Biochemical and ultrastructural data on Tetrahymena pyriformis treated with copper and cadmium

The phenotypic and demographic response to the combination of copper and thermal stressors strongly varies within the ciliate species, Tetrahymena thermophila

Copper pollution can alter biological and trophic functions. Organisms can utilise different tolerance strategies, including accumulation mechanisms (intracellular vacuoles, external chelation, etc.) to maintain themselves in copper-polluted environments. Accumulation mechanisms can influence the expression of other phenotypic traits, allowing organisms to deal with copper stress. Whether copper effects on accumulation strategies interact with other environmental stressors such as temperature and how this may differ within species are still unsolved questions. Here, we tested experimentally whether the combined effect of copper and temperature modulates traits linked to demography, morphology, movement and accumulation in six strains of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila. We also explored whether copper accumulation might modulate environmental copper concentration effects on phenotypic and demographic traits. Results showed high intraspecific variability in the phenotypic and demographic response to copper, with interactive effects between temperature and copper. In addition, they suggested an attenuation effect of copper accumulation on the sensitivity of traits to copper, but with great variation between strains, temperatures and copper concentrations. Diversity of responses among strains and their thermal dependencies pleads for the integration of intraspecific variability and multiple stressors approaches in ecotoxicological studies, thus improving the reliability of assessments of the effects of pollutants on biodiversity.

Arsenate and arsenite differential toxicity in Tetrahymena thermophila

A comparative analysis of toxicities of both arsenic forms (arsenite and arsenate) in the model eukaryotic microorganism Tetrahymena thermophila (ciliate protozoa) has shown the presence of various detoxification mechanisms and cellular effects comparable to those of animal cells under arsenic stress. In the wild type strain SB1969 arsenate is almost 2.5 times more toxic than arsenite. According to the concentration addition model used in binary metallic mixtures their toxicities show an additive effect. Using fluorescent assays and flow cytometry, it has been detected that As(V) generates elevated levels of ROS/RNS compared to As(III). Both produce the same levels of superoxide anion, but As(V) also causes greater increases in hydrogen peroxide and peroxynitrite. The mitochondrial membrane potential is affected by both As(V) and As(III), and electron microscopy has also revealed that mitochondria are the main target of both arsenic ionic forms. Fusion/fission and swelling mitochondrial and mitophagy, together with macroautophagy, vacuolization and mucocyst extruction are mainly associated to As(V) toxicity, while As(III) induces an extensive lipid metabolism dysfunction (adipotropic effect). Quantitative RT-PCR analysis of some genes encoding antioxidant proteins or enzymes has shown that glutathione and thioredoxin metabolisms are involved in the response to arsenic stress. Likewise, the function of metallothioneins seems to be crucial in arsenic detoxification processes, after using both metallothionein knockout and knockdown strains and cells overexpressing metallothionein genes from this ciliate. The analysis of the differential toxicity of As(III) and As(V) shown in this study provides cytological and molecular tools to be used as biomarkers for each of the two arsenic ionic forms.

Expression and molecular characterization of stress-responsive genes (hsp70 and Mn-sod) and evaluation of antioxidant enzymes (CAT and GPx) in heavy metal exposed freshwater ciliate, Tetmemena sp

Response of heavy metals namely cadmium (Cd) and copper (Cu) on the expression of stress responsive genes in the fresh water ciliate, Tetmemena sp. (single cell eukaryote) was studied. Stress responsive genes include heat shock protein genes and genes involved in antioxidant defence system. Quantitative real time PCR (qRT-PCR) was employed to evaluate the effects of Cd and Cu on the expression of cytosolic hsp70 and Mn-sod genes. Increase in the expression of these genes was observed after exposure with the heavy metals. The macronuclear cytosolic hsp70 and Mn-sod (SOD2) genes were also sequenced and characterized using various bioinformatics tools. In antioxidant defence system, the superoxide dismutase (SOD) family is a first line antioxidant enzyme group involved in catalysing reactive oxygen species (ROS) to hydrogen peroxide and molecular oxygen. Influence of Cd and Cu on the activity of SOD has already been reported by our group. Therefore, the enzymatic activities of antioxidant enzymes, catalase (CAT) and glutathione peroxidase (GPx) were studied in the presence of Cd and Cu and there was significant increase in activity of these enzymes in concentration dependent manner. This study suggests that cytosolic hsp70, Mn-sod and the antioxidant enzymes such as CAT and GPx can be used as effective molecular biomarkers for heavy metal toxicity and Tetmemena sp. can be used as potential model for understanding the molecular response to heavy metal contamination in aquatic ecosystems.

