Functional effects of myoblast implantation into histoincompatible mice with or without immunosuppression

Changes in Mass and Performance in Rabbit Muscles after Muscle Damage with or without Transplantation of Primary Satellite Cells

Changes in morphology, metabolism, myosin heavy chain gene expression, and functional performances in damaged rabbit muscles with or without transplantation of primary satellite cells were investigated. For this purpose, we damaged bilaterally the fast muscle tibialis anterior (TA) with either 1.5 or 2.6 ml cardiotoxin 10–5 M injections. Primary cultures of satellite cells were autotransplanted unilaterally 5 days after muscle degeneration. Two months postoperation, the masses of damaged TAs, with or without transplantation, were significantly larger than those of the controls. Furthermore, damaged transplanted muscles weighed significantly more than damaged muscles only. The increase in muscle mass was essentially due to increased fiber size. These results were independent of the quantity of cardiotoxin injected into the muscles. Maximal forces were similar in control and 2.6 ml damaged TAs with or without satellite cell transfer. In contrast, 1.5 ml damaged TAs showed a significant decrease in maximal forces that reached the level of controls after transplantation of satellite cells. Fatigue resistance was similar in control and 1.5 ml damaged TAs independently of satellite cell transfer. Fatigue index was significantly higher in 2.6 ml damaged muscles with or without cell transplantation. These changes could be explained in part by muscle metabolism, which shifted towards oxidative activities, and by gene expression of myosin heavy chain isoforms, which presented an increase in type IIa and a decrease in type I and IIb in all damaged muscles with or without cell transfer. Under our experimental conditions, these results show that muscle damage rather than satellite cell transplantation changes muscle metabolism, myosin heavy chain isoform gene expression, and, to a lesser extent, muscle contractile properties. In contrast, muscle weight and fiber size are increased both by muscle damage and by satellite cell transfer.

Cell therapy in muscular dystrophies: many promises in mice and dogs, few facts in patients

INTRODUCTION

Muscular dystrophies (MDs) are genetic diseases that produce progressive loss of skeletal muscle fibers. Cell therapy (CT) is an experimental approach to treat MD. The first clinical trials of CT in MD conducted in the 1990s were based on myoblast transplantation (MT). Since they did not yield the expected results, several researchers sought to discover other cells with more advantageous properties than myoblasts whereas others sought to improve MT.

AREAS COVERED

We explain the properties that are required for a cell to be used in CT of MD. We briefly review most of the cells that were proposed for this CT, and to what extent these properties were met not only in laboratory animals but also in clinical trials.

EXPERT OPINION

Although the repertoire of cells proposed for CT of MD has been expanded since the 1990s, only myoblasts have currently demonstrated unequivocally to significantly engraft in humans. Indeed, MT for MD involves significant technical challenges that need be solved. While it would be ideal to find cells involving less technical challenges for CT of MD, there is so far no clinical evidence that this is possible and therefore the work to improve MT should continue.

Leucine supplementation accelerates connective tissue repair of injured tibialis anterior muscle

This study investigated the effect of leucine supplementation on the skeletal muscle regenerative process, focusing on the remodeling of connective tissue of the fast twitch muscle tibialis anterior (TA). Young male Wistar rats were supplemented with leucine (1.35 g/kg per day); then, TA muscles from the left hind limb were cryolesioned and examined after 10 days. Although leucine supplementation induced increased protein synthesis, it was not sufficient to promote an increase in the cross-sectional area (CSA) of regenerating myofibers (p > 0.05) from TA muscles. However, leucine supplementation reduced the amount of collagen and the activation of phosphorylated transforming growth factor-β receptor type I (TβR-I) and Smad2/3 in regenerating muscles (p < 0.05). Leucine also reduced neonatal myosin heavy chain (MyHC-n) (p < 0.05), increased adult MyHC-II expression (p < 0.05) and prevented the decrease in maximum tetanic strength in regenerating TA muscles (p < 0.05). Our results suggest that leucine supplementation accelerates connective tissue repair and consequent function of regenerating TA through the attenuation of TβR-I and Smad2/3 activation. Therefore, future studies are warranted to investigate leucine supplementation as a nutritional strategy to prevent or attenuate muscle fibrosis in patients with several muscle diseases.

Electroporation as a method to induce myofiber regeneration and increase the engraftment of myogenic cells in skeletal muscles of primates

Engraftment of intramuscularly transplanted myogenic cells in mice can be optimized after induction of massive myofiber damage that triggers myofiber regeneration and recruitment of grafted cells; this generally involves either myotoxin injection or cryodamage. There are no effective methods to produce a similar process in the muscles of large mammals such as primates. In this study, we tested the use of intramuscular electroporation for this purpose in 11 macaques. The test sites were 1 cm of skeletal muscle. Each site was treated with 3 penetrations of a 2-needle electrode with 1 cm spacing, applying 3 pulses of 400 V/cm, for a duration of 5 milliseconds and a delay of 200 milliseconds during each penetration. Transplantation of β-galactosidase-labeled myoblasts was done in electroporated and nonelectroporated sites. Electroporation induced massive myofiber necrosis that was followed by efficient muscle regeneration. Myoblast engraftment was substantially increased in electroporated compared with nonelectroporated sites. This suggests that electroporation may be a useful tool to study muscle regeneration in primates and other large mammals and as a method for increasing the engraftment of myoblasts and other myogenic cells in intramuscular transplantation.

