A cost-benefit analysis of RSV prophylaxis in high-risk infants

Cost of Respiratory Syncytial Virus-Associated Acute Lower Respiratory Infection Management in Young Children at the Regional and Global Level: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Background

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is a major cause of acute lower respiratory infection (ALRI) in young children aged <5 years.

Methods

We aimed to identify the global inpatient and outpatient cost of management of RSV-ALRI in young children to assist health policy makers in making decisions related to resource allocation for interventions to reduce severe morbidity and mortality from RSV in this age group. We searched 3 electronic databases including Global Health, Medline, and EMBASE for studies reporting cost data on RSV management in children under 60 months from 2000 to 2017. Unpublished data on the management cost of RSV episodes were collected through collaboration with an international working group (RSV GEN) and claim databases.

Results

We identified 41 studies reporting data from year 1987 to 2017, mainly from Europe, North America, and Australia, covering the management of a total of 365 828 RSV disease episodes. The average cost per episode was €3452 (95% confidence interval [CI], 3265–3639) and €299 (95% CI, 295–303) for inpatient and outpatient management without follow-up, and it increased to €8591(95% CI, 8489–8692) and €2191 (95% CI, 2190–2192), respectively, with follow-up to 2 years after the initial event.

Conclusions

Known risk factors (early and late preterm birth, congenital heart disease, chronic lung disease, intensive care unit admission, and ventilator use) were associated with €4160 (95% CI, 3237–5082) increased cost of hospitalization. The global cost of inpatient and outpatient RSV ALRI management in young children in 2017 was estimated to be approximately €4.82 billion (95% CI, 3.47–7.93), 65% of these in developing countries and 55% of global costs accounted for by hospitalization. We have demonstrated that RSV imposed a substantial economic burden on health systems, governments, and the society.

Palivizumab in preventing respiratory syncytial virus-related hospitalization in high-risk infants

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) causes seasonal epidemics (winter or wet-season) of serious lower respiratory tract infections in young infants with subsequent increased frequency of recurrent wheezing during early childhood. Palivizumab is a humanized monoclonal antibody that provides immunoprophylaxis against RSV when administered monthly over the RSV season. It significantly reduced hospitalizations in high-risk infants including preterm infants with and without bronchopulmonary dysplasia and infants with hemodynamically significant congenital heart disease. Since its license in 1998, approximately 36 methodologically different economic studies have been performed to prove cost-effectiveness of the product. The majority of cost-effectiveness analyses revealed costs of palivizumab exceeding anticipated savings from reduced RSV hospitalizations. A minority of studies performed cost-effectiveness analyses using incremental cost-effectiveness ratios as costs per quality-adjusted life-year gained. The wide variability in the results of economic studies with estimates ranging from cost savings to incremental costs of a high order of magnitude with its use is discussed, in the light of the continuing burden of RSV disease, the limited treatment modalities, and the continuing research for a vaccine.

Cost effectiveness of respiratory syncytial virus prophylaxis: a critical and systematic review

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the leading cause of infant hospitalization in the US. The economic burden of severe disease is substantial, including hospitalization costs and out-of-pocket expenses. RSV prophylaxis with either RSV immune globulin intravenous (RSV-IGIV) or palivizumab has been shown to be effective in reducing RSV-related hospitalizations. Motavizumab, a new enhanced-potency humanized RSV monoclonal antibody, is presently in clinical trials. RSV-IGIV and palivizumab are associated with high acquisition costs. Cost-effectiveness analyses are therefore of great importance in helping to determine who should receive RSV prophylaxis. Six studies have analysed the cost effectiveness of RSV-IGIV, 14 have analysed the cost effectiveness of palivizumab and five have analysed the cost effectiveness of both agents, two of which directly compared palivizumab with RSV-IGIV. The cost effectiveness of motavizumab has not been studied. Significant variation exists in the modelling used in these analyses. Many studies have examined short-term benefits such as reducing hospitalizations and associated costs, while fewer studies have examined long-term benefits such as QALYs or life-years gained. The payer and society have been the most common perspectives used. The endpoints examined varied and generally did not account for the potential impact of RSV prophylaxis on RSV-related complications such as asthma. While some studies have reported acceptable cost-effectiveness ratios for RSV prophylaxis, the majority failed to show cost savings or cost-effectiveness ratios below commonly accepted thresholds for either RSV-IGIV or palivizumab. Cost effectiveness of RSV prophylaxis tended to be more favourable in populations with specific risk factors, including premature infants < or =32 weeks' gestational age, and infants or children aged < 2 years with chronic lung disease or congenital heart disease. Comparing the results of economic analyses of the two agents suggests palivizumab may be the more cost-effective option in the population for which RSV prophylaxis is recommended. Over time, the acquisition cost of RSV prophylaxis agents, a major cost driver, may decrease, and more acceptable outcomes of economic analyses may result. Albeit important, the results of economic analyses are not the only tool that decision makers rely on, as population-specific risk factors, and efficacy and safety data must be considered when developing treatment guidelines and making clinical decisions.

