Multiple generational bovine embryo cloning

Perspectives in Genome-Editing Techniques for Livestock

Genome editing of farm animals has undeniable practical applications. It helps to improve production traits, enhances the economic value of livestock, and increases disease resistance. Gene-modified animals are also used for biomedical research and drug production and demonstrate the potential to be used as xenograft donors for humans. The recent discovery of site-specific nucleases that allow precision genome editing of a single-cell embryo (or embryonic stem cells) and the development of new embryological delivery manipulations have revolutionized the transgenesis field. These relatively new approaches have already proven to be efficient and reliable for genome engineering and have wide potential for use in agriculture. A number of advanced methodologies have been tested in laboratory models and might be considered for application in livestock animals. At the same time, these methods must meet the requirements of safety, efficiency and availability of their application for a wide range of farm animals. This review aims at covering a brief history of livestock animal genome engineering and outlines possible future directions to design optimal and cost-effective tools for transgenesis in farm species.

Expression and secretory profile of buffalo fetal fibroblasts and Wharton's jelly feeder layers

The present study examined the comparative expression and secretory profile of vital signaling molecules in buffalo fetal fibroblasts (BFF) and Wharton's jelly (BWJ) feeder layers at different passages. Both feeder layers were expanded up to 8th passage. Signaling molecules viz. bone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4), fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2), leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF) and transforming growth factor beta 1 (TGFB1) and pluripotency-associated transcriptional factors (POU5F1, SOX2, NANOG, KLF4, MYC and FOXD3) were immunolocalized in the both feeder types. A clear variation in the expression pattern of key signaling molecules with passaging was registered in both feeders compared to primary culture (0 passage). The conditioned media (CM) was collected from different passages (2, 4, 6, 8) of both the feeder layers and was quantified using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). Concomitant to expression profile, protein quantification also revealed differences in the concentration of signaling molecules at different time points. Conjointly, expression and secretory profile revealed that 2nd passage of BFF and 6th passage of BWJ exhibit optimal levels of key signaling molecules thus may be selected as best passages for embryonic stem cells (ESCs) propagation. Further, the effect of mitomycin-C (MMC) treatment on the expression profile of signaling molecules in the selected passages of BFF and BWJ revealed that MMC modulates the expression profile of these molecules. In conclusion, the results indicate that feeder layers vary in expression and secretory pattern of vital signaling molecules with passaging. Based on these findings, the appropriate feeder passages may be selected for the quality propagation of buffalo ESCs.

Effect of Long-Term Exposure of Donor Nuclei to the Oocyte Cytoplasm on Production of Cloned Mice Using Serial Nuclear Transfer

Although animal cloning is becoming increasingly practicable, cloned embryos possess many abnormalities and so there has been a low success rate for producing live animals. This is most likely due to incomplete reprogramming of somatic cell nuclei before they start to develop as the donor nuclei are usually only exposed to the oocyte cytoplasm for 1-2 hours before reconstructed oocytes are activated to avoid oocyte aging. Therefore, in this study, we attempted to extend the exposure period of somatic cell nuclei to the oocyte cytoplasm to determine whether this could enhance reprogramming of donor nuclei. Donor nuclei were transferred into oocytes, following which pseudo-MII spindles (pMIIs) derived from these were extracted and injected into newly collected enucleated oocytes 24 hours after the first nuclear transfer (NT). These serial NT oocytes were then activated and their developmental potential was examined to full term. There was no obvious difference in the pMIIs of reconstructed oocytes at 6 and 24 hours after donor nucleus injection; however, in both of these, the chromosomes were more widely spread inside the spindle than in fresh intact oocytes. Furthermore, a few chromosomes remained in 25% and 47% of these enucleated oocytes at 6 and 24 hours after donor nucleus injection, respectively. When these pMIIs were injected into fresh enucleated oocytes, the developmental rate to blastocyst was significantly lower, but we could still obtain several healthy cloned offspring. Thus, serial NT at intervals of 24 hours using fresh oocytes is possible, but the success rate could not be improved due to loss of chromosomes during the second NT.

Artificial cloning of domestic animals

Domestic animals can be cloned using techniques such as embryo splitting and nuclear transfer to produce genetically identical individuals. Although embryo splitting is limited to the production of only a few identical individuals, nuclear transfer of donor nuclei into recipient oocytes, whose own nuclear DNA has been removed, can result in large numbers of identical individuals. Moreover, clones can be produced using donor cells from sterile animals, such as steers and geldings, and, unlike their genetic source, these clones are fertile. In reality, due to low efficiencies and the high costs of cloning domestic species, only a limited number of identical individuals are generally produced, and these clones are primarily used as breed stock. In addition to providing a means of rescuing and propagating valuable genetics, somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) research has contributed knowledge that has led to the direct reprogramming of cells (e.g., to induce pluripotent stem cells) and a better understanding of epigenetic regulation during embryonic development. In this review, I provide a broad overview of the historical development of cloning in domestic animals, of its application to the propagation of livestock and transgenic animal production, and of its scientific promise for advancing basic research.

