Establishment of stable multilineage hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific tolerance without irradiation

Immunological Consequences of In Utero Exposure to Foreign Antigens

Immunologic tolerance refers to a state of immune nonreactivity specific to particular antigens as an important issue in the field of transplantation and the management of autoimmune diseases. Tolerance conceptually originated from Owen’s observation of blood cell sharing in twin calves. Owen’s conceptual framework subsequently constituted the backbone of Medawar’s “actively acquired tolerance” as the major tenet of modern immunology. Based upon this knowledge, the delivery of genetically distinct hematopoietic stem cells into pre-immune fetuses represented a novel and unique approach to their engraftment without the requirement of myeloablation or immunosuppression. It might also make fetal recipients commit donor alloantigens to memory of their patterns as “self” so as to create a state of donor-specific tolerance. Over the years, the effort made experimentally or clinically toward in utero marrow transplantation could not reliably yield sufficient hematopoietic chimerism for curing candidate diseases as anticipated, nor did allogeneic graft tolerance universally develop as envisaged by Medawar following in utero exposure to various forms of alloantigens from exosomes, lymphocytes or marrow cells. Enduring graft tolerance was only conditional on a state of significant hematopoietic chimerism conferred by marrow inocula. Notably, fetal exposure to ovalbumin, oncoprotein and microbial antigens did not elicit immune tolerance, but instead triggered an event of sensitization to the antigens inoculated. These fetal immunogenic events might be clinically relevant to prenatal imprinting of atopy, immune surveillance against developmental tumorigenesis, and prenatal immunization against infectious diseases. Briefly, the immunological consequences of fetal exposure to foreign antigens could be tolerogenic or immunogenic, relying upon the type or nature of antigens introduced. Thus, the classical school of “actively acquired tolerance” might oversimplify the interactions between developing fetal immune system and antigens. Such interactions might rely upon fetal macrophages, which showed up earlier than lymphocytes and were competent to phagocytose foreign antigens so as to bridge toward antigen-specific adaptive immunity later on in life. Thus, innate fetal macrophages may be the potential basis for exploring how the immunological outcome of fetal exposure to foreign antigens is determined to improve the likelihood and reliability of manipulating fetal immune system toward tolerization or immunization to antigens.

Correction of murine sickle cell disease by allogeneic haematopoietic cell transplantation with anti-3rd party veto cells

Despite advances in gene therapy allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplants (HSCT) remains the most effective way to cure sickle cell disease (SCD). However, there are substantial challenges including lack of suitable donors, therapy-related toxicity (TRM) and risk of graft-versus-host disease (GvHD). Perhaps the most critical question is when to do a transplant for SCD. Safer transplant protocols for HLA-disparate HSCT is needed before transplants are widely accepted for SCD. Although risk of GvHD and TRM are less with T-cell-deplete HSCT and reduced-intensity conditioning (RIC), transplant rejection is a challenge. We have reported graft rejection of T cell-depleted non-myeloablative HSCT can be overcome in wild type fully mis-matched recipient mice, using donor-derived anti-3rd party central memory CD8-positive veto cells combined with short-term low-dose rapamycin. Here, we report safety and efficacy of this approach in a murine model for SCD. Durable donor-derived chimerism was achieved using this strategy with reversal of pathological parameters of SCD, including complete conversion to normal donor-derived red cells, and correction of splenomegaly and the levels of circulating reticulocytes, hematocrit, and hemoglobin.

Importance of Hematopoietic Mixed Chimerism for Induction of Renal Allograft Tolerance in Nonhuman Primates

BACKGROUND

Although induction of durable mixed chimerism is required for murine skin allograft tolerance (TOL), renal allograft TOL has been achieved after induction of only transient mixed chimerism in nonhuman primates (NHPs) and humans. To better define the level/duration of chimerism required for stable renal allograft TOL, we retrospectively analyzed these parameters and compared them with transplant outcomes in NHP combined kidney and bone marrow transplant recipients.

METHODS

Peripheral blood levels and duration of myeloid or lymphoid chimerism were retrospectively analyzed in 34 NHP combined kidney and bone marrow transplantation recipients which were divided into 3 groups: TOL, n = 10; chronic antibody-mediated rejection (CAMR), n = 12; and T cell-mediated rejection (TCMR), n = 12.

RESULTS

All 4 of the recipients that failed to develop any chimerism lost their allografts due to TCMR after discontinuation of immunosuppression (56 ± 3 d). Among 30 recipients who successfully developed multilineage chimerism, 10 achieved long-term immunosuppression-free survival without rejection (1258 ± 388 d), 12 eventually developed CAMR (932 ± 155 d), and 8 developed TCMR (82 ± 10 d). The maximum level but not duration of lymphoid chimerism was significantly higher in TOL recipients compared with both CAMR (P = 0.0159) and TCMR (P = 0.0074). On the other hand, the maximum myeloid chimerism was significantly higher in TOL than in TCMR (P = 0.0469), but not in CAMR. Receiver operating characteristic analyses revealed that lymphoid chimerism levels of 3.1% or greater could reliably predict long-term immunosuppression-free renal allograft survival (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

This retrospective study confirmed that induction of chimerism is essential for long-term immunosuppression-free survival, which best correlates with lymphoid chimerism levels higher than 3.1%.

Flt3-L Augments the Engraftment of Donor-Derived Bone Marrow Cells When Combined with Sublethal Irradiation and Costimulatory (CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40L) Blockade

T-cell costimulatory blockade as a constituent for recipient conditioning prior to bone marrow transplantation has led to the development of less toxic protocols for the establishment of donor cell chimerism. We therefore hypothesized that the addition of the hematopoietic growth factor, Flt3-ligand (Flt3-L), to the perioperative inhibition of the CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40 ligand costimulatory pathways would enhance the engraftment of allogeneic bone marrow. Recipient BALB/c ByJ (H-2d, Mlsc, Vβ6+/Vβ8+ TCR) received a single sublethal dose of total body irradiation (300 rad) 6 h prior to transplantation IV with unfractionated donor CBA/J (H-2k, Mlsd, Vβ6-/Vβ8+ TCR) bone marrow cells. CTLA4-Ig and/or MR1 were administered at 500 μg IP on days 0, 2, 4, and 6 posttransplantation. Flt3-L was administered at 10 μg IP on days 0–6. Donor cell chimerism was determined on days 30–90 by flow cytometric analysis. Donor-specific tolerance was assessed by skin grafting. In vitro TCR cross-linking assays and flow cytometry were utilized to explore the deletion of donor-reactive T cells. Recipients receiving CTLA4-Ig and MR1 engrafted allogeneic bone marrow cells in the peripheral blood (3/6; 50%) with chimerism being detected at 2–31%. Addition of Flt3-L to this preconditioning regimen enhanced the incidence of engraftment of donor bone marrow cells (10/13; 3–70%). Long-term survival of donor but not third-party-specific skin grafts demonstrated that donor-specific tolerance had been achieved in the chimeric recipients. Deletion of the donor-reactive T cells within the chimeric recipients was also observed. The addition of hematopoietic growth factors and cytokines to the nonmyeloablative regimen of sublethal irradiation and T-cell costimulatory blockade provides a novel strategy for the establishment of donor cell chimerism and for the induction of stable and robust donor-specific tolerance. The deletion of donor-reactive T cells using this protocol suggests the reliability and feasibility of this protocol for clinical transplantation.

