Export of maltose-binding protein species with altered charge distribution surrounding the signal peptide hydrophobic core in Escherichia coli cells harboring prl suppressor mutations

Functional implementation of the posttranslational SecB-SecA protein-targeting pathway in Bacillus subtilis

Bacillus subtilis and its close relatives are widely used in industry for the Sec-dependent secretory production of proteins. Like other Gram-positive bacteria, B. subtilis does not possess SecB, a dedicated targeting chaperone that posttranslationally delivers exported proteins to the SecA component of the translocase. In the present study, we have implemented a functional SecB-dependent protein-targeting pathway into B. subtilis by coexpressing SecB from Escherichia coli together with a SecA hybrid protein in which the carboxyl-terminal 32 amino acids of the B. subtilis SecA were replaced by the corresponding part of SecA from E. coli. In vitro pulldown experiments showed that, in contrast to B. subtilis SecA, the hybrid SecA protein gained the ability to efficiently bind to E. coli SecB, suggesting that the structural details of the extreme C-terminal region of SecA constitute a crucial SecB binding specificity determinant. Using a poorly exported mutant maltose binding protein (MalE11) and alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) as model proteins, we could demonstrate that the secretion of both proteins by B. subtilis was significantly enhanced in the presence of the artificial protein targeting pathway. Mutations in SecB that do not influence its chaperone activity but prevent its interaction with SecA abolished the secretion stimulation of both proteins, demonstrating that the implemented pathway in fact critically depends on the SecB targeting function. From a biotechnological view, our results open up a new strategy for the improvement of Gram-positive bacterial host systems for the secretory production of heterologous proteins.

Identification of a post-targeting step required for efficient cotranslational translocation of proteins across the Escherichia coli inner membrane

Recent studies have shown that cytoplasmic proteins are exported efficiently in Escherichia coli only if they are attached to signal peptides that are recognized by the signal recognition particle and are thereby targeted to the SecYEG complex cotranslationally. The evidence suggests that the entry of these proteins into the secretory pathway at an early stage of translation is necessary to prevent them from folding into a translocation-incompetent conformation. We found, however, that several glycolytic enzymes attached to signal peptides that are recognized by the signal recognition particle were exported inefficiently. Based on previous studies of post-translational export, we hypothesized that the export block was due to the presence of basic residues at the extreme N terminus of each enzyme. Consistent with our hypothesis, we found that the introduction of negatively charged residues into this segment increased the efficiency of export. Export efficiency was sensitive to the number, position, and sequence context of charged residues. The importance of charge for efficient export was underscored by an in silico analysis that revealed a conserved negative charge bias at the N terminus of the mature region of bacterial presecretory proteins. Our results demonstrate that cotranslational targeting of a protein to the E. coli SecYEG complex does not ensure its export but that export also depends on a subsequent event (most likely the initiation of translocation) that involves sequences both within and just beyond the signal peptide.

Folding and trimerization of signal sequence-less mature TolC in the cytoplasm of Escherichia coli

TolC is a multifunctional outer-membrane protein (OMP) of Escherichia coli that folds into a unique α/β-barrel structure. Previous studies have shown that unlike the biogenesis of β-barrel OMPs, such as porins, TolC assembles independently from known periplasmic folding factors. Yet, the assembly of TolC, like that of β-barrel OMPs, is dependent on BamA and BamD, two essential components of the β-barrel OMP assembly machinery. We have investigated the folding properties and cellular trafficking of a TolC derivative that lacks the entire signal sequence (TolCΔ2–22). A significant amount of TolCΔ2–22 was found to be soluble in the cytoplasm, and a fraction of it folded and trimerized into a conformation similar to that of the normal outer membrane-localized TolC protein. Some TolCΔ2–22 was found to associate with membranes, but failed to assume a wild-type-like folded conformation. The null phenotype of TolCΔ2–22 was exploited to isolate suppressor mutations, the majority of which mapped in secY. In the secY suppressor background, TolCΔ2–22 resumed normal function and folded like wild-type TolC. Proper membrane insertion could not be achieved upon in vitro incubation of cytoplasmically folded TolCΔ2–22 with purified outer membrane vesicles, showing that even though TolC is intrinsically capable of folding and trimerization, for successful integration into the outer membrane these events need to be tightly coupled to the insertion process, which is mediated by the Bam machinery. Genetic and biochemical data attribute the unique folding and assembly pathways of TolC to its large soluble α-helical domain.

Effect of charge distribution on the translocation of an inhomogeneously charged polymer through a nanopore

We investigate the voltage-driven translocation of an inhomogeneously charged polymer through a nanopore by utilizing discrete and continuous stochastic models. As a simplified illustration of the effect of charge distribution on translocation, we consider the translocation of a polymer with a single charged site in the presence and absence of interactions between the charge and the pore. We find that the position of the charge that minimizes the translocation time in the absence of pore-polymer interactions is determined by the entropic cost of translocation, with the optimum charge position being at the midpoint of the chain for a rodlike polymer and close to the leading chain end for an ideal chain. The presence of attractive and repulsive pore-charge interactions yields a shift in the optimum charge position toward the trailing end and the leading end of the chain, respectively. Moreover, our results show that strong attractive or repulsive interactions between the charge and the pore lengthen the translocation time relative to translocation through an inert pore. We generalize our results to accommodate the presence of multiple charged sites on the polymer. Our results provide insight into the effect of charge inhomogeneity on protein translocation through biological membranes.

