Encapsulated three-dimensional culture supports development of nonhuman primate secondary follicles

Non-human primate: the new frontier model of female reproductive engineering

Reproductive engineering encompasses a range of advanced tissue engineering techniques aimed at addressing infertility that is non-curable with current assisted reproductive technology (ART). The use of animal models has been crucial for these advancements, with a notable preference for non-human primates (NHPs) given their genetic, anatomical, and physiological similarities to humans. Therefore, NHPs are invaluable for studying reproductive engineering. Thus, in reproductive studies, NHPs bridge the anatomical and physiological gaps between rodent models and humans. Their shared features with humans, such as menstrual cycles, placentation, and hormonal regulation, allow for more accurate modeling of reproductive physiology and pathology. These traits make NHPs indispensable in the exploration of reproductive engineering, including infertility treatments, genetic engineering, and uterine transplantation. Reproductive engineering is a transformative field that addresses infertility and enhances reproductive health. By leveraging the unique traits of NHPs, researchers can deepen their understanding of reproductive processes and refine ART techniques for human use. Advances in genetic engineering have enabled the creation of transgenic NHP models, which have been used to modify genes to investigate roles for various purposes, and the process, as mentioned earlier, is closely related to the ART technique, including fertility, embryogenesis, and pregnancy. Therefore, the relation to reproductive studies and the necessity of the NHP model are prerequisites for reproductive engineering. The engineering of NHPs is critically related to integrating ethical practices and exploring complementary methodologies. This review overviews the types of NHP frequently used and studies using NHP for reproductive engineering. These studies may suggest a broader way to use NHP for reproductive engineering.

Hydrogel Strategies for Female Reproduction Dysfunction

Infertility is an important issue for human reproductive health, with over half of all cases of infertility associated with female factors. Dysfunction of the complex female reproductive system may cause infertility. In clinical practice, female infertility is often treated with oral medications and/or surgical procedures, and ultimately with assisted reproductive technologies. Owing to their excellent biocompatibility, low immunogenicity, and adjustable mechanical properties, hydrogels are emerging as valuable tools in the reconstruction of organ function, supplemented by tissue engineering techniques to increase their structure and functionality. Hydrogel-based female reproductive reconstruction strategies targeting the pathological mechanisms of female infertility may provide alternatives for the treatment of ovarian, endometrium/uterine, and fallopian tube dysfunction. In this review, we provide a general introduction to the basic physiology and pathology of the female reproductive system, the limitations of current infertility treatments, and the lack of translation from animal models to human reproductive physiology. We further provide an overview of the current and future potential applications of hydrogels in the treatment of female reproductive system dysfunction, highlighting the great prospects of hydrogel-based strategies in the field of translational medicine, along with the significant challenges to be overcome.

Follicle-intrinsic and spatially distinct molecular programs drive follicle rupture and luteinization during ex vivo mammalian ovulation

During ovulation, the apical wall of the preovulatory follicle breaks down to facilitate gamete release. In parallel, the residual follicle wall differentiates into a progesterone-producing corpus luteum. Disruption of ovulation, whether through contraceptive intervention or infertility, has implications for women's health. In this study, we harness the power of an ex vivo ovulation model and machine-learning guided microdissection to identify differences between the ruptured and unruptured sides of the follicle wall. We demonstrate that the unruptured side exhibits clear markers of luteinization after ovulation while the ruptured side exhibits cell death signals. RNA-sequencing of individual follicle sides reveals 2099 differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between follicle sides without ovulation induction, and 1673 DEGs 12 h after induction of ovulation. Our model validates molecular patterns consistent with known ovulation biology even though this process occurs in the absence of the ovarian stroma, vasculature, and immune cells. We further identify previously unappreciated pathways including amino acid transport and Jag-Notch signaling on the ruptured side and glycolysis, metal ion processing, and IL-11 signaling on the unruptured side of the follicle. This study yields key insights into follicle-inherent, spatially-defined pathways that underlie follicle rupture, which may further understanding of ovulation physiology and advance women's health.

Innovations in 3D ovarian and follicle engineering for fertility preservation and restoration

In-vitro maturation (IVM) is the process of cultivating early-stage follicles from the primordial to the antral stage and facilitating the maturation of oocytes outside the body within a supportive environment. This intricate procedure requires the careful coordination of various factors to replicate the natural ovarian conditions. Advanced techniques for IVM are designed to mimic the natural ovarian environment and enhance the development of follicles. Three-dimensional (3D) culture systems provide a more biologically relevant setting for follicle growth compared to traditional two-dimensional (2D) cultures. Traditional culture systems, often fail to support the complex process of follicle development effectively. However, modern engineered reproductive tissues and culture systems are making it possible to create increasingly physiological in-vitro models of folliculogenesis. These innovative methods are enabling researchers and clinicians to better replicate the dynamic and supportive environment of the ovary, thereby improving the outcomes of IVM offering new hope for fertility preservation and treatment. This paper focuses on the routine 3D culture, and innovative 3D culture of ovary and follicles, including a tissue engineering scaffolds, microfluidic (dynamic) culture system, organ-on-chip models, EVATAR system, from a clinical perspective to determine the most effective approach for achieving in-vitro maturation of follicles. These techniques provide critical support for ovarian function in various ovarian-associated disorders, including primary ovarian insufficiency (POI), premature ovarian failure (POF), ovarian cancer, and age-related infertility.

Three-dimensional culture in a bioengineered matrix and somatic cell complementation to improve growth and survival of bovine preantral follicles

Purpose

Here we explored poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) bioengineered hydrogels for bovine preantral follicle culture with or without ovarian cell co-culture and examined the potential for differentiation of bovine embryonic stem cells (bESCs) towards gonadal somatic cells to develop a system more similar to the ovarian microenvironment.

Methods

Bovine preantral follicles were first cultured in two-dimensional (2D) control or within PEG hydrogels (3D) and then co-cultured within PEG hydrogels with bovine ovarian cells (BOCs) to determine growth and viability. Finally, we tested conditions to drive differentiation of bESCs towards the intermediate mesoderm and bipotential gonad fate.

Results

Primary follicles grew over the 10-day culture period in PEG hydrogels compared to 2D control. Early secondary follicles maintained a similar diameter within the PEG while control follicles decreased in size. Follicles lost viability after co-encapsulation with BOCs; BOCs lost stromal cell signature over the culture period within hydrogels. Induction of bESCs towards gonadal somatic fate under WNT signaling was sufficient to upregulate intermediate mesoderm ( LHX1 ) and early coelomic epithelium/bipotential gonad markers ( OSR1 , GATA4 , WT1 ). Higher BMP4 concentrations upregulated the lateral plate mesoderm marker FOXF1 . PAX3 expression was not induced, indicating absence of the paraxial mesoderm lineage.

Conclusions

Culture of primary stage preantral follicles in PEG hydrogels promoted growth compared to controls; BOCs did not maintain identity in the PEG hydrogels. Collectively, we demonstrate that PEG hydrogels can be a potential culture system for early preantral follicles pending refinements, which could include addition of ESC-derived ovarian somatic cells using the protocol described here.

CAPSULE SUMMARY

We demonstrate that three-dimensional bioengineered hydrogels could aid in the survival and growth of small bovine preantral follicles. Moreover, bovine embryonic stem cells have the potential to differentiate towards precursors of somatic gonadal cell types, presenting an alternative cell source for preantral follicle co-culture.

Bioengineered 3D ovarian model for long-term multiple development of preantral follicle: bridging the gap for poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL)-based scaffold reproductive applications

BACKGROUND

Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ARTs) have been validated in human and animal to solve reproductive problems such as infertility, aging, genetic selection/amplification and diseases. The persistent gap in ART biomedical applications lies in recapitulating the early stage of ovarian folliculogenesis, thus providing protocols to drive the large reserve of immature follicles towards the gonadotropin-dependent phase. Tissue engineering is becoming a concrete solution to potentially recapitulate ovarian structure, mostly relying on the use of autologous early follicles on natural or synthetic scaffolds. Based on these premises, the present study has been designed to validate the use of the ovarian bioinspired patterned electrospun fibrous scaffolds fabricated with poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) for multiple preantral (PA) follicle development.

METHODS

PA follicles isolated from lamb ovaries were cultured on PCL scaffold adopting a validated single-follicle protocol (Ctrl) or simulating a multiple-follicle condition by reproducing an artificial ovary engrafted with 5 or 10 PA (AO5PA and AO10PA). The incubations were protracted for 14 and 18 days before assessing scaffold-based microenvironment suitability to assist in vitro folliculogenesis (ivF) and oogenesis at morphological and functional level.

RESULTS

The ivF outcomes demonstrated that PCL-scaffolds generate an appropriate biomimetic ovarian microenvironment supporting the transition of multiple PA follicles towards early antral (EA) stage by supporting follicle growth and steroidogenic activation. PCL-multiple bioengineering ivF (AO10PA) performed in long term generated, in addition, the greatest percentage of highly specialized gametes by enhancing meiotic competence, large chromatin remodeling and parthenogenetic developmental competence.

