An analysis of differential display shows a strong bias towards high copy number mRNAs

Full-length RNA sequencing reveals unique transcriptome composition in bermudagrass

Bermudagrass [Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers.] is an important perennial warm-season turfgrass species with great economic value. However, the reference genome and transcriptome information are still deficient in bermudagrass, which severely impedes functional and molecular breeding studies. In this study, through analyzing a mixture sample of leaves, stolons, shoots, roots and flowers with single-molecule long-read sequencing technology from Pacific Biosciences (PacBio), we reported the first full-length transcriptome dataset of bermudagrass (C. dactylon cultivar Yangjiang) comprising 78,192 unigenes. Among the unigenes, 66,409 were functionally annotated, whereas 27,946 were found to have two or more isoforms. The annotated full-length unigenes provided many new insights into gene sequence characteristics and systematic phylogeny of bermudagrass. By comparison with transcriptome dataset in nine grass species, KEGG pathway analyses further revealed that C₄ photosynthesis-related genes, notably the phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase and pyruvate, phosphate dikinase genes, are specifically enriched in bermudagrass. These results not only explained the possible reason why bermudagrass flourishes in warm areas but also provided a solid basis for future studies in this important turfgrass species.

Genetic Approaches to Study Plant Responses to Environmental Stresses: An Overview

The assessment of gene expression levels is an important step toward elucidating gene functions temporally and spatially. Decades ago, typical studies were focusing on a few genes individually, whereas now researchers are able to examine whole genomes at once. The upgrade of throughput levels aided the introduction of systems biology approaches whereby cell functional networks can be scrutinized in their entireties to unravel potential functional interacting components. The birth of systems biology goes hand-in-hand with huge technological advancements and enables a fairly rapid detection of all transcripts in studied biological samples. Even so, earlier technologies that were restricted to probing single genes or a subset of genes still have their place in research laboratories. The objective here is to highlight key approaches used in gene expression analysis in plant responses to environmental stresses, or, more generally, any other condition of interest. Northern blots, RNase protection assays, and qPCR are described for their targeted detection of one or a few transcripts at a once. Differential display and serial analysis of gene expression represent non-targeted methods to evaluate expression changes of a significant number of gene transcripts. Finally, microarrays and RNA-seq (next-generation sequencing) contribute to the ultimate goal of identifying and quantifying all transcripts in a cell under conditions or stages of study. Recent examples of applications as well as principles, advantages, and drawbacks of each method are contrasted. We also suggest replacing the term “Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS)” with another less confusing synonym such as “RNA-seq”, “high throughput sequencing”, or “massively parallel sequencing” to avoid confusion with any future sequencing technologies.

Expression profiles of subtracted mRNAs during cellular senescence in human mesenchymal stem cells derived from bone marrow

Cellular senescence is an irreversible cell cycle arrest that limits the replicative lifespan of cells. Senescence suppresses development of tumors by regulating aging factors, such as cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor (CKI) and telomerase. Suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) was used to identify genes that were differentially expressed between young human mesenchymal stem cells (Y-hMSCs) and senescent human mesenchymal stem cells (S-hMSCs). We selected positive clones that were functionally characterized by referring to public databases using NCBI BLAST tool. This search revealed that 19 genes were downregulated, and 43 genes were upregulated in S-hMSCs relative to Y-hMSCs. Among subtracted clones in Y-hMSCs, most of genes markedly were related to metabolic functions. These genes, PDIA3, WDR1, FSTL1, COPG1, LMAN1, and PDIA6, significantly downregulated. Conversely, genes for subtracted clones in S-hMSCs were mostly associated with cell adhesion. In particular, the expression levels of 9 genes, HSP90B1, EID1, ATP2B4, DDAH1, PRNP, RAB1A, PGS5, TM4SF1 and SSR3, gradually increased during senescence. These genes have not previously been identified as being related to cellular senescence, but they seemed to be potentially affected during cellular senescence.

Identification of a reproductive-specific, putative lipid transport protein gene in a queenless ponerine ant Diacamma sp

Of the various characteristics of social insects, communication for reproductive differentiation is one of the most important and basic social interactions among colony members. To elucidate the molecular basis underlying this process, genes responsible for reproductive differentiation in Diacamma were screened using fluorescent differential display. Differential display, together with real-time quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR), revealed that a gene belonging to the family of cellular retinaldehyde-binding proteins was specifically expressed in the epidermis of the head, legs, and thorax in reproductives. The deduced protein sequence in the coding region, obtained by rapid amplification of cDNA ends (RACE)-PCR, was found to include cellular retinaldehyde-binding domain (CRAL-TRIO domain), suggesting that DiaCRALDCP functions in transportation of lipids, such as cuticular hydrocarbons. DiaCRALDCP transcript levels immediately decreased 1 day after the gemma mutilation, suggesting that DiaCRALDCP is involved in the physiological changes provoked by the behavioral regulation. Considering these results, the social functions of DiaCRALDCP in Diacamma are discussed.

ANALYSIS OF DIFFERENTIALLY REGULATED mRNAs IN MONOCYTIC CELLS INDUCED BY IN VITRO STIMULATION WITH KVEIM-SILTZBACH TEST REAGENT

Sarcoidosis is a granulomatous disorder of unknown origin. The sarcoid spleen-derived Kveim-Siltzbach test reagent (KSTR) elicits a sarcoid-specific, granulomatous response and was used to diagnose sarcoidosis. The active component and the pathomechanism by which KSTR induces granuloma are still unknown. This study investigated the KSTR-associated gene expression pattern in cells of patients with sarcoidosis or chronic beryllium disease (CBD). The monocytic-like cell line U937, alveolar macrophages of sarcoidosis patients, and peripheral blood monocytes of patients with CBD were stimulated with KSTR and other granuloma-associated stimuli. The KSTR-associated gene expression pattern was analyzed by means of differential display reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction in combination with a multiple comparison of expressed sequence tags induced in response to KSTR and other granuloma-associated stimuli. Depending on the origin of cells tested, 3.7% to 14.6% of the analyzed sequence tags showed differential regulation induced by granuloma-associated stimuli. Alterations restricted to KSTR stimulation could be observed in 1.2% for the cell line U937, in 2.8% for blood monocytes of patients with CBD, and 1.3% for alveolar macrophages of sarcoidosis patients. These data are comparable to those achieved for the other granuloma-associated stimuli tested in this study. Therefore, it can be assumed that KSTR induces pathomechanisms for granuloma formation in sarcoidosis as beryllium in CBD.

