Assessment of hyperacute rejection in a rat-to-primate cardiac xenograft model

The role of macrophages in xenograft rejection

Safe and effective xenotransplantation would provide a valuable answer to many of the limitations of allogenic transplantation. Such limitations include scarcity of organ supply and morbidity to donors in cases of living-related donor transplantation. The main hurdle to the efficacious application of xenotransplantation in clinical medicine is the fierce host immune response to xenografts. This immune response is embodied in 3 different types of xenograft rejection. Both hyperacute rejection and delayed xenograft rejection are mediated by natural antibodies and are concerned primarily with whole organ rejection. Cellular xenograft rejection (CXR), on the other hand, is concerned with both whole organ and CXR and is mediated by innate immunity rather than natural antibodies. Macrophages, which are cells of the innate immune system, play a role in all 3 types of xenograft rejection (not just CXR). They impart their effects both directly and through T-cell activation.

Animal models in xenotransplantation

The severe shortage of donor organs has provided a strong impetus to push the investigation into the use of animal organs for humans. Xenotransplantation will not only benefit patients, but also represents a unique and potentially profitable business opportunity. However, there are many barriers to successful clinical xenotransplantation, including immunological barriers, physiological incompatibility, zoonosis and ethical concerns. This overview will focus on currently available animal models used in attempts to break through the immunological barriers to xenotransplantation. There are many advantages to using small animal, namely rodent, models in xenotransplantation research. For example, the use of the mouse model allows the use of knockout mice and careful dissection of rejection mechanisms at the molecular level. The following models can be used to study hyperacute rejection (HAR): guinea-pig-to-rat, mouse-to-rabbit, guinea-pig-to-mouse, rat-to-presensitised mouse and rat-to-alpha-Gal knockout mouse. The hamster-to-rat, mouse-to-rat and rat-to-mouse models are commonly used to study acute vascular rejection. Large animal models are complex and expensive, but they are more relevant to clinical xenotransplantation. Based on experiments using transgenic pig-to-primate models, HAR can be overcome. However, acute vascular rejection remains a major barrier at the present time. A pig cartilage-to-monkey model has been developed to study chronic rejection. Other novel models such as pig venous segment-to-monkey model and rat-to-primate model may represent viable options to study immunological barriers following xenotransplantation. Like many other medical breakthroughs, animal research will continue to make enormous contributions towards the eventual success of xenotransplantation.

Review of significant microvascular surgical breakthroughs involving the heart and lungs in rats

Models of transplantation of the heart and lung in the rat have been important in determining the mechanisms of rejection and their treatment. Reviewed here are several important milestones contributing to the current state of the art of clinical heart and lung transplantation.

Interaction of anti-HLA antibodies with pig xenoantigens

BACKGROUND

Many patients with renal failure are condemned to long-term dialysis with little prospect of transplantation because they are highly sensitized with immunoglobulin G (IgG) directed against class I human leukocyte antigens (HLA) of virtually all donors. Xenotransplantation could represent an attractive solution providing their alloantibodies (alloAb) do not recognize porcine motifs. Hitherto there has been no in vivo demonstration of any cross-reactivity and the objective of this work was to investigate this problem using a technique of extracorporeal pig kidney perfusion as a model of clinical xenografting.

METHODS

Pig kidneys were perfused ex vivo with plasma from both a group of highly sensitized patients and healthy individuals. Sequential plasma samples were analyzed for the titer of anti-Galalpha1-3Gal antibody (Ab) (major natural xenoreactive Ab) by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and anti-HLA class I Ab against a cell panel. At the end of perfusion, kidneys were perfused with a citric acid buffer to elute bound Ab.

RESULTS

Galalpha1-3Gal Ab were shown to decrease rapidly in the plasma (in less than 10 min) and then reached a plateau. A fractional decrease in anti-HLA Ab was also found in some of the perfused plasma samples. Anti-Gal Ab were readily detected in all citric acid perfusates and anti-HLA Ab in 8 of 10. The HLA specificities of eluted Ab were mainly concordant with the originally designated specificities for each patient.