Promotion of muscle regeneration by myoblast transplantation combined with the controlled and sustained release of bFGFcpr

Although myoblast transplantation is an attractive method for muscle regeneration, its efficiency remains limited. The efficacy of myoblast transplantation in combination with the controlled and sustained delivery of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) was investigated. Defects of thigh muscle in Sprague-Dawley (SD) rats were created, and GFP-positive myoblasts were subsequently transplanted. The rats were divided into three groups. In control group 1 (C1) only myoblasts were transplanted, while in control group 2 (C2) myoblasts were introduced along with empty gelatin hydrogel microspheres. In the experimental group (Ex), myoblasts were transplanted along with bFGF incorporated into gelatin hydrogel microspheres. Four weeks after transplantation, GFP-positive myoblasts were found to be integrated into the recipient muscle and to contribute to muscle fibre regeneration in all groups. A significantly higher expression level of GFP in the Ex group demonstrated that the survival rate of transplanted myoblasts in Ex was remarkably improved compared with that in C1 and C2. Furthermore, myofibre regeneration, characterized by centralization of the nuclei, was markedly accelerated in Ex. The expression level of CD31 in Ex was higher than that in both C1 and C2, but the differences were not statistically significant. A significantly higher expression level of Myogenin and a lower expression level of MyoD1 were both observed in Ex after 4 weeks, suggesting the promotion of differentiation to myotubes. Our findings suggest that the controlled and sustained release of bFGF from gelatin hydrogel microspheres improves the survival rate of transplanted myoblasts and promotes muscle regeneration by facilitating myogenesis rather than angiogenesis.

Intramuscular cell transplantation as a potential treatment of myopathies: clinical and preclinical relevant data

INTRODUCTION

Myopathies produce deficits in skeletal muscle function and, in some cases, literally progressive loss of skeletal muscles. The transplantation of cells able to differentiate into myofibers is an experimental strategy for the potential treatment of some of these diseases.

AREAS COVERED

Among the two routes used to deliver cells to skeletal muscles, that is intramuscular and intravascular, this paper focuses on the intramuscular route due to our expertise and because it is the most used in animal experiments and the only tested so far in humans. Given the absence of recent reviews about clinical observations and the profusion based on mouse results, this review prioritizes observations made in humans and non-human primates. The review provides a vision of cell transplantation in myology centered on what can be learned from clinical trials and from preclinical studies in non-human primates and leading mouse studies.

EXPERT OPINION

Experiments on myogenic cell transplantation in mice are essential to quickly identify potential treatments, but studies showing the possibility to scale up the methods in large mammals are indispensable to determine their applicability in humans and to design clinical protocols.

Mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 is involved in differentiation of regenerating myofibers in vivo

This work was undertaken to provide further insight into the role of mammalian target of rapamycin complex 1 (mTORC1) in skeletal muscle regeneration, focusing on myofiber size recovery. Rats were treated or not with rapamycin, an mTORC1 inhibitor. Soleus muscles were then subjected to cryolesion and analyzed 1, 10, and 21 days later. A decrease in soleus myofiber cross-section area on post-cryolesion days 10 and 21 was accentuated by rapamycin, which was also effective in reducing protein synthesis in these freeze-injured muscles. The incidence of proliferating satellite cells during regeneration was unaltered by rapamycin, although immunolabeling for neonatal myosin heavy chain (MHC) was weaker in cryolesion+rapamycin muscles than in cryolesion-only muscles. In addition, the decline in tetanic contraction of freeze-injured muscles was accentuated by rapamycin. This study indicates that mTORC1 plays a key role in the recovery of muscle mass and the differentiation of regenerating myofibers, independently of necrosis and satellite cell proliferation mechanisms.

Intramuscular transplantation of human postnatal myoblasts generates functional donor-derived satellite cells

Myogenic cell transplantation is an experimental approach for the treatment of myopathies. In this approach, transplanted cells need to fuse with pre-existing myofibers, form new myofibers, and generate new muscle precursor cells (MPCs). The last property was fully reported following myoblast transplantation in mice but remains poorly studied with human myoblasts. In this study, we provide evidence that the intramuscular transplantation of postnatal human myoblasts in immunodeficient mice generates donor-derived MPCs and specifically donor-derived satellite cells. In a first experiment, cells isolated from mouse muscles 1 month after the transplantation of human myoblasts proliferated in vitro as human myoblasts. These cells were retransplanted in mice and formed myofibers expressing human dystrophin. In a second experiment, we observed that inducing muscle regeneration 2 months following transplantation of human myoblasts led to myofiber regeneration by human-derived MPCs. In a third experiment, we detected by immunohistochemistry abundant human-derived satellite cells in mouse muscles 1 month after transplantation of postnatal human myoblasts. These human-derived satellite cells may correspond totally or partially to the human-derived MPCs evidenced in the first two experiments. Finally, we present evidence that donor-derived satellite cells may be produced in patients that received myoblast transplantation.