Kamchatka crab duplex-specific nuclease-mediated transcriptome subtraction method for identifying long cDNAs of differentially expressed genes

The subtraction method is a quick and economical technique to scan differential gene expression. However, most subtraction methods are limited by the complexity and length of cDNA samples. To overcome this problem, we developed a novel method to identify the unique full-length cDNAs in two complicated tissue or cell types. This method, duplex-specific nuclease (DSN)-mediated transcriptome subtraction (DTS), is based on the normalization strategy of the crab duplex-specific nuclease and the subtraction method of suppression subtractive hybridization. DSN eliminates nearly all of the common sequences in the tester and driver cDNA samples after the first hybridization step, ensures accurate discrimination between the tester and the driver cDNA samples, and enriches the full-length differential cDNAs from the tester. Using the DTS method, we have successfully identified an 1812-bp additional GUS gene from the complicated Arabidopsis seedling cDNA library. We also employed DTS to detect the differences in mRNA expression of salt-treated Arabidopsis seedlings to illustrate further the efficiency of the subtraction method.

Large-scale gene expression studies of the endometrium: what have we learnt?

The endometrium is a dynamic tissue that undergoes coordinated changes under the influence of steroid hormones. This results in proliferation and differentiation culminating in a receptive state, followed by menstruation and endometrial repair. These functions involve complex interactions between the epithelium, stroma and leucocytes in the endometrium. Understanding the underlying causes of endometrial disorders, such as infertility, endometriosis and heavy menstrual bleeding, therefore represents a considerable challenge. Recently developed techniques, such as differential display and DNA microarrays permit the abundance of thousands of mRNA transcripts within cells or tissues to be measured simultaneously. This provides a new approach to understanding the complex interactions that underlie both healthy and disease states. Responses of the endometrium to hormones or drugs can be studied and the response of the system as an integrated whole can be assessed. Comparisons of endometrium from healthy women and those with endometrial dysfunction have advanced our understanding of key areas of endometrial physiology, including infertility, receptivity, endometriosis and cancer. Using this approach, novel genes controlling specific endometrial functions like receptivity have been identified for functional testing. This paper will review the impact of these techniques for transcript profiling on our understanding of selected areas of endometrial biology and discuss the potential applications in future.

Annealing control primer system for identification of differentially expressed genes on agarose gels

We developed GeneFishing technology, an improved method for the identification of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) using our novel annealing control primer (ACP) system. Because of high annealing specificity during PCR using the ACP system, the application of the ACP to DEG discovery generates reproducible, authentic, and long (100 bp to 2 kb) PCR products that are detectable on agarose gels. To demonstrate this method for gene expression profiling, Gene-Fishing technology was used to detect genes that are differentially expressed during development using total RNAs isolated from mouse conceptus tissues at 4.5-18.5 days of gestation. Ten DEGs (DEG1-10) were isolated and confirmed by Northern blot hybridization. The sequence analysis of these DEGs showed that DEG6 and DEG10 are unknown genes.

A large scale analysis of resistance gene homologues in Arachis

Arachis hypogaea L., commonly known as the peanut or groundnut, is an important and widespread food legume. Because the crop has a narrow genetic base, genetic diversity in A. hypogaea is low and it lacks sources of resistance to many pests and diseases. In contrast, wild diploid Arachis species are genetically diverse and are rich sources of disease resistance genes. The majority of known plant disease resistance genes encode proteins with a nucleotide binding site domain (NBS). In this study, degenerate PCR primers designed to bind to DNA regions encoding conserved motifs within this domain were used to amplify NBS-encoding regions from Arachis spp. The Arachis spp. used were A. hypogaea var. Tatu and wild species that are known to be sources of disease resistance: A. cardenasii, A. duranensis, A. stenosperma and A. simpsonii. A total of 78 complete NBS-encoding regions were isolated, of which 63 had uninterrupted ORFs. Phylogenetic analysis of the Arachis NBS sequences derived in this study and other NBS sequences from Arabidopsis thaliana, Medicago trunculata, Glycine max, Lotus japonicus and Phaseolus vulgaris that are available in public databases This analysis indicates that most Arachis NBS sequences fall within legume-specific clades, some of which appear to have undergone extensive copy number expansions in the legumes. In addition, NBS motifs from A. thaliana and legumes were characterized. Differences in the TIR and non-TIR motifs were identified. The likely effect of these differences on the amplification of NBS-encoding sequences by PCR is discussed.

