Crown gall disease and hairy root disease : a sledgehammer and a tackhammer

Unveiling the regulatory mechanisms of nodules development and quality formation in Panax notoginseng using multi-omics and MALDI-MSI

INTRODUCTION

Renowned for its role in traditional Chinese medicine, Panax notoginseng exhibits healing properties including bidirectional regulatory effects on hematological system diseases. However, the presence of nodular structures near the top of the main root, known as nail heads, may impact the quality of the plant's valuable roots.

OBJECTIVES

In this paper, we aim to systematically analyze nail heads to identify their potential correlation with P. notoginseng quality. Additionally, we will investigate the molecular mechanisms behind nail head development.

METHODS

Morphological characteristics and anatomical features were analyzed to determine the biological properties of nail heads. Active component analysis and MALDI mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI) were performed to determine the correlation between nail heads and P. notoginseng quality. Phytohormone quantitation, MALDI-MSI, RNA-seq, and Arabidopsis transformation were conducted to elucidate the mechanisms of nail head formation. Finally, protein-nucleic acid and protein-protein interactions were investigated to construct a transcriptional regulatory network of nodule development and quality formation.

RESULTS

Our analyses have revealed that nail heads originate from an undeveloped lateral root. The content of ginsenosides was found to be positively associated with the amount of nail heads. Ginsenoside Rb1 specifically accumulated in the cortex of nail heads, while IAA, tZR and JAs also showed highest accumulation in the nodule. RNA-seq analysis identified PnIAA14 and PnCYP735A1 as inhibitors of lateral root development. PnMYB31 and PnMYB78 were found to form binary complexes with PnbHLH31 to synergistically regulate the expression of PnIAA14, PnCYP735A1, PnSS, and PnFPS.

CONCLUSION

Our study details the major biological properties of nodular structures in P. notoginseng and outlines their impact on the quality of the herb. It was also determined that PnMYB31- and PnMYB78-PnbHLH31 regulate phytohormones and ginsenosides accumulation, further affecting plant development and quality. This research provides insights for quality evaluation and clinical applications of P. notoginseng.

Lessons learned from metabolic engineering in hairy roots: Transcriptome and metabolic profile changes caused by Rhizobium-mediated plant transformation in Cucurbitaceae species

Cucurbitaceae species are used in traditional medicine around the world. Cucurbitacins are highly oxygenated triterpenoids found in Cucurbitaceae species and exhibit potent anticancer activity alone and in combination with other existing chemotherapeutic drugs. Therefore, increasing production of these specialized metabolites is of great relevance. We recently showed that hairy roots of Cucurbita pepo can be used as a platform for metabolic engineering of cucurbitacins to modify their structure and increase their production. To study the changes in cucurbitacin accumulation upon formation of hairy roots, an empty vector (EV) control and Cucurbitacin inducing bHLH transcription factor 1 (CpCUCbH1)-overexpressing hairy roots of C. pepo were compared to untransformed (WT) roots. Whilst CpCUCbH1-overexpression increased production of cucurbitacins I and B by 5-fold, and cucurbitacin E by 3-fold when compared to EV lines, this increase was not significantly different when compared to WT roots. This indicated that Rhizobium rhizogenes transformation lowered the cucurbitacins levels in hairy roots, but that increasing expression of cucurbitacin biosynthetic genes by CpCUCbH1-overexpression restored cucurbitacin production to WT levels. Subsequent metabolomic and RNA-seq analysis indicated that the metabolic profile and transcriptome of hairy roots was significantly changed when compared to WT roots. Interestingly, it was observed that 11% of the differentially expressed genes were transcription factors. It was noteworthy that the majority of transcripts showing highest Pearson correlation coefficients to the Rhizobium rhizogenes genes rolB, rolC and ORF13a, were predicted to be transcription factors. In summary, hairy roots are an excellent platform for metabolic engineering of plant specialized metabolites, but these extensive transcriptome and metabolic profile changes should be considered in subsequent studies.

Hairy root transformation system as a tool for CRISPR/Cas9-directed genome editing in oilseed rape (Brassica napus)

Our study examined the mutation efficiency of the CRISPR/Cas9 method for tryptophan aminotransferase BnaTAA1 genes involved in the auxin biosynthesis pathway. We made nine CRISPR/Cas9 constructs with various promoters driving the expression of a Cas9 from Staphylococcus aureus (SaCas9) or a plant-codon-optimized Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 (pcoCas9). We developed a fast and efficient system for evaluating the variety and frequency of mutations caused by each construct using Brassica napus hairy roots. We showed that pcoCas9 is more efficient in mutating the targeted loci than SaCas9 and the presence of the NLS signal enhanced the chance of mutagenesis by 25%. The mutations were studied further in regenerated lines, and we determined the BnaTAA1 gene expression and heritability of the gene modifications in transgenic plants. Hairy root transformation combined with CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing represents a fast and straightforward system for studying target gene function in the important oilseed crop B. napus.

Evolutionary classification of tumor- and root-inducing plasmids based on T-DNAs and virulence regions

Tumor-inducing (Ti) and root-inducing (Ri) plasmids of Agrobacterium that display a large diversity are involved in crown gall and hairy root plant diseases. Their phylogenetic relationships were inferred from an exhaustive set of Ti and Ri plasmids (including 36 new complete Ti plasmids) by focusing on T-DNA and virulence regions. The opine synthase gene content of T-DNAs revealed 13 opine types corresponding to former classifications based on opines detected in diseased plants, while the T-DNA gene content more finely separate opine types in 18 T-DNA organizations. This classification was supported by the phylogeny of T-DNA oncogenes of Ti plasmids. The five gene organizations found in Ti/Ri vir regions was supported by the phylogeny of common vir genes. The vir organization was found to be likely an ancestral plasmid trait separating "classic" Ti plasmids (with one or two T-DNAs) and "Ri and vine-Ti" plasmids. A scenario generally supported by the repABC phylogeny. T-DNAs likely evolved later with the acquisition of opine characteristics as last steps in the Ti/Ri plasmid evolution. This novel evolutionary classification of Ti/Ri plasmids was found to be relevant for accurate crown gall and hairy root epidemiology.

