Identification of editing positions in the ndhB transcript from maize chloroplasts reveals sequence similarities between editing sites of chloroplasts and plant mitochondria

Analysis of the Plastid Genome Sequence During Maize Seedling Development

Shoot development in maize progresses from small, non-pigmented meristematic cells to expanded cells in the green leaf. During this transition, large plastid DNA (ptDNA) molecules in proplastids become fragmented in the photosynthetically-active chloroplasts. The genome sequences were determined for ptDNA obtained from Zea mays B73 plastids isolated from four tissues: base of the stalk (the meristem region); fully-developed first green leaf; first three leaves from light-grown seedlings; and first three leaves from dark-grown (etiolated) seedlings. These genome sequences were then compared to the Z. mays B73 plastid reference genome sequence that was previously obtained from green leaves. The assembled plastid genome was identical among these four tissues to the reference genome. Furthermore, there was no difference among these tissues in the sequence at and around the previously documented 27 RNA editing sites. There were, however, more sequence variants (insertions/deletions and single-nucleotide polymorphisms) for leaves grown in the dark than in the light. These variants were tightly clustered into two areas within the inverted repeat regions of the plastid genome. We propose a model for how these variant clusters could be generated by replication-transcription conflict.

Organelle Genomes and Transcriptomes of Nymphaea Reveal the Interplay between Intron Splicing and RNA Editing

Posttranscriptional modifications, including intron splicing and RNA editing, are common processes during regulation of gene expression in plant organelle genomes. However, the intermediate products of intron-splicing, and the interplay between intron-splicing and RNA-editing were not well studied. Most organelle transcriptome analyses were based on the Illumina short reads which were unable to capture the full spectrum of transcript intermediates within an organelle. To fully investigate the intermediates during intron splicing and the underlying relationships with RNA editing, we used PacBio DNA-seq and Iso-seq, together with Illumina short reads genome and transcriptome sequencing data to assemble the chloroplast and mitochondrial genomes of Nymphaea 'Joey Tomocik' and analyze their posttranscriptional features. With the direct evidence from Iso-seq, multiple intermediates partially or fully intron-spliced were observed, and we also found that both cis- and trans-splicing introns were spliced randomly. Moreover, by using rRNA-depleted and non-Oligo(dT)-enrichment strand-specific RNA-seq data and combining direct SNP-calling and transcript-mapping methods, we identified 98 and 865 RNA-editing sites in the plastome and mitogenome of N. 'Joey Tomocik', respectively. The target codon preference, the tendency of increasing protein hydrophobicity, and the bias distribution of editing sites are similar in both organelles, suggesting their common evolutionary origin and shared editing machinery. The distribution of RNA editing sites also implies that the RNA editing sites in the intron and exon regions may splice synchronously, except those exonic sites adjacent to intron which could only be edited after being intron-spliced. Our study provides solid evidence for the multiple intermediates co-existing during intron-splicing and their interplay with RNA editing in organelle genomes of a basal angiosperm.

Light/heat effects on RNA editing in chloroplast NADH-plastoquinone oxidoreductase subunit 2 (ndhB) gene of Calotropis (Calotropis procera)

Background

RNA editing is common in terrestrial plants, especially in mitochondria and chloroplast. In the photosynthesis process, NAD dehydrogenase plays a very important role. Subunit 2 of NADH-dehydrogenase is one of the major subunits in NAD dehydrogenase complex. Using desert plant Calotropis (Calotropis procera), this study focuses on the RNA editing activity of ndhB based on light time.

Results

NdhB (NADH-dehydrogenase subunit 2) gene accession no. MK144329 was isolated from Calotropis procera genomic data (PRJNA292713). Additionally, using RNA-seq data, the cDNA of the ndhB gene of C. procera was isolated at three daylight periods, i.e., dawn (accession no. MK165161), at midday (accession no. MK165160), and pre-dusk (accession no. MK165159). Seven RNA editing sites have been found in several different positions (nucleotide no. C467, C586, C611, C737, C746, C830, and C1481) within the ndhB coding region. The rate of these alterations was deferentially edited across the three daylight periods. RNA editing rate of ndhB gene was highest at dawn, (87.5, 79.6, 78.5, 76, 68.6, 39.3, and 96.9%, respectively), less in midday (74.8, 54.1, 62.6, 47.4, 45.5, 47.4, and 93.4%, respectively), and less at pre-dusk (67, 52.6, 56.9, 40.1, 40.7, 33.2, and 90%, respectively), also all these sites were validated by qRT-PCR.

Conclusion

The differential editing of chloroplast ndhB gene across light periods may be led to a somehow relations between the RNA editing and control of photosynthesis.

Nuclear DYW-type PPR gene families diversify with increasing RNA editing frequencies in liverwort and moss mitochondria

RNA editing in mitochondria and chloroplasts of land plants alters transcript sequences by site-specific conversions of cytidines into uridines. RNA editing frequencies vary extremely between land plant clades, ranging from zero in some liverworts to more than 2,000 sites in lycophytes. Unique pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins with variable domain extension (E/E+/DYW) have recently been identified as specific editing site recognition factors in model plants. The distinctive functions of these PPR protein domain additions have remained unclear, although deaminase function has been proposed for the DYW domain. To shed light on diversity of RNA editing and DYW proteins at the origin of land plant evolution, we investigated editing patterns of the mitochondrial nad5, nad4, and nad2 genes in a wide sampling of more than 100 liverworts and mosses using the recently developed PREPACT program (www.prepact.de) and exemplarily confirmed predicted RNA editing sites in selected taxa. Extreme variability in RNA editing frequency is seen both in liverworts and mosses. Only few editings exist in the liverwort Lejeunea cavifolia or the moss Pogonatum urnigerum whereas up to 20% of cytidines are edited in the liverwort Haplomitrium mnioides or the moss Takakia lepidozioides. Interestingly, the latter are taxa that branch very early within their respective clades. Amplicons targeting the E/E+/DYW domains and subsequent random clone sequencing show DYW domains among bryophytes to be highly conserved in comparison with their angiosperm counterparts and to correlate well with RNA editing frequencies regarding their diversities. We propose that DYW proteins are the key players of RNA editing at the origin of land plants.