A targeted approach to the identification of candidate genes determining susceptibility to Plasmodium gallinaceum in Aedes aegypti

The malaria parasite, Plasmodium, has evolved an intricate life cycle that includes stages specific to a mosquito vector and to the vertebrate host. The mosquito midgut represents the first barrier Plasmodium parasites encounter following their ingestion with a blood meal from an infected vertebrate. Elucidation of the molecular interaction between the parasite and the mosquito could help identify novel approaches to preventing parasite development and subsequent transmission to vertebrates. We have used an integrated Bulked Segregant Analysis-Differential Display (BSA-DD) approach to target genes expressed that are in the midgut and located within two genome regions involved in determining susceptibility to P. gallinaceum in the mosquito Aedes aegypti. A total of twenty-two genes were identified and characterized, including five genes with no homologues in public sequence databases. Eight of these genes were mapped genetically to intervals on chromosome 2 that contain two quantitative trait loci (QTLs) that determine susceptibility to infection by P. gallinaceum. Expression analysis revealed several expression patterns, and ten genes were specifically or preferentially expressed in the midgut of adult females. Real-time PCR quantification of expression with respect to the time of blood meal ingestion and infection status in mosquito strains permissive and refractory for malaria revealed a differential expression pattern for seven genes. These represent candidate genes that may influence the ability of the mosquito vector to support the development of Plasmodium parasites. Here we describe their isolation and discuss their putative roles in parasite-mosquito interactions and their use as potential targets in strategies designed to block transmission of malaria.

Large scale isolation of non-uniform shear stress-responsive genes from cultured human endothelial cells through the preparation of a subtracted cDNA library

To investigate the molecular mechanisms responsible for the regional selectivity of early atherogenesis, we have applied a non-uniform shear stress to cultured human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC). We used a microcarrier culture system and a combination of subtraction and reverse-subtraction methods to isolate a number of genes upregulated by shear stress. The resultant subtracted library includes several known genes (e.g. MCP-1, TM) whose responsiveness to shear stress has been previously reported, indicating that the library is enriched for genes upregulated by shear stress. Also included are atherosclerosis-related genes (e.g. CTGF, IL-8) whose responsiveness to shear stress had not been demonstrated, other known genes whose relationship to atherosclerosis had not been reported, and novel genes. Some responsive to centrifugal force and shear stress (RECS) genes are also upregulated following stimulation by steady laminar shear stress in a parallel plate chamber. Interestingly, the library includes ET-1 and PAI, which are well known atherogenic factors that are downregulated by laminar shear stress. This implies that turbulent shear stress has effects on HUVEC that are different from those elicited by laminar shear stress. Importantly, analysis of specimens taken from human aorta showed that several RECS genes are transcriptionally upregulated in atherosclerotic lesions, suggesting that the subtracted library includes novel therapeutic targets for the treatment of atherosclerosis.

Genomic and proteomic perspectives in cell culture engineering

In the last few years, the number of biologics produced by mammalian cells have been steadily increasing. The advances in cell culture engineering science have contributed significantly to this increase. A common path of product and process development has emerged in the last decade and the host cell lines frequently used have converged to only a few. Selection of cell clones, their adaptation to a desired growth environment, and improving their productivity has been key to developing a new process. However, the fundamental understanding of changes during the selection and adaptation process is still lacking. Some cells may undergo irreversible alteration at the genome level, some may exhibit changes in their gene expression pattern, while others may incur neither genetic reconstruction nor gene expression changes, but only modulation of various fluxes by changing nutrient/metabolite concentrations and enzyme activities. It is likely that the selection of cell clones and their adaptation to various culture conditions may involve alterations not only in cellular machinery directly related to the selected marker or adapted behavior, but also those which may or may not be essential for selection or adaptation. The genomic and proteomic research tools enable one to globally survey the alterations at mRNA and protein levels and to unveil their regulation. Undoubtedly, a better understanding of these cellular processes at the molecular level will lead to a better strategy for 'designing' producing cells. Herein the genomic and proteomic tools are briefly reviewed and their impact on cell culture engineering is discussed.

Increased ratio of mitochondrial rDNA to cytoplasmic rDNA during zoosporic and germinating cyst stages of the life cycle of Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bary

A differential RNA display approach was used to study the gene expression in zoospores (Z) and germinating cysts (GC) of the late blight pathogen Phytophthora infestans. Four differentially amplified cDNAs were selected and cloned. The clone pGPiZ0.5 showed a 2.7-kb transcript highly expressed in Z. A BLAST search revealed an almost full sequence homology (98%) to the P. infestans mitochondrial large subunit rRNA. Northern blot analysis showed a twofold accumulation of the mitochondrial rRNA (mit rRNA) in Z compared with that of GC and mycelia of P. infestans. The high level of mit rRNA in Z might reflect an increased number of gene copies, an increased rDNA transcription rate, or both. Dot blot experiments indicated that the amount of mitochondrial rDNA (mit rDNA) relative to cytoplasmic rDNA is twofold higher in Z and GC than in mycelia. This relatively elevated mit rDNA could explain the high level of mit rRNA in the zoosporic phase. On the contrary, GC conserves the mit rDNA content, but the level of mit rRNA drops to 50% that of Z. The data are consistent with a very active mitochondrial protein synthesis during zoosporic phase, followed by a rapid down-regulation of mitochondrial activity during cyst formation.

Comprehensive gene expression analysis by transcript profiling

After the completion of the genomic sequence of Arabidopsis thaliana, it is now a priority to identify all the genes, their patterns of expression and functions. Transcript profiling is playing a substantial role in annotating and determining gene functions, having advanced from one-gene-at-a-time methods to technologies that provide a holistic view of the genome. In this review, comprehensive transcript profiling methodologies are described, including two that are used extensively by the authors, cDNA-AFLP and cDNA microarraying. Both these technologies illustrate the requirement to integrate molecular biology, automation, LIMS and data analysis. With so much uncharted territory in the Arabidopsis genome, and the desire to tackle complex biological traits, such integrated systems will provide a rich source of data for the correlative, functional annotation of genes.