NFAT/Fas signaling mediates the neuronal apoptosis and motor side effects of GSK-3 inhibition in a mouse model of lithium therapy

Use of lithium, the mainstay for treatment of bipolar disorder, is limited by its frequent neurological side effects and its risk for overdose-induced toxicity. Recently, lithium has also been proposed as a treatment for Alzheimer disease and other neurodegenerative conditions, but clinical trials have been hampered by its prominent side effects in the elderly. The mechanisms underlying both the positive and negative effects of lithium are not fully known. Lithium inhibits glycogen synthase kinase-3 (GSK-3) in vivo, and we recently reported neuronal apoptosis and motor deficits in dominant-negative GSK-3-transgenic mice. We hypothesized that therapeutic levels of lithium could also induce neuronal loss through GSK-3 inhibition. Here we report induction of neuronal apoptosis in various brain regions and the presence of motor deficits in mice treated chronically with lithium. We found that GSK-3 inhibition increased translocation of nuclear factor of activated T cells c3/4 (NFATc3/4) transcription factors to the nucleus, leading to increased Fas ligand (FasL) levels and Fas activation. Lithium-induced apoptosis and motor deficits were absent when NFAT nuclear translocation was prevented by cyclosporin A administration and in Fas-deficient lpr mice. The results of these studies suggest a mechanism for lithium-induced neuronal and motor toxicity. These findings may enable the development of combined therapies that diminish the toxicities of lithium and possibly other GSK-3 inhibitors and extend their potential to the treatment of Alzheimer disease and other neurodegenerative conditions.

Diaphragm muscle strip preparation for evaluation of gene therapies in mdx mice

1. Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), a severe muscle wasting disease of young boys with an incidence of one in every 3000, results from a mutation in the gene that encodes dystrophin. The absence of dystrophin expression in skeletal muscles and heart results in the degeneration of muscle fibres and, consequently, severe muscle weakness and wasting. The mdx mouse discovered in 1984, with some adjustments for differences, has proven to be an invaluable model for scientific investigations of dystrophy. 2. The development of the diaphagm strip preparation provided an ideal experimental model for investigations of skeletal muscle impairments in structure and function induced by interactions of disease- and age-related factors. Unlike the limb muscles of the mdx mouse, which show adaptive changes in structure and function, the diaphragm strip preparation reflects accurately the deterioration in muscle structure and function observed in boys with DMD. 3. The advent of sophisticated servo motors and force transducers interfaced with state-of-the-art software packages to drive complex experimental designs during the 1990s greatly enhanced the capability of the mdx mouse and the diaphragm strip preparation to evaluate more accurately the impact of the disease on the structure-function relationships throughout the life span of the mouse. 4. Finally, during the 1990s and through the early years of the 21st century, many promising, sophisticated genetic techniques have been designed to ameliorate the devastating impact of muscular dystrophy on the structure and function of skeletal muscles. During this period of rapid development of promising genetic therapies, the combination of the mdx mouse and the diaphragm strip preparation has provided an ideal model for the evaluation of the success, or failure, of these genetic techniques to improve dystrophic muscle structure, function or both. With the 2 year life span of the mdx mouse, the impact of age-related effects can be studied in this model.

First test of a "high-density injection" protocol for myogenic cell transplantation throughout large volumes of muscles in a Duchenne muscular dystrophy patient: eighteen months follow-up

A 26-years old Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) patient received normal muscle-precursor cells, proliferated in vitro and implanted in a thenar eminence, biceps brachii, and in a portion of a gastrocnemius by injections placed 1mm from each other or less. Saline was injected in the contralateral gastrocnemius. The patient was immunosuppressed with tacrolimus. The protocol of cell transplantation was well tolerated and did not cause permanent sequels. Some injected sites were biopsied at 1, 14 and 18 months post-transplantation. Muscles were replaced by fat and fibrosis. In the cell-grafted site of the gastrocnemius, 27.5% of the myofiber profiles expressed donor-derived dystrophin 1 month post-transplantation and 34.5% 18 months post-transplantation. The contralateral gastrocnemius was dystrophin-negative. Myofibers were virtually absent in the biceps brachii, where only two dystrophin-positive myofibers were observed. In conclusion, a "high-density injection" protocol was feasible for intramuscular cell-transplantation in a DMD patient and long-term expression of donor-derived dystrophin was observed.

Age dependence of the human skeletal muscle stem cell in forming muscle tissue

Human skeletal muscle stem cells from healthy donors aged 2-82 years (n = 13) and from three children suffering from Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD) were implanted into soleus muscles of immunoincompetent mice and were also expanded in vitro until senescence. Growth of implanted cells was quantified by structural features and by the amount of human DNA present in a muscle. Proliferative capacity in vitro and in vivo was inversely related to age of the donor. In vitro, a decline of about two mean population doublings (MPDs) per 10 years of donor's age was observed. Muscle stem cells from DMD children were prematurely aged. In general, cell preparations with low or decreasing content in desmin-positive cells produced more MPDs than age-matched high-desmin preparations and upon implantation more human DNA and more nonmyogenic than myogenic tissue. Thus, a "Desmin Factor" was derived which predicts "quality" of the human muscle tissue growing in vivo. This factor may serve as a prognostic tool.

Myoblast transplantation for inherited myopathies: a clinical approach

Myoblast transplantation (MT) is an experimental strategy for the potential treatment of myopathies. MT has two properties that make it potentially beneficial: genetic complementation and myogenic potential. Preclinical experiments on monkeys have shown that promising results can be obtained with MT in large muscles of primates depending on two conditions: appropriate immunosuppression and cell delivery by a method of high-density injections. Preclinical work on MT is being, or may be, addressed to: develop efficient methods of donor cell delivery applicable to clinics; control or avoid acute rejection by methods with the fewest secondary effects; understand the factors that condition the early survival of donor cells following transplantation; increase the success of each individual injection; re-engineer a functional structure in muscles that degenerates to fibrosis and fat substitution; and search for precursor cells with potential advantages over myoblasts.