Molecular evolution of pentatricopeptide repeat genes reveals truncation in species lacking an editing target and structural domains under distinct selective pressures

BACKGROUND

Pentatricopeptide repeat (PPR) proteins are required for numerous RNA processing events in plant organelles including C-to-U editing, splicing, stabilization, and cleavage. Fifteen PPR proteins are known to be required for RNA editing at 21 sites in Arabidopsis chloroplasts, and belong to the PLS class of PPR proteins. In this study, we investigate the co-evolution of four PPR genes (CRR4, CRR21, CLB19, and OTP82) and their six editing targets in Brassicaceae species. PPR genes are composed of approximately 10 to 20 tandem repeats and each repeat has two α-helical regions, helix A and helix B, that are separated by short coil regions. Each repeat and structural feature was examined to determine the selective pressures on these regions.

RESULTS

All of the PPR genes examined are under strong negative selection. Multiple independent losses of editing site targets are observed for both CRR21 and OTP82. In several species lacking the known editing target for CRR21, PPR genes are truncated near the 17th PPR repeat. The coding sequences of the truncated CRR21 genes are maintained under strong negative selection; however, the 3' UTR sequences beyond the truncation site have substantially diverged. Phylogenetic analyses of four PPR genes show that sequences corresponding to helix A are high compared to helix B sequences. Differential evolutionary selection of helix A versus helix B is observed in both plant and mammalian PPR genes.

CONCLUSION

PPR genes and their cognate editing sites are mutually constrained in evolution. Editing sites are frequently lost by replacement of an edited C with a genomic T. After the loss of an editing site, the PPR genes are observed with three outcomes: first, few changes are detected in some cases; second, the PPR gene is present as a pseudogene; and third, the PPR gene is present but truncated in the C-terminal region. The retention of truncated forms of CRR21 that are maintained under strong negative selection even in the absence of an editing site target suggests that unrecognized function(s) might exist for this PPR protein. PPR gene sequences that encode helix A are under strong selection, and could be involved in RNA substrate recognition.

A long antisense RNA in plant chloroplasts

Based on computational prediction of RNA secondary structures, a long antisense RNA (asRNA) was found in chloroplasts of Arabidopsis, Nicotiana tabacum and poplar, which occurs in two to three major transcripts. Mapping of primary 5' ends, northern hybridizations and quantitative real-time reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) experiments demonstrated that these transcripts originate from a promoter that is typical for the plastid-encoded RNA polymerase and are over their full length in antisense orientation to the gene ndhB and therefore were designated asRNA_ndhB. The asRNA_ndhB transcripts predominantly accumulate in young leaves and at physiological growth temperatures. Two nucleotide positions in the mRNA that are subject to C-to-U RNA editing and which were previously found to be sensitive to elevated temperatures are covered by asRNA_ndhB. Nevertheless, the correlation between the accumulation of asRNA_ndhB and RNA editing appeared weak in a temperature shift experiment. With asRNA_ndhB, we describe the first asRNA of plant chloroplasts that covers RNA editing sites, as well as a group II intron splice acceptor site, and that is under developmental control, raising the possibility that long asRNAs could be involved in RNA maturation or the control of RNA stability.

The ins and outs of editing and splicing of plastid RNAs: lessons from parasitic plants

In chloroplasts of higher plants, editing and splicing of transcripts is a prerequisite for the proper expression of the plastid genetic information and thereby for photosynthesis. Holoparasitic plants differ from photosynthetic plants in that they have abandoned a photoautotrophic life style, which has led to a reduction or loss of photosynthetic activity. The analysis of several parasitic plant plastid genomes revealed that coding capacities were reduced to different extent, encompassing genes that regulate plastid gene expression as well as photosynthesis genes. The reorganization of the plastid genome is also reflected in overall increases in point mutation rates that parallel the vanishing of RNA editing sites. Unprecedented in land plants is the parallel loss of the plastid gene coding for an intron maturase and all but one group IIa introns in two parasitic species. These observations highlight the plastome-wide effects that are associated with a relaxed evolutionary pressure in plants living a heterotrophic life style.

Plastid transcriptomics and translatomics of tomato fruit development and chloroplast-to-chromoplast differentiation: chromoplast gene expression largely serves the production of a single protein

Plastid genes are expressed at high levels in photosynthetically active chloroplasts but are generally believed to be drastically downregulated in nongreen plastids. The genome-wide changes in the expression patterns of plastid genes during the development of nongreen plastid types as well as the contributions of transcriptional versus translational regulation are largely unknown. We report here a systematic transcriptomics and translatomics analysis of the tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) plastid genome during fruit development and chloroplast-to-chromoplast conversion. At the level of RNA accumulation, most but not all plastid genes are strongly downregulated in fruits compared with leaves. By contrast, chloroplast-to-chromoplast differentiation during fruit ripening is surprisingly not accompanied by large changes in plastid RNA accumulation. However, most plastid genes are translationally downregulated during chromoplast development. Both transcriptional and translational downregulation are more pronounced for photosynthesis-related genes than for genes involved in gene expression, indicating that some low-level plastid gene expression must be sustained in chromoplasts. High-level expression during chromoplast development identifies accD, the only plastid-encoded gene involved in fatty acid biosynthesis, as the target gene for which gene expression activity in chromoplasts is maintained. In addition, we have determined the developmental patterns of plastid RNA polymerase activities, intron splicing, and RNA editing and report specific developmental changes in the splicing and editing patterns of plastid transcripts.

Faithful editing of a tomato-specific mRNA editing site in transgenic tobacco chloroplasts

RNA editing sites and their site-specific trans-acting recognition factors are thought to have coevolved. Hence, evolutionary loss of an editing site by a genomic mutation is normally followed by the loss of the specific recognition factor for this site, due to the absence of selective pressure for its maintenance. Here, we have tested this scenario for the only tomato-specific plastid RNA editing site. A single C-to-U editing site in the tomato rps12 gene is absent from the tobacco and nightshade plastid genomes, where the presence of a genomic T nucleotide obviates the need for editing of the rps12 mRNA. We have introduced the tomato editing site into the tobacco rps12 gene by plastid transformation and find that, surprisingly, this heterologous site is efficiently edited in the transplastomic plants. This suggests that the trans-acting recognition factor for the rps12 editing site has been maintained, presumably because it serves another function in tobacco plastids. Bioinformatics analyses identified an editing site in the rpoB gene of tobacco and tomato whose sequence context exhibits striking similarity to that of the tomato rps12 editing site. This may suggest that requirement for rpoB editing resulted in maintenance of the rps12 editing activity or, alternatively, the pre-existing rpoB editing activity facilitated the evolution of a novel editing site in rps12.