Alloreactive Regulatory T Cells Allow the Generation of Mixed Chimerism and Transplant Tolerance

The induction of donor-specific transplant tolerance is one of the main goals of modern immunology. Establishment of a mixed chimerism state in the transplant recipient has proven to be a suitable strategy for the induction of long-term allograft tolerance; however, current experimental recipient preconditioning protocols have many side effects, and are not feasible for use in future therapies. In order to improve the current mixed chimerism induction protocols, we developed a non-myeloablative bone-marrow transplant (NM-BMT) protocol using retinoic acid (RA)-induced alloantigen-specific Tregs, clinically available immunosuppressive drugs, and lower doses of irradiation. We demonstrate that RA-induced alloantigen-specific Tregs in addition to a NM-BMT protocol generates stable mixed chimerism and induces tolerance to allogeneic secondary skin allografts in mice. Therefore, the establishment of mixed chimerism through the use of donor-specific Tregs rather than non-specific immunosuppression could have a potential use in organ transplantation.

Recipients with in utero induction of tolerance upregulated MHC class I in the engrafted donor skin

The alterations in MHC class I expression play a crucial step in immune evasion of cancer or virus-infected cells. This study aimed to examine whether tolerized grafts modified MHC class I expression. FVB/N mice were rendered tolerant of C57BL/6 alloantigens by in utero transplantation of C57BL/6 marrows. Postnatally, engrafted donor skins and leukocytes were examined for their MHC expression by quantitative real-time PCR and flow cytometry. Engrafted donor skins upregulated their MHC class I related gene transcripts after short-term (1~2 weeks) or long-term (>1 month) engraftment. This biological phenomenon was simultaneously associated with upregulation of TAP1 gene transcripts, suggesting an important role of TAP1 in the regulation of MHC class I pathway. The surface MHC class I molecules of H-2K^b in engrafted donor leukocytes consistently showed overexpression. Conclusively, the induction of allograft tolerance involved biological modifications of donor transplants. The overexpression of MHC class I within engrafted transplants of tolerant mice might be used as the tolerance biomarkers for identifying a state of graft tolerance.

Sirolimus and post transplant Cy synergistically maintain mixed chimerism in a mismatched murine model

Because of the toxicity associated with myeloablative conditioning, nonmyeloablative regimens are increasingly being used in vulnerable patient populations. For patients with sickle cell disease, stable mixed chimerism has proven sufficient to reverse the phenotype. Because the vast majority of patients do not have an HLA-matched sibling, a safe nonmyeloablative regimen that could be applied to the haploidentical setting would be ideal. We employed a mismatched mouse model using BALB/c donors and C57BL/6 recipients. Recipient mice were conditioned with 200 cGy TBI and sirolimus or CSA with or without post transplant Cy (PT-Cy). Our data show that when sirolimus or PT-Cy alone is given to C57BL/6 recipients, donor cells are not detected. However, when sirolimus is administered for 15 or 31 days starting 1 day before or up to 6 days after transplant with PT-Cy, all mice maintain stable mixed chimerism. In contrast, conventional therapy employing CSA with or without PT-Cy does not result in stable mixed chimerism. Lastly, mice with stable mixed chimerism after sirolimus display decreased reactivity to donor Ag both in vitro and in vivo. These data identify a novel strategy for inducing mixed chimerism for the treatment of nonmalignant hematologic diseases.

Infusion of Lin- bone marrow cells results in multilineage macrochimerism and skin allograft tolerance in minimally conditioned recipient mice

Donor-specific immunological tolerance using high doses of donor bone marrow cells (BMC) has been demonstrated in mixed chimerism-based tolerance induction protocols; however, the development of graft versus host disease (GVHD) remains a risk. In the present study, we demonstrate that the infusion of low numbers of donor Lin(-) bone marrow cells (Lin(-) BMC) 7 days post allograft transplantation facilitates high level macrochimerism induction and graft tolerance. Full-thickness BALB/c skin allografts were transplanted onto C57BL/6 mice. Mice were treated with anti-CD4 and anti-CD8 mAbs on day 0, +2, +5, +7 and +14 along with low dose busulfan on day +5. A low dose of highly purified Lin(-) BMC from BALB/c donor mice was infused on day +7. Chimerism and clonal cell deletion were evaluated using flow cytometry. Donor-specific tolerance was tested by donor and third-party skin grafting and mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR). Lin(-) BMC infusion with minimal immunosuppression led to stable, mixed, multilineage macrochimerism and long-term allograft survival (>300 days). Mixed donor-recipient macrochimerism was observed. Donor-reactive T cells were clonally deleted and a 130% increase in CD4(+)CD25(+)Foxp3(+) regulatory T cells (Tregs) was observed in the spleen. Tolerant mice subsequently accepted second donor, but not third-party (C3H), skin grafts and recipient splenocytes failed to react with allogeneic donor cells indicating donor-specific immunological tolerance was achieved. We conclude that the infusion of donor Lin(-) BMC without cytoreductive recipient conditioning can induce indefinite survival of skin allografts via mechanisms involving the establishment of a multilineage macrochimeric state principally through clonal deletion of alloreactive T cells and peripherally induced CD4(+)Foxp3(+) Tregs.

Characterization of tolerance induction through prenatal marrow transplantation: the requirement for a threshold level of chimerism to establish rather than maintain postnatal skin tolerance

Hematopoietic chimerism resulting from prenatal marrow transplantation does not consistently result in allotolerance for unidentified causes. In a C57BL/6-into-FVB/N murine model, we transplanted T-cell-depleted adult marrow on gestational day 14 to elucidate the immunological significance of chimerism towards postnatal tolerance. Postnatally, chimerism was examined by flow cytometry, and tolerance by skin transplantation and mixed lymphocyte reaction. Regulatory T cells were quantified by FoxP3 expression. Peripheral chimerism linearly related to thymic chimerism, and predicted the degree of graft acceptance with levels >3% at skin placement, yielding consistent skin tolerance. Low- and high-level chimeras had lower intrathymic CD3(high) expression than microchimeras or untransplanted mice. Regardless of the skin tolerance status in mixed chimeras, donor-specific alloreactivity by lymphocytes was suppressed but could be partially restored by exogenous interleukin-2. Recipients that lost peripheral chimerism did not accept donor skin unless prior donor skin had engrafted at sufficient chimerism levels, suggesting that complete tolerance can develop as a consequence of chimerism-related immunosuppression of host lymphocytes and the tolerogenic effects of donor skin. Thus, hematopoietic chimerism exerted immunomodulatory effects on the induction phase of allograft tolerance. Once established, skin tolerance did not fade away along with spontaneous regression of peripheral and tissue chimerism, as well as removal of engrafted donor skin. Neither did it break following in vivo depletion of increased regulatory T cells, and subcutaneous interleukin-2 injection beneath the engrafted donor skin. Those observations indicate that the maintenance of skin tolerance is multifaceted, neither solely dependent upon hematopoietic chimerism and engrafted donor skin nor on the effects of regulatory T cells or clonal anergy. We conclude that hematopoietic chimerism generated by in utero hematopoietic stem cell transplantation is critical to establish rather than maintain postnatal skin tolerance. Therefore, the diminution of hematopoietic chimerism below a threshold level does not nullify an existing tolerance state, but lessens the chance of enabling complete tolerance.

Hematopoiesis from Human Embryonic Stem Cells: Overcoming the Immune Barrier in Stem Cell Therapies

The multipotency and proliferative capacity of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) make them a promising source of stem cells for transplant therapies and of vital importance given the shortage in organ donation. Recent studies suggest some immune privilege associated with hESC-derived tissues. However, the adaptability of the immune system makes it unlikely that fully differentiated tissues will permanently evade immune rejection. One promising solution is to induce a state of immune tolerance to a hESC line using tolerogenic hematopoietic cells derived from it. This could provide acceptance of other differentiated tissues from the same line. However, this approach will require efficient multilineage hematopoiesis from hESCs. This review proposes that more efficient differentiation of hESCs to the tolerogenic cell types required is most likely to occur through applying knowledge gained of the ontogeny of complex regulatory signals used by the embryo for definitive hematopoietic development in vivo. Stepwise formation of mesoderm, induction of definitive hematopoietic stem cells, and the application of factors key to their self-renewal may improve in vitro production both quantitatively and qualitatively.