Hospital pharmacists' role in the prevention and management of respiratory syncytial virus

PURPOSE

The role pharmacists play in managing respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is discussed.

SUMMARY

RSV can be a life-threatening disease in certain high-risk populations. Pharmacists can play an important role in partnering with other health care providers to reduce RSV-associated morbidity and mortality by identifying children who are at high risk for the disease, determining the most appropriate therapy for managing RSV, and identifying those who are candidates for immunoprophylaxis.

CONCLUSION

Pharmacists need to be involved in the selection, initiation, modification, and monitoring of a patient's RSV drug therapy and should also help implement institutional protocols for the management and prevention of RSV.

Variation in timing of respiratory syncytial virus outbreaks: lessons from national surveillance

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the leading cause of pneumonia and bronchiolitis in infants and children. Immune prophylaxis can reduce the risk of severe RSV disease among some high-risk infants. A summary and update of analyses using National Respiratory and Enteric Virus Surveillance System (NREVSS) data is provided to explore using surveillance data to better define the timing of RSV activity and RSV immune prophylaxis. The methodology used was that outlined in a study by Mullins et al (Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2003;22:857-862), which analyzed weekly antigen detection data reported by laboratories to NREVSS. Data reported to NREVSS between 1990 and 2006 were used to assess seasonality among regional, state, and local areas. Season onset, offset, and duration were calculated for each year and each laboratory, and compared with the U.S. Census region and national median measurements. Results demonstrated a distinct winter peak of RSV activity each year. The extent of variation in the timing of RSV activity in a community from year to year makes it difficult to predict the timing of RSV outbreaks. In addition, the onset timing can vary between communities, even those in close proximity, during the same year. There are, however, regional community patterns that may help guide timing of immune prophylaxis. For example, the South region exhibited an earlier median season onset and longer duration than the other regions, with median onset week 47 and duration 16 weeks. In contrast, the Midwest exhibited a significantly later median onset and shorter duration than the other regions, with median onset week 1 of the following year and duration 13 weeks. Therefore, analyses of NREVSS data show that using surveillance data to tailor the timing of immune prophylaxis precisely will be difficult. Surveillance data can, however, be used to determine how well national patterns represent local patterns. Further analyses are needed to determine how local surveillance data can be used to guide timing of immune prophylaxis.

Palivizumab prophylaxis to prevent respiratory syncytial virus mortality after pediatric bone marrow transplantation: a decision analysis model

OBJECTIVE

Palivizumab, a monoclonal antibody against respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), has been demonstrated to be safe and effective in young children, but evidence is lacking as to whether palivizumab is effective in preventing RSV-induced morbidity and mortality in children who are immunosuppressed after bone marrow transplantation (BMT). As a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial is lacking, we chose to examine this issue with the use of decision analysis methodology.

METHODS

A decision tree was designed to determine mortality from RSV-related lung disease in children who received palivizumab after BMT. Probabilities were derived by meta-analysis methodology on the basis of the available literature. Sensitivity analyses were performed across a broad range of biologically plausible probabilities to judge the robustness of the results of the model.

RESULTS

The model revealed that there is a 10% increase in survival in BMT patients who receive palivizumab. The absolute survival rate increased from 83% to 92%. A practitioner would need to treat 12 children to save 1 post-BMT child from dying from RSV-related lung disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Decision analysis modeling demonstrates a decrease in mortality in pediatric BMT patients with the addition of palivizumab to protect against RSV-related lung disease. A well-designed, randomized controlled trial is necessary.