Interactions that drive Sec-dependent bacterial protein transport

Understanding the transport of hydrophilic proteins across biological membranes continues to be an important undertaking. The general secretory (Sec) pathway in Escherichia coli transports the majority of E. coli proteins from their point of synthesis in the cytoplasm to their sites of final localization, associating sequentially with a number of protein components of the transport machinery. The targeting signals for these substrates must be discriminated from those of proteins transported via other pathways. While targeting signals for each route have common overall characteristics, individual signal peptides vary greatly in their amino acid sequences. How do these diverse signals interact specifically with the proteins that comprise the appropriate transport machinery and, at the same time, avoid targeting to an alternate route? The recent publication of the crystal structures of components of the Sec transport machinery now allows a more thorough consideration of the interactions of signal sequences with these components.

Modeling the effects of prl mutations on the Escherichia coli SecY complex

The apparatus responsible for translocation of proteins across bacterial membranes is the conserved SecY complex, consisting of SecY, SecE, and SecG. Prior genetic analysis provided insight into the mechanisms of protein export, as well as the interactions between the component proteins. In particular, the prl suppressor alleles of secE and secY, which allow export of secretory proteins with defective signal sequences, have proven particularly useful. Here, we report the isolation of novel mutations in secE and secY, as well as the phenotypic effects of combinations of prl mutations. These new alleles, as well as previously characterized prl mutations, were analyzed in light of the recently published crystal structure of the archaeal SecY complex. Our results support and expand a model of Prl suppressor activity that proposes that all of the prlA and prlG alleles either destabilize the closed state of the channel or stabilize the open form. These mutants thus allow channel opening to occur without the triggering event of signal sequence binding that is required in a wild-type complex.

The protein-conducting channel SecYEG

In bacteria, the translocase mediates the translocation of proteins into or across the cytosolic membrane. It consists of a membrane embedded protein-conducting channel and a peripherally associated motor domain, the ATPase SecA. The channel is formed by SecYEG, a multimeric protein complex that assembles into oligomeric forms. The structure and subunit composition of this protein-conducting channel is evolutionary conserved and a similar system is found in the endoplasmic reticulum of eukaryotes and the cytoplasmic membrane of archaea. The ribosome and other membrane proteins can associate with the protein-conducting channel complex and affect its activity or functionality.

Both transmembrane domains of SecG contribute to signal sequence recognition by the Escherichia coli protein export machinery

A chimeric protein containing the uncleaved signal sequence of plasminogen activators inhibitor-2 (PAI2) fused to alkaline phosphatase (AP) interferes with Escherichia coli protein export and arrests growth. Suppressors of this toxicity include secG mutations that define the Thr-41-Leu-42-Phe-43 (TLF) domain of SecG. These mutations slow down the export of PAI2-AP. Another construct encoding a truncated PAI2 signal sequence (hB-AP) is also toxic. Most suppressors exert their effect on both chimeric proteins. We describe here five secG suppressors that only suppress the toxicity of hB-AP and selectively slow down its export. These mutations do not alter the TLF domain: three encode truncated SecG, whereas two introduce Arg residues in the transmembrane domains of SecG. The shortest truncated protein only contains 13 residues of SecG, suggesting that the mutation is equivalent to a null allele. Indeed, a secG disruption selectively suppresses the toxicity of hB-AP. However, the missense mutations are not null alleles. They allow SecG binding to SecYE, although with reduced affinity. Furthermore, these mutated SecG are functional, as they facilitate the export of endogenous proteins. Thus, SecG participates in signal sequence recognition, and both transmembrane domains of SecG contribute to ensure normal signal sequence recognition by the translocase.

The net charge of the first 18 residues of the mature sequence affects protein translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane of gram-negative bacteria

This statistical study shows that in proteins of gram-negative bacteria exported by the Sec-dependent pathway, the first 14 to 18 residues of the mature sequences have the highest deviation between the observed and expected net charge distributions. Moreover, almost all sequences have either neutral or negative net charge in this region. This rule is restricted to gram-negative bacteria, since neither eukaryotic nor gram-positive bacterial exported proteins have this charge bias. Subsequent experiments performed with a series of Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase mutants confirmed that this charge bias is associated with protein translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane. Two consecutive basic residues inhibit translocation effectively when placed within the first 14 residues of the mature protein but not when placed in positions 19 and 20. The sensitivity to arginine partially reappeared again 30 residues away from the signal sequence. These data provide new insight into the mechanism of protein export in gram-negative bacteria and lead to practical recommendations for successful secretion of hybrid proteins.

Protein targeting to the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane

Proteins that perform their activity within the cytoplasmic membrane or outside this cell boundary must be targeted to the translocation site prior to their insertion and/or translocation. In bacteria, several targeting routes are known; the SecB- and the signal recognition particle-dependent pathways are the best characterized. Recently, evidence for the existence of a third major route, the twin-Arg pathway, was gathered. Proteins that use either one of these three different pathways possess special features that enable their specific interaction with the components of the targeting routes. Such targeting information is often contained in an N-terminal extension, the signal sequence, but can also be found within the mature domain of the targeted protein. Once the nascent chain starts to emerge from the ribosome, competition for the protein between different targeting factors begins. After recognition and binding, the targeting factor delivers the protein to the translocation sites at the cytoplasmic membrane. Only by means of a specific interaction between the targeting component and its receptor is the cargo released for further processing and translocation. This mechanism ensures the high-fidelity targeting of premembrane and membrane proteins to the translocation site.