Upregulation of molecules associated with T-regulatory function by thymoglobulin pretreatment of human CD4+ cells

BACKGROUND

This study evaluated the immunologic effects of thymoglobulin in modulating human CD4+ cells.

METHODS

Human CD4+ cells were purified from peripheral blood mononuclear cells by negative selection method. CD4+ cells were pretreated with thymoglobulin and incubated for 72 hr. Cells and culture supernatants were collected and studied by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction, fluorescence activated cell scanning, multiplex cytokine assay, and mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR).

RESULTS

Thymoglobulin pretreated CD4+ cells demonstrated up-regulation of gene transcripts for CTLA-4, OX40, forkhead box P3 (Foxp3), CD25, IFN-gamma, IL-10, and IL-2 as determined by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction. Fluorescence-activated cell scanning analysis demonstrated that CD4+ cells, pretreated with thymoglobulin, up-regulated CD25 expression on their surface, and the surface expression of CTLA-4 and OX40 and the expression of intracellular Foxp3 were observed in these CD4+CD25+ cells. Additionally, MLR demonstrated that thymoglobulin-pretreated cells partially inhibited proliferation of untreated autologous CD4+ cells in response to allogeneic cells. The high levels of IFN-gamma, IL-10, IL-2, and IL-4 were detected by multiplex cytokine assay in supernatants collected from cultures of thymoglobulin-pretreated CD4+ cells. The lymphocyte proliferation of allogeneic MLR was also partially blocked in the presence of supernatants from cultures of thymoglobulin-pretreated CD4+ cells.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that the unique effects of thymoglobulin in modulating CD4+ cells may be an important mechanism for its action in inducing immunosuppression and transplant tolerance.

Strategies to induce marked prolongation of secondary skin allograft survival in alloantigen-primed mice

Alloreactive memory T cells mediate accelerated rejection. We investigated the effect of polyclonal anti-T-cell antibody (ALS) and rapamycin (RAPA) on skin allograft survival in naïve or alloantigen-primed mice. ALS prolonged graft survival in both naïve and alloantigen-primed mice. T-cell depletion by ALS was associated with increased CD4(+)CD44(hi)OX40(+) and CD8(+)CD44(hi)CD122(+) memory T cells. Addition of RAPA to ALS extended graft survival in naïve mice, but had no effect on secondary allograft survival in alloantigen-primed mice. In adoptive transfer experiments, RAPA inhibited alloantigen-stimulated proliferation and allograft rejection by naïve T cells. In contrast, alloantigen-primed memory T cells, particularly CD4(+)CD44(hi)OX40(+) and CD8(+)CD44(hi)CD122(+) T cells, were resistant to RAPA in response to alloantigen and mediated accelerated rejection in the presence of RAPA. Resistance to RAPA by alloantigen-primed mice was overcome by the use of high-dose ALS, which achieved marked prolongation of secondary skin allograft survival (>100 days). Inhibition of CD122(+) T cells and/or OX40/OX40L costimulation blockade, combined with low-dose ALS and RAPA, was also effective. These results demonstrate that tolerance may be achieved in allosensitized individuals by T-cell depletion- and RAPA-based strategies employing high-dose ALS or targeting CD122(+)CD8(+) T cells and/or the OX40/OX40L costimulatory pathway.

Immune tolerance: mechanisms and application in clinical transplantation

The achievement of immune tolerance, a state of specific unresponsiveness to the donor graft, has the potential to overcome the current major limitations to progress in organ transplantation, namely late graft loss, organ shortage and the toxicities of chronic nonspecific immumnosuppressive therapy. Advances in our understanding of immunological processes, mechanisms of rejection and tolerance have led to encouraging developments in animal models, which are just beginning to be translated into clinical pilot studies. These advances are reviewed here and the appropriate timing for clinical trials is discussed.

Trafficking of Donor-Derived Bone Marrow Correlates With Chimerism and Extension of Composite Allograft Survival Across MHC Barrier

We proposed to evaluate differences between recipient's immune response to vascularized skin and combined vascularized skin/bone allografts, under a 7-day alphabeta-TCR plus cyclosporine (CsA) treatment protocol. Thirty-six transplantations were performed in six groups: group I (isograft control-vascularized skin graft; n=6); group II (isograft control-combined vascularized skin/bone graft; n=6); group III (allograft rejection control group-vascularized skin graft; n=6); group IV (allograft rejection control-combined vascularized skin/bone graft; n=6); group V (allograft treatment-vascularized skin graft; n=6); and group VI (allograft treatment-combined vascularized skin/bone graft; n=6). Isograft transplantations were performed between Lewis rats and allografts were transplanted across the MHC barrier from Brown Norway to Lewis rats. In the allograft treatment group, a combined alphabeta-TCR+CsA protocol was applied for 7 days. All groups were compared clinically, immunologically and histologically. Statistical significance was determined with two-tailed Student's t test. Indefinite graft survival was achieved in the isograft control group (>300 days). Allograft rejection controls rejected within 5 to 9 days posttransplant; chimerism levels were undetectable (<.5%). Allografts under the alphabeta-TCR+CsA protocol had significantly extended survival when skin was combined with bone (61-125 days) compared to vascularized skin allografts (43-61 days). Lymphoid macrochimerism was significantly higher in group VI than group V. Histology confirmed skin and bone viability. Combined vascularized skin/bone allografts had higher and sustained levels of donor-specific chimerism and extended allograft survival.

Low-dose radiation plus rapamycin promotes long-term bone marrow chimerism

BACKGROUND

The ability to achieve significant donor engraftment without fully myeloablative conditioning has revolutionized allogeneic stem cell transplantation. These nonmyeloablative approaches may allow extension of this potentially curative modality to an increasing number of patients including those with non-malignant diseases. Although a number of regimens have been explored, the optimal means of conditioning has not been determined.

METHODS

We previously demonstrated that rapamycin (RAPA) has the ability to promote T-cell tolerance even in the presence of costimulation. In the current study, we examine the ability of rapamycin or the calcineurin inhibitor cyclosporine A (CSA) to promote chimerism in a murine haploidentical bone marrow transplantation model. Mice were conditioned with 300 cGy and received either RAPA at 3 mg/kg/day IP, CSA at 20 mg/kg/day IP, or no immunosuppression starting on the day before the transplant and continued for 4 weeks.

RESULTS

There was no apparent toxicity, and animals maintained normal blood counts throughout. More importantly, long-term macrochimerism was observed only in the RAPA-treated group.

CONCLUSIONS

These results establish a simple, nontoxic, irradiation-based regimen that facilitates engraftment without ablation. This strategy may prove useful in nonmalignant disorders such as hemoglobinopathies in which moderate levels of donor chimerism could prove curative.

Infusion of nonmyeloablative bone marrow alleviates acute rejection reaction in liver allotransplantation

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect and implication of nonmyeloablative donor specific bone marrow (DSBM) infusion on the immunoreaction of liver allotransplantation.

METHODS

Orthotopic liver transplantation model was used in this study. Groups were set as follows: Group I, syngeneic control (Wistar-to-Wistar); Group II, acute rejection (SD-to-Wistar); Group III, acute rejection treated with cyclosporine A (CsA) by intramuscular injection (SD-to-Wistar+CsA); Group IV, bone marrow infusion at 7 d pretransplantation followed by short-term CsA treatment (SD-to-Wistar+DSBM); Another group of short-term CsA treatment preoperatively without bone marrow infusion was also set as control. General characteristics and survival time were observed. Histological grades of rejection were determined by pathological examination. IL-2 and IFN-gamma level in peripheral blood and donor liver were detected respectively by Enzyme-Linked Immuno-Sorbent Assay (ELISA) and Western blot. Chimerism of donor cells was measured by PCR for a male-specific marker (Y-chromosome-specific sequence, Sry).