Two-staged nuclear transfer can enhance the developmental ability of goat-sheep interspecies nuclear transfer embryos in vitro

The technique of interspecies somatic cell nuclear transfer, in which interspecies cloned embryos can be reconstructed by using domestic animal oocytes as nuclear recipients and endangered animal or human somatic cells as nuclear donors, can afford more opportunities in endangered animal rescue and human tissue transplantation, but the application of this technique is limited by extremely low efficiency which may be attributed to donor nucleus not fully reprogrammed by xenogenic cytoplasm. In this study, goat fetal fibroblasts (GFFs) were used as nuclear donors, in vitro-matured sheep oocytes were used as nuclear recipients, and a two-stage nuclear transfer procedure was performed to improve the developmental ability of goat-sheep interspecies clone embryos. In the first stage nuclear transfer (FSNT), GFFs were injected into the ooplasm of enucleated sheep metaphase-II oocytes, then non-activated reconstructed embryos were cultured in vitro, so that the donor nucleus could be exposed to the ooplasm for a period of time. Subsequently, in the second stage nuclear transfer, FSNT-derived non-activated reconstructed embryo was centrifuged, and the donor nucleus was then transferred into another freshly enucleated sheep oocyte. Compared with the one-stage nuclear transfer, two-stage nuclear transfer could significantly enhance the blastocyst rate of goat-sheep interspecies clone embryos, and this result indicated that longtime exposure to xenogenic ooplasm benefits the donor nucleus to be reprogrammed. The two-stage nuclear transfer procedure has two advantages, one is that the donor nucleus can be exposed to the ooplasm for a long time, the other is that the problem of oocyte aging can be solved.

Gene expression and development of early pig embryos produced by serial nuclear transfer

During nuclear transfer, reprogramming makes the donor nucleus capable of directing development of the reconstructed embryo. In most cases reprogramming is incomplete, which leads to abnormal expression of early embryonic genes and subsequently, to reduced developmental potential. In the present study, we monitored the expression of Oct4, Nanog, and Sox2 in cloned porcine embryos and evaluated whether serial nuclear transfer, the transfer of nuclei of cloned embryos into enucleated oocytes, has the potential to provide a more complete reprogramming of the donor genome. The data suggested that Nanog and Sox2 expression is properly reactivated after nuclear transfer, but the relative abundance of Oct4 transcripts is abnormally low in cloned porcine blastocysts compared to control embryos produced by in vitro fertilization. When the nuclei of 8- to 16-cell stage cloned embryos were introduced into enucleated oocytes to expose the chromosomes repeatedly to the ooplasmic factors, the resulting embryos showed poor developmental potential: a significantly lower percentage of embryos developed to the 4-cell (12.0% vs. 31.8%), 8-cell (3.1% vs. 15.0%) and blastocyst (0% vs. 8.7%) stages compared to those produced following a single round of nuclear transfer (P < 0.05). The additional time for reprogramming also did not improve gene expression. By the late 4-cell stage, Oct4 and Sox2 expression levels were low in serial nuclear transfer embryos compared to those in embryos generated by in vitro fertilization or nuclear transfer. Overall, both developmental and gene expression data indicated that reprogramming of the donor nucleus could not be improved by serial nuclear transfer in the pig.

Effect of embryonic cell cycle of nuclear donor embryos on the efficiency of nuclear transfer in Japanese black cattle

In the present study, the development in vitro and in vivo of nuclear transfer (NT) embryos reconstructed with embryonic cells (blastomeres) at the 32- to 63-cell (sixth cell cycle) and 64- to 127-cell (seventh cell cycle) stages was investigated to determine the optimum range of embryonic cell cycles for yielding the highest number of identical calves in Japanese black cattle. Rates of development to the blastocyst stage (overall efficiency) were higher in the sixth cell-cycle stage (45%) than in the seventh cell-cycle stage (12%). After the transfer of the blastocysts reconstructed with blastomeres of the sixth and seventh cell cycle-stage embryos to recipient heifers, there were no differences in the pregnancy (14/35: 40% versus 3/13: 23%, respectively) or calving rates (11/39: 28% versus 3/13: 23%, respectively). These results indicate that the highest number of identical calves would be obtained by using sixth cell cycle (32- to 63-cell)-stage embryos as nuclear donors.

A double nuclear transfer technique for cloning pigs

The first round of double nuclear transfer (NT) procedure includes the following steps: transfer of somatic cell nuclei into enucleated recipient oocytes, fusion, activation, and culture of reconstructed oocytes. The next day, a second round of NT is performed by removing karyoplasts from 1-d-old NT embryos and transferring them into in vivo-derived zygotes from which the two pronuclei have been removed. Couplets are then fused using an electrical pulse and transferred into synchronized recipient gilts. This system, which uses fertilized oocytes as cytoplast recipients, bypasses the inefficiencies of artificial activation procedures, and may promote more successful development.

Cloning: questions answered and unsolved

Cloning by the transfer of adult somatic cell nuclei to oocytes has produced viable offspring in a variety of mammalian species. The technology is still in its initial stages of development. Studies to date have answered several basic questions related to such issues as genome potency, life expectancy of clones, mitochondrial fates, and feasibility of inter-species nuclear transfer. They have also raised new questions related to the control of nuclear reprogramming and function. These questions are reviewed here.