Bacterial community dynamics of tomato hydroponic greenhouses infested with hairy root disease

The rhizosphere is a complex ecosystem consisting of microbes in the interface between growth medium and plant roots, which affects plant productivity and health. This is one of the few studies analysing bacterial communities present in the rhizosphere of hydroponically grown plants. Tomato grown under hydroponic conditions is prone to hairy root disease (HRD) that is caused by rhizogenic Agrobacterium biovar 1 strains. In this study, using high-throughput amplicon sequencing of partial ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes, we aimed to characterize bacterial communities in rockwool samples obtained from healthy or HRD-infested tomato during an entire growing season. Alpha diversity of rockwool increased in direct relation with time and samples obtained from healthy greenhouses presented a significantly lower alpha diversity than those from HRD-infested greenhouses. Beta diversity showed that bacterial community composition changed throughout the growing season. Amplicon Sequence Variants (ASVs) identified as rhizogenic Agrobacterium bv. 1 were more prevalent in HRD-infected greenhouses. Conversely, ASVs identified as Paenibacillus, previously identified as biocontrol organisms of rhizogenic agrobacteria, were more prevalent in healthy greenhouses. Altogether, our study greatly contributes to the knowledge of bacterial communities in rockwool hydroponics.

Development and validation of a UHPLC-ESI-QTOF mass spectrometry method to analyze opines, plant biomarkers of crown gall or hairy root diseases

Opines are low-molecular-weight metabolites specifically biosynthesized by agrobacteria-transformed plant cells when plants are struck by crown gall and hairy root diseases, which cause uncontrolled tissue overgrowth. Transferred DNA is sustainably incorporated into the genomes of the transformed plant cells, so that opines constitute a persistent biomarker of plant infection by pathogenic agrobacteria and can be targeted for crown gall/hairy root disease diagnosis. We developed a general, rapid, specific and sensitive analytical method for overall opine detection using ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometry (UHPLC-ESI-MS-QTOF), with easy preparation of samples. Based on MS, MS/MS and chromatography data, the detection selectivity of a wide range of standard opines was validated in pure solution and in different plant extracts. The method was successfully used to detect different structural types of opines, including opines for which standard compounds are unavailable, in tumors or hairy roots induced by pathogenic strains. As the method can detect a wide range of opines in a single run, it represents a powerful tool for plant gall analysis and crown gall/hairy root disease diagnosis. Using an appropriate dilution of plant extract and a matrix-based calibration curve, the quantification ability of the method was validated for three opines belonging to different families (nopaline, octopine, mannopine), which were accurately quantified in plant tissue extracts.

Agrobacterium strains and strain improvement: Present and outlook

Almost 40 years ago the first transgenic plant was generated through Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation, which, until now, remains the method of choice for gene delivery into plants. Ever since, optimized Agrobacterium strains have been developed with additional (genetic) modifications that were mostly aimed at enhancing the transformation efficiency, although an optimized strain also exists that reduces unwanted plasmid recombination. As a result, a collection of very useful strains has been created to transform a wide variety of plant species, but has also led to a confusing Agrobacterium strain nomenclature. The latter is often misleading for choosing the best-suited strain for one's transformation purposes. To overcome this issue, we provide a complete overview of the strain classification. We also indicate different strain modifications and their purposes, as well as the obtained results with regard to the transformation process sensu largo. Furthermore, we propose additional improvements of the Agrobacterium-mediated transformation process and consider several worthwhile modifications, for instance, by circumventing a defense response in planta. In this regard, we will discuss pattern-triggered immunity, pathogen-associated molecular pattern detection, hormone homeostasis and signaling, and reactive oxygen species in relationship to Agrobacterium transformation. We will also explore alterations that increase agrobacterial transformation efficiency, reduce plasmid recombination, and improve biocontainment. Finally, we recommend the use of a modular system to best utilize the available knowledge for successful plant transformation.

Two antibacterial and PPARα/γ-agonistic unsaturated keto fatty acids from a coral-associated actinomycete of the genus Micrococcus

A pair of geometrically isomeric unsaturated keto fatty acids, (6E,8Z)- and (6E,8E)-5-oxo-6,8-tetradecadienoic acids (1 and 2), were isolated from the culture broth of an actinomycete of the genus Micrococcus, which was associated with a stony coral, Catalaphyllia sp. Their chemical structures were elucidated by spectroscopic analysis including NMR and MS, with special assistance of spin system simulation studies for the assignment of an E geometry at C8 in 2. As metabolites of microbes, compounds 1 and 2 are unprecedented in terms of bearing a 2,4-dienone system. Both 1 and 2 showed antibacterial activity against the plant pathogen Rhizobium radiobacter and the fish pathogen Tenacibaculum maritimum, with a contrasting preference that 1 is more effective to the former strain while 2 is so to the latter. In addition, compounds 1 and 2 displayed agonistic activity against peroxisome proliferator-activated receptors (PPARs) with an isoform specificity towards PPARα and PPARγ.

Gateway®-compatible plant transformation vectors

Studies in functional genomics and crop improvement programs often rely on the introduction and expression of transgenes in plants. There are two essential components required for in planta transgene expression, a plasmid vector on which the transgene sequence is carried and a delivery system capable of transferring the vector to the target cells. Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation and the binary plasmid vector system is the preferred method of transgene delivery. The cloning technologies used for DNA manipulation underpin many of these studies. Increased demand for efficient high-throughput transformation systems is driving forward improvements in gene cloning techniques. This chapter gives an overview of Gateway(®)-compatible binary vectors for use in Agrobacterium-mediated transformation systems. It describes a fast, efficient, and robust cloning protocol for the production of an over-expression binary vector using Gateway(®) recombinational cloning.

Bacteria and fungi controlling plant growth by manipulating auxin: balance between development and defense

Plant diseases cause huge losses by changing the quality and quantity of harvested crops. Many disease symptoms caused by bacteria or fungi rely on the involvement of plant hormones, while other plant hormones act as defense signals in the plant. In this review the role of auxins in these processes will be evaluated. Some growth promoting plant hormones cause disease symptoms. For example auxins stimulate cell division and cell elongation in a healthy plant, but tumor formation after bacterial infection. Thus, control of auxin levels and auxin signaling pathways significantly contribute to the defense network in plants. Auxin can also act directly as defense molecule with antimicrobial activity. Since much research has been done in the recent years on auxin as a pathogenicity factor for many diseases, several examples will be presented to highlight the complexity between normal plant growth, which is regulated by auxin, and processes determining resistance or susceptibility, triggered by the same class of molecules.

