Biomaterial Scaffolds Recruit an Aggressive Population of Metastatic Tumor Cells In Vivo

Design Principles of an Engineered Metastatic Niche for Monitoring of Cancer Progression

Across many types of cancer, metastatic disease is associated with a substantial decrease in 5-year survival rates relative to only a localized primary tumor. Many patients self-report metastatic disease due to disruption of normal organ or tissue function, and earlier detection could enable treatment with a lower burden of disease. We have previously reported a subcutaneous biomaterial implant for early detection by serving as an engineered metastatic niche, which has been reported to recruit tumor cells before colonization of solid organs. In this report, we investigated the design principles of the scaffold and defined the conditions for use in disease detection. Using the metastatic 4T1 triple-negative breast cancer model, we identified that a porous structure was essential to capture tumor and immune cells. Scaffolds of multiple diameters were investigated for their ability to serve as a metastatic niche, with a porous scaffold with a diameter as small as 2 mm identifying disease accurately. Additionally, scaffolds that had been in vivo for 1-5 weeks were able to identify disease accurately. Finally, the sensitivity of the scaffold relative to liquid biopsies was analyzed, with scaffolds accurately detecting disease at earlier time points than liquid biopsy. Collectively, these studies inform the design principles and use conditions for porous scaffolds to detect metastatic disease.

Engineered immunological niche directs therapeutic development in models of progressive multiple sclerosis

Primary progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) is a demyelinating autoimmune disease with only a single class of FDA-approved treatment, B cell depletion. Novel treatments could emerge from a deeper understanding of the interplay between multiple cell types within diseased tissue throughout progression. We initially describe an engineered biomaterial-based immunological niche (IN) as a surrogate for diseased tissue to investigate immune cell function and phenotype dynamics throughout a chronic progressive mouse model of MS. Using these niches, we identify an array of dysregulated CC chemokine signaling as potential targets. We then develop antigen-loaded nanoparticles that reduce CC chemokine signaling, while delivering antigen. These nanoparticles serve as an antigen-specific treatment, and a single injection reduces disease burden, even if administered after symptomatic disease onset. This report demonstrates proof of principle of a biomaterial scaffold as a diseased tissue surrogate that can monitor immune function, identify potential drug targets, and guide the development of a therapeutic.

3D Scaffold-Based Culture System Enhances Preclinical Evaluation of Natural Killer Cell Therapy in A549 Lung Cancer Cells

Cell-based immunotherapies have emerged as promising cancer treatment modalities, demonstrating remarkable clinical efficacy. As interest in applying immune cell-based therapies to solid tumors has gained momentum, experimental models that enable long-term monitoring and mimic clinical administration are increasingly necessary. This study explores the potential of scaffold-based cell culture technologies, specifically three-dimensional (3D) extracellular matrix (ECM)-like frameworks, as promising solutions. These frameworks facilitate unhindered immune cell growth and enable continuous cancer cell culture. The three-dimensional (3D) cell culture model was developed using tailored scaffolds for natural killer (NK) cell culture. Within this framework, A549 lung cancer cells were cocultured with NK cells, allowing real-time monitoring for up to 28 days. The expression of critical markers associated with anticancer drug resistance and epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) was evaluated in cancer cells within this 3D culture context. Compared to conventional 2D monolayer cultures, this 3D scaffold-based culture revealed that solid tumor cells, specifically A549 cells, exhibited heightened resistance to anticancer drugs. Additionally, the 3D culture environment upregulated the expression of EMT markers namely vimentin, N-cadherin, and fibronectin, while NK and zEGFR-CAR-NK cells displayed anticancer effects. In the two-dimensional (2D) coculture, only zEGFR-CAR-NK cells exhibited such effects in the 3D coculture system, highlighting an intriguing inconsistency with the 2D culture model, further confirmed by in vivo experiments. This in vitro 3D cell culture model reliably predicts outcomes in NK immunotherapy experiments. Thus, it represents a valuable tool for investigating drug resistance mechanisms and assessing the efficacy of immune cell-based therapies. By bridging the gap between in vitro and in vivo investigations, this model effectively translates potential treatments into animal models and facilitates rigorous preclinical evaluations.