Commercial aspects of cloning and genetic modification in cattle

A range of potential commercial applications of cloning and genetic modification in cattle has been suggested over the last decade. It includes the rapid multiplication of elite genotypes, production of valuable human proteins, altered production characteristics, increased disease resistance and milk with improved nutritional value and processing capabilities. However, an economic return from the sale of product is far from reality in any of these areas. One impediment to achieving economic sustainability is the extremely low efficiency in producing healthy offspring from transferred cloned embryos. Other significant impediments are societal concerns surrounding such technologies, animal welfare issues and regulatory requirements. This review will focus on current biological limitations and technical capabilities in commercial settings, the changes required to allow the production and sale of products at economically sustainable levels, cryopreservation and the progress towards automation of cloning techniques.

Factors affecting the efficiency of somatic cell nuclear transplantation in the fish embryo

Procedures to improve somatic cell nuclear transplantation in fish were evaluated. We reported effects of nonirradiated recipient eggs, inactivated recipient eggs, different combinations between recipient eggs and donor cells, duration of serum starvation, generation number, and passage number of donor cells on developmental rates of nuclear transplant (NT) embryos. Exposure to 25,000 R of gamma-rays inactivated recipient eggs. Single nucleus of cultured, synchronized somatic cell from gynogenetic bighead carp (Aristichthys nobilis) was transplanted into nonirradiated or genetically inactivated unfertilized egg of gibel carp (Carassius auratus gibelio). There was no significant difference in developmental rate between nonirradiated and inactivated recipient eggs (27.27% vs. 25.71%, respectively). Chromosome count showed that 70.59% of NT embryos contained 48 chromosomes. It showed that most NT embryos came from donor nuclei of bighead carp, which was supported by microsatellite analysis of NT embryos. But 23.53% of NT embryos contained more than 48 chromosomes. It was presumed that those superfluous chromosomes came from nonirradiated recipient eggs. Besides, 5.88% of NT embryos were chimeras. Eggs of blunt-snout bream (Megalobrama amblycephala) and gibel carp were better recipient eggs than those of loach (Misgurnus anguillicaudatus) (25% and 18.03% vs. 8.43%). Among different duration of serum starvation, developmental rate of NT embryos from somatic nuclei of three-day serum starvation was the highest, reaching 25.71% compared to 14.14% (control), 20% (five-day), and 21.95% (seven-day). Cultured donor cells of less passage facilitated reprogramming of NT embryos than those of more passage. Recloning might improve the developmental rate of NT embryos from the differentiated donor nuclei. Developmental rate of fourth generation was the highest (54.83%) and the lowest for first generation (14.14%) compared to second generation (38.96%) and third generation (53.01%).

Nuclear transfer in practice

The technique of nuclear transfer (NT) allows the production of embryos, fetuses, and offspring from a range of embryonic, fetal, and adult derived cell types in a range of species. Successful development is dependent upon numerous factors, including type of recipient cell, source of recipient cell, method of reconstruction, activation, embryo culture, donor cell type, and donor and recipient cell cycle stages. The present review will discuss the uses of NT, the techniques presently available, and the factors affecting subsequent development.

Production of cloned cattle from in vitro systems

The pregnancy initiation and maintenance rates of nuclear transfer embryos produced from several bovine cell types were measured to determine which cell types produced healthy calves and had growth characteristics that would allow for genetic manipulation. Considerable variability between cell types from one animal and the same cell type from different animals was observed. In general, cultured fetal cells performed better with respect to pregnancy initiation and calving than adult cells with the exception of cumulous cells, which produced the highest overall pregnancy and calving rates. The cell type that combined relatively high pregnancy initiation and calving rates with growth characteristics that allowed for extended proliferation in culture were fetal genital ridge (GR) cells. Cultured GR cells used in nuclear transfer and embryo transfer initiated pregnancies in 40% of recipient heifers (197), and of all recipients that received nuclear transfer embryos, 9% produced live calves. Cultured GR cells doubled as many as 85 times overall and up to 75 times after dilution to single-cell culture. A comparison between transfected and nontransfected cells showed that transfected cells had lower pregnancy initiation (22% versus 32%) and calving (3.4% versus 8.9%) rates.

Development of bovine embryo-derived clones after increasing rounds of nuclear recycling

This study assessed in vitro and in vivo developmental ability of bovine embryo-derived clones after one, four or seven rounds of nuclear transfer. Initial donor embryo production and all subsequent cultures were performed in vitro. Donor clonal embryo lines were vitrified and warmed either once (first generation), twice (third generation) or three times (sixth generation) before the final round of cloning. No differences were observed in fusion, cleavage and development rates to the 16-cell stage between the first six cloning generations. Likewise, neither the fusion nor cleavage rates were different between first, fourth and seventh generation clones. However, development to morulae and blastocysts decreased significantly as the number of recycling rounds increased (24.8, 15.1 and 13.6% for first, fourth and seventh generation, respectively). In addition, the proportion of blastocysts compared to morulae decreased, indicating slower developmental speed in later generation clones. After transfer of 16, 25 and 7 clones to 7, 11 and 2 recipients (first, fourth and seventh generation, respectively) initial pregnancy rates of 57, 27 and 0% were obtained. Final rates of calves to term were 25 and 4% per transferred clone for first and fourth generation clones, respectively. These results indicate greatly reduced in vitro and in vivo developmental capacity of bovine embryo-derived clones after several rounds of nuclear recycling. Whether it is caused by intrinsic factors associated with the genome modification and reprogramming as such, or by external factors such as prolonged in vitro culture period or the effects of vitrification, remains to be determined.

