The Proton in Biochemistry: Impacts on Bioenergetics, Biophysical Chemistry, and Bioorganic Chemistry

Redox-Activated Proton Transfer through a Redundant Network in the Qo Site of Cytochrome bc1

Proton translocation catalyzed by cytochrome bc1 (respiratory complex III) during coenzyme-Q redox cycling is a critical bioenergetic process, yet its detailed molecular mechanism remains incompletely understood. In this study, the energetics of the long-range proton transfers through multiple proton-conducting wires in the Qo site of the bc1 complex was investigated computationally using hybrid QM/MM simulations and a specialized reaction coordinate. Key reactive groups and proton transfer mechanisms were characterized, confirming the propionate-A group of heme bL as a plausible proton acceptor. Upon coenzyme-Q oxidation, a Grotthuss hopping mechanism is activated, facilitating proton transfer along three distinct pathways with comparable barriers and stability. These pathways operate redundantly, forming a robust proton-conducting network, and account for the unusual experimental behavior observed in single-point mutations. Energetic analyses exclude charged closed-shell species as likely intermediates and propose a reaction sequence for coenzyme-Q oxidation proceeding as QH2 → QH• → Q0, either via coupled proton-electron transfers or stepwise mechanisms involving open-shell intermediates. These findings elucidate mechanistic details of the Q-cycle and improve our understanding of the catalytic reactions supporting redox-activated proton transfer in respiratory enzymes.

Nuclear quantum effects explain chemiosmosis: The power of the proton

ATP is a universal bio-currency, with chemiosmosis the metabolic mint by which currency is printed. Chemiosmosis leverages a membrane potential and ion gradient, typically a proton gradient, to generate ATP. The current chemiosmotic hypothesis is both cannon and dogma. However, there are obstacles to the unqualified and uncritical acceptance of this model. Intriguingly the proton is sufficiently small to exhibit quantum phenomena of wave-particle duality, often thought the exclusive prerogative of smaller subcellular particles. Evidence shows that chemiosmosis is by necessity critically dependent upon these nuclear quantum effects (NQE) of hydrogen, most notably as a proton. It is well established scientific orthodoxy that protons in water and hydrogen atoms of water molecules exhibit quantum phenomena. The effect is amplified by the hydrogen bonding and juxta-membrane location of protons in mitochondria and chloroplasts. NQE explains the otherwise inexplicable features of chemiosmosis, including the paucity of protons, the rate of proton movement and ATP genesis in otherwise subliminal proton motive forces and thus functionality of alkaliphiles. It also accounts for the efficiencies of chemiosmosis reported at greater than 100% in certain contexts, which violates the second law of thermodynamics under the paradigm of classical physics. Mitochondria may have evolved to exploit quantum biology with notable features such as dimeric ATP synthases adumbrating the first double-slip experiment with the protons. The dramatic global deceleration of mitochondrial chemiosmosis and all cellular function following proton substitution with its heavier isotopes, deuterium and tritium: "deuteruction", is testimony to the primacy of nuclear quantum effects in this Quantum Chemiosmosis. Indeed the speed of evolution itself and its inexorable route to homeothermy may be due to the power of nuclear quantum effects of the smallest nucleus, the proton. The atom that is almost nothing was selected to bring about the most important processes and complex manifestations of life.

Hydrated cable bacteria exhibit protonic conductivity over long distances

This study presents the direct measurement of proton transport along filamentous Desulfobulbaceae, or cable bacteria. Cable bacteria are filamentous multicellular microorganisms that have garnered much interest due to their ability to serve as electrical conduits, transferring electrons over several millimeters. Our results indicate that cable bacteria can also function as protonic conduits because they contain proton wires that transport protons at distances >100 µm. We find that protonic conductivity (σP) along cable bacteria varies between samples and is measured as high as 114 ± 28 µS cm-1 at 25 °C and 70% relative humidity (RH). For cable bacteria, the protonic conductance (GP) and σP are dependent upon the RH, increasing by as much as 26-fold between 60% and 80% RH. This observation implies that proton transport occurs via the Grotthuss mechanism along water associated with cable bacteria, forming proton wires. In order to determine σP and GP along cable bacteria, we implemented a protocol using a modified transfer-printing technique to deposit either palladium interdigitated protodes (IDP), palladium transfer length method (TLM) protodes, or gold interdigitated electrodes (IDE) on top of cable bacteria. Due to the relatively mild nature of the transfer-printing technique, this method should be applicable to a broad array of biological samples and curved materials. The observation of protonic conductivity in cable bacteria presents possibilities for investigating the importance of long-distance proton transport in microbial ecosystems and to potentially build biotic or biomimetic scaffolds to interface with materials via proton-mediated gateways or channels.