Polymer scaffolds delineate healthy from diseased states at sites distal from the pancreas in two models of type 1 diabetes

Type 1 diabetes (T1D) prevention is currently limited by the lack of diagnostic tools able to identify disease before autoimmune destruction of the pancreatic β cells. Autoantibody tests are used to predict risk and, in combination with glucose dysregulation indicative of β cell loss, to determine administration of immunotherapies. Our objective was to remotely identify immune changes associated with the disease, and we have employed a subcutaneously implanted microporous poly(e-caprolactone) (PCL) scaffold to function as an immunological niche (IN) in two models of T1D. Biopsy and analysis of the IN enables disease monitoring using transcriptomic changes at a distal site from autoimmune destruction of the pancreas, thereby gaining cellular level information about disease without the need for a biopsy of the native organ. Using this approach, we identified gene signatures that stratify healthy and diseased mice in both an adoptive transfer model and a spontaneous onset model of T1D. The gene signatures identified herein demonstrate the ability of the IN to identify immune activation associated with diabetes across models.

Inflammation drives tumor growth in an immunocompetent implantable metastasis model

Nearly 90% of cancer deaths are due to metastasis. Conventional cancer therapeutics including chemotherapy, surgery, and radiotherapy, are effective in treating primary tumors, but may aggravate disseminated tumor cells (DTCs) into regaining a proliferative state. Models isolating the post dissemination environment are needed to address the potential risks of these therapies, however modeling post dissemination environments is challenging. Often, host organisms become moribund due to primary tumor mass before native metastatic niches can evolve. Implantable tissue engineered niches have been used to attract circulating tumor cells independent of the primary tumor. Here, we serially transplant such tissue engineered niches with recruited DTCs in order to isolate the post dissemination environment. After transplantaion, 69% of scaffolds developed overt post-dissemination cancer growth, however 100% of scaffolds did not grow to a life-threatening critical size within twelve weeks. Adjuvant chemotherapy, while initially effective, did not prevent long-term DTC growth in scaffolds. Subjecting these transplanted niches to surgical resection via biopsy punch enhanced CD31, MMP9, Ly6G, and tumor burden compared to control scaffolds. Biopsy punching was able to rescue tumor incidence from prior chemotherapy. This model of serial transplantation of engineered DTC niches is a highly controllable and flexible method of establishing and systematically investigating the post-dissemination niche.

Biomarkers from subcutaneous engineered tissues predict acute rejection of organ allografts

Invasive graft biopsies assess the efficacy of immunosuppression through lagging indicators of transplant rejection. We report on a microporous scaffold implant as a minimally invasive immunological niche to assay rejection before graft injury. Adoptive transfer of T cells into Rag2-/- mice with mismatched allografts induced acute cellular allograft rejection (ACAR), with subsequent validation in wild-type animals. Following murine heart or skin transplantation, scaffold implants accumulate predominantly innate immune cells. The scaffold enables frequent biopsy, and gene expression analyses identified biomarkers of ACAR before clinical signs of graft injury. This gene signature distinguishes ACAR and immunodeficient respiratory infection before injury onset, indicating the specificity of the biomarkers to differentiate ACAR from other inflammatory insult. Overall, this implantable scaffold enables remote evaluation of the early risk of rejection, which could potentially be used to reduce the frequency of routine graft biopsy, reduce toxicities by personalizing immunosuppression, and prolong transplant life.

Human Breast Cancer Cell Lines Differentially Modulate Signaling from Distant Microenvironments, Which Reflects Their Metastatic Potential

Metastasis is the stage at which the prognosis substantially decreases for many types of cancer. The ability of tumor cells to metastasize is dependent upon the characteristics of the tumor cells, and the conditioning of distant tissues that support colonization by metastatic cells. In this report, we investigated the systemic alterations in distant tissues caused by multiple human breast cancer cell lines and the impact of these alterations on the tumor cell phenotype. We observed that the niche within the lung, a common metastatic site, was significantly altered by MDA-MB-231, MCF7, and T47 tumors, and that the lung microenvironment stimulated, to differing extents, an epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT), reducing proliferation, increasing transendothelial migration and senescence, with no significant impact on cell death. We also investigated the ability of an implantable scaffold, which supports the formation of a distant tissue, to serve as a surrogate for the lung to identify systemic alterations. The scaffolds are conditioned by the primary tumor similarly to the lung for each tumor type, evidenced by promoting a pro-EMT profile. Collectively, we demonstrate that metastatic and non-metastatic breast cancers condition distant tissues, with distinct effects on tumor cell responses, and that a surrogate tissue can distinguish the metastatic potential of human breast cancer cell lines in an accessible site that avoids biopsy of a vital organ.