Reliability of medicaid claims versus medical record data: in a cost analysis of palivizumab

BACKGROUND

Palivizumab is one of the most costly paediatric medications for Medicaid and other health plans. It is uncertain whether the costs of palivizumab administration are justified in specific risk groups. Ongoing investigations of palivizumab require identification of reliable data sources.

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the reliability between Medicaid paid claims data and medical records documentation in a cost analysis of palivizumab.

STUDY DESIGN

A cross-sectional study of data reliability was performed within a cost analysis study of palivizumab in a cohort of at-risk patients during the US 2002/3 respiratory syncytial virus season. Exposure classification (to palivizumab prophylaxis) was compared using Medicaid claims and medical records data.

METHODS

The study was performed in 28 widely dispersed paediatric medical practices serving North Carolina, USA Medicaid patients within the AccessCare/Community Care of North Carolina (CCNC) Program, an enhanced primary care case management programme. Patients were eligible if they were born between 1 March 2002 and 28 February 2003 at 32-35 weeks estimated gestational age, were enrolled in the North Carolina primary care case management Medicaid programme during the study period and were patients of the participating practices. Medicaid healthcare claims were obtained in December 2003 for services provided between October 2002 and May 2003. Medical records were abstracted by community-based case managers. Primary variables included frequency, dates and dose of palivizumab injections. The main outcomes measures were agreement in the number of palivizumab injections, dates of administration and doses of palivizumab between Medicaid paid claims and medical record data.

RESULTS

Injection frequencies matched between medical record and Medicaid claims data for only 46.2% of study participants. Congruence in injection service dates occurred between data sources for only 1% of injections. Doses were similar between data sources for 81.9% of injections.

CONCLUSIONS

In Medicaid recipients receiving palivizumab injection, Medicaid claims data were inconsistent with medical records data. Use of multiple data sources and validation are recommended to identify temporal relationships between drug administration and endpoints of interest.

Beyond randomized controlled trials: a "real life" experience of respiratory syncytial virus infection prevention in infancy with and without palivizumab

A population-based study of the impact of palivizumab on confirmed Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) hospitalizations over a 7-year period within and between two similar health regions . Clinicians in Calgary implemented palivizumab prophylaxis for high-risk infants during the last four RSV seasons; clinicians in Edmonton did not. The two cities are part of a unified health care system and similar sociodemographics. Infants <36 weeks (wk) of gestational age (GA) were identified. RSV prophylaxis data and RSV-hospitalizations for high-risk infants eligible for prophylaxis were reviewed, as well as that of moderate-risk infants (33-35 weeks GA) for whom RSV prophylaxis was not given a high priority in the recommendations published by the Canadian Paediatric Society (CPS). Prevalence of RSV hospitalization before and after palivizumab was determined (1995-1998 and 1999-2002, respectively). There were 411 high-risk infants eligible for palivizumab prior to its provision (Pre) and 496 during the prophylaxis program (Post) in Calgary. There were 401 Pre and 425 Post in Edmonton, where no such prophylaxis program was implemented. In Calgary where palivizumab was offered (Post), RSV hospitalization was significantly reduced: 7.3% Pre versus 3.0% Post (OR, 2.53, 95% CI, 1.34, 4.76). No reduction was observed in Edmonton where palivizumab was not offered: 5.0% Pre versus 7.1% Post (OR, 1.45, 95% CI, 0.81, 2.59; P = 0.212). RSV hospitalizations did not change for moderate-risk infants not receiving palivizumab in Calgary (OR, 1.26, 95% CI, 0.75, 2.12; P = 0.389). An RSV prevention program with palivizumab for high-risk infants reduced RSV hospitalizations, providing "real life" evidence of the benefits of this prophylaxis strategy. Further research is required to determine if specific sub-sets of moderate-risk infants would also benefit from an RSV prophylaxis program with palivizumab.

Administration of the first dose of palivizumab immunoprophylaxis against respiratory syncytial virus in infants before hospital discharge: what is the evidence for its benefit?

BACKGROUND

Palivizumab is 1 of 2 agents used to prevent severe lower respiratory tract disease due to respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infection. The American Academy of Pediatrics and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists recommend administering the first dose of RSV immunoprophylaxis to eligible infants before hospital discharge. Unfortunately, third-party payers frequently do not separately reimburse administration of this therapy to hospitalized infants.

