Apoptosis of mononuclear cell infiltrates in cardiac allograft biopsy specimens questions studies of biopsy-cultured cells

Apoptosis and acute cellular rejection in human heart transplants

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

Apoptosis has been implicated in the pathophysiology of various forms of heart disease. Acute cellular rejection leads to morbidity after heart transplantation and invasive techniques are needed for its diagnosis. We investigated the presence of cardiomyocyte apoptosis in transplanted hearts, its progression, its relationship with rejection, and the possibility that serological markers of apoptosis can be used to detect rejection noninvasively.

METHODS

Overall, 130 endomyocardial biopsies obtained sequentially from 14 consecutive patients during the first 6 months following heart transplantation underwent histochemical analysis. The degree of acute rejection was determined, myocyte apoptosis was assessed using the TUNEL method, and caspase-3 activity was measured. In the first 10 patients, soluble Fas, tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNFα) and interleukin 6 levels were determined in serum collected at biopsy.

RESULTS

Apoptotic cells were detected in 81.5% of biopsies. No significant correlation was found between the apoptotic index and either the degree of rejection or the time from transplantation; there was only a trend to higher values during prolonged episodes of rejection, which did not reach statistical significance. An inverse correlation was observed between the degree of rejection and the TNFα level (rs=-0.33; P=.003). There was no correlation with any other variable.

CONCLUSIONS

Cardiomyocyte loss due to apoptosis was observed in transplanted hearts, but no correlation was observed with either acute rejection or the time from transplantation. Our findings suggest there could be an inverse correlation between rejection and the serum TNFα level. No serum parameter evaluated was regarded as suitable for the noninvasive diagnosis of acute rejection.

Apollon/RNF41 myocardial messenger RNA diagnoses cardiac allograft apoptosis in rejection

BACKGROUND

Endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) remains the gold standard for acute cellular rejection (ACR) diagnosis in cardiac transplantation yet is subject to interobserver variability. A method that could avoid discordant EMB analysis would be desirable. The apoptosis rate in EMB correlates with ACR severity. Apollon inhibits apoptosis, and RNF41 catalyzes its degradation. Whether tissue Apollon/RNF41 could diagnose ACR is not known. This study addressed this issue.

METHODS

Apollon/RNF41 messenger RNA (mRNA) was measured by real time reverse-transcriptase polymerase chain reaction and apoptosis was quantified with TUNEL assays in EMBs of 268 transplant recipients. EMBs were obtained at 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 12, 24, and 52 posttransplant weeks.

RESULTS

At all time points posttransplant, Apollon mRNA decreased significantly in EMBs with ACR grades 2R/3R combined (P<or=0.0010) compared with 0/1R combined, although RNF41 mRNA significantly increased in EMBs with ACR grade 1R (P<0.0001) or 2R/3R combined (P<0.0001) compared with 0. At the identified cut-off level of less than or equal to 168.2 arbitrary units, Apollon mRNA identified ACR grades 2R/3R with 100% sensitivity and 84% specificity, whereas RNF41 mRNA at the cut-off level of more than or equal to 51.8 identified ACR grades 1R-3R with 99% sensitivity and 95% specificity. Increased RNF41 (rs, 0.728; P<0.0001) and decreased Apollon (rs, -0.562; P<0.0001) expression correlated significantly with the degree of apoptosis in EMBs.

CONCLUSIONS

Combined Apollon/RNF41 mRNA quantitatively and specifically identifies ACR associated with apoptosis in cardiac allografts and could validate ACR grading variability associated with histologic EMB analysis.

Expression of Fas, FasL, and Soluble Fas mRNA in Endomyocardial Biopsies of Human Cardiac Allografts

Apoptosis mediated by the Fas/Fas ligand (FasL) has been implicated in rejection of solid organ allografts and it has been recently proposed that soluble forms of Fas could interfere with this interaction, blocking apoptosis. The purpose of this study was to analyze intragraft Fas, FasL, and soluble Fas mRNA levels in relation to acute rejection in cardiac allografts in humans. mRNA levels were determined by quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction in 42 samples of endomyocardial biopsies obtained from 18 cardiac transplant recipients within the first 6 months after transplantation. FasL and Fas mRNA levels were higher in biopsies with rejection than in biopsies without rejection, and no difference was observed in soluble Fas mRNA. During rejection, there was a positive correlation between the mRNA levels of Fas-FasL, Fas-soluble Fas, and FasL-soluble Fas. During quiescent periods, however, the only correlation observed was between Fas and soluble Fas mRNA levels. In conclusion, our findings do not suggest a role for soluble Fas, confirm the heightened expression of FasL, and indicate, for the first time, an increased expression of Fas in acute rejection of cardiac allografts.