An engineered niche delineates metastatic potential of breast cancer

Metastatic breast cancer is often not diagnosed until secondary tumors have become macroscopically visible and millions of tumor cells have invaded distant tissues. Yet, metastasis is initiated by a cascade of events leading to formation of the pre-metastatic niche, which can precede tumor formation by a matter of years. We aimed to distinguish the potential for metastatic disease from nonmetastatic disease at early times in triple-negative breast cancer using sister cell lines 4T1 (metastatic), 4T07 (invasive, nonmetastatic), and 67NR (nonmetastatic). We used a porous, polycaprolactone scaffold, that serves as an engineered metastatic niche, to identify metastatic disease through the characteristics of the microenvironment. Analysis of the immune cell composition at the scaffold was able to distinguish noninvasive 67NR tumor-bearing mice from 4T07 and 4T1 tumor-bearing mice but could not delineate metastatic potential between the two invasive cell lines. Gene expression in the scaffolds correlated with the up-regulation of cancer hallmarks (e.g., angiogenesis, hypoxia) in the 4T1 mice relative to 4T07 mice. We developed a 9-gene signature (Dhx9, Dusp12, Fth1, Ifitm1, Ndufs1, Pja2, Slc1a3, Soga1, Spon2) that successfully distinguished 4T1 disease from 67NR or 4T07 disease throughout metastatic progression. Furthermore, this signature proved highly effective at distinguishing diseased lungs in publicly available datasets of mouse models of metastatic breast cancer and in human models of lung cancer. The early and accurate detection of metastatic disease that could lead to early treatment has the potential to improve patient outcomes and quality of life.

Distinguished biomimetic dECM system facilitates early detection of metastatic breast cancer cells

Breast cancer is the most prevalent malignant tumor affecting women's health. Bone is the most common distant metastatic organ, worsening the quality of life and increasing the mortality of patients. Early detection of breast cancer bone metastasis is urgent for halting disease progression and improving tumor prognosis. Recently, extracellular matrix (ECM) with biomimetic tissue niches opened a new avenue for tumor models in vitro. Here, we developed a biomimetic decellularized ECM (dECM) system to recapitulate bone niches at different situations, bone mimetic dECM from osteoblasts (BM-ECM) and bone tumor mimetic dECM from osteosarcoma cells (OS-ECM). The two kinds of dECMs exhibited distinct morphology, protein composition, and distribution. Interestingly, highly metastatic breast cancer cells tended to adhere and migrate on BM-ECM, while lowly metastatic breast cancer cells preferred the OS-ECM niche. Epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition was a potential mechanism to initiate the breast cancer cell migration on different biomimetic dECMs. Importantly, in the nude mice model, the dECM system captured metastatic breast cancer cells as early as 10 days after orthotopic transplantation in mammary gland pads, with higher signal on BM-ECM than that on OS-ECM. Collectively, the biomimetic dECM system might be a promising tumor model to distinguish the metastatic ability of breast cancer cells in vitro and to facilitate early detection of metastatic breast cancer cells in vivo, contributing to the diagnosis of breast cancer bone metastasis.

A synthetic metastatic niche reveals antitumor neutrophils drive breast cancer metastatic dormancy in the lungs

Biomaterial scaffolds mimicking the environment in metastatic organs can deconstruct complex signals and facilitate the study of cancer progression and metastasis. Here we report that a subcutaneous scaffold implant in mouse models of metastatic breast cancer in female mice recruits lung-tropic circulating tumor cells yet suppresses their growth through potent in situ antitumor immunity. In contrast, the lung, the endogenous metastatic organ for these models, develops lethal metastases in aggressive breast cancer, with less aggressive tumor models developing dormant lungs suppressing tumor growth. Our study reveals multifaceted roles of neutrophils in regulating metastasis. Breast cancer-educated neutrophils infiltrate the scaffold implants and lungs, secreting the same signal to attract lung-tropic circulating tumor cells. Second, antitumor and pro-tumor neutrophils are selectively recruited to the dormant scaffolds and lungs, respectively, responding to distinct groups of chemoattractants to establish activated or suppressive immune environments that direct different fates of cancer cells.