Further exploration of the physicochemical nature of μ2-bridge-relevant deprotonations via the elucidation of four kinds of alditol complexes

Single-crystal structures of four alditol complexes are presented. In LuCl3/galactitol and ScCl3/myo-inositol complexes, μ2-bridge-relevant deprotonations were observed. The polarization from two rare earth ions in the μ2-bridge activates the chemically inert OH and promotes deprotonation. Additionally, mass spectrometry, pH experiments, and quantum chemistry calculations were conducted to enhance our understanding of the μ2-bridge-relevant deprotonations. A common structural feature of the complexes where μ2-bridge-relevant deprotonation takes place is that two metal ions and two oxygen atoms in two μ2-bridges form an M2O2 cluster. The four atoms in the M2O2 cluster make up a parallelogram. Such a structure is useful to balance the strong coulombic repulsions between two M3+ and between two O-. In the ScCl3/myo-inositol complex, the deprotonation exhibits a characteristic of regional/chiral selectivity. Galactitol is a third alditol ligand where μ2-bridge-relevant deprotonation is observed. The flexible backbone of the galactitol allows the formation of more five-membered chelating rings and six-membered chelating rings, which are used to stabilize the rare earth ions of the μ2-bridge. The coordination makes the backbone of galactitol deviate from the zigzag conformation. The above results are helpful in the rational design of high-performance catalysts.

Metabolic stress induces a double-positive feedback loop between AMPK and SQSTM1/p62 conferring dual activation of AMPK and NFE2L2/NRF2 to synergize antioxidant defense

Co-occurring mutations in KEAP1 in STK11/LKB1-mutant NSCLC activate NFE2L2/NRF2 to compensate for the loss of STK11-AMPK activity during metabolic adaptation. Characterizing the regulatory crosstalk between the STK11-AMPK and KEAP1-NFE2L2 pathways during metabolic stress is crucial for understanding the implications of co-occurring mutations. Here, we found that metabolic stress increased the expression and phosphorylation of SQSTM1/p62, which is essential for the activation of NFE2L2 and AMPK, synergizing antioxidant defense and tumor growth. The SQSTM1-driven dual activation of NFE2L2 and AMPK was achieved by inducing macroautophagic/autophagic degradation of KEAP1 and facilitating the AXIN-STK11-AMPK complex formation on the lysosomal membrane, respectively. In contrast, the STK11-AMPK activity was also required for metabolic stress-induced expression and phosphorylation of SQSTM1, suggesting a double-positive feedback loop between AMPK and SQSTM1. Mechanistically, SQSTM1 expression was increased by the PPP2/PP2A-dependent dephosphorylation of TFEB and TFE3, which was induced by the lysosomal deacidification caused by low glucose metabolism and AMPK-dependent proton reduction. Furthermore, SQSTM1 phosphorylation was increased by MAP3K7/TAK1, which was activated by ROS and pH-dependent secretion of lysosomal Ca2+. Importantly, phosphorylation of SQSTM1 at S24 and S226 was critical for the activation of AMPK and NFE2L2. Notably, the effects caused by metabolic stress were abrogated by the protons provided by lactic acid. Collectively, our data reveal a novel double-positive feedback loop between AMPK and SQSTM1 leading to the dual activation of AMPK and NFE2L2, potentially explaining why co-occurring mutations in STK11 and KEAP1 happen and providing promising therapeutic strategies for lung cancer.Abbreviations: AMPK: AMP-activated protein kinase; BAF1: bafilomycin A1; ConA: concanamycin A; DOX: doxycycline; IP: immunoprecipitation; KEAP1: kelch like ECH associated protein 1; LN: low nutrient; MAP3K7/TAK1: mitogen-activated protein kinase kinase kinase 7; MCOLN1/TRPML1: mucolipin TRP cation channel 1; MEFs: mouse embryonic fibroblasts; MTORC1: mechanistic target of rapamycin kinase complex 1; NAC: N-acetylcysteine; NFE2L2/NRF2: NFE2 like bZIP transcription factor 2; NSCLC: non-small cell lung cancer; PRKAA/AMPKα: protein kinase AMP-activated catalytic subunit alpha; PPP2/PP2A: protein phosphatase 2; ROS: reactive oxygen species; PPP3/calcineurin: protein phosphatase 3; RPS6KB1/p70S6K: ribosomal protein S6 kinase B1; SQSTM1/p62: sequestosome 1; STK11/LKB1: serine/threonine kinase 11; TCL: total cell lysate; TFEB: transcription factor EB; TFE3: transcription factor binding to IGHM enhancer 3; V-ATPase: vacuolar-type H+-translocating ATPase.

