Stereotaxic biopsy of intrinsic lesions of the brain stem

Dr. Joan Venes: A Pioneer of Pediatric Neurosurgery

Dr. Joan Venes (1935-2010) is a well-respected pioneer of pediatric neurosurgery. She was the third board-certified female neurosurgeon in the United States and was the first female neurosurgery resident to be accepted by her residency program at Yale University. She was the recipient of numerous awards, including the prestigious Van Wagenen Fellowship, which sparked her interest in furthering research around pediatric intracranial pressure monitoring. Throughout her career, Dr. Venes was a prolific researcher, publishing extensively on pediatric shunts, procedural techniques, and the use of technology in pediatric neurosurgery. She was one of the founding members of the American Society of Pediatric Neurosurgeons and the first female chairman of the Pediatric Section of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons and Congress of Neurological Surgeons. In the latter half of her career, Dr. Venes developed a strong interest in health policy, becoming a Pew Fellow in Health Policy at the University of Michigan and, subsequently, a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Health Policy Fellow. Her leadership and mentorship laid the groundwork for an exponential increase of female neurosurgeons and her research continues to be impactful today.

Pediatric Brainstem Tumor Biopsy: Surgical Planning and Execution for Maximal Safety and Tissue Yield

Brainstem tumors account for 10-20% of pediatric brain tumors with a peak age of diagnosis between 7 and 9 years old and are often fatal. Historically, diagnosis of brainstem tumors has been largely based on imaging; however, recent studies have demonstrated the incongruities between preoperative MRI diagnosis and postoperative pathological findings highlighting the importance of brainstem biopsy for diagnostic accuracy. Stereotactic brainstem biopsy for pediatric brainstem tumors has been proven to be safe with a high diagnostic yield (96.1-97.4%) and relatively low morbidity and mortality. Successful pediatric brainstem tumor biopsy demands intricate knowledge of brainstem anatomy, cranial nerves and vasculature, and common pediatric brainstem tumors by the performing surgeon. Additionally, understanding of the surgical indications and techniques (e.g., frame-based versus frameless, robotic assistance, surgical approach, and targets selection) helps to ensure maximal safety and tissue yield. Pediatric brainstem biopsy permits histological conformation of brainstem lesions leading to accurate diagnosis and the potential for personalized treatment and future therapeutic research.

Frameless robot-assisted stereotactic biopsies for lesions of the brainstem-a series of 103 consecutive biopsies

PURPOSE

Targeted treatment for brainstem lesions requires above all a precise histopathological and molecular diagnosis. In the current technological era, robot-assisted stereotactic biopsies represent an accurate and safe procedure for tissue diagnosis. We present our center's experience in frameless robot-assisted biopsies for brainstem lesions.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of all patients benefitting from a frameless robot-guided stereotactic biopsy at our University Hospital, from 2001 to 2017. Patients consented to the use of data and/or images. The NeuroMate® robot (Renishaw™, UK) was used. We report on lesion location, trajectory strategy, histopathological diagnosis and procedure safety.

RESULTS

Our series encompasses 96 patients (103 biopsies) treated during a 17 years period. Mean age at biopsy: 34.0 years (range 1-78). Most common location: pons (62.1%). Transcerebellar approach: 61 procedures (59.2%). Most common diagnoses: diffuse glioma (67.0%), metastases (7.8%) and lymphoma (6.8%). Non conclusive diagnosis: 10 cases (9.7%). After second biopsy this decreased to 4 cases (4.1%). Overall biopsy diagnostic yield: 95.8%. Permanent disability was recorded in 3 patients (2.9%, all adults), while transient complications in 17 patients (17.7%). Four cases of intra-tumoral hematoma were recorded (one case with rapid decline and fatal issue). Adjuvant targeted treatment was performed in 72.9% of patients. Mean follow-up (in the Neurosurgery Department): 2.2 years.

CONCLUSION

Frameless robot-assisted stereotactic biopsies can provide the initial platform towards a safe and accurate management for brainstem lesions, offering a high diagnostic yield with low permanent morbidity.

Stereotactic Biopsy for Brainstem Lesions: A Meta-analysis with Noncomparative Binary Data

Objectives

To evaluate the diagnostic yield and safety of brainstem stereotactic biopsy for brainstem lesions.

Methods

We performed a meta-analysis of English articles retrieved from the PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, and APA psycInfo databases up to May 12, 2021. A binary fixed-effect model, the inverse variance method, or a binary random-effect model, the Dersimonian Laird method, were utilized for pooling the data. This meta-analysis was registered with INPLASY, INPLASY202190034.

Findings

A total of 41 eligible studies with 2792 participants were included. The weighted average diagnostic yield was 97.0% (95% confidential interval [CI], 96.0-97.9%). The weighted average proportions of temporary complications, permanent deficits, and deaths were 6.2% (95% CI, 4.5–7.9%), .5% (95% CI, .2–.8%), and .3% (95% CI, .1–.5%), respectively. The subgroup analysis indicated a nearly identical weighted average diagnostic yield between MRI-guided stereotactic biopsy and CT-guided stereotactic biopsy (95.9% vs 95.8%) but slightly increased proportions of temporary complications (7.9% vs 6.0%), permanent deficits (1.9% vs .2%), and deaths (1.1% vs .4%) in the former compared to the latter. Moreover, a greater weighted average diagnostic yield (99.2% vs 97.6%) and lower proportions of temporary complications (5.1% vs 6.8%) and deaths (.7% vs 1.5%) were shown in the pediatric patient population than in the adult patient population.

Conclusions

Brainstem stereotactic biopsy demonstrates striking accuracy plus satisfying safety in the diagnosis of brainstem lesions. The diagnostic yield, morbidity, and mortality mildly vary based on the diversity of assistant techniques and subject populations.

Stereotactic biopsy for adult brainstem lesions: A surgical approach and its diagnostic value according to the 2016 World Health Organization Classification

BACKGROUND

The brainstem has the critical role of regulating cardiac and respiratory function and it also provides motor and sensory function to the face via the cranial nerves. Despite the observation of a brainstem lesion in a radiological examination, it is difficult to obtain tissues for a pathological diagnosis because of the location and small volume of the brainstem. Thus, we aimed to share our 6-year experience with stereotactic biopsies from brainstem lesions and confirm the value and safety of stereotactic biopsy on this highly eloquent area in this study.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 42 adult patients who underwent stereotactic biopsy on brainstem lesions from 2015 to 2020. The radiological findings, surgical records, pathological diagnosis, and postoperative complications of all patients were analyzed.