Advances in livestock nuclear transfer

Cloning and transgenic animal production have been greatly enhanced by the development of nuclear transfer technology. In the past, genetic modification in domestic animals was not tightly controlled. With the nuclear transfer technology one can now create some domestic animals with specific genetic modifications. An ever-expanding variety of cell types have been successfully used as donors to create the clones. Both cell fusion and microinjection are successfully being used to create these animals. However, it is still not clear which stage(s) of the cell cycle for donor and recipient cells yield the greatest degree of development. While for the most part gene expression is reprogrammed in nuclear transfer embryos, all structural changes may not be corrected as evidenced by the length of the telomeres in sheep resulting from nuclear transfer. Even after these animals are created the question of "are they really clones?" arises due to mitochondrial inheritance from the donor cell versus the recipient oocyte. This review discusses these issues as they relate to livestock.

Effects of preactivation of ooplasts or synchronization of blastomere nuclei in G1 on preimplantation development of rabbit serial nuclear transfer embryos

Blastomeres from eight-cell-stage rabbit embryos have been fused with enucleated metaphase II oocytes (ooplasts) or with ooplasts that were preactivated before fusion. Preactivation of ooplasts before nuclear transfer (NT) raises the rate of preimplantation development from 15% to 56%, which remains elevated in the next series of NT (48.6% and 47.2% in the second and third rounds, respectively). Transfer of eight-cell embryos from the third round to the recipient resulted in the birth of normal young. Synchronization of blastomere nuclei in the G1 phase with nocodazole before fusion results in 42% morula/blastocyst formation. However, in the second generation of NT embryos, the yield drops to as low as 17%, indicating deleterious effects of the second nocodazole treatment on blastomeres. The calculated number of clones per one round of cloning was 4.5, 3.9, and 3.8 in subsequent series; the highest number of morulae and blastocysts that developed from individual donor embryos after three rounds were 26 and 27, respectively.

Review: Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer in Mammals: Progress and Applications

Somatic nuclear transfer has been performed with frogs since the early 1960s, yet it has proved impossible to generate an adult frog using an adult cell as nuclear donor. After some initial skepticism, the birth of sheep, cows, goats, and mice using this technique with fetal or adult cell donors is now established fact. The success with adult mammalian cell donors extends the historic work in frogs by attesting to the totipotency of nuclei in at least some adult, differentiated cell types. Because the technique offers a developmental read out of the totality of genetic and molecular lifetime changes accumulated by the nucleus of a single somatic cell, basic research applications are seen in the fields of ageing, cancer, X chromosome inactivation, and imprinting. The prospect of a method for gene targeting in livestock holds particular promise for commercial applications; whilst for humans, the use of nuclear transfer to provide diverse populations of customized stem cells for therapeutic purposes presents a tantalizing future goal.

Production of cloned calves following nuclear transfer with cultured adult mural granulosa cells

Adult somatic cell nuclear transfer was used to determine the totipotent potential of cultured mural granulosa cells, obtained from a Friesian dairy cow of high genetic merit. Nuclei were exposed to oocyte cytoplasm for prolonged periods by electrically fusing quiescent cultured cells to enucleated metaphase II cytoplasts 4-6 h before activation (fusion before activation [FBA] treatment). Additionally, some first-generation morulae were recloned by fusing blastomeres to S-phase cytoplasts. A significantly higher proportion of fused embryos developed in vitro to grade 1-2 blastocysts on Day 7 with FBA (27.5 +/- 2.5%) than with recloning (13.0 +/- 3.6%; p < 0. 05). After the transfer of 100 blastocysts from the FBA treatment, survival rates on Days 60, 100, 180, and term were 45%, 21%, 17%, and 10%, respectively. Ten heifer calves were delivered by elective cesarean section; all have survived. After the transfer of 16 recloned blastocysts, embryo survival on Day 60 was 38%; however, no fetuses survived to Day 100. DNA analyses confirmed that the calves are all genetically identical to the donor cow. It is suggested that the losses throughout gestation may in part be due to placental dysfunction at specific stages. The next advance in this technology will be to introduce specific genetic modifications of biomedical or agricultural interest.

Nuclear Equivalence, Nuclear Transfer, and the Cell Cycle

The last 20 years have seen the development of techniques for the production of mammals by nuclear transfer. Originally limited to the swapping of pronuclei and the use of early cleavage-stage embryos as nuclear donors, nuclear transfer came of age in 1995 with the birth of 2 Welsh Mountain lambs, Megan and Morag, that were produced using cultured differentiated cells as donors of genetic material. In 1996, Dolly was the first animal to be produced using the genetic material from an adult-derived somatic cell. The techniques used in the production of these animals have now been reproduced in both sheep and cattle, and as predicted, successful development has been obtained using donor cells taken directly ex vivo. This article reviews the current status of mammalian nuclear transfer and the biological background to these successes.

