chemical crosslinking, and interlayer adhesive strength could be important parameters in the fabrication process that would affect compliance. This work provides the relationship between the wall thickness, burst pressure, and compliance of PVA. Furthermore, our data showed that interlayer adhesion as well as chemical and physical crosslinking density can increase the compliance of PVA grafts.

3D printing of tissue engineering scaffolds: a focus on vascular regeneration

Tissue engineering is an emerging means for resolving the problems of tissue repair and organ replacement in regenerative medicine. Insufficient supply of nutrients and oxygen to cells in large-scale tissues has led to the demand to prepare blood vessels. Scaffold-based tissue engineering approaches are effective methods to form new blood vessel tissues. The demand for blood vessels prompts systematic research on fabrication strategies of vascular scaffolds for tissue engineering. Recent advances in 3D printing have facilitated fabrication of vascular scaffolds, contributing to broad prospects for tissue vascularization. This review presents state of the art on modeling methods, print materials and preparation processes for fabrication of vascular scaffolds, and discusses the advantages and application fields of each method. Specially, significance and importance of scaffold-based tissue engineering for vascular regeneration are emphasized. Print materials and preparation processes are discussed in detail. And a focus is placed on preparation processes based on 3D printing technologies and traditional manufacturing technologies including casting, electrospinning, and Lego-like construction. And related studies are exemplified. Transformation of vascular scaffolds to clinical application is discussed. Also, four trends of 3D printing of tissue engineering vascular scaffolds are presented, including machine learning, near-infrared photopolymerization, 4D printing, and combination of self-assembly and 3D printing-based methods.

Effects of Braiding Parameters on Tissue Engineered Vascular Graft Development

Tissue engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) using scaffolds fabricated from braided poly(glycolic acid) (PGA) fibers coated with poly(glycerol sebacate) (PGS) are developed. The approach relies on in vivo tissue engineering by which neotissue forms solely within the body after a scaffold has been implanted. Herein, the impact of altering scaffold braid design and scaffold coating on neotissue formation is investigated. Several combinations of braiding parameters are manufactured and evaluated in a Beige mouse model in the infrarenal abdominal aorta. Animals are followed with 4D ultrasound analysis, and 12 week explanted vessels are evaluated for biaxial mechanical properties as well as histological composition. Results show that scaffold parameters (i.e., braiding angle, braiding density, and presence of a PGS coating) have interdependent effects on the resulting graft performance, namely, alteration of these parameters influences levels of inflammation, extracellular matrix production, graft dilation, neovessel distensibility, and overall survival. Coupling carefully designed in vivo experimentation with regression analysis, critical relationships between the scaffold design and the resulting neotissue that enable induction of favorable cellular and extracellular composition in a controlled manner are uncovered. Such an approach provides a potential for fabricating scaffolds with a broad range of features and the potential to manufacture optimized TEVGs.

In Situ Remodeling Overrules Bioinspired Scaffold Architecture of Supramolecular Elastomeric Tissue-Engineered Heart Valves

In situ tissue engineering that uses resorbable synthetic heart valve scaffolds is an affordable and practical approach for heart valve replacement; therefore, it is attractive for clinical use. This study showed no consistent collagen organization in the predefined direction of electrospun scaffolds made from a resorbable supramolecular elastomer with random or circumferentially aligned fibers, after 12 months of implantation in sheep. These unexpected findings and the observed intervalvular variability highlight the need for a mechanistic understanding of the long-term in situ remodeling processes in large animal models to improve predictability of outcome toward robust and safe clinical application.

Inconsistency in Graft Outcome of Bilayered Bioresorbable Supramolecular Arterial Scaffolds in Rats

There is a continuous search for the ideal bioresorbable material to develop scaffolds for in situ vascular tissue engineering. As these scaffolds are exposed to the harsh hemodynamic environment during the entire transformation process from scaffold to neotissue, it is of crucial importance to maintain mechanical integrity and stability at all times. Bilayered scaffolds made of supramolecular polycarbonate-ester-bisurea were manufactured using dual electrospinning. These scaffolds contained a porous inner layer to allow for cellular infiltration and a dense outer layer to provide strength. Scaffolds (n = 21) were implanted as an interposition graft into the abdominal aorta of male Lewis rats and explanted after 1, 3, and 5 months in vivo to assess mechanical functionality and neotissue formation upon scaffold resorption. Results demonstrated conflicting graft outcomes despite homogeneity in the experimental group and scaffold production. Most grafts exhibited adverse remodeling, resulting in aneurysmal dilatation and calcification. However, a few grafts did not demonstrate such features, but instead were characterized by graft extension and smooth muscle cell proliferation in the absence of endothelium, while remaining patent throughout the study. We conclude that it remains extremely difficult to anticipate graft development and performance in vivo. Next to rational mechanical design and good performance in vitro, a thorough understanding of the mechanobiological mechanisms governing scaffold-driven arterial regeneration as well as potential influences of surgical procedures is warranted to further optimize scaffold designs. Careful analysis of the differences between preclinical successes and failures, as is done in this study, may provide initial handles for scaffold optimization and standardized surgical procedures to improve graft performance in vivo. Impact statement In situ vascular tissue engineering using cell-free bioresorbable scaffolds is investigated as an off-the-shelf option to grow small caliber arteries inside the body. In this study, we developed a bilayered electrospun supramolecular scaffold with a dense outer layer to provide mechanical integrity and a porous inner layer for cell recruitment and tissue formation. Despite homogenous scaffold properties and mechanical performance in vitro, in vivo testing as rat aorta interposition grafts revealed distinct graft outcomes, ranging from aneurysms to functional arteries. Careful analysis of this variability provided valuable insights into materials-driven in situ artery formation relevant for scaffold design and implantation procedures.