Expression, secretion and surface display of a human alkaline phosphatase by the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila

Background

Tetrahymena thermophila possesses many attributes that render it an attractive host for the expression of recombinant proteins. Surface proteins from the parasites Ichthyophthirius multifiliis and Plasmodium falciparum and avian influenza virus antigen H5N1 were displayed on the cell membrane of this ciliate. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that T. thermophila is also able to produce a functional human DNase I. The present study investigates the heterologous expression of the functional human intestinal alkaline phosphatase (hiAP) using T. thermophila and thereby presents a powerful tool for the optimization of the ciliate-based expression system.

Results

Functional and full length human intestinal alkaline phosphatase was expressed by T. thermophila using a codon-adapted gene containing the native signal-peptide and GPI (Glycosylphosphatidylinositol) anchor attachment signal. HiAP activity in the cell extract of transformants suggested that the hiAP gene was successfully expressed. Furthermore, it was demonstrated that the enzyme was modified with N-glycosylation and localized on the surface membrane by the C-terminal GPI anchor. A C-terminally truncated version of hiAP lacking the GPI anchor signal peptide was secreted into the medium as an active enzyme. In a first approach to establish a high level expression system up to 14,000 U/liter were produced in a time frame of two days, which exceeds the production rate of other published expression systems for this enzyme.

Conclusions

With the expression of hiAP, not only a protein of commercial interest could be produced, but also a reporter enzyme that offers the possibility to analyze T. thermophila genes that play a role in the regulation of protein secretion. Additionally, the fact that ciliates do not secrete an endogenous alkaline phosphatase provides the possibility to use the truncated hiAP as a reporter enzyme, allowing the quantification of measures that will be necessary for further optimization of the host strains and the fermentation processes.

Effects of xenobiotic compounds on the cell activities of Euplotes crassus, a single-cell eukaryotic test organism for the study of the pollution of marine sediments

It is now widely accepted that assays with protists are relevant to be exploited for the study of environmental modifications due to the presence of xenobiotic compounds. In this work, the possibility of utilizing Euplotes crassus, an interstitial marine ciliate, for the pre-chemical screening of estuarine and coastal sediments was evaluated. For this purpose, the effects of exposure to pollutants were tested on the cell viability, fission rate and lysosomal membrane stability of E. crassus. The following toxicants were used: an organophosphate (OP) pesticide, basudin, an organochlorine hydrocarbon, AFD25, both employed especially for pest control in agricultural sites, a toxic heavy metal, mercury (HgCl2) and different mixtures of the above-mentioned compounds, as they might occur in polluted sites. Exposure to these toxicants affected cell viability at concentrations ranging from 96.6 to 966 x 10(3)mg/l for basudin, from 3.3 to 33 x 10(3)mg/l for AFD25 and from 0.1 to 1mg/l for HgCl2. A significant decrease in the mean fission rate (P<0.001) was found after 24- or 48-h exposures to 9.66 mg/l basudin, 3.3 mg/l AFD25 and 7 x 10(-2)mg/l HgCl2. Furthermore, the Neutral Red Retention Assay showed a significant decrease in lysosomal membrane stability after 60- and 120-min exposures to AFD25 (33 mg/l) and HgCl2 (0.33 mg/l). In addition, as it is well-known that the inhibition of acetylcholinesterase activity represents a specific biomarker of exposure to OP and carbamate pesticides in higher organisms, initially the presence of cholinesterase (ChE) activity was detected in E. crassus, using cytochemical, spectrophotometric and electrophoretic methods. Afterwards, this enzyme activity was characterized spectrophotometrically by its sensitivity to specific ChE inhibitors and to variations in pH and temperature. The ChE activity was inhibited significantly by basudin- (9.66 and 96.6 mg/l) or AFD25-exposure (3.3 mg/l). Conversely, exposure to AFD25 (33 mg/l) or HgCl2 (0.1 and 0.3mg/l) caused a significant increase in this enzyme activity. Moreover, exposure to mixtures containing basudin, AFD25 and HgCl2 was found to affect the cell viability, the mean fission rate and the ChE activity differently, in an unpredictable manner. Our results indicate that E. crassus seems to be a suitable test organism to evaluate the toxicity of marine sediments.

