Effects of transgenic mixed-haplotype MHC class II molecules A alpha d A beta z on autoimmune disease in New Zealand mice

B cell MHC haplotype affects follicular inclusion, germinal center participation and plasma cell differentiation in a mouse model of lupus

Introduction

MHC class II molecules are essential for appropriate immune responses against pathogens but are also implicated in pathological responses in autoimmune diseases and transplant rejection. Previous studies have shed light on the systemic contributions of MHC haplotypes to the development and severity of autoimmune diseases. In this study, we addressed the B cell intrinsic MHC haplotype impact on follicular inclusion, germinal center (GC) participation and plasma cell (PC) differentiation in the context of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

Methods

We leveraged the 564Igi mouse model which harbors a B cell receptor knock-in from an autoreactive B cell clone recognizing ribonuclear components, including double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). This model recapitulates the central hallmarks of the early stages of SLE. We compared 564Igi heterozygous offspring on either H2b/b, H2b/d, or H2d/d background.

Results

This revealed significantly higher germinal center (GC) B cell levels in the spleens of H2b/b and H2b/d as compared to H2d/d (p<0.0001) mice. In agreement with this, anti-dsDNA-antibody levels were higher in H2b/b and H2b/d than in H2d/d (p<0.0001), with H2b/b also being higher compared to H2b/d (p<0.01). Specifically, these differences held true both for autoantibodies derived from the knock-in clone and from wild-type (WT) derived clones. In mixed chimeras where 564Igi H2b/b, H2b/d and H2d/d cells competed head-to-head in the same environment, we observed a significantly higher inclusion of H2b/b cells in GC and PC compartments relative to their representation in the B cell repertoire, compared to H2b/d and H2d/d cells. Furthermore, in mixed chimeras in which WT H2b/b and WT H2d/d cells competed for inclusion in GCs associated with an epitope spreading process, H2b/b cells participated to a greater extent and contributed more robustly to the PC compartment. Finally, immature WT H2b/b cells had a higher baseline of BCRs with an autoreactive idiotype and were subject to more stringent negative selection at the transitional stage.

Discussion

Taken together, our findings demonstrate that B cell intrinsic MHC haplotype governs their capacity for participation in the autoreactive response at multiple levels: follicular inclusion, GC participation, and PC output. These findings pinpoint B cells as central contributors to precipitation of autoimmunity.

Genetic control of the spontaneous activation of CD4+ Th cells in systemic lupus erythematosus-prone (NZB x NZW) F1 mice

The F(1) hybrid of autoimmune hemolytic anemia-prone NZB and nonautoimmune NZW strains of mice has been studied as a murine model of systemic lupus erythematosus. Both NZB and F(1) hybrid mice show age-dependent spontaneous activation of peripheral CD4(+) T cells as reflected by the elevated frequencies of CD4(+) T cells positive for CD69 early activation marker. Both strains also show age-dependent abnormal decrease of the frequencies of CD62L(+) naive CD4(+) T cells and/or NTA260(+) memory CD4(+) T cells in the spleen. We studied the multigenic control of these abnormal features of peripheral CD4(+) T cells in (NZB x NZW) F(1) x NZW backcross mice by quantitative trait loci mapping and by association rule analysis. The abnormally elevated frequencies of CD69(+)CD4(+) T cells and decreased frequencies of CD62L(+) naive and/or NTA260(+) memory CD4(+) T cells were under the common genetic control, in which the interaction between MHC and a hitherto unknown locus, designated Sta-1 (spontaneous T-cell activation) on chromosome 12, plays a major role. The allelic effects of these loci likely predispose CD4(+) T cells to the loss of self-tolerance, and are responsible for the accelerated autoimmune phenotypes of (NZB x NZW) F(1) hybrid mice.