Single-cell RNA-sequencing identifies anti-cancer immune phenotypes in the early lung metastatic niche during breast cancer

Microenvironmental changes in the early metastatic niche may be exploited to identify therapeutic targets to inhibit secondary tumor formation and improve disease outcomes. We dissected the developing lung metastatic niche in a model of metastatic, triple-negative breast cancer using single-cell RNA-sequencing. Lungs were extracted from mice at 7-, 14-, or 21 days after tumor inoculation corresponding to the pre-metastatic, micro-metastatic, and metastatic niche, respectively. The progression of the metastatic niche was marked by an increase in neutrophil infiltration (5% of cells at day 0 to 81% of cells at day 21) and signaling pathways corresponding to the hallmarks of cancer. Importantly, the pre-metastatic and early metastatic niche were composed of immune cells with an anti-cancer phenotype not traditionally associated with metastatic disease. As expected, the metastatic niche exhibited pro-cancer phenotypes. The transition from anti-cancer to pro-cancer phenotypes was directly associated with neutrophil and monocyte behaviors at these time points. Predicted metabolic, transcription factor, and receptor-ligand signaling suggested that changes in the neutrophils likely induced the transitions in the other immune cells. Conditioned medium generated by cells extracted from the pre-metastatic niche successfully inhibited tumor cell proliferation and migration in vitro and the in vivo depletion of pre-metastatic neutrophils and monocytes worsened survival outcomes, thus validating the anti-cancer phenotype of the developing niche. Genes associated with the early anti-cancer response could act as biomarkers that could serve as targets for the treatment of early metastatic disease. Such therapies have the potential to revolutionize clinical outcomes in metastatic breast cancer.

Machine learning approaches for biomolecular, biophysical, and biomaterials research

A fluent conversation with a virtual assistant, person-tailored news feeds, and deep-fake images created within seconds-all those things that have been unthinkable for a long time are now a part of our everyday lives. What these examples have in common is that they are realized by different means of machine learning (ML), a technology that has fundamentally changed many aspects of the modern world. The possibility to process enormous amount of data in multi-hierarchical, digital constructs has paved the way not only for creating intelligent systems but also for obtaining surprising new insight into many scientific problems. However, in the different areas of biosciences, which typically rely heavily on the collection of time-consuming experimental data, applying ML methods is a bit more challenging: Here, difficulties can arise from small datasets and the inherent, broad variability, and complexity associated with studying biological objects and phenomena. In this Review, we give an overview of commonly used ML algorithms (which are often referred to as "machines") and learning strategies as well as their applications in different bio-disciplines such as molecular biology, drug development, biophysics, and biomaterials science. We highlight how selected research questions from those fields were successfully translated into machine readable formats, discuss typical problems that can arise in this context, and provide an overview of how to resolve those encountered difficulties.

Engineer a pre-metastatic niched microenvironment to attract breast cancer cells by utilizing a 3D printed polycaprolactone/nano-hydroxyapatite osteogenic scaffold - An in vitro model system for proof of concept

Breast cancer bone metastasis is not a random process. It is affected by the local microenvironment which determines the propensity of cancer cells to invade and colonize into the secondary sites. This microenvironment is termed a pre-metastatic niche. With the flexibility to incorporate different biofactors, tissue-engineering scaffolds provide an advantageous environment to promote "designed" osteogenesis that may mimic the bony pre-metastatic niche. In the current study, designed polycaprolactone (PCL) scaffolds enriched with nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) were fabricated through three-dimensional (3D) printing. Subsequently, human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) were seeded onto PCL-nHA scaffolds for osteogenic differentiation to establish the pre-metastatic niched microenvironment. Furthermore, transwell migration assay was used to investigate recruitment of MDA-MB-231, MCF-7, and MDA-MB-453 breast cancer cells to the osseous PCL-nHA scaffolds. Our results showed that the mRNA levels of alkaline phosphatase (ALP), runt-related transcription factor 2 (Runx2), and osteocalcin (OCN) of hMSCs on the PCL-nHA scaffolds were dramatically increased compared those with the PCL scaffolds (control) at day 7, 14, and 28. Meanwhile, the migration analysis showed that the higher maturation of osteogenesis and bone metabolism collectively contributed to the creation of a more favorable niched site for the cancerous invasion. Moreover, one of the hypothesized key mediators for the promoted migration, CXCL12, was confirmed using an assay of antagonist LIT-927. This early study demonstrated that a designed tissue engineering scaffold can be utilized to create a bone-mimicking environment that serves as a novel platform to recapitulate the pre-metastatic niche and help interrogate the scheme of bone metastasis by breast cancer.