Significance of physicochemical forms of storage in microalgae in predicting copper transfer to filter-feeding oysters (Crassostrea gigas)

Copper distribution has been examined in two microalgae (Haslea ostrearia, Diatom; Tetraselmis suecica, Prasinophyceae) exposed to Cu at 30 microg/L(-1). Exchangeable copper linked at the cell surface was desorbed using 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulfonate as complexing agent. Then, incorporated copper was separated between soluble and insoluble fractions. In addition, algae were resuspended in acid solutions, the pHs of which covered the range existing in the digestive tract of bivalves. Considering that the soluble fraction is the most easily transferred in the food chain and that exchangeable Cu is easily desorbed, the percentages of Cu potentially available in microalgae have been assessed. These percentages have been compared with those retained in oysters Crassostrea gigas fed with contaminated microalgae in previous studies. In H. ostrearia, the potentially available fraction of Cu (90%) was very similar to the percentage retained by oysters (93%) when the bivalves were acclimated to this food for 3 weeks. Only half (21%) of the potentially available Cu of T. suecica (42%) was readily assimilated in oysters after 3 weeks. This is in agreement with the results of the desorption tests at physiological pHs which showed that only 15-25% of Cu was lost, despite solubilization of other constituents of T. suecica as demonstrated by the decrease in their dry weight. Bioavailability determined from metal speciation in food allows a relevant prediction of the trophic transfer in the case of H. ostrearia, but caution is recommended in generalizing this mode of assessment as shown in the case of T. suecica.

Cytotoxicity and bioaccumulation of heavy metals by ciliated protozoa isolated from urban wastewater treatment plants

We studied the cytotoxic effect of the heavy metals Cd, Zn and Cu on three different species of ciliated protozoa isolated from an urban wastewater treatment plant. The order of toxicity was Cd>Cu>>Zn or Cu>Cd>>Zn, depending on the microbial species. In bimetallic (Cd+Zn) treatments, results indicated that, in general, the presence of Zn in the same medium decreased Cd cytotoxicity. Both cellular assays and microscopic observations showed that bioaccumulation is an important mechanism of resistance to these toxic environmental pollutants in such eukaryotic microorganisms. However, bioaccumulation might not be the main mechanism involved in Cu resistance. For the first time, fluorescence methodology was applied for revealing metal deposits in the cellular cytoplasm. This microscopic method is only useful when cell cultures can be exposed to rather high metal concentrations, as in the case of Zn. Inside the ciliated protozoa exposed to sublethal concentrations of Cd or Zn, it is possible to observe diverse electron-dense granules by TEM which are not seen in controls. Problems in comparing our results on heavy metal cytotoxic effects on ciliates with already published data are exposed and discussed. The use of these eukaryotic microorganisms as potential whole cells or molecular (ciliate metallothioneins) biosensors seems to be a reasonable useful alternative for assessing metallic pollution.

Cadmium effects on Ichthyophthirius: evidence for metal-sequestration in fish tissues following administration of recombinant vaccines