RESULTS

Histopathological diagnoses were made in 40 (95.2%) patients. Astrocytic tumors were diagnosed in 29 (69.0%) patients, diffuse large B cell lymphoma in 5 (11.9%) patients, demyelinating disease in 4 (9.5%) patients, germinoma in 1 (2.4%) patient, and radiation necrosis in 1 (2.4%) patient. In the 40 patients with successful stereotactic biopsy, 10 (25.0%) patients had inconsistent preoperative radiological diagnosis and postoperative pathological diagnosis. In addition, there was a difference between the treatments prescribed by the radiological and pathological diagnoses in 8 out of 10 patients whose diagnoses changed after biopsy. There was no operative mortality among the 42 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

A pathological diagnosis can be made safely and efficiently in brainstem lesions using stereotactic biopsy. This pathological diagnosis will enable patients to receive appropriate treatment.

How to avoid pneumocephalus in deep brain stimulation surgery? Analysis of potential risk factors in a series of 100 consecutive patients

BACKGROUND

Accuracy of lead placement is the key to success in deep brain stimulation (DBS). Precise anatomic stereotactic planning usually is based on stable perioperative anatomy. Pneumocephalus due to intraoperative CSF loss is a common procedure-related phenomenon which could lead to brain shift and targeting inaccuracy. The aim of this study was to evaluate potential risk factors of pneumocephalus in DBS surgery.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective single-center analysis in patients undergoing bilateral DBS. We quantified the amount of pneumocephalus by postoperative CT scans and corrected the data for accompanying brain atrophy by an MRI-based score. Automated computerized segmentation algorithms from a dedicated software were used. As potential risk factors, we evaluated the impact of trephination size, the number of electrode tracks, length of surgery, intraoperative blood pressure, and brain atrophy.

RESULTS

We included 100 consecutive patients that underwent awake DBS with intraoperative neurophysiological testing. Systolic and mean arterial blood pressure showed a substantial impact with an inverse correlation, indicating that lower blood pressure is associated with higher volume of pneumocephalus. Furthermore, the length of surgery was clearly correlated to pneumocephalus.

CONCLUSION

Our analysis identifies intraoperative systolic and mean arterial blood pressure as important risk factors for pneumocephalus in awake stereotactic surgery.

Stereotactic brain biopsy: evaluation of robot-assisted procedure in 60 patients

BACKGROUND

Frameless stereotactic biopsies, particularly robot-assisted procedures are increasing in neurosurgery centers. Results of these procedures should be at least equal to or greater than frame-based reference procedure. Evaluate robot-assisted technology is necessary in particular, when a team has chosen to switch from one to another method.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our prospective work was (i) to evaluate the success rate of contributive robotic-assisted biopsy in 60 patients, to report the morbidity and mortality associated with the procedure and (ii) to compare it with literature data.

METHODS

We performed a prospective and descriptive study including 60 consecutive patients having had robotic-assisted stereotactic biopsy at the Rouen University Hospital, France. All patients had presurgical imaging before the procedure included Magnetic Resonance Imaging merged with Computed Tomography scan acquisition. Registration was mostly performed with a touch-free laser (57/60). A control Computed Tomography scan was always realized at day 0 or day 1 after surgery. Data collected were success rate, bleeding, clinical worsening, infection, and mortality.

RESULTS

All the biopsies were considered as contributive and lead to the final diagnosis. In 41/60 patients (68%), the lesion was glial. Six in 60 patients (10%) had visible bleeding without clinical worsening related, 5/60 patients (8.5%) showed clinical impairment following surgery, which was permanent in 2 patients, and 1/60 patient presented generalized seizures. We did not report any infection and mortality.

CONCLUSION

Robot-assisted frameless surgery is efficient and provides a reasonable alternative to frame-based procedure. The operating time can be reduced, without increasing morbidity and mortality rates.

Update on the diagnostic value and safety of stereotactic biopsy for pediatric brainstem tumors: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 735 cases

OBJECTIVE Recent studies have shed light on the molecular makeup of diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas and led to the identification of potential treatment targets for these lesions, which account for the majority of pediatric brainstem tumors (pedBSTs). Therefore, stereotactic biopsy-driven molecular characterization of pedBSTs may become an important prerequisite for the management of these fatal brain tumors. The authors conducted a systemic review and meta-analysis to precisely determine the safety and diagnostic success of stereotactic biopsy of pedBSTs. METHODS A systematic search of PubMed, EMBASE, and the Web of Science yielded 944 potentially eligible abstracts. Meta-analysis was conducted on 18 studies (including the authors' own institutional series), describing a total of 735 biopsy procedures for pedBSTs. The primary outcome measures were diagnostic success and procedure-related complications. Pooled estimates were calculated based on the Freeman-Tukey double-arcsine transformation and DerSimonian-Laird random-effects model. Heterogeneity, sensitivity, and meta-regression analyses were also conducted. RESULTS The weighted average proportions across the analyzed studies were 96.1% (95% CI 93.5%-98.1%) for diagnostic success, 6.7% (95% CI 4.2%-9.6%) for overall morbidity, 0.6% (95% CI 0.2%-1.4%) for permanent morbidity, and 0.6% (95% CI 0.2%-1.3%) for mortality. Subgroup analyses at the study level identified no significant correlation between the outcome measures and the distribution of the chosen biopsy trajectories (transfrontal vs transcerebellar), age, year of publication, or the number of biopsy procedures annually performed in each center. CONCLUSION Stereotactic biopsy of pedBSTs is safe and allows successful tissue sampling as a prerequisite for the molecular characterization and the identification of potentially druggable targets toward more individualized treatment concepts to improve the outcome for children harboring such lesions.

Diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas: treatments and controversies

Diffuse intrinsic pontine gliomas (DIPGs) are a fairly common pediatric brain tumor, and children with these tumors have a dismal prognosis. They generally are diagnosed within the first decade of life, and due to their location within the pons, these tumors are not surgically resectable. The median survival for children with DIPGs is less than 1 year, in spite of decades of clinical trial development of unique approaches to radiation therapy and chemotherapy. Novel therapies are under investigation for these deadly tumors. As clinicians and researchers make a concerted effort to obtain tumor tissue, the molecular signals of these tumors are being investigated in an attempt to uncover targetable therapies for DIPGs. In addition, direct application of chemotherapies into the tumor (convection-enhanced delivery) is being investigated as a novel delivery system for treatment of DIPGs. Overall, DIPGs require creative thinking and a disciplined approach for development of a therapy that can improve the prognosis for these unfortunate children.

Validation of a magnetic resonance imaging guided stereotactic access to the ovine brainstem

Background

Anatomical differences between humans and domestic mammals preclude the use of reported stereotactic approaches to the brainstem in animals. In animals, brainstem biopsies are required both for histopathological diagnosis of neurological disorders and for research purposes. Sheep are used as a translational model for various types of brain disease and therefore a species-specific approach needs to be developed. The aim of the present study was to establish a minimally invasive, accurate and reproducible stereotactic approach to the brainstem of sheep, using the magnetic resonance imaging guided Brainsight^TM frameless stereotactic system.

Results

A transoccipital transcerebellar approach with an entry point in the occipital bone above the vermis between the transverse sinus and the external occipital protuberance was chosen. This approach provided access to the target site in all heads. The overall mean needle placement error was 1.85 ± 1.22 mm.

Conclusions

The developed transoccipital transcerebellar route is short, provides accurate access to the ovine caudal cranial fossa and is a promising approach to be further assessed in live animals.

Diagnostic value and safety of stereotactic biopsy for brainstem tumors: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 1480 cases

BACKGROUND

The feasibility and safety of stereotactic biopsy for brainstem tumors (BSTs) are controversial. Although magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been reported as the preferred diagnostic tool, histopathological analysis is frequently necessary to establish a definitive diagnosis. Recent advances in molecular characterization of brainstem gliomas-accounting for the majority of BSTs-have revealed several potential targets for molecular-based therapies. Hence, a molecular stereotactic biopsy that combines histopathological diagnosis with molecular-genetic analysis will become increasingly important for patients with BSTs.

OBJECTIVE

We conducted a systemic review and meta-analysis to determine the risks and benefits of stereotactic biopsy for BSTs.

METHODS

A systematic search in PubMed, Embase, and the Web of Science yielded 3766 potentially eligible abstracts. Meta-analysis was conducted on 38 studies describing 1480 biopsy procedures for BSTs. Primary outcome measures were diagnostic success and procedure-related complications. Data were analyzed according to standard meta-analytic techniques.

RESULTS

The weighted average proportions across the analyzed studies were: 96.2% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 94.5%-97.6%) for diagnostic success, 7.8% (95% CI: 5.6%-10.2%) for overall morbidity, 1.7% (95% CI: 0.9%-2.7%) for permanent morbidity, and 0.9% (95% CI: 0.5%-1.4%) for mortality. Meta-regression revealed a significant correlation between diagnostic success rates and the number of biopsy procedures performed annually in each center (P = .011). Other factors did not affect the outcome measures.

CONCLUSION

Stereotactic biopsy of BSTs is safe. It allows exact histopathological diagnosis as a prerequisite for adequate treatment and opens new perspectives for the molecular characterization of these tumors as a crucial first step toward more individualized treatment concepts.

ABBREVIATIONS

: BST, brainstem tumorCI, confidence intervalD-BSG, diffuse brainstem gliomaHGG, high-grade gliomaLGG, low-grade gliomasTC, transcerebellarTF, transfrontal.

Transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy for brainstem lesions in children

Brain stem lesions are pathologically heterogeneous. Pre-operative radiological diagnoses prove to be wrong in 10 to 20% of cases. It is therefore imperative to have a tissue diagnosis for appropriate therapeutic measures. We report a series of 24 patients (14 males, ten females, age range: 6-17 years) CT guided stereotactic biopsy for brain stem lesions approached via the suboccipital transcerebellar route in semi sitting position with principle used to violate only one pial plane with the biopsy probe not entering the ventral surface of the cerebellum. The inclusion and exclusion criteria with detailed material and method are discussed. Histological diagnosis was established in 23 patients (96%) with no procedure-related mortality. Our results indicate that stereotaxic approach to brain-stem lesions provides a high yield of positive histological diagnoses with a low incidence of morbidity. Awake CT-guided stereotactic biopsy via the suboccipital transcerebellar route in a semi-sitting position is a safe, reliable, and effective method for brainstem lesions that can obtain adequate tissue for histological diagnosis, thus providing each patient with the best available treatment.

Stereotactic biopsy with electrical monitoring for deep-seated brain tumors

OBJECTIVE

The stereotactic biopsy is widely integrated into clinical practice as an efficient and safe procedure for histologic diagnoses. However, the surgical risk increases when the lesions are close to the eloquence of the adjacent brain. The present report describes two patients with deep-seated brain tumors who underwent a stereotactic biopsy with electrical monitoring and demonstrates the importance of this technique.

METHODS

The tentative target and trajectory were determined on a stereotactic map from the Schaltenbrand and Wahren atlas. A Cosman-Roberts-Wells stereotactic frame was applied to the patient. Electrical recording along a single trajectory was used to identify the circumscribed neuronal structures, and electrical simulation was administered to the target. The biopsy point was decided when no adverse events were observed with a low electric current level.

RESULTS

A 34-year-old male patient with anaplastic astrocytoma in the putamen and thalamus and an 81-year-old female patient with malignant lymphoma in the midbrain underwent stereotactic biopsies with electrical monitoring. The biopsies were successfully performed without any resulting neurologic deficits.

CONCLUSIONS

This report describes two patients with deep-seated brain tumors who underwent stereotactic biopsies with electrical recording and stimulation. The electrical monitoring appears to be a useful technique to complement the ordinary image-guided biopsy.

Endoscopic Port Surgery for Resection of Lesions of the Cerebellar Peduncles: Technical Note

BACKGROUND:

Mass lesions of the inferior, middle, and superior cerebellar peduncles (cerebellar peduncle complex [CPC]) present numerous surgical pitfalls when resection or debulking is warranted. Success has been achieved through multiple approaches, but complications can be severe.