Increased accumulation of the cardio-cerebrovascular disease treatment drug tanshinone in Salvia miltiorrhiza hairy roots by the enzymes 3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl CoA reductase and 1-deoxy-D-xylulose 5-phosphate reductoisomerase

Tanshinone is widely used for treatment of cardio-cerebrovascular diseases with increasing demand. Herein, key enzyme genes SmHMGR (3-hydroxy-3-methylglutaryl CoA reductase) and SmDXR (1-deoxy-D-xylulose 5-phosphate reductoisomerase) involved in the tanshinone biosynthetic pathway were introduced into Salvia miltiorrhiza (Sm) hairy roots to enhance tanshinone production. Over-expression of SmHMGR or SmDXR in hairy root lines can significantly enhance the yield of tanshinone. Transgenic hairy root lines co-expressing HMGR and DXR (HD lines) produced evidently higher levels of total tanshinone (TT) compared with the control and single gene transformed lines. The highest tanshinone production was observed in HD42 with the concentration of 3.25 mg g(-1) DW. Furthermore, the transgenic hairy roots showed higher antioxidant activity than control. In addition, transgenic hairy root harboring HMGR and DXR (HD42) exhibited higher tanshinone content after elicitation by yeast extract and/or Ag(+) than before. Tanshinone can be significantly enhanced to 5.858, 6.716, and 4.426 mg g(-1) DW by YE, Ag(+), and YE-Ag(+) treatment compared with non-induced HD42, respectively. The content of cryptotanshinone and dihydrotanshinone was effectively elevated upon elicitor treatments, whereas there was no obvious promotion effect for the other two compounds tanshinone I and tanshinone IIA. Our results provide a useful strategy to improve tanshinone content as well as other natural active products by combination of genetic engineering with elicitors.

Threats and opportunities of plant pathogenic bacteria

Plant pathogenic bacteria can have devastating effects on plant productivity and yield. Nevertheless, because these often soil-dwelling bacteria have evolved to interact with eukaryotes, they generally exhibit a strong adaptivity, a versatile metabolism, and ingenious mechanisms tailored to modify the development of their hosts. Consequently, besides being a threat for agricultural practices, phytopathogens may also represent opportunities for plant production or be useful for specific biotechnological applications. Here, we illustrate this idea by reviewing the pathogenic strategies and the (potential) uses of five very different (hemi)biotrophic plant pathogenic bacteria: Agrobacterium tumefaciens, A. rhizogenes, Rhodococcus fascians, scab-inducing Streptomyces spp., and Pseudomonas syringae.

Composite Cucurbita pepo plants with transgenic roots as a tool to study root development

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

In most plant species, initiation of lateral root primordia occurs above the elongation zone. However, in cucurbits and some other species, lateral root primordia initiation and development takes place in the apical meristem of the parental root. Composite transgenic plants obtained by Agrobacterium rhizogenes-mediated transformation are known as a suitable model to study root development. The aim of the present study was to establish this transformation technique for squash.

METHODS

The auxin-responsive promoter DR5 was cloned into the binary vectors pKGW-RR-MGW and pMDC162-GFP. Incorporation of 5-ethynyl-2'-deoxyuridine (EdU) was used to evaluate the presence of DNA-synthesizing cells in the hypocotyl of squash seedlings to find out whether they were suitable for infection. Two A. rhizogenes strains, R1000 and MSU440, were used. Roots containing the respective constructs were selected based on DsRED1 or green fluorescent protein (GFP) fluorescence, and DR5::Egfp-gusA or DR5::gusA insertion, respectively, was verified by PCR. Distribution of the response to auxin was visualized by GFP fluorescence or β-glucuronidase (GUS) activity staining and confirmed by immunolocalization of GFP and GUS proteins, respectively.

KEY RESULTS

Based on the distribution of EdU-labelled cells, it was determined that 6-day-old squash seedlings were suited for inoculation by A. rhizogenes since their root pericycle and the adjacent layers contain enough proliferating cells. Agrobacterium rhizogenes R1000 proved to be the most virulent strain on squash seedlings. Squash roots containing the respective constructs did not exhibit the hairy root phenotype and were morphologically and structurally similar to wild-type roots.

CONCLUSIONS

The auxin response pattern in the root apex of squash resembled that in arabidopsis roots. Composite squash plants obtained by A. rhizogenes-mediated transformation are a good tool for the investigation of root apical meristem development and root branching.

Selection of reference genes for qPCR in hairy root cultures of peanut

Background

Hairy root cultures produced via Agrobacterium rhizogenes-mediated transformation have emerged as practical biological models to elucidate the biosynthesis of specialized metabolites. To effectively understand the expression patterns of the genes involved in the metabolic pathways of these compounds, reference genes need to be systematically validated under specific experimental conditions as established by the MIQE (Minimum Information for Publication of Quantitative Real-Time PCR Experiments) guidelines. In the present report we describe the first validation of reference genes for RT-qPCR in hairy root cultures of peanut which produce stilbenoids upon elicitor treatments.

Results

A total of 21 candidate reference genes were evaluated. Nineteen genes were selected based on previous qPCR studies in plants and two were from the T-DNAs transferred from A. rhizogenes. Nucleotide sequences of peanut candidate genes were obtained using their homologous sequences in Arabidopsis. To identify the suitable primers, calibration curves were obtained for each candidate reference gene. After data analysis, 12 candidate genes meeting standard efficiency criteria were selected. The expression stability of these genes was analyzed using geNorm and NormFinder algorithms and a ranking was established based on expression stability of the genes. Candidate reference gene expression was shown to have less variation in methyl jasmonate (MeJA) treated root cultures than those treated with sodium acetate (NaOAc).

Conclusions

This work constitutes the first effort to validate reference genes for RT-qPCR in hairy roots. While these genes were selected under conditions of NaOAc and MeJA treatment, we anticipate these genes to provide good targets for reference genes for hairy roots under a variety of stress conditions. The lead reference genes were a gene encoding for a TATA box binding protein (TBP2) and a gene encoding a ribosomal protein (RPL8C). A commonly used reference gene GAPDH showed low stability of expression suggesting that its use may lead to inaccurate gene expression profiles when used for data normalization in stress-stimulated hairy roots. Likewise the A. rhizogenes transgene rolC showed less expression stability than GAPDH. This study proposes that a minimum of two reference genes should be used for a normalization procedure in gene expression profiling using elicited hairy roots.