Significance of MHC class II haplotypes and IgG Fc receptors in SLE

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a systemic antibody-mediated autoimmune disease that develops under the control of multiple susceptibility genes. Genetic studies in murine and human SLE have identified several chromosomal intervals that contain candidate susceptibility genes. However, the ultimate identification of the genes and their roles in disease process need much further investigation. Spontaneous murine SLE models provide useful tools in this respect. In this chapter, we show this line of investigation, particularly focusing on the roles of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II and immunoglobulin G Fc receptors (FcgammaRs). The existence of high-affinity autoantibodies is evidence that autoimmunity in SLE is antigen-driven. Thereby, MHC class II haplotypes have been implicated in SLE susceptibility; however, because of the linkage disequilibrium that exists among the class I, II and III genes within the MHC complex, it has been difficult to discriminate the relative contributions of individual loci. On the other hand, the extent of antibody synthesis upon antigen stimulation and associated inflammatory cascades are controlled in several ways by the balance of stimulatory and inhibitory signaling molecules on immune cells. Stimulatory/inhibitory FcgammaRs mediate one such mechanism, and there are reports indicating the association between polymorphic FcgammaRs and SLE. However, as stimulatory and inhibitory FcgammaRs cluster on the telomeric chromosome 1, the absolute contribution of individual genes has been difficult to dissect. In studies of genetic dissection using interval-congenic and intragenic recombinant mouse strains of SLE models, we show evidence and discuss how and to what extent MHC class II molecules and stimulatory/inhibitory FcgammaRs are involved in SLE susceptibility.

A novel susceptibility locus on chromosome 2 in the (New Zealand Black x New Zealand White)F1 hybrid mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is inherited as a complex polygenic trait. (New Zealand Black (NZB) x New Zealand White (NZW)) F(1) hybrid mice develop symptoms that remarkably resemble human SLE, but (NZB x PL/J)F(1) hybrids do not develop lupus. Our study was conducted using (NZW x PL/J)F(1) x NZB (BWP) mice to determine the effects of the PL/J and the NZW genome on disease. Forty-five percent of BWP female mice had significant proteinuria and 25% died before 12 mo of age compared with (NZB x NZW)F(1) mice in which >90% developed severe renal disease and died before 12 mo. The analysis of BWP mice revealed a novel locus (chi(2) = 25.0; p < 1 x 10(-6); log of likelihood = 6.6 for mortality) designated Wbw1 on chromosome 2, which apparently plays an important role in the development of the disease. We also observed that both H-2 class II (the u haplotype) and TNF-alpha (TNF(z) allele) appear to contribute to the disease. A suggestive linkage to proteinuria and death was found for an NZW allele (designated Wbw2) telomeric to the H-2 locus. The NZW allele that overlaps with the previously described locus Sle1c at the telomeric part of chromosome 1 was associated with antinuclear autoantibody production in the present study. Furthermore, the previously identified Sle and Lbw susceptibility loci were associated with an increased incidence of disease. Thus, multiple NZW alleles including the Wbw1 allele discovered in this study contribute to disease induction, in conjunction with the NZB genome, and the PL/J genome appears to be protective.

HLA-DR modulates autoantibody repertoire, but not mortality, in a humanized mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus

To evaluate the disease-modulating role of HLA-DR2 and DR3 molecules, which have been associated with systemic lupus erythematosus, a humanized mouse model was examined. HLA-DR2 (DRB1*1502)- and DR3 (DRB1*0301)-transgenic mice were backcrossed to the New Zealand Mixed 2410 (NZM 2410, H2(z)) strain. Seventh generation DR2 and DR3 transgene-positive animals along with their transgene-negative littermates and the parental strain NZM2410 were monitored for proteinuria, azotemia, autoantibody production, development of nephritis, and mortality. The results showed no significant differences in proteinuria, azotemia, or mortality between the backcrosses with and without HLA-DR2 or HLA-DR3. However, the genetic analysis of different backcrosses showed that heterozygosity at the endogenous H2-E locus (E(z)/E(b)) was strongly linked with acceleration of lupus nephritis in both HLA-DR2 and HLA-DR3 transgenics. More importantly, the presence of the HLA-DR2, but not the HLA-DR3, transgene significantly enhanced the production of anti-dsDNA, but not anti-ssDNA, anti-histone-dsDNA complex, or anti-histone, Abs. In contrast, neither HLA-DR2 nor HLA-DR3 influenced the development of glomerulonephritis or the degree of immune complex deposition. Moreover, nephritic kidneys from mice with and without HLA-DR2 or HLA-DR3 transgenes showed similar patterns of cytokine expression. Collectively, these findings provide molecular evidence that the association of HLA-DR2 or HLA-DR3 with lupus susceptibility is related to the type of autoantibody rather than to disease mortality. The use of a humanized mouse model provides a way of dissecting the roles of human MHC genes in systemic lupus erythematosus pathogenesis.