A critical evaluation of differential display as a tool to identify genes involved in legume nodulation: looking back and looking forward

Screening for differentially expressed genes is a straightforward approach to study the molecular basis of a biological system. In the last 10 years, differential screening technology has evolved rapidly and currently high-throughput tools for genome-wide transcript profiling, such as expressed sequence tags and microarray analysis, are becoming widely available. Here, an overview of this (r)evolution is given with emphasis on the differential display method, which for many years has been the preferred technique of scientists in diverse fields of research. Differential display has also been the method of choice for the identification of genes involved in the symbiotic interaction between Azorhizobium caulinodans and Sesbania rostrata. The advantages with respect to tissue specificity of this particular model system for legume nodulation and the results of a screening for early nodulation-related genes have been considered in the context of transcriptome analyses in other rhizobium-legume interactions.

Identification of a polymorphic mucin-like gene expressed in the midgut of the mosquito, Aedes aegypti, using an integrated bulked segregant and differential display analysis

The identification of putative differentially expressed genes within genome regions containing QTL determining susceptibility of the mosquito, Aedes aegypti, to the malarial parasite, Plasmodium gallinaceum, was investigated using an integrated, targeted approach based on bulked segregant and differential display analysis. A mosquito F2 population was obtained from pairwise matings between the parasite-susceptible RED strain and the resistant MOYO-R substrain. DNA from female carcasses was used to genotype individuals at RFLP markers of known chromosomal position around the major QTL (pgs 1). Midguts, dissected 48 hr after an infected blood meal, were used to prepare two RNA bulks, each representing one of the parental genotypes at the QTL interval. The RNA bulks were compared by differential display PCR. A mucin-like protein gene (AeIMUC1) was isolated and characterized. The gene maps within the pgs 1 QTL interval and is expressed in the adult female midgut. AeIMUC1 RNA abundance decreased with time after blood meal ingestion. No differential expression was observed between the two mosquito strains but three different alleles with inter- and intrastrain allelic polymorphisms including indels and SNPs were characterized. The AeIMUC1 gene chromosome location and allelic polymorphisms raise the possibility that the protein might be involved in parasite-mosquito interactions.

Identification of differentially expressed genes in mouse development using differential display and in situ hybridization

A common problem in developmental biology is the isolation of genes that are expressed differentially between two closely matched tissue populations, for example, between wild-type and mutant mouse embryos generated by targeted gene disruption. Typically, the applicable experimental methodologies are limited by the amount of mRNA that can be obtained for cDNA library construction and/or expression analysis. Differential display is a polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based RNA fingerprinting technique that is ideally suited for the identification of differentially expressed transcripts when only limiting amounts of tissue are available, as is frequently encountered in studies of vertebrate development. Here, I describe protocols for differential display using arbitrarily primed reverse transcription PCR and for the subsequent verification of differential gene expression that are adapted for molecular genetic studies of mouse embryogenesis. The overall strategy involves two steps: First, RNA samples isolated from two nearly identical populations of embryos or microdissected embryonic tissues are compared by differential display, and candidate differentially expressed transcripts are identified. Second, these candidate transcripts are analyzed for differential expression in vivo using nonradioactive whole-mount or section in situ hybridization. In principle, this strategy permits the efficient isolation of genes that are differentially expressed during early mouse embryogenesis.

Arabidopsis thaliana genes expressed in the early compatible interaction with root-knot nematodes

In the compatible interaction between Arabidopsis thaliana and the endoparasitic nematode Meloidogyne incognita, galls are formed on the roots of the host plant. Differential display was used to identify alterations of gene expression in young A. thaliana root galls caused by M. incognita. Six genes were confirmed as plant genes by DNA gel blot hybridizations. Significant homology was found with a trypsin inhibitor, peroxidase, mitochondrial uncoupling protein, endomembrane protein, 20S proteasome alpha-subunit, and diaminopimelate decarboxylase. The cellular and temporal expression of each of the six genes was analyzed by mRNA in situ hybridizations.

From outer to inner space: traveling along a scientific career from astrochemistry to drug research

This professional history describes my journey as a research scientist after my early training and experiences in the pre- and early post-World War II United States. My graduate training concentrated on a problem in astrochemistry: phenomena on comets. As my career developed, I felt confident enough in myself as an experimentalist to enter, and make contributions to, several different fields: structural biochemistry (via nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy), molecular immunology, pharmacology, neurochemistry, and cell biology. One emphasis is on the nature and quality of my scientific training that permitted me to do cross-disciplinary work. A second emphasis is on the technical and intellectual developments in late twentieth-century science and how, along with the changes in American society as it passed through three major wars, they influenced my life and thought.

Subtractive hybridization--genetic takeaways and the search for meaning

Gene expression profiling relies on mRNA extraction from defined cell systems, which in the case of pathological processes necessarily results in the use of small quantities of tissues, sometimes as little as a few cells. This obviates the use of many systems of gene expression profiling and is best carried out using cDNA amplified by poly(A) reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction, which is capable of generating material representative of all the expressed genes in samples as small as one cell. Analysis of this material using subtractive hybridization compares the genes expressed at different stages of a biological/pathological process allowing identification of the all the genes upregulated during the process. The identification of the genes present is not dependent on their prior description or on the choice of genes used in a screen and as such the method is ideal for identifying novel genes or unsuspected genes. We have used the method to identify genes involved in normal osteoblastic differentiation and in Paget's disease of bone and it has been widely used to study normal differentiation and pathological processes in a number of systems. The method, its applications and its relationship with the other methods of gene expression profiling are reviewed.