Plastid mRNAs are neither spliced nor edited in maize and cauliflower mitochondrial in organello systems

The process of RNA editing in chloroplasts and higher plant mitochondria displays some similarities, raising the question of common or similar components in editing apparatus of these two organelles. To investigate the ability of plant mitochondria to edit plastid transcripts, we employed a previously established mitochondrial maize and cauliflower in organello system. Two plastid genes, Zea mays ndhB and ycf3 containing group II introns and several editing sites, were introduced into mitochondria. The genes were transcribed in organello. However, these transcripts of the plastid genes are neither spliced nor edited in plant mitochondria. A comparison of maize ndhB editing sites and maize mitochondrial editing sites reveals considerable sequence similarities between three ndhB editing sites and several mitochondrial sites. Nevertheless, these ndhB editing sites were not recognized in the mitochondria. Thus, we present for the first time direct evidence that the factors present in the plant mitochondria are not sufficient to allow editing and splicing of plastid transcripts.

Sequence of the tomato chloroplast DNA and evolutionary comparison of solanaceous plastid genomes

Tomato, Solanum lycopersicum (formerly Lycopersicon esculentum), has long been one of the classical model species of plant genetics. More recently, solanaceous species have become a model of evolutionary genomics, with several EST projects and a tomato genome project having been initiated. As a first contribution toward deciphering the genetic information of tomato, we present here the complete sequence of the tomato chloroplast genome (plastome). The size of this circular genome is 155,461 base pairs (bp), with an average AT content of 62.14%. It contains 114 genes and conserved open reading frames (ycfs). Comparison with the previously sequenced plastid DNAs of Nicotiana tabacum and Atropa belladonna reveals patterns of plastid genome evolution in the Solanaceae family and identifies varying degrees of conservation of individual plastid genes. In addition, we discovered several new sites of RNA editing by cytidine-to-uridine conversion. A detailed comparison of editing patterns in the three solanaceous species highlights the dynamics of RNA editing site evolution in chloroplasts. To assess the level of intraspecific plastome variation in tomato, the plastome of a second tomato cultivar was sequenced. Comparison of the two genotypes (IPA-6, bred in South America, and Ailsa Craig, bred in Europe) revealed no nucleotide differences, suggesting that the plastomes of modern tomato cultivars display very little, if any, sequence variation.

Sequence of the Tomato Chloroplast DNA and Evolutionary Comparison of Solanaceous Plastid Genomes

Tomato, Solanum lycopersicum (formerly Lycopersicon esculentum), has long been one of the classical model species of plant genetics. More recently, solanaceous species have become a model of evolutionary genomics, with several EST projects and a tomato genome project having been initiated. As a first contribution toward deciphering the genetic information of tomato, we present here the complete sequence of the tomato chloroplast genome (plastome). The size of this circular genome is 155,461 base pairs (bp), with an average AT content of 62.14%. It contains 114 genes and conserved open reading frames (ycfs). Comparison with the previously sequenced plastid DNAs of Nicotiana tabacum and Atropa belladonna reveals patterns of plastid genome evolution in the Solanaceae family and identifies varying degrees of conservation of individual plastid genes. In addition, we discovered several new sites of RNA editing by cytidine-to-uridine conversion. A detailed comparison of editing patterns in the three solanaceous species highlights the dynamics of RNA editing site evolution in chloroplasts. To assess the level of intraspecific plastome variation in tomato, the plastome of a second tomato cultivar was sequenced. Comparison of the two genotypes (IPA-6, bred in South America, and Ailsa Craig, bred in Europe) revealed no nucleotide differences, suggesting that the plastomes of modern tomato cultivars display very little, if any, sequence variation.

Studies of the Ndh complex and photosystem II from mesophyll and bundle sheath chloroplasts of the C4-type plant Zea mays

In C(4) plants, granal mesophyll (MS) chloroplasts contain higher photosystem (PS) II and lower PS I activity than agranal bundle sheath (BS) chloroplasts. The maize NAD(P)H dehydrogenase or NAD(P)H-plastoquinone oxidoreductase (also named Ndh complex) from MS and BS chloroplasts, contains at least 11 subunits (NdhA-K) and is homologous to NADH dehydrogenase or Complex I from mitochondria and bacteria. The amount of Ndh complex is higher in BS compared with MS chloroplasts. However, there is little information about the interdependence of the PS II and Ndh complex in chlororespiration and linear and cyclic electron transport in C(4) plants. To characterize the expression of the PS II and Ndh complex in maize plastids, we used cytochrome b559 (cyt b559) antibodies and Ndh immunoglobulins (IgG) to analyze the Ndh complex and PS II in both MS and BS chloroplasts from maize leaves by Western blotting and immunolabeling. In Western blot experiments, it was found that the amount of cyt b559 (a marker for PS II) is 7-8 times higher in MS than BS chloroplasts. Conversely, the NdhH, -J, -K and -E content is 2.5-3 times higher in BS than MS chloroplasts. Similar results were obtained in immunolabeling experiments using Ndh IgGs and cyt b559 antibodies in MS and BS chloroplasts. These data suggest that in BS chloroplasts, ATP could be produced mainly by cyclic electron transport around PS I and Ndh complexes. Conversely, the linear electron transport in BS chloroplasts via PS II could have a lower production of ATP. These results also suggest that the contribution of the Ndh complex in the production of ATP in MS chloroplasts is minimal and that instead, this complex could have a chlororespiratory role.

Editing of plastid RNA in Arabidopsis thaliana ecotypes

Post-transcriptional maturation of plastid-encoded mRNAs from land plants includes editing by making cytidine to uridine alterations at highly specific positions; this usually restores codon identities for conserved amino acids that are important for the proper function of the affected proteins. In contrast to the rather constant number of editing sites their location varies greatly, even between closely related taxa. Here, we experimentally determined the specific pattern of editing sites (the editotype) of the plastid genome of Arabidopsis thaliana ecotype Columbia (Col-0). Based on phylogenetic analyses of plastid open reading frames, we identified 28 editing sites. Two editing events in the genes matK and ndhB seem to have evolved late during the evolution of flowering plants. Strikingly, they are embedded in almost identical sequence elements and seem to be phylogenetically co-processed. This suggests that the two sites are recognized by the same trans-factor, which could help to explain the hitherto enigmatic gain of editing sites in evolution. In order to trace variations in editotype at the subspecies level we examined two other A. thaliana accessions, Cape Verde Islands (Cvi-0) and Wassilewskija (Ws-2), for the Col-0 editing sites. Both Cvi-0 and Ws-2 possess and process the whole set of editing sites as determined in Col-0, but the consequences of RNA editing differ at one position between the ecotypes.