Horizontal gene transfers with or without cell fusions in all categories of the living matter

This article reviews the history of widespread exchanges of genetic segments initiated over 3 billion years ago, to be part of their life style, by sphero-protoplastic cells, the ancestors of archaea, prokaryota, and eukaryota. These primordial cells shared a hostile anaerobic and overheated environment and competed for survival. "Coexist with, or subdue and conquer, expropriate its most useful possessions, or symbiose with it, your competitor" remain cellular life's basic rules. This author emphasizes the role of viruses, both in mediating cell fusions, such as the formation of the first eukaryotic cell(s) from a united crenarchaeon and prokaryota, and the transfer of host cell genes integrated into viral (phages) genomes. After rising above the Darwinian threshold, rigid rules of speciation and vertical inheritance in the three domains of life were established, but horizontal gene transfers with or without cell fusions were never abolished. The author proves with extensive, yet highly selective documentation, that not only unicellular microorganisms, but the most complex multicellular entities of the highest ranks resort to, and practice, cell fusions, and donate and accept horizontally (laterally) transferred genes. Cell fusions and horizontally exchanged genetic materials remain the fundamental attributes and inherent characteristics of the living matter, whether occurring accidentally or sought after intentionally. These events occur to cells stagnating for some 3 milliard years at a lower yet amazingly sophisticated level of evolution, and to cells achieving the highest degree of differentiation, and thus functioning in dependence on the support of a most advanced multicellular host, like those of the human brain. No living cell is completely exempt from gene drains or gene insertions.

Rhizosecretion of recombinant proteins from plant hairy roots

Rhizosecretion of a target protein in the hydroponic medium provides an alternative manufacturing platform that simplifies the downstream purification procedure and increases protein yield. In order to increase the production rates of rhizosecreted proteins, we have exploited the ability of Agrobacterium rhizogenes to induce the formation of large amounts of root tissue on transgenic tobacco plants engineered to secrete a model recombinant protein, human secreted alkaline phosphatase (SEAP). The secretion of SEAP from hairy roots induced on the stems of transgenic tobacco plants was 5-7 times higher than that from adventitious transgenic roots.

Isolation and Characterization of Derivative Lines of the Onion Yellows Phytoplasma that Do Not Cause Stunting or Phloem Hyperplasia

ABSTRACT Two lines of onion yellows phytoplasma producing milder symptoms were isolated from the original line (OY-W). One has an additional characteristic, non-insect-transmissibility (OY-NIM), compared with the other (OY-M). OY-M was established after maintaining OY-W for 11 years on a plant host (Chrysanthemum coronarium) with an insect vector (Macrosteles striifrons), and OY-NIM was isolated after subsequent maintenance of OY-M in plants by periodic grafting. Polymerase chain analysis suggested that OY-NIM cannot traverse the gut or survive in the hemolymph of the leafhopper. OY-W results in witches'-broom formation and stunted growth in the host plant. In contrast, OY-M and OY-NIM do not cause stunting in the host plant, although they result in witches'-broom. Histopathological analysis of these lines revealed that the hyperplastic phloem tissue and severe phloem necrosis seen in OY-W did not exist in OY-M and OY-NIM. This was attributed to a reduction in the population of phytoplasma in tissues in both OY-M- and OY-NIM-infected plants. The results suggest that the cause of stunting and phloem hyperplasia may be genetically different from the cause of witches'-broom. Pulsed field gel electrophoresis analysis showed that OY-M had a smaller genome size ( approximately 870 kbp) than OY-W ( approximately 1,000 kbp). Thus, some of the OY-W genes responsible for pathogenicity may not be present in OY-M.

The effect of yeast elicitor on the growth and secondary metabolism of hairy root cultures of Salvia miltiorrhiza

Hairy root cultures of Salvia miltiorrhiza transformed with Agrobacterium rhizogenes ATCC 15834 produced a tiny amount of tanshinones and a constituent level of phenolic acids under normal growth conditions. Upon elicitation with yeast elicitor, the production of both phenolic acids and tanshinones was enhanced. For example, the contents of two phenolic acids, rosmarinic acid and lithospermic acid B were elevated from 1.24% and 2.59% to 2.89% and 2.98% of dry wt, respectively while the intracellular content of cryptotanshinone increased from 0.001% to as much as 0.096% of dry wt. Yeast elicitor also improved the growth of hairy roots (from 3.9 g/l to 7.3 g/l on a dry wt basis). Liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) was developed for simultaneous detection and identification of phenolic acids and tanshinones in the extracts of S. miltiorrhiza. Rosmarinic acid, lithospermic acid B, cryptotanshinone, tanshinone I, tanshinone IIA and tanshinone IIB were identified by comparison with standards available. Dihydrotanshinone I and methylenetanshiquinone were tentatively identified by the molecular weights and the elution comparable with the literature. An unknown compound with a molecular weight of 280 was found in yeast-elicitor treated hairy root cultures, which was one of the major tanshinones induced.

Nicotiana tabacum cDNAs encoding alpha and beta subunits of a heterotrimeric GTP-binding protein isolated from hairy root tissues

Heterotrimeric GTP-binding proteins (G-proteins) play important roles in signal transduction pathways in eukaryotic cells. Through differential screening of a hairy root cDNA library of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) against transcripts from non-root tissues of normal cuttings, we obtained a partial cDNA clone that showed abundant expression and high homology to the alpha subunit gene of plant G-protein. After RACE-PCR, a full-length cDNA clone was obtained, which was 1,677-bp in length and contained an open reading frame encoding a protein of 384 amino acids. A cDNA clone encoding a beta subunit of G-protein was also isolated from the same cDNA library based on PCR amplification and library screening. The clone was 1,600-bp in length and contained an open reading frame encoding 377 amino acids. The deduced amino acid sequences of these clones showed high homology (75.5 to 99.8% amino acid identity) with alpha and beta subunits of other plant G-proteins. Genomic Southern blot analysis showed that the amphidiploid tobacco genome possessed two major copies of both alpha and beta subunit genes and some minor homologous copies. Northern blot analysis showed that the transcript of alpha subunit gene was abundant in the root tissues, particularly in the hairy root tissues. In contrast, the level of expression of the beta subunit gene was equivalent in all the tissues studied. Possible function of tobacco G-protein was discussed.