CONCLUSION

Anti-HLA class I Ab presumably cross-react with pig class I homologues. However, some plasma samples did not cross-react, suggesting that negatively cross-matched pig kidneys could be identified in the pig population for xenotransplantation in these patients. Further studies are required to precisely describe these cross-reactivities and to understand their functional significance in xenotransplantation.

Mouse-to-rabbit xenotransplantation: a new small animal model of hyperacute rejection mediated by the classical complement pathway

BACKGROUND

Hyperacute rejection of porcine organs transplanted into primate recipients is initiated by the binding of preformed xenoreactive natural antibodies to the vascular endothelium of the graft and activation of the classical complement pathway. Several small animal models are currently employed to study various aspects of xenograft rejection; however, none has been shown to manifest hyperacute rejection mediated by the classical pathway of complement activation.

METHODS

We performed heterotopic mouse heart transplants into weanling rabbits, adult rabbits, and C6-deficient rabbits. The recipients received no immunosuppression. Rejected grafts were subjected to histologic analysis and immunofluorescence staining for rabbit IgG, IgM, and C3. Levels of preexisting cytotoxic antibodies as well as classical and alternative complement pathway activities were determined in rabbit serum using mouse red cells as targets.

RESULTS

Mean graft survival was 37+/-9.6 min for mouse-to-weanling rabbit transplants (n=10), and 40+/-11.1 min for mouse-to-adult rabbit transplants (n=5). Rejected grafts showed diffuse interstitial hemorrhage, endothelial cell damage, myocyte necrosis, moderate diffuse deposition of rabbit IgG, and dense deposition of rabbit IgM and C3 on the vascular endothelium of the graft, consistent with hyperacute rejection. One mouse-to-C6-deficient rabbit transplant was rejected at 21 hr with severe interstitial hemorrhage, cellular necrosis and a moderate cellular infiltrate consisting primarily of neutrophils and some mononuclear cells. A second transplant in a C6-deficient rabbit was functioning when the recipient died at 6.5 hr as a result of complications of surgery; the graft had normal myocytes and vasculature with minimal spotty interstitial hemorrhage. Both weanling and adult rabbit serum were found to have high titers of cytotoxic IgM anti-mouse antibodies and strong classical complement pathway activity with minimal alternative pathway activity towards mouse red cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The mouse-to-rabbit species combination manifests hyperacute xenograft rejection. In vitro studies suggest that this process is mediated by IgM anti-mouse natural antibodies and activation of the classical pathway of complement.

Anti-xenograft immune responses in alpha 1,3-galactosyltransferase knock-out mice

Although originally generated to test the effect of eliminating the alpha-Gal epitope on HAR, it is becoming increasingly clear that GalT KO mice offer a convenient and inexpensive model to investigate many aspects of the anti-xenorgraft immune response. Clearly, not all aspects of anti-xenograft rejection responses are identical in mice and primates, which should be kept in mind when interpreting results of GalT KO mouse studies. However, with this and other mouse models it is possible to test a large number of variables, which is impractical for both logistical and financial reasons with primates. Furthermore the short gestation time and large litter size of mice means that genetic strategies targeting different aspects of the anti-xenograft immune response can be combined and subsequently tested to identify the optimal combination of genetic and therapeutic approaches to achieve long term xenograft survival. In this regard the GalT KO mouse has been and will continue to be a valuable small animal model for the study of all facets of xenograft rejection involving anti-Gal antibodies.