Rapid evolution of RNA editing sites in a small non-essential plastid gene

Chloroplast RNA editing proceeds by C-to-U transitions at highly specific sites. Here, we provide a phylogenetic analysis of RNA editing in a small plastid gene, petL, encoding subunit VI of the cytochrome b6f complex. Analyzing representatives from most major groups of seed plants, we find an unexpectedly high frequency and dynamics of RNA editing. High-frequency editing has previously been observed in plastid ndh genes, which are remarkable in that their mutational inactivation does not produce an obvious mutant phenotype. In order to test the idea that reduced functional constraints allow for more flexible evolution of RNA editing sites, we have created petL knockout plants by tobacco chloroplast transformation. We find that, in the higher plant tobacco, targeted inactivation of petL does not impair plant growth under a variety of conditions markedly contrasting the important role of petL in photosynthesis in the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Together with a low number of editing sites in plastid genes that are essential to gene expression and photosynthetic activity, these data suggest that RNA editing sites may evolve more readily in those genes whose transitory loss of function can be tolerated. Accumulated evidence for this 'relative neutrality hypothesis for the evolution of plastid editing sites' is discussed.

Heterologous, splicing-dependent RNA editing in chloroplasts: allotetraploidy provides trans-factors

RNA editing is unique among post-transcriptional processes in plastids, as it exhibits extraordinary phylogenetic dynamics leading to species-specific editing site patterns. The evolutionary loss of a site is considered to entail the loss of the corresponding nuclear-encoded site-specific factor, which prevents the editing of foreign, i.e. heterologous, sites. We investigated the editing of short 'spliced' and 'unspliced' ndhA gene fragments from spinach in Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) in vivo using biolistic transformation. Surprisingly, it turned out that the spinach site is edited in the heterologous nuclear background. Furthermore, only exon-exon fusions were edited, whereas intron-containing messages remained unprocessed. A homologue of the spinach site was found to be present and edited in Nicotiana tomentosiformis, representing the paternal parent, but absent from Nicotiana sylvestris, representing the maternal parent of tobacco. Our data show that: (i) the cis-determinants for ndhA editing are split by an intron; (ii) the editing capacity cannot be deduced from editing sites; and (iii) allopolyploidization can increase the editing capacity, which implies that it can influence speciation processes in evolution.

Sense from nonsense: how the genetic information of chloroplasts is altered by RNA editing

Plastid transcripts can be subject to an RNA processing mechanism changing the identity of individual nucleotides and thus altering the information content of the mRNA. This processing step was termed RNA editing and adds a novel mechanism to the multitude of RNA maturation events required before mRNAs can serve as faithful templates in plastid protein biosynthesis. RNA editing in chloroplasts proceeds by the conversion of individual cytidine residues to uridine and, in some bryophytes, also by the reverse event, uridine-to-cytidine transitions. The discovery of RNA editing in chloroplasts has provided researchers with a wealth of molecular and evolutionary puzzles, many of which are not yet solved. However, recent work employing chloroplast transformation technologies has shed some light on the molecular mechanisms by which RNA editing sites are recognized with extraordinarily high precision. Also, extensive phylogenetic studies have provided intriguing insights in the evolutionary dynamics with which editing sites may come and go. This review summarizes the state-of-the-art in the field of chloroplast RNA editing, discusses mechanistic and evolutionary aspects of editing and points out some of the important open questions surrounding this enigmatic RNA processing step.

Transfer of plastid RNA-editing activity to novel sites suggests a critical role for spacing in editing-site recognition

RNA editing in higher plant plastids alters mRNA sequences by C-to-U conversions at highly specific sites through an unknown mechanism. To elucidate how the cytidine residues to be edited are specifically recognized and distinguished from other cytidines in close proximity, we have changed in vivo the distances of two plastid RNA-editing sites from their essential upstream cis-acting sequence element. Analysis of RNA editing in transgenic chloroplasts revealed that reduction of this distance by 1 nt entirely abolishes RNA editing. Surprisingly, deletions or combinations of deletional and point mutations that shift a heterologous cytidine residue in the same distance from the upstream cis-element as the editing site in the wild type result in transfer of the RNA-editing activity to the heterologous cytidine whereas the wild-type site remains unedited. Our results suggest that the molecular identity of at least some editing sites in the chloroplast genome is defined by their distance from an essential upstream sequence element.

Analysis of RNA editing in plastids

Chloroplast mRNAs can be subject to posttranscriptional pyrimidine-to-pyrimidine conversions at highly specific sites. This RNA modification mechanism shows a high degree of similarity to plant mitochondrial editing but differs markedly from, and is most likely evolutionarily unrelated to, all other RNA editing systems. The study of RNA editing processes in chloroplasts has been largely hampered by the lack of in vitro editing systems; however, considerable insights into the recognition mechanisms of individual editing sites have come from in vivo approaches. Chloroplast transformation proved to be a particularly useful tool to study plastid RNA editing. In this article, specific methods for the analysis of chloroplast RNA editing are discussed. Detailed experimental procedures are provided for (i) the purification of chloroplasts and (ii) the stable genetic transformation of higher plant plastids.

Site-selective inhibition of plastid RNA editing by heat shock and antibiotics: a role for plastid translation in RNA editing

RNA editing in higher plant plastids changes single cytidine residues to uridine through an unknown mechanism. In order to investigate the relation of editing to physiological processes and to other steps in plastid gene expression, we have tested the sensitivity of chloroplast RNA editing to heat shock and antibiotics. We show that heat shock conditions as well as treatment of plants with prokaryotic translational inhibitors can inhibit plastid RNA editing. Surprisingly, this inhibitory effect is confined to a limited number of plastid editing sites suggesting that some site-specific factor(s) but none of the general components of the plastid RNA editing machinery are compromised. Contrary to previous expectations, our results provide evidence for a role of plastid translation in RNA editing.

Involvement of 5' flanking sequence for specifying RNA editing sites in plant mitochondria

Unsuccessful insertion of foreign DNA into plant mitochondrial genomes has hindered scientific evaluation of cis-elements needed for RNA editing. Both a normal atp6 gene and a chimeric atp6 sequence are present in rice mitochondria. The chimeric atp6 contains one-half of the normal atp6 sequence in its 5' portion and an unknown sequence in its downstream portion. The C-nucleotide at position 511, located just upstream of the unknown sequence recombined in the chimeric atp6 sequence, is edited, as are other possible editing sites upstream from position 511. We report here that the 5' sequence adjacent to the editing site of atp6 contains cis-information required for RNA editing and that the 3' sequence flanking the editing site provides little contribution to editing-site recognition.

