The Discovery of Chicken Foxp3 Demands Redefinition of Avian Regulatory T Cells

Single-cell RNA sequencing of bone marrow reveals the immune response mechanisms of lymphocytes under avian leukosis virus subgroup J infection

Avian Leukosis Virus (ALV) can induce tumorigenesis and immune suppression by acting on lymphocytes in the bone marrow. In this study, single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) was used to analyze chicken bone marrow lymphocytes under Avian Leukosis Virus subtype J (ALV-J) infection. Using subgroup-specific marker genes and cell state analysis, we identified 18 distinct cell clusters, including 8 T cell clusters, 2 B cell clusters, 5 tumor-like cell clusters, and 3 unidentified clusters. Gene expression analysis revealed that in the 10 T/B lymphocyte clusters, the differentially expressed genes in double-positive T cells, B1-like B cells, and cytotoxic T cells were highly enriched in pathways related to viral infection and immune response. These three cell populations exhibited high proportions and significant changes after infection, suggesting a strong immune response to ALV-J infection. Additionally, during ALV-J infection, the proportion of regulatory T cells and CTLA4 T cells increased, while immune suppressive factors TGFB1 and IL16 were highly expressed across the cell populations, indicating an immune-suppressive state in bone marrow lymphocytes. Moreover, ALV-J infected all cell populations; however, within the same cluster, only a fraction of the cells expressed ALV-J viral genes. Notably, in all cells expressing ALV-J viral genes, the "Rho family GTPase signaling pathway" associated with antiviral responses was activated. The Rho family, which is a key regulator of cytoskeletal reorganization and cell polarity, also plays a critical role in tumor cell proliferation and metastasis. Further analysis using Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) software predicted key upstream regulators of immune response, such as MYC and MCYN. In conclusion, this study identifies key genes and signaling pathways involved in immune responses of different lymphocyte subpopulations triggered by ALV-J infection in bone marrow. These findings contribute to a better understanding of the immune mechanisms in ALV-J-infected bone marrow lymphocytes and provide insights for discovering breeding loci for ALV-J resistance.

Selection for Improved Water Efficiency in Broiler Breeder Lines Does Not Negatively Impact Immune Response Capabilities to Gram- and Gram+ Bacterial Components and a Killed-Salmonella Enteritidis Vaccine

Selection for water consumption could impact broiler breeders' immune capabilities. To assess these impacts of selection based on the water conversion ratio (WCR), three trials were conducted using broiler breeders from the modern random bred (MRB), low (L)WCR, and high (H)WCR lines. Ten- to 11-week-old male broilers received intradermal (i.d.) growing feather (GF)-pulp injections of LPS (Trial 1) or PGN (Trial 2), to assess local (GF-pulp) and systemic (blood) inflammatory responses over 24 h and 72 h p.i., respectively. Measurements included leukocyte profiles in GF-pulps and blood, GF cytokine mRNA expression and reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, and plasma concentrations of α1-acid glycoprotein (AGP-1). In Trial 3, 14-week-old pullets were immunized by i.d. GF-pulp injection of SEV (108 CFU/mL). Leukocyte profiles in the GF-pulp and blood were measured over 72 h and plasma levels of SEV-specific IgM, IgY(G), and IgA antibodies over 4 weeks p.i. Independent of the line, phagocytes infiltrated GF-pulps by 6 h post-LPS injection (p ≤ 0.05), while lymphocytes were the major leukocyte recruited in response to PGN (p ≤ 0.05). However, with both LPS and PGN, HWCR broilers were less effective in recruiting lymphocytes than MRB and LWCR broilers, which had similar lymphocyte infiltration levels. There were no line differences in GF-pulp cytokine mRNA expression and ROS generation, nor in blood leukocyte and AGP-1 concentrations, following LPS injections. Independent of the line, SEV immunization stimulated similar phagocyte recruitment profiles; however, the LWCR and MRB lines had a higher infiltration of lymphocytes (esp. B cells) than the HWCR line (p ≤ 0.05). Independent of the line, SEV immunization triggered a robust, high-quality, primary SE-specific antibody response (p ≤ 0.05). Collectively, selection for improved water efficiency in the LWCR broiler breeder lines did not negatively impact immune response capabilities to LPS, PGN, and a killed SEV.