Breast Cancer Cells Metastasize to the Tissue-Engineered Premetastatic Niche by Using an Osteoid-Formed Polycaprolactone/Nanohydroxyapatite Scaffold

It has been deemed that the premetastatic niche (PMN) plays a critical role in facilitating bone metastasis of breast cancer cells. Tissue engineering scaffolds provide an advantageous environment to promote osteogenesis that may mimic the bony premetastatic niches (BPMNs). In this study, human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSCs) were seeded onto designed polycaprolactone/nanohydroxyapatite (PCL-nHA) scaffolds for osteogenic differentiation. Subsequently, a coculture system was used to establish the tissue-engineered BPMNs by culturing breast cancer cells, hMSCs, and osteoid-formed PCL-nHA scaffolds. Afterwards, a migration assay was used to investigate the recruitment of MDA-MB-231, MCF-7, and MDA-MB-453 cells to the BPMNs' supernatants. The cancer stem cell (CSC) properties of these migrated cells were investigated by flow cytometry. Our results showed that the mRNA expression levels of alkaline phosphatase (ALP), Osterix, runt-related transcription factor 2 (Runx2), and collagen type I alpha 1 (COL1A1) on the PCL-nHA scaffolds were dramatically increased compared to the PCL scaffolds on days 11, 18, and 32. The expression of CXCL12 in these BPMNs was increased gradually over coculturing time, and it may be a feasible marker for BPMNs. Furthermore, migration analysis results showed that the higher maturation of BPMNs collectively contributed to the creation of a more favorable niched site for the cancerous invasion. The subpopulation of breast cancer stem cells (BCSCs) was more likely to migrate to fertile BPMNs. The proportion of BCSCs in metastatic MDA-MB-231, MCF-7, and MDA-MB-453 cells were increased by approximately 63.47%, 149.48%, and 127.60%. The current study demonstrated that a designed tissue engineering scaffold can provide a novel method to create a bone-mimicking environment that serves as a useable platform to recapitulate the BPMNs and help interrogate the scheme of bone metastasis by breast cancer.

Precision biomaterials in cancer theranostics and modelling

Despite significant achievements in the understanding and treatment of cancer, it remains a major burden. Traditional therapeutic approaches based on the 'one-size-fits-all' paradigm are becoming obsolete, as demonstrated by the increasing number of patients failing to respond to treatments. In contrast, more precise approaches based on individualized genetic profiling of tumors have already demonstrated their potential. However, even more personalized treatments display shortcomings mainly associated with systemic delivery, such as low local drug efficacy or specificity. A large amount of effort is currently being invested in developing precision medicine-based strategies for improving the efficiency of cancer theranostics and modelling, which are envisioned to be more accurate, standardized, localized, and less expensive. To this end, interdisciplinary research fields, such as biomedicine, material sciences, pharmacology, chemistry, tissue engineering, and nanotechnology, must converge for boosting the precision cancer ecosystem. In this regard, precision biomaterials have emerged as a promising strategy to detect, model, and treat cancer more efficiently. These are defined as those biomaterials precisely engineered with specific theranostic functions and bioactive components, with the possibility to be tailored to the cancer patient needs, thus having a vast potential in the increasing demand for more efficient treatments. In this review, we discuss the latest advances in the field of precision biomaterials in cancer research, which are expected to revolutionize disease management, focusing on their uses for cancer modelling, detection, and therapeutic applications. We finally comment on the needed requirements to accelerate their application in the clinic to improve cancer patient prognosis.

Localized delivery of immunotherapeutics: A rising trend in the field

Immunotherapy is becoming a new standard of care for multiple cancers, while several limitations are impending its further clinical success. Immunotherapeutic agents often have inappropriate pharmacokinetics on their own and/or exhibit limited specificity to tumor cells, leading to severe immuno-related adverse effects and limited efficacy. Suitable formulating strategies that confer prolonged contact with or efficient proliferation in tumors while reducing exposure to normal tissues are highly worthy to explore. With the assistance of biomaterial carriers, targeted therapy can be achieved artificially by implanting or injecting drug depots into desired sites, about which the wisdoms in literature have been rich. The relevant results have suggested a "local but systemic" effect, that is, local replenishment of immune modulators achieves a high treatment efficacy that also governs distant metastases, thereby building another rationale for localized delivery. Particularly, implantable scaffolds have been further engineered to recruit disseminated tumor cells with an efficiency high enough to reduce tumor burdens at typical metastatic organs, and simultaneously provide diagnostic signals. This review introduces recent advances in this emerging area along with a perspective on the opportunities and challenges in the way to clinical application.