Heavy water inhibits DNA double-strand break repairs and disturbs cellular transcription, presumably via quantum-level mechanisms of kinetic isotope effects on hydrolytic enzyme reactions

Heavy water, containing the heavy hydrogen isotope, is toxic to cells, although the underlying mechanism remains incompletely understood. In addition, certain enzymatic proton transfer reactions exhibit kinetic isotope effects attributed to hydrogen isotopes and their temperature dependencies, indicative of quantum tunneling phenomena. However, the correlation between the biological effects of heavy water and the kinetic isotope effects mediated by hydrogen isotopes remains elusive. In this study, we elucidated the kinetic isotope effects arising from hydrogen isotopes of water and their temperature dependencies in vitro, focusing on deacetylation, DNA cleavage, and protein cleavage, which are crucial enzymatic reactions mediated by hydrolysis. Intriguingly, the intracellular isotope effects of heavy water, related to the in vitro kinetic isotope effects, significantly impeded multiple DNA double-strand break repair mechanisms crucial for cell survival. Additionally, heavy water exposure enhanced histone acetylation and associated transcriptional activation in cells, consistent with the in vitro kinetic isotope effects observed in histone deacetylation reactions. Moreover, as observed for the in vitro kinetic isotope effects, the cytotoxic effect on cell proliferation induced by heavy water exhibited temperature-dependency. These findings reveal the substantial impact of heavy water-induced isotope effects on cellular functions governed by hydrolytic enzymatic reactions, potentially mediated by quantum-level mechanisms underlying kinetic isotope effects.

Spatiotemporal dynamics of the proton motive force on single bacterial cells

Electrochemical gradients across biological membranes are vital for cellular bioenergetics. In bacteria, the proton motive force (PMF) drives essential processes like adenosine triphosphate production and motility. Traditionally viewed as temporally and spatially stable, recent research reveals a dynamic PMF behavior at both single-cell and community levels. Moreover, the observed lateral segregation of respiratory complexes could suggest a spatial heterogeneity of the PMF. Using a light-activated proton pump and detecting the activity of the bacterial flagellar motor, we perturb and probe the PMF of single cells. Spatially homogeneous PMF perturbations reveal millisecond-scale temporal dynamics and an asymmetrical capacitive response. Localized perturbations show a rapid lateral PMF homogenization, faster than proton diffusion, akin to the electrotonic potential spread observed in passive neurons, explained by cable theory. These observations imply a global coupling between PMF sources and consumers along the membrane, precluding sustained PMF spatial heterogeneity but allowing for rapid temporal changes.