Apoptotic death of infiltrating cells in human cardiac allografts is regulated by IL-2, FASL, and FLIP

INTRODUCTION

In vitro studies have shown that apoptotic cell death is triggered by a IL-2-dependent activation of the Fas-FasL pathway and that this pathway can be inhibited by FLIP.

METHODS

To define whether FLIP regulates apoptotic death of graft infiltrating T-cells during IL-2-mediated rejection, we analyzed endomyocardial biopsies (EMB) from cardiac allograft recipients for CD3, DNA strand breaks (TUNEL assay), FLIP (mRNA and protein), and FasL mRNA expression.

RESULTS

Apoptosis was present in CD3+ T-cell infiltrates. The number of TUNEL-stained mononuclear cells was inversely correlated with FLIP mRNA expression levels (P=.09). FLIP protein was present in 5% to 10% of the infiltrating cells and was constitutively produced by cardiomyocytes irrespective of the rejection grade. Rejection biopsies had elevated IL-2 and FasL mRNA expression levels compared to the expression levels before and after acute rejection (P=.03 and P=.11), while FLIP mRNA expression levels were significantly decreased during rejection (P=.05).

CONCLUSION

Our results indicate that during the IL-2-induced rejection process, infiltrated T cells become more sensitive to apoptosis.

The relationship of nodular endocardial infiltrates (Quilty lesions) to survival, patient age, anti-HLA antibodies, and coronary artery disease following heart transplantation

BACKGROUND

Quilty lesions are mononuclear cell infiltrates identified in human heart transplant biopsies. The biologic significance of Quilty lesions remains undetermined.

METHODS

We monitored acute rejection by biopsy and lymphocyte growth assay (LGA) as well as transplant-related coronary artery disease (TRCAD) by yearly angiogram in 285 recipients of primary heart allografts. Patients showing Quilty lesions on biopsies during the first year posttransplant were compared with patients without such lesions. Recipients' sera were obtained at the time of biopsy and tested for anti-HLA Class I and II antibodies.

RESULTS

The actuarial survival of patients who developed Quilty lesions was significantly better than those who did not (P=.0074). Patients with Quilty lesions were younger and more likely to have a biopsy diagnosis of acute rejection (P=.002) and positive LGA (P<.0001) during the first posttransplant year. Among patients who do not form anti-HLA Class II antibodies, those with Quilty lesions were more likely than patients without Quilty lesions to develop TRCAD 5 years posttransplantation (P=.04). There was no correlation of Quilty status with the number of HLA donor-recipient mismatches or posttransplant development of anti-HLA antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Quilty formers showed improved survival and are more likely to be diagnosed with acute rejection on biopsy and have positive LGAs. Allograft recipients who do not form anti-HLA Class II antibodies but do form Quilty lesions are more likely to develop TRCAD by 5 years posttransplantation than those who do not form Quilty lesions.

Sustained apoptosis in human cardiac allografts despite histologic resolution of rejection1

BACKGROUND

We investigated the occurrence of apoptosis during and after resolution of cardiac allograft rejection. Apoptosis could play different roles in graft survival depending on the target cells; thus, we also determined the cell types involved.

METHODS

Endomyocardial biopsy specimens were evaluated during the first 6 months after transplantation as follows: group I, no current or prior rejection; group II, during an episode of moderate rejection; and group III, histologic resolution after an episode of moderate rejection.

RESULTS

Groups II and III showed significantly increased apoptotic activity, indicated by increased caspase-8 and caspase-3 activity; however, activated caspase-3 was undetectable in group I. Activated caspase-3 was detected only in groups II and III. Terminal deoxynucleotide transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling was detected in groups II and III but not group I and predominantly in inflammatory cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Increased caspase activity and apoptosis of infiltrating cells not only occurs during acute cardiac allograft rejection but persists after histologic resolution. Thus, programmed cell death occurs beyond the period of histologic resolution and may play a role in regulation of the rejection process.