Recent advances in regenerative medicine strategies for cancer treatment

Cancer stands as one of the most leading causes of death worldwide, while one of the most significant challenges in treating it is revealing novel alternatives to predict, diagnose, and eradicate tumor cell growth. Although various methods, such as surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation therapy, are used today to treat cancer, its mortality rate is still high due to the numerous shortcomings of each approach. Regenerative medicine field, including tissue engineering, cell therapy, gene therapy, participate in cancer treatment and development of cancer models to improve the understanding of cancer biology. The final intention is to convey fundamental and laboratory research to effective clinical treatments, from the bench to the bedside. Proper interpretation of research attempts helps to lessen the burden of treatment and illness for patients. The purpose of this review is to investigate the role of regenerative medicine in accelerating and improving cancer treatment. This study examines the capabilities of regenerative medicine in providing novel cancer treatments and the effectiveness of these treatments to clarify this path as much as possible and promote advanced future research in this field.

Pancreatic cancer is marked by complement-high blood monocytes and tumor-associated macrophages

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDA) is accompanied by reprogramming of the local microenvironment, but changes at distal sites are poorly understood. We implanted biomaterial scaffolds, which act as an artificial premetastatic niche, into immunocompetent tumor-bearing and control mice, and identified a unique tumor-specific gene expression signature that includes high expression of C1qa, C1qb, Trem2, and Chil3 Single-cell RNA sequencing mapped these genes to two distinct macrophage populations in the scaffolds, one marked by elevated C1qa, C1qb, and Trem2, the other with high Chil3, Ly6c2 and Plac8 In mice, expression of these genes in the corresponding populations was elevated in tumor-associated macrophages compared with macrophages in the normal pancreas. We then analyzed single-cell RNA sequencing from patient samples, and determined expression of C1QA, C1QB, and TREM2 is elevated in human macrophages in primary tumors and liver metastases. Single-cell sequencing analysis of patient blood revealed a substantial enrichment of the same gene signature in monocytes. Taken together, our study identifies two distinct tumor-associated macrophage and monocyte populations that reflects systemic immune changes in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma patients.

Breast cancer dormancy: need for clinically relevant models to address current gaps in knowledge

Breast cancer is the most commonly diagnosed cancer in the USA. Although advances in treatment over the past several decades have significantly improved the outlook for this disease, most women who are diagnosed with estrogen receptor positive disease remain at risk of metastatic relapse for the remainder of their life. The cellular source of late relapse in these patients is thought to be disseminated tumor cells that reactivate after a long period of dormancy. The biology of these dormant cells and their natural history over a patient's lifetime is largely unclear. We posit that research on tumor dormancy has been significantly limited by the lack of clinically relevant models. This review will discuss existing dormancy models, gaps in biological understanding, and propose criteria for future models to enhance their clinical relevance.

3D Culture Systems for Exploring Cancer Immunology

Simple Summary

To study any disease, researchers need convenient and relevant disease models. In cancer, the most commonly used models are two-dimensional (2D) culture models, which grow cells on hard, rigid, plastic surfaces, and mouse models. Cancer immunology is especially difficult to model because the immune system is exceedingly complex; it contains multiple types of cells, and each cell type has several subtypes and a spectrum of activation states. These many immune cell types interact with cancer cells and other components of the tumor, ultimately influencing disease outcomes. 2D culture methods fail to recapitulate these complex cellular interactions. Mouse models also suffer because the murine and human immune systems vary significantly. Three-dimensional (3D) culture systems therefore provide an alternative method to study cancer immunology and can fill the current gaps in available models. This review will describe common 3D culture models and how those models have been used to advance our understanding of cancer immunology.