The protein translocation apparatus contributes to determining the topology of an integral membrane protein in Escherichia coli

The assembly of integral membrane proteins is determined by features of these proteins and the protein translocation apparatus. We used alkaline phosphatase fusions to the membrane protein MalF to investigate the role of the protein translocation machinery in the arrangement of proteins in the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli. In particular, we studied the effects of prlA mutations on membrane protein topology. These mutations lie in the secY gene, which encodes a core component of the protein translocation apparatus. We find that the topology of some of the fusion proteins is changed and, in one case, is completely inverted in prlA mutants. We discuss the mechanism of prlA-mediated export and the role of the protein translocation apparatus in contributing to membrane protein topology.

Amino-terminal charge affects the periplasmic accumulation of recombinant heregulin/EGF hybrids exported using the Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase signal sequence

An Escherichia coli expression system that exploits the bacterial alkaline phosphatase (PhoA) signal sequence to translocate recombinant human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) to the periplasm was used to evaluate how changes in the composition and sequence of amino acids near the PhoA-hEGF junction influence the periplasmic accumulation of recombinant protein. A series of chimeric structural genes was generated by in vitro replacement of hEGF sequence with analogous segments from the EGF-like domain of human heregulin (HRG), significantly altering the electrostatic character of the amino-terminal region of the mature protein. Quantitation of HRG/EGF protein in E. coli periplasmic extracts, by RP-HPLC, showed a fourfold decrease after one of two acidic residues located in the amino-terminal region of the mature hEGF, near the PhoA junction, was replaced. An additional threefold decrease was observed when the second acidic residue was replaced with a positively charged lysine. Further extension of the amino-terminal HRG sequence, beyond the first six residues, resulted in net neutralization of a more distant EGF acidic residue with no additional effect on protein yield. The importance of having a negatively charged group in the amino-terminal region of the mature protein was confirmed when insertion of an aspartic acid near the amino-terminus of two poorly expressed hybrid protein sequences resulted in a five- to eightfold increase in their recovery from the periplasm. This study demonstrates the importance of having negatively charged residues near the fusion junction of recombinant proteins expressed in E. coli using the PhoA signal sequence for protein export.

Folding of the presequence of yeast pAPI into an amphipathic helix determines transport of the protein from the cytosol to the vacuole

To investigate the role of the 17 residues long presequence (p17) in the transport of the precursor of yeast API (pAPI) from the cytosol to the vacuole we have studied the effects of point mutations upon its conformation and on the process of transport. 1H NMR analysis of p17 indicates that in aqueous solution 26% of the molecules have the 4-12 segment folded into an helix. The hydrophobic environment provided by SDS micelles promotes the folding of 54% of the p17 molecules into a 5-16 amphipathic alpha-helix. Both Schiffer-Edmunson helical wheel analysis of segment 4-12 and residue hydrophobic moments calculated considering all possible side-chain orientations between 80 and 120 degrees, indicate the amphipathic character of the helixes assembled in water and detergent. Charge interactions between the dipole pairs N-Glu2Glu3 and C-Lys12Lys13 are essential for helix stability and condition pAPI transport. Substitution of either Pro2Pro3 or Lys2Lys3 for Glu2Glu3, results in moderate destabilization of the helix, decreases protein targeting to the vacuolar membrane and partly inhibits translocation of the protein to the vacuolar lumen. Replacement of either Pro12Pro13 or Glu12Glu13 for Lys12Lys13, causes a major disruption of the helix, decreases protein targeting and blocks completely the translocation of the protein to the vacuolar lumen. Replacement of Gly7 for Ile7, a substitution which is known to destabilize alpha-helixes in peptides and proteins as a result of the peptide bond to the solvent at Gly residues, produces similar effects as the substitutions for the K12K13 pair. The effects of Gly7 on helix stability and protein transport are partly reversed by introduction of Asp residues at positions 2 and 3 and Ala at position 4. Replacements such as Arg2 for Glu2, or Arg6 for Glu6, which change the net and local charges of the presequence without altering its conformation, have no effect on the protein transport. These results provide direct evidence of the involvement of the presequence in the transport of pAPI from the cytosol to the vacuole. They show that folding of the pAPI presequence is conditioned by the physical/chemical properties of the environment and is critical for targeting the protein to the vacuolar membrane and for its translocation to the vacuolar lumen.

Short hydrophobic segments in the mature domain of ProOmpA determine its stepwise movement during translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli

Based on the finding that a series of engineered proOmpAs containing disulfide-bridged loops of different sizes at different positions exhibits a discontinuous mode of polypeptide transit across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli, we suggested previously that the translocation of preproteins takes place at every 30 amino acid residues (Uchida, K., Mori, H., and Mizushima, S. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 30862-30868). In the present study, we investigated the molecular mechanism underlying this stepwise translocation. Deletion or relocation of hydrophobic segments of the mature domain of proOmpA (H1, residues 233-237; H2, residues 261-265) significantly altered the pattern of the stepwise translocation. The stepwise mode of polypeptide insertion was also observed with reconstituted proteoliposomes comprising purified SecA, SecY, and SecE. Cross-linking experiments involving a photoactivable cross-linker revealed that SecY and SecA are the components which interact with the hydrophobic segment of proOmpA. The present results indicate that the hydrophobic segments of the mature domains of preproteins interact with membrane embedded translocase during polypeptide transit across the membrane, which causes a discontinuous mode of polypeptide movement.