Thymic re-entry of mature activated T cells and increased negative selection in vascularized allograft recipients

Transplantation tolerance is a dynamic state that involves several homeostatic mechanisms intrinsic to the host. One of these mechanisms is activation-induced T cell death (AICD). However, it is unclear where AICD takes place during alloreactive responses. Since activated T cells can re-enter the thymus, we hypothesized that mature T cells activated by an allograft could be deleted upon re-entry into the thymus. To test this hypothesis, we used wild-type or 2C TCR transgenic mice receiving syngeneic or allogeneic heterotopic, vascularized heart grafts. First, we demonstrated that ex vivo CFSE-labelled T cells re-entered the thymus when transferred into allograft recipients but not when transferred into isograft recipients. Next, we compared the changes in cell subset numbers and incidence of apoptosis in the thymi and spleens of allograft or isograft recipients. Seven days after transplantation, at a time in which all the allografts were undergoing rejection, cells expressing donor-MHC class II molecules had migrated to the thymus and to the spleen. In the thymus of allograft recipients, overall cellularity was significantly reduced by 40% and associated with an increase in the number of double negative (CD4-CD8-) thymocytes and a decrease in double positive (CD4+CD8+) thymocytes, consistent with increased negative selection of thymocytes. Additionally, thymi of allograft recipients showed an increase in the number of recently activated, mature T cells (TCRhi, CD25+, CD44+) and a significant increase in the number of apoptotic cells, especially in the thymic medulla, that involved mature T cells as indicated by the TCRhi, CD44+, CD4 or CD8 single positive phenotype. Spleens of allograft recipients were increased in size and cellularity but did not show any of the changes in cell subsets seen in the thymi. Our data show that after allografting there is an increase in apoptotic cell death that is associated with negative selection of developing thymocytes as well as of alloreactive mature T cells that have re-entered the thymus upon activation in the periphery. This may occur upon migration of graft-derived antigen-presenting cells to the thymus.

In vivo imaging of acute cardiac rejection in human patients using (99m)technetium labeled annexin V

Annexin V binds phosphatidylserine moieties on apoptotic cells. This study reports the initial experience at Stanford University Medical Center with 99mTc-labeled annexin V imaging as a noninvasive measure of apoptosis in acute cardiac rejection. Ten cardiac transplant patients had 99mTc Annexin V imaging and endomyocardial biopsy (EMB) performed within 24 h. No complications related to 99mTc annexin V administration occurred. Eight patients had ISHLT grade of acute rejection of 1A or less. Five patients had two or more areas of uptake noted in the right ventricle on imaging studies. Two of these patients had positive biopsies: one patient had grade 2 rejection with two focal uptake areas and another had grade 3A rejection with three foci. An additional five patients had either one or zero hot spot areas and corresponding negative EMBs. 99mTc-annexin V appears to be well tolerated and may identify patients with acute cardiac rejection.

APOPTOSIS IN CHRONIC REJECTION OF HUMAN CARDIAC ALLOGRAFTS1

BACKGROUND

We investigated the role of apoptosis (programed cell death) in the pathogenesis of chronic rejection.

METHODS

Epicardial coronary arteries from cardiac allografts with chronic rejection were examined for apoptosis by the TUNEL assay. Double labeling was carried out using anti-CD3, anti-CD68, and anti-von Willenbrand factor (vWF) monoclonal antibodies. Additional immunostaining was carried using anti-Fas, anti-Fas-L, and anti-Bcl-2 monoclonal antibodies. Apoptosis-associated oligonucleosomal DNA degradation was assessed by DNA agarose gel electrophoresis. The transcription level of apoptosis-related caspase genes were determined using microarrays.