Electrospun Tissue-Engineered Arterial Graft Thickness Affects Long-Term Composition and Mechanics

Wall stress is often lower in tissue-engineered constructs than in comparable native tissues due to the use of stiff polymeric materials having thicker walls. In this work, we sought to design a murine arterial graft having a more favorable local mechanical environment for the infiltrating cells; we used electrospinning to enclose a compliant inner core of poly(glycerol sebacate) with a stiffer sheath of poly(caprolactone) to reduce the potential for rupture. Two scaffolds were designed that differed in the thickness of the core as previous computational simulations found that circumferential wall stresses could be increased in the core toward native values by increasing the ratio of the core:sheath. Our modified electrospinning protocols reduced swelling of the core upon implantation and eliminated residual stresses in the sheath, both of which had contributed to the occlusion of implanted grafts during pilot studies. For both designs, a subset of implanted grafts occluded due to thrombosis or ruptured due to suspected point defects in the sheath. However, there were design-based differences in collagen content and mechanical behavior during early remodeling of the patent samples, with the thinner-core scaffolds having more collagen and a stiffer behavior after 12 weeks of implantation than the thicker-core scaffolds. By 24 weeks, the thicker-core scaffolds also became stiff, with similar amounts of collagen but increased smooth muscle cell and elastin content. These data suggest that increasing wall stress toward native values may provide a more favorable environment for normal arterial constituents to form despite the overall stiffness of the construct remaining elevated due to the absolute increase in load-bearing constituents.

Vascular adaptation in the presence of external support - A modeling study

Vascular grafts have long been used to replace damaged or diseased vessels with considerable success, but a new approach is emerging where native vessels are merely supported, not replaced. Although external supports have been evaluated in diverse situations - ranging from aneurysmal disease to vein grafts or the Ross operation - optimal supports and procedures remain wanting. In this paper, we present a novel application of a growth and remodeling model well suited for parametrically exploring multiple designs of external supports while accounting for mechanobiological and immunobiological responses of the supported native vessel. These results suggest that a load bearing external support can reduce vessel thickening in response to pressure elevation. Results also suggest that the final adaptive state of the vessel depends on the structural stiffness of the support via a mechano-driven adaptation, although luminal encroachment may be a complication in the presence of chronic inflammation. Finally, the supported vessel can stiffen (structurally and materially) along circumferential and axial directions, which could have implications on overall hemodynamics and thus subsequent vascular remodeling. The proposed framework can provide valuable insights into vascular adaptation in the presence of external support, accelerate rational design, and aid translation of this emerging approach.

Next-generation tissue-engineered heart valves with repair, remodelling and regeneration capacity

Valvular heart disease is a major cause of morbidity and mortality worldwide. Surgical valve repair or replacement has been the standard of care for patients with valvular heart disease for many decades, but transcatheter heart valve therapy has revolutionized the field in the past 15 years. However, despite the tremendous technical evolution of transcatheter heart valves, to date, the clinically available heart valve prostheses for surgical and transcatheter replacement have considerable limitations. The design of next-generation tissue-engineered heart valves (TEHVs) with repair, remodelling and regenerative capacity can address these limitations, and TEHVs could become a promising therapeutic alternative for patients with valvular disease. In this Review, we present a comprehensive overview of current clinically adopted heart valve replacement options, with a focus on transcatheter prostheses. We discuss the various concepts of heart valve tissue engineering underlying the design of next-generation TEHVs, focusing on off-the-shelf technologies. We also summarize the latest preclinical and clinical evidence for the use of these TEHVs and describe the current scientific, regulatory and clinical challenges associated with the safe and broad clinical translation of this technology.

Computational modeling for cardiovascular tissue engineering: the importance of including cell behavior in growth and remodeling algorithms

Understanding cardiovascular growth and remodeling (G&R) is fundamental for designing robust cardiovascular tissue engineering strategies, which enable synthetic or biological scaffolds to transform into healthy living tissues after implantation. Computational modeling, particularly when integrated with experimental research, is key for advancing our understanding, predicting the in vivo evolution of engineered tissues, and efficiently optimizing scaffold designs. As cells are ultimately the drivers of G&R and known to change their behavior in response to mechanical cues, increasing efforts are currently undertaken to capture (mechano-mediated) cell behavior in computational models. In this selective review, we highlight some recent examples that are relevant in the context of cardiovascular tissue engineering and discuss the current and future biological and computational challenges for modeling cell-mediated G&R.

