Regulation of intracellular proteolysis in Escherichia coli

Protein degradation sets the fraction of active ribosomes at vanishing growth

Growing cells adopt common basic strategies to achieve optimal resource allocation under limited resource availability. Our current understanding of such “growth laws” neglects degradation, assuming that it occurs slowly compared to the cell cycle duration. Here we argue that this assumption cannot hold at slow growth, leading to important consequences. We propose a simple framework showing that at slow growth protein degradation is balanced by a fraction of “maintenance” ribosomes. Consequently, active ribosomes do not drop to zero at vanishing growth, but as growth rate diminishes, an increasing fraction of active ribosomes performs maintenance. Through a detailed analysis of compiled data, we show that the predictions of this model agree with data from E. coli and S. cerevisiae. Intriguingly, we also find that protein degradation increases at slow growth, which we interpret as a consequence of active waste management and/or recycling. Our results highlight protein turnover as an underrated factor for our understanding of growth laws across kingdoms.

The idea that simple quantitative relationships relate cell physiology to cellular composition dates back to the 1950s, but the recent years saw a leap in our understanding of such “growth laws”, with relevant implications regarding the interdependence between growth, metabolism and biochemical networks. However, recent works on nutrient-limited growth mainly focused on laboratory conditions that are favourable to growth. Thus, our current mathematical understanding of the growth laws neglects protein degradation, under the argument that it occurs slowly compared to the timescale of the cell cycle. Instead, at slow growth the timescales of mass loss from protein degradation and dilution become comparable. In this work, we propose that protein degradation shapes the quantitative relationships between ribosome allocation and growth rate, and determines a fraction of ribosomes that do not contribute to growth and need to remain active to balance degradation.

An optimal growth law for RNA composition and its partial implementation through ribosomal and tRNA gene locations in bacterial genomes

The distribution of cellular resources across bacterial proteins has been quantified through phenomenological growth laws. Here, we describe a complementary bacterial growth law for RNA composition, emerging from optimal cellular resource allocation into ribosomes and ternary complexes. The predicted decline of the tRNA/rRNA ratio with growth rate agrees quantitatively with experimental data. Its regulation appears to be implemented in part through chromosomal localization, as rRNA genes are typically closer to the origin of replication than tRNA genes and thus have increasingly higher gene dosage at faster growth. At the highest growth rates in E. coli, the tRNA/rRNA gene dosage ratio based on chromosomal positions is almost identical to the observed and theoretically optimal tRNA/rRNA expression ratio, indicating that the chromosomal arrangement has evolved to favor maximal transcription of both types of genes at this condition.

Unlike the proteome composition, RNA composition is often assumed to be independent of growth rate in bacteria, despite experimental evidence for a growth rate dependence in many microbes. In this work, we derived a growth-rate dependent optimal tRNA/rRNA concentration ratio by minimizing the combined costs of ribosome and ternary complex at the required protein production rate. The predicted optimal tRNA/rRNA expression ratio, which is a monotonically decreasing function of growth rate, agrees with experimental data for E. coli and other fast-growing microbes. This indicates the existing of an RNA composition growth law. Due to the presence of partially replicated chromosomes, gene dosage is higher for those genes whose DNA is replicated earlier, an effect that becomes stronger at higher growth rates. Because rRNA genes are located closer to origin of replication than tRNA genes in fast-growing species, the tRNA/rRNA gene dosage ratio scales with growth rate in the same direction as the optimal tRNA/rRNA expression ratio. Thus, it appears that the RNA growth law is–at least in part–implemented simply through the genomic positions of tRNA and rRNA genes. This finding indicates that growth rate-dependent optimal resource allocation can influence the genomic organization in bacteria.

Applications of Bacterial Degrons and Degraders - Toward Targeted Protein Degradation in Bacteria

A repertoire of proteolysis-targeting signals known as degrons is a necessary component of protein homeostasis in every living cell. In bacteria, degrons can be used in place of chemical genetics approaches to interrogate and control protein function. Here, we provide a comprehensive review of synthetic applications of degrons in targeted proteolysis in bacteria. We describe recent advances ranging from large screens employing tunable degradation systems and orthogonal degrons, to sophisticated tools and sensors for imaging. Based on the success of proteolysis-targeting chimeras as an emerging paradigm in cancer drug discovery, we discuss perspectives on using bacterial degraders for studying protein function and as novel antimicrobials.

