Figures of merit (FOMs) for imaging and therapy using monoclonal antibodies

A mechanistic compartmental model for total antibody uptake in tumors

Antibodies are under development to treat a variety of cancers, such as lymphomas, colon, and breast cancer. A major limitation to greater efficacy for this class of drugs is poor distribution in vivo. Localization of antibodies occurs slowly, often in insufficient therapeutic amounts, and distributes heterogeneously throughout the tumor. While the microdistribution around individual vessels is important for many therapies, the total amount of antibody localized in the tumor is paramount for many applications such as imaging, determining the therapeutic index with antibody drug conjugates, and dosing in radioimmunotherapy. With imaging and pretargeted therapeutic strategies, the time course of uptake is critical in determining when to take an image or deliver a secondary reagent. We present here a simple mechanistic model of antibody uptake and retention that captures the major rates that determine the time course of antibody concentration within a tumor including dose, affinity, plasma clearance, target expression, internalization, permeability, and vascularization. Since many of the parameters are known or can be estimated in vitro, this model can approximate the time course of antibody concentration in tumors to aid in experimental design, data interpretation, and strategies to improve localization.

Review: update on selection of optimal radiopharmaceuticals for clinical trials

Multiple formulations of radiopharmaceuticals (RPs) are possible because of engineering at the nanometer scale. Yet, numbers of patients are limited, and the cost of each clinical trial is high. Thus, there is the need of preclinical evaluation of one agent versus another for the selection of an optimal choice. In the application of RPs to cancer, this selection involves both visualization and treatment aspects. In this paper, we propose the use of imaging and therapeutic figures of merit (IFOM and TFOM, respectively) to select the optimal structure and radiolabel for subsequent clinical trials given animal biodistribution results. Limiting cases and Monte Carlo simulation were used to demonstrate that these modern figures of merit are superior to traditional ratio functions that have been employed in these two contexts. Finally, there is the question of how animal and human results resemble each other kinetically. We considered allometry and compared mouse and human results for several of the cognate cT84.66 antibodies (anti-CEA; carcinoembryonic antigen). While kinetics of intact and 120-kDa engineered proteins are similar across the two species, the 80-kDa cognate shows a manifest difference in the RP first moment in the blood. In particular, human blood clearance is slower than that seen in the nude mouse. We suggest that such allometric comparisons become standard in the reporting of clinical trials.

Monodispersed DOTA-PEG-conjugated anti-TAG-72 diabody has low kidney uptake and high tumor-to-blood ratios resulting in improved 64Cu PET

Diabodies are noncovalent dimers of single-chain antibody fragments that retain the avidity of intact IgG but have more favorable blood clearance than intact IgG. Radiometals offer a wide range of half-lives and emissions for matching imaging and therapy requirements and provide facile labeling of chelate-antibody conjugates. However, because of their high retention and metabolism in the kidney, the use of radiometal-labeled diabodies can be problematic for both imaging and therapy.

METHODS

Having previously shown that (111)In-DOTA-polyethylene glycol (PEG)3400-anti-carcinoembryonic antigen diabody has less than half the kidney uptake and retention of non-PEGylated diabody and that the two have similarly high tumor uptake and retention, we synthesized a similar derivative for an anti-tumor-associated glycoprotein 72 diabody. We also reduced the molecular size of the polydispersed PEG3400 to monodispersed PEG27 and PEG12 (nominal masses of 1,321 and 617, respectively). We performed biodistributions of their DOTA conjugates radiolabeled with (125)I, (111)In, or (64)Cu in tumor-bearing athymic mice.

RESULTS

The addition of PEG3400 to the diabody reduced kidney uptake to a level (approximately 10 percentage injected dose/g) comparable to that obtained with radiometal-labeled intact IgG. The PEG27 and PEG12 diabody conjugates also demonstrated low kidney uptake without reduction of tumor uptake or tumor-to-blood ratios. When radiolabeled with (64)Cu, the DOTA-PEG12 and -PEG27 diabody conjugates gave high-contrast PET images of colon cancer xenografts in athymic mice.

CONCLUSION

PEGylated diabodies may be a valuable platform for delivery of radionuclides and other agents to tumors.