Super-Resolution Imaging of Voltages in the Interior of Individual, Vital Mitochondria

We present super-resolution microscopy of isolated functional mitochondria, enabling real-time studies of structure and function (voltages) in response to pharmacological manipulation. Changes in mitochondrial membrane potential as a function of time and position can be imaged in different metabolic states (not possible in whole cells), created by the addition of substrates and inhibitors of the electron transport chain, enabled by the isolation of vital mitochondria. By careful analysis of structure dyes and voltage dyes (lipophilic cations), we demonstrate that most of the fluorescent signal seen from voltage dyes is due to membrane bound dyes, and develop a model for the membrane potential dependence of the fluorescence contrast for the case of super-resolution imaging, and how it relates to membrane potential. This permits direct analysis of mitochondrial structure and function (voltage) of isolated, individual mitochondria as well as submitochondrial structures in the functional, intact state, a major advance in super-resolution studies of living organelles.

A New Theory about Interfacial Proton Diffusion Revisited: The Commonly Accepted Laws of Electrostatics and Diffusion Prevail

The high propensity of protons to stay at interfaces has attracted much attention over the decades. It enables long-range interfacial proton diffusion without relying on titratable residues or electrostatic attraction. As a result, various phenomena manifest themselves, ranging from spillover in material sciences to local proton circuits between proton pumps and ATP synthases in bioenergetics. In an attempt to replace all existing theoretical and experimental insight into the origin of protons' preference for interfaces, TELP, the "Transmembrane Electrostatically-Localized Protons" hypothesis, has been proposed. The TELP hypothesis envisions static H+ and OH- layers on opposite sides of interfaces that are up to 75 µm thick. Yet, the separation at which the electrostatic interaction between two elementary charges is comparable in magnitude to the thermal energy is more than two orders of magnitude smaller and, as a result, the H+ and OH- layers cannot mutually stabilize each other, rendering proton accumulation at the interface energetically unfavorable. We show that (i) the law of electroneutrality, (ii) Fick's law of diffusion, and (iii) Coulomb's law prevail. Using them does not hinder but helps to interpret previously published experimental results, and also helps us understand the high entropy release barrier enabling long-range proton diffusion along the membrane surface.

Acid/Base-Triggered Photophysical and Chiroptical Switching in a Series of Helicenoid Compounds

A series of molecules that possess two quinolines, benzoquinolines, or phenanthrolines connected in a chiral fashion by a biaryl junction along with their water-soluble derivatives was developed and characterized. The influence of the structure on the basicity of the nitrogen atoms in two heterocycles was examined and the photophysical and chiroptical switching activity of the compounds upon protonation was studied both experimentally and computationally. The results demonstrated that changes in the electronic structure of the protonated vs. neutral species, promoting a bathochromic shift of dominant electronic transitions and alternation of their character from π-to-π* to charge-transfer-type, when additionally accompanied by the high structural flexibility of a system, leading to changes in conformational preferences upon proton binding, produce particularly pronounced modifications of the spectral properties in acidic medium. The latter combined with reversibility of the read-out make some of the molecules in this series very promising multifunctional pH probes.

Lee's transient protonic capacitor cannot explain the surface proton current observed in bacteriorhodopsin purple membranes

Recently in this Journal, James Lee employed his transmembrane electrostatically localized proton (TELP) hypothesis and the notion of a transient protonic capacitor to explain the force holding protons at the surface of bacteriorhodopsin purple membrane fragments. Here we show that purple membrane fragments cannot maintain the requisite transient non-zero transmembrane potential, and even if they could, it would not support the surface proton current moving from the P side to the N side that was reported by Heberle et al. (Nature, 1994). Currently accepted models explain the force keeping protons at the membrane surface by invoking the unusual structure of water at the interface which serves to stabilize the proton (energy well) and/or raise the activation ∆G‡ (energy barrier) for release to the bulk phase. Any future invocations of TELP should be required to include experimental measurements carried out at the surfaces of lipid bilayer membranes and/or biological membranes.

Transient protonic capacitor: Explaining the bacteriorhodopsin membrane experiment of Heberle et al. 1994

The transmembrane-electrostatically localized protons (TELP) theory can serve as a unified framework to explain experimental observations and elucidate bioenergetic systems including both delocalized and localized protonic coupling. With the TELP model as a unified framework, it is now better explained how the bacteriorhodopsin-purple membrane-ATPase system functions. The bacteriorhodopsin pumping of protons across the membrane results in the formation of TELP around the halobacterial extracellular membrane surface that is perfectly positioned to drive ATP synthase for the synthesis of ATP from ADP and Pi. The bacteriorhodopsin purple membrane sheet experiment of Heberle et al. 1994 is now better explained here as a transient "protonic capacitor". During the lifetime of a flashlight-induced protonic bacteriorhodopsin purple membrane capacitor activity, there is at least a transient non-zero membrane potential (Δψ ≠ 0). The experimental results demonstrated that "after proton release by an integral membrane protein, long-range proton transfer along the membrane surface is faster than proton exchange with the bulk water phase" exactly as predicted by the TELP theory, which is fundamentally important to the science of bioenergetics.