CONCLUSIONS

The study showcased the proof of concept for a next-generation ART use of PCL-patterned scaffold aimed to generate transplantable artificial ovary engrafted with autologous early-stage follicles or to advance ivF technologies holding a 3D bioinspired matrix promoting a physiological long-term multiple PA follicle protocol.

Three-Dimensionally Printed Agarose Micromold Supports Scaffold-Free Mouse Ex Vivo Follicle Growth, Ovulation, and Luteinization

Ex vivo follicle growth is an essential tool, enabling interrogation of folliculogenesis, ovulation, and luteinization. Though significant advancements have been made, existing follicle culture strategies can be technically challenging and laborious. In this study, we advanced the field through development of a custom agarose micromold, which enables scaffold-free follicle culture. We established an accessible and economical manufacturing method using 3D printing and silicone molding that generates biocompatible hydrogel molds without the risk of cytotoxicity from leachates. Each mold supports simultaneous culture of multiple multilayer secondary follicles in a single focal plane, allowing for constant timelapse monitoring and automated analysis. Mouse follicles cultured using this novel system exhibit significantly improved growth and ovulation outcomes with comparable survival, oocyte maturation, and hormone production profiles as established three-dimensional encapsulated in vitro follicle growth (eIVFG) systems. Additionally, follicles recapitulated aspects of in vivo ovulation physiology with respect to their architecture and spatial polarization, which has not been observed in eIVFG systems. This system offers simplicity, scalability, integration with morphokinetic analyses of follicle growth and ovulation, and compatibility with existing microphysiological platforms. This culture strategy has implications for fundamental follicle biology, fertility preservation strategies, reproductive toxicology, and contraceptive drug discovery.

Strategies for developing 3D printed ovarian model for restoring fertility

Ovaries play a crucial role in the regulation of numerous essential processes that occur within the intricate framework of female physiology. They are entrusted with the responsibility of both generating a new life and orchestrating a delicate hormonal symphony. Understanding their functioning is crucial for gaining insight into the complexities of reproduction, health, and fertility. In addition, ovaries secrete hormones that are crucial for both secondary sexual characteristics and the maintenance of overall health. A three-dimensional (3D) prosthetic ovary has the potential to restore ovarian function and preserve fertility in younger females who have undergone ovariectomies or are afflicted with ovarian malfunction. Clinical studies have not yet commenced, and the production of 3D ovarian tissue for human implantation is still in the research phase. The main challenges faced while creating a 3D ovary for in vivo implantation include sustenance of ovarian follicles, achieving vascular infiltration into the host tissue, and restoring hormone circulation. The complex ovarian microenvironment that is compartmentalized and rigid makes the biomimicking of the 3D ovary challenging in terms of biomaterial selection and bioink composition. The successful restoration of these properties in animal models has led to expectations for the development of human ovaries for implantation. This review article summarizes and evaluates the optimal 3D models of ovarian structures and their safety and efficacy concerns to provide concrete suggestions for future research.

Establishing a 3D-cultured system based on alginate-hydrogel embedding benefits the in vitro maturation of porcine Oocytes

The in vitro maturation (IVM) quality of oocytes is directly related to the subsequent developmental potential of embryos and a fundamental of in vitro embryo production. However, conventional IVM methods fail to maintain the gap-junction intercellular communication (GJIC) between cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs), which leads to insufficient oocyte maturation. Herein, we investigated the effects of three different three-dimensional (3D) culture methods on oocyte development in vitro, optimized of the alginate-hydrogel embedding method, and assessed the effects of the alginate-hydrogel embedding method on subsequent embryonic developmental potential of oocytes after IVM and parthenogenetic activation (PA). The results showed that Matrigel embedding and alginate-hydrogel embedding benefited the embryonic developmental potential of oocytes after IVM and PA. With the further optimization of alginate-hydrogel embedding, including crosslinking and decrosslinking of parameters, we established a 3D culture system that can significantly increase oocyte maturation and the blastocyst rate of embryos after PA (27.2 ± 1.5 vs 36.7 ± 2.8, P < 0.05). This 3D culture system produced oocytes with markedly increased mitochondrial intensity and membrane potential, which reduced the abnormalities of spindle formation and cortical granule distribution. The alginate-hydrogel embedding system can also remarkably enhance the GJIC between COCs. In summary, based on alginate-hydrogel embedding, we established a 3D culture system that can improve the IVM quality of porcine oocytes, possibly by enhancing GJIC.

In Vitro Growth of Human Follicles: Current and Future Perspectives

Ovarian tissue cryopreservation is gaining importance as a successful method to restore fertility to girls and young women at high risk of sterility. However, there are concerns regarding the safety of transplantation after ovarian tissue cryopreservation due to the high risk of reintroducing cancer cells and causing disease recurrence. In these cases, the development of culture systems that support oocyte development from the primordial follicle stage is required. Notable achievements have been reached in human follicle in vitro growth in the past decade. Currently, systems for the in vitro culture of ovarian tissue are based on two-dimensional substrates that do not support the survival of follicles or recapitulate the mechanical heterogenicity in the mammalian ovary. Recognition of the importance of special arrangements between cells has spurred research in three-dimensional culture systems, and the provision of a precise culture system that maximizes the diffusion of nutrients and gases through the follicles has raised interest in advanced biomimetic models. The current review critically examines various culture systems employed for the in vitro development of follicles, with a particular focus on solutions utilizing Organ-on-a-Chip (OOC) technology. The emphasis on OOC technology underscores its role as a promising avenue in ensuring the successful cultivation and maintenance of follicular structures during the culture period.

Current progress on in vitro differentiation of ovarian follicles from pluripotent stem cells

Mammalian female reproduction requires a functional ovary. Competence of the ovary is determined by the quality of its basic unit-ovarian follicles. A normal follicle consists of an oocyte enclosed within ovarian follicular cells. In humans and mice, the ovarian follicles are formed at the foetal and the early neonatal stage respectively, and their renewal at the adult stage is controversial. Extensive research emerges recently to produce ovarian follicles in-vitro from different species. Previous reports demonstrated the differentiation of mouse and human pluripotent stem cells into germline cells, termed primordial germ cell-like cells (PGCLCs). The germ cell-specific gene expressions and epigenetic features including global DNA demethylation and histone modifications of the pluripotent stem cells-derived PGCLCs were extensively characterized. The PGCLCs hold potential for forming ovarian follicles or organoids upon cocultured with ovarian somatic cells. Intriguingly, the oocytes isolated from the organoids could be fertilized in-vitro. Based on the knowledge of in-vivo derived pre-granulosa cells, the generation of these cells from pluripotent stem cells termed foetal ovarian somatic cell-like cells was also reported recently. Despite successful in-vitro folliculogenesis from pluripotent stem cells, the efficiency remains low, mainly due to the lack of information on the interaction between PGCLCs and pre-granulosa cells. The establishment of in-vitro pluripotent stem cell-based models paves the way for understanding the critical signalling pathways and molecules during folliculogenesis. This article aims to review the developmental events during in-vivo follicular development and discuss the current progress of generation of PGCLCs, pre-granulosa and theca cells in-vitro.

A Critical Review on Classified Excipient Sodium-Alginate-Based Hydrogels: Modification, Characterization, and Application in Soft Tissue Engineering

Alginates are polysaccharides that are produced naturally and can be isolated from brown sea algae and bacteria. Sodium alginate (SA) is utilized extensively in the field of biological soft tissue repair and regeneration owing to its low cost, high biological compatibility, and quick and moderate crosslinking. In addition to their high printability, SA hydrogels have found growing popularity in tissue engineering, particularly due to the advent of 3D bioprinting. There is a developing curiosity in tissue engineering with SA-based composite hydrogels and their potential for further improvement in terms of material modification, the molding process, and their application. This has resulted in numerous productive outcomes. The use of 3D scaffolds for growing cells and tissues in tissue engineering and 3D cell culture is an innovative technique for developing in vitro culture models that mimic the in vivo environment. Especially compared to in vivo models, in vitro models were more ethical and cost-effective, and they stimulate tissue growth. This article discusses the use of sodium alginate (SA) in tissue engineering, focusing on SA modification techniques and providing a comparative examination of the properties of several SA-based hydrogels. This review also covers hydrogel preparation techniques, and a catalogue of patents covering different hydrogel formulations is also discussed. Finally, SA-based hydrogel applications and future research areas concerning SA-based hydrogels in tissue engineering were examined.