Genetic aspects of inherent B-cell abnormalities associated with SLE and B-cell malignancy: lessons from New Zealand mouse models

Genes that predispose to SLE are closely related to key events in pathogenesis of this disease. As much of the pathology can be attributed to high affinity autoantibodies and/or their immune complexes, some of the genes may exert effects in the process of emergence, escape from tolerance mechanisms, activation, clonal expansion, differentiation, class switching and affinity maturation of self-reactive B cells. A number of growth and differentiation factors and signaling molecules, including positive and negative regulators, are involved in this process. Genetic variations associated with functional deficits in some of such molecules can be involved in the susceptibility for SLE. As is the case with SLE, hereditary factors play significant roles in the pathogenesis of B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL). Patients with B-CLL or their family members frequently have immunological abnormalities, including those associated with SLE. It is suggested that certain genetically determined regulatory abnormalities of B cells may be a crossroad between B-CLL and SLE. A thorough understanding of the genetic pathways in B cell abnormalities leading to either SLE or B-CLL is expected to shed light on their association. New Zealand mouse strains are pertinent laboratory models for these studies. Chromosomal locations of several major genetic loci for abnormal proliferation, differentiation and maturation of B cells and relevant candidate genes, located in close proximity to these intervals and potentially related to the SLE pathogenesis, have been identified in these mice. Further studies make for a wider knowledge and understanding of the pathogenesis of SLE and related B-cell malignancy.

Lessons from BXSB and related mouse models

The BXSB murine strain spontaneously develops an autoimmune syndrome with features of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) that affects males much earlier than females, due to the presence of an as yet unidentified mutant gene located on its Y chromosome, designated Yaa (Y-linked autoimmune acceleration). The Yaa gene by itself is unable to induce significant autoimmune responses in mice without an apparent SLE background, while it can induce and accelerate the development of an SLE in combination with autosomal susceptibility alleles present in lupus-prone mice. Although the genes encoded within or closely linked to the MHC locus play an important role in the development or protection of SLE, the MHC effect can be completely masked by the presence of the Yaa gene in mice highly predisposed to SLE. The role of the Yaa gene for the acceleration of SLE is apparently two-fold; it enhances overall autoimmune responses against autoantigens to which mice respond relatively weakly, and promotes Th 1 responses against autoantigens to which mice respond relatively well, leading to the production of more pathogenic autoantibodies, i.e., FcgammaR-fixing IgG2a and cryoglobulin IgG3 autoantibodies. Yaa+ - Yaa- double bone marrow chimera experiments revealed that the Yaa defect is expressed in B cells, but not in T cells, and that T cells from non-autoimmune mice are capable of providing help for autoimmune responses by collaborating Yaa+ B cells. We speculate that the Yaa defect may decrease the threshold for antigen receptor-dependent stimulation, leading to the triggering and excessive stimulation of autoreactive T and B cells.

The pathogenesis of autoimmunity in New Zealand mice

OBJECTIVE

New Zealand mice were the first spontaneous animal model of human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Since their initial discovery in 1959, studies of these mice have provided insights into the immunopathogenesis and genetics of lupus and have had a substantial impact on our understanding of autoimmunity.

METHODS

We extensively reviewed published data for the past 40 years, including work in cellular immunology and molecular biology, to provide new information on the role of lymphoid subpopulations, cytokines, costimulatory molecules, apoptosis, and genetic susceptibility in the natural history of immunopathology in murine lupus.