Suppression subtractive hybridization identifies genes expressed in oviduct during mouse preimplantation period

Fertilization and development of mouse embryos occur in the ampullae of oviduct. Various growth factors and embryotrophic factors produced by the oviductal cells have been demonstrated to enhance embryo development in vitro. As a step towards understanding the genetic changes of mouse oviduct during mouse embryos preimplantation period, we adopted suppression subtractive hybridization (SSH) to establish four subtracted cDNA libraries to identify (1) oviduct-expressing genes, and (2) genes that may support embryo development in vivo. Using this method, we isolated 82, 88, 99, and 109 clones from four mouse libraries prepared from 0 (day 0), 24 (day 1), 48 (day 2), and 72 h (day 3) post-human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) treated mice. Reverse dot-blot analysis confirmed that 25 (day 0), 24 (day 1), 40 (day 2), and 29 (day 3) clones were highly expressed in mouse oviduct when compared to other tissues. DNA sequence analysis identified genes encoding mouse oviduct-specific glycoprotein (MOGP), actin-binding protein 280, and several viral genes. Northern analysis confirmed that the genes were mainly expressed in oviduct, with some viral genes also expressed in uterus. About 9% of these oviduct expressing clones (11/118) were novel. We further demonstrated that one of the novel clones ODEG0-17 was expressed in the oviduct during early embryo preimplantation period and rarely in other tissues by RT-PCR. Our results show that SSH is a powerful method applicable to identifying tissue-specific transcripts on fertilization and development.

Use of mRNA differential display to study the action of lymphocyte subsets in vivo and application to a murine model of herpes simplex virus infection

Depletion of lymphocyte subsets in vivo using monoclonal antibodies against cell surface markers has helped to define the roles for these subsets in many immune processes. However, in some cases the mechanisms through which these lymphocytes act remain partially elucidated or completely unknown. A new approach to these biological problems is the use of transcriptional analyses to find mRNAs whose abundance in tissues is altered by depletion of lymphocyte subsets. We have verified the use mRNA differential display (DD) for this purpose and applied it in a study of CD8(+) lymphocyte mediated clearance of herpes simplex virus (HSV) from the nervous systems of experimentally infected mice. The results of the differential displays and characterisation of a large mRNA identified using this strategy are presented.

A cDNA RDA protocol using solid-phase technology suited for analysis in small tissue samples

cDNA representational difference analysis (cDNA RDA) is a PCR-based subtractive enrichment procedure for the cloning of differentially expressed genes. In this study, we have further developed the procedure to take advantage of solid-phase technology, and to facilitate the use of RDA when starting material is limited. Several parameters of the PCR-based generation of cDNA representations were investigated, and a solid-phase based purification step was introduced to simplify removal of digested adapter-ends and uncleaved fragments. The use of magnetic particles increased the speed of the method, and also eliminated the risk of carry-over contamination between iterative steps of subtraction and PCR amplification. The modified protocol was evaluated in monitoring differences in gene expression in (i) a rat system consisting of livers with and without growth hormone treatment, and in (ii) a human system consisting of normal colon and colon cancer.

Applications of differential-display reverse transcription-PCR to molecular pathogenesis and medical mycology

The host-fungus interaction is characterized by changes in gene expression in both host and pathogen. Differential-display reverse transcription PCR (DDRT-PCR) is a PCR-based method that allows extensive analysis of gene expression among several cell populations. Several limitations and drawbacks to this procedure have now been addressed, including the large number of false-positive results and the difficulty in confirming differential expression. Modifications that simplify the reaction time, allow the use of minute quantities of RNA, or address unusual species- or gene-specific sequences have been reported. DDRT-PCR has been used to address biological questions in mammalian systems, including cell differentiation, cell activation, cell stress, and identification of drug targets. In microbial pathogenesis and plant pathogenesis, DDRT-PCR has allowed the identification of virulence factors, genes involved in cell death, and signaling genes. In Candida albicans, DDRT-PCR studies identified TIF-2, which may play a role in the upregulation of phospholipases, and the stress-related genes, CIP1 and CIP2. In Histoplasma capsulatum and C. albicans, genes involved in the host-pathogen interaction, including a member of the 100-kDa family in Histoplasma and an ALS and 14-3-3 gene in Candida, were potentially identified by DDRT-PCR. Although very few reports have been published in medical mycology, studies in mammalian, nonfungal microbial, and plant pathogen systems are easily applied to basic questions in fungal pathogenesis and antifungal therapeutics.

Applications of differential-display reverse transcription-PCR to molecular pathogenesis and medical mycology

The host-fungus interaction is characterized by changes in gene expression in both host and pathogen. Differential-display reverse transcription PCR (DDRT-PCR) is a PCR-based method that allows extensive analysis of gene expression among several cell populations. Several limitations and drawbacks to this procedure have now been addressed, including the large number of false-positive results and the difficulty in confirming differential expression. Modifications that simplify the reaction time, allow the use of minute quantities of RNA, or address unusual species- or gene-specific sequences have been reported. DDRT-PCR has been used to address biological questions in mammalian systems, including cell differentiation, cell activation, cell stress, and identification of drug targets. In microbial pathogenesis and plant pathogenesis, DDRT-PCR has allowed the identification of virulence factors, genes involved in cell death, and signaling genes. In Candida albicans, DDRT-PCR studies identified TIF-2, which may play a role in the upregulation of phospholipases, and the stress-related genes, CIP1 and CIP2. In Histoplasma capsulatum and C. albicans, genes involved in the host-pathogen interaction, including a member of the 100-kDa family in Histoplasma and an ALS and 14-3-3 gene in Candida, were potentially identified by DDRT-PCR. Although very few reports have been published in medical mycology, studies in mammalian, nonfungal microbial, and plant pathogen systems are easily applied to basic questions in fungal pathogenesis and antifungal therapeutics.