Overexpression of inducible 70-kDa heat shock protein in mouse attenuates skeletal muscle damage induced by cryolesioning

Heat shock protein expression is elevated upon exposure to a variety of stresses and limits the extent of stress-induced damage. To investigate the putative role of inducible 70-kDa heat shock protein (HSP70) in skeletal muscle damage and regeneration, soleus and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles from HSP70-overexpressing transgenic mice were subjected to cryolesioning and analyzed after 1, 10, and 21 days. Histological analysis showed that the muscles from both HSP70 and wild-type mice treated with radicicol (a HSP inducer) had decreased necrosis after cryolesioning compared with controls. The decrease in muscle fiber cross-sectional area in both soleus and TA muscles in 10 days postlesioning was attenuated in HSP70 mice compared with wild-type mice. Glutathione peroxidase activity was increased 1 day after cryolesioning in both HSP70 and control mice and remained elevated for up to 21 days. Immunodetection of neuronal cell adhesion molecule (a satellite cell marker) and developmental/neonatal MHC were significantly lower in cryolesioned HSP70-overexpressing mice than in cryolesioned controls. These results suggest that HSP70 protects skeletal muscle against injury and radicicol might be useful as a skeletal muscle protective agent.

Cyclosporin A preferentially attenuates skeletal slow-twitch muscle regeneration

Calcineurin, a Ca2+/calmodulin-dependent phosphatase, is associated with muscle regeneration via NFATc1/GATA2-dependent pathways. However, it is not clear whether calcineurin preferentially affects the regeneration of slow- or fast-twitch muscles. We investigated the effect of a calcineurin inhibitor, cyclosporin A (CsA), on the morphology and fiber diameter of regenerating slow- and fast-twitch muscles. Adult Wistar rats (259.5 +/- 9 g) maintained under standard conditions were treated with CsA (20 mg/kg body weight, ip) for 5 days, submitted to cryolesion of soleus and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles on the 6th day, and then treated with CsA for an additional 21 days. The muscles were removed, weighed, frozen, and stored in liquid nitrogen. Cryolesion did not alter the body weight gain of the animals after 21 days of regeneration (P = 0.001) and CsA significantly reduced the body weight gain (15.5%; P = 0.01) during the same period. All treated TA and soleus muscles showed decreased weights (17 and 29%, respectively, P < 0.05). CsA treatment decreased the cross-sectional area of both soleus and TA muscles of cryoinjured animals (TA: 2108 +/- 930 vs 792 +/- 640 microm(2); soleus: 2209 +/- 322 vs 764 +/- 439 m(2); P < 0.001). Histological sections of both muscles stained with Toluidine blue revealed similar regenerative responses after cryolesion. In addition, CsA was able to minimize these responses, i.e., centralized nuclei and split fibers, more efficiently so in TA muscle. These results indicate that calcineurin preferentially plays a role in regeneration of slow-twitch muscle.

On the Regenerative Capacity of Human Skeletal Muscle

The proliferative capacity of organotypic muscle stem cells, the satellite cells, from nine healthy human donors aged between 2 and 78 years was investigated. There was a loss in proliferative capacity with age, but the oldest donors (76, 78 years) would still be able to replace their musculature several times. Depending on frequency of desmin-positive (i.e., myogenic) cells during prolonged expansion, myoblast cultures could be designated as stable or unstable. There was a weak correlation between mean telomere lengths (estimated by flow-FISH) and remaining mean population doublings until senescence. A bimodal distribution of mean telomere lengths was apparent in both stable and unstable myoblast cultures and could be assigned to populations of differently sized cells. Furthermore, due to the presence of nonmyogenic cells with longer telomeres, unstable cultures tended to show an increasing rather than decreasing mean telomeric length on expansion. Bimodal distributions in myoblast cultures could be due to hitherto undefined myoblast populations.

Expression of tropism-related genes in regenerating skeletal muscle of rats treated with cyclosporin-A

This work was undertaken to provide further insights into the expression of tropism-related genes in regenerating skeletal muscle of adult rats treated with cyclosporin-A (CsA), a calcineurin inhibitor. Rats were treated with CsA for 5 days and, on the 6th day, were submitted to cryolesion of the soleus muscles. CsA treatment continued for 1, 10, and 21 days after cryolesion. Muscles were removed, frozen, and stored in liquid nitrogen. Body and muscle weights, histological sections stained with toluidine blue, and gene expression of the regeneration molecular markers, viz., desmin and neonatal myosin heavy chain, were assessed to confirm that cryolesion and CsA treatment were effective during the allowed regeneration time. Quantitative reverse transcription/polymerase chain reaction demonstrated that myostatin gene expression was not altered by either cryolesion or CsA treatment combined with cryolesion. Calpain-3 gene expression decreased at 1 day after cryolesion and also following CsA treatment combined with cryolesion. However, calpain-3 gene expression was strongly up-regulated (approximately five-fold) 10 days after cryolesion and returned to control levels at day 21. CsA treatment blocked calpain-3 gene expression rise induced by 10 days of cryolesion. Atrogin-1 gene expression was decreased at 1 day after cryolesion and following cryolesion combined with CsA treatment, returning to control levels at day 10. These results suggest that (1) calpain-3 has a differential role in the early and late stages of regeneration in a calcineurin-dependent manner, and (2) atrogin-1 is involved in the early stages of regeneration independently of calcineurin.