RESULTS

Genetic factors constitute the most important contribution to autoimmunity in New Zealand mice, and specific major susceptibility loci have been described. In addition, there is evidence for a pluripotent stem cell defect, which has implications for developmental and functional defects of T and B cells. The end result of these defects is a breakdown of self-tolerance and production of autoantibodies. Further studies will undoubtedly shape our understanding of this murine model and provide the basis for novel diagnostic and therapeutic approaches in humans.

CONCLUSIONS

The advent of molecular biology, including the use of monoclonal antibody therapy in New Zealand mice, has been instrumental in our understanding of the loss of self-tolerance in SLE. Finally, identification of genetic susceptibility loci in the murine system has also led to important comparable studies in humans with SLE.

RELEVANCE

The observations in New Zealand mice are of particular importance to systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

Control of separate pathogenic autoantibody responses marks MHC gene contributions to murine lupus

Previous studies have suggested that MHC and non-MHC genes contribute to the development of autoimmune disease in F1 hybrids of New Zealand black (NZB) and white (NZW) mice. We conducted a genome-wide screen of 148 female (NZB x NZW)F1 x NZB backcross mice to map dominant NZW genetic loci linked with lupus disease traits. In this backcross analysis, inheritance of the NZW MHC (H2(d/z) vs. H2(d/d)) was strongly linked with the development of lupus nephritis (P approximately 1 x 10(-16)), increasing the risk of disease by over 30-fold. H2(d/z) was also linked with elevated serum levels of IgG autoantibodies to single-stranded DNA, double-stranded DNA, histones, and chromatin but not with anti-gp70 autoantibodies, measured as circulating gp70-anti-gp70 immune complexes. Non-MHC contributions from NZW seemed weak in comparison to MHC, although NZW loci on chromosomes 7 and 16 were noted to be suggestively linked with autoantibody production. Strikingly, H2(d/z) (compared with H2(d/d)) enhanced antinuclear antibodies in a coordinate fashion but did not affect anti-gp70 production in the current backcross. However, the opposite influence was noted for H2(d/z) (compared with H2(z/z)) when (NZB x NZW)F1 x NZW backcross mice were analyzed. These results suggest that H2(z) and H2(d) haplotypes differentially regulate two different sets of nephritogenic autoantibody responses. This study confirms a critical role for H2(z) compared with other dominant NZW loci in (NZB x NZW)F1 mice and provides an explanation as to why H2(d/z) heterozygosity is required for full expression of disease in this model.

Analysis of MHC Class II Genes in the Susceptibility to Lupus in New Zealand Mice

Hybrids of New Zealand Black (NZB) and New Zealand White (NZW) mice spontaneously develop a disease similar to human systemic lupus erythematosus. MHC and non-MHC genes contribute to disease susceptibility in this murine model. Multiple studies have shown that the NZW H2z locus is strongly associated with the development of lupus-like disease in these mice. The susceptibility gene(s) within H2z is not known, but different lines of evidence have pointed to class II MHC genes, either H2-E or H2-A (Ez or Az in NZW). Recent studies from our laboratory showed that Ez does not supplant H2z in the contribution to lupus-like disease. In the present work we generated C57BL/10 (B10) mice transgenic for Aaz and Abz genes (designated B10.Az mice) and used a (B10.Az × NZB)F1 × NZB backcross to assess the contributions of Az genes to disease. A subset of backcross mice produced high levels of IgG autoantibodies and developed severe nephritis. However, no autoimmune phenotype was linked to the Az transgenes. Surprisingly, in the same backcross mice, inheritance of H2b from the nonautoimmune B10 strain was strongly linked with both autoantibody production and nephritis. Taken together with our previous Ez studies, the present work calls into question the importance of class II MHC genes for lupus susceptibility in this model and provides new insight into the role of MHC in lupus-like autoimmunity.