OBJECTIVE:

To report the surgical technique for and clinical results of the treatment of lesions in the CPC with an endoscopic port via a lateral transcerebellar corridor.

METHODS:

Three patients underwent resection of intrinsic lesions of the CPC via a lateral transcerebellar approach with an endoscopic port. Deployment of the port was performed with frameless image-guided placement into the area of interest. Resection was performed using bimanual microsurgical technique under parallel endoscopic visualization.

RESULTS:

Three patients 43, 27, and 13 years of age underwent successful resection of lesion in the CPC. Histopathological diagnosis consisted of cavernous malformation, glioblastoma multiforme, and a juvenile pilocytic astrocytoma. All had complete gross total resection except for the patient with a high-grade glioma. Clinically, all had excellent outcomes, with 1 patient suffering postoperative facial palsy after resection of her high-grade glioma.

CONCLUSION:

The lateral transcerebellar approach to the CPC with an endoscopic port may be a feasible alternative to standard microsurgical resection in such difficult cases. Careful patient selection is critical to identify those who may be suitable for endoscopic port surgery on the basis of clinical, radiographic, and anatomical considerations.

Precision of navigated stereotactic probe implantation into the brainstem

OBJECT

The indications for stereotactic biopsies or implantation of probes for local chemotherapy in diffuse brainstem tumors have recently come under debate. The quality of performing these procedures significantly depends on the precision of the probes' placement in the brainstem. The authors evaluated the precision of brainstem probe positioning using a navigated frameless stereotactic system in an experimental setting.

METHODS

Using the VarioGuide stereotactic system, 33 probes were placed into a specially designed model filled with agarose. In a second experimental series, 8 anatomical specimens were implanted with a total of 32 catheters into the pontine brainstem using either a suboccipital or a precoronal entry point. Before intervention in both experimental settings, a thin-sliced CT scan for planning was obtained and fused to volumetric T1-weighted MR imaging data. After the probe positioning procedures, another CT scan and an MR image were obtained to compare the course of the catheters versus the planned trajectory. The deviation between the planned and the actual locations was measured to evaluate the precision of the navigated intervention.

RESULTS

Using the VarioGuide system, mean total target deviations of 2.8 +/- 1.2 mm on CT scanning and 3.1 +/- 1.2 mm on MR imaging were detected with a mean catheter length of 151 +/- 6.1 mm in the agarose model. The catheter placement in the anatomical specimens revealed mean total deviations of 1.95 +/- 0.6 mm on CT scanning and 1.8 +/- 0.7 mm on MR imaging for the suboccipital approach and a mean catheter length of 59.5 +/- 4.1 mm. For the precoronal approach, deviations of 2.2 +/- 1.2 mm on CT scanning and 2.1 +/- 1.1 mm on MR imaging were measured (mean catheter length 85.9 +/- 4.7 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

The system-based deviation of frameless stereotaxy using the VarioGuide system reveals good probe placement in deep-seated locations such as the brainstem. Therefore, the authors believe that the system can be accurately used to conduct biopsies and place probes in patients with brainstem lesions.

Transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy for lesions of the brainstem and peduncles under local anesthesia

OBJECTIVE

For certain brainstem lesions, a diagnostic biopsy is required for treatment planning. We reviewed the indications, safety, and diagnostic effectiveness of a transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy using local anesthesia and sedation.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed hospital records for all adult patients with symptomatic lesions of the pons and/or cerebellar peduncle who underwent an awake transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy at our institution over a 7-year period. Our technique features several modifications from the standard method and was performed under local anesthesia with patients in the semi-sitting position.

RESULTS

Our rate of diagnostic success (92%) was comparable to those in other published reports. However, only 5 (42%) of 12 biopsy-derived diagnoses were consistent with those predicted from preoperative magnetic resonance imaging. There were no deaths, and the only neurological complication was a cranial nerve palsy. Diagnoses in the 13 cases included infiltrative glioma (), metastases (), lymphoma (), encephalitis (), and reactive astrogliosis ().

CONCLUSION

Tissue diagnosis of lesions in the brainstem and cerebellar peduncles continues to be a significant challenge, with the potential for major morbidity. With appropriate patient selection, however, awake transcerebellar biopsy is a safe and effective procedure that can change clinical management and provide important prognostic information.

Real-time image-guided direct convective perfusion of intrinsic brainstem lesions. Technical note

Recent preclinical studies have demonstrated that convection-enhanced delivery (CED) can be used to perfuse the brain and brainstem with therapeutic agents while simultaneously tracking their distribution using coinfusion of a surrogate magnetic resonance (MR) imaging tracer. The authors describe a technique for the successful clinical application of this drug delivery and monitoring paradigm to the brainstem. Two patients with progressive intrinsic brainstem lesions (one with Type 2 Gaucher disease and one with a diffuse pontine glioma) were treated with CED of putative therapeutic agents mixed with Gd-diethylenetriamene pentaacetic acid (DTPA). Both patients underwent frameless stereotactic placement of MR imaging-compatible outer guide-inner infusion cannulae. Using intraoperative MR imaging, accurate cannula placement was confirmed and real-time imaging during infusion clearly demonstrated progressive filling of the targeted region with the drug and Gd-DTPA infusate. Neither patient had clinical or imaging evidence of short- or long-term infusate-related toxicity. Using this technique, CED can be used to safely perfuse targeted regions of diseased brainstem with therapeutic agents. Coinfused imaging surrogate tracers can be used to monitor and control the distribution of therapeutic agents in vivo. Patients with a variety of intrinsic brainstem and other central nervous system disorders may benefit from a similar treatment paradigm.

Stereotactic biopsy of brain stem masses: decision analysis and literature review

BACKGROUND

Adult brain stem tumors are rare, and diverse pathology can be found in this location. Stereotactic biopsy of lesions in the brain stem has been performed since the 1960s with high diagnostic and low complication rates. Advances in imaging technology have raised questions regarding the utility of biopsy. We perform decision analysis to aid clinicians in their approach to management of adult brain stem lesions.

METHODS

A structured literature search revealed 20 publications with 457 patients who had undergone brain stem lesion biopsy. These publications were reviewed to determine diagnostic rates and the incidence of complications. Standard decision analytic techniques were applied to the case of a virtual adult patient with a lesion in the brain stem.