Current Trends on Bioengineering Approaches for Ovarian Microenvironment Reconstruction

Ovarian tissue has a unique microarchitecture and a complex cellular and molecular dynamics that are essential for follicular survival and development. Due to this great complexity, several factors may lead to ovarian insufficiency, and therefore to systemic metabolic disorders and female infertility. Techniques currently used in the reproductive clinic such as oocyte cryopreservation or even ovarian tissue transplant, although effective, have several limitations, which impair their wide application. In this scenario, mimetic ovarian tissue reconstruction comes as an innovative alternative to develop new methodologies for germ cells preservation and ovarian functions restoration. The ovarian extracellular matrix (ECM) is crucial for oocyte viability maintenance, once it acts actively in folliculogenesis. One of the key components of ovarian bioengineering is biomaterials application that mimics ECM and provides conditions for cell anchorage, proliferation, and differentiation. Therefore, this review aims at describing ovarian tissue engineering approaches and listing the main limitations of current methods for preservation and reestablishment of ovarian fertility. In addition, we describe the main elements that structure this study field, highlighting the main advances and the challenges to overcome to develop innovative methodologies to be applied in reproductive medicine. Impact Statement This review presents the main advances in the application of tissue bioengineering in the ovarian tissue reconstruction to develop innovative solutions for ovarian fertility reestablishment.

Determination of the appropriate concentration of sodium alginate used for in vitro culture of cat preantral follicles in a serum-free medium containing FSH, EGF and IGF-I

Culture of domestic cat preantral follicles can be a suitable technology to assist oocyte conservation strategies in the family Felidae. This research was aimed to comparatively analyse cat preantral follicular development of follicles directly seeded on growth surface or encapsulated in 0.5 or 1% of sodium alginate in a serum-free medium containing FSH, EGF and IGF-I. Preantral follicles were isolated from cat ovarian cortical tissue after ovariectomy. Alginate was dissolved at 0.5 or 1% in PBS. Follicles, 4 per well, with 0% (G-0%), 0.5% (G-0.5%) or 1% (G-1%) of sodium alginate were cultured in M199 with FSH (100 ng/mL), EGF (100 ng/mL) and IGF-I (100 ng/mL) for 7 days at 37°C, 5% CO₂ and 99% humidity. Culture medium was replaced every 48 h and samples were stored at -20°C until ELISA of steroid hormones. Morphometric evaluation of follicles was performed every 24 h. G-0% follicles showed granulosa cell migration away from the oocyte and disrupted morphology, whereby they reached apparently larger diameters (203.70 ± 5.82 μm; p < .05) than G-0.5% and G-1% follicles (157.89 ± 8.47 μm and 95.23 ± 1.67 μm, respectively) which maintained three-dimensional organization, being larger in G-0.5% than in G-1% (p < .05). G-0.5% follicles attained the multi-layer preantral follicle stage on day 7 of culture, whereas G-1% follicles underwent progressive atresia. On day 6, steroid concentrations were higher (p < .05) in G-0% than in G-1%: 60 ± 19 vs 0.88 ± 0.32 pg/mL oestradiol; 2.6 ± 0.84 vs 0.04 ± 0.02 ng/mL progesterone; 1.3 ± 0.22 vs 0.61 ± 0.04 ng/mL testosterone and 1.6 ± 0.54 vs 0.22 ± 0.07 ng/mL androstenedione respectively. Steroid concentrations in G-0.5% were comprised between those of G-0% and G-1% (p > .05). In conclusion, two-layer cat preantral follicles encapsulated in 0.5% alginate cultured in medium containing FSH, EGF and IGF-I can develop up to the multi-layer preantral stage in 7 days of culture, whereas follicles directly seeded on growth surface or encapsulated in 1% alginate lost their three-dimensional organization, and experienced regression with compromised steroidogenesis, respectively.

Recapitulating folliculogenesis and oogenesis outside the body: encapsulated in vitro follicle growth†

Folliculogenesis is a tightly coordinated process essential for generating a fertilization-competent gamete while also producing gonadal hormones that sustain endocrine function. In vitro follicle growth systems have been critical to our understanding of key events in folliculogenesis, such as gonadotropin-independent and dependent growth, steroid hormone production, and oocyte growth and maturation (cytoplasmic and meiotic). Although there are several successful follicle culture strategies, the following protocol details an encapsulated in vitro follicle growth (eIVFG) system for use with mouse ovarian follicles. Encapsulated IVFG is performed with alginate hydrogels, which are biologically inert, maintains cell-to-cell interactions between granulosa cells and the oocyte, and preserves follicle architecture as found in the ovary. The system supports follicle growth, development, and differentiation from the early primary follicle to the antral follicle stage. Moreover, post-folliculogenesis events including meiotic maturation, ovulation, and luteinization are also supported. Importantly, the culture of secondary follicles has successfully resulted in viable pups after blastocyst transfer. This alginate-based eIVFG system is versatile and has broad applications as a tool for interrogating the fundamental biology of the ovarian follicle in a controlled manner, a screening platform for toxicity and bioactivity, and a potential fertility preservation method for endangered species as well as humans.

A bioengineered in situ ovary (ISO) supports follicle engraftment and live-births post-chemotherapy

Female cancer patients who have undergone chemotherapy have an elevated risk of developing ovarian dysfunction and failure. Experimental approaches to treat iatrogenic infertility are evolving rapidly; however, challenges and risks remain that hinder clinical translation. Biomaterials have improved in vitro follicle maturation and in vivo transplantation in mice, but there has only been marginal success for early-stage human follicles. Here, we developed methods to obtain an ovarian-specific extracellular matrix hydrogel to facilitate follicle delivery and establish an in situ ovary (ISO), which offers a permissive environment to enhance follicle survival. We demonstrate sustainable follicle engraftment, natural pregnancy, and the birth of healthy pups after intraovarian microinjection of isolated exogenous follicles into chemotherapy-treated (CTx) mice. Our results confirm that hydrogel-based follicle microinjection could offer a minimally invasive delivery platform to enhance follicle integration for patients post-chemotherapy.

Three-Dimensional Culture for In Vitro Folliculogenesis in the Aspect of Methods and Materials

In vitro ovarian follicle culture is a reproduction technique used to obtain fertilizable oocytes, for overcoming fertility issues due to premature ovarian failure. This requires the establishment of an in vitro culture model that is capable of better simulating the in vivo ovarian growth environment. Two-dimensional (2D) culture systems have been successfully set up in rodent models. However, they are not suitable for larger animal models as the follicles of larger animals cultured in 2D culture systems often lose their shape due to dysfunction in the gap junctions. Three-dimensional (3D) culture systems are more suitable for maintaining follicle architecture, and therefore are proposed for the successful in vitro culturing of follicles in various animal models. The role of different methods, scaffolds, and suspension cultures in supporting follicle development has been studied to provide direction for improving in vitro follicle culture technologies. The three major strategies for in vitro 3D follicle cultures are discussed in this article. First, the in vitro culture systems, such as microfluidics, hanging drop, hydrogels, and 3D-printing, are reviewed. We have focused on the 3D hydrogel system as it uses different materials for supporting follicular growth and oocyte maturation in several animal models and in humans. We have also discussed the criteria used for biomaterial evaluations such as solid concentration, elasticity, and rigidity. In addition, future research directions for advancing in vitro 3D follicle culture system are discussed. Impact statement A new frontier in assisted reproductive technology is in vitro tissue or follicle culture, particularly for fertility preservation. The in vitro three-dimensional (3D) culture technique enhances follicular development and provides mature oocytes, overcoming the limitations of traditional in vitro two-dimensional cultures. Polymer biomaterials have good compatibility and retain the physiological structure of follicles in the 3D culture system. Utilizing hybrid in vitro culture materials by merging matrix, hydrogel, and unique patterned materials may facilitate follicular growth in the future.

Advanced bioengineering of female germ cells to preserve fertility

Oogenesis and folliculogenesis are considered as complex and species-specific cellular differentiation processes, which depend on the in vivo ovarian follicular environment and endocrine cues. Considerable efforts have been devoted to driving the differentiation of female primordial germ cells toward mature oocytes outside of the body. The recent experimental attempts have laid stress on offering a suitable microenvironment to assist the in vitro folliculogenesis and oogenesis. Despite developing a variety of bioengineering techniques and generating functional mature gametes through in vitro oogenesis in earlier studies, we still lack knowledge of appropriate microenvironment conditions for building biomimetic culture systems for female fertility preservation. Therefore, this review paper can provide a source for a large body of scientists developing cutting-edge in vitro culture systems for female germ cells or setting up the next generation of reproductive medicine as feasible options for female infertility treatment. The focal point of this review outlines advanced bioengineering technologies such as 3D biofabricated hydrogels/scaffolds and microfluidic systems utilized with female germlines for fertility preservation through in vitro folliculogenesis and oogenesis.