Effectiveness of transient immunosuppression using cyclosporine for xenomyoblast transplantation for cardiac repair

We studied the survival of human myoblast for cellular myocardial reconstruction in a porcine model of chronic myocardial ischemia with immune tolerance using transient immunosuppression. A porcine model of chronic cardiac ischemia was created in 10 pigs (DMEM medium-injected n = 4; myoblast transplanted n = 6) by clamping ameroid ring around left circumflex coronary artery. Three weeks later, 3 x 10(8) human myoblasts carrying lac-z reporter gene were transplanted in multiple sites (0.25 mL each) into the left ventricular wall. Immunosuppression was achieved with 5 mg/kg cyclosporine for 6 weeks after cell transplantation. After animals were euthanized between 6 and 30 weeks after cell transplantation; the heart was removed for histological studies. Discontinuation of immunosuppression after 6 weeks of cell transplantation did not result in donor cell rejection. The lac-z-positive donor cells were detected in porcine host cardiac tissue for up to 30 weeks posttransplantation, expressing human skeletal myosin heavy chain. The results highlight the effectiveness of transient immunosuppression for myoblast transplantation for cardiac repair.

Cell therapies for inherited myopathies

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Cell therapies for inherited myopathies are based on the implantation of normal or genetically corrected myogenic cells into the body. This review summarizes the recent progress in this field, systematized according to the factors important for success.

RECENT FINDINGS

In the choice of donor cells, myoblasts derived from satellite cells remain the best choice. Some studies on the population of muscle-derived stem cells in mice suggested that these cells may have some advantages over myoblasts; however, no results supporting this advantage have been presented in a primate model. Recent studies on bone marrow transplantation as a systemic source of myogenic precursors for the treatment of myopathies were disappointing. Concerning donor cell delivery, intramuscular myoblast injection remains the only way that can significantly introduce exogenous myogenic cells into the muscles. A recent study in primates showed some parameters of myoblast injection that could be useful in the human. Progress was made in mice to understand the factors that could favor the migration of the donor myoblasts in the host muscles. Concerning donor cell survival, analysis of immune cell infiltration dynamics allowed a better understanding of the factors implicated in early donor cell death. Progress was made on the control of acute rejection for myoblast transplantation in primates. So far, few mouse experiments have advanced the field of tolerance induction toward myogenic cells.

SUMMARY

Myoblast transplantation (intramuscular injection of satellite cell-derived myoblasts) currently remains the only cell-based therapy that has produced promising results in the context of a preclinical model such as the nonhuman primate.

Extended amplification in vitro and replicative senescence: key factors implicated in the success of human myoblast transplantation

The limited success of human myoblast transplantation has been related to immune rejection, poor survival, and limited spread of injected myoblasts after transplantation. An important issue that has received little attention, but is nevertheless of fundamental importance in myoblast transplantation protocols, is the proliferative capacity of human satellite cells. Previous studies from our laboratory have demonstrated that the maximum number of divisions that a population of satellite cells can make decreases with age during the first two decades of life then stabilizes in adulthood. These observations indicate that when satellite cells are used as vectors in myoblast transplantation protocols it is important to consider donor age and the number of divisions that the cells have made prior to transplantation as limiting factors in obtaining an optimal number of donor derived muscle fibers. In this study, myoblasts derived from donors of different ages (newborn, 17 years old, and 71 years old) were isolated and amplified in culture. Their potential to participate in in vivo muscle regeneration in RAG2(-/-)/gamma(c)/C5 triple immunodeficient hosts after implantation was evaluated at 4 and 8 weeks postimplantation. Our results demonstrate that prolonged amplification in culture and the approach to replicative senescence are both important factors that may condition the success of myoblast transplantation protocols.

Efficacy of myoblast transplantation in nonhuman primates following simple intramuscular cell injections: toward defining strategies applicable to humans

Nonhuman primates were used to define myoblast transplantation strategies applicable to humans. Nevertheless, previous experiments were based on the use of myotoxins concomitant with the myoblast injections. Since myotoxins must be avoided for clinical applications, we analyzed the efficacy of simple myoblast injections (i.e., myoblasts resuspended only in saline) into monkey muscles. We also evaluated different FK506 dosages (in combination or not with mycophenolate mofetil) for immunosuppression. Allogeneic myoblasts transduced with the beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) gene were implanted in the muscles of 19 monkeys by injections placed 1 to 2 mm from each other. A biopsy was performed at the implanted sites 1 month later, and histologically studied for demonstration of beta-Gal+ myofibers, lymphocyte infiltration, and CD8+ cells. The presence of antibodies against the donor myoblasts and the blood levels of FK506 were analyzed. Our results show that: (1) If myoblast injections are sufficiently close to each other, high percentages of hybrid myofibers can be obtained following myoblast transplantation in primates (25 to 67% with an interinjection distance of 1 mm). (2) Efficient immunosuppression can be reached by increasing FK506 dosages, but also by combining this drug with mycophenolate mofetil, a combination that reduces toxic effects. The present results represent a step towards a better designing of myoblast transplantation strategies in humans.