RESULTS

A 1-way sensitivity analysis revealed the likelihood that the preoperative diagnosis was correct and the rate at which incorrect treatment was based on faulty empirical diagnosis as the 2 factors with the greatest effects on patient outcome. The diagnostic rate and complication rate of biopsy, within the ranges reported in the literature, had lesser effects. A threshold analysis was constructed to compare outcomes from stereotactic biopsy vs empiric therapy for a brain stem lesion. The probability that the preoperative diagnosis is correct is plotted vs the probability that empirical treatment based on an incorrect diagnosis will have adverse effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Management of lesions in the adult brain stem requires careful consideration of multiple preoperative factors including clinical and radiographic diagnostic certainty, consequences of empiric therapy, and the surgeon's complication rate.

A contralateral, transfrontal, extraventricular approach to stereotactic brainstem biopsy procedures. Technical note

The authors report on the technique and results of stereotactic biopsy for intrinsic lateral pontine and medial cerebellar lesions via a contralateral, transfrontal, extraventricular approach. Multiplanar stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging was used to plan an intraparenchymal approach, thus limiting the number of crossed pial surfaces to one and eliminating the need to cross ependymal surfaces. After the administration of a local anesthetic agent with light intravenous sedation, six patients harboring intrinsic lateral pontine lesions underwent biopsies via this intraparenchymal approach with 100% diagnostic yield and no operative morbidity. In comparison to the ipsilateral transfrontal approach, the contralateral approach laterally expands the infratentorial area accessible during biopsy to include the lateral pons and middle cerebellar peduncle. The contralateral, transfrontal, extraventricular approach is a useful, straightforward and safe alternative to the suboccipital transcerebellar and ipsilateral, transfrontal, transtentorial routes for reaching lesions of the lateral pons and middle cerebellar peduncle.

Stereotactic biopsies of focal brainstem lesions

BACKGROUND

Stereotactic biopsies of the brainstem (SBB) are a selected group of stereotactic operations owing to the lower incidence of brainstem lesions requiring biopsy, the greater complexity, and the higher risks of these procedures. Usually, the lower the lesion in the brainstem, the greater the risks involved. The approach of the different target locations by distinct routes, transcerebral and transcerebellar, is still a matter of debate. Moreover, pure medullary lesions are seldom biopsied, whereas diffuse brainstem lesions, typical of children's brainstem gliomas and rather frequent in most published series, depend less and less on the histopathological confirmation for treatment. In this study, the authors present their own experience on SBB aiming to discuss mainly their indications, approach routes choice, and procedure techniques.

METHODS

The authors reviewed a series of 30 SBB (27 adults and 3 children) out of 450 stereotactic biopsies of the central nervous system performed for the last 10 years. All cases but one presented as focal brainstem masses, 19 mainly in the pons and 10 in the midbrain. Eleven lesions (10 in the midbrain and one midbrain-pontine) were approached by a transfrontal route. All the others were approached by a suboccipital transcerebellar route.

RESULTS

Twenty-six (87%) out of the 28 cases (93%) where a positive histopathological result was obtained had a specific diagnosis: 18 tumors (14 astrocytomas, 2 primary brain lymphomas, 1 oligodendroglioma, and 1 ganglioglioma), 2 toxoplasmosis, 2 sarcoidosis, 1 aspergillus abscess, 1 vasculitis, 1 acute inflammatory demyelinating disease, and 1 progressive multifocal leucoencephalopathy. Four nontumoral lesions arose in patients with AIDS. Morbidity was restricted to 2 cases consisting of transient cranial nerve deficits.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic biopsies are specially useful for the diagnosis of focal brainstem lesions. Midbrain and midline lesions should be approached through the cerebrum, whereas most of the pontine lesions through the cerebellum. Overall, this procedure should be performed with "functional-like" precision and require some technical refinements to reach maximal accuracy with minimal morbidity.

Stereotactically-guided biopsies of brainstem tumors

INTRODUCTION

More than 10 years ago, the goal of our work had been to obtain a tissue sample of infiltrating lesions of the brainstem that had been diagnosed using computerized axial tomography (CAT). At that time, biopsies were believed to be indispensable when starting treatment of tumors. With time our objectives changed. Biopsies remained necessary, since until 1 year before the writing of this article we had not had the benefits of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at our Hospital. We also decided that carrying out sound statistics, confirmed by biopsies, was in itself a good procedure, especially in a country in which, to date, no serial studies of brainstem tumors had been undertaken.

METHODS

We analyzed all of the patients diagnosed with posterior fossa tumors between March 1989 and March 2002 at the Hospital Infantil de México Federico Gómez (HIM). A preoperative TAC of the cranium was performed on every patient. Stereotactically-guided biopsies during tomography allowed precise control of penetration. Material obtained was sent to the Department of Pathology for analysis.

RESULTS

Fifty patients were diagnosed with infiltrating tumors of the brainstem: 30 cases of low-grade astrocytomas, 13 cases of high-grade astrocytomas, 2 cases of primitive neuroectodermic tumors, 2 cases of rhabdoid tumors, 1 case of ependymoma, and 2 patients had non-specified tumors. The most frequent symptoms and signs were ataxia and disturbances of the cranial nerves. There was no mortality caused by penetration, and follow-up studies of more than 5 years were carried out.

DISCUSSION

The results from our series were similar to those in the literature. In our case, follow-up studies were undertaken for longer periods. In the first section of our work, we suggest the need for stereotactic biopsies in order to arrive at a precise diagnosis in environments in which MRI may be unavailable.

CONCLUSION

At present, presumptive diagnosis of infiltrating brainstem lesions may be adequately undertaken with imaging methods, such as MRI. However, we believe that a stereotactically-guided biopsy provides an accurate method for diagnosing lesions of the brainstem. In our case, this procedure has been carried out entirely in the tomography room, without any complications of disease or mortality.