New hyaluronan-based biomatrix for 3-D follicle culture yields functionally competent oocytes

BACKGROUND

Encapsulation of follicles within a biomatrix is one approach to maintaining 3-D follicle architecture during culture. Hyaluronan is one component of the natural extracellular matrix (ECM) that provides support to cells in vivo. This report describes the application of a novel tyramine-linked hyaluronan for 3-D in vitro follicle culture and the production of developmentally competent metaphase II oocytes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Enzymatically isolated mouse preantral follicles or follicle clusters (FL-C) from fresh or vitrified ovaries were encapsulated in 3 mg/ml of hyaluronan gel (HA). Follicle growth, antrum formation and meiotic maturation to metaphase II oocytes was monitored. Chromatin staining was used to assess GV oocyte progression towards meiotic competence. Functional competence of in vitro matured (IVM) oocytes was evaluated by in vitro fertilization and ability to develop to blastocyst. Modifying the HA gel by inclusion of laminin (HA-LM), mouse sarcoma extracellular matrix (Matrigel;HA-MG) or placental extracellular matrix (HA-PM) was also tested to see if this might further enhance IVM outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 402 preantral follicles were cultured in HA gel. After hCG trigger, 314 oocyte-cumulus complexes ovulated from the embedded follicles. Meiotic maturation rate to the metaphase II stage was 73% (228/314). After insemination 83% (188/228) of IVM oocytes fertilized with a subsequent blastulation rate of 46% (87/188). A pilot transfer study with 3 recipient mice resulted in the birth of a single pup. HA gel supported individually isolated follicles as well ovarian tissue fragments containing clusters of 6-8 preantral follicles. Meiotic maturation was lower with FL-clusters from vitrified versus fresh ovaries (34% and 55%, respectively; p < 0.007). Modification of the HA gel with ECMs or laminin affected antrum formation and follicle retention. Maturation rates to the metaphase II stage were however not significantly different: 74% for HA gel alone as compared to HA-LM (67%), HA-MG (56%) and HA-PM (58%).

CONCLUSION

Hyaluronan gel is an effective and versatile extracellular matrix based biomaterial for 3-D culture of ovarian follicles. This culture model allowed ovulation of functionally competent metaphase II oocytes, capable of fertilization, genomic activation and blastulation. Future testing with human follicles that require longer in vitro culture times should be considered.

Follicle isolation methods reveal plasticity of granulosa cell steroidogenic capacity during mouse in vitro follicle growth

Follicles are the functional unit of the ovary and several methods have been developed to grow follicles ex vivo, which recapitulate key events of oogenesis and folliculogenesis. Enzymatic digestion protocols are often used to increase the yield of follicles from the ovary. However, the impact of these protocols on the outermost theca and granulosa cells, and thereby follicle function, is not well defined. To investigate the impact of enzymatic digestion on follicle function, we collected preantral follicles from CD1 mice either by enzymatic digestion (Enzy-FL) or mechanical isolation (Mech-FL) and compared follicle growth, steroidogenesis and cell differentiation within an encapsulated in vitro follicle growth system which maintains the 3D architecture of the oocyte and its surrounding somatic cells. Follicles were encapsulated in 0.5% alginate and cultured for 8 days. Compared with Enzy-FL, Mech-FL grew more rapidly and produced significantly higher levels of androstenedione, estradiol and progesterone. The expression of theca-interstitial cell marker genes, Cyp17a1, which encodes 17-hydroxylase/17, 20-lyase and catalyzes the hydroxylation of pregnenolone and progesterone to 17-hydroxypregnenolone and 17-hydroxyprogesterone, and the conversion of these products into dehydroepiandrosterone and androstenedione, and Star, which encodes a transport protein essential for cholesterol entry into mitochondria, were also higher in Mech-FL than in Enzy-FL. Mech-FL maintained an intact theca-interstitial layer on the outer edge of the follicle that phenocopied in vivo patterns as confirmed by alkaline phosphatase staining, whereas theca-interstitial cells were absent from Enzy-FL from the onset of culture. Therefore, preservation of the theca cell layer at the onset of culture better supports follicle growth and function. Interestingly, granulosa cells in the outermost layers of Enzy-FL expressed CYP17A1 by Day 4 of culture while maintaining inhibin α-subunit expression and a cuboidal nucleus. Thus, in the absence of theca-interstitial cells, granulosa cells have the potential to differentiate into androgen-producing cells. This work may have implications for human follicle culture, where enzymatic isolation is required owing to the density of the ovarian cortex.

Biomaterials and advanced technologies for the evaluation and treatment of ovarian aging

Ovarian aging is characterized by a progressive decline in ovarian function. With the increase in life expectancy worldwide, ovarian aging has gradually become a key health problem among women. Over the years, various strategies have been developed to preserve fertility in women, while there are currently no clinical treatments to delay ovarian aging. Recently, advances in biomaterials and technologies, such as three-dimensional (3D) printing and microfluidics for the encapsulation of follicles and nanoparticles as delivery systems for drugs, have shown potential to be translational strategies for ovarian aging. This review introduces the research progress on the mechanisms underlying ovarian aging, and summarizes the current state of biomaterials in the evaluation and treatment of ovarian aging, including safety, potential applications, future directions and difficulties in translation.

Effects of IGF-1 on the Three-Dimensional Culture of Ovarian Preantral Follicles and Superovulation Rates in Mice

Insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) plays a crucial role during folliculogenesis, which has been demonstrated by previous research. However, the optimal IGF-1 dosage in the three-dimensional (3D) culture system is unknown. Mouse secondary follicles (140−150 µm) were cultured for 6 days within an alginate bead in a medium supplemented with 0 (G0), 5 ng/mL (G5), 10 ng/mL (G10), or 50 ng/mL IGF-1 (G50). Secretions of 17β-estradiol and progesterone were significantly increased in G10 and G50 (p < 0.05). However, G50 significantly inhibited follicular growth (p < 0.05), while G10 showed a higher oocyte maturation rate. Thus, the 10 ng/mL IGF-1 was used in subsequent experiments. IGF-1 enhanced the function of granulosa cells (GCs) by upregulating expressions of Star, Cyp19a1, Hsd3b1, Fshr, and Lhcgr. Oocyte secretory function was promoted by upregulating expressions of Bmp-15, Gdf-9, and Fgf-8. Addition of IGF-1 showed anti-apoptotic effect. However, G10 did not improve fertilization rate of MII oocytes compared to G0. In an intraperitoneal injection experiment in mice, IGF-1 significantly increased the number of ovulated oocytes (p < 0.05). In conclusion, 10 ng/mL IGF-1 can promote the production of mature oocytes in the 3D culture medium and injection of IGF-1 before superovulation increases the number of ovulated oocytes.

Therapeutic Potential of In Vitro-Derived Oocytes for the Restoration and Treatment of Female Fertility

Considerable progress has been made with the development of culture systems for the in vitro growth and maturation (IVGM) of oocytes from the earliest-staged primordial follicles and from the more advanced secondary follicles in rodents, ruminants, nonhuman primates, and humans. Successful oocyte production in vitro depends on the development of a dynamic culture strategy that replicates the follicular microenvironment required for oocyte activation and to support oocyte growth and maturation in vivo while enabling the coordinated and timely acquisition of oocyte developmental competence. Significant heterogeneity exists between the culture protocols used for different stages of follicle development and for different species. To date, the fertile potential of IVGM oocytes derived from primordial follicles has been realized only in mice. Although many technical challenges remain, significant advances have been made, and there is an increasing consensus that complete IVGM will require a dynamic, multiphase culture approach. The production of healthy offspring from in vitro-produced oocytes in a secondary large animal species is a vital next step before IVGM can be tested for therapeutic use in humans.

Effects of Androgen Excess-Related Metabolic Disturbances on Granulosa Cell Function and Follicular Development

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is a common reproductive endocrine disease in women of reproductive age. Ovarian dysfunction including abnormal steroid hormone synthesis and follicular arrest play a vital role in PCOS pathogenesis. Hyperandrogenemia is one of the important characteristics of PCOS. However, the mechanism of regulation and interaction between hyperandrogenism and ovulation abnormalities are not clear. To investigate androgen-related metabolic state in granulosa cells of PCOS patients, we identified the transcriptome characteristics of PCOS granulosa cells by RNA-seq. Gene ontology (GO) and Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) analysis of differentially expressed genes (DEGs) revealed that genes enriched in lipid metabolism pathway, fatty acid biosynthetic process and ovarian steroidogenesis pathway were abnormally expressed in PCOS granulosa cells in comparison with that in control. There are close interactions among these three pathways as identified by analysis of the protein-protein interaction (PPI) network of DEGs. Furthermore, in vitro mouse follicle culture system was established to explore the effect of high androgen and its related metabolic dysfunction on follicular growth and ovulation. RT-qPCR results showed that follicles cultured with dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) exhibited decreased expression levels of cumulus expansion-related genes (Has2, Ptx3, Tnfaip6 and Adamts1) and oocyte maturation-related genes (Gdf9 and Bmp15), which may be caused by impaired steroid hormone synthesis and lipid metabolism, thus inhibited follicular development and ovulation. Furthermore, the inhibition effect of DHEA on follicle development and ovulation was ameliorated by flutamide, an androgen receptor (AR) antagonist, suggesting the involvement of AR signaling. In summary, our study offers new insights into understanding the role of androgen excess induced granulosa cell metabolic disorder in ovarian dysfunction of PCOS patients.