Primary regulatory T cell activator FOXP3 is present across Amphibia

The overall structure of the immune system is highly conserved across jawed vertebrates, but characterization and description of the immune system is heavily biased toward mammals. One arm of the vertebrate immune system, the adaptive immune system, mounts pathogen-specific responses that tend to be robust and effective at clearing pathogens. This system requires selection against self-recognition and modulation of the immune response. One of the mechanisms of immune modulation is the presence of regulatory T cells that suppress other effector immune cells. Regulatory T cells and their primary activator forkhead box protein P3 (FOXP3) have been well characterized in mammalian models but unexplored in most other vertebrate taxa. Amphibians are a good focal group for the characterization of FOXP3 due to their phylogenetic position on the vertebrate tree of life, and their susceptibility to emerging pathogens. In this study, we mined available transcriptomic and genomic data to confirm the presence of FOXP3 across the amphibian tree of life. We find that FOXP3 is present in all major clades of amphibians. We also test whether selection on FOXP3 shows signatures of intensification among the three main clades of amphibians, which may reflect shifts in the stringency of natural selection on this gene. Our findings provide insights into the evolutionary history of the vertebrate immune system and confirm the conservation of vertebrate immune genes within amphibians.

From feather pecking to immunity: Immune differences between lines selected for high and low feather pecking

Feather pecking (FP) is a serious behavioral disorder in laying hens, leading to feather damage, skin lesions, and often resulting in cannibalism. The mechanisms underlying FP are not clear yet, but recently the role of the immune system as a cause has been discussed. In humans, the interrelation between personality traits and the immune system is well-documented, with impulsivity and hyperactivity linked to distinct alterations in blood immune cell numbers and to elevated levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Similarly, FP in hens is associated with impulsivity and hyperactivity, suggesting a possible connection between FP and immune cell alterations. In this study numbers of leukocyte subsets in blood, spleen and cecal tonsils, along with mitogen-induced lymphocyte proliferative response and antibody concentrations across hens selectively bred for high (HFP) and low (LFP) feather pecking behavior were analyzed. Results showed that divergent selection altered FP behavior, with HFP hens showing about 10 times more pecking behavior than hens of the LFP line. HFP hens had lower numbers of T helper cells, CD4+ CD25high as well as B cells compared to LFP hens. Furthermore, HFP hens demonstrated a stronger proliferation of T cells when stimulated with ConA, while showed a weaker response in T cell-dependent B cell proliferation when stimulated with PWM, compared to LFP hens. Antibody plasma concentrations were similar between both lines. These findings highlight substantial immunological differences between HFP and LFP hens, especially in T cell immunity, and support the hypothesis that FP may be an immune-related behavioral response.

The Bacterial Cell Wall Components Lipopolysaccharide and Peptidoglycan Initiate Divergent Local Tissue and Systemic Inflammatory Response Profiles in the Chicken Model

The innate immune system plays an important role in the defense against pathogens, whereby the ability to rapidly mount an effective inflammatory response is critical in the elimination/containment of the infection. To better understand the nature of the inflammatory responses to bacterial components in chickens, we used the growing feather (GF) cutaneous bioassay together with blood sampling to examine the local and systemic inflammatory responses initiated by intradermal (i.d.) GF-pulp injection of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) from Salmonella Typhimurium or peptidoglycan (PGN) from Staphylococcus aureus. Three studies were conducted in egg-type chickens between 9 and 15 weeks of age; Study 1 and 2 examined the leukocyte response profiles to a 100-fold dose range of LPS or PGN over 24 h or 7 d, respectively; Study 3 examined the leukocyte- and cytokine mRNA-profiles in pulps in response to LPS and PGN concurrently over 72 h. I.d. injection of LPS stimulated a heterophil and monocyte/macrophage dominated response in both GF-pulps and blood that was resolved by 48-72 h and differed based on dose administered. The inflammatory response stimulated by PGN was characterized by rapid infiltration of lymphocytes in GF-pulps with sustained high levels of T and B cells over 5-7 d and was neither affected by PGN dose nor reflected in the blood. Limited cytokine transcriptome analyses did not reveal differences that could explain the divergent response profiles to LPS versus PGN. More research is needed to understand the mechanisms underlying the divergent inflammatory responses to LPS and PGN in chickens.