Stereotactic Transcerebellar Approach to Pontine Lesions through the Middle Cerebellar Peduncle

SUMMARY

A stereotactic approach to the pons through the middle cerebellar peduncle based on MR studies was used to biopsy 18 patients. The stereotactic coordinates and angles were defined with reference to three orthogonal planes (midsagittal, IVth ventricular floor and pontomedullary junction). The pathological diagnoses were in keeping with clinical outcome and comprised five highgrade astrocytomas, three low-grade astrocytomas, two glioblastomas multiforme, two oligodendrogliomas, two primitive neuroectodermic tumours, two lymphomas, one medulloblastoma, and one tuberculosis. This approach provides a high yield of positive histological diagnoses with little morbidity (transient neurological deficits in two cases) and thereby avoids inappropriate therapy.

A clinicopathologic reappraisal of brain stem tumor classification. Identification of pilocystic astrocytoma and fibrillary astrocytoma as distinct entities

BACKGROUND

Brain stem tumors in children have been classified pathologically as low grade or high grade gliomas and descriptively as diffuse gliomas, intrinsic gliomas, midbrain tumors, tectal gliomas, pencil gliomas, dorsal exophytic brain stem tumors, pontine gliomas, focal medullary tumors, cervicomedullary tumors, focal gliomas, or cystic gliomas.

METHODS

To search for a simplified and prognostic clinicopathologic scheme for brain stem tumors, the authors reviewed a consecutive cohort of patients younger than age 21 years with tumors diagnosed from 1980 through 1997. Pathology specimens and neuroimaging were classified by masked review. Statistical and survival analysis along with Cox proportional hazards regression was performed.

RESULTS

Seventy-six patients were identified, with initial diagnostic magnetic resonance imaging available for 51 and pathology specimens for 48 patients. Twenty cases were classified histologically as pilocytic astrocytoma (PA), 14 as fibrillary astrocytoma (FA), and 14 as other tumors or indeterminate pathology. For all tumors, characteristics significantly associated with a worse survival rate were: symptom duration less than 6 months before diagnosis (P = 0.004); abducens palsy at presentation (P < 0.0001); pontine location (P = 0.0002); and engulfment of the basilar artery (P = 0.006). Pilocytic astrocytoma was associated with location outside the ventral pons (P = 0.001) and dorsal exophytic growth (P = 0.013); Fibrillary astrocytoma was associated with symptoms less than 6 months (P = 0. 006), abducens palsy (P < 0.001), and engulfment of the basilar artery (P = 0.002). Pilocytic astrocytoma showed 5-year overall survival (OS) of 95% (standard error [SE], 5%) compared with FA 1-year OS of 23% (SE, 11%;P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Brain stem tumors can be succinctly and better biologically classified as diffusely infiltrative brain stem gliomas-generally FA located in the ventral pons that present with abducens palsy, often engulf the basilar artery, and carry a grim prognosis-and focal brain stem gliomas-frequently PA arising outside the ventral pons, often with dorsal exophytic growth, a long clinical prodrome, and outstanding prognosis for survival. Our findings emphasize the individuality of PA as a distinct clinicopathologic entity with an exceptional prognosis.

Computerized tomography-guided stereotactic surgery for brainstem masses: a risk-benefit analysis in 71 patients

The benefits of the use of computerized tomography (CT)-guided stereotactic surgical techniques for the management of intrinsic brainstem masses diagnosed from clinical evaluation and imaging studies were evaluated vis-à-vis the risks involved in 71 consecutive patients. Seventy-two procedures were performed. The masses were diffuse, involving two or three contiguous brainstem segments, in 60 patients and focal in 11 patients. On the CT scans, 25 patients had hypodense nonenhancing masses, two had isodense nonenhancing masses, 19 had ring-enhancing masses, and 25 had heterogeneously enhancing masses. A positive biopsy was obtained in 68 of 69 patients (98.5%) undergoing a biopsy procedure. In nine patients (12.6%) with suspected malignant masses a benign pathology was diagnosed (four tuberculomas, two epidermoid cysts, one pyogenic abscess, one epidermal cyst, and one case of encephalitis). Additionally, fluid from cystic masses could be aspirated in eight cases, providing benefit in six (four patients had benign lesions and two had neoplastic lesions). Thereby, a total of 13 patients (18.3%) were deemed to have benefited from the surgery (two patients were included in both categories). Patients with focal masses and ring-enhancing masses had the highest proportion of benign lesions (60% and 36.8%, respectively) and therefore derived the most benefit from histological verification. There was no procedure-related mortality. One patient (1.4%) suffered permanent morbidity and four others (5.6%) had transient worsening attributable to the procedure. The authors conclude that CT-guided stereotactic surgery of the brainstem is safe and reliable. Histological verification of all enhancing (especially ring-enhancing) and focal brainstem masses should be undertaken to identify patients with benign nonneoplastic lesions. Selected patients with diffuse hypodense nonenhancing masses with atypical clinical or imaging features may also benefit from stereotactic biopsy. Even in these patients the lack of enhancement on a contrast-enhanced magnetic resonance image, rather than the diffuse location of the tumor alone, should form the basis for diagnosing a malignant glioma. The main value of stereotactic surgery lies in the identification of benign masses in a significant proportion of patients with intrinsic brainstem masses and in providing a rapid and safe method for evacuation of the contents of cystic masses.

Results and expectations with image-integrated brainstem stereotactic biopsy

BACKGROUND

The histologic diagnosis of an intrinsic brainstem tumor remains problematic due to controversies in methods of biopsy. Despite the widespread use of biopsy techniques, stereotactic brain stem biopsy has received limited attention due to potential morbidity and limited sample size.

METHODS

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of brain stem stereotactic biopsy using a dedicated computed tomography (CT)-stereotactic operating room suite, we reviewed our outcomes in 40 consecutive patients over a 13-year interval. This study included patients with midbrain lesions (n = 20), pontine lesions (n = 18), and medullary lesions (n = 2). Midline lesions were approached via a coronal, transthalamic trajectory; lateral brain stem lesions usually were approached via a transcerebellar route.

RESULTS

A histologic diagnosis was achieved in 38 patients (95%). All patients had an immediate, intraoperative, postbiopsy CT scan to check for hemorrhage (none occurred). Morbidity was limited to one patient (2.5%) who developed a transient diplopia; there was no mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

Stereotactic biopsy for intrinsic brain stem lesions proved as safe and effective as biopsy in the supratentorial compartment. Using high-resolution stereotactic imaging, an appropriate intraparenchymal trajectory, limited sampling, and specific neuropathologic tests, stereotactic techniques within the brain stem were performed with low risk and high accuracy. Biopsy results facilitated specific management strategies for each patient.