OUP accepted manuscript

BACKGROUND

To provide the optimal milieu for implantation and fetal development, the female reproductive system must orchestrate uterine dynamics with the appropriate hormones produced by the ovaries. Mature oocytes may be fertilized in the fallopian tubes, and the resulting zygote is transported toward the uterus, where it can implant and continue developing. The cervix acts as a physical barrier to protect the fetus throughout pregnancy, and the vagina acts as a birth canal (involving uterine and cervix mechanisms) and facilitates copulation. Fertility can be compromised by pathologies that affect any of these organs or processes, and therefore, being able to accurately model them or restore their function is of paramount importance in applied and translational research. However, innate differences in human and animal model reproductive tracts, and the static nature of 2D cell/tissue culture techniques, necessitate continued research and development of dynamic and more complex in vitro platforms, ex vivo approaches and in vivo therapies to study and support reproductive biology. To meet this need, bioengineering is propelling the research on female reproduction into a new dimension through a wide range of potential applications and preclinical models, and the burgeoning number and variety of studies makes for a rapidly changing state of the field.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This review aims to summarize the mounting evidence on bioengineering strategies, platforms and therapies currently available and under development in the context of female reproductive medicine, in order to further understand female reproductive biology and provide new options for fertility restoration. Specifically, techniques used in, or for, the uterus (endometrium and myometrium), ovary, fallopian tubes, cervix and vagina will be discussed.

SEARCH METHODS

A systematic search of full-text articles available in PubMed and Embase databases was conducted to identify relevant studies published between January 2000 and September 2021. The search terms included: bioengineering, reproduction, artificial, biomaterial, microfluidic, bioprinting, organoid, hydrogel, scaffold, uterus, endometrium, ovary, fallopian tubes, oviduct, cervix, vagina, endometriosis, adenomyosis, uterine fibroids, chlamydia, Asherman’s syndrome, intrauterine adhesions, uterine polyps, polycystic ovary syndrome and primary ovarian insufficiency. Additional studies were identified by manually searching the references of the selected articles and of complementary reviews. Eligibility criteria included original, rigorous and accessible peer-reviewed work, published in English, on female reproductive bioengineering techniques in preclinical (in vitro/in vivo/ex vivo) and/or clinical testing phases.

OUTCOMES

Out of the 10 390 records identified, 312 studies were included for systematic review. Owing to inconsistencies in the study measurements and designs, the findings were assessed qualitatively rather than by meta-analysis. Hydrogels and scaffolds were commonly applied in various bioengineering-related studies of the female reproductive tract. Emerging technologies, such as organoids and bioprinting, offered personalized diagnoses and alternative treatment options, respectively. Promising microfluidic systems combining various bioengineering approaches have also shown translational value.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

The complexity of the molecular, endocrine and tissue-level interactions regulating female reproduction present challenges for bioengineering approaches to replace female reproductive organs. However, interdisciplinary work is providing valuable insight into the physicochemical properties necessary for reproductive biological processes to occur. Defining the landscape of reproductive bioengineering technologies currently available and under development for women can provide alternative models for toxicology/drug testing, ex vivo fertility options, clinical therapies and a basis for future organ regeneration studies.

Equine Chorionic Gonadotropin as an Effective FSH Replacement for In Vitro Ovine Follicle and Oocyte Development

The use of assisted reproductive technologies (ART) still requires strategies through which to maximize individual fertility chances. In vitro folliculogenesis (ivF) may represent a valid option to convey the large source of immature oocytes in ART. Several efforts have been made to set up ivF cultural protocols in medium-sized mammals, starting with the identification of the most suitable gonadotropic stimulus. In this study, Equine Chorionic Gonadotropin (eCG) is proposed as an alternative to Follicle Stimulating Hormone (FSH) based on its long superovulation use, trans-species validation, long half-life, and low costs. The use of 3D ivF on single-ovine preantral (PA) follicles allowed us to compare the hormonal effects and to validate their influence under two different cultural conditions. The use of eCG helped to stimulate the in vitro growth of ovine PA follicles by maximizing its influence under FBS-free medium. Higher performance of follicular growth, antrum formation, steroidogenic activity and gap junction marker expression were recorded. In addition, eCG, promoted a positive effect on the germinal compartment, leading to a higher incidence of meiotic competent oocytes. These findings should help to widen the use of eCG to ivF as a valid and largely available hormonal support enabling a synchronized in vitro follicle and oocyte development.

In Vitro Folliculogenesis in Mammalian Models: A Computational Biology Study

In vitro folliculogenesis (ivF) has been proposed as an emerging technology to support follicle growth and oocyte development. It holds a great deal of attraction from preserving human fertility to improving animal reproductive biotechnology. Despite the mice model, where live offspring have been achieved,in medium-sized mammals, ivF has not been validated yet. Thus, the employment of a network theory approach has been proposed for interpreting the large amount of ivF information collected to date in different mammalian models in order to identify the controllers of the in vitro system. The WoS-derived data generated a scale-free network, easily navigable including 641 nodes and 2089 links. A limited number of controllers (7.2%) are responsible for network robustness by preserving it against random damage. The network nodes were stratified in a coherent biological manner on three layers: the input was composed of systemic hormones and somatic-oocyte paracrine factors; the intermediate one recognized mainly key signaling molecules such as PI3K, KL, JAK-STAT, SMAD4, and cAMP; and the output layer molecules were related to functional ivF endpoints such as the FSH receptor and steroidogenesis. Notably, the phenotypes of knock-out mice previously developed for hub.BN indirectly corroborate their biological relevance in early folliculogenesis. Finally, taking advantage of the STRING analysis approach, further controllers belonging to the metabolic axis backbone were identified, such as mTOR/FOXO, FOXO3/SIRT1, and VEGF, which have been poorly considered in ivF to date. Overall, this in silico study identifies new metabolic sensor molecules controlling ivF serving as a basis for designing innovative diagnostic and treatment methods to preserve female fertility.

Advancements in Microfluidic Systems for the Study of Female Reproductive Biology

The female reproductive tract is a highly complex physiological system that consists of the ovaries, fallopian tubes, uterus, cervix, and vagina. An enhanced understanding of the molecular, cellular, and genetic mechanisms of the tract will allow for the development of more effective assisted reproductive technologies, therapeutics, and screening strategies for female specific disorders. Traditional 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional static culture systems may not always reflect the cellular and physical contexts or physicochemical microenvironment necessary to understand the dynamic exchange that is crucial for the functioning of the reproductive system. Microfluidic systems present a unique opportunity to study the female reproductive tract, as these systems recapitulate the multicellular architecture, contacts between different tissues, and microenvironmental cues that largely influence cell structure, function, behavior, and growth. This review discusses examples, challenges, and benefits of using microfluidic systems to model ovaries, fallopian tubes, endometrium, and placenta. Additionally, this review also briefly discusses the use of these systems in studying the effects of endocrine disrupting chemicals and diseases such as ovarian cancer, preeclampsia, and polycystic ovarian syndrome.

Ageing and chronic disease-related changes in the morphometric characteristics of ovarian follicles in cynomolgus monkeys (Macaca fascicularis)

STUDY QUESTION

How is the localisation of ovarian follicles affected by ageing and chronic diseases?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Ovarian follicles shift deeper towards the medulla, due to thickening of the tunica albuginea (TA), with ageing and some major common chronic diseases.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

The ovary undergoes morphological and functional changes with ageing. The follicular pool follows these changes with alterations in the amount and distribution of residual follicles. Diseases causing a chronic inflammatory process are associated with morphological changes and impaired ovarian function.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

We conducted a cross-sectional study, examining 90 ovaries from 90 female monkeys. The samples were collected from April 2018 to March 2019 at Tsukuba Primate Research Center in National Institutes of Biomedical Innovation, Health and Nutrition, Japan.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Ovarian samples were obtained from cynomolgus monkeys that died from natural causes or were euthanised. Ovarian sections were stained with haematoxylin and eosin (H&E) for histological analyses. In ovarian sections from 64 female macaques aged 0-25 years, a total of 13 743 follicles at different developmental stages (primordial, intermediary, primary, early secondary and late secondary) were assessed to determine the depth of each follicle from the outer surface of the ovarian cortex to the far end of the follicle, by using a digital imaging software. TA thickness was measured as sum of basal membrane and tunica collagen layer for each ovary under H&E staining. To explore the possibility of age-related trends in ovarian morphometric characteristics, samples were divided into four different age groups (0-3 years (pre-menarche), 4-9 years, 10-14 years and 15-20 years). To evaluate the effect of common chronic diseases on ovarian morphometric characteristics, macaques with diabetes mellitus (DM) (n = 10), endometriosis (n = 8) or inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) (n = 8) were compared to age-matched controls without chronic diseases.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Ovarian morphometric analysis revealed that the relative location of follicles became deeper in all age groups according to development of follicles (P < 0.05). Total follicle distance from the ovarian surface was increased with ageing (P < 0.05). In a sub-analysis according to developmental stage, only primordial and intermediary follicles were localised deeper with increasing age (P < 0.05). TA thickness was also increased with ageing (P < 0.05). The localisation of the total number of follicles became deeper in ovaries from monkeys with DM, endometriosis or IBD as compared to the control group (P < 0.05). With DM, analysis of follicles distance at almost each developmental stage was significantly deeper compared to controls (P < 0.05) with the exception of early secondary follicles. With endometriosis, follicles at primary and early and late secondary stages were significantly deeper compared to controls (P < 0.05). Also with IBD, follicles at primary and early and late secondary follicles were significantly deeper compared to controls (P < 0.001). The TA was thicker with DM and endometriosis compared to controls (P < 0.05), but not with IBD (P = 0.16).