RESULTS

Apoptotic cells (TUNEL+) were detected within the arterial wall and in perivascular areas. Double labeling demonstrated that apoptotic cells included T cells (CD3+), monocyte/macrophages (CD68+), and vascular endothelial cells (VWF+). Numbers and densities of TUNEL+ cells did not correlate with the degree of arterial stenosis. Apoptosis-associated oligonucleosomal DNA degradation was assessed by agarose gel electrophoresis of DNA, which showed DNA fragments of approximately 180 bp and multimers thereof (DNA laddering gel), which are characteristic for DNA fragmentation in apoptotic cells. Microarray analysis demonstrated that the apoptosis related caspases 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, were all transcribed (caspases 8, 9, and 10 were highly up-regulated). These results are consistent with the involvement of apoptosis in chronic rejection. Immunoreactivity for Fas/Fas-L was present at the sites of apoptotic cells. Immunoreactivity for Bcl-2 was present in areas with very few apoptotic cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Apoptotic cells include T cells, monocyte/macrophages, and endothelial cells. Apoptosis, likely through the Fas/Fas-L system, is involved in the pathogenesis of chronic rejection in cardiac allografts.

Apoptosis in cardiac transplant rejection

Apoptosis occurs in human cardiac allograft rejection and may occur with all degrees of rejection and even in its absence. The prevalence and severity of apoptosis is determined predominantly by the intensity of macrophage infiltration and may be mediated by NO-related mechanisms. Apoptosis of interstitial, endothelial, and inflammatory cells is also present in heart allografts and may influence the degree and extent of vascular injury contributing to allograft rejection. Ongoing apoptosis of inflammatory cells suggests an immunoregulatory role. Studies of the involvement of NO in myocyte damage and Fas-FasL interactions in peripheral tolerance have raised the exciting possibility that these pathways can be exploited in a beneficial way. Further understanding of the role of apoptosis and the cellular and biochemical mechanisms that are involved in cardiac myocyte death and in inflammatory, endothelial, and interstitial cell death may provide insights into therapeutic modalities to suppress allograft rejection and vasculopathy.

Fas (CD95, Apo-1) ligand gene transfer

Gene therapy represents a new form of medical intervention that relies on direct transfer of genetic materials into patients. Although initially envisioned as a treatment for genetic diseases, gene therapy is currently being explored for a wide range of acquired disorders including cancer, cardiovascular diseases, arthritis, and neurodegenerative disorders. Since most acquired diseases are not caused by single gene mutations, the choice of therapeutic genes is crucial for the success of the gene therapy. In this review, we discuss the progresses that have been made and problems that remain to be resolved in using Fas (CD95, Apo-1) ligand gene for the treatment of acquired disorders. Fas ligand is a member of the tumor necrosis factor family that can induce both apoptosis and activation of various cells. While Fas ligand gene transfer indeed eliminates cancer cells and inflammatory cells through apoptosis, it also kills normal cells and initiates inflammation in certain tissues. Thus, new strategies that can modify the apoptotic or proinflammatory activities of the FasL will help to fully realize the potential of the FasL gene therapy.

Prolonged survival of heart allografts from p53-deficient mice

BACKGROUND

Acute rejection of the heart allograft is the major cause of heart failure in the first month after transplantation. Most studies on the prevention of acute rejection have concentrated on immune suppression of the recipients, whereas little is known about the effects of genetically manipulated donor organs on heart allograft survival. Herein, we describe a mouse model of heart allografts donated by p53-/- mice that can prolong the survival time of the grafts.

METHODS

Hearts of p53-/- or p53+/+ C57BL/6J mice were grafted to the neck carotid artery and jugular vein of BALB/c mice using a cuff technique. The graft survival was observed daily. The hearts were analyzed using several techniques, including histology, immunofluorescence, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling (TUNEL), and Western blot analysis.

RESULTS

p53+/+ allografts ceased beating at 7.6+/-0.5 days, whereas p53-/- hearts were beating at 10.5+/-1.1 days after transplantation (P<0.01). Mean histological rejection scores were significantly lower in allografts donated by p53-deficient mice. Furthermore, apoptotic cells, determined by TUNEL and a reagent kit for detection of cardiac apoptosis, were of high numbers in the allograft sections from wild-type hearts but rare in p53-/- allografts (4.2+/-1.3 vs. 0.7+/-0.5/250x field). Immunofluorescence staining and Western blot analysis revealed that high levels of p53 and proapoptotic protein Bax were expressed in wild-type grafts but not p53-/- allografts. Interestingly, Bcl-2, an antiapoptotic protein, was abundant in cardiac allografts from p53-/- mice and almost undetectable in grafts from wild-type mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus, p53 is involved in cardiac apoptosis induced by alloimmune reaction, and prolonged survival of heart allografts can be achieved when p53 is lacking.