OBJECTIVE

Because palivizumab is commonly used to provide RSV immunoprophylaxis, we systematically reviewed all published data on this drug to determine whether the evidence supports the recommendation of administering the first dose before hospital discharge.

METHODS

MEDLINE was searched for all articles published in English from January 1, 1996, to October 31, 2003, using the search terms palivizumab and Synagis, and the following data were extracted onto a standardized form: author(s), year of publication, study design, patient population, sample size, criteria used for administration of RSV prophylaxis, location of palivizumab prophylaxis (inpatient or outpatient), parental satisfaction with administration of prophylaxis, incidence of RSV infection, and hospitalization rates for RSV. All selected publications were reviewed to determine whether they reported differences in the incidence of RSV infection or hospitalization in patients who received palivizumab before discharge compared with those who received it after discharge. Only those publications that specifically documented administration of the first dose of palivizumab before hospital discharge were included in the final analysis.

RESULTS

Six of the 166 studies reviewed met the selection criteria. Although all 6 studies reported reduced RSV hospitalization rates with palivizumab prophylaxis, no study directly compared inpatient and outpatient administration with regard to parental satisfaction or rates of RSV infection or hospitalization. Furthermore, based on the data in these studies, it was not possible to detect any differences in parental satisfaction or rates of RSV infection or hospitalization between the 2 locations of administration.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on our literature review, there is no evidence to support the recommendation that palivizumab be administered before hospital discharge in every infant who meets the criteria for RSV immunoprophylaxis. Eligible infants may be given the initial dose of RSV prophylaxis as outpatients, reducing the cost to institutions that currently provide palivizumab before hospital discharge.

Economic analysis of palivizumab in infants with congenital heart disease

OBJECTIVE

Palivizumab has been shown to reduce the number of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV)-related hospitalizations by 45% in children with congenital heart disease (CHD). The American Academy of Pediatrics has recommended that infants with hemodynamically significant CHD be considered for palivizumab. However, the economic implications of palivizumab prophylaxis in the CHD population have not been evaluated. In the present study, we sought to examine the cost savings and cost utility of RSV prophylaxis with palivizumab in children with CHD.

METHODS

Probabilities of hospitalization and efficacy of prophylaxis were based on published results. Costs of hospitalization were derived from a published analysis of bronchiolitis hospitalization costs from a consortium of children's hospitals. A hypothetical cohort of 10,000 CHD patients (half of whom would receive palivizumab) was created to calculate cost-savings and cost-utility. To assess cost utility, we assumed that by reducing hospitalization, palivizumab would reduce RSV-related hospital mortality, generally reported to be 3% in CHD patients. Sensitivity analysis was performed.

RESULTS

On the basis of a protocol of 5 monthly doses of palivizumab, the cost of prophylaxis for 1 RSV season was calculated as 6160 dollars per patient. After accounting for impact on direct and indirect costs of hospitalization, administration of palivizumab to 5000 CHD patients would result in a net loss of 20,415,753 dollars. If one assumes that palivizumab confers a survival benefit, then the cost of life-year saved is 100,338 dollars and cost of quality-adjusted life-year saved is 114,337 dollars.

CONCLUSIONS

The cost of palivizumab prophylaxis was high relative to benefits realized. Given the large number of CHD patients who might be considered candidates for RSV prophylaxis (>6000 patients per year in United States) routine use of palivizumab in young children with hemodynamically significant CHD needs to be evaluated further.

Anticipated costs of hospitalization for respiratory syncytial virus infection in young children at risk

BACKGROUND

Reliable estimates of hospitalization costs for severe respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infection are necessary to perform economic analyses of preventive strategies of severe RSV disease. We aimed to develop a model that predicts anticipated mean RSV hospitalization costs of groups of young children at risk for hospitalization, but not yet hospitalized, based on readily available child characteristics.

METHODS

We determined real direct medical costs of RSV hospitalization from a societal perspective, using a bottom-up strategy, in 3458 infants and young children hospitalized for severe RSV disease during the RSV seasons 1996-1997 to 1999-2000 in the Southwest of the Netherlands. We used a linear regression model to predict anticipated mean RSV hospitalization costs of groups of children at risk, based on 4 child characteristics [age, gestational age, birth weight and bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD)], expressed in EC Euros as of the year 2000.