LARGE SCALE DATA

NA.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

Two-dimensional histology was used to assess follicle localisation. The possibility of minimal variations between the measured distance to the actual distance in a spherical structure cannot be excluded. Additionally, the severity of disease was not assessed.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study is the first step towards enhancing our understanding of how ageing and chronic diseases affect the relative localisation of dormant and developing follicles. These observations, combined with possible future human studies, may have managerial implications in the field of fertility preservation and other conditions involving ovarian tissue cryopreservation.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

The present work was supported by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research B (19H03801) (to K.K.), Challenging Exploratory Research (18K19624), Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development, Mochida Memorial Foundation for Medical and Pharmaceutical Research, Takeda Science Foundation and Naito Foundation (to K.K.). All authors have no conflicts of interest directly relevant to the content of this article.

Advances in the applications of polymer biomaterials for in vitro follicle culture

The ovarian reserve (OR) indicates ovarian function by representing the quantity and quality of ovarian follicles, and it gradually decreases with increasing age. With the prolongation of women's lives, the protection provided by estrogen is lost for decades in postmenopausal women, and the related cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases, osteoporosis, and decreased immunity are the main risk factors affecting women's quality of life and longevity. Pharmacologic hormone replacement therapy (PHRT) has been controversial, and the construction of artificial ovary (AO) has attracted increasing attention. The most critical step of AO generation is the establishment of an in vitro culture (IVC) system to support the development of isolated follicles. This article mainly compares the advantages and disadvantages of different polymer biomaterials for use in follicle IVC, provides theoretical support for the development and construction of the follicle IVC system using natural biological materials, and provides a theoretical basis for establishing mature AO technology.

Recent Advancements in Engineered Biomaterials for the Regeneration of Female Reproductive Organs

Various gynecologic diseases and chemoradiation or surgery for the management of gynecologic malignancies may damage the uterus and ovaries, leading to clinical problems such as infertility or early menopause. Embryo or oocyte cryopreservation-the standard method for fertility preservation-is not a feasible option for patients who require urgent treatment because the procedure requires ovarian stimulation for at least several days. Hormone replacement therapy (HRT) for patients diagnosed with premature menopause is contraindicated for patients with estrogen-dependent tumors or a history of thrombosis. Furthermore, these methods cannot restore the function of the uterus and ovaries. Although autologous transplantation of cryopreserved ovarian tissue is being attempted, it may re-introduce malignant cells after cancer treatment. With the recent development in regenerative medicine, research on engineered biomaterials for the restoration of female reproductive organs is being actively conducted. The use of engineered biomaterials is a promising option in the field of reproductive medicine because it can overcome the limitations of current therapies. Here, we review the ideal properties of biomaterials for reproductive tissue engineering and the recent advancements in engineered biomaterials for the regeneration of female reproductive organs.

Human dermal fibroblasts support the development of human primordial/primary follicles in a 3-dimensional alginate matrix culture system

Background

Alginate matrix 3-dimensional culture offers the opportunity for the development and maturation of human secondary follicles in vitro. However, alginate may not be the most suitable culture system for human primordial/primary follicles in vitro. Thus, the innovation of alginate matrix 3-dimensional culture systems for human primordial/primary follicles could hold promise as an ideal approach to restoring fertility.

Methods

We extracted primordial/primary follicles from ovarian tissues collected from patients with non-ovarian benign gynecological conditions. Fibroblasts were isolated from dermal tissue from 1 male patient who had undergone posthectomy. The isolated human follicles were randomly divided into 2 groups and encapsulated within fibroblast-alginate-hydrogels or alginate hydrogels. The survival and growth of human primordial/primary follicles were measured after 21 days of in vitro culture.

Results

The dermal fibroblasts in alginate hydrogel microcapsules were round in shape, and were distributed as uniform clouds on the surface and gaps of the alginate. After 21 days of culture, the survival rate of follicles in the fibroblast-alginate group was higher than that of the alginate group (P<0.05). The diameter of follicles in the fibroblast-alginate group and the alginate group after 21 days of culture was 152.80±13.64 and 129.14±9.95 μm, respectively (P<0.05). After 21-day culture, the mean cpm (log-converted) for 3H-thymidine incorporated by granulosa cells in the fibroblast-alginate and alginate groups was 6.87±0.24 and 4.63±0.38, respectively (P<0.05). After 21 days of culture, the messenger RNA expression levels of growth differentiation factor 9 (GDF9) and bone morphogenetic protein 15 (BMP15) were significantly higher in oocytes in fibroblast-alginate hydrogels than in those in alginate hydrogels (P<0.05).

Conclusions

Human fibroblasts are beneficial to the development of human follicles in 3-dimensional culture alginate gel systems over a long period of time. More studies are required to investigate the molecular biological mechanisms of human fibroblasts that promote follicle growth in vitro.

The effect of agar substrate on growth and development of cryopreserved-thawed human ovarian cortical follicles in organ culture

OBJECTIVE

To preserve human ovarian tissue structure and improve follicular growth and survival during in-situ culture, various biomaterials are used. In this study we aimed to compare agar as a cultivation substrate with matrigel-coated insert in order to achieve an optimum system for in-situ human follicle culture.

STUDY DESIGN

Frozen-thawed human ovarian cortical tissues were cultured on either matrigel-coated inserts or agar-soaked substrates. The proportion of morphologically viable and degenerated follicles at different developmental stages, secreted hormonal levels, and apoptotic and proliferation gene expressions were compared between the cultured groups after 7-days of culture.

RESULTS

The follicular growth was not significantly different between the two cultured groups, although showing higher percentage of growing follicles in agar cultured group. The secreted hormonal levels didn't have any difference between two cultured groups. Although the apoptotic gene expressions didn't show any difference between the cultured groups, the apoptotic index was lower in agar cultured group. In addition, Ki67 gene expression, a proliferative marker, showed a significantly higher expression in agar cultured group.

CONCLUSION

Based on the results, agar is as suitable as matrigel-coated inserts for the survival and growth of follicles during culture. Therefore, agar can be an inexpensive alternative substrate for culturing frozen-thawed human ovarian cortical strips.

Effects of sodium alginate capsules as 3D scaffolds on hormones and genes expression in preantral follicles of mice compared to 2D medium: An experimental study

Background

The improvement of in vitro maturation methods, which can activate the preantral follicle growth, plays a crucial role in the production of mature oocytes in reproductive technology.

Objective

To evaluate the different concentrations of 3D scaffolds of sodium alginate on hormones and gene expression in mice preantral follicles.

Materials and Methods

Immature female BALB/c mice (12-14 days) were sacrificed. The follicles were removed mechanically and transferred into α minimal essential medium with 5% fetal bovine serum. The preantral follicles were incubated with different concentrations of sodium alginate (0.25%, 0.5%, and 1%) and 2D medium for 12 days. The follicles were examined for antral formation following the 10th day and the diameter on days 6 th and 12 th . The levels of hormones (AMH, androstenedione, 17β-estradiol, and progesterone) and the expression of genes (CYP11a1, CYP17a1, CYP19a1, AMH, and GnRH) at the end of the 12 th day.

Results

Maximum follicle diameter and highest percentage of antrum formation were related to 0.5% concentration (p = 0.00). The levels of hormones in different doses of sodium alginate were increased significantly compared to the control group (p = 0.00). The highest and lowest levels of these hormones were related to 0.5% concentration and 2D medium, respectively. The highest level of genes expression was observed in 0.5% sodium alginate, which showed a significant increase compared to the control group (p = 0.00).

Conclusion

Proper concentration of alginate hydrogel increases follicle growth, causes follicle maturation, produces steroid hormones, and increases appropriate expression of steroidogenesis-related genes.

Lessons from bioengineering the ovarian follicle: a personal perspective

The ovarian follicle and its maturation captivated my imagination and inspired my scientific journey - what we know now about this remarkable structure is captured in this invited review. In the past decade, our knowledge of the ovarian follicle expanded dramatically as cross-disciplinary collaborations brought new perspectives to bear, ultimately leading to the development of extragonadal follicles as model systems with significant clinical implications. Follicle maturation in vitro in an 'artificial' ovary became possible by learning what the follicle is fundamentally and autonomously capable of - which turns out to be quite a lot. Progress in understanding and harnessing follicle biology has been aided by engineers and materials scientists who created hardware that enables tissue function for extended periods of time. The EVATAR system supports extracorporeal ovarian function in an engineered environment that mimics the endocrine environment of the reproductive tract. Finally, applying the tools of inorganic chemistry, we discovered that oocytes require zinc to mature over time - a truly new aspect of follicle biology with no antecedent other than the presence of zinc in sperm. Drawing on the tools and ideas from the fields of bioengineering, materials science and chemistry unlocked follicle biology in ways that we could not have known or even predicted. Similarly, how today's basic science discoveries regarding ovarian follicle maturation are translated to improve the experience of tomorrow's patients is yet to be determined.