Complications of CT-guided stereotactic biopsy of intra-axial brain lesions

A series of 300 consecutive stereotactic biopsies for intra-axial brain lesions performed by one neurosurgeon was critically analyzed regarding complications of the procedure. Complications were incurred by a total of 19 patients (6.3%). Five patients (1.7%) died following the procedure, all due to intracranial hypertension: one from subarachnoid hemorrhage, one from intracerebral hemorrhage, and three from increased edema without hemorrhage. The three patients who died without hemorrhage all had marked intracranial hypertension at the time of biopsy. All five patients who died harbored a glioblastoma multiforme. The surviving 14 patients (4.7%) with complications suffered increased neurological deficit due to hemorrhage. In 10 (3.3%), the deficit was mild and/or transient; in the other four (1.3%), a major deficit was incurred which markedly affected the remainder of the patient's life. Therefore, mortality or major morbidity was seen in 3.0% of patients and minor morbidity in 3.3%. Stereotactic biopsy is a very effective procedure with a complication rate significantly lower than that of craniotomy (particularly in the population of patients selected for stereotactic biopsy), but in a small number of patients the outcome is devastating.

Stereotactic biopsy for intrinsic lesions of the medulla through the long-axis of the brainstem: technical considerations

The authors report the technique and results for stereotactic biopsy of intrinsic lesions of the medulla oblongata through the long-axis of the brainstem. Multi-planar stereotactic magnetic resonance imaging and/or reformatted computed tomography imaging is used for coordinate determination and trajectory selection and facilitates a completely intra-axial pathway through critical neural tissue. Two patients with small, solitary, enhancing lesions of the medulla had stereotactic sampling via this approach performed under local anesthesia. There was no morbidity and in both the patients a histologic diagnosis of lymphoma was obtained. We believe that with high-resolution, multi-planar stereotactic imaging, small lesions in the medulla can safely be biopsied, avoiding the need for either posterior fossa craniectomy and open biopsy, or for empiric management.

Stereotactic radiosurgery of deeply seated low grade gliomas

The authors report the results of a series of 16 cases of low-grade gliomas in whom radiosurgery was performed. This series started in 1977. All the tumours received a single radiosurgical session (with a mean dose of 21.7 Gy, 5-10 mm. collimator; one patient received two sessions and in another patient two different targets were irradiated in the same session). Prior to radiosurgery, six patients received conventional external fractionated radiotherapy, with two lateral fields of up to 10 x 10 cm. and a mean dose of 55.1 Gy and another six patients with tumours less than 5 cm. in diameter, received stereotactic radiotherapy using four fields of up to 5 x 5 cm. and a mean dose of 53.1 Gy. In both cases, conventional fractionation was used, giving a dose of 1.8 to 2 Gy/day. The tumour disappeared in 8 cases (50%) and shunk or ceased its growth in 5 additional cases (31%). In 3 cases of brainstem gliomas in which the clinical condition was previously very poor there was no evolutional change and the patients eventually died. We conclude that radiosurgery is effective in the treatment of deeply seated low-grade gliomas, where it may become the treatment of choice in the absence of other more definitive choices.

Transcerebellar biopsy of posterior fossa lesions using the Leksell gamma model stereotactic frame

We describe a technical modification of the Leksell gamma stereotactic system that enables a direct transcerebellar biopsy of posterior fossa lesions. By using an additional pair of long (14 cm) posts placed in the posterior positions of the frame, the frame can be positioned low enough to allow for direct approaches to the posterior fossa. With the patient in the semisitting position, a biopsy can be performed under local anesthesia. We have found this technique provides a simple, comfortable, and effective biopsy of posterior fossa lesions.

Indications for stereotactically-aided differential diagnosis: the neurologist's view

The contribution of stereotactic biopsy (SB) in three pathological conditions; neoplastic disease, immunodeficiency states and degenerative cerebral atrophy, is reviewed. When craniotomy is contraindicated, SB is the most reliable method for demonstrating the neoplastic nature and the degree of malignancy of an intracranial space occupying lesion and may help to delineate it limits. In immunodepressed patients, SB is frequently used to differentiate tumours from opportunistic infections. In degenerative dementia, SB is susceptible of differentiating Alzheimer's disease from other degenerative conditions.

The role of image-directed biopsy in the diagnosis and management of brainstem lesions

The appreciation that brainstem tumours do not comprise a homogeneous pathological group and that up to 20% of the preoperative radiological diagnoses of brainstem lesions prove at operation to be wrong, has established the need for a firm histological diagnosis prior to treatment. Current neuro-imaging modalities may have increased the diagnostic accuracy and the detection rate of intrinsic brainstem lesions, but open exploration in cases without an exophytic component is still associated with a low diagnostic yield and considerable morbidity. A series of 72 brainstem lesions approached stereotactically with CT or MRI guidance is presented. A transcortical frontal precoronal trajectory was used in 58 and a suboccipital transcerebellar route in 14. Haematoma was diagnosed preoperatively in 16 cases and therapeutic aspiration was planned. In 56 cases the diagnosis was uncertain, although intrinsic tumour was suspected. A histological diagnosis was established in 52 cases, although in the remaining four cases a tumour was excluded. Unexpected findings occurred in over 15% of the cases. There were no operative deaths and the morbidity was low. In no case was there a permanent neurological deterioration directly related to the procedure, although there was a transient deterioration in two patients and another patient required early re-aspiration of a haematoma.