Temporal and spatial aspects of fragmentation in early human embryos: possible effects on developmental competence and association with the differential elimination of regulatory proteins from polarized domains

This study examined the relationship between blastomere fragmentation in cultured human embryos obtained by in-vitro fertilization and the effect of fragmentation on the distribution of the following eight regulatory proteins found to be: (i) localized in the mature oocyte in subplasmalemmal, polarized domains; and (ii) unequally inherited by the blastomeres during cleavage: leptin, signal transducer and activator of transcription 3 (STAT3), Bax, Bcl-x, transforming growth factor beta 2 (TGF beta 2), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), c-kit and epidermal growth factor R (EGF-R). Four basic patterns of fragmentation were observed. The severity of the impact of each type of fragmentation on the affected blastomere(s) and the developmental competence of the embryo appeared to be a function of the unique temporal and spatial features associated with the particular fragmentation pattern(s) involved in each instance. The findings demonstrate that certain patterns of fragmentation can result in the partial or near total loss of the eight regulatory proteins from specific blastomeres and that the developmental potential of the affected embryo can be particularly compromised if it occurs during the 1- or 2-cell stages. In contrast, fragmentation from portions of a fertilized egg or a blastomere(s) in a 2-cell embryo that do not contain the protein domains, or the complete loss by fragmentation of a regulatory protein domain-containing blastomere after the 4-cell stage does not necessarily preclude continued development to the blastocyst, although the normality and developmental potential of the embryo may be compromised. The possible association between fragmentation and apoptosis was examined by annexin V staining of plasma membrane phosphatidylserine and TUNEL analysis of blastomere DNA. No direct correlation between fragmentation and apoptosis was found following the analyses of fragmented embryos with these two markers. However, while we suggest that changes in cell physiology unrelated to apoptosis are the more likely causes of fragmentation, we cannot exclude the possibility that fragmentation itself may be an initiator of apoptosis if critical ratios or levels of developmentally important proteins are altered by partial or complete elimination of their polarized domains. The findings are discussed with respect to the possible developmental significance of regulatory protein polarization in human oocytes and preimplantation stage embryos.

Preparation of young preactivated oocytes with high enucleation efficiency for bovine nuclear transfer

To improve the enucleation rate in newly matured bovine oocytes, we investigated the position of cytoplasmic chromatin in relation to the polar body and the consequent enucleation efficiency before and after sequential activation with calcium ionophore A23187 and cycloheximide. Oocytes aspirated from the follicles of slaughterhouse-collected ovaries were cultured for 18 to 20 h. With Hoechst staining, only 40.7% of the chromatin material was found adjacent to the first polar body in metaphase II oocytes, while 100% was located adjacent to the second polar body in oocytes after the activation. Enucleation trials after activation showed a higher enucleation rate (91.5%) than that before activation (59.9%). The following experiment determined the effect of using both kinds of cytoplast on the in vitro development of nuclear transfer embryos. Blastomeres of the 32-cell-stage in vitro-produced embryos were transferred, fused to the activated cytoplasts and cultured in vitro. No significant difference was detected in fusion, cleavage or development to blastocysts obtained 7 d (174 h) post fusion. In conclusion, this study showed that young in vitro-matured bovine oocytes sequentially activated with calcium ionophore and cycloheximide have cytoplasmic chromatin material adjacent to the second polar body, leading to a high enucleation rate.

Development and application of technology for large scale cloning of cattle

Mammalian cloning technologies originally developed as methods of testing hypotheses about the mechanisms of cell differentiation. Embryo splitting procedures demonstrated that each of the cells in the early embryo are capable of developing into a complete new individual. Nuclear transplantation technologies have shown that loss of genetic sequences or even irreversible repression of gene function are also not mechanisms of cell differentiation. Therefore, both of these methods can be used for producing genetically identical animals. Nuclear transplantation has the advantage of being able to produce unlimited numbers of identical offspring. Highly efficient procedures have been developed for nuclear transplantation in mammals and several important characteristics of donor cells have been described. Unfortunately, the efficiency of producing cloned offspring is still low and many factors affecting the development of nuclear transfer embryos to term remain to be investigated. The tremendous potential of the technology for use in agriculture and medicine, however, will ensure that these problems are addressed and solved.

Nuclear transfer in mammals: recent developments and future perspectives

A clone can be defined as a set of genetically identical animals. Small clones of two or occasionally up to four identical animals can be obtained by embryo splitting or blastomere separation. Embryo cloning by nuclear transfer involves the transfer of genetic material from a donor cell (karyoplast) to the cytoplasm of an oocyte or zygote from which the genetic material has been removed (cytoplast). In farm animals, metaphase II oocytes are most widely used as cytoplasts. There are now many factors known to influence the efficiency of embryo cloning by nuclear transfer. These include stage of development and cell cycle of donor cells, the choice of the recipient cell, the methods for activation of oocytes, the cell cycle coordination between donor cell and recipient cytoplast, and the method for fusion between nuclear donor and recipient cytoplast. Recent progress in cloning embryos and animals from cultured cells of embryonic, fetal, or adult origin offers a wide spectrum of potential applications of nuclear transfer, such as the unlimited multiplication of elite embryos or animals from selected matings and the potential for precise genetic modification of farm animals for gene farming or xenotransplantation.