Why do cultured transplanted myoblasts die in vivo? DNA quantification shows enhanced survival of donor male myoblasts in host mice depleted of CD4+ and CD8+ cells or Nk1.1+ cells

Overcoming the massive and rapid death of injected donor myoblasts is the primary hurdle for successful myoblast transfer therapy (MTT), designed as a treatment for the lethal childhood myopathy Duchenne muscular dystrophy. The injection of male myoblasts into female host mice and quantification of surviving male DNA using the Y-chromosome-specific (Y1) probe allows the speed and extent of death of donor myoblasts to be determined. Cultured normal C57BL/10Sn male donor myoblasts were injected into untreated normal C57BL/10Sn and dystrophic mdx female host mice and analyzed by slot blots using a 32P-labeled Y1 probe. The amount of male DNA from donor myoblasts showed a remarkable decrease within minutes and by 1 h represented only about 10-18% of the 2.5 x 10(5) cells originally injected (designated 100%). This declined further over 1 week to approximately 1-4%. The host environment (normal or dystrophic) as well as the extent of passaging in tissue culture (early "P3" or late "P15-20" passage) made no difference to this result. Modulation of the host response by CD4+/CD8+ -depleting antibodies administered prior to injection of the cultured myoblasts dramatically enhanced donor myoblast survival in dystrophic mdx hosts (15-fold relative to untreated hosts after 1 week). NK1.1 depletion also dramatically enhanced donor myoblast survival in dystrophic mdx hosts (21-fold after 1 week) compared to untreated hosts. These results provide a strategic approach to enhance donor myoblast survival in clinical trials of MTT.

Exposure to tissue culture conditions can adversely affect myoblast behavior in vivo in whole muscle grafts: implications for myoblast transfer therapy

The effects of tissue culture conditions on the viability of myoblasts in whole muscles transplanted in vivo were investigated. Whole male (SJL/J) donor muscles were exposed to various tissue culture reagents and proteolytic enzymes, and allografted into female (SJL/J) host mice. Desmin immunohistochemistry was used to assess the numbers of myogenic cells (as an index of myoblast viability and the extent of regeneration) in tissue sections of whole-muscle grafts sampled on days 7 and 14. DNA quantitation with a Y-chromosome-specific probe was used to determine the total Y-1 sequence DNA (as an index of myoblast survival and proliferation) in whole-muscle grafts sampled on days 1, 3, and 7. In grafts exposed to serum-free medium, there was a delay in myoblast fusion at 7 days that was recovered by 14 days, but exposure to serum (10% or 20%) had a prolonged adverse effect on myotube formation at 14 days. DNA quantitation demonstrated that either serum-free culture medium or 10% serum enhanced the number of male cells within whole-muscle grafts at 7 days. Proteolytic digestion (even for 5 min) of whole muscles prior to grafting was extremely detrimental to myoblast survival and viability at 7 and 14 days. The unexpected finding of adverse effects of tissue culture conditions on the regeneration of whole-muscle grafts in vivo appears to parallel the major problem of the rapid death of isolated cultured donor myoblasts after injection in myoblast transfer therapy. The use of whole-muscle grafts provides an alternative and sensitive model to analyze the crucial effects of various tissue culture components on the subsequent survival and proliferation of myogenic cells in vivo.

Immunobiology and the future of myoblast transfer therapy

Myoblast transfer therapy (MTT) is a cell-mediated gene transfer method aimed at the restoration of normal dystrophin expression in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Initial clinical MTT trials were conducted amid much controversy, as they were based on very few animal studies. Unfortunately, the trials were of little therapeutic benefit. As a result, there has been a renaissance of interest in experimental studies in animal models. In MTT, myoblasts are obtained by muscle biopsy from normal, i.e., dystrophin-positive, donors, expanded in culture, and injected directly into the muscles of dystrophic recipients. The major requirement for successful MTT is the survival of injected donor myoblasts in the host environment. However, a vast majority of donor cells fail to survive for more than 1 h after injection, and very few last beyond the first week. This review on the immunological aspects of MTT focuses in particular on the roles of specific components of the host immune response, the effects of tissue culture on donor cells, and strategies under development to circumvent the problem of donor myoblast death after injection in vivo.

Enhanced migration and fusion of donor myoblasts in dystrophic and normal host muscle

Sliced male C57Bl/10Sn (H2-b) donor muscles were grafted into the female histocompatible muscles of untreated, FK506-treated, and T-cell depleted (with or without thymic tolerization) dystrophic (mdx; H2-b) and normal (C57Bl/10Sn; H2-b) hosts, and also into histoincompatible normal (Balb/c; H2-d) hosts. The fate of male donor nuclei was monitored on tissue sections by in situ hybridization with a Y-chromosome specific probe. The results demonstrate that the dystrophic environment is more conducive than normal muscle to donor myoblast migration, with the distance moved being threefold greater at 12 weeks in dystrophic hosts. T-cell depletion was significantly more effective than FK506 treatment at enhancing donor myoblast emigration in both histocompatible and histoincompatible hosts at 3 weeks. Furthermore, the effects of T-cell depletion were sustained in histoincompatible hosts at 12 weeks. These data endorse the use of host T-cell depletion as a promising long-term strategy to improve myoblast transfer therapy (MTT) in the clinical situation.