Combined genetic and physical map of the complex genome of Agrobacterium tumefaciens

A combined genetic and physical map of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens A348 (derivative of C58) genome was constructed to address the discrepancy between initial single-chromosome genetic maps and more recent physical mapping data supporting the presence of two nonhomologous chromosomes. The combined map confirms the two-chromosome genomic structure and the correspondence of the initial genetic maps to the circular chromosome. The linear chromosome is almost devoid of auxotrophic markers, which probably explains why it was missed by genetic mapping studies.

pSa causes oncogenic suppression of Agrobacterium by inhibiting VirE2 protein export

When coresident with the Ti (tumor-inducing) plasmid, the 21-kDa product of the osa gene of the plasmid pSa can suppress crown gall tumorigenesis incited by Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Neither T-DNA processing nor vir (virulence) gene induction is affected by the presence of osa in the bacterium. We used Arabidopsis thaliana root segments and tobacco leaf discs to demonstrate that Osa inhibits A. tumefaciens from transforming these plants to the stable phenotypes of tumorigenesis, kanamycin resistance, and stable beta-glucuronidase (GUS) expression. When A. tumefaciens contained osa, the lack of expression of transient GUS activity in infected plant tissues, as well as the lack of systemic viral symptoms following agroinfection of Nicotiana benthamiana by tomato mottle virus, suggested that oncogenic suppression by Osa occurs before T-DNA enters the plant nucleus. The extracellular complementation of an A. tumefaciens virE2 mutant (the T-DNA donor strain) by an A. tumefaciens strain lacking T-DNA but containing a wild-type virE2 gene (the VirE2 donor strain) was blocked when osa was present in the VirE2 donor strain, but not when osa was present in the T-DNA donor strain. These data indicate that osa inhibits VirE2 protein, but not T-DNA export from A. tumefaciens. These data further suggest that VirE2 protein and T-DNA are separately exported from the bacterium. The successful infection of Datura stramonium plants and leaf discs of transgenic tobacco plants expressing VirE2 protein by an A. tumefaciens virE2 mutant carrying osa confirmed that oncogenic suppression by osa does not occur by blocking T-DNA transfer. Overexpression of virB9, virB10, and virB11 in A. tumefaciens did not overcome oncogenic suppression by osa. The finding that the expression of the osa gene by itself, rather than the formation of a conjugal intermediate with pSa, blocks transformation suggests that the mechanism of oncogenic suppression by osa may differ from that of the IncQ plasmid RSF1010.

Control of genes for conjugative transfer of plasmids and other mobile elements

Conjugative transfer is a primary means of spread of mobile genetic elements (plasmids and transposons) between bacteria.It leads to the dissemination and evolution of the genes (such as those conferring resistance to antibiotics) which are carried by the plasmid. Expression of the plasmid genes needed for conjugative transfer is tightly regulated so as to minimise the burden on the host. For plasmids such as those belonging to the IncP group this results in downregulation of the transfer genes once all bacteria have a functional conjugative apparatus. For F-like plasmids (apart from F itself which is a derepressed mutant) tight control results in very few bacteria having a conjugative apparatus. Chance encounters between the rare transfer-proficient bacteria and a potential recipient initiate a cascade of transfer which can continue until all potential recipients have acquired the plasmid. Other systems express their transfer genes in response to specific stimuli. For the pheromone-responsive plasmids of Enterococcus it is small peptide signals from potential recipients which trigger the conjugative transfer genes. For the Ti plasmids of Agrobacterium it is the presence of wounded plants which are susceptible to infection which stimulates T-DNA transfer to plants. Transfer and integration of T-DNA induces production of opines which the plasmid-positive bacteria can utilise. They multiply and when they reach an appropriate density their plasmid transfer system is switched on to allow transfer of the Ti plasmid to other bacteria. Finally some conjugative transfer systems are induced by the antibiotics to which the elements confer resistance. Understanding these control circuits may help to modify management of microbial communities where plasmid transfer is either desirable or undesirable. z 1998 Published by Elsevier Science B.V.

Differences in susceptibility of Arabidopsis ecotypes to crown gall disease may result from a deficiency in T-DNA integration

We show that among ecotypes of Arabidopsis, there is considerable variation in their susceptibility to crown gall disease. Differences in susceptibility are heritable and, in one ecotype, segregate as a single major contributing locus. In several ecotypes, recalcitrance to tumorigenesis results from decreased binding of Agrobacterium to inoculated root explants. The recalcitrance of another ecotype occurs at a late step in T-DNA transfer. Transient expression of a T-DNA-encoded beta-glucuronidase gusA gene is efficient, but the ecotype is deficient in crown gall tumorigenesis, transformation to kanamycin resistance, and stable GUS expression. This ecotype is also more sensitive to gamma radiation than is a susceptible ecotype. DNA gel blot analysis showed that after infection by Agrobacterium, less T-DNA was integrated into the genome of the recalcitrant ecotype than was integrated into the genome of a highly susceptible ecotype.

Pleiotropic phenotypes caused by genetic ablation of the receiver module of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens VirA protein

The VirA protein of Agrobacterium tumefaciens is a transmembrane sensory kinase that phosphorylates the VirG response regulator in response to chemical signals released from plant wound sites. VirA contains both a two-component kinase module and, at its carboxyl terminus, a receiver module. We previously provided evidence that this receiver module inhibited the activity of the kinase module and that inhibition might be neutralized by phosphorylation. In this report, we provide additional evidence for this model by showing that overexpressing the receiver module in trans can restore low-level basal activity to a VirA mutant protein lacking the receiver module. We also show that ablation of the receiver module restores activity to the inactive VirA (delta324-413) mutant, which has a deletion within a region designated the linker module. This indicates that deletion of the linker module does not denature the kinase module, but rather locks the kinase into a phenotypically inactive conformation, and that this inactivity requires the receiver module. These data provide genetic evidence that the kinase and receiver modules of VirA attain their native conformations autonomously. The receiver module also restricts the variety of phenolic compounds that have stimulatory activity, since removal of this module causes otherwise nonstimulatory phenolic compounds such as 4-hydroxyacetophenone to stimulate vir gene expression.