Genetic engineering in the pig. Gene knockout and alternative techniques

Since endothelial cells (EC) are the major target cells during hyperacute rejection and are likely in delayed graft rejection, most of the genetic engineering of the xenotransplant donor is aimed at modifying their properties. Among the various strategies that are reviewed are the genotypic or phenotypic knockout of the alpha 1,3Gal antigen, which is a major target of xenoantibodies and is also probably involved in innate cellular response. In addition, the success of the transgeny of complement regulatory proteins is well established. In vitro data from analyses of the mechanisms of endothelial cell activation also suggest that other molecules could be used to regulate apoptosis or thrombotic microenvironment or to minimize recipient T-cell activation by inhibiting costimulatory proteins such as CD40 or B7. Alternative to usual knockout techniques (thus far not available in pigs, where no ES cells have been derived) will be presented.

Antibodies to human adhesion molecules and von Willebrand factor: in vitro cross-species reactivity in the xenotransplantation setting

Endothelial cell activation is thought to play an important role in xenograft rejection through cell retraction and expression of pro-coagulant and pro-inflammatory factors. Identification of antibodies recognizing porcine endothelial molecules would be useful to study and manipulate the inflammatory response to a xenograft. The aim of this study was to investigate the cross-reactivity of antibodies directed against human adhesion molecules and von Willebrand factor (vWF). Binding of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) directed against human CD3 1, CD44, CD49, CD54, CD62E, CD102, and CD106 was evaluated on resting and activated endothelial cells from human and pig by flow cytometry. Among 30 antibodies tested, 4 were shown to react with pig cells. Two of them, directed against human CD62E (E-selectin) and rabbit CD106 (VCAM-1) reacted strongly with activated and/or resting pig cells, whereas two others, directed to human CD31 (PECAM) and CD44 (H-CAM), bound weakly to pig cells. In addition, we analyzed the cross-reactivity of five polyclonal or monoclonal antibodies to human or pig vWF with human, baboon, rhesus, pig, and rat vWF. Binding of antibodies was tested by ELISA by using platelet lysates as source of vWF from the different species. Four anti-human or porcine vWF antibodies exhibited a broad reactivity with vWF from all species, whereas one anti-human vWF antibody was specific for primate vWF. In this study, we identified a small number of cross-reacting antibodies that may prove useful to study in vitro and in vivo xenogeneic responses. However, the weak antibody cross-reactivity observed with most porcine molecules points out the necessity of producing species-specific antibodies to study the immune response to xenografts or for use as specific immunosuppressive therapeutic reagents.

Anti-Gal antibody-mediated allograft rejection in alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase gene knockout mice: a model of delayed xenograft rejection

BACKGROUND

The key role of anti-galactose alpha1,3-galactose (anti-alphaGal) xenoantibodies in initiating hyperacute xenograft rejection has been clearly demonstrated using a variety of in vitro and in vivo approaches. However, the role of anti-alphaGal antibodies in mediating post-hyperacute rejection mechanisms, such as antibody-dependent cellular cytoxicity, remains to be determined, primarily because of the lack of a small animal model with which to study this phenomena.

METHODS

Hearts from wild-type mice were transplanted heterotopically into alpha1,3-galactosyltransferase knockout (Gal KO) mice, which like humans develop antibodies to the disaccharide galactose alpha1,3-galactose (Gal). At the time of rejection, hearts were examined histologically to determine the mechanism of rejection.

RESULTS

Hearts from wild-type mice transplanted into high-titer anti-alphaGal recipients were rejected in 8-13 days. Histological examination demonstrated a cellular infiltrate consisting of macrophages (80-90%), natural killer cells (5-10%), and T cells (1-5%). In contrast, wild-type hearts transplanted into low anti-Gal titer recipients demonstrated prolonged (>90 day) survival. However, a significant proportion (30-40%) of these underwent a minor rejection episode between 10 and 13 days, but then recovered ("accommodated").