Effect of temperature on in vivo protein synthetic capacity in Escherichia coli

In this report, we examine the effect of temperature on protein synthesis. The rate of protein accumulation is determined by three factors: the number of working ribosomes, the rate at which ribosomes are working, and the rate of protein degradation. Measurements of RNA/protein ratios and the levels of individual ribosomal proteins and rRNA show that the cellular amount of ribosomal machinery in Escherichia coli is constant between 25 and 37 degreesC. Within this range, in a given medium, temperature affects ribosomal function the same as it affects overall growth. Two independent methodologies show that the peptide chain elongation rate increases as a function of temperature identically to growth rate up to 37 degreesC. Unlike the growth rate, however, the elongation rate continues to increase up to 44 degreesC at the same rate as between 25 and 37 degreesC. Our results show that the peptide elongation rate is not rate limiting for growth at high temperature. Taking into consideration the number of ribosomes per unit of cell mass, there is an apparent excess of protein synthetic capacity in these cells, indicating a dramatic increase in protein degradation at high temperature. Temperature shift experiments show that peptide chain elongation rate increases immediately, which supports a mechanism of heat shock response induction in which an increase in unfolded, newly translated protein induces this response. In addition, we find that at low temperature (15 degreesC), cells contain a pool of nontranslating ribosomes which do not contribute to cell growth, supporting the idea that there is a defect in initiation at low temperature.

A large decrease in heat-shock-induced proteolysis after tryptophan starvation leads to increased expression of phage lambda lysozyme cloned in Escherichia coli

The R gene coding for phage lambda lysozyme (lambda L), cloned under the control of the PL promoter on a multicopy vector, is expressed in an Escherichia coli strain auxotrophic for tryptophan. Induction by a thermal shift after tryptophan supplementation in a culture initially brought into stationary phase by tryptophan starvation leads to highly increased expression. A thermally unstable mutant protein, difficult to obtain under standard conditions, can be easily produced by post-stationary-phase expression. It is shown that this is due to a drastic decrease in the heat-shock-induced proteolysis normally observed on thermal induction. These data are discussed in relation to our present knowledge of stringent and heat-shock responses.

Substitution in the poliovirus replicase gene determines actinomycin D sensitivity of viral replication at elevated temperature

A series of ts+ revertants and recombinants derived from a temperature-sensitive plurimutant of poliovirus type 1 showed identical plaquing efficiencies at 37 degrees C and at 39 degrees C and exhibited similar yields and plaque morphology to wild-type virus. However, these viruses were characterized by clear inhibition of viral RNA synthesis at 39 degrees C, as measured by uridine incorporation in the presence of actinomycin D. Similarly, virus yields were decreased by one log in the presence of actinomycin D during infection at 39 degrees C. All the ts+ recombinants formed between temperature-sensitive mutants of poliovirus that were inhibited by actinomycin D carried a glutamine----histidine modification at residue 170 of their viral replicase (polypeptide 3D), due to a G----U substitution at nucleotide 6496. Inhibition of viral growth was increased by pretreatment of cells with actinomycin D for 3 h prior to infection, suggesting that actinomycin D sensitivity could reflect an increased dependence of viral RNA replication on host factor(s).

Combined effect of temperature and nutrients on protein turnover in Bacillus megaterium

Protein turnover was followed in populations of Bacillus megaterium growing in temperature range of 17-48 degrees C in different media. Higher temperature stimulated the protein turnover (expressed as the amount of protein degraded during 3.3 h) in all the media tested up to the optimal growth temperature (40-42 degrees C). Protein turnover in a medium containing amino acids continued to be stimulated by temperature even above this point; no further significant increase of turnover was found in the other media.

Relative stability of membrane proteins in Escherichia coli

The relative stability of membrane proteins in Escherichia coli was investigated to determine whether these proteins are degraded at heterogeneous rates and, if so, whether the degradative rates are correlated with the sizes or charges of the proteins. Cells growing in a glucose-limited chemostat with a generation time of 15 h were labeled with [(14)C]leucine. After allowing 24 h for turnover of (14)C-labeled proteins, the cells were labeled for 15 min with [(3)H]leucine. By this protocol, the rapidly degraded proteins have a high ratio of (3)H to (14)C, whereas the stable proteins have a lower ratio. The total cell envelope fraction was collected by differential centrifugation, and the proteins were separated by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The relative ratio for each protein was determined by dividing its (3)H/(14)C ratio by the (3)H/(14)C ratio of the total membrane fraction. Although most of the 125 membrane proteins had relative ratios close to the average for the total membrane fraction, 19 varied significantly from this value. These differences were also observed when the order of addition of [(14)C]leucine and [(3)H]leucine was reversed. In control cultures labeled simultaneously with both isotopes, the relative ratios of these 19 proteins were similar to that of the total membrane fraction. Thirteen of these proteins had low relative ratios, which suggested that they were more stable than the average protein. An experiment in which the normal labeling procedure was followed by a 60-min chase period in the presence of excess unlabeled leucine suggested that the low relative ratios of 3 of these 13 proteins may be due to a slow post-translational modification step. Six membrane proteins had high relative ratios, which indicated that they were degraded rapidly. In contrast to the relationships found for soluble proteins in mammalian cells, there were no strong correlations between the degradative rates and either the isoelectric points or the molecular weights of membrane proteins in E. coli.