Sequence-specific interactions of wound-inducible nuclear factors with mannopine synthase 2' promoter wound-responsive elements

A 318 bp mannopine synthase 2' (mas2') promoter element from the T-DNA of Agrobacterium tumefacians can direct wound-inducible and root-preferential expression of a linked uidA gene in transgenic tobacco plants. Wound inducibility is further enhanced by sucrose in the medium. Promoter deletion analysis indicated that the sucrose enhancement is conferred by a region extending from -318 to -213. DNase I footprinting indicated that an A/T-rich DNA sequence in this region is protected by tobacco nuclear factors. Regions extending from -103 to +66 and from -213 to -138 directed wound-inducibile expression of a linked uidA gene when placed downstream of a CaMV 35S enhancer or upstream of a truncated (-209) CaMV 35S promoter, respectively. DNase I footprinting analyses indicated that proteins from wounded tobacco leaves specifically bound to three contiguous motifs downstream of the mas2' TATA box. In addition to a common retarded band formed by the upstream wound-responsive element complexed with proteins from either wounded or unwounded tobacco leaves, two unique retarded bands were observed when this element was incubated with protein from wounded leaves. Methylation interference analysis additionally identified an unique motif composed of promoter elements and nuclear factors derived specifically from wounded tobacco leaves. We propose a model to describe the involvement of nuclear factors with mas2' promoter elements in wound-inducible gene expression.

Biosynthesis of defense-related proteins in transformed root cultures of Trichosanthes kirilowii Maxim. var japonicum (Kitam.)

We have established transformed ("hairy") root cultures from Trichosanthes kirilowii Maxim. var japonicum Kitam. (Cucurbitaceae) and four related species to study the biosynthesis of the ribosome-inactivating protein trichosanthin (TCN) and other root-specific defense-related plant proteins. Stable, fast-growing root clones were obtained for each species by infecting in vitro grown plantlets with Agrobacterium rhizogenes American Type Culture Collection strain 15834. Each species accumulated reproducibly a discrete protein pattern in the culture medium. Analysis of the extracellular proteins from T. kirilowii var japonicum root cultures showed differential protein accumulation in the medium during the time course of growth in batch cultures. Maximum protein accumulation, approaching 20 micrograms/mL, was observed at mid-exponential phase, followed by a degradation of a specific protein subset that coincided with the onset of stationary phase. Two major extracellular proteins and one intracellular protein, purified by ion-exchange and reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography, were identified as class III chitinases (EC 3.2.1.14) based on N-terminal amino acid sequence and amino acid composition homologies with other class III chitinases. The Trichosanthes chitinases also showed reactivity with a cucumber class III chitinase antiserum and chitinolytic activity in a glycol chitin gel assay. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and western blot analysis of intracellular proteins showed that normal and transformed T. kirilowii var japonicum roots accumulated only low levels of TCN (approximately 0.5% total soluble protein). Storage roots from the plant displayed protein and antigen patterns different from root cultures and produced TCN as the dominant protein. Roots undergoing secondary growth and differentiation exhibited patterns similar to those of storage roots, including increased TCN levels, indicating that high production of TCN is associated with induction of secondary growth in roots.

Bacterial plant oncogenes: the rol genes' saga

The rol genes are part of the T-DNA which is transferred by Agrobacterium rhizogenes in plant cells, causing neoplastic growth and differentiation. Each of these bacterial oncogenes deeply influences plant development and is finely regulated once transferred into the plant host. Both from the study of the effects and biochemical function of the rol genes and from the analysis of their regulation, important insight in plant development can be derived. Some of the most intriguing aspects of past, current and future research on this gene system are highlighted and discussed.

ocs element promoter sequences are activated by auxin and salicylic acid in Arabidopsis

ocs elements are a group of promoter elements that have been exploited by two distinct groups of plant pathogens, Agrobacterium and certain viruses, to express genes in plants. We examined the activity of single and multiple ocs elements linked to a minimal plant promoter and the uidA reporter gene in transgenic Arabidopsis. beta-Glucuronidase activity was detected only in root tips and in callus tissue after auxin treatment. A more sensitive assay revealed that auxin treatment also increased ocs element activity in aerial parts of the plant, although the absolute levels of ocs element activity were greater in roots. The response of ocs elements to exogenous auxin began within 1 h. Salicylic acid, a disease-resistance signal in plants, also increased ocs element activity in both roots and aerial parts of the plant. The question of whether the induction in ocs element activity is mediated through auxin and/or salicylic acid signal transduction pathways or is part of a more general stress response is discussed.

The chromosomal response regulatory gene chvI of Agrobacterium tumefaciens complements an Escherichia coli phoB mutation and is required for virulence

In an effort to identify the Agrobacterium tumefaciens phosphate regulatory gene(s), we isolated a clone from an A. tumefaciens cosmid library that restored regulated alkaline phosphatase activity to an Escherichia coli phoB mutant. The gene that complemented phoB was localized by subcloning and deletion analysis, and the DNA sequence was determined. An open reading frame, denoted chvI, was identified that encoded a predicted protein with amino acid similarity to the family of bacterial response regulators and 35% identify to PhoB. Surprisingly, an A. tumefaciens chvI mutant showed normal induction of phosphatase activity and normal virG expression when grown in phosphate-limiting media. However, this mutant was unable to grow in media containing tryptone, peptone, or Casamino Acids and was also more sensitive than the wild type to acidic extracellular pH. This mutant was avirulent on Kalanchoeë diagremontiana and was severely attenuated in vir gene expression. The pH-inducible expression of virG was also abolished. Growth of the chvI mutant was inhibited by K. diagremontiana wound sap, suggesting that avirulence may be due, in part, to the inability of this mutant to survive the plant wound environment.