In vitro ovarian follicle growth: a comprehensive analysis of key protocol variables†

Folliculogenesis is a complex process that requires integration of autocrine, paracrine, and endocrine factors together with tightly regulated interactions between granulosa cells and oocytes for the growth and survival of healthy follicles. Culture of ovarian follicles is a powerful approach for investigating folliculogenesis and oogenesis in a tightly controlled environment. This method has not only enabled unprecedented insight into the fundamental biology of follicle development but also has far-reaching translational applications, including in fertility preservation for women whose ovarian follicles may be damaged by disease or its treatment or in wildlife conservation. Two- and three-dimensional follicle culture systems have been developed and are rapidly evolving. It is clear from a review of the literature on isolated follicle culture methods published over the past two decades (1980-2018) that protocols vary with respect to species examined, follicle isolation methods, culture techniques, culture media and nutrient and hormone supplementation, and experimental endpoints. Here we review the heterogeneity among these major variables of follicle culture protocols.

Effects of Alginate Concentration and Ovarian Cells on In Vitro Development of Mouse Preantral Follicles: A Factorial Study

BACKGROUND

In the present study, the effects of alginate (ALG) concentration and ovarian cells (OCs) on the development and function of follicles were simultaneously evaluated.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In the first step of this experimental study, preantral follicles were isolated from the ovaries of 2-week-old mice, encapsulated in the absence or presence of OCs in 0.5, 0.75 and 1% ALG hydrogels, and cultured for 14 days. The morphology, diameter, survival and antrum formation rates of the follicles and the maturation of the oocytes were evaluated during culture. In the second step, preantral follicles were cultured in the best chosen ALG concentration, in both the absence and presence of OCs. Following these steps, the amount of DNA fragmentation, the expression levels of connexin 37 and connexin 43 proteins, the secretion levels of estradiol, progesterone and androstenedione by the follicles and the quality of mature (MII) oocytes were assessed.

RESULTS

Our data revealed that in the absence of OCs, follicles of 0.5% group showed a higher survival rate than the 0.75 and 1% groups (71.87 vs. 52.52 and 40%, respectively, P<0.05). Nonetheless, the antrum formation rate of the 1% group was higher and its oocyte degeneration rate was lower than that in the other groups. Furthermore, it was observed that co-culture of follicles with OCs relatively increased the follicle diameter, survival, antrum formation, and germinal vesicle (GV) to GV break down (GVBD)/MII transition rates. At last, the comparison of 0.5%-OCs and 0.5%+OCs groups indicated that the co-culture condition resulted in more progesterone production (1.8 ± 0.2 vs. 3.2 ± 0.4 ng/ml, respectively, P<0.05) and also decreased oocytes' cortical granule abnormalities (100 vs. 40% for 0.5%- OCs and 0.5%+OCs groups, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The present study revealed that 0.5% ALG hydrogel is relatively suitable for preantral follicle culture, and in the presence of OCs, it mimics the natural ovarian condition better than the higher concentrations of ALG hydrogel.

Insulin promotes preantral follicle growth and antrum formation through temporal expression of genes regulating steroidogenesis and water transport in the cat

The aims of the present study were to determine the effects of insulin, invitro, on: (1) the viability and growth of domestic cat ovarian follicles; (2) mRNA expression of genes regulating steroidogenesis (cytochrome P450 family 17 subfamily, A polypeptide 1 (Cyp17a1), cytochrome P450 family 19 subfamily, A polypeptide 1 (Cyp19a1) and steroidogenic acute regulatory protein (Star)) and water transport (aquaporins (AQPs) Aqp1, Aqp3, Aqp7, Aqp9); and (3) steroid production (17β-oestradiol (E2), progesterone (P4), androstenedione (A4)). Cat secondary follicles were isolated from ovarian cortices and cultured in 0 (Control), 1 or 10µgmL-1 insulin for 14 days (Day 0=culture onset). Follicle and oocyte viability (based on neutral red staining), diameter and antrum formation were assessed every 72h and at the end of incubation (Day 14). Expression of steroidogenic and water transport genes was evaluated on Days 0, 6 and 12, and E2, P4 and A4 concentrations in the culture medium were determined on Day 12. By Day 14, 1 and 10µgmL-1 insulin had significantly promoted (P<0.05) both antrum formation in a mean (±s.e.m.) 26.9±9.0% and 78.0±10.0% of follicles respectively, and follicle growth (diameter 151.4±4.5 and 169.9±10.5µm respectively) compared with Control (antrum formation in 3.3±3.3% of follicles and follicle diameter 129.1±6.6µm). High insulin (10µgmL-1) treatment increased follicle viability compared with Control (86.0±9.8% vs 38.1±10.9% respectively; P<0.05). However, insulin had no beneficial effect (P>0.05) on oocyte diameter. Cyp17a1 expression on Days 6 and 12 was higher (P<0.05) in follicles cultured in the low (1µgmL-1) compared with high (10µgmL-1) insulin treatment, with no significant difference between low or high insulin vs Control groups. Star expression was higher (P<0.01) in the low insulin compared with Control group on Day 6, but Star was undetectable in the high insulin group by Day 12. Compared with high insulin, low insulin increased (P<0.05) Aqp1 expression on Day 6, but there were no significant differences between these two groups on Day 12. In contrast, high insulin decreased (P<0.05) Aqp9 transcript levels compared with Control. Only P4 production was affected by insulin, with P4 concentrations in the medium being higher (P<0.05) in the low compared with high insulin and Control groups. In summary, the findings indicate that insulin promotes cat ovarian follicle growth and survival invitro, including enhanced antrum formation, with the likely mechanism involving temporal expression of Cyp17a1, Star and Aqp9 genes.

Modification of the medium volume and gel substrate under in vitro culture conditions improves growth of porcine oocytes derived from early antral follicles

This study compared the effects of different volumes of culture medium for the in vitro growth of oocytes derived from porcine early antral follicles (EAFs). Oocyte granulosa cell complexes (OGCs) were collected from EAFs (0.5–0.7 mm in diameter) and individually cultured for 14 days. When OGCs were cultured in 1 ml of medium with or without polyacrylamide gel (PAG), the presence of PAG supported granulosa cell (GC) proliferation and oocyte growth. When OGCs were cultured in 0.2 or 1 ml of medium on PAG, the number of GC in the OGC culture and the developmental ability of the oocytes cultured in vitro were significantly higher for the 1 ml of culture medium group than for the 0.2 ml group. In conclusion, a combination of a large volume of culture medium with PAG improved the growth and developmental ability of the oocytes cultured in vitro, which were comparable to the oocytes collected from large antral follicles.

Enhancing oxygen delivery to ovarian follicles by three different methods markedly improves growth in serum-containing culture medium

Invitro ovarian follicle culture systems are routinely used to study folliculogenesis and may provide solutions for infertility. Mouse follicles are typically cultured in standard gas-impermeable culture plates under gas phase oxygen concentrations of 5% or 20% (v/v). There is evidence that these conditions may not provide adequate oxygenation for follicles cultured as non-attached intact units in medium supplemented with serum and high levels of FSH. Three different methods of enhancing follicle oxygenation were investigated in this study: increasing the gas phase oxygen concentration, inverting the culture plates and using gas-permeable culture plates. Follicles cultured under 40% O2 were significantly larger (P P P 2 . These effects were associated with reduced secretion of vascular endothelial growth factor (P P P invivo -matured follicles (~500μm in diameter). Such follicular development is not possible under hypoxic conditions.

IVF-on-a-Chip: Recent Advances in Microfluidics Technology for In Vitro Fertilization

In vitro fertilization (IVF) has been one of the most exciting modern medical technologies. It has transformed the landscape of human infertility treatment. However, current IVF procedures still provide limited accessibility and affordability to most infertile couples because of the multiple cumbersome processes and heavy dependence on technically skilled personnel. Microfluidics technology offers unique opportunities to automate IVF procedures, reduce stress imposed upon gametes and embryos, and minimize the operator-to-operator variability. This article describes the rapidly evolving state of the application of microfluidics technology in the field of IVF, summarizes the diverse angles of how microfluidics has been complementing or transforming current IVF protocols, and discusses the challenges that motivate continued innovation in this field.