Peptide-binding motifs of the mixed haplotype Abetaz/Aalphad major histocompatibility complex class II molecule: a restriction element for auto-reactive T cells in (NZBxNZW)F1 mice

We previously showed that the mixed haplotype Abetaz/Aalphad major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules function as restricting element for autoreactive T-cell clones derived from autoimmune prone (NZBxNZW)F1 (B/WF1) mice. Subsequent analysis revealed that some of these Abetaz/Aalphad-restricted autoreactive T-cell clones were pathogenic upon transfer to pre-autoimmune B/WF1 mice. In this paper, we analysed the peptide-binding motif of Abetaz/Aalphad class II molecules. Amino acid-sequencing analysis of peptides eluted from purified Abetaz/Aalphad molecules revealed several sequences, including one that corresponds to murine l-plastin 588-601. Synthetic 18-mer l-plastin 588-605 peptide (SMARKIGARVYALPEDLV, as described by the amino acid single letter code) was demonstrated to bind to Abetaz/Aalphad MHC class II molecules on transfectant B lymphoma cells (TAbetaz). A competitive binding inhibition assay using truncation peptides revealed the core sequence for binding resides in 591Arg to 601Pro. Binding inhibition assay using substitution peptides, each having substitution to the other 19 residues at positions from 590Ala to 601Pro, revealed four major anchor sites 592Lys (p1), 594Gly (p3), 595Ala (p4), 597Val (p6) and one minor anchor site 600Leu (p9). Positively charged residues are not allowed at p3 and negatively charged residues are not allowed at p4 and p6. Relatively large hydrophobic residues (Leu, Ile) are not tolerated at p3 and p4. Met and Trp are not tolerated at p6. Based on these findings, the characteristics of peptides recognized by autoreactive T cells in B/WF1 mice are discussed.

Multigenic control of lupus-associated antiphospholipid syndrome in a model of (NZW x BXSB) F1 mice

In a subset of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients, antiphospholipid syndrome, characterized by occurrence of anti-cardiolipin (CL) antibodies, thrombocytopenia, thrombosis and recurrent intrauterine fetal death occurs. Male (NZW x BXSB)F1 mice, carrying the BXSB Yaa gene, serve as a model for SLE-associated antiphospholipid syndrome. Using microsatellite markers in the NZW x (NZW x BXSB)F1 backcross male progeny, we mapped BXSB alleles contributing to the generation of anti-CL antibodies, platelet-binding antibodies, thrombocytopenia and myocardial infarction. Generation of each disease character was controlled by two major independently segregating dominant alleles, i.e. those on chromosomes (Chr.) 4 and 17 for anti-CL antibodies, Chr. 8 and 17 for both anti-platelet antibodies and thrombocytopenia and, to our surprise, Chr. 7 and 14 for myocardial infarction, and that a combination of the two alleles appeared to produce full expression of each character, as a complementary gene action. The alleles on Chr. 17 linked to the above three characters were all mapped in close proximity to the H-2 complex. Therefore, no single factor such as anti-CL antibodies can explain the pathogenesis of SLE-associated antiphospholipid syndrome. Rather, a combination of susceptibility alleles such as described here, along with additional modifying loci, i.e. BXSB Yaa and some from NZW, characterizes unique SLE features in male (NZW x BXSB) F1 mice. There are potentially important candidate genes which may be linked to the syndrome.

A Subset of CD4+ T Cells Expressing Early Activation Antigen CD69 in Murine Lupus: Possible Abnormal Regulatory Role for Cytokine Imbalance