Splicing and intron-internal RNA editing of trnK-matK transcripts in barley plastids: support for MatK as an essential splice factor

Group II introns frequently require assistance by specific factors, maturases, for folding and effective splicing in vivo. The only putative maturase of higher plant chloroplasts is encoded by matK, located in the intron of trnK. We show that in barley matK transcripts are modified at a first codon base by C-to-U RNA editing. The resulting H --> Y substitution restores a sequence motif that is present in maturases of yeast and plant mitochondria and of Lactococcus ltrA and that is positioned within the X domain. Processing of trnK-matK transcripts was further investigated in plastids lacking functional ribosomes due to a mutation. Absence of the intron-encoded matK gene product in these plastids is correlated with the accumulation of precursor transcripts for tRNALys(UUU)-matK, processed to different degrees, and by the lack of mature and spliced tRNA molecules. These results suggest an essential role of MatK for splicing of its own transcript in vivo. Processing of the 5' end of trnK exon 1 was found to proceed efficiently also in the mutant plastids although the two tRNA exons were separated by the 2481 nt intron. Consequently, presence of the intron does not interfere with the formation of mature 5' termini.

Occurrence of plastid RNA editing in all major lineages of land plants

RNA editing changes posttranscriptionally single nucleotides in chloroplast-encoded transcripts. Although much work has been done on mechanistic and functional aspects of plastid editing, little is known about evolutionary aspects of this RNA processing step. To gain a better understanding of the evolution of RNA editing in plastids, we have investigated the editing patterns in ndhB and rbcL transcripts from various species comprising all major groups of land plants. Our results indicate that RNA editing occurs in plastids of bryophytes, fern allies, true ferns, gymnosperms, and angiosperms. Both editing frequencies and editing patterns show a remarkable degree of interspecies variation. Furthermore, we have found that neither plastid editing frequencies nor the editing pattern of a specific transcript correlate with the phylogenetic tree of the plant kingdom. The poor evolutionary conservation of editing sites among closely related species as well as the occurrence of single species-specific editing sites suggest that the differences in the editing patterns and editing frequencies are probably due both to independent loss and to gain of editing sites. In addition, our results indicate that RNA editing is a relatively ancient process that probably predates the evolution of land plants. This supposition is in good agreement with the phylogenetic data obtained for plant mitochondrial RNA editing, thus providing additional evidence for common evolutionary roots of the two plant organellar editing systems.

Mitochondrial tRNAs in the lower fungus Spizellomyces punctatus: tRNA editing and UAG 'stop' codons recognized as leucine

The mitochondrial DNA of the chytridiomycete fungus Spizellomyces punctatusen codes only eight tRNAs, although a minimal set of 24-25 tRNAs is normally found in fungi. One of these tRNAs has a CAU anticodon and is structurally related to leucine tRNAs, which would permit the translation of the UAG 'stop' codons that occur in most of its protein genes. The predicted structures of all S. punctatus tRNAs have the common feature of containing one to three mis-pairings in the first three positions of their acceptor stems. Such mis-pairing is expected to impair proper folding and processing of tRNAs from their precursors. Five of these eight RNAs were shown to be edited at the RNA level, in the 5'portion of the molecules. These changes include both pyrimidine to purine and A to G substitutions that restore normal pairing in the acceptor stem. Editing was not found at other positions of the tRNAs, or in the mitochondrial mRNAs of S. punctatus. While tRNA editing has not been observed in other fungi, the editing pattern inS.punctatus is virtually identical to that described in the amoeboid protozoan Acanthamoeba castellanii. If this type of mitochondrial tRNA editing has originated from their common ancestor, one has to assume that it was independently lost in plants, animals and in most fungi. Alternatively, editing might have evolved independently, or the genes coding for the components of the editing machinery were laterally transferred.

Mutations of cytochrome b6 in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii disclose the functional significance for a proline to leucine conversion by petB editing in maize and tobacco

We have introduced a proline codon in place of a leucine codon at position 204 of the petB gene of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. This gene modification mimics the presence of proline codons at the same position in the petB genes of maize and tobacco, which are subsequently edited to leucine codons at the RNA level. Following transformation, we observed no editing at this position in C. reinhardtii, independent of the type of proline codon we have used: the CCA codon, edited in maize, or a CCT codon. Strains carrying the introduced mutation were non phototrophic and displayed a block in photosynthetic electron transfer, consistent with a lack of cytochrome b6f activity. Thus the presence of a proline residue at position 204 in cytochrome b6 is detrimental to photosynthesis. We show that the mutant phenotype arose from a defective assembly of cytochrome b6f complexes and not from altered electron transfer properties in the assembled protein complex. Biochemical comparison of the proline-containing transformants with a cytochrome b6 mutant deficient in heme-attachment indicates that their primary defect is at the level of assembly of apocytochrome b6 with the bh heme, thereby preventing assembly of the whole cytochrome b6f complex.

Sequences directing C to U editing of the plastid psbL mRNA are located within a 22 nucleotide segment spanning the editing site

In plastids, editing of an ACG codon to an AUG codon creates the translation initiation codon for the psbL and ndhD transcripts in tobacco. To identify the RNA segment required for psbL editing, chimeric kanamycin resistance genes were constructed containing psbL deletion derivatives, and tested in vivo for editing in transgenic plants. We report here that a 22 nucleotide segment is sufficient to direct efficient psbL editing, including 16 nucleotides upstream and five nucleotides downstream of the editing site. Mutation of the A nucleotide to a C upstream of the editing site completely abolished editing, while mutation of the downstream G to a C only reduced the editing efficiency. Out of the 22 nucleotide editing target sequence, the 16 upstream nucleotides were found to compete with the endogenous psbL transcript for a depletable trans-factor. To test whether editing of initiation codons involves a common trans-factor, a chimeric gene containing the ndhD editing site was expressed in tobacco plastids. As for psbL, editing of the ndhD site requires a depletable trans-factor. However, the ndhD trans-factor is distinct from that required for psbL editing. Distinct cissequences and trans-factor requirements for the psbL and ndhD editing sites indicate an individual recognition mechanism for the editing of plastid initiation codons.

