Positive and negative selection of antigen-specific B cells in transgenic mice expressing variant forms of the V(H)1 (T15) heavy chain

B Cell Defects Observed in Nod2 Knockout Mice Are a Consequence of a Dock2 Mutation Frequently Found in Inbred Strains

Phenotypic differences among substrains of laboratory mice due to spontaneous mutations or pre-existing genetic variation confound the interpretation of targeted mutagenesis experiments and contribute to challenges with reproducibility across institutions. Notably, C57BL/6 Hsd mice and gene-targeted mice that have been backcrossed to this substrain have been reported to harbor a duplication in exons 28 and 29 of Dock2 In this study, we demonstrate the presence of this Dock2 variant in the widely used Nod2^-/- mice. Nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain-containing protein 2 (NOD2) is a cytosolic innate immune receptor associated with inflammatory bowel disease susceptibility. Consistent with a role of NOD2 in an immunological disorder, Nod2^-/- mice bred at our institution displayed multiple B cell defects including deficiencies in recirculating B cells, marginal zone B cells, and B1a cells in vivo, as well as defects in class switch recombination in vitro. However, we found that these effects are due to the Dock2 variant and are independent of Nod2 deletion. Despite originating from the same gene-targeted founder mice, Nod2^-/- mice from another source did not harbor the Dock2 variant or B cell defects. Finally, we show that Dock2^-/- mice display the same B cell defects as mice harboring the Dock2 variant, confirming that the variant is a loss-of-function mutation and is sufficient to explain the alterations to the B cell compartment observed in Nod2^-/- mice. Our findings highlight the effects of confounding mutations from widely used inbred strains on gene-targeted mice and reveal new functions of DOCK2 in B cells.

Types of tolerance seen in autoreactive phosphocholine-specific B cells are dependent on the idiotype of the receptors expressed

Phosphocholine (PC) is the immunodominant epitope found on the surface of a number of microorganisms, including Streptococcus pneumoniae (SPn), and is thought to play a vital role in the pathogenesis of SPn. B cells expressing M167Hκ24L immunoglobulin receptors specific for PC have been shown to be autoreactive in that they undergo clonal deletion in both X-linked immune-deficient and Rag(-/-) mice. We have now shown that B cells expressing M603Hκ8L PC-specific receptors also delete in Rag(-/-) mice, whereas those expressing T15Hκ22L transgenes do not delete. However, T15Hκ22L B cells are lost in normal heterozygous transgenic mice because they cannot compete with normal B cells. These data indicate that M167Hκ24L and M603Hκ8L PC-specific B cells are recognizing an autoantigen expressed on membranes which causes them to downregulate their receptors and clonally delete, while T15Hκ22L B cells are tolerized by a soluble form of PC-antigen which results in their being trapped in the spleen. Thus, the types of tolerance seen in autoreactive PC-specific B cells are dependent on the idiotype of the receptors expressed.

Differential idiotype utilization for the in vivo type 14 capsular polysaccharide-specific Ig responses to intact Streptococcus pneumoniae versus a pneumococcal conjugate vaccine

Murine IgG responses specific for the capsular polysaccharide (pneumococcal capsular polysaccharide serotype 14; PPS14) of Streptococcus pneumoniae type 14 (Pn14), induced in response to intact Pn14 or a PPS14-protein conjugate, are both dependent on CD4(+) T cell help but appear to use marginal zone versus follicular B cells, respectively. In this study, we identify an idiotype (44.1-Id) that dominates the PPS14-specific IgG, but not IgM, responses to intact Pn14, isolated PPS14, and Group B Streptococcus (strain COH1-11) expressing capsular polysaccharide structurally identical to PPS14. The 44.1-Id, however, is not expressed in the repertoire of natural PPS14-specific Abs. In distinct contrast, PPS14-specific IgG responses to a soluble PPS14-protein conjugate exhibit minimal usage of the 44.1-Id, although significant 44.1-Id expression is elicited in response to conjugate attached to particles. The 44.1-Id elicited in response to intact Pn14 was expressed in similar proportions among all four IgG subclasses during both the primary and secondary responses. The 44.1-Id usage was linked to the Igh(a), but not Igh(b), allotype and was associated with induction of relatively high total PPS14-specific IgG responses. In contrast to PPS14-protein conjugate, avidity maturation of the 44.1-Id-dominant PPS14-specific IgG responses was limited, even during the highly boosted T cell-dependent PPS14-specific secondary responses to COH1-11. These results indicate that different antigenic forms of the same capsular polysaccharide can recruit distinct B cell clones expressing characteristic idiotypes under genetic control and suggest that the 44.1-Id is derived from marginal zone B cells.