RESULTS

No signs of rejection were found in Group I. Acute rejection occurred in both Group II and the short-term CsA treated group. All the recipients died at (9-15) d posttransplantation with a median survival time of (10.7+/-0.5) d and (11.2+/-2.4) d, respectively. Only mild rejection could be seen in Group III. In Group IV, 4 out of 6 recipients had long-term survival (>100 d), the histological grade of rejection was significantly lower than that of Group II, so did the expression level of IL-2 and IFN-gamma in both peripheral blood and grafted liver. Y-chromosome-specific sequence (Sry) of male SD rats could be detected in the bone marrow, spleen and thymus of female recipients at 15 d after bone marrow infusion.

CONCLUSION

Mild preconditioning nonmyeloablative donor specific bone marrow infusion can enhance chimerism formation in recipients, alleviate the rejection of liver allotransplantation and prolong survival of liver allotransplantation.

Low dose busulfan facilitates chimerism and tolerance in a murine model

T cell depletion, sirolimus and "mega" dose donor specific bone marrow (DSBM) infusion promotes stable multilineage chimerism and indefinite survival of skin allografts in completely mismatched mice. The purpose of this study is to determine whether the addition of low dose busulfan can reduce the amount of DSBM required while preserving efficacy. C57BL/6 recipients of BALB/c skin allografts were treated with alphaCD4 and alphaCD8 monoclonal antibodies, DSBM, sirolimus and various doses of busulfan. The kinetics and phenotype of chimerism and the presence of clonal deletion of alloreactive T-cells were defined using flow cytometry. In vitro reactivity was determined using mixed lymphocyte culture. Second skin grafts confirmed the presence of tolerance. All doses of busulfan resulted in engraftment when combined with this regimen using a reduced dose of donor marrow. The level, kinetics and character of chimerism observed were dose related. Chimerism was associated with indefinite allograft acceptance (>200 days). Tolerance was documented both in vitro/in vivo and was associated with clonal deletion. Addition of a single low dose of busulfan to an established tolerance protocol reduced the required DSBM dose by over 80% while still promoting comparable levels of donor chimerism and donor-specific tolerance.

Robust Tolerance to Fully Allogeneic Islet Transplants Achieved by Chimerism with Minimal Conditioning

BACKGROUND

Whether mixed chimeras induced by nonmyeloablative conditioning are tolerant to challenge with donor allogeneic islet grafts is unknown. Here we investigate whether our nonmyeloablative, costimulation blockade-free and sirolimus (SRL)-based protocol could facilitate mixed chimerism via bone marrow transplantation (BMT) and induce islet allograft tolerance.

METHODS

After low dose (1-3 Gy) total body irradiation (TBI, day -1), with or without prior lymphocyte depletion, C57BL/6 mice were transfused with 40 x 10(6) BALB/c bone marrow cells (day 0) and received SRL (3 mg/kg/day) for 4 weeks. Chimerism was monitored by flow cytometry and the recipients were rendered diabetic chemically and challenged with donor islets.

RESULTS

Mixed chimerism was achieved in mice treated with TBI 3 Gy/SRL but it declined over time in 60% (9/15) of them. Long-term stable chimerism was established in 100% of recipients over 50 weeks with either antilymphocyte serum (ALS, 9/9), anti-CD4 (4/4), or anti-CD4 plus anti-CD8 (5/5) prior to BMT. TBI conditioning could be reduced to 1 Gy, with 90% (9/10) maintaining chimerism in the long-term. When TBI was substituted with cyclophosphamide (CTX) or busulfan (BUS), all mice remained chimeric in the long-term. The chimeras showed no proliferative response to donor antigen and accepted both first and second donor-specific islet grafts indefinitely while rejecting third-party grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

This data provides the first evidence that stable fully allogeneic chimeras induced with BMT after nonmyeloablative conditioning with SRL and lymphocyte-depleting antibodies exhibit robust donor-specific tolerance to islet grafts.

Strategies to develop chimerism in vascularized skin allografts across MHC barrier

In this study, we investigated the effects of 7-day-protocols of alphabeta-T-cell receptor monoclonal antibody (alphabeta-TCRmAb), cyclosporine A (CsA), and tacrolimus (FK-506) immunosuppressive monotherapies, and their combinations on the survival of vascularized skin allografts (VSA). Forty-two transplantations of VSA across a strong MHC barrier were performed between ACI (RT1a) donors and Lewis (RT1(l)) recipients in seven groups. Isograft and allograft rejection controls received no treatment. Treatment groups received a 7-day protocol of alphabeta-TCRmAb, CsA, or FK-506 monotherapy, or a combination of alphabeta-TCRmAb/CsA and alphabeta-TCRmAb/FK-506. VSA transplants were evaluated on a daily basis. Donor-specific chimerism was determined by flow cytometry (FC). The combined protocols of alphabeta-TCRmAb/FK-506 and alphabeta-TCRmAb/CsA significantly prolonged VSA survivals compared to monotherapy groups ( P < 0.005). FC analysis revealed 15.82% of donor-specific chimerism on day 7 under the alphabeta-TCRmAb/CsA protocol and a gradual chimerism decline on day 63 posttransplant. The significant extension of VSA survival achieved under 7-day protocols of combined therapies was directly associated with the presence of donor-specific chimerism.

Targeted T-Cell Depletion or CD154 Blockade Generates Mixed Hemopoietic Chimerism and Donor-Specific Tolerance in Mice Treated with Sirolimus and Donor Bone Marrow

BACKGROUND

The administration of donor specific bone marrow (DSBM) to mice conditioned with antilymphocyte serum (ALS) and sirolimus can result in stable multilineage mixed chimerism and long-term graft survival. This study seeks to determine if either the targeted depletion of CD4 and/or CD8 pos T cells or costimulation blockade can substitute for ALS and preserve the efficacy of this regimen.

METHODS

C57BL/6 recipients of BALB/c skin allografts were treated with DSBM (150 x 10(6) cells), sirolimus (24 mg/kg intraperitonealy), and either ALS or various monoclonal antibodies (alphaCD4, alphaCD8, alphaCD154 alone or in combination). Recipient peripheral blood mononuclear cell (PBMC) depletion, donor chimerism, and deletion of donor reactive T cells were assessed using flow cytometry. The specificity of immunologic nonreactivity and the presence of immunoregulatory activity were assessed through a mixed lymphocyte reaction assay.

RESULTS

The administration of ALS, sirolimus, and DSBM resulted in sustained recipient PBMC depletion, transient chimerism, and prolonged graft survival. The substitution of an equivalent degree and duration of targeted depletion of either CD4 or CD8 pos T cells alone for ALS failed to produce chimerism or prolonged graft survival. In contrast, depletion of both CD4 and CD8 pos T cells resulted in durable multilineage chimerism, indefinite allograft acceptance (>350 days), and donor-specific tolerance to secondary skin grafts. Substitution of alphaCD154 monoclonal antibody for ALS also resulted in a state of mixed chimerism and donor specific tolerance. This tolerant state appears to be maintained at least partially through clonal deletion and suppression.

CONCLUSION

Either combined CD4 and CD8 T-cell depletion or alphaCD154 blockade can effectively substitute for ALS in producing chimerism and tolerance in this model.

Prospects and strategies for clinical tolerance

The morbidity and mortality associated with chronic immunosuppression provide a strong motivation for development of clinical tolerance. This paper discusses the definition(s) of clinical (operational) tolerance, the role of chimerism in experimental and clinical tolerance, and the special role of bone marrow in tolerance induction. The states of microchimerism and macrochimerism are defined and related to certain clinical observations in solid organ transplantation. Current clinical strategies already being tested in the clinic are briefly reviewed. Certain principles for induction of clinical (operational) tolerance are elaborated.