Involvement of Fas-Fas ligand interactions in graft rejection

The Fas/Fas ligand (FasL) pathway has been shown to be important in T lymphocyte-mediated cell death and is a key peripheral immunoregulatory mechanism that limits expansion of antigen-activated lymphocytes. The expression of Fas by commonly transplanted organs such as the heart, lung, kidney, and liver suggests that these tissues may be targets of FasL-expressing allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocytes. In this review the current literature examining the Fas/FasL system as a potential cellular effector pathway in tissue injury is discussed. In addition to a deleterious role in destruction of graft tissue, Fas/FasL interactions may have a beneficial role in transplantation. Recent studies suggest that modulation of FasL in target tissue leads to deletion, via apoptosis, of graft infiltrating lymphoid cells. However, an equally compelling series of reports indicate that overexpression of FasL can lead to a heightened immune response. These data are reviewed in the context of strategies to achieve long term allograft survival.

T cell apoptosis in human heart allografts: association with lack of co-stimulation?

It is unclear whether the intracardial immune reactivity after heart transplantation influences the peripheral immunological status (activation or nonresponsiveness) of the patient. Co-stimulation and activation-induced cell death (AICD) or apoptosis play an important role in determining the balance between lymphocyte reactivity and nonreactivity. Therefore, we studied the expression of co-stimulatory molecules and the process of apoptosis in biopsies of human heart allografts, using immunohistochemistry. Although a normal expression of co-stimulatory molecules on antigen-presenting cells was observed, the expression of their counter-structures on T cells was absent. This may be due to chronic T cell activation, which can lead to the induction of apoptosis via the Fas/Fas ligand pathway. In the infiltrates, a considerable percentage of the lymphocytes, but not the macrophages, were apoptotic. Apoptosis was confirmed by DNA fragmentation analysis. Increased numbers of Bax-expressing versus decreased numbers of Bcl2-expressing lymphocytes in comparison with normal lymphoid tissue confirmed a imbalance in favor of apoptosis. Apoptosis was biased towards CD4+ T cells (65.7% versus 26.6% in CD8+ T cells). Fas was expressed on most of the infiltrating cells. Fas ligand expression was also observed, not only on most of the T cells but also on all macrophages. Because macrophages were often detected in close contact with T cells, they may play a role in T cell regulation via the Fas/Fas ligand pathway. This study indicates that, during rejection, not only is tissue damage induced by infiltrating T cells, but also the infiltrating lymphocytes themselves are actively down-regulated (eg, AICD) by one another and by macrophages in the infiltrate. This regulatory process may affect the immunological status of the patient after heart transplantation.

The use of technetium Tc 99m annexin V for in vivo imaging of apoptosis during cardiac allograft rejection

OBJECTIVE

Apoptosis, or programmed cell death, has been suggested as a mechanism of immunologic injury during cardiac allograft rejection. We tested the hypothesis that technetium Tc 99m annexin V, a novel radiopharmaceutical used to detect apoptosis, can be used to detect cardiac allograft rejection by nuclear imaging.

METHODS

Untreated ACI rats served as recipients of allogeneic PVG rat (n = 66) or syngeneic ACI rat (n = 30) cardiac grafts. Untreated recipient animals underwent 99mTc-annexin V imaging daily for 7 days. Region of interest analysis was used to quantify the uptake of 99mTc-annexin V. Immediately after imaging grafts were procured for histopathologic analysis and terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated deoxyuridine triphosphate-biotin nick-end labeling of apoptotic nuclei. One group was treated with 10 mg/kg/d cyclosporine (INN: ciclosporin) commencing on day 4 after transplantation (n = 6).

RESULTS

Untreated allografts showed histologic signs of rejection 4 days after transplantation. Apoptotic nuclei could be demonstrated in myocytes, endothelial cells, and graft-infiltrating cells of all rejecting allografts. Nuclear imaging revealed a significantly greater uptake of 99mTc-annexin V in rejecting allogeneic grafts than in syngeneic grafts on day 4 (P = .05), day 5 (P < .001), day 6 (P < .001), and day 7 (P = .013) after transplantation. A correlation between the histologic grade of acute rejection and uptake of 99mTc-annexin V was observed (r2 = 0.87). After treatment of rejection with cyclosporine, no apoptotic nuclei could be identified in allografts and uptake of 99mTc-annexin V decreased to baseline.