Myoblast transplantation in whole muscle of nonhuman primates

The goal of the present study was to determine the feasibility, success, and toxicity of myoblast transplantation (MT) in the whole muscle of primates. Allogenic myoblasts transduced with the beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) gene were transplanted in the whole Biceps brachii of 5 monkeys immunosuppressed with FK506. Myoblast injections were spaced at every 1 to 1.5 mm in 7 muscles, as well as at every 5 mm in 2 muscles. Myoblasts were resuspended in HBSS, notexin 1 microg/ml or notexin 5 microg/ml. Depending on the number of beta-Gal labeled myoblasts and the injection protocol, biopsies of transplanted muscles exhibited 7% to 74% beta-Gal+ fibers 1 month after MT. Beta-Gal+ fibers were present in muscle biopsies made 3, 8, and 12 months after MT. Myoglobinuria and hyperkalemia, the risk factors after extensive muscle damage and notexin toxicity, were not observed. The withdrawal of immunosuppression led to histological evidences of cellular rejection of the graft. We concluded that MT can be successfully performed in large primate muscles without toxicity due to muscle damage. An effective immunosuppression allowed the maintenance of beta-Gal+ fibers up to 1 year after MT. These results suggest parameters that may allow effective MT in humans.

Progress in myoblast transplantation: a potential treatment of dystrophies

Myoblast transplantation (MT) consists of injecting normal or genetically modified myogenic cells into muscles, where they are expected to fuse and form mature fibers. As an experimental approach to treat severe genetic muscle diseases, MT was tested in dystrophic patients at the beginning of the 1990s. Although these early clinical trials were unsuccessful, MT has progressed through the research on animal models. Many factors that may condition the success of MT were identified in the last years. The present review updates our knowledge on MT and describes the different problems that have limited its success. Factors that were first underestimated, like the specific immune response after MT, are presently well characterized. Destruction of the hybrid fibers by activated T-lymphocytes and production of antibodies against the transplanted myoblasts take place after MT and are responsible for the graft rejection. The choice of the immunosuppression seems to be very important, and FK506 is the best agent known to allow the best results after MT. Under FK506 immunosuppression, very efficient MT were obtained both in mice and monkeys. Moreover, in dystrophic mice it was demonstrated that MT ameliorates some phenotypical characteristics of the disease. The improvement of the survival of the transplanted cells and the increase of their migration into the injected tissue are presently under investigation. Some of the present research is directed also to bypass the immunosuppression by using the patient's own cells for MT. In this sense, efforts are conducted to introduce the normal gene into the patient's myoblasts before MT and to improve the ability of these cells to proliferate in vitro. Micros. Res. Tech. 48:213-222, 2000.

Function of skeletal muscle tissue formed after myoblast transplantation into irradiated mouse muscles

1. Pretreatment of muscles with ionising radiation enhances tissue formation by transplanted myoblasts but little is known about the effects on muscle function. We implanted myoblasts from an expanded, male-donor-derived, culture (i28) into X-ray irradiated (16 Gy) or irradiated and damaged soleus muscles of female syngeneic mice (Balb/c). Three to 6 months later the isometric contractile properties of the muscles were studied in vitro, and donor nuclei were visualised in muscle sections with a Y chromosome-specific DNA probe. 2. Irradiated sham-injected muscles had smaller masses than untreated solei and produced less twitch and tetanic force (all by about 18 %). Injection of 106 myoblasts abolished these deficiencies and innervation appeared normal. 3. Cryodamage of irradiated solei produced muscle remnants with few (1-50) or no fibres. Additional myoblast implantation led to formation of large muscles (25 % above normal) containing numerous small-diameter fibres. Upon direct electrical stimulation, these muscles produced considerable twitch (53 % of normal) and tetanic forces (35 % of normal) but innervation was insufficient as indicated by weak nerve-evoked contractions and elevated ACh sensitivity. 4. In control experiments on irradiated muscles, reinnervation was found to be less complete after botulinum toxin paralysis than after nerve crush indicating that proliferative arrest of irradiated Schwann cells may account for the observed innervation deficits. 5. Irradiation appears to be an effective pretreatment for improving myoblast transplantation. The injected cells can even produce organised contractile tissue replacing whole muscle. However, impaired nerve regeneration limits the functional performance of the new muscle.

Intracardiac transplantation of skeletal myoblasts yields two populations of striated cells in situ

BACKGROUND

Adult heart lacks stem cells and cannot effectively regenerate. In contrast, skeletal muscle is constantly undergoing repair. We proposed to transplant immature skeletal myoblasts into injured myocardium.

METHODS

Approximately 7x10(6) soleus skeletal myoblasts were expanded in vitro from adult New Zealand White rabbits (n = 23) whose posterior left ventricle was cryoinjured to create a transmural lesion. Autologous myoblasts (n = 18) or saline (n = 5) was transplanted into the central cryolesion at the time of injury (n = 6) or 1 week later (n = 12). Hearts were harvested 2 weeks after injection.

RESULTS

Myoblast transfer did not incur further morbidity. After cryolesion, grossly, a 1.6-cm epicardial hemorrhagic lesion could be seen. Histologically, the transmural lesion contained inflammatory cells and active scarring but no viable cardiomyocytes. Electron microscopy demonstrated a predominance of collagen and fibroblasts. Nine hearts contained multinucleated cells within the cryolesion that covered approximately 75% of the central cryolesion in 17% of animals. Immunohistochemical analysis confirmed their skeletal muscle origin. At the periphery of the lesion, isolated clusters of nonskeletal muscle cells could be visualized (n = 12) that resembled immature cardiocytes.

CONCLUSIONS

Autologous skeletal myoblasts can regenerate viable striated tissue within damaged myocardium. Myoblast transfer warrants further investigation as a new method for improving myocardial performance within infarcted myocardium.