We are developing Tetrahymena thermophila as a delivery system for recombinant vaccines against parasitic protozoa, including the common fish parasite, Ichthyophthirius multifiliis. T. thermophila cell lines expressing I. multifiliis genes under the control of a cadmium-inducible metallothionein gene promoter conferred strong protection against a lethal parasite challenge when administered parenterally to naive fish. Nevertheless, given that heavy metals can be toxic to parasites, a question arose as to whether protection resulted from Cd residues carried over with the vaccine, rather than acquired immunity per se. To address this issue, we examined the sensitivity of I. multifiliis to Cd in vitro and determined Cd concentrations in different host tissues following i.p. injection of juvenile channel catfish with the recombinant vaccine. We found that CdCl2 at concentrations > or = 50 ppb were lethal to I. multifiliis theronts in vitro. Furthermore, Cd concentrations were clearly elevated in fish tissues and reached levels equivalent to 74 ng/g wet weight (74 ppb) in the skin within 14 days of injection with recombinant T. thermophila. Nevertheless, fish injected with non-transformed Tetrahymena grown in the presence or absence of CdCl2 showed no significant difference in either relative survival or parasite load following direct challenge with I. multifiliis.

Effect of different toxic compounds on ATP content and acid phosphatase activity in axenic cultures of Tetrahymena pyriformis

The sensitivity of protozoa, and particularly ciliated protozoa, to environmental changes suggested a study on the physiological responses arising from exposure to toxic compounds. Tetrahymena pyriformis was used as a test organism in a set of miniaturized assays. The physiological response of this ciliate was assessed in terms of adenosine-5'-triphosphate content and acid phosphatase activity after exposure of the cultures of T. pyriformis to four toxicants: copper, zinc, Triton X-100, and cycloheximide. In the range of concentrations used, stimulation and inhibition of these two parameters were observed. The correlation between the two parameters is analyzed.

A comparative study using a fluorescence-based and a direct-count assay to determine cytotoxicity in Tetrahymena pyriformis

A novel cellular cytotoxicity assay using two fluorescent dyes was developed as an alternative method to the standard direct count of viable protozoa under light microscopy. The compound calcein AM is a non-fluorescent substance that diffuses passively across intact cell membranes and is converted by intracellular esterases to the green fluorescent calcein, which is retained in viable cells. The addition of EthD-1 that binds to DNA stained nuclei of dead cells red. The experiments were carried out in order to assess viability in the freshwater ciliate Tetrahymena pyriformis after exposure to eight surfactants, two of each representing one of four ionic class (non-ionic, anionic, cationic and amphoteric), and two heavy metals, copper and zinc, at several concentrations. In earlier time exposure, less than one hour of contact with surfactants at sublethal concentrations, the fluorescent method is more sensitive and provides more accurate results than direct counting under light microscopy. In contrast, with increasing time exposure, the results obtained by the two methods were similar. Calcein was shown to be a poor viability marker in the presence of zinc and copper since the fluorescence intensity was affected by the metal presence. However, the fluorescent method offers new opportunities to use advanced techniques, such as flow cytometry, to assess cytotoxicity in protozoa.

Trends in the use of protozoa in the assessment of wastewater treatment

Increasing environmental pollution and the continuous development of new chemicals and drugs has led to ever growing concern about the potential effects of these compounds directly or indirectly on human health. As concerns water pollution, protozoa seem to be an excellent tool to assess both toxicity and pollution: they are regarded as biological indicators of pollution when their presence or absence can be related to particular environmental conditions, and they are considered test organisms when a species or population is used to evaluate the toxicity of relevant toxic compounds. Thus, an integrated approach is being developed to assess how toxic compounds affect the different biological levels of organisation--from the community level to the species level--of ciliated protozoa. The present paper reports and discusses the current state of the art of this approach.

Characterization of a heavy metal ATPase from the apicomplexan Cryptosporidium parvum

P1-ATPases are transporters which pump heavy metals across membranes, either to provide enzymes with essential cofactors or to remove excess, toxic metal cations from the cytosol. The first protist P1-ATPase (CpATPase2) has been isolated from the apicomplexan Cryptosporidium parvum, an opportunistic pathogen of AIDS patients. This single copy gene encodes 1260 amino acids (aa), predicting a protein of 144.7 kDa. Reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and western blot analysis confirmed CpATPase2 expression. Immunofluorescence microscopy of C. parvum sporozoites using rabbit antiserum raised against a glutathione-S-transferase (GST) fusion protein suggests that CpATPase2 is associated with the plasma- and cytoplasmic membranes. The protein shares greatest overall sequence similarity to previously characterized copper P1-ATPases. Expression and subsequent biochemical analyses of the N-terminal heavy metal binding domain (HMBD, GMxCxxC) of CpATPase2 as a maltose-binding protein (MBP) in Escherichia coli reveals that the protein specifically binds reduced copper, Cu(I), in vitro and in vivo, and that the cysteine residues of HMBD are responsible for heavy metal coordination. Overall, these data show that the apicomplexan C. parvum possesses a heavy metal P-ATPase transporter with a specificity for reduced copper. Since this discovery represents the first time a heavy metal P-ATPase has been identified and characterized from a protist, further molecular and biochemical studies are needed to understand the roles heavy metal P-ATPases play in heavy metal metabolism and potential virulence for this and other apicomplexa.