Gene expression in fetal Down syndrome brain as revealed by subtractive hybridization

Information on gene expression in brain of patients with Down Syndrome (DS, trisomy 21) is limited and molecular biological research is focussing on mapping and sequencing chromosome 21. The information on gene expression in DS available follows the current concept of a gene dosage effect due to a third copy of chromosome 21 claiming overexpression of genes encoded on this chromosome. Based upon the availability of fetal brain and recent technology of gene hunting, we decided to use subtractive hybridization to evaluate differences in gene expression between DS and control brains. Subtractive hybridization was applied on two fetal brains with DS and two age and sex matched controls, 23rd week of gestation, and mRNA steady state levels were evaluated generating a subtractive library. Subtracted sequences were identified by gene bank and assigned by alignments to individual genes. We found a series of up- and downregulated sequences consisting of chromosomal transcripts, enzymes of intermediary metabolism, hormones, transporters/channels and transcription factors (TFs). We show that trisomy 21 or aneuploidy leads to the deterioration of gene expression and the derangement of transcripts described describes the involvement of chromosomes other than chromosome 21, explains impairment of transport, carriers, channels, signaling, known metabolic and hormones imbalances. The dys-coordinated expression of transcription factors including homeobox genes, POU-domain TFs, helix-loop-helix-motifs, LIM domain containing TFs, leucine zippers, forkhead genes, maybe of pathophysiological significance for abnormal brain development and wiring found in patients with DS. This is the first description of the concomitant expression of a large series of sequences indicating disruption of the concerted action of genes in that disorder.

Metallothionein-null mice express altered genes during development

Metallothionein (MT) can modulate transcriptional activity in vitro. We examined whether the absence of MT affects gene expression in vivo. We compared the hepatic RNA profiles of wild-type and MT-null neonatal mice using improved differential display. The hepatic MT level was maximal during neonatal development. We identified five cDNA fragments that were expressed in MT-null mice at different levels from those in wild-type mice. Two were fragments of MT-I and mutant MT-I cDNA. The sequences of the other cDNA fragments were identical to those of contrapsin, transketolase, and vanin-3. The latter two were up-regulated, whereas contrapsin was down-regulated in neonatal MT-null mice. These mRNA levels were remarkably different between the two strains of neonatal mice. Further characterization of the regulated mRNA identified here will determine whether or not they are primary or secondary effects of an MT deficiency.

Use of suppression-PCR subtractive hybridisation to identify genes that demonstrate altered expression in male rat and guinea pig livers following exposure to Wy-14,643, a peroxisome proliferator and non-genotoxic hepatocarcinogen

Understanding the genetic profile of a cell at all stages of normal and carcinogenic development should provide an essential aid to developing new strategies for the prevention, early detection, diagnosis and treatment of cancers. We have attempted to identify some of the genes that may be involved in peroxisome-proliferator (PP)-induced non-genotoxic hepatocarcinogenesis using suppression PCR subtractive hybridisation (SSH). Wistar rats (male) were chosen as a representative susceptible species and Duncan-Hartley guinea pigs (male) as a resistant species to the hepatocarcinogenic effects of the PP, [4-chloro-6-(2,3-xylidino)-2-pyrimidinylthio] acetic acid (Wy-14,643). In each case, groups of four test animals were administered a single dose of Wy-14,643 (250 mg/kg per day in corn oil) by gastric intubation for 3 consecutive days. The control animals received corn oil only. On the fourth day the animals were killed and liver mRNA extracted. SSH was carried out using mRNA extracted from the rat and guinea pig livers, and used to isolate genes that were up and downregulated following Wy-14,643 treatment. These genes included some predictable (and hence positive control) species such as CYP4A1 and CYP2C11 (upregulated and downregulated in rat liver, respectively). Several genes that may be implicated in hepatocarcinogenesis have also been identified, as have some unidentified species. This work thus provides a starting point for developing a molecular profile of the early effects of a non-genotoxic carcinogen in sensitive and resistant species that could ultimately lead to a short-term assay for this type of toxicity.

A novel strategy for identifying differential gene expression: An improved method of differential display analysis

We propose a novel alternative approach, an advanced method for recently developed strategies, for identifying differentially expressed genes. Firstly, double-stranded cDNAs were digested using Sau3AI and the 3'-end restriction fragments of the cDNA were ligated to a double-stranded adapter. Next, the restriction fragments were directly amplified using several combinations of adapter-specific primers and FITC-labeled oligo dT primers. The selected cDNA fragments were displayed on a polyacrylamide gel. Neither nested PCR nor purification of 3'-end fragments are necessary. We examined the validity of this approach by evaluating gene expression changes during granulocytic differentiation of HL-60 cells. This method can theoretically detect almost all gene expression changes more rapidly and through simpler manipulations than by any other approach.

Genes involved in the pathophysiology of perinatal asphyxia

Mechanisms in the pathogenesis of perinatal asphyxia (PA) at the gene level are only beginning to be elucidated, although gene hunting using differential display has revealed differences in gene expression between hypoxic and normoxic cells in vitro. As no information on gene expression was available from in vivo studies, we decided to use a non-invasive and clinically relevant animal model of PA for mRNA hunting applying the subtractive hybridization method. mRNAs from normoxic rat brain and brain of rat pups with 20 min of asphyxia were isolated and compared by this technique. The resulting subtracted mRNAs were converted to cDNA, sequenced and identified by gene bank data. A series of transcripts representing transcription factors, transporters, metabolic factors, were found to be up- or downregulated providing insight into mechanisms of PA, and on the other hand, genes with unknown functions could be given a preliminary role i.e. in PA. Results obtained with this powerful tool are now challenging quantitative determination of these genes and gene products at the protein and activity level to confirm their role in PA.

Identification of genes regulated by muscarinic acetylcholine receptors: application of an improved and statistically comprehensive mRNA differential display technique

In order to identify genes that are regulated by muscarinic acetylcholine receptors, we developed an mRNA differential display technique (DD) approach. By increasing redundancy and by evaluating optimised reagents and conditions for reverse transcription of total RNA, PCR and separation of PCR products, we generated a DD protocol that yields highly consistent results. A set of 64 distinct random primers was specifically designed in order to approach a statistically comprehensive analysis of all mRNA species in a defined cell population. This modified DD protocol was applied to total RNA of HEK293 cells stably expressing muscarinic m1 acetylcholine receptors and cells stimulated with the receptor agonist carbachol were compared to identical but non-stimulated cells. In 81 of 192 possible PCR experiments, 38 differential bands were identified. Sequence analysis followed by northern blot analyses confirmed differentially expressed genes in 19 of 23 bands analysed. These represented 10 distinct immediate-early genes that were up-regulated by m1AChR activation: Egr-1, Egr-2, Egr-3, NGFi-B, ETR101, c- jun, jun -D, Gos-3 and hcyr61, as well as the unknown gene Gig-2. These data show that this improved DD protocol can be readily applied to reliably identify differentially expressed genes.