Evolutionary diversity of CXCL16-CXCR6: Convergent substitutions and recurrent gene loss in sauropsids

The CXCL16-CXCR6 axis is crucial for regulating the persistence of CD8 tissue-resident memory T cells (TRM). CXCR6 deficiency lowers TRM cell numbers in the lungs and depletes ILC3s in the lamina propria, impairing mucosal defence. This axis is linked to diseases like HIV/SIV, cancer, and COVID-19. Together, these highlight that the CXCL16-CXCR6 axis is pivotal in host immunity. Previous studies of the CXCL16-CXCR6 axis found genetic variation among species but were limited to primates and rodents. To understand the evolution and diversity of CXCL16-CXCR6 across vertebrates, we compared approximately 400 1-to-1 CXCR6 orthologs spanning diverse vertebrates. The unique DRF motif of CXCR6 facilitates leukocyte adhesion by interacting with cell surface-expressed CXCL16 and plays a key role in G-protein selectivity during receptor signalling; however, our findings show that this motif is not universal. The DRF motif is restricted to mammals, turtles, and frogs, while the DRY motif, typical in other CKRs, is found in snakes and lizards. Most birds exhibit the DRL motif. These substitutions at the DRF motif affect the receptor-Gi/o protein interaction. We establish recurrent CXCR6 gene loss in 10 out of 36 bird orders, including Galliformes and Passeriformes, Crocodilia, and Elapidae, attributed to segmental deletions and/or frame-disrupting changes. Notably, single-cell RNA sequencing of the lung shows a drop in TRM cells in species with CXCR6 loss, suggesting a possible link. The concurrent loss of ITGAE, CXCL16, and CXCR6 in chickens may have altered CD8 TRM cell abundance, with implications for immunity against viral diseases and vaccines inducing CD8 TRM cells.

In vitro assessment of the immunomodulatory effects of probiotic Bacillus strains on chicken PBMCs

The beneficial effects of feeding probiotic Bacillus subtilis DSM 32315 (BS) and Bacillus velezensis CECT 5940 (BV) to chickens in vivo are well-documented, with potential immune modulation as a key mechanism. In this study, we investigated the direct interactions of chicken peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) with BS or BV in vitro through whole transcriptome profiling and cytokine array analysis. Transcriptome profiling revealed 20 significantly differentially expressed genes (DEGs) in response to both Bacillus treatments, with twelve DEGs identified in BS-treated PBMCs and eight in BV-treated PBMCs. Pathway analysis using the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) indicated significant regulation of immune-related pathways by both BS and BV. Notably, BS treatment upregulated genes associated with immune cell surface markers (CD4, CD25, CD28), anti-inflammatory cytokine interleukin-10 (IL-10), and C-C motif chemokine ligand 5 (CCL5), while downregulating the gene encoding pro-inflammatory IL-16. BV treatment similarly affected genes associated with immune cell surface markers, IL-16, and CCL5, with no impact on the gene encoding IL-10. Both treatments induced higher expression of the gene encoding the avian β-defensin 1 (AvBD1). The results of this in vitro study indicate an immunomodulatory effect of BS and BV in chicken PBMCs by regulating genes involved in anti-inflammatory, bacteriostatic, protective, and pro-inflammatory responses. Consequently, BS and BV may serve to augment the immune system's capacity to defend against infection by modulating immune responses and cytokine expression. Thus, the administration of these probiotics holds promise for reducing reliance on antimicrobials in farming practices.