Ectopic skeletal muscles derived from myoblasts implanted under the skin

We investigated the potential of cultured myoblasts to generate skeletal muscle in an ectopic site. Myoblasts from a clonal cell line or from expanded primary cultures were injected under the skin of the lumbar region of adult syngenic Balb/c mice. One to 7 weeks after injection, distinct muscles, of greater mass in mice injected with clonal myoblasts (6–78 mg, n=37) than in mice injected with primary myoblasts (1–7 mg, n=26), had formed between the subcutaneous panniculus carnosus muscle and the trunk muscles of host animals. These ectopic muscles exhibited spontaneous and/or electrically-evoked contractions after the second week and, when stimulated directly in vitro, isometric contractile properties similar to those of normal muscles. Histological, electron microscopical and tissue culture examination of these muscles revealed their largely mature morphology and phenotype. The fibres, most of which were branched, were contiguous, aligned and capillarised, exhibited normal sarcormeric protein banding patterns, and expressed muscle-specific proteins, including desmin, dystrophin, and isoforms of developmental and adult myosin heavy chain. Enveloping each fibre was a basal lamina, beneath which lay quiescent satellite cells, which could be stimulated to produce new muscle in culture. Presence of endplates (revealed by alpha-bungarotoxin and neurofilament staining), and the eventual loss of expression of neural cell adhesion molecule and extrasynaptic acetylcholine receptors, indicated that some fibres were innervated. That these muscle fibres were of implanted-cell origin was supported by the finding of Y-chromosome and a lack of dystrophin in ectopic muscles formed after subcutaneous injection of, respectively, male myoblasts into female mice and dystrophin-deficient (mdx) myoblasts into normal C57Bl/10 muscle. Our results demonstrate that an organised, functional muscle can be generated de novo from a disorganised mass of myoblasts implanted in an extramuscular subcutaneous site, whereby the host contributes significantly in providing support tissues and innervation. Our observations are also consistent with the idea that myogenic cells behave like tissue-specific stem cells, generating new muscle precursor (satellite) cells as well as mature muscle. Subcutaneous implantation of myoblasts may have a range of useful applications, from the study of myogenesis to the delivery of gene products.

Impaired functional and structural recovery after muscle injury in dystrophic mdx mice

We compared functional and structural recovery from imposed muscle injury in mdx and wild type mice to test their regenerative capacity. Soleus muscle, known to be particularly affected by the disease process, was subjected to most severe damage caused by freeze injury plus 'bystander damage'; the latter causes destruction of host muscle cells in the course of immune rejection of implanted non-histocompatible myogenic cells. Freezing/implantation was performed in mdx and control mice at two ages (4-6 months, "young' and 10-12 months, 'old' age). While recovery of muscle force in the control groups reached 77 and 88% of contralateral by 3 and 6 months, it was 60% and only 43% in mdx mice damaged at young and old age, respectively. Larger force deficits in mdx mice were due to loss of muscle tissue as measured from desmin-positive areas. Worse recovery of dystrophic muscles in general, and old muscles in particular, is interpreted to indicate pronounced exhaustion of the regenerative capacity, possibly caused by previous cycles of degeneration and regeneration.

"Bystander" damage of host muscle caused by implantation of MHC-compatible myogenic cells

Transplantation of normal myoblasts has been considered a potential therapy for muscle dystrophies. While survival of implanted cells has been described in animal experiments and in human trials, functional effects remained unclear. Here we report on survival of progenors of implanted C2nlsBAG cells in regenerating muscles but irreversible net loss in muscle tissue and contractile force. This is caused by immune rejection of implanted myoblasts despite MHC-compatibility and "bystander" damage of host muscle tissue.

Cellular and molecular reactions in mouse muscles after myoblast implantation

Implantation of skeletal muscle precursor cells is a potential means of cell-mediated gene therapy. One unresolved question is the degree of immunogenicity of such myoblasts. We designed the extreme situation of implanting cells of a non-histocompatible myoblast cell line into cryodamaged, but regeneration-capable, muscles of adult mice. Without immunosuppression donor cells are rejected within the first weeks. Immunosuppression with Cyclosporin A prevented invasion of T-lymphocytes and allowed differentiation of implanted myoblasts into myofibres as well as down-regulation of MHC expression. Still, withdrawal of Cyclosporin A after 4 weeks triggered lymphocyte invasion and cytotoxic cell reactions with rejection of donor tissue. Although the vast majority of muscle fibres was MHC-negative 1-4 days after Cyclosporin A withdrawal, single small desmin-positive profiles were weakly positive for donor MHC. Parallel with the increase in the number of lymphocytes, larger numbers of small and large muscle fibres expressed high levels of either donor, host or both, class I--but not class II--molecules. Surprisingly, immune reactions continued over several months, causing gradual loss of muscle tissue. Donor class I molecules persisted for more than 6 months after Cyclosporin A withdrawal, clearly indicating survival of donor muscle fibres despite ongoing rejection. Indirect evidence on the other hand suggests additional loss of host fibres, possibly caused by cytokine release from the immune cells (bystander damage). We conclude that transient treatment with Cyclosporin A induced a kind of tolerance related to the maturation and down-regulation of class I antigens in donor muscle fibres. It is suggested that the start of immune reaction following Cyclosporin A withdrawal is initiated by remaining small amounts of donor MHC molecules, possibly related to the continuous proliferation of the cell-lined-derived donor myoblasts.