Search for oncogenic regulators in an autocrine tumor model using differential display PCR: identification of novel candidate genes including the calcium channel mtrp6

A hemopoietic multistep tumor model, in which IL-3 dependent PB-3c mast cells, following expression of v-H-ras progress in vivo to IL-3 producing autocrine tumors has previously been established. Central for this oncogenic progression is a recessive step, which is reversible by cell fusion and leads to stabilization of IL-3 mRNA with concomitant activation of the autocrine loop. Comparing the IL-3 dependent PB-3c and the IL-3 autocrine V2D1 tumor cells with differential display PCR revealed 12 differentially expressed genes of which eight were upregulated and four downregulated in the tumor. They included four proteases (mouse mast cell protease 2, granzyme B, pepsinogen F and serine protease 1) and two metabolic enzymes (adenine phosphoribosyltransferase and fructose1,6-bisphosphatase). For validation, expression of the identified genes was tested in independent PB-3c precursor clones and their tumor derivatives. Expression of an endogenous retroviral IAP element and three unknown transcripts were consistently upregulated in all tumor lines. In somatic cell hybrids, two of these unknown cDNAs showed a dominant and one a recessive expression pattern. One transcript, expressed in the precursor but downregulated in the tumor cells, was cloned and identified as the murine calcium channel mtrp6.

Altered gene expression in fetal Down syndrome brain as revealed by the gene hunting technique of subtractive hybridization

Information on gene expression in brain of patients with Down Syndrome (DS, trisomy 21) is limited and molecular biological research is focussing on mapping and sequencing chromosome 21. The information on gene expression in DS available follows the current concept of a gene dosage effect due to a third copy of chromosome 21 claiming overexpression of genes encoded on this chromosome. Based upon the availability of fetal brain and recent technology of gene hunting, we decided to use subtractive hybridization to evaluate differences in gene expression between DS and control brains. Subtractive hybridization was applied on two fetal brains with DS and two age and sex matched controls, 23rd week of gestation, and mRNA steady state levels were evaluated generating a subtractive library. Subtracted sequences were identified by gene bank and assigned by alignments to individual genes. We found a series of up- and downregulated sequences consisting of chromosomal transcripts, enzymes of intermediary metabolism, hormones, transporters/channels and transcription factors (TFs). We show that trisomy 21 or aneuploidy leads to the deterioration of gene expression and the derangement of transcripts describes the impairment of transport, carriers, channels, signaling, known metabolic and hormone imbalances. The dys-coordinated expression of transcription factors including homeobox genes, POU-domain TFs, helix-loop-helix-motifs, LIM domain containing TFs, leucine zippers, forkhead genes, maybe of pathophysiological significance for abnormal brain development and wiring found in patients with DS. This is the first description of the concomitant expression of a large series of sequences indicating disruption of the concerted action of genes in this disorder.

Use of differential display in conjunction with bulked segregants to target specific genomic loci

Differential display has proven to be a very successful technique for isolating differentially expressed transcripts. We sought to expand the capabilities of the technique by attempting to isolate cDNAs from specific genomic loci. Two loci of interest to us are the S locus and the MOD locus, both involved in the self-incompatibility phenomenon of Brassica. The S locus is a complex locus for which molecular markers have previously been isolated, and the MOD locus is a single-gene locus for which no markers are available. We used plant material from F2 populations that segregate for two allelic variants of each locus to create two bulks or pools of plants for each differential display screen. Pooling F2 individuals effectively homogenizes background polymorphisms found in the parent plants. RNA was prepared from each bulk and differential display was performed using a kit from GenHunter Corporation (Nashville, TN). One cDNA that segregated completely with the target locus was isolated from each screen. Multiple cDNAs that were linked to each locus were also identified. We have demonstrated that differential display, when used in conjunction with bulked segregants, is a very powerful technique for isolating cDNAs from genomic loci of interest.

Limitations of differential display

Since its original description, differential display PCR (DD-PCR) has been extensively used in attempts to identify novel genes under a variety of circumstances. Despite its widespread use, however, few novel genes of interest have been identified. In the present study we describe a set of experiments examining reasons for failure of differential display. Evidence is presented that aberrant priming at both the 5' and 3' ends results in competition in the PCR, precluding detection of messages other than those which are abundantly expressed. Appropriate calculations are discussed which indicate this was predictable and unlikely to be overcome. While DD may be successfully applied in some settings, the evidence indicates that only abundantly expressed messages can be detected. This limitation is emphasized.

Differential display of mRNA

Differential display of mRNA (DD) is a technique in which mRNA species expressed by a cell population are reverse transcribed and then amplified by many separate polymerase chain reactions (PCR). PCR primers and conditions are chosen so that any given reaction yields a limited number of amplified cDNA fragments, permitting their visualization as discrete bands following gel electrophoresis. This robust and relatively simple procedure allows identification of genes that are differentially expressed in different cell populations. Here we review DD including some recent modifications, and compare it with other techniques for analyzing differential mRNA expression.