In vivo dissection of cis-acting determinants for plastid RNA editing

Substitutional RNA editing changes single C nucleotides in higher plant chloroplast transcripts into U residues. To determine the cis-acting sequence elements involved in plastid RNA editing, we constructed a series of chloroplast transformation vectors harboring selected editing sites of the tobacco ndhB transcript in a chimeric context. The constructs were inserted into the tobacco plastid genome by biolistic transformation leading to the production of stable chimeric RNAs. Analysis of RNA editing revealed unexpected differences in the size of the essential cis elements or in their distance from the editing site. Flanking sequences of identical size direct virtually complete editing for one pair of editing sites, partial editing for a second and no editing at all for a third pair of sites. Serial 5' and 3' deletions allowed us to define the cis-acting elements more precisely and to identify a sequence element essential for editing site recognition. In addition, a single nucleotide substitution immediately upstream of an editing position was introduced. This mutation was found drastically and selectively to reduce the editing efficiency of the downstream editing site, demonstrating that position -1 is important for either site recognition or catalysis. Our results indicate that the editing of adjacent sites is likely to be mechanistically coupled. In no case did the presence in the plastome of the additional editing sites have any effect on the editing efficiency of the endogenous ndhB sites, indicating that the availability of site-specific trans-acting factors is not rate limiting.

Creation of a novel protein-coding region at the RNA level in black pine chloroplasts: the pattern of RNA editing in the gymnosperm chloroplast is different from that in angiosperms

The phenomenon of RNA editing has been found to occur in chloroplasts of several angiosperm plants. Comparative analysis of the entire nucleotide sequence of a gymnosperm [Pinus thunbergii (black pine)] chloroplast genome allowed us to predict several potential editing sites in its transcripts. Forty-nine such sites from 14 genes/ORFs were analyzed by sequencing both cDNAs from the transcripts and the corresponding chloroplast DNA regions, and 26 RNA editing sites were identified in the transcripts from 12 genes/ORFs, indicating that chloroplast RNA editing is not restricted to angiosperms but occurs in the gymnosperm, too. All the RNA editing events are C-to-U conversions; however, many new codon substitutions and creation of stop codons that have not so far been reported in angiosperm chloroplasts were observed. The most striking is that two editing events result in the creation of an initiation and a stop codon within a single transcript, leading to the formation of a new reading frame of 33 codons. The predicted product is highly homologous to that deduced from the ycf7 gene (ORF31), which is conserved in the chloroplast genomes of many other plant species.

A promiscuous chloroplast DNA fragment is transcribed in plant mitochondria but the encoded RNA is not edited

The RNA editing processes in chloroplasts and mitochondira of higher plants show several similarities which are suggestive of common components and/or biochemical steps between the two plant organelles. The existence of various promiscuous DNA fragments of chloroplast origin in plant mitochondrial genomes allowed us to test the possibility that chloroplast sequences are also edited in mitochondria. An rpoB fragment transferred from chloroplasts to mitochondria in rice was chosen as it contains several editing sites, two of which match sequence motifs surrounding even non-homologous editing sites in both chloroplast and mitochondrial transcripts. Rice chloroplast and mitochondrial rpoB DNA and cDNA sequences were selectively amplified and the editing status of the cDNA sequences was determined. Three of the four potential rpoB editing sites previously detected in maize were found to be edited in the rice chloroplast rpoB transcript, whereas the fourth was found to remain unedited. In mitochondria, however, all four editing sites remain unmodified at the cDNA level. This indicates that the editing processes of higher plant mitochondria and chloroplasts are not identical and that organelle-specific factors are required for eliciting the respective editing events.

Extensive RNA editing of U to C in addition to C to U substitution in the rbcL transcripts of hornwort chloroplasts and the origin of RNA editing in green plants

We cloned and sequenced a portion of chloroplast DNA from the hornwort Anthoceros formosae. A nucleotide sequence of 7556 bp contained structures similar to those of ndhK, ndhC, trnV, trnM, atpE, atpB, rbcL, trnR and accD. The arrangement of these was the same as that of other chloroplast DNA. However, two nonsense codons were located within the putative coding region of rbcL, although they were used as putative termination codons of the genes. RNA was extensively edited in the transcripts of rbcL when cDNA sequences were analyzed. The unusual nonsense codons of TGA and TAA became CGA and CAA respectively. These are examples of U to C type RNA editing, which was never been found before in chloroplast mRNA. In general, 13 Cs of genomic DNA were found as Ts in the cDNA sequence and seven Ts were found as Cs. This is the first finding of RNA editing on the transcripts of rbcL and also in bryophytes. This event had been thought to arise in land plants after the split of bryophytes. The origin of RNA editing is discussed in relation to the landing of green plants.

Occurrence of silent RNA editing in chloroplasts: its species specificity and the influence of environmental and developmental conditions

We have identified three new C-to-U RNA editing sites, one in atpF and two in atpA transcripts from tobacco chloroplasts. Two of them lead to amino acid substitutions to restore the conserved amino acid found in the corresponding genes of other plants. However, one editing site in the atpA transcript was found to take place partially at the third base of a serine codon (CUC_ to CUU_), thus not leading to an amino acid substitution. This is the first report of silent editing in chloroplasts. The extent of silent editing depends on plastid stage and light conditions, while editing as another site (found 4 nt upstream from the silent editing site) takes place constitutively even in non-photosynthetic cultured cells and bleached white seedlings grown in the presence of spectinomycin and streptomycin. In pea and spinach, despite a conservation in sequence, no editing at the site corresponding to the silent site in tobacco was found. This observation suggests that the silent editing detected in this study is species-specific.

Transcription, splicing and editing of plastid RNAs in the nonphotosynthetic plant Epifagus virginiana

Expression of the vestigial plastid genome of the nonphotosynthetic, parasitic flowering plant Epifagus virginiana was examined by northern analysis and by characterization of cDNAs. Probes for each of 12 plastid genes tested hybridized to all lanes of northern blots containing total RNA prepared from stems and fruits of Epifagus and from leaves of tobacco. Certain transcript patterns in Epifagus plastids are highly complex and similar to those of tobacco operons. In contrast, genes such as rps2, which have become orphaned in Epifagus as a result of evolutionary loss of formerly cotranscribed genes, show simpler transcript patterns in Epifagus than in tobacco. Sizing and sequencing of cDNAs generated by reverse transcriptase-PCR for three genes, rps12, rpl2, and clpP, show that their transcripts are properly cis- and/or trans-spliced at the same five group II intron insertion sites used in photosynthetic plants. A single, conventional C-->U edit in rps12 was found among the total of 1401 nucleotides of cDNA sequence that was determined for the three genes. An octanucleotide sequence identical to a putative guide RNA of plant organelles and perfectly complementary to the rps12 edit site itself was identified just 200 bp upstream of the edit site. These data, together with previous results from the complete sequencing of the Epifagus plastid genome, provide compelling evidence that this degenerate genome is nonetheless expressed and functional. Analysis of the putative maturase MatK, encoded by the group II intron of trnK in photosynthetic land plants but by a freestanding gene in Epifagus, leads us to hypothesize that it acts 'in trans' to assist the splicing of group II introns other than the one in which it is normally encoded.