prl mutations in the Escherichia coli secG gene

SecG, an integral membrane component of the Escherichia coli preprotein translocase, contributes to the efficiency of the export process by undergoing cycles of topology inversion in the membrane, coupled with the insertion-deinsertion cycles of SecA. We have previously identified sec alleles of secG that cause a generalized secretion defect. In this study, by screening mutagenized secG libraries for suppressors of a malE signal sequence mutation, we isolated prl alleles of secG. By analogy with secY/prlA, secA/prlD, and secE/prlG, secG could therefore be called secG/prlH. The prlH mutations affect 13 codons distributed along the secG sequence, and none map to the codons affected by sec mutations. prlH suppressors suppress a variety of signal sequence mutations and they allow export of alkaline phosphatase lacking its entire signal sequence. Although secG was not identified in previous selections for prl mutants, several prlH alleles are as strong as the strongest known prlG alleles of secE. Some prlH alleles can also promote the export of alkaline phosphatase fused to predicted cytoplasmic domains of UhpT, an integral membrane protein. These results support the notion that SecG contributes to signal sequence recognition, and suggest that it may also contribute to the topology of integral membrane proteins.

Escherichia coli SecB stimulates export without maintaining export competence of ribose-binding protein signal sequence mutants

Ribose-binding protein (RBP) is exported to the periplasm of Escherichia coli via the general export pathway. An rbsB-lacZ gene fusion was constructed and used to select mutants defective in RBP export. The spontaneous Lac+ mutants isolated in this selection contained either single-amino-acid substitutions or a deletion of the RBP signal sequence. Intact rbsB genes containing eight different point mutations in the signal sequence were reconstructed, and the effects of the mutations on RBP export were examined. Most of the mutations caused severe defects in RBP export. In addition, different suppressor mutations in SecY/PrlA protein were analyzed for their effects on the export of RBP signal sequence mutants in the presence or absence of SecB. Several RBP signal sequence mutants were efficiently suppressed, but others were not suppressed. Export of an RBP signal sequence mutant in prlA mutant strains was partially dependent on SecB, which is in contrast to the SecB independence of wild-type RBP export. However, the kinetics of export of an RBP signal sequence mutant point to a rapid loss of pre-RBP export competence, which occurs in strains containing or lacking SecB. These results suggest that SecB does not stabilize the export-competent conformation of RBP and may affect translocation by stabilizing the binding of pre-RBP at the translocation site.

Different PrlA proteins increase the efficiency of periplasmic production of human interleukin-6 in Escherichia coli

The export efficiency of a fusion of the Escherichia coli preOmpA signal peptide to human interleukin-6 can be significantly raised by coexpressing three different prlA alleles of sec Y along with wild type secE. The effect seems prlA-specific, as prlG1 (a prl allele of secE) does not affect the export of preOmpA-hIL-6. Coexpression of secD and secF also stimulates the export of the fusion protein.

Influence of specific signal peptide mutations on the expression and secretion of the alpha-amylase inhibitor tendamistat in Streptomyces lividans

The Streptomyces alpha-amylase inhibitor tendamistat is secreted by a signal peptide with an amino-terminal charge of +3. To elucidate the influence of the charged residues on protein secretion in Streptomyces, the amino-terminal charge was varied from +6 to neutral net charge. The effects of charge variation were analyzed in combination with three Streptomyces promoters and two transcriptional terminators. Introduction of additional positive charges significantly decreased the amount of secreted tendamistat. On the contrary, a charge reduction to +2 resulted in the doubling of inhibitor production. After exclusion of transcriptional effects, the observed alterations of inhibitor secretion by the mutants with a charge of +6 to +2 were attributed to a modulation of precursor synthesis. Furthermore, a tight coupling of synthesis and export was stated. Charge reduction to +1 or neutral charge generally reduced the yield of secreted tendamistat, yet remarkable differences were found for mutants with identical net charge. Elimination of the positive charge at a defined position resulted in the release of tendamistat precursor protein, which suggested a specific uncoupling of synthesis and translocation.

Pro-OmpA derivatives with a His6 tag in their N-terminal "translocation initiation domains" are arrested by Ni2+ at an early post-targeting stage of translocation

We examined in vitro translocation of pro-OmpA derivatives with a His6 tag at various positions in their mature proteins and with a c-Myc tag at their C termini across inverted membrane vesicles of Escherichia coli. Those with a His6 tag in the N-terminal region of the mature domain, which corresponds to the "translocation initiation domain" proposed previously (Andersson, H., and von Heijne, G. (1991) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 88, 9751-9754), could not be translocated in the presence of 100 micron Ni2+, while OmpA derivatives with a His6 tag in the middle of or at the C terminus did not show such Ni2+ sensitivity. The inhibitory action of Ni2+ on pro-3His-OmpA' (with a His6 tag after the third amino acid of the mature OmpA-c-Myc region) translocation was exerted only during early events, after which it became ineffective. The inhibition point of Ni2+ was suggested to lie between membrane targeting and exposure of the signal cleavage site to the periplasm since the unprocessed and membrane-bound form of pro-3His-OmpA' was accumulated by the addition of Ni2+. The Ni(2+)-"trapped" precursor was released from its translocation block by 30 mM histidine, which should compete with the His6 tag on the precursor protein for formation of a Ni2+ chelating complex. We propose that Ni2+ confers a reversible positive charge effect on the His6-tagged initiation domain of the pro-OmpA derivatives and inhibits an early event(s) of protein translocation, such as presentation of the precursor to the membranous part of the translocase. This system will be useful in dissecting early events of the protein translocation pathway.