Physiological responses of Tetrahymena pyriformis to copper, zinc, cycloheximide and Triton X-100

Protozoa, and particularly ciliates, are essential in aerobic purification processes of wastewaters and have proved to be very sensitive to environmental changes. The physiological response of the ciliate Tetrahymena pyriformis was assessed in terms of mortality, growth and grazing capacity after exposure to four toxicants: copper, zinc, cycloheximide and Triton X-100. In the ranges of concentrations used, mortality, inhibition of growth and inhibition of grazing were observed with all toxicants employed, but in different ways. Copper and zinc showed lower toxicity than observed in other studies with protozoa, though some of the present results are in accordance with those reported by other authors. This supports the importance of the organism tested and the experimental conditions of the bioassays.

Effects of cadmium on the performance and microbiology of laboratory-scale lagoons treating domestic sewage

Two experiments were performed to assess the impact of cadmium on the sewage lagoon wastewater treatment process. For each one, three laboratory-scale pilot plants with one tank receiving the same raw effluent were used; one plant served as control and the other two were contaminated once only with cadmium. In the first study, the effects of a shock load of two concentrations of cadmium chloride (60 and 300 micrograms/l) on the plant performance, microbial populations (protists and bacteria) and enzyme activities were determined. Initially, most of the performance parameters were affected concentration-dependently. A reduction in the protist population density and some influence on the total bacterial population were observed, and the potential enzymatic activities were also modified. A second experiment with a lower cadmium concentration (30 micrograms/l), supplied as chloride or sulphate, still perturbed most of the parameters studied, and the effects of the two cadmium salts were identical.

Tetrahymena pyriformis: a tool for toxicological studies. A review

Among protozoa, Tetrahymena pyriformis is the most commonly ciliated model used for laboratory research. After a brief description of the morphology and biology of Tetrahymena pyriformis, this article focuses on the most important and recent investigations performed with this species in toxicology and ecotoxicology. The methodological features of its culture, and main tests, based on cell growth rate, biochemical markers, behavioral changes and motility, are discussed. Examples of xenobiotics (organic and inorganic substances, pharmaceutical drugs, water pollutants) tested with Tetrahymena pyriformis are also given.

Purification and primary structure of metallothioneins induced by cadmium in the protists Tetrahymena pigmentosa and Tetrahymena pyriformis

Tetrahymena pyriformis and Tetrahymena pigmentosa grown in the presence of a non-toxic dose of cadmium, accumulate the metal in the cytosol. Purification by gel-permeation, ion-exchange and reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography showed that the metal is bound principally to newly formed proteins with ultraviolet spectra and cysteine contents similar to those of Cd(2+)-metallothioneins from multicellular organisms. The isolated proteins revealed that the two species of ciliates each express two Cd(2+)-isothioneins. The primary structures determined by both Edman degradation and mass spectrometry revealed that the equivalent proteins from T. pyriformis and T. pigmentosa have identical sequences and that the two isoforms in each species differ only by the presence or absence of a lysine residue at the N-terminus. The development of automated mass spectrometric sequence analysis algorithms combined with an accurate determination of the molecular mass allowed the rapid confirmation of the sequences. The Tetrahymena metallothionein sequences are unusually long (105 and 104 amino acids) and show a unique internal homology which suggests that the proteins arose by gene duplication. The chains contain 31 cysteine residues, 15 of which are arranged in motifs characteristic of the mammalian metallothioneins; the remaining residues show several unique repeating motifs, which could have interesting consequences for the tertiary structure of the metal-binding sites. Amino acid sequences of Tetrahymena metallothioneins have some similarity with other eukaryotic metallothioneins. A comparison on the basis of optimised FASTA scores, shows a closer relationship with horse metallothionein-1B.