Optimization of differential display of prokaryotic mRNA: application to pure culture and soil microcosms

The differential display (DD) technique, which is widely used almost exclusively for eukaryotic gene discovery, was optimized to detect differential mRNA transcription from both pure-culture and soil-derived bacterial RNA. A model system which included toluene induction of todC1 in Pseudomonas putida F1 was used to optimize the procedure. At 24-h tod induction was determined to be approximately 8 x 10(7) transcripts/microg or 0.08% of the total mRNA. The primer concentration, primer length, annealing temperature, and template, deoxynucleoside triphosphate, and MgCl2 concentrations were varied to optimize amplification of a todC1 fragment. The limit of detection of todC1 by DD was found to be 0.015 ng of total RNA template or approximately 10(3) transcripts. Once optimized, a todC1C2 gene fragment from P. putida F1 RNA was detected by using an arbitrary primer for the reverse transcriptase step in conjunction with the same arbitrary primer and a Shine-Dalgarno primer in the PCR. To verify the results, an arbitrary primer was used to detect recovery of a new salicylate-inducible naphthalene dioxygenase in Burkholderia cepacia JS150. The method was then used to detect mRNA induction in both inoculated and uninoculated toluene-induced soil microcosms. Several putative differentially expressed partial gene sequences obtained from the uninoculated microcosms were examined, and one novel fragment was found to be differentially expressed.

A subtractive hybridisation method for the enrichment of moderately induced sequences

Moderately induced genes often escape detection in conventional subtraction hybridisation cloning. Here a modification of a phagemid subtraction protocol is described that overcomes this problem. The protocol uses low ratio hybridisation of driver to target sequences to allow enrichment of the sequences of interest, and back-hybridisation of the subtracted sequences with induced sequences to reduce the accumulation of false positive clones. The procedure takes advantage of the quantitative representation of cellular RNA populations in cDNA libraries, therefore, they may serve not only as renewable sources of driver and target sequences, but also as sources of population cRNAs used in northern blots and differential Southern blots.

Improved differential screening approach to analyse transcriptional variations in organized cDNA libraries

A cDNA library was generated from rat brain tissues and organized into 1536-well plates, using a fluorescence activated cell sorter (FACS), acting as a single cell deposition system. The organized library containing 10,000 clones, with 60% full-length cDNA inserts, allowed the generation of multiple identical membrane replicas. Each replica was hybridized with a complex probe obtained from a particular brain tissue or a given cultured cell. The signal intensity for each of the clones present on the membrane, quantified with a standard image-analysis software, is proportional both to the abundance of the corresponding mRNA in the probe and to the amount of plasmid template on the membrane. The latter value was thus used to normalize the signals produced with complex probes, to optimize the comparison of mRNA expression levels for the different systems under study. The construction of high-quality cDNA libraries, the generation of identical membrane replicas and comparable probes, and the utilization of an image-analysis software package, coupled with the normalization of the spot intensity by assaying plasmid quantity, significantly improves the differential screening approach. Altogether, these technical improvements open the possibility to compare a great number of different probes and, in consequence, to accumulate biological information for each clone present in an organized cDNA library. The functional information obtained should complement data from DNA sequencing projects.

Multiplex display polymerase chain reaction amplifies and resolves related sequences sharing a single moderately conserved domain

We present a technique, multiplex display polymerase chain reaction (MD-PCR), that amplifies and resolves coding sequences from messenger RNAs sharing only a single moderately conserved domain encoding eight or nine amino acids. The technique, a form of single-sided PCR, allows detection of known and novel genes in a family by using one degenerate primer complementary to a gene family-specific domain. A second common primer is complementary to an oligonucleotide ligated to a nearby restriction enzyme cleavage site. Uniquely, restriction enzyme digestion of single-stranded cDNA, a technique never previously performed to useful advantage, is used to increase the specificity and sensitivity of the technique. Up to several hundred bases of coding sequence are amplified simultaneously from many (potentially from all) genes in a specific family, yielding products of different sizes from different genes, and allowing amplified products to be resolved electrophoretically. Typically, more than 50% of the amplified sequences are from the targeted gene family and many of the amplified products are novel sequences. mRNAs representing less than 1 in 100,000 messages can be detected. The method allows the focused yet open-ended examination of genes in families known to be important in both normal cellular homeostasis and the etiology of many diseases.

Differential display with carboxy-X-rhodamine-labeled primers and the selection of differentially amplified cDNA fragments without cloning

Differential display (DD) has been used extensively to detect differentially expressed genes. However, the low reproducibility of displayed bands makes verification by Northern blot difficult and the technique is labor-intensive. This report describes a fluorescent DD with a ROX (carboxy-X-rhodamine)-labeled anchor primer and a revised RT-PCR, utilizing AMV reverse transcriptase, a more thermostable reverse transcriptase than Mu-MLV, and optimized concentrations of dNTPs and of MgCl2. Our technique yielded clear fingerprints with high reproducibility. Further, we have developed a method of rapid screening to select the cDNA fragments of interest in excised bands from a polyacrylamide gel without cloning. This method consists of electrophoresis with an agarose gel containing a base-specific DNA ligand to separate the equally sized fragments differing in base composition, and side-by-side comparison of the reamplified products from the experimental and control lane. Most of the cDNA fragments selected by this protocol provided readable sequences by direct sequencing and were confirmed to exhibit differential expression by Northern blot analysis or semiquantitative RT-PCR.

Rapid determination of the complexity of cDNA bands extracted from DDRT-PCR polyacrylamide gels

A band extracted from a differential display polyacrylamide gel often represents a composite of heterogeneous products. We have developed a non- radioactive method to simply and rapidly analyse its complexity. A fluorescent restriction enzyme fingerprint of the composite mixture is generated. The number of individual bands observed in this fingerprint indicates the complexity of the re-amplified cDNA mixture. Restriction fingerprints of the inserts of cDNA subclones derived from the re-amplified cDNA mixture are compared to the composite fingerprint to select those representing the most intense bands in the composite. This dramatically reduces the number of clones required for further characterisation.