Mutational analysis of the Streptomyces scabies esterase signal peptide

Ten site-directed mutations affecting the predicted 39-amino-acid signal peptide of the Streptomyces scabies esterase were used to examine start-codon usage and esterase secretion in S. lividans. The first of two in-frame AUG codons was preferred for translation initiation. Removal of 2 of the 4 positively charged amino acids at the amino terminus of the signal peptide reduced esterase expression more than 100-fold; however, deletion of all 4 charged residues reduced expression by only 2- to 5-fold. Deletion of 4 or 8 amino acids from the hydrophobic core of the signal peptide reduced esterase production more than 200-fold, and a signal peptide processing site deletion completely disrupted esterase expression. For all constructs in which a mutation in the signal sequence decreased esterase production, esterase mRNA levels were also reduced, suggesting that a defect in secretion or processing affected esterase transcript abundance.

Differential secretion of isoforms of Serratia marcescens extracellular nuclease

Extracellular secretion of the Serratia marcescens nuclease occurs in a two-step process: (i) rapidly to the periplasm via a signal sequence-dependent pathway and then (ii) slowly to the extracellular growth medium without cell lysis. There are two major isoforms of the nuclease in the culture supernatant of S. marcescens. We have isolated, purified, and determined the sequences of both isoforms. The first isoform, the mature nuclease (Sm2), is the result of signal sequence processing. The second isoform (Sm1) has three additional amino acids missing from the N terminus of the mature nuclease. Sm1 starts to appear extracellularly only during prolonged growth of a culture (16 to 48 h), probably because of cell lysis. However, pulse-chase experiments show that it is made early with Sm2 but is not secreted efficiently.

Protein transport via amino-terminal targeting sequences: common themes in diverse systems

Many proteins that are synthesized in the cytoplasm of cells are ultimately found in non-cytoplasmic locations. The correct targeting and transport of proteins must occur across bacterial cell membranes, the endoplasmic reticulum membrane, and those of mitochondria and chloroplasts. One unifying feature among transported proteins in these systems is the requirement for an amino-terminal targeting signal. Although the primary sequence of targeting signals varies substantially, many patterns involving overall properties are shared. A recent surge in the identification of components of the transport apparatus from many different systems has revealed that these are also closely related. In this review we describe some of the key components of different transport systems and highlight these common features.

Effect of alteration of charged residues at the N termini of signal peptides on protein export in Bacillus subtilis

The role of positively charged residues at the N termini of signal peptides in protein export has been studied in Bacillus subtilis. Bacillus signal peptides (alkaline protease [Apr] and neutral protease [Npr] from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens) were altered and fused to mature levansucrase (Lvs). The effects of the various alterations on the export of Lvs in B. subtilis were determined. The replacement of positively charged residues with neutral residues in both Apr and Npr signal peptides resulted in a slight defect in the export of Lvs from B. subtilis. Introduction of a negatively charged residue (aspartic acid) at the N terminus of Npr signal peptide blocked the export of Lvs. However, Apr signal peptide with a net charge of -3 (three aspartic acid residues) was still functional.

Signal peptides: exquisitely designed transport promoters

Prokaryotic proteins destined for transport out of the cytoplasm typically contain an N-terminal extension sequence, called the signal peptide, which is required for export. It is evident that many secretory proteins utilize a common export system, yet the signal sequences themselves display very little primary sequence homology. In attempting to understand how different signal peptides are able to promote protein secretion through the same pathway, the physical features of natural signal sequences have been extensively examined for similarities that might play a part in function. Experimental data have confirmed statistical analyses which highlighted dominant features of natural signal sequences in Escherichia coli: a net positive charge in the N-terminus increases efficiency of transport; the core region must maintain a threshold level of hydrophobicity within a range of length limitations; the central portion adopts an alpha-helical conformation in hydrophobic environments; and the signal cleavage region is ideally six residues long, with small side-chain amino acids in the -1 and -3 positions. This review focuses on the parallels between signal peptide physical features and their functions, which emerge when the results of a variety of experimental approaches are combined. The requirement for each property may be ascribed to a potential interaction that is critical for efficient protein export. The summation of the key physical features produces signal peptides with the flexibility to function in multiple roles in order to expedite secretion. In this way, nature has indeed evolved exquisitely tuned signal sequences.

Ability of MBP or RBP signal peptides to influence folding and in vitro translocation of wild-type and hybrid precursors

Maltose-binding protein (MBP), whose export in E. coli is dependent upon the chaperone SecB, and ribose-binding protein (RBP), whose export is SecB-independent, have been used to generate hybrid secretory proteins. Here, in vitro techniques were used to analyze MBP, RBP, RBP-MBP (RBP signal and MBP mature), and MBP-RBP (MBP signal and RBP mature). In protease-protection experiments, RBP folded considerably faster than MBP, RBP-MBP, or MBP-RBP. Only the folding properties of proteins containing the MBP mature moiety were influenced by SecB. In post-translational translocation assays, MBP exhibited the highest translocation efficiency. The hybrids RBP-MBP and MBP-RBP showed intermediate levels, and RBP translocation was not detected in these assays. These experiments demonstrate the influence of the signal peptide in determining folding properties and translocation efficiency of precursor secretory proteins.