Active Role of Chimerism in Transplantation Tolerance Induced by Antilymphocyte Serum, Sirolimus, and Bone–Marrow-Cell Infusion

BACKGROUND

A regimen consisting of antilymphocyte serum (ALS), sirolimus, and donor bone-marrow-cell (BMC) infusion induces indefinite skin allograft survival across fully mismatched mouse strain combinations. We investigated the role of chimerism in this transplantation tolerance model.

MATERIALS

B10.A (H-2a) mice were treated with ALS on day -1 and 2, sirolimus, and infusion of (C57BL/6xDBA/2)F1 (B6D2F1, H-2(b/d)) BMCs on day 7 relative to DBA/2 (D2) skin grafting on day 0. At postgraft days 30, 50 and 120, the recipient mice were injected intravenously with splenocytes prepared from either naive or D2 mixed chimeric B10.A mice that had been sensitized in vivo to B6. Changes in chimerism and graft survival were monitored.

RESULTS

Although D2 skin grafts were rejected with a median survival time of 63.8 days in B10.A mice given ALS and sirolimus alone, they survived more than 200 days in all B10.A mice given ALS, sirolimus, and B6D2F1 BMCs. Chimerism became evident 21 days postgrafting and progressively increased thereafter to 20% at postgraft day 200. Infusion of anti-B6 presensitized cells resulted in depletion of chimeric donor cells and subsequent graft rejection regardless of the timing of injection. Injection of presensitized cells in mice given ALS and sirolimus alone had no effect on graft survival. Injection of presensitized cells that were cytotoxic to alloantigen expressed by BMCs but tolerant to skin reduced, but did not deplete, established chimerism and allowed continued allograft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Chimeric donor cells play a major role in both the early and late phases of transplantation tolerance induced by the ALS, sirolimus, and BMC regimen.

Transplantation of hematopoietic stem cells for induction of unresponsiveness to organ allografts

Although it has been recognized since the early days of Owen and Medawar that engraftment of donor stem cells, induced in utero spontaneously or intentionally neonatally, results in life-long unresponsiveness to donor alloantigens. However, successful induction of transplantation tolerance in adult life still represents an unsolved problem. Engraftment of donor stem cells using conventional modalities involves intensive myeloablative or lymphoablative immunosuppression, which is associated with toxicity and mortality and such methods are not suitable for organ allograft recipients. In this chapter, we present an innovative approach for induction of donor-specific unresponsiveness to bone marrow and organ allografts without myeloablative conditioning. Our methods is based on cyclophosphamide-induced, alloantigen-primed lymphocyte depletion. Cyclophosphamide is administered 1 day following infusion of donor hematopoietic cells, thus eliminating predominantly host T lymphocytes reacting against donor cell challenge, and resulting in relative unresponsiveness to donor alloantigens. Subsequently, life-long tolerance to fully mismatched donor skin allografts can be accomplished by a second infusion of stem cells from the same donor, with donor T cells displacing residual alloreactive host cells that may have escaped deletion. Taken together, we believe that induction of true permanent and specific tolerance to organ allografts using donor hematopoietic cells could become a clinical reality in the foreseeable future.

Potent Skin Allograft Survival Prolongation Using a Committed Progenitor Fraction of Bone Marrow in Mice

BACKGROUND

The infusion of donor bone marrow (BM) into mice conditioned with antilymphocyte serum (ALS) and sirolimus (Sir) prolongs skin allograft survival and produces chimerism. This study identifies the BM cell(s) responsible for this effect and determines whether enrichment for these cells will improve efficacy.

METHODS

Skin grafts from BALB/C mice were transplanted into C57BL/6 or C57BL/10 recipients by using ALS, Sir, and BM (or fractions). BM was fractionated by using immunomagnetic beads. Flow cytometry was used for phenotyping and detecting chimerism.

RESULTS

The median graft survival in mice receiving 25 million BM cells was 61 days. Infusion of BM depleted of cells expressing CD19, CD3, CD11c, and c-kit had no effect on median graft survival, whereas infusion of fractions enriched for those cells resulted in median graft survival of 38, 48, 28, and 83 days, respectively. The administration of higher doses (4 x 10(6) and 8x10(6)) of fractions enriched for c-kit resulted in median graft survival of 124 and 197 days, respectively, without chimerism. This favorably compared with mice receiving 150 million BM cells that demonstrated transient mixed chimerism and a median graft survival of 190 days. The majority of cells in the c-kit+-enriched fraction expressed lineage markers. Removal of lineage positive cells from BM before infusion shortened median graft survival (90 days), indicating that the c-kit+ lin+ population is largely responsible for prolongation of graft survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Cells enriched for C-kit+lin+ constitute approximately 5% of murine BM cells and are more potent than whole BM at prolonging skin allograft survival in mice treated with ALS and Sir.

Bone marrow chimerism and tolerance induced by single-dose cyclophosphamide

BACKGROUND

Establishment of hematopoietic chimerism is the most stable strategy for donor-specific tolerance. Safer pretreatment regimens are needed for clinical application. We evaluated the efficacy of a simple protocol using cyclophosphamide (CYP) on induction of chimerism and organ transplant tolerance across major histocompatibility complex (MHC) barriers in the rat.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Bone marrow cells from BN (RT1(n)) donors were infused to LEW (RT1(l)) recipients on day 0 after a single injection of CYP at various doses on day -1. Donor-derived hematopoietic chimerism was evaluated by flowcytometry. The recipients received BN or third party (BUF) heart allografts on day 100.

RESULTS

While pretreatment with 200 mg/kg of CYP induced high levels of hematopoietic chimerism, six of eight recipients died of severe graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD). CYP at dose of 150 mg/kg induced 36.5 +/- 24.1% of donor-derived chimerism on day 10, and sustained macrochimerism was seen until day 100 without GVHD. Pretreatment with 100 mg/kg of CYP resulted in only transient chimerism (4.8 +/- 5.2%) which disappeared by day 20. In the recipients with 50 mg/kg of CYP, donor bone marrow cells were rapidly rejected and no chimerism was observed. The recipients with 150 mg/kg of CYP accepted BN heart allografts (>100 days x 5), while rejecting BUF allografts by day 12 (n = 4). BN heart allografts were rejected in the recipients with 100 (MST: 57 days, n = 5) and 50 mg/kg (MST: 7 days, n = 5) of CYP.

CONCLUSIONS

A single dose of CYP can induce hematopoietic chimerism across MHC-barriers. The dose of 150 mg/kg seems to be optimal to induce organ transplant tolerance without developing GVHD.

USE OF LENTIVIRAL VECTORS TO INDUCE LONG-TERM TOLERANCE TO GAL+ HEART GRAFTS

BACKGROUND

Tolerance to organ grafts has been achieved by establishing a state of stable mixed-cell chimerism after bone marrow transplantation. Gene therapy has been applied to establish chimerism for cells expressing galactose alpha 1,3 galactose in alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase deficient (gal knockout) mice using retroviral vectors. Limitations to the success of this methodology include short-term expression of the introduced gene and rejection of gal hearts transplanted into these animals within a month.

METHODS

Autologous bone marrow from gal knockout mice was transduced with a lentiviral vector expressing porcine alpha 1,3 galactosyltransferase and transplanted into lethally irradiated gal knockout mice. Chimerism was monitored by flow cytometry. Hearts from wild type mice (gal/) were transplanted into these animals and palpated daily. Xenoantibodies directed at the gal carbohydrate or porcine xenoantigens were detected by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay.