The effect of recipient oocyte volume on nuclear transfer in cattle

This study compared the developmental potential of bovine nuclear transfer embryos with varying amounts of cytoplasm. Embryos formed from single cytoplasts fused to blastomeres by a single electrical pulse or from double cytoplasts using a double electrical pulse resulted in reconstituted embryos containing 75% and 150% of the original oocyte volume. No differences in fusion, cleavage, or development rates to blastocysts were observed between the groups. Mean cell numbers 2 days after fusion were significantly lower in single-cytoplast clones. Cell numbers of resulting blastocysts were likewise significantly lower in single-cytoplast clones. Embryos formed by fusion of blastomeres with single cytoplasts using a single electrical pulse or from double cytoplasts using either a single or a double pulse resulted in reconstituted embryos containing 50%, 100% and 100% of the original oocyte volume. Again, no differences in fusion or cleavage rates were observed between groups, but the development to blastocysts at day 7 was significantly higher in double cytoplasts constructed with one fusion pulse than in single cytoplasts (P < 0.05). Mean cell numbers 2 days after fusion were significantly lower in single-cytoplast clones (P < 0.05), but at the blastocyst stage, no statistically significant differences in cell numbers were observed. The results of this study show that cytoplasmic volume plays a role in the development of nuclear transfer embryos. When using crude enucleation methods such as oocyte bisection, normal cytoplasmic volumes can be achieved by fusing double cytoplasts with embryonic blastomeres.

Cloning: new breakthroughs leading to commercial opportunities

Research on cloning animals, again, came to the forefront of public attention in 1997. Most scientists involved in biomedical and agricultural research have emphasized the benefits, of which there are many, of cloning to the public. Basic studies on nuclear transfer have and will continue to contribute to our understanding of how genomic activation and cell cycle synchrony affect nuclear reprogramming and cloning efficiencies, specifically. Also, more basic information on actual mechanisms and specific factors in the oocyte causing nuclear reprogramming is forthcoming. As new molecular approaches in functional genomics are combined with nuclear transfer experiments, new genes involved in nuclear reprogramming will be found. The commercial potentials of products stemming from discoveries in cloning are vast. Cloning will be a more efficient, faster and more useful way of making transgenic fetuses for cell therapies, adult animals for protein production and organs for xenotransplantation. Clearly there are new opportunities in animal cloning technology that will produce many benefits to society.

Influence of combined activation treatments on the success of bovine nuclear transfer using young or aged oocytes

This study was determined if the combined activation of young or aged oocytes influence their development. The 16-cell stage in vitro maturation/fertilization embryos were exposed to 10 microL nocodazole for 18-20 h, blastomeres that divided within 3 h after the release from nocodazole were used as synchronized donor blastomeres. Metaphase II oocytes were enucleated at 20-22 h post onset of maturation. Enucleated oocytes were divided into 2 groups: oocytes activated at 24 h (young) and oocytes activated at 38 h (aged). In both groups (young and aged), one group of oocytes was activated in 7% ethanol alone for 5 min (alone) and the other group (combination) was activated in ethanol and subsequently incubated in 5 micrograms/ml cycloheximide in TCM199 for 6 h (combination). Electrofusion was carried out at 30 h (young) and 44 h (aged). The nuclear morphology of the blastomere-oocyte complexes at 1 h post-fusion and their development to the blastocyst stage after 6 days of culture in modified synthetic oviduct fluid were examined. Interphase and swollen nuclei were observed at 1 h post-fusion following nuclear transfer to the cytoplasm from young oocytes of combined activation and aged oocytes of combined and ethanol alone activation. When young oocytes were treated with the combined activation method, the reconstituted embryos had a significantly higher developmental rate to the blastocyst stage than the aged oocyte groups (P < 0.05). We conclude that the combined activation of young oocytes leads to a more efficient development of bovine nuclear transfer embryos.

Karyoplast-cytoplast volume ratio in bovine nuclear transfer embryos: effect on developmental potential

To evaluate the effect of karyoplast-cytoplast ratio on the development of nuclear transfer embryos, karyoplasts from day 4, day 5, and day 6 embryos were transferred to oocytes enucleated with different volumes of cytoplasm: Type 1, removal of a small volume of cytoplasm equivalent to the first polar body, Type 2, removal of a volume of cytoplasm approximately equal to the volume of the respective karyoplast, and Type 3, removal of half of the oocyte volume. In addition, the effect of experimental reduction of karyoplast cytoplasm was investigated in day 4 and day 5 karyoplasts. Intact day 4 karyoplasts fused to Type 3 cytoplasts did not support development to blastocysts, whereas these karyoplasts yielded blastocysts in combination with Type 1 (7%) and Type 2 cytoplasts (12%). After experimental reduction of cytoplasmic volume in day 4 karyoplasts, blastocysts (10%) were also obtained after fusion with Type 3 cytoplasts, probably due to reduction of cytoplasmic chimerism. With day 5 karyoplasts, blastocyst rate was higher in combination with Type 2 (34%) than with Type 1 (19%) and Type 3 cytoplasts (16%; P < 0.05). The use of day 6 intact karyoplasts resulted in a significantly (P < 0.05) higher proportion of blastocysts when fused with Type 2 (38%) or Type 1 cytoplasts (34%) than with Type 3 cytoplasts (16%). These results suggest that enucleation of oocytes with a volume similar to that of the respective karyoplast creates better conditions for cell cycle interactions with all types of karyoplasts than enucleation with minimal or large volume of cytoplasm.