Requirements for translocation of periplasmic domains in polytopic membrane proteins

Periplasmic domains of cytoplasmic membrane proteins require export signals for proper translocation. These signals were studied by using a MalF-alkaline phosphatase fusion in a genetic selection that allowed the isolation of mislocalization mutants. In the original construct, alkaline phosphatase is fused to the second periplasmic domain of the membrane protein, and its activity is thus confined exclusively to the periplasm. Mutants that no longer translocated alkaline phosphatase were selected by complementation of a serB mutation. A total of 11 deletions in the amino terminus were isolated, all of which spanned at least the third transmembrane segment. This domain immediately precedes the periplasmic domain to which alkaline phosphatase was fused. Our results obtained in vivo support the model that amino-terminal membrane-spanning segments are required for translocation of large periplasmic domains. In addition, we found that the inability to export the alkaline phosphatase domain could be suppressed by a mutation, prlA4, in the secretion apparatus.

Membrane insertion defects caused by positive charges in the early mature region of protein pIII of filamentous phage fd can be corrected by prlA suppressors

The filamentous phage coat protein pIII has been used to display a variety of peptides and proteins to allow easy screening for desirable binding properties. We have examined the biological constraints that restrict the expression of short peptides located in the early mature region of pIII, adjacent to the signal sequence cleavage site. Many functionally defective pIII fusion proteins contained several positively charged amino acids in this region. These residues appear to inhibit proper insertion of pIII into the Escherichia coli inner membrane, blocking the assembly and extrusion of phage particles. Suppressor mutations in the prlA (secY) component of the protein export apparatus dramatically alleviate the phage growth defect caused by the positively charged residues. We conclude that insertion of pIII fusion proteins into the inner membrane can occur by a sec gene-dependent mechanism. The suppressor strains should be useful for increasing the diversity of peptides displayed on pIII in phage libraries.

Signal peptide hydrophobicity is finely tailored for function

In order to titrate the dependence of individual steps in protein transport on signal peptide hydrophobicity, we have examined a series of mutants which involve replacement of the hydrophobic core segment of the Escherichia coli alkaline phosphatase signal peptide. The core regions vary in composition from 10:0 to 0:10 in the ratio of alanine to leucine residues. Thus, a nonfunctional polyalanine-containing signal peptide is titrated with the more hydrophobic residue, leucine. Analysis of this series identified a midpoint for rapid precursor processing between alanine to leucine ratios of 6:4 and 5:5 [Doud et al. (1993): Biochemistry 32:1251-1256]. Examination of precursors that are processed more slowly indicates a lower limit of signal peptide hydrophobicity that permits membrane association and translocation. Analysis of precursors that are processed rapidly defines an intermediate range of hydrophobicity that is optimum; above this level precursors become insensitive to transport inhibitors such as sodium azide and carbonyl cyanide 3-chlorophenylhydrazone (CCCP) in parallel with substantial inhibition of beta-lactamase processing. Our data indicate that there is a surprisingly narrow range of signal peptide hydrophobicity which both supports transport of the protein to which it is attached and which does not have such a high affinity for the transport pathway that it disrupts the appropriate balance of other secreted proteins.

Thirty-three amino acids of the mature moiety of an unprocessed maltose-binding protein are sufficient for export in Escherichia coli

Maltose-binding protein (MBP) is translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane of Escherichia coli; successful export depends on information in both the signal peptide and the mature moiety of the protein. To determine the shortest portion of the mature region that would maintain detectable entry of MBP into the export pathway, we took advantage of the properties of an MBP species with proline substituted in the +1 position relative to the cleavage site (MBP27-P). This protein efficiently crosses the cytoplasmic membrane but is not processed and acts as a competitive inhibitor of signal peptidase I (leader peptidase). Export of MBP27-P is measured by the inhibition of processing of other proteins, such as ribose-binding protein (RBP). A series of truncated derivatives of MBP27-P were tested for the ability to inhibit processing of RBP. An MBP27-P species with only 33 amino acids of the mature moiety inhibited processing of RBP, indicating that this truncated polypeptide was probably exported and interacted with signal peptidase I.

Genetic analysis of SecY: additional export-defective mutations and factors affecting their phenotypes

A number of secY mutants of Escherichia coli showing protein export defects were isolated by a combination of localized mutagenesis and secA-lacZ screening. Most of them were cold sensitive and contained single base substitutions in secY leading to amino acid replacements in various parts of the SecY protein, mainly in the cytoplasmic and the transmembrane domains. A temperature-sensitive mutant with an export defect had the same base substitution as secY24, which was characterized previously. Many cold-sensitive secY mutants exhibited rapid responses to temperature lowering but their apparent defects varied at the permissive temperature. Others exhibited delayed responses to the temperature shift. Some secY mutations, including secY39, interfered with protein export when expressed from a multicopy plasmid, even in the presence of wild-type secY on the chromosome. Such "dominant negative" mutations, including secY-d1, which was studied previously, were all located in either cytoplasmic domain 5 or 6, which is consistent with our previous proposal that the C-terminal region of SecY is important for its function as a protein translocator. We also studied the phenotypes of strains in which one of the secY mutations was combined with the components of the secD operon. Overexpression of secD partially suppressed the secY39 mutation, while overexpression of secF exacerbated the export defects of secY122 and secY125 mutations. Overexpression of "yajC", located within the secD operon, suppressed secY-d1. Although yajC itself proved to be dispensable, its disruption impaired the growth of the secY39 mutant at 42 degrees C. These observations suggest that SecY interacts with SecD, SecF, and the product of yajC.