Anti-nuclear antibody production and autoimmunity in transgenic mice that overexpress the transcription factor Bright

The B cell-restricted transcription factor, B cell regulator of Ig(H) transcription (Bright), up-regulates Ig H chain transcription 3- to 7-fold in activated B cells in vitro. Bright function is dependent upon both active Bruton's tyrosine kinase and its substrate, the transcription factor, TFII-I. In mouse and human B lymphocytes, Bright transcription is down-regulated in mature B cells, and its expression is tightly regulated during B cell differentiation. To determine how Bright expression affects B cell development, transgenic mice were generated that express Bright constitutively in all B lineage cells. These mice exhibited increases in total B220(+) B lymphocyte lineage cells in the bone marrow, but the relative percentages of the individual subpopulations were not altered. Splenic immature transitional B cells were significantly expanded both in total cell numbers and as increased percentages of cells relative to other B cell subpopulations. Serum Ig levels, particularly IgG isotypes, were increased slightly in the Bright-transgenic mice compared with littermate controls. However, immunization studies suggest that responses to all foreign Ags were not increased globally. Moreover, 4-wk-old Bright-transgenic mice produced anti-nuclear Abs. Older animals developed Ab deposits in the kidney glomeruli, but did not succumb to further autoimmune sequelae. These data indicate that enhanced Bright expression results in failure to maintain B cell tolerance and suggest a previously unappreciated role for Bright regulation in immature B cells. Bright is the first B cell-restricted transcription factor demonstrated to induce autoimmunity. Therefore, the Bright transgenics provide a novel model system for future analyses of B cell autoreactivity.

Pre-B cell loss in senescence coincides with preferential development of immature B cells characterized by partial activation and altered Vh repertoire

Senescent mice show decline in B lymphopoiesis marked by reduced pre-B cells. Analysis of bone marrow from aged (approximately 2 years old) BALB/c mice indicates that, in senescence, an increased proportion of immature B cells exhibit a CD43/S7+ surface phenotype. This results from continued production of new CD43/S7+ B cells in aged mice from their limited pre-B cell pool while production of CD43/S7- immature B cells is highly reduced. CD43/S7 is ordinarily observed on a minor subset of immature B cells in young mice and is indicative of their partial activation. Senescent immature B cells, both ex vivo and derived in vitro, also demonstrate increased expression of VhS107 concomitant with CD43/S7. These alterations in the phenotype and Vh repertoire among senescent immature B cells likely originate prior to surface Ig expression. In aged mice with depleted pre-B and immature B cells in vivo, pre-B and immature B cells exhibited increased apoptosis in vitro. Dexamethasone-induced apoptosis among B lineage cells in young adult mice also resulted in pre-B cell loss and increased expression of CD43/S7 and VhS107 among immature B cells similar to that observed spontaneously in aged mice. These results suggest that old age, possibly due to increased apoptosis, results in loss of pre-B cells and alterations in the phenotype and Vh repertoire of newly derived B cells.

Natural antibodies and the autoimmunity of atherosclerosis

In recent years, the subject of natural antibodies has been revisited and the immunobiological roles of these humoral factors are being better defined. These antibodies are secreted by distinct sets of innate-like B cells, B-1 cells and marginal zone B cells, which arise early in development to become the sources of "natural immune memory". Due to their interactions with a variety of self-determinants, natural antibodies have previously been postulated to play roles in the maintenance of host homeostasis. A central paradigm has recently been developed from the demonstration that oxidation derived epitopes on apoptotic cells and oxidized low-density lipoproteins are recognized by the phosphorylcholine-specific germline encoded B-1 cell natural antibody, T15, which has provided important insights into possible "house-keeping" functions under both normal and pathological conditions. In this review, the potential functions of natural antibodies in the pathogenesis and progression of the chronic inflammatory condition of atherosclerosis are discussed, as well as their capacities for apoptotic cell binding and clearance. These interactions of natural antibodies and oxidation-epitopes from phospholipids appear to provide a dynamic immunobiological connection linking host responses in infection, autoimmunity and atherosclerosis.