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), which spontaneously develops in (NZB (New Zealand Black) × NZW (New Zealand White)) F1 mice, is strictly dependent on CD4+ T cells. We found that in these mice with overt SLE, CD4+ T cells expressing CD69 molecules, an early activation Ag, are dramatically increased in peripheral lymphoid tissues and inflammatory infiltrates in the kidney and lung, but not in peripheral blood, while CD8+ and NK1.1+ T cells were virtually CD69−. Various adhesion molecules, including LFA-1, ICAM-1, CD43, CD44, P-selectin, and E-selectin, were up-regulated. Analysis of the TCR repertoire showed no skewed TCR Vβ usage. Studies on in vitro cytokine production of spleen cells on TCR cross-linking indicated that compared with findings in young mice, the aged mice showed severely impaired production of IL-2, IL-3, and IL-4, whereas the levels of IL-10 and IFN-γ remained relatively intact. FACS-sorted CD69−CD4+ T cells from aged mice produced substantial amounts of these cytokines, including IL-2, IL-3, and IL-4, whereas CD69+CD4+ T cells were poor producers. Intriguingly, when cocultured, CD69+CD4+ T cells significantly inhibited the production of IL-2 by CD69−CD4+ T cells. IL-2 production by spleen cells from young mice was also markedly inhibited in the presence of CD69+CD4+ T cells obtained from aged mice. We propose that CD69+CD4+ T cells that are continuously activated by self peptides bound to MHC class II molecules in (NZB × NZW)F1 mice may be involved in the pathogenesis of SLE through abnormal regulatory effects on cytokine balance.

Effect of genetic background on Ea(d) transgene-mediated protection from murine lupus

The expression of a transgenic encoding the I-E alpha-chain, Ea(d), is highly effective in the protection from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in BXSB and (MRL x BXSB)F1 male mice, in which a mutant gene, Yaa (Y-linked autoimmune acceleration), plays a critical role. To gain further insight into the protective role of the Ea(d) transgene, we compared the effect of the transgene in two additional lupus-prone (NZB x BXSB)F1 and (NZW x BXSB)F1 hybrid mice, in which both F1 female mice develop typical SLE in the absence of the Yaa gene and their F1 males bearing the Yaa gene develop a more accelerated form of SLE. Comparative analysis of the clinical development of SLE in these F1 hybrid mice showed that Ea(d) transgene expression was much more effective in the protection from SLE occurring in the F1 females than in their male counterparts. Our results indicate that the Ea(d) transgene is capable of preventing SLE by inhibiting autoimmune responses, independently of the Yaa gene-accelerating effect, and that its protective capacity is strongly influenced by the genetic susceptibility to SLE in individual strains of lupus-prone mice. In addition, this autoimmune inhibitory effect was shown to be selective for IgG, but not IgM, anti-DNA autoantibody production, and is more specific for anti-gp70 autoantibody than for anti-DNA autoantibody. These results favour the hypothesis that the transgene expression may lead to the modulation of self-peptide presentation, thereby preventing excessive T-cell-dependent activation of autoreactive B cells.

Genetic susceptibility to systemic lupus erythematosus

Considerable evidence suggests that the development of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has a strong genetic basis. Recent studies have emphasized that this disease, like other autoimmune diseases, is a complex genetic trait with contributions from major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes and multiple non-MHC genes. Etiologic genes in these disorders determine susceptibility, and no particular gene is necessary or sufficient for disease expression. Studies of murine models of lupus have provided important insight into the immunopathogenesis of IgG autoantibody production and lupus nephritis, and genetic analyses of these mice overcome certain obstacles encountered when studying patients. Genome-wide linkage studies of different crosses have mapped the position of at least 12 non-MHC disease-susceptibility loci in the New Zealand hybrid model of lupus. Although the identity of the actual genes is currently unknown, recent studies have begun to characterize how these genetic contributions may function in the autoimmune process, especially in terms of their role in autoantibody production. Studies of MHC gene contributions in New Zealand mice have shown that heterozygosity for particular haplotypes greatly increases pathogenic autoantibody production and the incidence of severe nephritis. The mechanism for this effect appears to be genetically complex. Studies in human SLE have mostly focused on the association of disease with alleles of immunologically relevant genes, especially in the MHC. Associations with various complement component deficiencies and an allele of a particular Fc gamma receptor gene (FCGR2A) also have been described. In a diversion from previous association studies, a recent directed linkage analysis of sibpairs with SLE was based on mapping studies in murine lupus and may be an important step toward identifying a new disease-susceptibility gene in patients. Since the genes that predispose to autoimmunity are probably related to key events in pathogenesis, their identification in patients and murine models will almost certainly provide important insight into the breakdown of immunological self-tolerance and the cause of autoimmune disease.