Escherichia coli signal peptides direct inefficient secretion of an outer membrane protein (OmpA) and periplasmic proteins (maltose-binding protein, ribose-binding protein, and alkaline phosphatase) in Bacillus subtilis

Signal peptides of gram-positive exoproteins generally carry a higher net positive charge at their amino termini (N regions) and have longer hydrophobic cores (h regions) and carboxy termini (C regions) than do signal peptides of Escherichia coli envelope proteins. To determine if these differences are functionally significant, the ability of Bacillus subtilis to secrete four different E. coli envelope proteins was tested. A pulse-chase analysis demonstrated that the periplasmic maltose-binding protein (MBP), ribose-binding protein (RBP), alkaline phosphatase (PhoA), and outer membrane protein OmpA were only inefficiently secreted. Inefficient secretion could be ascribed largely to properties of the homologous signal peptides, since replacing them with the B. amyloliquefaciens alkaline protease signal peptide resulted in significant increases in both the rate and extent of export. The relative efficiency with which the native precursors were secreted (OmpA >> RBP > MBP > PhoA) was most closely correlated with the overall hydrophobicity of their h regions. This correlation was strengthened by the observation that the B. amyloliquefaciens levansucrase signal peptide, whose h region has an overall hydrophobicity similar to that of E. coli signal peptides, was able to direct secretion of only modest levels of MBP and OmpA. These results imply that there are differences between the secretion machineries of B. subtilis and E. coli and demonstrate that the outer membrane protein OmpA can be translocated across the cytoplasmic membrane of B. subtilis.

Isolation and analysis of novel mutants of Escherichia coli prlA (secY)

Plasmid libraries of prlA mutants containing single-base-pair changes throughout the gene were generated by in vitro random mutagenesis. The prlA mutations capable of suppressing the secretion defect of LamB caused by mutations in the LamB signal peptide were selected and analyzed. Together with additional mutations generated by site-directed mutagenesis, a number of novel prlA mutations and/or suppressors were identified. These mutations provide the starting points for studying the relationship of structure and function of PrlA in its interaction with LamB and/or other component(s) in the Escherichia coli protein secretion-translocation complex.

prlA suppression of defective export of maltose-binding protein in secB mutants of Escherichia coli

An Escherichia coli strain containing a signal sequence mutation in the periplasmic maltose-binding protein (MBP) (malE18-1) and a point mutation in the soluble export factor SecB (secBL75Q) is completely defective in export of MBP and unable to grow on maltose (Mal- phenotype). We isolated 95 spontaneous Mal+ revertants and characterized them genetically. Three types of extragenic suppressors were identified: informational (missense) suppressors, a bypass suppressor conferring the Mal+ phenotype in the absence of MBP, and suppressors affecting the prlA gene, which encodes a component of the protein export apparatus. In this study, a novel prlA allele, designated prlA1001 and mapping in the putative second transmembrane domain of the PrlA (SecY) protein, was found. In addition, we isolated a mutation designated prlA1024 which is identical to prlA4-2, the mutation responsible for the signal sequence suppression in the prlA4 (prlA4-1 prlA4-2) double mutant (T. Sako and T. Iino, J. Bacteriol. 170:5389-5391, 1988). Comparison of the prlA1024 mutant and the prlA4 double mutant provides a possible explanation for the isolation of these prlA alleles.

Charged amino-terminal amino acids affect the lethal capacity of Lambda lysis proteins S107 and S105

The lysis inhibitor protein S107 and the lysis effector protein S105 start at Met codons 1 and 3 of the Lambda S gene, respectively. The antagonistic action of both proteins precisely schedules lysis by formation of a non-specific lesion in the inner membrane through which the Lambda-encoded murein transglycosylase can pass. Here, we show that the main difference between lysis-effector and lysis-inhibitor is the degree by which an energized membrane inhibits either protein from hole formation. To dissect the structural parameters responsible for intrinsic inhibition of both proteins, charged amino acids were replaced proximal to the first putative membrane-spanning region in both S proteins. Our results show that the distribution of amino-terminal charged amino acids as well as the total amino-terminal net charge of S107 and S105 influence their lethal potential. The data are interpreted in terms of a model in which the electrostatic status of the amino-terminus of both S107 and S105 is an important feature affecting their conformational change required for formation of the S-dependent hole.

The complete general secretory pathway in gram-negative bacteria

The unifying feature of all proteins that are transported out of the cytoplasm of gram-negative bacteria by the general secretory pathway (GSP) is the presence of a long stretch of predominantly hydrophobic amino acids, the signal sequence. The interaction between signal sequence-bearing proteins and the cytoplasmic membrane may be a spontaneous event driven by the electrochemical energy potential across the cytoplasmic membrane, leading to membrane integration. The translocation of large, hydrophilic polypeptide segments to the periplasmic side of this membrane almost always requires at least six different proteins encoded by the sec genes and is dependent on both ATP hydrolysis and the electrochemical energy potential. Signal peptidases process precursors with a single, amino-terminal signal sequence, allowing them to be released into the periplasm, where they may remain or whence they may be inserted into the outer membrane. Selected proteins may also be transported across this membrane for assembly into cell surface appendages or for release into the extracellular medium. Many bacteria secrete a variety of structurally different proteins by a common pathway, referred to here as the main terminal branch of the GSP. This recently discovered branch pathway comprises at least 14 gene products. Other, simpler terminal branches of the GSP are also used by gram-negative bacteria to secrete a more limited range of extracellular proteins.