The autoreactivity of anti-phosphorylcholine antibodies for atherosclerosis-associated neo-antigens and apoptotic cells

Abs specific for phosphorylcholine (PC) are known to contribute to the immune defense against a variety of microbial infections. To assess for other types of binding interactions, we performed surveys of anti-PC Abs of diverse biologic origins and structural diversity and demonstrated a common autoreactivity for oxidatively modified low density lipoprotein and other oxidation-specific structures containing PC-Ags. We also found that cells undergoing apoptosis sequentially express a range of oxidation-specific neo-self PC determinants. Whereas natural Abs to PC recognized cells at early stages of apoptosis, by contrast, an IgG anti-PC Ab, representative of a T cell-dependent response, recognized PC determinants primarily associated with late stages of apoptosis. Cumulatively, these results demonstrate a fundamental paradigm in which Abs from both the innate and the T cell-dependent tiers of the B cell compartment recognize a minimal molecular motif arrayed both on microbes and as neo-self Ags linked to atherosclerosis and autoimmune disease.

T15-idiotype-negative B cells dominate the phosphocholine binding cells in the preimmune repertoire of T15i knockin mice

T15i knockin (KI) mice express a H chain that is encoded by a rearranged T15 VDJ transgene which has been inserted into the J(H) region of chromosome 12. This T15H chain combines with a kappa22-33 L chain to produce a T15-Id+ Ab having specificity for phosphocholine (PC). Inasmuch as T15-Id+ Abs dominate the primary immune response to PC in normal mice, it was surprising to find that 80% of the PC-dextran-binding B cells in unimmunized homozygous T15i KI mice were T15-Id-. Analysis of L chains expressed in these T15-Id-, PC-specific B cells revealed that two L chains, kappa8-28 and kappa19-15, were expressed in this population. The V(kappa) region of these L chains was recombined to J(kappa)5, which is typical of L chains present in PC-specific Abs. When T15i KI mice were immunized with PC Ag, T15-Id+ B cells expanded 6-fold and differentiated into Ab-secreting cells. There was no indication that the T15-Id- B cells either proliferated or differentiated into Ab-secreting cells following immunization. Thus, T15-Id- B cells dominate the PC-binding population, but they fail to compete with T15-Id+ B cells during a functional immune response. Structural analysis of T15H:kappa8-28L and T15H:kappa19-15L Abs revealed L chain differences from the kappa22-33 L chain which could account for the lower affinity and/or avidity of these Abs for PC or PC carrier compared with the T15-Id+ T15H:kappa22-33L Ab.

Marginal zone and B1 B cells unite in the early response against T-independent blood-borne particulate antigens

The rate of pathogen elimination determines the extent and consequences of an infection. In this context, the spleen with its highly specialized lymphoid compartments plays a central role in clearing blood-borne pathogens. Splenic marginal zone B cells (MZ), by virtue of their preactivated state and topographical location, join B1 B cells to generate a massive wave of IgM producing plasmablasts in the initial 3 days of a primary response to particulate bacterial antigens. Because of the intensity and rapidity of this response, combined with the types of antibodies produced, splenic MZ and B1 B cells endowed with a "natural memory" provide a bridge between the very early innate and the later appearing adaptive immune response.

Cutting edge commentary: origins of B-1 cells

The origin of B-1a cells, a minority population of B cells that express CD5, are abundant in coelomic cavities, and often produce autoantibodies, has been the subject of study for many years. Accumulating evidence demonstrates that the hypothesis that only B cells arising in fetal or neonatal tissues have the potential to become B-1a cells cannot be true. Rather, B cell receptor-mediated signaling initiated by ligation of autoantigen has now been shown to be required for induction of the B-1a phenotype. Furthermore, cells with a functional B-1a phenotype can be induced from adult precursors by appropriate Ag. At the same time, microenvironment-specific events may determine the likelihood that a given B cell, either adult or fetal derived, enters this pathway. CD5 expression and possibly localization to the peritoneum appear to provide some protection to autoreactive cells otherwise slated for elimination.