Delineation of chicken immune markers in the era of omics and multicolor flow cytometry

Multiparameter flow cytometry is a routine method in immunological studies incorporated in biomedical, veterinary, agricultural, and wildlife research and routinely used in veterinary clinical laboratories. Its use in the diagnostics of poultry diseases is still limited, but due to the continuous expansion of reagents and cost reductions, this may change in the near future. Although the structure and function of the avian immune system show commonalities with mammals, at the molecular level, there is often low homology across species. The cross-reactivity of mammalian immunological reagents is therefore low, but nevertheless, the list of reagents to study chicken immune cells is increasing. Recent improvement in multicolor antibody panels for chicken cells has resulted in more detailed analysis by flow cytometry and has allowed the discovery of novel leukocyte cell subpopulations. In this article, we present an overview of the reagents and guidance needed to perform multicolor flow cytometry using chicken samples and common pitfalls to avoid.

Single-cell RNA-seq mapping of chicken peripheral blood leukocytes

BACKGROUND

Single-cell transcriptomics provides means to study cell populations at the level of individual cells. In leukocyte biology this approach could potentially aid the identification of subpopulations and functions without the need to develop species-specific reagents. The present study aimed to evaluate single-cell RNA-seq as a tool for identification of chicken peripheral blood leukocytes. For this purpose, purified and thrombocyte depleted leukocytes from 4 clinically healthy hens were subjected to single-cell 3' RNA-seq. Bioinformatic analysis of data comprised unsupervised clustering of the cells, and annotation of clusters based on expression profiles. Immunofluorescence phenotyping of the cell preparations used was also performed.

RESULTS

Computational analysis identified 31 initial cell clusters and based on expression of defined marker genes 28 cluster were identified as comprising mainly B-cells, T-cells, monocytes, thrombocytes and red blood cells. Of the remaining clusters, two were putatively identified as basophils and eosinophils, and one as proliferating cells of mixed origin. In depth analysis on gene expression profiles within and between the initial cell clusters allowed further identification of cell identity and possible functions for some of them. For example, analysis of the group of monocyte clusters revealed subclusters comprising heterophils, as well as putative monocyte subtypes. Also, novel aspects of TCRγ/δ + T-cell subpopulations could be inferred such as evidence of at least two subtypes based on e.g., different expression of transcription factors MAF, SOX13 and GATA3. Moreover, a novel subpopulation of chicken peripheral B-cells with high SOX5 expression was identified. An overall good correlation between mRNA and cell surface phenotypic cell identification was shown.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, we were able to identify and infer functional aspects of both previously well known as well as novel chicken leukocyte populations although some cell types. e.g., T-cell subtypes, proved more challenging to decipher. Although this methodology to some extent is limited by incomplete annotation of the chicken genome, it definitively has benefits in chicken immunology by expanding the options to distinguish identity and functions of immune cells also without access to species specific reagents.

Loss of αβ but not γδ T cells in chickens causes a severe phenotype

The availability of genetically modified mice has facilitated the study of mammalian T cells. No model has yet been developed to study these cells in chickens, an important livestock species with a high availability of γδ T cells. To investigate the role of γδ and αβ T cell populations in birds, we generated chickens lacking these T cell populations. This was achieved by genomic deletion of the constant region of the T cell receptor γ or β chain, leading to a complete loss of either γδ or αβ T cells. Our results show that a deletion of αβ T cells but not γδ T cells resulted in a severe phenotype in KO chickens. The αβ T cell KO chickens exhibited granulomas associated with inflammation of the spleen and the proventriculus. Immunophenotyping of αβ T cell KO chickens revealed a significant increase in monocytes and expectedly the absence of CD4+ T cells including FoxP3+ regulatory T cells. Surprisingly there was no increase of γδ T cells. In addition, we observed a significant decrease in immunoglobulins, B lymphocytes, and changes in the bursa morphology. Our data reveal the consequences of T cell knockouts in chickens and provide new insights into their function in vertebrates.