Immuno-positron emission tomography in cancer models

Positron emission tomography (PET) is playing an increasingly important role in the diagnosis, staging, and monitoring response to treatment in a variety of cancers. Recent efforts have focused on immuno-PET, which uses antibody-based radiotracers, to image tumors based on expression of tumor-associated antigens. It is postulated that the specificity afforded by antibody targeting should both improve tumor detection and provide phenotypic information related to primary and metastatic lesions that will guide therapy decisions. Advances in antibody-engineering are providing the tools to develop antibody-based molecules with pharmacokinetic properties optimized for use as immuno-PET radiotracers. Coupled with technical advances in the design of PET scanners, immuno-PET holds promise to improve diagnostic imaging and to guide the use of targeted therapies. An overview of the preclinical immuno-PET studies in cancer models is reviewed here.

Anniversary paper: nuclear medicine: fifty years and still counting

The history, present status, and possible future of nuclear medicine are presented. Beginning with development of the rectilinear scanner and gamma camera, evolution to the present forms of hybrid technology such as single photon emission computed tomography/computed tomography (CT) and positron emission tomography/CT is described. Both imaging and therapy are considered and the recent improvements in dose estimation using hybrid technologies are discussed. Future developments listed include novel radiopharmaceuticals created using short chains of nucleic acids and varieties of nanostructures. Patient-specific radiotherapy is an eventual outcome of this work. Possible application to proving the targeting of potential chemotherapeutics is also indicated.

Multimodality imaging of the HER-kinase axis in cancer

The human epidermal growth factor receptor (HER) family of receptor tyrosine kinases controls critical pathways involved in epithelial cell differentiation, growth, division, and motility. Alterations and disruptions in the function of the HER-kinase axis can lead to malignancy. Many therapeutic agents targeting the HER-kinase axis are approved for clinical use or are in preclinical/clinical development. The ability to quantitatively image the HER-kinase axis in a noninvasive manner can aid in lesion detection, patient stratification, new drug development/validation, dose optimization, and treatment monitoring. This review summarizes the current status in multimodality imaging of the HER-kinase axis using PET, SPECT, optical, and MR imaging. The targeting ligands used include small-molecule tyrosine kinase inhibitors, peptides, proteins, antibodies, and engineered antibody fragments. EGFR and HER2 imaging have been well documented in the past, and imaging of HER3, HER4, HER heterodimers, and HER-kinase mutants deserves significant research effort in the future. Successful development of new HER-kinase-targeted imaging agents with optimal in vivo stability, targeting efficacy, and desirable pharmacokinetics for clinical translation will enable maximum benefit in cancer patient management.

Monoclonal antibody therapy for cancer

Monoclonal antibody therapy has emerged as an important therapeutic modality for cancer. Unconjugated antibodies show significant efficacy in the treatment of breast cancer, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, and chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Promising new targets for unconjugated antibody therapy include cellular growth factor receptors, receptors or mediators of tumor-driven angiogenesis, and B cell surface antigens other than CD20. Immunoconjugates composed of antibodies conjugated to radionuclides or toxins show efficacy in non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. One immunoconjugate containing an antibody and a chemotherapy agent exhibits clinically meaningful antitumor activity in acute myeloid leukemia. Numerous efforts to exploit the ability of antibodies to focus the activities of toxic payloads at tumor sites are under way and show early promise. The ability to create essentially human antibody structures has reduced the likelihood of host-protective immune responses that otherwise limit the duration of therapy. Antibody structures now can be readily manipulated to facilitate selective interaction with host immune effectors. Other structural manipulations that improve the selective targeting properties and rapid systemic clearance of immunoconjugates should lead to the design of effective new treatments, particularly for solid tumors.

Accumulation of radiolabeled anti-CEA antibody (mT84.66) in the case of multiple LS174T tumors in a nude mouse model

A comparison was made between labeled antibody accumulations in nude mice having either single or multiple human xenografts. The LS174T tumors were implanted subcutaneously. All animals were given 2 micrograms of labeled murine anti-carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) monoclonal antibody 111In-mT84.66. Some animals were also given specific antibody pretreatment (SAP) of 200 micrograms of unlabeled mT84.66 to reduce liver accumulation of activity. In order to represent these multiple tumor examples, a simple initial-phase pharmacokinetic model was first fitted to each of the two groups (SAP and PBS treated) of single-tumor animals. Using the resultant six non-adjustable parameters as constants, the n = 1 uptake model was then used to represent tumor, liver and blood accumulations (%injected dose/organ) in the multiple-tumor animals. The model was found to be a good representation; in particular, it had far better agreement than single tumor predictions in the PBS mice. Differences between the single-tumor accumulations and those seen in multiple tumor examples were generally between two- and three-fold. The model also demonstrated that the result of SAP was to essentially eliminate the effect of liver targeting of tumor-secreted CEA. We conclude that an initial-phase one-tumor model can describe the decrease of accumulation of activity in the case of multiple tumors in nude mice in both untreated (PBS) and pretreated conditions. Implications for clinical imaging and therapy with monoclonal agents are discussed.