Current understanding of intimal hyperplasia and effect of compliance in synthetic small diameter vascular grafts

Despite much effort, synthetic small diameter vascular grafts still face limited success due to vascular wall thickening known as intimal hyperplasia (IH). Compliance mismatch between graft and native vessels has been proposed to be one of a key mechanical factors of synthetic vascular grafts that could contribute to the formation of IH. While many methods have been developed to determine compliance both in vivo and in vitro, the effects of compliance mismatch still remain uncertain. This review aims to explain the biomechanical factors that are responsible for the formation and development of IH and their relationship with compliance mismatch. Furthermore, this review will address the current methods used to measure compliance both in vitro and in vivo. Lastly, current limitations in understanding the connection between the compliance of vascular grafts and the role it plays in the development and progression of IH will be discussed.

Bioresorbable silk grafts for small diameter vascular tissue engineering applications: In vitro and in vivo functional analysis

The success of tissue-engineered vascular graft (TEVG) predominantly relies on the selection of a suitable biomaterial and graft design. Natural biopolymer silk has shown great promise for various tissue-engineering applications. This study is the first to investigate Indian endemic non-mulberry silk (Antheraea assama-AA) - which inherits naturally superior mechanical and biological traits (e.g., RGD motifs) compared to Bombyx mori-BM silk, for TEVG applications. We designed bi-layered biomimetic small diameter AA-BM silk TEVGs adopting a new fabrication methodology. The inner layer showed ideally sized (~40 µm) pores with interconnectivity to allow cellular infiltration, and an outer dense electrospun layer that confers mechanical resilience. Biodegradation of silk TEVGs into amino acids as resorbable byproducts corroborates their in vivo remodeling ability. Following our previous reports, we surgically implanted human adipose tissue-derived stromal vascular fraction (SVF) seeded silk TEVGs in Lewis rats as abdominal aortic interposition grafts for 8 weeks. Adequate suture retention strength (0.45 ± 0.1 N) without any blood seepage post-implantation substantiate the grafts' viability. AA silk-based TEVGs showed superior animal survival and graft patency compared to BM silk TEVGs. Histological analysis revealed neo-tissue formation, host cell infiltration and graft remodeling in terms of extracellular matrix turnover. Altogether, this study demonstrates promising aspects of AA silk TEVGs for vascular tissue engineering applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Clinical 'off the shelf' implementation of tissue-engineered vascular grafts (TEVGs) remains a challenge. Achieving optimal blood vessel regeneration requires the use of bioresorbable materials having suitable degradation rates while producing minimal or no toxic byproducts. Host cell recruitment and preventing acute thrombosis are other pre-requisites for successful graft remodeling. In this study, for the first time we explored the use of naturally derived Indian endemic non-mulberry Antheraea assama silk in combination with Bombyx mori silk for TEVG applications by adopting a new biomimetic approach. Our bi-layered silk TEVGs were optimally porous, mechanically resilient and biodegradable. In vivo implantation in rat aorta showed long-term patency and graft remodeling by host cell infiltration and extracellular matrix deposition corroborating their clinical feasibility.

Histological mapping of porcine carotid arteries - An animal model for the assessment of artificial conduits suitable for coronary bypass grafting in humans

BACKGROUND

Using animal models in experimental medicine requires mapping of their anatomical variability. Porcine common carotid arteries (CCA) are often preferred for the preclinical testing of vascular grafts due to their anatomical and physiological similarity to human small-diameter arteries. Comparing the microscopic structure of animal model organs to their human counterparts reveals the benefits and limitations of translational medicine.

METHODS

Using quantitative histology and stereology, we performed an extensive mapping of the regional proximodistal differences in the fractions of elastin, collagen, and smooth muscle actin as well as the intima-media and wall thicknesses among 404 segments (every 1 cm) of porcine CCAs collected from male and female pigs (n = 21). We also compared the microscopic structure of porcine CCAs with segments of human coronary arteries and one of the preferred arterial conduits used for the coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG), namely, the internal thoracic artery (ITA) (n = 21 human cadavers).

RESULTS

The results showed that the histological structure of left and right porcine CCA can be considered equivalent, provided that gross anatomical variations of the regular branching patterns are excluded. The proximal elastic carotid (51.2% elastin, 4.2% collagen, and 37.2% actin) transitioned to more muscular middle segments (23.5% elastin, 4.9% collagen, 54.3% actin) at the range of 2-3 centimeters and then to even more muscular distal segments (17.2% elastin, 4.9% collagen, 64.0% actin). The resulting morphometric data set shows the biological variability of the artery and is made available for biomechanical modeling and for performing a power analysis and calculating the minimum number of samples per group when planning further experiments with this widely used large animal model.

CONCLUSIONS

Comparison of porcine carotids with human coronary arteries and ITA revealed the benefits and the limitations of using porcine CCAs as a valid model for testing bioengineered small-diameter CABG vascular conduits. Morphometry of human coronary arteries and ITA provided more realistic data for tailoring multilayered artificial vascular prostheses and the ranges of values within which the conduits should be tested in the future. Despite their limitations, porcine CCAs remain a widely used and well-characterized large animal model that is available for a variety of experiments in vascular surgery.