Co-administration of chicken IL-2 alleviates clinical signs and replication of the ILTV chicken embryo origin vaccine by pre-activating natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes

IMPORTANCE

Chickens immunized with the infectious laryngotracheitis chicken embryo origin (CEO) vaccine (Medivac, PT Medion Farma Jaya) experience adverse reactions, hindering its safety and effective use in poultry flocks. To improve the effect of the vaccine, we sought to find a strategy to alleviate the respiratory reactions associated with the vaccine. Here, we confirmed that co-administering the CEO vaccine with chIL-2 by oral delivery led to significant alleviation of the vaccine reactions in chickens after immunization. Furthermore, we found that the co-administration of chIL-2 with the CEO vaccine reduced the clinical signs of the CEO vaccine while enhancing natural killer cells and cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to decrease viral loads in their tissues, particularly in the trachea and conjunctiva. Importantly, we demonstrated that the chIL-2 treatment can ameliorate the replication of the CEO vaccine without compromising its effectiveness. This study provides new insights into further applications of chIL-2 and a promising strategy for alleviating the adverse reaction of vaccines.

CD4+TGFβ+ cells infiltrated the bursa of Fabricius following IBDV infection, and correlated with a delayed viral clearance, but did not correlate with disease severity, or immunosuppression

Introduction

Infectious Bursal Disease Virus (IBDV) causes immunosuppression in chickens. While B-cell destruction is the main cause of humoral immunosuppression, bursal T cells from IBDV-infected birds have been reported to inhibit the mitogenic response of splenocytes, indicating that some T cell subsets in the infected bursa have immunomodulatory activities. CD4+CD25+TGFβ+ cells have been recently described in chickens that have immunoregulatory properties and play a role in the pathogenesis of Marek's Disease Virus.

Methods

To evaluate if CD4+CD25+TGFβ+ cells infiltrated the bursa of Fabricius (BF) following IBDV infection, and influenced the outcome of infection, birds were inoculated at either 2 days or 2 weeks of age with vaccine strain (228E), classic field strain (F52/70), or PBS (mock), and bursal cell populations were quantified by flow cytometry.

Results

Both 228E and F52/70 led to atrophy of the BF, a significant reduction of Bu1+-B cells, and a significant increase in CD4+ and CD8α+ T cells in the BF, but only F52/70 caused suppression of immune responses to a test antigen in younger birds, and clinical signs in older birds. Virus was cleared from the BF more rapidly in younger birds than older birds. An infiltration of CD4+CD25+T cells into the BF, and elevated expression of bursal TGFβ-1+ mRNA was observed at all time points following infection, irrespective of the strain or age of the birds, but CD4+TGFβ+cells and CD4+CD25+TGFβ+ cells only appeared in the BF at 28 dpi in younger birds. In older birds, CD4+TGFβ+ cells and CD4+CD25+TGFβ+ cells were present at earlier time points, from 7dpi following 228E infection, and from 14 and 28 dpi following F52/70 infection, respectively.

Discussion

Our data suggest that an earlier infiltration of CD4+TGFβ+ cells into the BF correlated with a delayed clearance of virus. However, the influx of CD4+TGFβ+ cells and CD4+CD25+TGFβ+ into the BF did not correlate with increased pathogenicity, or immunosuppression.

Influence of Live Attenuated Salmonella Vaccines on Cecal Microbiome Composition and Microbiota Abundances in Young Broiler Chickens