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggest that the Gal KO mouse is a useful small animal vascularized allograft model, in which the role of anti-alphaGal antibody in graft rejection can be studied in isolation from other rejection mechanisms. The titer of anti-alphaGal antibody was found to be the critical determinant of rejection. The histopathological features of rejection in this model are very similar to other models of delayed xenograft rejection, in both the timing and composition of the cellular infiltrate. The Gal KO mouse therefore provides a new rodent model, which will aid in the identification of the distinct components involved in the pathogenesis of delayed xenograft rejection.

Controlling the complement system in inflammation

Inappropriate or excessive activation of the complement system can lead to harmful, potentially life-threatening consequences due to severe inflammatory tissue destruction. These consequences are clinically manifested in various disorders, including septic shock, multiple organ failure and hyperacute graft rejection. Genetic complement deficiencies or complement depletion have been proven to be beneficial in reducing tissue injury in a number of animal models of severe complement-dependent inflammation. It is therefore believed that therapeutic inhibition of complement is likely to arrest the process of certain diseases. Attempts to efficiently inhibit complement include the application of endogenous soluble complement inhibitors (C1-inhibitor, recombinant soluble complement receptor 1- rsCR1), the administration of antibodies, either blocking key proteins of the cascade reaction (e.g. C3, C5), neutralizing the action of the complement-derived anaphylatoxin C5a, or interfering with complement receptor 3 (CR3, CD18/11b)-mediated adhesion of inflammatory cells to the vascular endothelium. In addition, incorporation of membrane-bound complement regulators (DAF-CD55, MCP-CD46, CD59) has become possible by transfection of the correspondent cDNA into xenogeneic cells. Thereby, protection against complement-mediated inflammatory tissue damage could be achieved in various animal models of sepsis, myocardial as well as intestinal ischemia/reperfusion injury, adult respiratory distress syndrome, nephritis and graft rejection. Supported by results from first clinical trials, complement inhibition appears to be a suitable therapeutic approach to control inflammation. Current strategies to specifically inhibit complement in inflammation have been discussed at a recent meeting on the 'Immune Consequences of Trauma, Shock and Sepsis', held from March 4-8, 1997, in Munich, Germany. The Congress (chairman: E. Faist, Munich, Germany), which was held in close cooperation with various national and international shock and trauma societies, was attended by about 2000 delegates from 40 countries. The major objective of the meeting was to provide an overview on the most state-of-the-art methods to prevent multiple organ dysfunction syndrome (MODS)/multiple organ failure (MOF) following the systemic inflammatory response (SIRS) to severe trauma. One of the largest symposia held within the Congress was devoted to current aspects of controlling complement in inflammation (for abstracts see: Shock 1997, 7 Suppl., 71-75). After providing the audience with information on the scientific background by addressing the clinical relevance of complement activation (G.O. Till, Ann Arbor, MI, USA) and discussing recent developments in modern complement diagnosis (J. Köhl, Hannover, Germany), B.P. Morgan (Cardiff, UK) introduced the symposium's special issue by giving an overview on complement regulatory molecules. Selected topics included overviews on the application of C1 inhibitor (C.E. Hack, Amsterdam, NL), sCR1 (U.S. Ryan, Needham, MA, USA), antibodies to C5 (Y. Wang, New Haven CT, USA) and to the anaphylatoxin C5a (M. Oppermann, Göttingen, Germany), and a report on complement inhibition in cardiopulmonary bypass (T.E. Mollnes, Bodø, Norway). The growing interest of clinicians in complement-directed anti-inflammatory therapy, and the fact that only some of the various aspects of therapeutic complement inhibition could be addressed on the meeting, has motivated the author to expand a Congress report into a short comprehensive review on recent strategies to control complement in inflammation.

Comparative study of target antigens for primate xenoreactive natural antibodies in pig and rat endothelial cells

BACKGROUND

A rat-to-primate cardiac xenograft model has been proposed as an alternative to the clinically relevant but more cumbersome pig-to-primate model for assessing the efficacy of strategies aimed at preventing xenograft hyperacute rejection. As in pig xenografts, the rejection of rat hearts was mediated by the binding of xenoreactive natural antibodies (XNA) and complement activation. The present study was conducted to identify target antigens recognized by cynomolgus and rhesus monkey IgM XNA on rat tissues and cells in comparison with pig cells.