Numerical selection of optimal tumor imaging agents with application to engineered antibodies

Three analytic indicators were used to compare five members of a monoclonal antibody (Mab) family. The cognates consisted of the genetically engineered intact chimeric IgGI (cT84.66) and related engineered fragments [scFv, diabody, minibody, F(ab')2] reactive against the same epitope of carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). All analyses were based on radioiodinated Mabs targeting to colorectal xenografts of LS174T tumors in nude mice. Affinity constants were evaluated initially. A second indicator was the imaging figure of merit (IFOM) which determines how rapidly a statistically significant tumor image can be acquired. Finally, deconvolution was used to determine tumor temporal response to an arterial bolus. This last analysis gave the possible tumor accumulation in the absence of normal tissue sequestration. Affinities were all in excess of 10(8) M-1 and were highest for the divalent Mabs. Using the IFOM criterion, an 131I label was best suited as a radiolabel for the intact (IgG) T84.66, while an 123I label indicated optimal imaging with either minibody or F(ab')2. Deconvolution analyses showed that divalent members behaved similarly while the univalent member (scFv) had a tumor residence time smaller by an order of magnitude. The diabody had the largest impulse response function, but renal uptake may limit its present usefulness.

Truncation of blood curves to enhance imaging and therapy with monoclonal antibodies

Targeting of monoclonal antibody (Mab) to solid tumor sites is a function of the blood curve of activity versus time. It has been suggested that the blood curve be artificially reduced to approach zero so that the contrast between tumor and blood uptake is maximized. We analyzed tumor uptake as a function of the time tc of blood curve truncation. By using a convolution approach, we were able to find the optimal times for setting the blood curve to zero in either diagnostic or therapeutic animal examples. Two iodinated cT84.66 anti-CEA engineered fragments, diabody and minibody, were considered using previous data from nude mouse studies involving the LS174T colorectal tumor model. Figures of merit (FOMs) were used to compare ordinary and truncated blood curves and their associated tumor accumulations. Using a 1231 label, it was seen that the appropriate time for diagnostic truncation occurred when tumor uptake, as measured, was a maximum. The corresponding point for therapy (with 1311 as a label) was at infinite time. We also demonstrated that the use of traditional indices led to ambiguities in the choice of truncation times. The traditional therapy index, the ratio of the integral of the tumor uptake to the integral of the blood uptake, was found to be a numerical constant independent of tc. This ratio was proved to be the integral of the tumor impulse response function. Use of such convolution techniques to assess truncation of the perfused material is probably also applicable to multistep processes as well as to lesion targeting with other tumor-specific pharmaceuticals.

Antibodies for targeted gene therapy: extracellular gene targeting and intracellular expression

Antibody genes of human origin and human antibodies directed against human proteins have become widely available in recent years. These are valuable reagents for gene therapy applications, in which the use of human proteins and genes allows for increased therapeutic benefit. Engineered human antibodies can be used in gene therapy both as a component of a gene delivery system and as a therapeutic gene. As the targeting moiety of a gene delivery system, the antibody should meet certain criteria that have been previously determined from other clinical applications of antibodies. These include bioavailability, specificity for the target cell, and rapid clearance. In addition, if repeat delivery of therapeutic genes is going to be needed, then gene delivery vectors should be non-immunogenic to allow repeated administration. The use of human antibodies in this application should therefore be superior to approaches which use rodent-derived antibodies. Another application of antibodies in gene therapy is the use of antibodies expressed inside the cell (intrabodies) as therapeutic agents. The power of the immune system to rearrange a limited set of genes to create recognition sites for any known molecule is well documented. The ability to harness this information and use these highly specific binding molecules as medicines to inhibit an unwanted cellular function is a promising advance in the field of molecular medicine, and in particular, in the field of intracellular immunization.