Salmonellosis is a global food safety challenge caused by Salmonella, a gram-negative bacterium of zoonotic importance. Poultry is considered a major reservoir for the pathogen, and humans are exposed through consumption of raw or undercooked products derived from them. Prophylaxis of Salmonella in poultry farms generally mainly involves biosecurity measures, flock testing and culling, use of antibiotics, and vaccination programs. For decades, the use of antibiotics has been a common practice to limit poultry contamination with important pathogenic bacteria such as Salmonella at the farm level. However, due to an increasing prevalence of resistance, non-therapeutic use of antibiotics in animal production has been banned in many parts of the world. This has prompted the search for non-antimicrobial alternatives. Live vaccines are among the developed and currently used methods for Salmonella control. However, their mechanism of action, particularly the effect they might have on commensal gut microbiota, is not well understood. In this study, three different commercial live attenuated Salmonella vaccines (AviPro^® Salmonella Vac T, AviPro^® Salmonella DUO, and AviPro^® Salmonella Vac E) were used to orally vaccinate broiler chickens, and cecal contents were collected for microbiomes analysis by 16S rRNA next generation sequencing. Quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) was used to study the cecal immune-related genes expression in the treatment groups, while Salmonella-specific antibodies were analyzed from sera and cecal extracts by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). We show that vaccination with live attenuated Salmonella vaccines had a significant influence on the variability of the broiler cecal microbiota (p = 0.016). Furthermore, the vaccines AviPro^® Salmonella Vac T and AviPro^® Salmonella DUO, but not AviPro^® Salmonella Vac E, had a significant effect (p = 0.024) on microbiota composition. This suggests that the live vaccine type used can differently alter the microbiota profiles, driving the gut colonization resistance and immune responses to pathogenic bacteria, and might impact the overall chicken health and productivity. Further investigation is, however, required to confirm this.

Clostridium butyricum Can Promote Bone Development by Regulating Lymphocyte Function in Layer Pullets

Bone health problems are a serious threat to laying hens; microbiome-based therapies, which are harmless and inexpensive, may be an effective solution for bone health problems. Here, we examined the impacts of supplementation with Clostridium butyricum (CB) on bone and immune homeostasis in pullets. The results of in vivo experiments showed that feeding the pullets CB was beneficial to the development of the tibia and upregulated the levels of the bone formation marker alkaline phosphatase and the marker gene runt-related transcription factor 2 (RUNX2). For the immune system, CB treatment significantly upregulated IL-10 expression and significantly increased the proportion of T regulatory (Treg) cells in the spleen and peripheral blood lymphocytes. In the in vitro test, adding CB culture supernatant or butyrate to the osteoblast culture system showed no significant effects on osteoblast bone formation, while adding lymphocyte culture supernatant significantly promoted bone formation. In addition, culture supernatants supplemented with treated lymphocytes (pretreated with CB culture supernatants) stimulated higher levels of bone formation. In sum, the addition of CB improved bone health by modulating cytokine expression and the ratio of Treg cells in the immune systems of layer pullets. Additionally, in vitro CB could promote the bone formation of laying hen osteoblasts through the mediation of lymphocytes.

Investigation of the Molecular Evolution of Treg Suppression Mechanisms Indicates a Convergent Origin

Regulatory T cell (Treg) suppression of conventional T cells is a central mechanism that ensures immune system homeostasis. The exact time point of Treg emergence is still disputed. Furthermore, the time of Treg-mediated suppression mechanisms’ emergence has not been identified. It is not yet known whether Treg suppression mechanisms diverged from a single pathway or converged from several sources. We investigated the evolutionary history of Treg suppression pathways using various phylogenetic analysis tools. To ensure the conservation of function for investigated proteins, we augmented our study using nonhomology-based methods to predict protein functions among various investigated species and mined the literature for experimental evidence of functional convergence. Our results indicate that a minority of Treg suppressor mechanisms could be homologs of ancient conserved pathways. For example, CD73, an enzymatic pathway known to play an essential role in invertebrates, is highly conserved between invertebrates and vertebrates, with no evidence of positive selection (w = 0.48, p-value < 0.00001). Our findings indicate that Tregs utilize homologs of proteins that diverged in early vertebrates. However, our findings do not exclude the possibility of a more evolutionary pattern following the duplication degeneration−complementation (DDC) model. Ancestral sequence reconstruction showed that Treg suppression mechanism proteins do not belong to one family; rather, their emergence seems to follow a convergent evolutionary pattern.