METHODS

The reactivity of rhesus or cynomolgus serum on pig and rat endothelial cells (ECs) was studied by flow cytometry, ELISA, and complement-dependent cytotoxicity, after removal of primate XNA by perfusion of pig livers, immunoadsorption on a Gal alpha(1,3)Gal affinity column, and enzymatic removal of alpha-galactosyl epitopes from the cell surface. Rat and pig EC extracts were also immunoprecipitated with primate serum and resolved in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The expression of the Gal alpha(1,3)Gal epitope was analyzed on rat tissues and ECs by immunohistochemistry, flow cytometry, and Western blot, using the isolectin B4 from Griffonia simplicifolia.

RESULTS

Removal of primate XNA or of alphaGal epitopes resulted in a decrease in XNA binding to pig and rat cells, leaving a similar degree of residual reactivity in the two species. At least five proteins of 260, 210, 110, 56, and 50 kDa were immunoprecipitated on rat ECs, with molecular weight similar to several proteins identified on pig ECs. These results suggest that primate XNA recognize similar antigens on rat and pig ECs. Rat cells expressed lower levels of the Gal alpha(1,3)Gal epitope than pig cells. A large proportion, but not all, of primate XNA react with this epitope on pig and rat ECs.

CONCLUSION

This study suggests that the rat is a valuable species for the evaluation of genetic engineering strategies on the vascular endothelium aimed at preventing hyperacute xenograft rejection.

Analysis of human CD59 tissue expression directed by the CMV-IE-1 promoter in transgenic rats

The investigation of human complement (C) inhibitors with a view to overcoming C-mediated tissue injury stands to benefit from the production of anatomically suitable transgenic animals. In this study, we used the CMV-IE1 enhancer/promoter to control the expression in vivo in transgenic rats of the human terminal C protein inhibitor CD59. Five transgenic rats were identified, of which four possessed at least one complete copy of the transgene. The presence of human CD59 transcripts and protein was demonstrated in two transgenic rat lines. A widespread tissue distribution of cells expressing human CD59, similar in the two lines, was observed-principally in pancreas, brain, heart, kidney, intestine and striated muscle. Whereas expression in pancreas and brain was uniform, mosaicism of CD59 expression was observed in some tissues such as heart and kidney, a proportion of cells within the tissue not expressing the transgene. Immunohistological analysis revealed surface expression of human CD59 in a variety of cells, including fibroblasts, epithelial cells and muscle cells, but not in endothelial cells. In conclusion, this paper analyses at the cellular level human CD59 expression directed by the CMV promoter in transgenic rats, amd discusses how they could be used to investigate in vivo the role of C in a variety of pathologies.

Transgenesis in rats: technical aspects and models

The production of transgenic rats by DNA-microinjection into fertilized ova has now become an established procedure, although fewer than 20 lines have been described during the last 5 years. Overall, transgenic rats remain more difficult to produce than transgenic mice, but satisfactory yields have been obtained by several laboratories. A review of the methods used to generate transgenic rats shows considerable variation between different laboratories, particularly in choice of strain, superovulation protocols and the use of embryo culture before reimplantation. In some instances, the production of transgenic rats has provided data that are new and relevant, compared to data obtained in mice bearing the same transgene. Models have been developed for human diseases such as hypertension and autoimmunity, and applications have been found in the study of carcinogenesis and in pharmacological research. Transgenic rat technology also opens up interesting perspectives for transplantation research, in which microsurgery is an essential procedure. Intensive research is in progress in several laboratories to produce rat embryonic stem (ES) cell lines, but existing lines have not participated in germ line formation a prerequisite for their use in gene knock out experiments.