Cloning of bovine embryos by multiple nuclear transfer

The in vitro development of multiple generation bovine nuclear transferred embryos to blastocysts and their survival ability after freezing and thawing were examined. Parent donor embryos which had 20 to 50 cells were recovered from superovulated cows. Follicular oocytes matured in vitro were used as recipient oocytes. The recipient oocytes enucleated at 22 to 24 h after the onset of maturation were preactivated at 33 h. Enucleated oocytes with a donor blastomere were fused 9 h after activation by an electric stimulus and the fused oocytes were cultured in vitro (first generation). Reconstituted oocytes that had developed to the 8- to 16-cell stage 3 to 4 d after fusion were used as donor embryos for the next generation. Recloning procedures were performed twice (second and third generations). The proportion of recipient oocytes successfully fused with a blastomere increased with the cycle of nuclear transfer. Eighty to 86% of fused oocytes developed to the 2-cell stage and there was no significant difference with the generation. The proportion of reconstituted embryos receiving blastomeres derived from first generation embryos had higher developmental ability in vitro, than those derived from other generations (43 vs 31% for 8 to 16-cell stage, 37 vs 20 and 21% for blastocyst stage). The number of cloned blastocysts increased with repeated nuclear transfer (once: 6.2 +/- 4.3, twice: 19.8 +/- 9.2 and three times: 30.0 +/- 14.7) but varied greatly with each parent donor embryo. The in vitro viability of cloned blastocysts after freezing and thawing (59%) was low but not significantly different from that obtained for in vitro fertilized blastocysts (72%). After transfer of either fresh or frozen-thawed cloned blastocysts to 21 recipients, 10 of them were pregnant on Day 60. Four and 3 offspring were produced from 20 fresh and 14 frozen-thawed blastocysts,respectively.

Production of identical sextuplet mice by transferring metaphase nuclei from four-cell embryos

Mouse clones were produced by serial nuclear transfer commencing with the transfer of four-cell nuclei at metaphase into unfertilized ooplasts. The donor four-cell-stage nuclei were synchronized in metaphase with nocodazole. The oocytes receiving a four-cell nucleus at metaphase formed two nuclei after artificial activation and inhibition of cytokinesis with cytochalasin B. To obtain embryos with diploid sets of chromosomes, nuclei from each reconstructed embryo were transferred individually into separate enucleated fertilized one-cell embryos, thus doubling the number of identical embryos. This procedure produced a high frequency of development of reconstructed embryos to the blastocyst stage. Of 11 sets of identical embryos produced by serial nuclear transplantation, 83% developed into blastocysts, including three sets of identical septuplet blastocysts. After transfer to recipient mice, a total of 25 (57%) live young were obtained, which included one set of identical sextuplet and two sets of identical quadruplet mice.

Reducing the amount of cytoplasm available for early embryonic development decreases the quality but not quantity of embryos produced by in vitro fertilization and nuclear transplantation

The effect of reducing the amount of cytoplasm available for early embryonic development was investigated in embryos produced by in vitro fertilization (IVF) and nuclear transplantation. In Experiment 1, approximately 1/2 or 1/20 of the cytoplasm was removed from bovine embryos at the pronuclear-stage of development. The percentage of embryos developing to the compact morula or blastocyst stage was significantly higher in non-manipulated controls (26%) than in embryos with 1/20 of the cytoplasm removed (16%), and those with 1/2 of the cytoplasm removed (10%; P < 0.05). There was also a significant difference in the average number of cells between blastocysts in which 1/20 of their cytoplasm was removed (67), those with 1/2 of their cytoplasm removed (55), and nonmanipulated controls (77; P < 0.05). In Experiment 2, nuclear transfer embryos were produced in which approximately 1/2 or 1/20 of the cytoplasm was removed during oocyte enucleation. The percentage of embryos developing to the blastocyst stage was 17% for both groups of nuclear transfer embryos compared to 44% for control embryos (P < 0.05). The mean number of cells in blastocysts produced by nuclear transfer in which 1/20 of the cytoplasm was removed during oocyte enucleation (61) was no different than that in control embryos (66), but significantly higher than the mean number of cells in blastocysts produced by nuclear transfer in which 1/2 of the cytoplasm was removed (42; P < 0.05). There was no indication that altering the amount of cytoplasm available for early embryonic development of IVF embryos affected the timing of differentiation events, including those of embryo compaction and blastocyst formation.