Effects of Cadmium in Stylonychia lemnae, Stylonychia notophora and Oxytricha granulifera: Isolation of a Cadmium‐Binding Protein

ABSTRACT The effects of cadmium on three ciliates are reported here. Cultures of Stylonychia lemnae, Stylonychia notophora and Oxytricha granulifera were treated with different doses of Cd according to tolerance. The two species of Stylonychia are very sensitive to the metal, white O. granulifera tolerates higher doses. Adding 50 μM of Cd to the medium did not damage cells. The accumulated metal is almost totally present in the particulate fraction after day 3. Two Cd‐Zn linking fractions were separated from the soluble fraction of culture treated on day 1. The first protein linking 17 μg Cd/mg showed an ultraviolet absorption spectrum similar to that of Cd‐thioneins. Preliminary amino acid analyses indicated that it contained 13% cysteine. The second protein, linking 60 μg Cd/mg, was a glycoprotein. Its ultraviolet absorption spectrum and amino acid analysis showed that this binding protein was far from being a metallothionein: its cysteine content was very low and aromatic and cyclic residues were present. This Cd‐linking compound seems to be unique, since it was very different both from metallothioneins and chelatins isolated by other protozoa. The protective role of these chelating proteins is discussed.

Replacement of calcium by cadmium ions from Ca-affinity sites localized in different cytoplasmic compartments of Acanthamoeba cells

In Acanthamoeba cells both Ca and Cd may be precipitated in different cytoplasmic compartments forming electron-opaque deposits, as shown in cells treated with glutaraldehyde supplied with either Ca or Cd respectively. It was found by semiquantitative X-ray microanalysis that the transfer of cells containing Ca-deposits to glutaraldehyde supplied with Cd causes a considerable replacement of Ca by Cd: in deposits formed at cell membrane, in cytoplasm, and in mitochondria the total weight percentage of Cd amounted to over 90, only in deposits formed in vacuoles the value was about 80. The replacement was not prevented by the presence of Ca in the transfer medium. When cells containing Cd-deposits were transferred to Ca-supplied medium, Cd predominated as well, its total weight percentage also amounting to over 90 in all the examined deposits. The results suggest that calcium bound in different cell structures may be easily replaced by cadmium, but not conversely, which suggests that Cd is more firmly than calcium linked to many cell constituents well preserved by fixation.

The influence of growth phase and culture conditions of Tetrahymena on effects of cadmium

The batch culture system is used in the majority of toxicity studies employing protozoa and other cell cultures, although it is known that metal toxicity may vary depending on the age and therefore on the physiological state of the culture. The ciliate Tetrahymena was exposed to cadmium during short-term incubations at different stages of the growth cycle. In cultures with cells proliferating at a high rate (log phase cells) the toxicity of cadmium was found to increase with increasing initial cell density. However, in the subsequent stationary growth phase with decreased rate of cell proliferation, the sensitivity against cadmium again decreases. Thus the effect of a given concentration of cadmium depends on the initial cell density of the culture. This effect of cadmium may be explained either by changes in the chemical composition of the culture medium during the growth cycle or by a changed cellular metabolism. Furthermore, it is shown that the cadmium concentration of the medium decreases during prolonged exposure when the cells are grown in batch cultures. Some of the problems associated with the toxicity bioassay performed in a static system may be overcome by using a continuous flow system. In such a system, Tetrahymena can be kept under optimal growth conditions with a generation time of less than 3 h, and any cell density may be maintained for extended periods of time. Furthermore, the cadmium concentration of the medium remained constant during prolonged exposure when maintaining a cell density of about 50 x 10(3) cells/ml. This illustrates the great advantage of using a continuous flow system in such investigations, where for example, long-term adaptations of the organism to a metal may be studied under constant conditions.