CONCLUSIONS

Apoptosis occurs during acute cardiac allograft rejection and disappears after treatment of rejection. 99mTc-annexin V can be used to detect and monitor cardiac allograft rejection.

Fas ligand, tumor necrosis factor-alpha expression, and apoptosis during allograft rejection and tolerance

BACKGROUND

Cytotoxic T cells can induce target cell lysis and apoptosis by different pathways. The interactions of CD95 antigen (Fas) with its ligand (CD95L) and of tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha with its receptor (TNF-R1) lead to apoptotic cell death. Recently, conflicting studies have been published concerning the expression and the role of CD95L in allograft rejection and tolerance.

METHODS

In this study, the intragraft expression of CD95/CD95L and TNF-alpha and the frequency and distribution of apoptotic cells were compared in a model of heterotopic cardiac allograft in the rat in which recipients were either not treated (acute rejection) or pretreated with donor-specific blood transfusion (tolerant).

RESULTS

In the acutely rejected allografts, a peak in the expression of CD95L and TNF-alpha and in the number of apoptotic cells was observed during the first week after transplantation; apoptotic cells were confined to graft-infiltrating cells. In the tolerated allografts, however, levels of graft-infiltrating cell apoptosis and CD95L and TNF-alpha expression during the same period of time were dramatically lower. The expression of Fas was constitutive and was not modulated during acute rejection or tolerance.

CONCLUSION

This down-regulation of CD95L and TNF-alpha in allografts rendered tolerant by donor-specific transfusion suggests a role for apoptosis-inducing pathways in acute allograft rejection.

In vivo detection and imaging of phosphatidylserine expression during programmed cell death

One of the earliest events in programmed cell death is the externalization of phosphatidylserine, a membrane phospholipid normally restricted to the inner leaflet of the lipid bilayer. Annexin V, an endogenous human protein with a high affinity for membrane bound phosphatidylserine, can be used in vitro to detect apoptosis before other well described morphologic or nuclear changes associated with programmed cell death. We tested the ability of exogenously administered radiolabeled annexin V to concentrate at sites of apoptotic cell death in vivo. After derivatization with hydrazinonicotinamide, annexin V was radiolabeled with technetium 99m. In vivo localization of technetium 99m hydrazinonicotinamide-annexin V was tested in three models: fuminant hepatic apoptosis induced by anti-Fas antibody injection in BALB/c mice; acute rejection in ACI rats with transplanted heterotopic PVG cardiac allografts; and cyclophosphamide treatment of transplanted 38C13 murine B cell lymphomas. External radionuclide imaging showed a two- to sixfold increase in the uptake of radiolabeled annexin V at sites of apoptosis in all three models. Immunohistochemical staining of cardiac allografts for exogenously administered annexin V revealed intense staining of numerous myocytes at the periphery of mononuclear infiltrates of which only a few demonstrated positive apoptotic nuclei by the terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated UTP end labeling method. These results suggest that radiolabeled annexin V can be used in vivo as a noninvasive means to detect and serially image tissues and organs undergoing programmed cell death.

Apoptosis, graft rejection, and transplantation tolerance

Transplantation tolerance can be achieved through several mechanisms, including the action of suppressor cells, the induction of anergy, or the deletion of graft-reactive donor T cells. In this article, the possible involvement of programmed cell death (apoptosis) in allograft rejection and transplantation tolerance is discussed. The recent characterization of members of the tumor necrosis factor-alpha gene family has identified ligands (Fas ligand and TRAIL) and corresponding death receptors (DR). In rejected organ transplants, apoptotic cells are frequently encountered. Conversely, high-level expression of Fas ligand on the allograft correlates with graft acceptance in some models of organ transplantation. Furthermore, some of the immunosuppressive drugs currently in clinical use might exert their activity at least in part through effects on apoptotic pathways. From the available data, it can be inferred that apoptosis contributes to the outcome after organ transplantation, being involved both in graft rejection and in transplantation tolerance.