Abstract

Cancer immunotherapy has revolutionized cancer treatment, spurring extensive investigation into cancer immunology and how to exploit this biology for therapeutic benefit. Current methods to investigate cancer-immune cell interactions and develop novel drug therapies rely on either two-dimensional (2D) culture systems or murine models. However, three-dimensional (3D) culture systems provide a potentially superior alternative model to both 2D and murine approaches. As opposed to 2D models, 3D models are more physiologically relevant and better replicate tumor complexities. Compared to murine models, 3D models are cheaper, faster, and can study the human immune system. In this review, we discuss the most common 3D culture systems—spheroids, organoids, and microfluidic chips—and detail how these systems have advanced our understanding of cancer immunology.

Disease-induced immunomodulation at biomaterial scaffolds detects early pancreatic cancer in a spontaneous model

Pancreatic cancer has the worst prognosis of all cancers due to disease aggressiveness and paucity of early detection platforms. We developed biomaterial scaffolds that recruit metastatic tumor cells and reflect the immune dysregulation of native metastatic sites. While this platform has shown promise in orthotopic breast cancer models, its potential in other models is untested. Herein, we demonstrate that scaffolds recruit disseminated pancreatic cells in the KPCY model of spontaneous pancreatic cancer prior to adenocarcinoma formation (3-fold increase in scaffold YFP + cells). Furthermore, immune cells at the scaffolds differentiate early- and late-stage disease with greater accuracy (0.83) than the natural metastatic site (liver, 0.50). Early disease was identified by an approximately 2-fold increase in monocytes. Late-stage disease was marked by a 1.5-2-fold increase in T cells and natural killer cells. The differential immune response indicated that the scaffolds could distinguish spontaneous pancreatic cancer from spontaneous breast cancer. Collectively, our findings demonstrate the utility of scaffolds to reflect immunomodulation in two spontaneous models of tumorigenesis, and their particular utility for identifying early disease stages in the aggressive KPCY pancreatic cancer model. Such scaffolds may serve as a platform for early detection of pancreatic cancer to improve treatment and prognosis.

Engineered Niches to Analyze Mechanisms of Metastasis and Guide Precision Medicine

Cancer metastasis poses a challenging problem both clinically and scientifically, as the stochastic nature of metastatic lesion formation introduces complexity for both early detection and the study of metastasis in preclinical models. Engineered metastatic niches represent an emerging approach to address this stochasticity by creating bioengineered sites where cancer can preferentially metastasize. As the engineered niche captures the earliest metastatic cells at a nonvital location, both noninvasive and biopsy-based monitoring of these sites can be performed routinely to detect metastasis early and monitor alterations in the forming metastatic niche. The engineered metastatic niche also provides a new platform technology that serves as a tunable site to molecularly dissect metastatic disease mechanisms. Ultimately, linking the engineered niches with advances in sensor development and synthetic biology can provide enabling tools for preclinical cancer models and fosters the potential to impact the future of clinical cancer care.

Engineered immunological niches to monitor disease activity and treatment efficacy in relapsing multiple sclerosis

Relapses in multiple sclerosis can result in irreversible nervous system tissue injury. If these events could be detected early, targeted immunotherapy could potentially slow disease progression. We describe the use of engineered biomaterial-based immunological niches amenable to biopsy to provide insights into the phenotype of innate immune cells that control disease activity in a mouse model of multiple sclerosis. Differential gene expression in cells from these niches allow monitoring of disease dynamics and gauging the effectiveness of treatment. A proactive treatment regimen, given in response to signal within the niche but before symptoms appeared, substantially reduced disease. This technology offers a new approach to monitor organ-specific autoimmunity, and represents a platform to analyze immune dysfunction within otherwise inaccessible target tissues.

Metastatic Conditioning of Myeloid Cells at a Subcutaneous Synthetic Niche Reflects Disease Progression and Predicts Therapeutic Outcomes