Degradation of maize protein in rumen contents. Influence of ammonia concentration

1. The influence of ammonia concentration on the distribution of nitrogen derived from opaque-2 maize uniformly-labelled with 15N has been investigated during short-term in vitro incubation of bovine rumen contents. 2. Less 15N derived from maize was found in the non-protein-N (NPN) fraction during incubation without added NH3 than with added NH3, due entirely to differences in the amount of N derived from maize in the NH3 fraction. 3. From calculations based on the transfer of N derived from maize to the NPN pool and to a bacterial fraction, it was concluded that degradation of maize protein was not influenced by NH3 concentration within the examined limits. 4. The decrease in relative amount of N derived from maize in the NH3 fraction at low concentrations of NH3, together with evidence for an increased fractional turnover rate of NH3-N suggests that a deficient supply of NH3 is compensated for by increased catabolism of nitrogenous compounds derived from the rumen micro-organisms.

Histidine starvation and adenosine 5'-triphosphate depletion in chemotaxis of Salmonella typhimurium

Starvation for histidine prevented tumbling in Salmonella typhimurium hisF auxotrophs, including constantly tumbling strains with an additional mutation in cheB or cheZ. However, histidine-starved cheZs hisF strains were not defective in flagellar function or the tumbling mechanism since freshly starved auxotrophs tumbled in response to a variety of repellents. Tumbling in histidine-starved S. typhimurium could be restored in 13 s by addition of adenine or in 4 min by addition of histidine. Chloramphenicol did not prevent restoration of tumbling by these substances. Assays of adenosine 5'-triphosphate were performed based upon previous demonstration of adenine depletion in hisF auxotrophs starved for histidine. The adenosine 5'-triphosphate concentration dropped rapidly during the course of starvation, falling to less than 5% of the initial level as the cells ceased tumbling entirely. The change to smooth motility was prevented by 2-thiazolealanine, which inhibits phosphoribosyltransferase, thereby preventing adenine depletion during histidine starvation. These results suggest that an adenosine 5'-triphosphate deficiency was responsible for the change in tumbling frequency.

Growth conditions and rifampin susceptibility

The susceptibility of Escherichia coli to rifampin was measured during unlimited growth in rich and poor media and during chemostat growth limited by the carbon source. During batch growth at low turbidities, the susceptibility of the bacteria increased as the growth rate decreased, consistent with the longer time available for drug penetration in the poorer media. During chemostat culture, the bacteria remained highly susceptible or became genetically resistant, dependent on the manner in which the bacteria were exposed to the antibiotic. If the concentration of rifampin was abruptly raised, susceptible cells were replaced by genetically resistant cells. However, if the concentration of antibiotic was raised slowly, the genetically susceptible cells continued to grow. This difference in response of chemostat cultures according to mode of drug administration was attributed to an inducible detoxification of the drug by the bacteria, because the susceptible genotype is maintained only when the concentration of rifampin is increased gradually and when a high population of cells is maintained. Direct evidence for the inactivation of the rifampin from the bioassay of culture supernatants is presented.