RESULTS

Hearts from wild-type gal/ donors were permanently accepted in all mice receiving autologous, transduced bone marrow before heart transplantation. Control mice rejected gal hearts within 12 to 14 days. Histologic analysis demonstrated classical signs of rejection in controls and normal myocardium with no evidence of rejection in mice chimeric for the gal carbohydrate. Anti-gal xenoantibodies were not produced in gal chimeras, but normal antibody responses to other xenoantigens were detected. Specific tolerance for the gal carbohydrate was achieved by this procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

These experiments report the first demonstration of permanent survival of gal hearts after transplantation with autologous, transduced bone marrow. Transduction with lentiviral vectors results in long-term, stable chimerism at levels sufficient to induce long-term tolerance to heart grafts in mice.

Production of donor T cells is critical for induction of donor-specific tolerance and maintenance of chimerism

Nonmyeloablative conditioning has significantly reduced the morbidity associated with bone marrow transplantation. The donor hemopoietic cell lineage(s) responsible for the induction and maintenance of tolerance in nonmyeloablatively conditioned recipients is not defined. In the present studies we evaluated which hemopoietic stem cell-derived components are critical to the induction of tolerance in a total body irradiation-based model. Recipient B10 mice were pretreated with mAbs and transplanted with allogeneic B10.BR bone marrow after conditioning with 100-300 cGy total body irradiation. The proportion of recipients engrafting increased in a dose-dependent fashion. All chimeric recipients exhibited multilineage donor cell production. However, induction of tolerance correlated strictly with early production of donor T cells. The chimeras without donor T cells rejected donor skin grafts and demonstrated strong antidonor reactivity in vitro, while possessing high levels of donor chimerism. These animals lost chimerism within 8 mo. Differentiation into T cells was aborted at a prethymic stage in recipients that did not produce donor T cells. Moreover, donor Ag-driven clonal deletion of recipient T cells occurred only in chimeras with donor T cells. These results demonstrate that donor T cell production is critical in the induction of transplantation tolerance and the maintenance of durable chimerism. In addition, donor T cell production directly correlates with the deletion of potentially alloreactive cells.

Targeted bone marrow radioablation with 153Samarium-lexidronam promotes allogeneic hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific immunologic hyporesponsiveness

BACKGROUND

Transplantation tolerance, defined as acceptance of a graft by an otherwise fully immunocompetent host, has been an elusive goal. Although robust tolerance has been achieved by the induction of stable hematopoietic chimerism after bone marrow transplantation, lethal or sublethal radiation conditioning used to induce long-term chimerism precludes its clinical use. We studied whether targeted delivery of radiation to bone marrow could allow for bone marrow cell (BMC) engraftment, chimerism, and donor-specific tolerance in the absence of the side effects associated with external irradiation.

METHODS

We administered a radioactive bone-seeking compound (Samarium-Lexidronam, Quadramet, Berlex Laboratories, Wayne, NJ) together with transient T-cell costimulatory blockade to recipient mice. Allogeneic BMCs were given 7 or 14 days after preconditioning. Costimulatory blockade was obtained by the use of an anti-CD154 antibody for 4 weeks. Chimerism was assessed by flow cytometry. Mice then received donor-specific and third-party skin grafts. Graft survival was analyzed with mechanisms of donor-specific hyporesponsiveness.

RESULTS

High levels of stable chimerism across an allogeneic barrier were achieved in mice by a single administration of Samarium-Lexidronam, transient T-cell costimulatory blockade, and BMC transplantation. A large percentage of chimeric animals retained donor-derived skin grafts for more than 120 days without requiring additional immunosuppression, suggesting that harsh cytotoxic preconditioning is not necessary to achieve stable chimerism and donor specific hyporesponsiveness. Analysis of the T-cell repertoire in chimeras indicates T-cell deletional mechanisms.

CONCLUSIONS

These data broaden the potential use of BMC transplantation for tolerance induction and argue for its potential in treating autoimmune diseases.

Long-term acceptance of composite tissue allografts through mixed chimerism and CD28 blockade

BACKGROUND

Clinical composite-tissue (hand) transplantation between genetically disparate individuals currently requires potent, nonspecific immunosuppressive agents that are neither completely successful in preventing acute episodes of rejection nor free from complications. The reliance on long-term immunosuppression has prompted this study to achieve donor-specific transplantation tolerance in adult recipients using a nontoxic, nonmyeloablative protocol.

METHODS

Fully mismatched, 4- to 6-week-old ACI (RT1Aa) and Wistar Furth (WF) rats were used as donors and recipients, respectively. Recipients were administered CTLA4-Ig at 2 mg/kg per day (alternate days) in combination with tacrolimus at 1 mg/kg per day (daily) from day 0 through day +10, antilymphocyte serum at 10 mg at day +10 (single dose), and total-body irradiation t 300 cGy (day 0) before bone-marrow transplantation (BMT) (day 0) with 100 x 10(6) T-cell-depleted bone marrow cells. Hindlimb transplants were performed 4 weeks postBMT. Multilineage donor hematopoiesis was determined pre- and posttransplant using flow cytometry. In vitro T-cell responses were evaluated by mixed lymphocyte reactivity assays.

RESULTS

CD28 blockade in a transplant model of mixed chimerism effectively aborts T-cell clonal expansion in vitro and in vivo, inhibits the development of acute and chronic rejection of vascularized hindlimb allografts in rats (ACI limbs to ACI-->WF chimeras, n=5; WF limbs to ACI-->WF chimeras, n=4), and subsequently leads to long-term survival of allogeneic skin grafts (n=9). Third-party (F344, n=4) transplants were uniformly rejected within 14 days posttransplant. Multilineage donor hematopoiesis was demonstrated pre- and posttransplant. Donor chimerism, present postBMT, increased throughout the study (pretransplant range 2-28%, mean 17%; posttransplant range 5-49%, mean 34%). Transplant recipients maintained full reactivity to respond to third-party antigens without harmful manifestations of graft-versus-host disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Although efforts have been made to induce tolerance to composite tissue allografts in adult recipients, thus far, none have succeeded without toxic, myeloablative host preconditioning. Our demonstration that tolerance can be achieved with minimal preconditioning provides a rationale for application to large animals and humans and suggests that although composite tissue allografts may have a significant skin component (and are therefore felt to be highly antigenic), protocols used to induce tolerance to organ transplants may be equally applicable to composite-tissue allotransplantation.

Chimerism and tolerance in rat recipients of intestinal allografts from ALS-treated donors with and without adjunct naïve-donor-strain bone-marrow cells

BACKGROUND

BN --> LEW small-intestine transplantation (SITx) given a 28-day course of tacrolimus results in partial tolerance and prolonged alloengraftment despite the development of indolent chronic rejection (CR). We determined whether the CR was associated with the quantity or quality of passenger leukocytes contained in the unmodified or antilymphocyte serum (ALS)-depleted BN intestine at the time of transplantation, and with the subsequent migration and persistence of these donor leukocytes in the LEW recipients (chimerism).

METHODS

Four experimental cohorts were defined by differences of the BN allografts and by the infusion (or not) of naïve donor (bone marrow cells [BMC]) on the day of the BN --> LEW SITx. All LEW recipients were treated with the same 28-day course of tacrolimus. The LEW animals received: (1) unaltered intestine; (2) intestine from ALS-treated donor; (3) intestine from ALS-treated donor plus BMC from naive BN donor on day 0; and (4) unaltered intestine and BMC from unmodified (naïve) BN donor.