Monitoring metastatic events in distal tissues is challenged by their sporadic occurrence in obscure and inaccessible locations within these vital organs. A synthetic biomaterial scaffold can function as a synthetic metastatic niche to reveal the nature of these distal sites. These implanted scaffolds promote tissue ingrowth, which upon cancer initiation is transformed into a metastatic niche that captures aggressive circulating tumor cells. We hypothesized that immune cell phenotypes at synthetic niches reflect the immunosuppressive conditioning within a host that contributes to metastatic cell recruitment and can identify disease progression and response to therapy. We analyzed the expression of 632 immune-centric genes in tissue biopsied from implants at weekly intervals following inoculation. Specific immune populations within implants were then analyzed by single-cell RNA-seq. Dynamic gene expression profiles in innate cells, such as myeloid-derived suppressor cells, macrophages, and dendritic cells, suggest the development of an immunosuppressive microenvironment. These dynamics in immune phenotypes at implants was analogous to that in the diseased lung and had distinct dynamics compared with blood leukocytes. Following a therapeutic excision of the primary tumor, longitudinal tracking of immune phenotypes at the implant in individual mice showed an initial response to therapy, which over time differentiated recurrence versus survival. Collectively, the microenvironment at the synthetic niche acts as a sentinel by reflecting both progression and regression of disease. SIGNIFICANCE: Immune dynamics at biomaterial implants, functioning as a synthetic metastatic niche, provides unique information that correlates with disease progression. GRAPHICAL ABSTRACT: http://cancerres.aacrjournals.org/content/canres/80/3/602/F1.large.jpg.See related commentary by Wolf and Elisseeff, p. 377.

High Frequency Spectral Ultrasound Imaging to Detect Metastasis in Implanted Biomaterial Scaffolds

For most cancers, metastasis is the point at which disease is no longer curable. Earlier detection of metastasis, when it is undetectable by current clinical methods, may enable better outcomes. We have developed a biomaterial implant that recruits metastatic cancer cells in mouse models of breast cancer. Here, we investigate spectral ultrasound imaging (SUSI) as a non-invasive strategy for detecting metastasis to the implanted biomaterial scaffolds. Our results show that SUSI, which detects parameters related to tissue composition and structure, identified changes at an early time point when tumor cells were recruited to scaffolds in orthotopic breast cancer mouse models. These changes were not associated with acellular components in the scaffolds but were reflected in the cellular composition in the scaffold microenvironment, including an increase in CD31 + CD45-endothelial cell number in tumor bearing mice. In addition, we built a classification model based on changes in SUSI parameters from scaffold measurements to stratify tumor free and tumor bearing status. Combination of a linear discriminant analysis and bagged decision trees model resulted in an area under the curve of 0.92 for receiver operating characteristics analysis. With the potential for early non-invasive detection, SUSI could facilitate clinical translation of the scaffolds for monitoring metastatic disease.

Microporous scaffolds loaded with immunomodulatory lentivirus to study the contribution of immune cell populations to tumor cell recruitment in vivo

Metastases are preceded by stochastic formation of a hospitable microenvironment known as the premetastatic niche, which has been difficult to study. Herein, we employ implantable polycaprolactone scaffolds as an engineered premetastatic niche to independently investigate the role of interleukin-10 (IL10), CXCL12, and CCL2 in recruiting immune and tumor cells and impacting breast cancer cell phenotype via lentiviral overexpression. Lentivirus delivered from scaffolds in vivo achieved sustained transgene expression for 56 days. IL10 lentiviral expression, but not CXCL12 or CCL2, significantly decreased tumor cell recruitment to scaffolds in vivo. Delivery of CXCL12 enhanced CD45+ immune cell recruitment to scaffolds while delivery of IL10 reduced immune cell recruitment. CCL2 did not alter immune cell recruitment. Tumor cell phenotype was investigated using conditioned media from immunomodulated scaffolds, with CXCL12 microenvironments reducing proliferation, and IL10 microenvironments enhancing proliferation. Migration was enhanced with CCL2 and reduced with IL10-driven microenvironments. Multiple linear regression identified populations of immune cells associated with tumor cell abundance. CD45+ immune and CD8+ T cells were associated with reduced tumor cell abundance, while CD11b+Gr1+ neutrophils and CD4+ T cells were associated with enhanced tumor cell abundance. Collectively, biomaterial scaffolds provide a tool to probe the formation and function of the premetastatic niche.

Precision health for breast cancer metastasis: biomaterial scaffolds as an engineered metastatic niche to define, study, and monitor metastatic progression

Metastasis represents the greatest challenge to treatment of cancer patients. Biomaterial scaffolds that recruit tumor cells to a defined site in vivo are an emerging platform for the diagnosis, treatment, and study of metastasis. Recruitment of immune cells and metastatic tumor cells to a defined location provides a precision health platform to assess current clinical cancer biomarkers in a metastatic setting, and to define the next generation of biomarkers. These platforms represent an opportunity to create a molecular staging of metastasis that could aid in both the early diagnosis and treatment of metastasis.