Comparative physiological effects of incorporated amino acid analogs in Escherichia coli

The relative toxicities of several incorporated analogs of phenylalanine, methionine, arginine, and proline were assessed by a variety of criteria in a derivative of Escherichia coli 15 requiring the antagonized amino acids. Toxicity of the analog-substituted cell protein was most consistently indicated by its insolubility at graded temperatures, its increased breakdown, the relative suppression of further cell growth, and lethality. The relative toxicity of poorly utilized analogs could be judged clearly only by the first two criteria. Toxicity generally increased as follows: selenomethionine < 2,5-dihydrophenylalanine and m-fluorophenylalanine < o-fluorophenylalanine and norleucine < ethionine < p-fluorophenylalanine < azetidine-2-carboxylate < canavanine. The overall perturbation of cell protein structure indicated by the toxicity of the methionine and phenylalanine analogs correlated with their alteration of charge and bulk and was greatly modified by minor positional modifications of fluorine. Among the more specific functional impairments, the activity and heat stability of beta-galactosidase were lowered in parallel by substitutions of phenylalanine and methionine analogs, but not in the usual order of toxicity. Flagella were transiently motile with p-fluorophenylalanine, moderately motile with m-fluorophenylalanine, and fully motile with all methionine analogs. Usually the analog incorporations were no more than bacteriostatic in E. coli strains, canavanine killing only the E. coli 15 substrain extensively in minimal media. Selenomethionine supported indefinite growth of procaryotes such as Bacillus subtilis and certain E. coli strains, but only upon supplementation, at least initially, with many nonessential metabolites.

Inactivation and partial degradation of phosphoribosylanthranilate isomerase-indoleglycerol phosphate synthetase in nongrowing cultures of Escherichia coli

The stability of tryptophan biosynthetic enzyme activities was examined in cultures of repressor-negative (trpR) strains of Escherichia coli K-12 incubated under conditions of nutrient starvation of chloramphenicol inhibition. The results show that four of the five activities examined are stable under most nongrowing conditions, whereas one activity, indoleglycerol phosphate (InGP) synthetase, carried by the trpC protein, is unstable under most conditions tested. Phosphoribosylanthranilate (PRA) isomerase activity, which is also carried by the trpC protein, is unstable during starvation for ammonium, cysteine, or sulfate but is stable under other nongrowing conditions where InGP synthetase is not. InGP synthetase activity but not PRA isomerase activity is also diminished about twofold in cultures using glycerol as a carbon-energy source. These results indicate that one or both activities of the trpC protein is specifically inactivated under several culture conditions. Experiments with antibodies to the trpC protein show that sulfate-starved and ammonium-starved cultures contain 20 to 40% less immunologically reactive trpC protein than unstarved cultures. This indicates that the trpC protein is probably partially degraded under these conditions. During recovery from sulfate starvation or ammonium starvation, cultures slowly regain normal levels of InGP synthetase and PRA isomerase activities, suggesting that inactivation may be reversible.

Regulation of two phosphatases and a cyclic phosphodiesterase of Salmonella typhimurium

The regulation of three Salmonella typhimurium phosphatases in reponse to different nutritional limitations has been studied. Two enzymes, an acid hexose phosphatase (EC 3.1.3.2) and a cyclic phosphodiesterase (EC 3.1.4.d), appear to be regulated by the cyclic adenosine 3' ,5'-monophosphate (AMP) catabolite repression system. Levels of these enzymes increased in cells grown on poor carbon sources but not in cells grown on poor nitrogen or phosphorus sources. Mutants lacking adenyl cyclase did not produce elevated levels of these enzymes in response to carbon limitation unless cyclic AMP was supplied. Mutants lacking the cyclic AMP receptor protein did not produce elevated levels of these enzymes in response to carbon limitation regardless of the presence of cyclic AMP. Since no specific induction of either enzyme could be demonstrated, these enzymes appear to be controlled solely by the cyclic AMP system. Nonspecific acid phsphatase activity (EC 3.1.3.2) increased in response to carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, or sulfur limitation. The extent of the increase depended on growth rate, with slower growth rates favoring greater increases, and on the type of limitation. Limitation for either carbon or phosphorus resulted in maximum increases, whereas severe limitation of Mg2+ caused only a slight increase. The increase in nonspecific acid phosphatase during carbon limitation was apparently not mediated by the catabolite repression system since mutants lacking adenyl cyclase or the cyclic AMP receptor protein still produced elevated levels of this enzyme during carbon starvation. Nor did the increase during phosphorus limitation appear to be mediated by the alkaline phosphatase regulatory system. A strain of Salmonella bearing a chromosomal mutation, which caused constitutive production of alkaline phosphatase (introduced by an episome from Escherichia coli), did not have constitutive levels of nonspecific acid phosphatase.