The real reason why ATP hydrolysis is spontaneous at pH > 7: It's (mostly) the proton concentration!

Common wisdom holds that ATP hydrolysis is spontaneous because of the weakness of its phosphoanhydride bonds, electrostatic repulsion within the polyanionic ATP4- molecule, and resonance stabilization of the inorganic phosphate and ADP products. By examining the pH-dependence of the hydrolysis Gibbs free energy, we show that in fact, above pH 7, ATP hydrolysis is spontaneous due mainly to the low concentration of the H+ that is released as product. Hence, ATP is essentially just an electrophilic target whose attack by H2 O causes the acidity of the water nucleophile to increase dramatically; the spontaneity of the resulting acid ionization supplies much of the released Gibbs free energy. We also find that fermentation lowers pH not due to its organic acid products (e.g., lactic, acetic, formic, or succinic acids), but again, due to the H+ product of ATP hydrolysis.

Protonic conductor: Explaining the transient "excess protons" experiment of Pohl's group 2012

The transmembrane-electrostatically localized protons (TELP) theory can serve as a unified framework to explain experimental observations and elucidate bioenergetic systems including both delocalized and localized protonic coupling. With the TELP model as a unified framework, we can now better explain: the experimental results of Pohl's group (Zhang et al. 2012) as an effect of transient "excess protons" that can temporally form because of the difference between the fast protonic conduction in liquid water through the "hops and turns" mechanism and the relatively slow diffusion of chloride anions. This new understanding with the TELP theory agrees well with the independent analysis on the Pohl's lab group experiment results by Agmon and Gutman who also concluded that "the excess protons propagate as an advancing front".

Molecular Dynamics Investigation on the Effects of Protonation and Lysyl Hydroxylation on Sulfilimine Cross-links in Collagen IV

Collagen IV networks are an essential component of basement membranes that are important for their structural integrity and thus that of an organism's tissues. Improper functioning of these networks has been associated with several diseases. Cross-links, such as sulfilimine bonds interconnecting NC1 domains, are critical for forming and mechanically stabilizing these collagen IV networks. More specifically, the sulfilimine cross-links form between methionine (Met93) and lysine/hydroxylsine (Lys211/Hyl211) residues of NC1 domains. Therefore, the dynamic nature of the sulfilimine bond in collagen IV is crucial for network formation. To understand the dynamic nature of a neutral and protonated sulfilimine bond in collagen IV, we performed molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on four sulfilimine cross-linked systems (i.e., _Met93S-N_Lys211, _Met93S-NH_Lys211 ⁺, _Met93S-N_Hyl211, and _Met93S-NH_Hyl211 ⁺) of collagen IV. The MD results showed that the neutral _Met93S-N_Lys211 system has the smallest protein backbone and showed the cross-linked residues' RMSD value. The conformational change analyses showed that the conformations of the sulfilimine cross-linked residues take on a U-shape for the _Met93S-N_Hyl211 and _Met93S-HN_Hyl211 ⁺ systems, whereas the conformations of the sulfilimine cross-linked residues are more open for the _Met93S-N_Lys211, and _Met93S-NH_Lys211 ⁺ systems. Protonation is a crucial biochemical process to stabilize the protein structure or the biological cross-links. Furthermore, the protonation of the sulfilimine bond could potentially influence hydrogen bond interaction with near amino acid residues, and according to water distribution analyses, the sulfilimine bond can potentially exist in one or more protonation states.