Viability of cloned bovine embryos after one or two cycles of nuclear transfer and in vitro culture

We described an exclusively in vitro procedure for cloning and recloning bovine embryos. Embryos obtained by IVM/IVF/IVC developed to the morula stage were used as blastomere donors in cunjunction with IVM recipient oocytes. Reconstructed embryos were developed in vitro in co-culture using bovine oviductal epithelial cells. The resulting morulae were used as donors for recloning under the same experimental conditions. No significant difference was observed between cloning and recloning in terms of development (rates of blastocysts: 12.9 versus 14.9%), in the number of nuclei per blastocyst (63.8 versus 49.1), or in pregnancy rates (35.7 versus 33.3%). The high variability observed between replicates and the correlation between results in first and second cycle nuclear transfer may suggest an inherant potential of individual donor embryos to support development by cloning.

Effect of donor embryo cell number and cell size on the efficiency of bovine embryo cloning

To establish reliable criteria for the evaluation of nuclear donor embryos, we studied the effect of cell number and cell size of in vitro produced day 6 donor morulae on the rate of blastocyst formation following nuclear transfer to in vitro matured oocytes. In experiment 1, donor embryos were divided into three groups with low (25-34), intermediate (40-55), and high (60-81) blastomere numbers. Transfer of nuclei from day 6 morulae with intermediate and high cell numbers resulted in a significantly higher blastocyst rate (31% and 32%, respectively) than use of nuclei from day 6 morulae with low cell numbers (17%) or nuclei from day 7 morulae with 50-83 blastomeres (19%). This suggests that blastomeres from the developmentally advanced day 6 morulae are more viable than blastomeres from retarded embryos. In experiment 2, we evaluated the effect of blastomere size in day 6 donor morulae with intermediate (40-55) or high (60-81) cell numbers on the efficiency of nuclear transfer. In both classes of embryos, small blastomeres were better nuclear donors than large blastomeres. The rates of development to the blastocyst stage were 28% versus 15% (40-55 cells) and 41% versus 25% (60-81 cells), suggesting that small blastomeres include a higher proportion of totipotent cells than the polarized large blastomeres. Our results demonstrate that blastomere number and size markedly affect the efficiency of nuclear transfer and therefore are useful criteria for evaluating nuclear donor embryos. These parameters are easy to determine and may therefore be helpful to improve the efficiency of cattle cloning.

Developmental ability of bovine embryos after nuclear transfer based on the nuclear source: In vivo versus in vitro

Bovine nuclear transfer embryos reconsitituted from in vitro-matured recipient oocyte cytoplasm and different sources of donor nuclei (in vivo, in vitro-produced or frozen-thawed) were evaluated for their ability to develop in vitro. Their cleavage rate and blastocyst formation are compared with those of control IVF embryos derived from the same batches of in vitro-matured oocytes that were used for nuclear transfer and were co-cultured under the same conditions on bovine oviducal epithelial cell monolayers for 7 d. Using fresh donor morulae as the source of nuclei resulted in 30.2% blastocyst formation (150 497 ), which was similar to that of control IVM-IVF embryos (33.8% blastocysts, 222 657 ). When IVF embryos were used as the source of nuclei for cloning, a slightly lower blastocyst formation rate (22.6%, 41 181 ) was obtained but not significantly different from that using fresh donor morulae. Nuclear transfer embryos derived from vitrified donor embryos showed poor development in vitro (7.1%, 11 154 ). No difference in morphology or cell number was observed after 7 d of co-culture between blastocysts derived from nuclear transfer or control IVF embryos. The viability of 34 in vitro-developed nuclear transfer blastocysts was tested in vivo and resulted in the birth of 11 live calves (32.3%).

Parthenogenetic development of bovine oocytes matured in vitro for 24 hr and activated by ethanol and cycloheximide

This research was undertaken to improve development of parthenogenetic embryos following various combined treatments of ethanol and cycloheximide. In Experiment 1 in vitro matured oocytes (IVM, 24 hr) were treated with 7% ethanol for 5 min followed by incubation in 10 micrograms/ml cycloheximide in Medium 199 for 0 (control), 5, 10, and 20 hr. Development to 2-8 cells following culture for 3 days was similar among treated groups (32-41%; P > 0.05), which was higher than that of controls (6%; P < 0.05). Experiment 2 compared pre-ethanol exposures for 0, 1, 2.5, and 5 min, followed by 5 hr cycloheximide treatment on activation development. One- to 5-min groups resulted in 42-44% cleavage contrasted to 1-12% for controls (P < 0.05). Experiment 3 examined the effect on oocyte development of ethanol and different concentrations of cycloheximide (0, 1, 5, and 10 micrograms/ml). Cleavage to 2-8 cells was similar among the 5 and 10 micrograms/ml cycloheximide groups (36% and 42%, P > 0.05) but lower (P < 0.05) for the 1 micrograms/ml group (24%) and the controls (2-13%). When 5 micrograms/ml cycloheximide was used (Experiment 4), pre-exposure to ethanol (1, 2.5, and 5 min) resulted in more oocytes cleaved (38-41%) than in the cycloheximide alone group (0%) or the control (0%, P < 0.05). Experiment 5 tested blastocyst development of the activated oocytes with or without cytochalasin B treatment.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)