Editing of the chloroplast ndhB encoded transcript shows divergence between closely related members of the grass family (Poaceae)

The ndhB-encoded transcript from barley chloroplasts deviates from the genomic ndhB sequence by nine C-to-U transitions, which is the maximum number of editing events for a chloroplast mRNA reported so far. Comparison with ndhB transcripts from other chloroplast species shows that six of the nine editing sites observed in barley are structurally and functionally conserved in maize, rice and tobacco. The remaining three sites, however, show divergent patterns of conservation even within the three members of the grass family. The conservation of two of these sites in tobacco but not in the closely related graminean species suggests that divergence of the ndhB editing sites is caused by the loss of preexisting editing sites rather than by gain of new sites.

Site-specific factor involved in the editing of the psbL mRNA in tobacco plastids

In tobacco plastids, functional psbL mRNA is created by editing an ACG codon to an AUG translation initiation codon. To determine if editing may occur in a chimeric mRNA, the N-terminal part of psbL containing the editing site was translationally fused with the aadA and kan bacterial genes. The chimeric constructs were introduced into the tobacco plastid genome by targeted gene insertion. Editing of the chimeric mRNAs indicated that the 98 nt fragment spanning the psbL editing site contains all cis information required for editing. Expression of the chimeric gene transcripts led to a significant decrease in the editing efficiency of the endogenous psbL mRNA. However, the efficiency of editing in the transplastomic lines was unchanged for four sites in the rpoB and ndhB mRNAs. Reduced efficiency of psbL editing, but not of the other four sites, in the transplastomic lines indicates depletion of psbL-specific editing factor(s). This finding implicates the involvement of site-specific factors in editing of plastid mRNAs in higher plants.

In vivo testing of a tobacco plastid DNA segment for guide RNA function in psbL editing

A C-to-U RNA editing event creates a functional initiation codon for translation of the psbL mRNA in tobacco plastids. Small trans-acting guide RNAs (gRNAs) have been shown to be involved in editing site selection in kinetoplastid mitochondria. A computer search of the tobacco plastid genome (ptDNA) identified such a putative gRNA, a 14-nucleotide sequence motif that is complementary to the psbL mRNA, including the A nucleotide required to direct the C-to-U change. The critical A nucleotide of the putative gRNA gene was changed to G by plastid transformation. We report here that the introduced mutation did not abolish psbL editing. Since no other region of the plastid genome contains significant complementarity to the psbL editing site we suggest that, if gRNAs serve as trans-acting factors for plastid psbL mRNA editing, they either have only a limited complementarity to the editing site, or are encoded in the nuclear genome.

RNA-binding activity of the matK protein encoded by the chloroplast trnK intron from mustard (Sinapis alba L.)

The chloroplast trnK gene for tRNALys(UUU) from mustard contains a 2574 bp group II intron with a long open reading frame for 524 amino acids. The encoded polypeptide appears to be structurally related to mitochondrial maturases which are involved in splicing. To study the properties of the intron encoded protein, we overexpressed the trnK ORF as a beta-galactosidase fusion protein in E. coli and carried out RNA-protein binding experiments with crude bacterial extracts and the purified fusion protein. Both gel-shift and UV-crosslinking experiments revealed preferential binding to the trnK precursor transcript. Of two other RNA probes containing chloroplast group II introns, the trnG precursor was recognized by the trnK ORF protein, but the rps16 precursor was not. Competition binding experiments indicate that G-residues seem to play a role in RNA-protein interaction. RNA-binding activity of the trnK intron encoded polypeptide is consistent with its suggested function as a plastid maturase, hence justifying the assignment matK for this gene.

A plant mitochondrial sequence transcribed in transgenic tobacco chloroplasts is not edited

RNA editing occurs in two higher-plant organelles, chloroplasts and mitochondria. Because chloroplasts and mitochondria exhibit some similarity in editing site selection, we investigated whether mitochondrial RNA sequences could be edited in chloroplasts. We produced transgenic tobacco plants that contained chimeric genes in which the second exon of a Petunia hybrida mitochondrial coxII gene was under the control of chloroplast gene regulatory sequences. coxII transcripts accumulated to low or high levels in transgenic chloroplasts containing chimeric genes with the plastid ribosomal protein gene rps16 or the rRNA operon promoter, respectively. Exon 2 of coxII was chosen because it carries seven editing sites and is edited in petunia mitochondria even when located in an abnormal context in an aberrant recombined gene. When editing of the coxII transcripts in transgenic chloroplasts was examined, no RNA editing at any of the usual sites was detected, nor was there any novel editing at any other sites. These results indicate that the RNA editing mechanisms of chloroplasts and mitochondria are not identical but must have at least some organelle-specific components.

Introduction of a heterologous editing site into the tobacco plastid genome: the lack of RNA editing leads to a mutant phenotype

The psbF mRNA is edited in spinach plastids by a C to U conversion, changing a serine to a conserved phenylalanine codon. In tobacco at this position a phenylalanine codon is present at the DNA level, and the psbF mRNA here is not edited. To test if the psbF editing capacity is evolutionarily conserved, the tobacco psbF gene was modified to match the corresponding spinach sequence. The endogenous tobacco gene was replaced with the modified copy using biolistic transformation. We report here that the heterologous editing site remains unmodified in transplastomic tobacco plants. The lack of editing is associated with slower growth, lowered chlorophyll content and high chlorophyll fluorescence, a phenotype characteristic of photosynthetic mutants. This finding confirms that the editing of the psbF mRNA is an essential processing step for protein function and thus provides direct proof for the biological significance of plant organellar RNA editing. Given that a mutant phenotype is associated with the lack of editing, it seems likely that the evolutionary loss of the site-specific capacity for psbF editing was preceded by the mutation that eliminated the editing requirement.

RNA editing of tobacco petB mRNAs occurs both in chloroplasts and non-photosynthetic proplastids

We found an RNA editing site in the protein coding region of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) petB transcripts. This editing (CCA to CUA) leads to an amino acid conversion from proline to leucine. It is observed not only in chloroplasts isolated from tobacco leaves but also in non-photosynthetic proplastids isolated from a tobacco cell culture. Also unspliced pre-mRNA shows complete editing. The editing site is the same as that recently observed in the maize petB transcripts which restores the codon for a highly conserved leucine residue, suggesting that RNA editing at this site is critical for the protein (cytochrome b6) function.