RESULTS

Blood chimerism during the first 2 weeks after transplantation was lowest in the recipients of intestine from ALS-treated donors (groups 2 and 3), apparently because of the nearly complete elimination from the bowel of alphabetaTCR+ passenger leukocytes. After 2 weeks posttransplant to 5 months, greater than 2% of circulating donor cells were seen in animals given adjunct BMC from naïve BN donors (groups 3 and 4); this was associated with the absence of CR in the intestinal allografts. With lower levels of chimerism, moderate CR including arteritis and fibrosis in the Peyer's patches and mesenteric lymph nodes was found in the intestinal grafts of all group 1 and group 2 animals. Nevertheless, the CR-prone recipients in groups 1 and 2 had equivalent weight gain for greater than or equal to 150 days as in the CR-free groups 3 and 4. Detailed tissue chimerism studies in groups 1 to 3 showed that most of the donor cells in the gut-associated lymphoid tissues were rapidly replaced, but that the residual donor constituency of up to 6% in the allografts of group 3 was nearly 10-fold greater at 150 days than in groups 1 and 2 and closely reflected the findings in blood.

CONCLUSION

The development of CR in intestinal allografts to which the recipients are partially tolerant is associated with a decline with time of donor-leukocyte chimerism. Multilineage chimerism in the recipient, and a similar profile of donor cells in the allografts, is better achieved with infused donor BMC than with the normal intestinal passenger leukocytes of the intestine. The difference may be because of a higher number of precursor and pluripotent stem cells in BMC.

Chimerism in organ transplantation: conflicting experiments and clinical observations

The concepts of chimerism has influenced our thinking about tolerance and rejection of organs and tissues since the beginning of modern transplantation. In macrochimerism, persisting donor-specific cells are easily detectable by flow cytometry at levels of several to 100%, usually after transient lymphoablation and bone marrow (or other cell) transplantation. Microchimerism refers to a state in which donor cells persist at low levels (1 cell per 10(4) or 10(5) or less), frequently detectable by molecular techniques and usually consisting of class II dendritic cells. Although macrochimerism is frequently associated with donor-specific tolerance in many experimental animals and people, instances occur in which macrochimerism can be produced, but tolerance is not achieved. Also, in large animal models, macrochimerism and associated tolerance can be produced but macrochimerism can then disappear, yet tolerance persists. Clinically, states of microchimerism can exist, but rejection still occurs. Also, persisting microchimerism does not necessarily correlate with clinical tolerance or the ability to wean from or reduce immunosuppressive drugs. Recent experiments in several rodents using bone marrow to induce macrochimerism and tolerance have shown that establishment of the macrochimeric state does not necessarily produce tolerance. The presence of class II positive cells in the donor bone marrow inoculum is essential for tolerance induction in these models.

Donor-derived hematopoietic cells in organ transplantation: a major step toward allograft tolerance?

Infusion of donor-derived cells can improve organ allograft survival in animal models. Under certain conditions, it can even induce tolerance (i.e., unlimited organ survival without any maintenance immunosuppressive therapy). Use of nonmyeloablative regimens allows engraftment of donor-derived bone marrow cells, induction of mixed chimerism, and tolerance in rodents. High doses of bone marrow cells together with anti-T-cell antibodies can even result in mixed chimerism without cytoablative host conditioning. Cultured donor-derived CD34+ cells or donor-derived immature (or even mature) dendritic cells associated with monoclonal antibodies directed against co-stimulatory molecules might also induce tolerance. Among the numerous experimental protocols leading to tolerance of solid organs in animal models, how can we find our bearings in human transplantation? Numerous problems have yet to be solved: the type and amount of donor-derived cells (including stromal cells) to be used, the timing for infusion of donor cells in keeping with organ transplantation, the route of infusion (should it be intravenous, into the portal vein?), and the conditioning regimen. The first clinical trials would appear to indicate that tolerance induction in humans using donor-derived cells is a relatively safe solution that is both promising and realistic.

Induction of tolerance to hind limb allografts in rats receiving cyclosporine A and antilymphocyte serum: effect of duration of the treatment

BACKGROUND

This study assessed the ability of antilymphocyte serum (ALS) and cyclosporine A (CsA) to induce tolerance for hind limb composite tissue allograft in rats without chronic immunosuppression.

METHODS

Hind limb transplantations were performed in Lewis-Brown-Norway (LBN, RT1(1+n)) and Lewis (LEW, RT1(1)) rats. Treatment consisted of ALS only (0.4 mL/kg), CsA only (16 mg/kg), and a combination of CsA and ALS, and it was administered 12 hr before surgery at three different intervals (7, 14, and 21 days). Long-term survivors were tested for tolerance by standard skin grafting from the recipient (LEW), the donor (LBN), and the third party (ACI, RT1 ) 60 days after cessation of the treatment and by mixed lymphocyte reaction at 100 days. T-cell lines were analyzed with flow cytometry.

RESULTS

Single use of ALS in all treatment intervals did not prolong allograft survival. Single use of CsA extended survival up to 23 days in the 21-day protocol group. CsA and ALS caused indefinite survival in two of six rats in the 14-day protocol and in all six rats in the 21-day protocol (>420 days). The six long-term survivors in the 21-day protocol accepted the skin grafts from the donor (LBN) and the recipient (LEW) and rejected third-party grafts (ACI). Tolerant animals showed a donor-specific hematopoietic chimerism of 35% to 42% in the peripheral blood. Mixed lymphocyte reaction assay demonstrated tolerance to the host and donor alloantigens and increased response to the third party.

CONCLUSIONS

Administration of CsA and ALS for 21 days induced donor-specific tolerance in the recipients of the rat hind limb composite tissue allografts. The mechanism of tolerance should be investigated further.

Induction of donor-specific tolerance in rat hind-limb allografts under antilymphocyte serum and cyclosporine A protocol

Composite tissue allograft (CTA) transplantation became a clinical reality despite major side effects associated with the administration of chronic immunosuppression. Development of new treatment modalities eliminating life-long immunosuppression is essential for the future of CTA transplantation. In this study, combined use of cyclosporine A (CsA) and antilymphocyte serum (ALS) was tested for the potential to induce tolerance in the rat hind-limb allograft recipients across a major histocompatibility (MHC) barrier (Lewis-Brown-Norway [LBN, RT1(l+n)] to Lewis [LEW, RT1(l)] rats). Thirty transplantations were performed in 5 experimental groups. Animals received CsA and ALS 12 hours before surgery for 21 days thereafter. Although the allograft controls rejected their limbs at day 7 combined treatment of CsA and ALS resulted in indefinite survival (over 420 d) in all allograft recipients. Long-term survivors showed 35% to 42% of donor-specific chimerism in the peripheral blood. Clinical tolerance was confirmed by acceptance of the donor-specific skin grafts and immunocompetence was confirmed by rejection of the third-party grafts. Mixed lymphocyte reaction revealed suppressed response against donor-type antigens and increased response to third-party antigens. Donor-specific tolerance across MHC barrier was induced in CTA allografts under 21 days protocol of ALS/CsA.

Immunologic mechanisms in tolerance produced in mice with nonradiation-based lymphoablation and donor-specific bone marrow

BACKGROUND

These experiments evaluate the mechanisms associated with tolerance in mice treated with sirolimus, antilymphocyte serum (ALS), and donor-specific bone marrow (BM).

METHODS

Tolerance to fully MHC-incompatible skin allografts was induced as follows: C57Bl/10 (H2b) recipients received 0.5 mL of rabbit anti-mouse polyclonal ALS on days -1, +2, and +5 relative to B10.A (H2k) donor skin grafting on day 0. Sirolimus was given in a single dose (24 mg/kg intraperitoneally) on day 6. Freshly harvested B10.A (H2k) donor-specific BM was administered at a dose of 25 x 10(6) (ALS/BM25/sirolimus) or 150 x 10(6) (ALS/BM150/sirolimus) cells intravenously on day 7. Skin allograft survival was correlated with the recipient's immunologic status. Recipients were assayed for suppressor cell activity (mixed lymphocyte coculture assays), clonal deletion (T-cell receptor Vbeta11 assay), peripheral and thymic chimerism (flow cytometry and reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction), and anergy (response to exogenous interleukin 2).