TL -DNA transformation decreases ABA level

The endogenous levels of ABA were measured in Agrobacterium rhizogenes A₄ T_l -DNA transformed oilseed rape (Brassica napus L. var. oleifera cv. Brutor and cv. Drakkar), cabbage (Brassica oleracea). A₄ transformed tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum cv. Xanthi) and their normal counterparts, using high performance liquid chromatography and enzyme-liked immunosorbent assay. Measurements were made on different plant tissues (i. e. floral stem, terminal bud, young leaf, mature leaf, root and root tips) and ABA levels were compared in unstressed and osmotically stressed oilseed rape plants (cv. Brutor). In unstressed Plants. in each of the 5 independent transformation events studied, a significant reduction (about 65% of control) in ABA concentration was observed in all transformed plants. When subjected to an osmotic stress, T_L transformed Brutor plants showed a higher ABA accumulation than untransformed plants. The change in ABA content as a consequence of T_L -DNA transformation is discussed with regard to phenotype, drought resistance and adaptability.

Levels and location of expression of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens pTiA6 ipt gene promoter in transgenic tobacco

The location of gene expression of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens ipt gene promoter in transgenic tobacco plants was examined using the beta-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene. Expression of GUS was detected in every organ and most cell types examined. The highest levels of GUS activity were found in roots. To further examine the transcriptional basis of this broad expression pattern, deletions in the 5' non-coding region of the gene were translationally fused to two promoterless reporter genes, encoding the enzymes chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) and beta-glucuronidase (GUS). Reporter enzyme assays revealed the existence of an upstream segment required for maximal promoter function, the 5' end of which is between -442 and -408 of the Pipt ATG codon. This upstream segment is required for maximal levels of GUS expression in roots, but not in other organs, and a tobacco suspension-cultured cell line. The implications of broad ipt expression on the process of crown gall tumorigenesis are discussed.

The plant hormone auxin: insight in sight

Physiological experiments conducted over the last 60 years indicate that the plant hormone auxin regulates a diverse set of developmental processes via changes in cell division, cell elongation and cell differentiation. Recent studies using transgenic plants with altered auxin levels support these conclusions and promise to provide more detailed information on the role of auxin during plant development. Although it is possible that all auxin responses are mediated by the same primary biochemical events, the studies described in this review are more consistent with multiple modes of auxin action. The development of molecular and genetic approaches to the study of hormone action should resolve this issue. The accelerated rate of progress in this field suggests that real insight into the mechanism of auxin action may be forthcoming.

Two-way chemical signaling in Agrobacterium-plant interactions

The discovery in 1977 that Agrobacterium species can transfer a discrete segment of oncogenic DNA (T-DNA) to the genome of host plant cells has stimulated an intense interest in the molecular biology underlying these plant-microbe associations. This attention in turn has resulted in a series of insights about the biology of these organisms that continue to accumulate at an ever-increasing rate. This excitement was due in part to the notion that this unprecedented interkingdom DNA transfer could be exploited to create transgenic plants containing foreign genes of scientific or commercial importance. In the course of these discoveries, Agrobacterium became one of the best available models for studying the molecular interactions between bacteria and higher organisms. One extensively studied aspect of this association concerns the exchange of chemical signals between Agrobacterium spp. and host plants. Agrobacterium spp. can recognize no fewer than five classes of low-molecular-weight compounds released from plants, and other classes probably await discovery. The most widely studied of these are phenolic compounds, which stimulate the transcription of the genes needed for infection. Other compounds include specific monosaccharides and acidic environments which potentiate vir gene induction, acidic polysaccharides which induce one or more chromosomal genes, and a family of compounds called opines which are released from tumorous plant cells to the bacteria as nutrient sources. Agrobacterium spp. in return release a variety of chemical compounds to plants. The best understood is the transferred DNA itself, which contains genes that in various ways upset the balance of phytohormones, ultimately causing neoplastic cell proliferation. In addition to transferring DNA, some Agrobacterium strains directly secrete phytohormones. Finally, at least some strains release a pectinase, which degrades a component of plant cell walls.

Expression of the GUS-gene in the monocot tulip after introduction by particle bombardment and Agrobacterium

Gene transfer to the monocotyledon tulip (Tulipa sp. L.) was obtained both by particle bombardment and Agrobacterium transformation. Using a Particle Delivery System, transient expression of the reporter gene for ßglucuronidase was demonstrated. It was shown that the CAMV 35S as well as the TR2' promoter were active in flower stem expiants. Various wildtype and disarmed Agrobacterium strains, harbouring the 35S GUSintron gene on a binary plasmid, were used for infection of flower stem expiants of 7 cultivars and 7 botanical Tulipa species. In nine genotypes the GUSintron gene was expressed, despite the fact that tulip tissue did not produce detectable amounts of virulence-inducing substances. Agrobacterium rhizogenes appeared to be most effective in gene transfer to tulip tissue.

Hormone-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis have an attenuated response to agrobacterium strains

We have examined the response of the hormone-resistant mutants axr1 and axr2 of Arabidopsis thaliana to inoculation by Agrobacterium tumefaciens and Agrobacterium rhizogenes. Our results indicate that recessive mutations in the axr1 gene affect the frequency of tumor formation after inoculation with either Agrobacterium strain. In addition, tumors produced on axr1 plants were smaller than those growing on wild-type plants. These results indicate that the product of the AXR1 gene is important for both crown gall and hairy root tumor formation. In contrast, the dominant axr2 mutation has a more severe effect on the development of crown gall tumors than on hairy root tumors. Crown gall tumors produced on axr2 plants had a different morphology than wild-type tumors and did not grow when they were removed from the explant. In contrast, a large number of hairy root tumors were produced on wild-type and axr2 plants, and both types of tumors grew when they were removed from the explant. Like the roots of axr2 plants, roots produced on axr2 explants lacked root hairs.

The Agrobacterium tumefaciens vir gene transcriptional activator virG is transcriptionally induced by acid pH and other stress stimuli

A set of Agrobacterium tumefaciens operons required for pathogenesis is coordinately induced during plant infection by the VirA and VirG proteins. The intracellular concentration of VirG increases in response to acidic media, and this response was proposed to be regulated at the level of transcription at a promoter (P2) that resembles the Escherichia coli heat shock promoters. To test this hypothesis, we first constructed a virG-lacZ transcriptional fusion. A strain containing this fusion had higher levels of beta-galactosidase activity in acidic media than in media at neutral pH. Second, primer extension analysis of virG indicated that acidic media stimulated the transcription of this promoter. To determine whether P2 is a member of a heat shock-like regulon in A. tumefaciens, five agents that induce E. coli heat shock genes were tested for their abilities to induce a P2-lacZ fusion in A. tumefaciens. P2 was most strongly induced by low pH, was moderately stimulated by CdCl2 or mitomycin C, and was slightly induced by P2 as measured by beta-galactosidase activity and primer extension analysis. Induction by these treatments did not require any Ti plasmid-encoded function or the chromosomally encoded RecA protein. We also pulse-labeled cellular proteins after a shift to low pH and detected several proteins whose synthesis was induced by these conditions. We conclude that P2 is primarily induced by acid pH and secondarily by certain other stimuli, each of which is stressful to cell growth. This stress induction is at least partly independent of the heat shock and SOS responses.