Regulation of branched-chain amino acid transport in Escherichia coli

The repression and derepression of leucine, isoleucine, and valine transport in Escherichia coli K-12 was examined by using strains auxotrophic for leucine, isoleucine, valine, and methionine. In experiments designed to limit each of these amino acids separately, we demonstrate that leucine limitation alone derepressed the leucine-binding protein, the high-affinity branched-chain amino acid transport system (LIV-I), and the membrane-bound, low-affinity system (LIV-II). This regulation did not seem to involve inactivation of transport components, but represented an increase in the differential rate of synthesis of transport components relative to total cellular proteins. The apparent regulation of transport by isoleucine, valine, and methionine reported elsewhere was shown to require an intact leucine, biosynthetic operon and to result from changes in the level of leucine biosynthetic enzymes. A functional leucyl-transfer ribonucleic acid synthetase was also required for repression of transport. Transport regulation was shown to be essentially independent of ilvA or its gene product, threonine deaminase. The central role of leucine or its derivatives in cellular metabolism in general is discussed.

Role of methionine in bacterial chemotaxis: requirement for tumbling and involvement in information processing

Chemotactic responses are mediated by modulation of the frequency of tumbling. Studies with methionine auxotrophs of wild-type Escherichia coli and four mutants which tumble continuously show that methionine or one of its metabolites is involved in the tumbling process. Following removal of methionine, the wild type and two mutants, after various periods of time, became unable to tumble. The presence of constant levels of chemical attractants considerably shortened these periods in the three strains and eliminated tumbling in another mutant. This effect of attractants considerably shortened these periods in the three strains and eliminated tumbling in another mutant. This effect of attractants implies that methionine or some derivative of methionine is also involved in transducing chemical stimuli to bacterial responses.

Stimulation of derepressed enzyme synthesis in bacteria by growth on sublethal concentrations of chloramphenicol

Culturing of Salmonella typhimurium or Escherichia coli cells in the presence of low concentrations (</=1 mug/ml) of chloramphenicol (CAP) permitted exponential growth, but at doubling times up to twice those of controls. When such cultures were subsequently starved for uracil or arginine, derepression of aspartate transcarbamylase (ATCase) or ornithine transcarbamylase, respectively, was enhanced three- to 10-fold as compared to cultures not exposed to CAP. Enhancement of beta-galactosidase synthesis by prior exposure to CAP was also observed in uracil-starved E. coli cultures. Stimulation of enzyme synthesis appeared to be a specific effect of CAP; low levels of erythromycin, puromycin, sparsomycin, tetracycline, and rifampin did not show such effects. Derepression of ATCase synthesis in exponentially growing cells in the presence of CAP did not result in stimulation of enzyme synthesis by CAP. A prior history of growth of a culture in the presence of CAP was shown to be necessary for enhancement of enzyme synthesis by CAP; furthermore, continued presence of CAP in the medium during starvation was not necessary for enhanced enzyme synthesis and inhibited it in some instances. Enhanced enzyme synthesis in starving, CAP-treated cultures could be blocked by rifampin, which suggested that CAP treatment allows prolonged or more extensive messenger ribonucleic acid synthesis.

Structural aberrations in T-even bacteriophage. V. Effects of canavanine on the maturation and utilization of specific gene products

Previous results have shown that when a T-even bacteriophage-infected cell was exposed to l-canavanine followed by an exposure to l-arginine, a monster phage particle, termed a lollipop, was formed. l-Canavanine was necessary for the induction event but l-arginine was required for the maturation of the particle. We now describe the effects of canavanine on the maturation of certain T4 proteins and their role in the induction of lollipops. The cleavage reactions of the head proteins P22, P23, P24, and IPIII are prevented by l-canavanine as shown by the accumulation of the precursor proteins and the failure of the cleaved products to appear. l-Canavanine also prevents the appearance of P12 (tailplate protein) and P20 (head protein) indicating that these proteins may undergo a proteolytic cleavage during normal assembly. The formation of P10 (tailplate protein) and P18 (tail sheath protein) is also affected by l-canavanine. The data suggest that P23 in conjunction with P20 plays a major role in the determination of the length of the phage head.

Stringent control of intracellular proteolysis in Escherichia coli

Regulation of intracellular proteolysis has been compared during amino acid deficiencies in seven double auxotrophs of Escherichia coli 9723f with a common phenylalanine requirement. Individual deficiencies were either more effective than, less effective, or equal to phenylalanine deficiency in stimulating intracellular proteolysis. For each amino acid, the same relationship prevailed in inhibiting uracil incorporation into nucleic acids, a reaction series regulated by the rel gene for stringent control. The three amino acids least abundant in the cellular protein were the least effective regulators. These findings are interpreted as supportive evidence for stringent control of intracellular proteolysis by the rel gene.