Alterations in the hydrophilic segment of the maltose-binding protein (MBP) signal peptide that affect either export or translation of MBP

Mutations that reduce the net positive charge within the hydrophilic segments of the signal peptides of several prokaryotic exported proteins can result in a reduction in the rate of protein export, as well as a reduction in protein synthesis (M. N. Hall, J. Gabay, and M. Shwartz, EMBO J. 2:15-19, 1983; S. Inouye, X. Soberon, T. Franceschini, K. Nakamura, K. Itakura, and M. Inouye, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:3438-3441, 1982; J. W. Puziss, J. D. Fikes, and P. J. Bassford, Jr., J. Bacteriol. 171:2302-2311, 1989). This result has been interpreted as evidence that the hydrophilic segment is part of a mechanism that obligatorily couples translation to protein export. We have investigated the role of the hydrophilic segment of the Escherichia coli maltose-binding protein (MBP) signal peptide in the export and synthesis of MBP. Deletion of the entire hydrophilic segment from the MBP signal peptide resulted in a defect in MBP export, as well as a dramatic reduction in total MBP synthesis. Suppressor mutations that lie upstream of the malE coding region were isolated. These mutations do not affect MBP export but instead were shown to partially restore MBP synthesis by increasing the efficiency of MBP translational initiation. In addition, analysis of a series of substitution mutations in the second codon of certain malE alleles demonstrated that MBP export and synthesis can be independently affected by mutations in the hydrophilic segment. Finally, analysis of alterations in the hydrophilic segment of the ribose-binding protein signal peptide fused to the mature moiety of the MBP has revealed that the role of the hydrophilic segment in the export process can be functionally separated from any role in translation. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that the hydrophilic segment of the MBP signal peptide is not involved in a mechanism that couples MBP translation to export and argue against the presence of a mechanism that obligatorily couples translation to protein export in Escherichia coli.

SecY and integral membrane components of the Escherichia coli protein translocation system

Genetic approaches can address the question of how integral membrane Sec factors interact with each other and facilitate protein translocation across the cytoplasmic membrane of E. coli. This review summarizes genetic analyses of SecY, SecE and some other protein translocation factors, utilizing 'prl' mutations, 'sec' mutations, 'suppressor-directed inactivation', 'Sec titration', dominant negative mutations and their suppressors. Evidence suggests that co-ordinate participation of SecY, SecE, SecD, SecF, and probably some other factors, is crucial for the process.

Involvement of SecB, a chaperone, in the export of ribose-binding protein

Ribose-binding protein (RBP) is an exported protein of Escherichia coli that functions in the periplasm. The export of RBP involves the secretion machinery of the cell, consisting of a cytoplasmic protein, SecA, and the integral membrane translocation complex, including SecE and SecY. SecB protein, a chaperone known to mediate the export of some periplasmic and outer membrane proteins, was previously reported not to be involved in RBP translocation even though small amounts of in vitro complexes between SecB and RBP have been detected. In our investigation, it was shown that a dependence on SecB could be demonstrated under conditions in which export was compromised. Species of RBP which carry two mutations, one in the leader that blocks export and a second in the mature protein which partially suppresses the export defect, were shown to be affected by SecB for efficient translocation. Five different changes which suppress the effect of the signal sequence mutation -17LP are all located in the N domain of the tertiary structure of RBP. All species of RBP show similar interaction with SecB. Furthermore, a leaky mutation, -14AE, generated by site-specific mutagenesis causes reduced export in the absence of SecB. These results indicate that SecB can interact with RBP during secretion, although it is not absolutely required under normal circumstances.

Biochemical analysis of the biogenesis and function of the Escherichia coli export factor SecY

SecY is an integral plasma-membrane protein of Escherichia coli which is essential for the export of periplasmic and outer-membrane proteins containing cleavable signal sequences. We have synthesized SecY in vitro using an E. coli transcription/translation system. In the absence of membranes, SecY remained largely soluble but cosedimented on sucrose gradients with the membrane fraction when inside-out plasma-membrane vesicles (INV) had been added cotranslationally. Membrane association of SecY was unaffected if the endogenous SecY of the INV had been inactivated by either antibodies, a mutation or trypsin treatment. In contrast, inactivation of the INV SecY interfered with membrane targeting and, consequently, the processing of precursors to beta-lactamase and lambda receptor. When SecY-deprived INV were, however, first functionally reconstituted with in-vitro-synthesized SecY, targeting and translocation of the lambda receptor were partially restored. Thus, the assembly of SecY into INV in vitro leads to an active enzyme. In addition, we show that the prlA4 allele of the secY gene suppresses signal-sequence mutations of the lambda receptor in vitro. Collectively, our results demonstrate that SecY, while functioning as a membrane-located receptor for precursors of exported proteins, appears to be virtually independent of pre-existing SecY for its own membrane integration.

Abnormal fractionation of beta-lactamase in Escherichia coli: evidence for an interaction with the inner membrane in the absence of a leader peptide

beta-Lactamase with the -20 to -1 region of the leader peptide deleted (almost complete deletion of the leader peptide) [delta(-20,-1) beta-lactamase] was released from Escherichia coli cells by osmotic shock. Fractionation of the cells by conversion to spheroplasts and protease accessibility experiments further indicated that a portion of the protein may be bound to the cytoplasmic membrane and be partially exposed in the periplasmic space. Expression of delta(-20,-1) beta-lactamase conferred a 25-fold increase in the 50% lethal dose for ampicillin relative to that for controls, thus confirming that a small amount (about 2%) of the active protein is completely exported from the cytoplasm. These results suggest that even in the absence of a leader peptide, mature beta-lactamase is able to interact with the cytoplasmic membrane and be translocated into the periplasmic space, albeit with a low efficiency.