The role of RNA editing in conservation of start codons in chloroplast genomes

Open reading frames (ORFs), encoded by the plastid genomes of tobacco, liverwort, rice and maize were aligned with a view to studying the conservation of translational start and stop codons created by RNA editing of homologous genes. It became evident that most of the homologous ORFs have conserved translation start and stop signals at the gene level. However, some of the ORFs show differences with respect to extensions of their 3' and 5' terminal regions. For example, the proposed N-termini of the ndhD-encoded peptides from different plant species are very variable in length and amino-acid composition. Sequence analysis of ndhD and the corresponding cDNA shows that editing of an ACG triplet in tobacco, spinach and snapdragon leads to the creation of an AUG codon, corresponding to the start codon in other species. Conservation of translational start codons of plastome-encoded genes can, therefore, be achieved by editing of transcripts, and the definition of plastome-encoded ORFs must take potential editing events into consideration.

A novel RNA gene in the tobacco plastid genome: its possible role in the maturation of 16S rRNA

A small plastid-encoded RNA (spRNA, 218 nt) has been detected in tobacco. The corresponding locus (sprA) does not contain any open reading frame and is actively transcribed from its own promoter, as shown by ribonuclease protection assays using in vitro capped RNAs. Gel-shift and UV-crosslinking experiments showed the formation of a specific complex between spRNA and chloroplast polypeptides. The mobility of the complex was further shifted when a transcript bearing part of the 16S rRNA leader sequence was added to the incubation mixture. Glycerol gradient fractionation of a chloroplast lysate indicated a preferential sedimentation of spRNA at 15-20S and 70S. These observations, and the potential base-pairing with the leader sequence of pre-16S rRNA, suggest a role for spRNA in chloroplast ribosome biogenesis, i.e. 16S rRNA maturation. By sequencing of tomato plastid DNA and heterologous northern hybridizations, the presence of sprA homologs and their expression in a number of dicot plants have also been shown.

Complete RNA editing of unspliced and dicistronic transcripts of the intron-containing reading frame IRF170 from maize chloroplasts

The maize plastome harbors within the rps4-rps14 gene cluster the reading frame IRF170, which is interrupted by two introns. Although the function of the encoded peptide of 170 amino acids is not known, the conservation of IRF170 homologs in other plastomes is a strong indication that IRF170 is a functional gene. Amplification and sequence analyses of IRF170 specific cDNAs reveals two C-to-U editing events occurring within each of the first two exons. This situation allows an analysis of the temporal order between editing and splicing of a chloroplast transcript. By using intron-specific primer combinations, cDNAs derived from partially or even unspliced IRF170 transcripts could be amplified which in all cases showed complete editing. Complete editing was also observed with a cDNA derived from a transcript in which the proximal rps4 and the 5' half of IRF170-encoded sequences were still linked. This demonstrates that editing of the IRF170 transcript is an early processing step preceding both splicing and cleavage to monocistronic mRNA.

Evidence for RNA editing in mitochondria of all major groups of land plants except the Bryophyta

RNA editing has been documented in mitochondria of higher plants, notably dicots and monocots. To determine the distribution of mitochondrial RNA editing in the plant kingdom, we have now undertaken a survey of evolutionarily distant plants. RNA editing occurs in all major groups of land plants except the Bryophyta, suggesting that this process is an ancient trait that was established before the radiation of kormophyte plants. No editing is observed in representatives of the green algae, suggesting that editing arose in early land plants after the split of the Bryophyta or has been lost selectively in both algae and mosses. In ferns several U-->C changes are observed, one of which eliminates a genomically encoded UAA termination codon and creates a functional open reading frame.

Origin and evolution of organelle genomes

Molecular data (particularly sequence analyses) have established that two eukaryotic organelles, the mitochondrion and the plastid, are the descendants of endosymbiotic (eu)bacteria whose closest living relatives are the alpha-Proteobacteria (mitochondrion) and Cyanobacteria (plastid). This review describes recent data that favor the view that each organelle arose via this primary endosymbiotic pathway only once (monophyletic origin), such as the discovery of group I introns that appear to be structurally homologous and have identical insertion sites in metaphyte, chlorophyte and fungal mitochondrial genomes. However, it is also evident that the plastids in certain algal groups were acquired secondarily through a eukaryotic rather than a prokaryotic endosymbiont.

Tissue- and stage-specific modulation of RNA editing of the psbF and psbL transcript from spinach plastids--a new regulatory mechanism?

The psbE operon of spinach chloroplasts, which includes the genes psbE, psbF, psbL and psbJ, encodes two RNA editing sites. One site corresponds to the initiation codon of the psbL transcript, as has been described earlier for the homologous transcript from tobacco, while at a second editing site, newly reported here, an internal phenylalanine codon of the psbF transcript is restored. Both these sites were investigated with respect to the extent of editing in spinach plastids at various developmental stages. The apparent existence of only completely edited transcripts in etioplasts and chloroplasts, indicates that light-induced processes are not acting as determinants in eliciting the editing process. Reduced editing is, however, observed in the psbF and psbL transcript from seeds and roots. This finding suggests that the RNA editing process is differentially down-regulated in leucoplasts and proplastids and that editing may, therefore, function as a regulatory device in plastid gene expression.

RNA editing in plant mitochondria and chloroplasts

In the mitochondria and chloroplasts of flowering plants (angiosperms), transcripts of protein-coding genes are altered after synthesis so that their final primary nucleotide sequence differs from that of the corresponding DNA sequence. This posttranscriptional mRNA editing consists almost exclusively of C-to-U substitutions. Editing occurs predominantly within coding regions, mostly at isolated C residues, and usually at first or second positions of codons, thereby almost always changing the amino acid from that specified by the unedited codon. Editing may also create initiation and termination codons. The net effect of C-to-U RNA editing in plants is to make proteins encoded by plant organelles more similar in sequence to their nonplant homologs. In a few cases, a strong argument can be made that specific C-to-U editing events are essential for the production of functional plant mitochondrial proteins. Although the phenomenon of RNA editing in plants is now well documented, fundamental questions remain to be answered: What determines the specificity of editing? What is the biochemical mechanism (deamination, base exchange, or nucleotide replacement)? How did the system evolve? RNA editing in plants, as in other organisms, challenges our traditional notions of genetic information transfer.