Tuning ESIPT-coupled luminescence by expanding π-conjugation of a proton acceptor moiety in ESIPT-capable zinc(II) complexes with 1-hydroxy-1H-imidazole-based ligands

The emission of ESIPT-fluorophores is known to be sensitive to various external and internal stimuli and can be fine-tuned through substitution in the proton-donating and proton-accepting groups. The incorporation of metal ions in the molecules of ESIPT fluorophores without their deprotonation is an emerging area of research in coordination chemistry which provides chemists with a new factor affecting the ESIPT reaction and ESIPT-coupled luminescence. In this paper we present 1-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-(pyridin-2-yl)-2-(quinolin-2-yl)-1H-imidazole (HLq) as a new ESIPT-capable ligand. Due to the spatial separation of metal binding and ESIPT sites this ligand can coordinate metal ions without being deprotonated. The reactions of ZnHal₂ with HLq afford ESIPT-capable [Zn(HLq)Hal2] (Hal = Cl, Br, I) complexes. In the solid state HLq and [Zn(HLq)Hal2] luminesce in the orange region (λ_max = 600-650 nm). The coordination of HLq by Zn²⁺ ions leads to the increase in the photoluminescence quantum yield due to the chelation-enhanced fluorescence effect. The ESIPT process is barrierless in the S₁ state, leading to the only possible fluorescence channel in the tautomeric form (T), S₁^T → S₀^T. The emission of [Zn(HLq)Hal2] in the solid state is blue-shifted as compared with HLq due to the stabilization of the ground state and destabilization of the excited state. In CH₂Cl₂ solutions, the compounds demonstrate dual emission in the UV (λ_max = 358 nm) and green (λ_max = 530 nm) regions. This dual emission is associated with two radiative deactivation channels in the normal (N) and tautomeric (T) forms, S₁^N → S₀^N and S₁^T → S₀^T, originating from two minima on the excited state potential energy surfaces. High energy barriers for the GSIPT process allow the trapping of molecules in the minimum of the tautomeric form, S₀^T, resulting in the possibility of the S₀^T → S₁^T photoexcitation and extraordinarily small Stokes shifts in the solid state. Finally, the π-system of quinolin-2-yl group facilitates the delocalization of the positive charge in the proton-accepting part of the molecule and promotes the ESIPT reaction.

Kidney metabolism and acid-base control: back to the basics

Kidneys are central in the regulation of multiple physiological functions, such as removal of metabolic wastes and toxins, maintenance of electrolyte and fluid balance, and control of pH homeostasis. In addition, kidneys participate in systemic gluconeogenesis and in the production or activation of hormones. Acid-base conditions influence all these functions concomitantly. Healthy kidneys properly coordinate a series of physiological responses in the face of acute and chronic acid-base disorders. However, injured kidneys have a reduced capacity to adapt to such challenges. Chronic kidney disease patients are an example of individuals typically exposed to chronic and progressive metabolic acidosis. Their organisms undergo a series of alterations that brake large detrimental changes in the homeostasis of several parameters, but these alterations may also operate as further drivers of kidney damage. Acid-base disorders lead not only to changes in mechanisms involved in acid-base balance maintenance, but they also affect multiple other mechanisms tightly wired to it. In this review article, we explore the basic renal activities involved in the maintenance of acid-base balance and show how they are interconnected to cell energy metabolism and other important intracellular activities. These intertwined relationships have been investigated for more than a century, but a modern conceptual organization of these events is lacking. We propose that pH homeostasis indissociably interacts with central pathways that drive progression of chronic kidney disease, such as inflammation and metabolism, independent of etiology.

A critique of the capacitor-based "Transmembrane Electrostatically Localized Proton" hypothesis

In his Transmembrane Electrostatically Localized Proton hypothesis (TELP), James W. Lee has modeled the bioenergetic membrane as a simple capacitor. According to this model, the surface concentration of protons is completely independent of proton concentration in the bulk phase, and is linearly proportional to the transmembrane potential. Such a proportionality runs counter to the results of experimental measurements, molecular dynamics simulations, and electrostatics calculations. We show that the TELP model dramatically overestimates the surface concentration of protons, and we discuss the electrostatic reasons why a simple capacitor is not an appropriate model for the bioenergetic membrane.