Activin promotes growth and antral cavity expansion in the dog ovarian follicle

Understanding regulators of folliculogenesis remains limited in the domestic dog (Canis familiaris), which challenges our ability to develop in vitro follicle culture systems for canid genome rescue efforts. Here, we investigated the influence of activin on dog follicle development and survival, oocyte quality, and FSH receptor expression in culture. Preantral (150 - ≤230 μm diameter), early antral (231 - ≤330 μm), and antral (>330-550 μm) stage follicles were encapsulated in a fibrin-alginate hydrogel with 0, 100, or 200 ng/ml rhActivin plus 0, 0.1, 1, or 10 μg/ml FSH for 12 or 21 d of in vitro culture. All follicle groups increased in diameter (P < 0.05) with activin acting synergistically with FSH to improve (P < 0.05) growth and antral cavity expansion (to >630 μm) in early antral and antral cohorts. This complementary effect was not linked to changes in FSHR mRNA expression (P > 0.05). Although not influencing (P > 0.05) follicle survival or transzonal projection (TZP) density in shorter term 12 d culture, activin in the presence of 1 ng/ml FSH maintained TZP density from the 12-21 d interval. Activin also increased oocyte diameter and improved nuclear integrity compared to un-supplemented controls. These results indicate that activin acts synergistically with FSH to promote growth and antral cavity expansion of the dog follicle in vitro, information useful to formulating an effective culture microenvironment for this species.

Three-Dimensional Hydrogel-Based Culture to Study the Effects of Toxicants on Ovarian Follicles

Various toxicants, such as drugs and their metabolites, can cause potential ovarian toxicity. As the functional units of the ovary, ovarian follicles are susceptible to this type of damage at all developmental stages. Studying the effects of toxicants on ovarian follicles is an important task. Three-dimensional (3D) hydrogels, such as fibrin alginate interpenetrating networks (FA-IPNs), can support ovarian follicle culture in vitro for extended periods of time and serve as a suitable tool for studying ovotoxicity. Growing follicles encapsulated in the FA-IPN can proteolytically degrade the fibrin component in the FA-IPN. The degradation of fibrin mirrors the follicle growth and serves as a surrogate reporter for follicle health. The speed of fibrin degradation can be further controlled by aprotinin, a small molecule that inhibits plasmin-driven proteolytic degradation, which further expands the application of the described system. In this chapter, we describe methods to (1) isolate and encapsulate mouse ovarian follicles in FA-IPN, (2) follow follicle growth and development in vitro, and (3) evaluate the effects of toxicants on folliculogenesis using fibrin degradation.

Three-dimensional levitation culture improves in-vitro growth of secondary follicles in bovine model

RESEARCH QUESTION

Does a three-dimensional culture system based on magnetic levitation with nanoparticles assembly maintain the follicular structure and viability with adequate growth rates leading to oocyte maturation after long-term culture?

DESIGN

Randomized-controlled trial of treatments in a bovine model. Secondary follicles (n = 213) isolated from bovine ovaries were cultured in a two-dimensional system (two-dimensional control) or three-dimensional levitation system with different concentrations (three-dimensional 50 µl/ml, 100 µl/ml and 200 µl/ml) of magnetic nanoparticles. Follicular growth (diameter, daily growth and growth patterns), morphology (normal, degenerated and extruded follicles), antrum formation, oocyte viability and chromatin configuration were assessed.

RESULTS

Secondary follicles of three-dimensional 200-µl/ml treatment showed higher viability, antrum formation and lower degeneration rates than two-dimensional control. Also, follicles cultured in the three-dimensional 200-µl/ml treatment presented a most homogenous daily growth rate as shown by the lowest variance and standard deviation. Compared with the two-dimensional control, the proportion of non-growing and slow-growing follicles were 3.8-fold lower and 1.6-fold higher, respectively, in the three-dimensional 200-µl/ml treatment. After in-vitro maturation, the three-dimensional 200-µl/ml had a greater proportion of viable oocytes (1.7-fold) and meiotic resumption rates (2.4-fold) than the two-dimensional control treatment.

CONCLUSION

The three-dimensional levitation culture system improves the viability of in-vitro development of bovine secondary follicles, antrum formation and lower extrusion and degeneration rates and adequate growth rate leading to relevant oocyte viability and meiotic resumption after in-vitro maturation. This approach does not require a specific medium, and has the potential as an alternative method to in-vitro follicle culture in several species, including humans.

In vitro follicle culture in the context of IVF

The currently available assisted reproduction techniques for fertility preservation (i.e. in vitro maturation (IVM) and in vitro fertilization) are insufficient as stand-alone procedures as only few reproductive cells can be conserved with these techniques. Oocytes in primordial follicles are well suited to survive the cryopreservation procedure and of use as valuable starting material for fertilization, on the condition that these could be grown up to fully matured oocytes. Our understanding of the biological mechanisms directing primordial follicle activation has increased over the last years and this knowledge has paved the way toward clinical applications. New multistep in vitro systems are making use of purified precursor cells and extracellular matrix components and by applying bio-printing technologies, an adequate follicular niche can be built. IVM of human oocytes is clinically applied in patients with polycystic ovary/polycystic ovary syndrome; related knowhow could become useful for fertility preservation and for patients with maturation failure and follicle-stimulating hormone resistance. The expectations from the research on human ovarian tissue and immature oocytes cultures, in combination with the improved vitrification methods, are high as these technologies can offer realistic potential for fertility preservation.

Direct actions of androgen, estrogen and anti-Müllerian hormone on primate secondary follicle development in the absence of FSH in vitro

STUDY QUESTION

What are effects of androgen, estrogen and anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), independent of FSH action, on the development and function of primate follicles from the preantral to small antral stage in vitro?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Androgen and estrogen, but not AMH, promote follicle survival and growth in vitro, in the absence of FSH. However, their growth-promoting effects are limited to the preantral to early antral stage.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

FSH supports primate preantral follicle development in vitro. Androgen and estrogen augment follicle survival and growth in the presence of FSH during culture.

STUDY DESIGN SIZE, DURATION

Nonhuman primate model; randomized, control versus treatment groups. Rhesus macaque (n = 6) secondary follicles (n = 24 per animal per treatment group) were cultured for 5 weeks.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Follicles were encapsulated in 0.25% (w/v) alginate and cultured individually in modified alpha minimum essential media with (i) FSH (1 ng/ml; control), (ii) no FSH, (iii) no FSH + estradiol (E2; 100 pg/ml)/dihydrotestosterone (DHT; 50 ng/ml) and (iv) no FSH + AMH (50 ng/ml). In a second experiment, follicles were cultured with (i) FSH (1 ng/ml), (ii) no FSH, (iii) no FSH + E2 (1 ng/ml), (iv) no FSH + DHT (50 ng/ml) and (v) no FSH + E2/DHT. Follicle survival, antrum formation and growth pattern were evaluated. Progesterone (P4), E2 and AMH concentrations in culture media were measured.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

In the first experiment, FSH deprivation significantly decreased (P < 0.05) follicle survival rates in the no FSH group (16 ± 5%), compared to CTRL (66 ± 9%). E2/DHT (49 ± 5%), but not AMH (27 ± 8%), restored follicle survival rate to the CTRL level. Similarly, antrum formation rates were higher (P < 0.05) in CTRL (56 ± 6%) and E2/DHT groups (54 ± 14%), compared to no FSH (0 ± 0%) and AMH (11 ± 11%) groups. However, follicle growth rate after antrum formation and follicle diameter at week 5 was reduced (P < 0.05) in the E2/DHT group (405 ± 25 μm), compared to CTRL (522 ± 29 μm). Indeed, the proportion of fast-grow follicles at week 5 was higher in CTRL (29% ± 5), compared to E2/DHT group (10 ± 3%). No fast-grow follicles were observed in no FSH and AMH groups. AMH levels at week 3 remained similar in all groups. However, media concentrations of P4 and E2 at week 5 were lower (P < 0.05, undetectable) in no FSH, E2/DHT and AMH groups, compared to CTRL (P4 = 93 ± 10 ng/ml; E2 = 4 ± 1 ng/ml). In the second experiment, FSH depletion diminished follicle survival rate (66 ± 8% in control versus 45 ± 9% in no FSH, P = 0.034). E2 plus DHT (31.5 ± 11%) or DHT alone (69 ± 9%) restored follicle survival rate to the control (FSH) level as expected. Also, E2 plus DHT or DHT alone improved antrum formation rate. However, in the absence of FSH, E2 plus DHT or DHT alone did not support growth, in terms of follicle diameter, or steroid (P4 or E2) production after the antral stage.

LIMITATIONS REASONS FOR CAUTION

This study is limited to in vitro effects of E2, DHT and AMH during the interval from the secondary to small antral stage of macaque follicular development. In addition, the primate follicle pool is heterogeneous and differs between animals; therefore, even though only secondary follicles were selected, follicle growth and developmental outcomes might differ from one animal to another.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study provides novel information on the possible actions of estrogen and androgen during early follicular development in primates. Our results suggest that sequential exposure of preantral follicles to local factors, e.g. E2 and DHT, followed by gonadotropin once the follicle reaches the antral stage, may better mimic primate folliculogenesis in vivo.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

Research reported in this publication was supported by the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Center for Translational Research on Reproduction and Infertility 5P50HD071836, and the NIH Primate Centers Program 8P510D011092. There are no conflicts of interest.