Characterization of the Agrobacterium tumefaciens heat shock response: evidence for a sigma 32-like sigma factor

We have characterized the heat shock response of Agrobacterium tumefaciens and compared it with the well-characterized Escherichia coli heat shock response. Four major heat shock proteins with apparent molecular masses of 98, 75, 65, and 20 kDa were identified by pulse-labelling cultures after temperature upshift. The three largest proteins comigrated with proteins that were antigenically related to the E. coli heat shock proteins sigma 70, DnaK, and GroEL, respectively. The heat shock proteins were also strongly induced by ethanol and cadmium chloride and were mildly induced by mitomycin C. To determine whether the A. tumefaciens heat shock regulatory system was similar to that of E. coli, we introduced the E. coli dnaK gene into A. tumefaciens. The E. coli DnK protein was expressed in A. tumefaciens, and its synthesis was induced after heat shock. Primer extension analysis of the E. coli dnaK gene in A. tumefaciens indicated that transcription initiated from one or possibly both of the E. coli heat shock promoters. We conclude that A. tumefaciens has a heat shock response similar to that of E. coli, in that (i) similar proteins are induced by heat shock, (ii) synthesis of these proteins is induced in response to similar stimuli, and (iii) A. tumefaciens can recognize an E. coli heat shock promoter, suggesting that A. tumefaciens has a sigma factor similar to sigma 32.

A plausible model for reversal of neoplastic transformations in plants based on multiple steady states

We offer a plausible interpretation of some experiments on the reversal of neoplastic transformations in plants. We suggest that normal cells and tumorous cells represent multiple stable-steady states corresponding to a reaction feedback mechanism. The (autocatalytic) feedback loop is constructed from observations on the role played by myo-inositol: it increases the permeability of ions through the membrane and the biosynthetic pathway to myo-inositol is activated by ions. Provided that the permeabilities of nutrients (sugars and salts) are a product-enhanced function of myo-inositol, then we have a (oversimplified) model that can exhibit multiple stationary stable states, one or two depending on the exogenous nutrients and myo-inositol concentrations, and reversible and irreversible transitions from one of these states to the other are possible. From this model, straightforward simple experiments are suggested. We also propose that recent models dealing with the intracellular calcium regulation by hormones, where one key step requires the hydrolysis of inositol phospholipids, take into account free myo-inositol and endogenous hormone concentrations (e.g., auxins).

Agrobacterium rhizogenes-mediated transformation of Echinacea purpurea

Echinacea purpurea seedlings were inoculated with several Agrobacterium rhizogenes strains in order to obtain hairy roots. Infection with A. rhizogenes strains LMG63 and LMG150 resulted in callus formation. Upon infection with strains ATCC 15834 and R1601 hairy roots were obtained. Opine detection confirmed transformation of E. purpurea. Comparative HPLC fingerprint analysis of the alkamides from natural plant source, control tissues, and transformed callus and roots indicated that transformed callus and hairy roots might be a promising source for continuous and standardized production of the dodeca-2E,4E,8Z,10E/Z-tetraenoic acid isobutylamide and related amides.

Growth and development of the axr1 mutants of Arabidopsis

We have recovered eight new auxin-resistant lines of Arabidopsis that carry mutations in the AXR1 gene. These eight lines, together with the 12 lines described in a previous report, define at least five different axr1 alleles. All of the mutant lines have a similar phenotype. Defects include decreases in plant height, root gravitropism, hypocotyl elongation, and fertility. Mutant line axr1-3 is less resistant to auxin than the other mutant lines and has less severe morphological abnormalities. This correlation suggests that the morphological defects are a consequence of a defect in auxin action. To determine whether the altered morphology of mutant plants is associated with changes in cell size or tissue organization, tissue sections were examined using scanning electron microscopy. No clear differences in cell size were observed between wild-type and mutant tissues. However, the vascular bundles of mutant stems were found to be less well differentiated than those in wild-type stems. The auxin sensitivity of rosette-stage plants was determined by spraying plants with auxin solutions. Mutant rosettes were found to be significantly less sensitive to exogenously applied auxin than wild-type rosettes, indicating that the AXR1 gene functions in aerial portions of the plant. Our studies suggest that the AXR1 gene is required for auxin action in most, if not all, tissues of the plant and plays an important role in plant development. Linkage studies indicate that the gene is located on chromosome 1 approximately 2 centiMorgans from the closest restriction fragment length polymorphism.

Growth and development of the axr1 mutants of Arabidopsis

We have recovered eight new auxin-resistant lines of Arabidopsis that carry mutations in the AXR1 gene. These eight lines, together with the 12 lines described in a previous report, define at least five different axr1 alleles. All of the mutant lines have a similar phenotype. Defects include decreases in plant height, root gravitropism, hypocotyl elongation, and fertility. Mutant line axr1-3 is less resistant to auxin than the other mutant lines and has less severe morphological abnormalities. This correlation suggests that the morphological defects are a consequence of a defect in auxin action. To determine whether the altered morphology of mutant plants is associated with changes in cell size or tissue organization, tissue sections were examined using scanning electron microscopy. No clear differences in cell size were observed between wild-type and mutant tissues. However, the vascular bundles of mutant stems were found to be less well differentiated than those in wild-type stems. The auxin sensitivity of rosette-stage plants was determined by spraying plants with auxin solutions. Mutant rosettes were found to be significantly less sensitive to exogenously applied auxin than wild-type rosettes, indicating that the AXR1 gene functions in aerial portions of the plant. Our studies suggest that the AXR1 gene is required for auxin action in most, if not all, tissues of the plant and plays an important role in plant development. Linkage studies indicate that the gene is located on chromosome 1 approximately 2 centiMorgans from the closest restriction fragment length polymorphism.