Image directed stereotactic surgery for brain stem lesions

Advances in neurological imaging may have increased the diagnostic accuracy and the detection rate of intrinsic brain stem lesions, but a histological diagnosis is still an essential requirement for rational and appropriate management. Open exploration allows biopsy and resection in cases where an exophytic component is present. The surgical inaccessibility and the resultant morbidity of these approaches, however, associated with a low diagnostic yield in cases with no visible surface abnormality, are important limiting factors. A series of 45 brain stem lesions stereotactically approached with CT or MRI guidance is presented. A transcortical frontal pre-coronal trajectory was used in all of them. Haematoma was preoperatively diagnosed in 10 cases and the procedure was for therapeutic aspiration. Of 35 cases where the diagnosis was uncertain, although intrinsic tumour was suspected, positive results were obtained in 33, while unexpected findings of granuloma, lymphoma, angioma, leucoencephalopathy, vasculitis and radiation necrosis were found in over 10% of the cases. There were no operative deaths and the morbidity was low. In no case was there a permanent neurological deterioration directly related to the procedure, although there was a transient deterioration in two patients and one patient required early reaspiration of a haematoma. Image directed stereotactic approaches to brain stem lesions can combine a high degree of accuracy (offering positive histological diagnoses) with a low operative morbidity. MRI directed biopsies can complement CT guided ones thus increasing the number of suitable cases and improving the success rate. The frontal precoronal transcortical trajectory provides safe access to the majority of the brain stem targets.

Stereotactic suboccipital transcerebellar biopsy under local anesthesia using the Cosman-Roberts-Wells frame. Technical note

Previously reported suboccipital transcerebellar stereotactic biopsy methods, performed with the patient in the prone position, have required general endotracheal anesthesia. A technique is described for performing such biopsies with the patient in the lateral decubitus position, under local anesthesia. Phantom planning and routine computerized tomography graphics allow the selection of a safe entry point and intra-axial trajectory to the lesion. The time required for data acquisition and the operative procedure itself compares well with that of more routine biopsy techniques.

Stereotactic anatomy of the posterior cranial fossa. A study of the transcerebellar approach to the brainstem

The stereotactic transcerebellar (suboccipital) approach to the brainstem is one of the most accessible routes to reach targets located in the pons or in the medulla oblongata. Its use requires a perfect knowledge of the stereotactic anatomy of the posterior cranial fossa, and a standard reference system related to structures of the brainstem itself which can easily be visualized by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance. The present work consists in a three-dimensional variability study of the human posterior cranial fossa with its main contents, based on the investigation of 30 normal specimens (hemifossae). A new stereotactic reference system is proposed for the pons and the medulla, comprising three orthogonal** planes: the midsagittal plane, the IVth ventricular floor plane and the pontomedullary junction plane. A standard "safety access tunnel" was defined for the transcerebellar approach to the pons and, with some limitations, to the medulla. A complementary investigation, based upon angiographic studies, was carried out to define a safe "entry zone" to the posterior cranial fossa of the occipital bone beneath the transverse venous sinus.

The stereotactic approach to brain stem lesions: a follow-up of 29 cases

Stereotactic biopsy is the safest and most reliable method for the histological diagnosis of intraaxial brain stem lesions. The definitive pathological diagnosis permits the selection of adequate therapy. No operative and/or adjuvant therapy must be proposed without a previous histological diagnosis. This approach avoids the complication of inappropriate therapy and provides valuable prognostic information.

Brain stem glioma: the role of a biopsy

A retrospective review of the clinical and histopathological features of 31 patients with brain stem gliomas treated between 1965 and 1990 at Kyushu University Hospital was performed to determine the role of biopsy on these lesions. These 16 male and 15 female patients ranged in age from 3 to 50 years at diagnosis (average: 18.1 years). The primary site of the tumour was the pons in 20 patients, followed by the medulla oblongata and midbrain, and the final histological diagnoses of the lesions based on either the biopsy or autopsy materials were grade I astrocytomas in five patients, grade II in nine, grade III in 10, grade IV in five, and ependymoma in two patients. No consistent correlation could be obtained between the CT findings and histological diagnoses. Open surgical posterior fossa exploration was performed on 17 patients (diagnostic biopsy: 10; volume reduction by tumour removal with or without cyst evacuation: 7) and stereotaxic biopsy on three patients, without any mortality related to these procedures. In our biopsy series, half of the patients with grade II astrocytoma died within 12 months after diagnosis, whereas three out of four patients with grade I astrocytoma survived more than 10 years after diagnosis. Because of the relative safety of the tissue sampling technique, and the importance of an accurate diagnosis in order to select appropriate treatment modalities, histological verification of the lesion should be considered for all patients harbouring a brain stem mass lesion.

Direct surgery for brainstem tumours

Updating a previous report, the authors offer a review of 45 patients between age 2 and 63 treated by direct surgical excision for brainstem tumours of various description. Since 1986 all candidate patients were examined by NMR imaging in addition to CT scanning, sometimes with the further addition of digital-subtraction vertebral angiography. By Epstein and McLeary's criteria, 24 of the tumours were focal, 12 were cervicomedullary and 9 were diffuse. The most frequent histological diagnosis was glioma (36 cases between low-grade astrocytoma, anaplastic astrocytoma and glioblastoma); the balance was provided by cavernoma (6 cases), haemangioblastoma (2 cases), and lipoma (2 cases). Gross total resection was achieved in 28 patients, namely all those with ependymoma or vascular tumours and 14 of 17 with low-grade astrocytoma. Resection was subtotal in 16 cases and confined to a generous biopsy in one. There was no operative mortality, but 2 deaths occurred in the early postoperative period. At discharge, neurological status was unchanged or improved in 35 cases. At 3-month follow-up examination, 12 patients were improved, 27 were unchanged and 3 were worsened. By January 1990 (6 to 72 months postoperatively) 27 of the first 40 patients treated were alive: 13 had resumed normal life, 6 were self-sufficient and 8 were disabled. The authors conclude that present-day microsurgical resection of intra-axial brainstem tumours is associated with low mortality and morbidity and affords favourable results for which they credit high-quality NMR imaging, efficient microsurgery, adequate anesthesia, and competent postoperative intensive care.

Stereotaxic biopsy of brain-stem tumours in children

Stereotaxic biopsies were performed in a series of 14 patients with clinical and computed tomographic evidence of a brain-stem lesion. Seven of these cases were in the paediatric age group (under 15 years of age). Biopsies were obtained by means of the Leksell stereotaxic system, through the transcerebellar (three cases) or transfrontal route (four cases). A definite tumour diagnosis could be obtained in all cases. No patients were subjected to open biopsy, as the further management of their tumours did not warrant surgery. One patient developed transient oculomotor nerve palsy. There was no mortality related to the biopsy procedure in this series. The biopsy technique and its utility and safety are discussed.