RESULTS

Mice treated with ALS/BM25/sirolimus showed specifically prolonged but not indefinite allograft survival (median survival time 116 days). Allograft survival correlated with donor-specific clonal deletion and the presence of donor class II mRNA in the recipient's thymus. Mice given the ALS/BM150/sirolimus protocol showed indefinite donor-specific tolerance. Tolerance could not be broken with the administration of high doses of interleukin 2. Splenocytes taken from mice 14 days after tolerance induction inhibited donor-specific and third-party mixed lymphocyte culture proliferation in a dose-dependent fashion. This suppression could be ablated by depleting splenocytes of cells of donor origin before use in coculture. Clonal deletion was detectable 30 days after tolerance induction in mice treated with ALS/BM150/sirolimus and was maintained indefinitely.

CONCLUSION

Induction of tolerance by ALS, BM, and sirolimus results in a state of donor-specific tolerance, and multilineage chimerism evolves that is permanent and associated with clonal deletion of alloreactive T cells.

Rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockade as post-transplant treatment promote fully MHC-mismatched allogeneic bone marrow engraftment under irradiation-free conditioning therapy

Hematopoietic macrochimerism, established by bone marrow transplantation, can be used as an approach for treating autoimmune disease and inducing transplant tolerance. In this study, we investigated whether a stable, high level of fully MHC-mismatched hematopoietic macrochimerism can be induced by using irradiation-free protocols, and whether rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockades (anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) and CTLA4Ig) as post-transplant treatment promote bone marrow engraftment. Donor-specific blood transfusion (DST), anti-lymphocyte serum (ALS), busulfan, and cyclophosphamide were given pretransplantation. Balb/c (H-2(d)) bone marrow cells, at a dose of 4 x 10(7), were infused into each C57BL/6 mouse (H-2(b)). Rapamycin, anti-CD40L mAb, and CTLA4Ig were then administered, either alone or in combination. Without ALS or busulfan and cyclophosphamide, macrochimerism can only rarely be induced. Donor-specific transfusion (DST) enhances induction of hematopoietic macrochimerism. Rapamycin, anti-CD40L mAb and CTLA4Ig, alone or in combination, induce a stable and high level of hematopoietic macrochimerism. In the chimeric mice, donor-derived cells were detected in all lymphohematopoietic tissues and donor-specific tolerance was induced in vitro. We conclude that a stable and high level of fully MHC-mismatched hematopoietic macrochimerism can be induced in mice after transplanting a single modest dose of bone marrow cells without irradiation. Rapamycin and T cell costimulatory blockade as post-transplant treatment promote bone marrow engraftment.

Delayed low-level calcineurin inhibition promotes allospecific tolerance induction by posttransplantation donor leukocyte infusion

BACKGROUND

Donor lymphocytes infused after organ transplantation can have strong immunoregulatory effects. Application of such protocols for transplant tolerance induction in a clinical setting will, however, require combination of specific immunomodulatory strategies with nonspecific immunosuppressive medication for safety reasons. The aim of this study was to analyze the effects of immunosuppressive treatment on tolerance induction protocols by posttransplantation donor lymphocyte infusion.

METHODS

The interaction of postoperative donor leukocyte infusion with different types, dosage, and timing of immunosuppressive drugs were studied in a rat model of heart transplantation.

RESULTS

Tolerance could be achieved if donor cell infusion was combined with delayed, but not immediate, low-dose cyclosporine treatment, and this was associated with activation and apoptosis of host lymphocytes. In contrast, combinations with an antibody against the interleukin 2 receptor led to long-term graft survival but severe chronic rejection, and combinations with high-dose cyclosporine or sirolimus led to acute rejection.

CONCLUSIONS

Postoperative donor leukocyte infusion is a potential way for tolerance induction, but the type, dose, and timing of medication are highly critical for its efficacy.

A clinically relevant CTLA4-Ig-based regimen induces chimerism and tolerance to heart grafts

BACKGROUND

We determined whether a nontoxic CTLA4-Ig-based conditioning regimen effected mixed chimerism and donor-specific tolerance when heart and bone marrow were transplanted simultaneously.

METHODS

Fully mismatched rat strain combinations were used. Recipients received total-body irradiation (300 centigrays), bone marrow (10(8) cells), and cardiac transplants from the donor on day 0. Subsequently, recipient animals received CTLA4-Ig (2 mg/kg, every other day, x 5 doses), tacrolimus (1 mg/kg/day; days 0 to 9), and one dose (10 mg) of antilymphocyte serum on day 10.

RESULTS

All bone marrow recipients (n = 7) developed mixed chimerism (mean = 25% +/- 9% at 1 year) and accepted cardiac allografts permanently (> 375 +/- 32 days). Recipients that received conditioning regimen but no bone marrow (n = 5) rejected donor hearts within 51 +/- 13 days (p < 0.01). Recipients that accepted heart grafts also permanently accepted (> 180 days) donor-specific skin grafts, but rapidly rejected (< 10 days) third-party skin grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

A nontoxic CTLA4-Ig-based conditioning regimen effects mixed chimerism and donor-specific tolerance when heart and bone marrow are transplanted simultaneously. This regimen may have clinical application.

Tolerance and pancreatic islet transplantation

Islet transplantation holds renewed promise as a cure for type I diabetes mellitus. Results of recent clinical trials have shown remarkable success, and have reignited universal optimism for this procedure. In spite of this success, the need for life-long immunosuppression of the recipient still limits islet transplantation to patients with poorly controlled diabetes or to those requiring kidney transplantation. It is obvious that the achievement of immunological tolerance would broaden the indication for islet transplantation to a much larger cohort of patients with type I diabetes mellitus, most likely preventing long-term complications and contributing to a much improved quality of life. Increased understanding of the basic mechanisms of tolerance induction has resulted in the implementation of numerous experimental approaches to achieve long-term survival of islet grafts in the absence of chronic immunosuppression. In this brief review we will attempt to summarize the current status of research and knowledge.

Mixed chimerism

Induction of mixed chimerism has the potential to overcome the current limitations of transplantation, namely chronic rejection, complications of immunosuppressive therapy and the need for xenografts to overcome the current shortage of allogeneic organs. Successful achievement of mixed chimerism had been shown to tolerize T cells, B cells and possibly natural killer cells, the lymphocyte subsets that pose major barriers to allogeneic and xenogeneic transplants. Current understanding of the mechanisms involved in tolerization of each cell type is reviewed. Considerable advances have been made in reducing the potential toxicity of conditioning regimens required for the induction of mixed chimerism in rodent models, and translation of these strategies to large animal models and in a patient are important advances toward more widespread clinical application of the mixed chimerism approach for tolerance induction.

Mixed allogeneic chimerism and tolerance to composite tissue allografts

The development of effective immunosuppressive drugs has made solid organ allotransplantation the preferred approach for treatment of end-organ failure. The benefits of these immunosuppressants outweigh their risks in preventing rejection of lifesaving solid-organ allografts. On the contrary, composite tissue allotransplants are non-lifesaving and whether the risks of immunosuppressants justify their benefits is a subject of debate. Hence, composite tissue allografts (CTA) have not enjoyed widespread clinical application for reconstruction of large tissue defects. Therefore, a method of preventing rejection that would eliminate the need for toxic immunosuppressants is of particular importance in CTA. Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) to establish mixed chimerism induces tolerance to a variety of allografts in animal models. This article reviews mixed chimerism-based tolerance protocols. Their limitations and their relevance to CTA are discussed, highlighting some unique characteristics (high antigenicity and the presence of active bone marrow) that make CTAs different from solid organ allografts.