FINDINGS

The mean RSV hospitalization costs of all patients were 3110 Euros. RSV hospitalization costs were higher for patients with lower gestational age (5555 Euros; gestational age, </=28 weeks), lower birth weight (3895 Euros; birth weight </=2500 g), BPD (5785 Euros; with BPD) and young age (4730 Euros; first month of life). The linear regression model had an adjusted R of 0.08. This indicates a low explanatory ability for hospitalization costs of individual children. However, the model could accurately estimate the anticipated mean hospitalization costs of groups of children with the same characteristics.

INTERPRETATION

RSV hospitalization costs were substantial, especially of specific high risk groups. Anticipated mean hospitalization costs of groups of children at risk for RSV hospitalization, but not yet hospitalized, could well be estimated with 4 child characteristics (age, gestational age, birth weight and BPD). These estimated costs can be used for economic analyses of preventive strategies for severe RSV disease.

Substantial variability in community respiratory syncytial virus season timing

BACKGROUND

Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the major cause of bronchiolitis and pneumonia in young children. Prevention of RSV disease in children in certain high risk groups through use of immunoglobulin preparations has been recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics since 1998. A more precise understanding of the timing of annual RSV epidemics should assist providers in maximizing the benefit of these preventive therapies. The objective of this study was to determine whether current national RSV surveillance data could be used to define the timing of seasonal outbreaks

METHODS

Weekly RSV testing data from the National Respiratory and Enteric Viruses Surveillance System for the period July 1990 through June 2000 were analyzed. RSV season onset week, peak week and duration were calculated for the entire United States, Census regions and select local laboratories. Season variability was estimated by comparing calculations for individual RSV seasons to median measurements for the entire surveillance period

RESULTS

RSV seasons in the South region began significantly earlier (P < 0.05) and lasted longer (P < 0.05) than seasons for the rest of the nation. RSV seasons in the Midwest region began significantly later (P < 0.01) and were shorter (P < 0.05) than those for the rest of the nation. Local RSV seasons varied substantially by year and by laboratory. The variability between laboratories generally increased with distance between laboratories

CONCLUSIONS

Onset weeks and durations of RSV seasons vary substantially by year and location. Local RSV data are needed to accurately define the onset and offset of RSV seasons and to refine timing of passive immune prophylaxis therapy recommendations.

Current strategies in the prevention of respiratory syncytial virus disease

Infants infected with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) develop both upper and lower respiratory tract infections resulting in laryngotracheobronchitis, bronchiolitis and pneumonia. Premature infants of less than 32 weeks' gestation and those with underlying chronic lung disease are particularly susceptible and incur significant morbidity and mortality following hospitalisation. Conservative RSV prevention strategies focus on the interruption of transmission by proper hand-washing techniques and reducing exposure to potential environmental risk factors. Major challenges have impeded the development of an RSV vaccine but a licensed product may be expected in the near future. Prophylaxis with a humanised mouse monoclonal antibody (palivizumab) has been effective in reducing the rate of RSV hospitalisation in high-risk premature infants in phase II-IV trials and is available for use within internationally approved guidelines. Experimental studies evaluating the use of palivizumab in patients with congenital heart disease, those with cystic fibrosis and immunosuppressed bone marrow transplant recipients are well underway, the results of which are eagerly awaited.

Lower respiratory infections in children

Lower respiratory infections (LRIs) continue to threaten the health of children worldwide and are exacerbated by global environmental problems such as air pollution [1]. In the developing world where nutrition remains poor and access to healthcare is scarce, LRIs are the most common cause of illness and death in children. Outcomes of LRI illness are far better in developed countries, but the overall morbidity of LRI is still high and may exceed that of other age groups [2]. The environmental "health" of our planet remains an issue closely linked to the health of children--particularly in terms of LRI disease. It is also clear that further progress in preventing, diagnosing, and treating LRI disease will have a significant impact on the health of children. The recent literature details both progress and clinical dilemmas of LRI-related illnesses in children. Lower respiratory infection disease is considered to include the following entities: acute lower respiratory infections, pneumonia, atypical pneumonia, bronchitis, and bronchiolitis. This update will review current reports on the evaluation of children with LRIs, bacterial and viral LRIs, and sequelae of LRIs.