Continuous, real-time monitoring of the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) in animal cell bioreactors

Off-Gas-Based Soft Sensor for Real-Time Monitoring of Biomass and Metabolism in Chinese Hamster Ovary Cell Continuous Processes in Single-Use Bioreactors

In mammalian cell culture, especially in pharmaceutical manufacturing and research, biomass and metabolic monitoring are mandatory for various cell culture process steps to develop and, finally, control bioprocesses. As a common measure for biomass, the viable cell density (VCD) or the viable cell volume (VCV) is widely used. This study highlights, for the first time, the advantages of using VCV instead of VCD as a biomass depiction in combination with an oxygen-uptake- rate (OUR)-based soft sensor for real-time biomass estimation and process control in single-use bioreactor (SUBs) continuous processes with Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines. We investigated a series of 14 technically similar continuous SUB processes, where the same process conditions but different expressing CHO cell lines were used, with respect to biomass growth and oxygen demand to calibrate our model. In addition, we analyzed the key metabolism of the CHO cells in SUB perfusion processes by exometabolomic approaches, highlighting the importance of cell-specific substrate and metabolite consumption and production rate qS analysis to identify distinct metabolic phases. Cell-specific rates for classical mammalian cell culture key substrates and metabolites in CHO perfusion processes showed a good correlation to qOUR, yet, unexpectedly, not for qGluc. Here, we present the soft-sensoring methodology we developed for qPyr to allow for the real-time approximation of cellular metabolism and usage for subsequent, in-depth process monitoring, characterization and optimization.

Online monitoring of the cell-specific oxygen uptake rate with an in situ combi-sensor

In a biotechnological process, standard monitored process variables are pH, partial oxygen pressure (pO₂), and temperature. These process variables are important, but they do not give any information about the metabolic activity of the cell. The ISICOM is an in situ combi-sensor that is measuring the cell-specific oxygen uptake rate (qOUR) online. This variable allows a qualitative judgement of metabolic cell activity. The measuring principle of the ISICOM is based on a volume element enclosed into a small measuring chamber. Inside the measuring chamber, the pO₂ and the scattered light is measured. Within a defined measuring interval, the chamber closes, and the oxygen supply for the cells is interrupted. The decreasing oxygen concentration is recorded by the pO₂ optode. This measuring principle, known as the dynamic method, determines the oxygen uptake rate (OUR). Together with the scattered light signal, the cell concentration is estimated and the qOUR is available online. The design of the ISICOM is focused on functionality, sterility, long-term stability, and response time behavior so the sensor can be used in bioprocesses. With the ISICOM, measurement of online and in situ measurement of the OUR is possible. The OUR and qOUR online measurement of an animal cell batch cultivation is demonstrated, with maximum values of OUR = 2.5 mmol L^-1 h^-1 and a qOUR = 9.5 pmol cell^-1 day^-1. Information about limitation of the primary and secondary substrate is derived by the monitoring of the metabolic cell activity of bacteria and yeast cultivation processes. This sensor contributes to a higher process understanding by offering an online view on to the cell behavior. In the sense of process analytical technology (PAT), this important information is needed for bioprocesses to realize a knowledge base process control.

New developments in online OUR monitoring and its application to animal cell cultures

The increasing demand for biopharmaceuticals produced in mammalian cells has driven the industry to enhance the productivity of bioprocesses through intensification of culture process. Fed-batch and perfusion culturing strategies are considered the most attractive choices, but the application of these processes requires the availability of reliable online measuring systems for the estimation of cell density and metabolic activity. This manuscript reviews the methods (and the devices used) for monitoring of the oxygen consumption, also known as oxygen uptake rate (OUR), since it is a straightforward parameter to estimate viable cell density and the physiological state of cells. Furthermore, as oxygen plays an important role in the cell metabolism, OUR has also been very useful to estimate nutrient consumption, especially the carbon (glucose and glutamine) and nitrogen (glutamine) sources. Three different methods for the measurement of OUR have been developed up to date, being the dynamic method the golden standard, even though DO and pH perturbations generated in the culture during each measurement. For this, many efforts have been focused in developing non-invasive methods, such as global mass balance or stationary liquid mass balance. The low oxygen consumption rates by the cells and the high accuracy required for oxygen concentration measurement in the gas streams (inlet and outlet) have limited the applicability of the global mass balance methodology in mammalian cell cultures. In contrast, stationary liquid mass balance has successfully been implemented showing very similar OUR profiles compared with those obtained with the dynamic method. The huge amount of studies published in the last years evidence that OUR have become a reliable alternative for the monitoring and control of high cell density culturing strategies with very high productivities.

Metabolic flux balance analysis during lactate and glucose concomitant consumption in HEK293 cell cultures

At early stages of the exponential growth phase in HEK293 cell cultures, the tricarboxylic acid cycle is unable to process all the amount of NADH generated in the glycolysis pathway, being lactate the main by-product. However, HEK293 cells are also able to metabolize lactate depending on the environmental conditions. It has been recently observed that one of the most important modes of lactate metabolization is the cometabolism of lactate and glucose, observed even during the exponential growth phase. Extracellular lactate concentration and pH appear to be the key factors triggering the metabolic shift from glucose consumption and lactate production to lactate and glucose concomitant consumption. The hypothesis proposed for triggering this metabolic shift to lactate and glucose concomitant consumption is that HEK293 cells metabolize extracellular lactate as a response to both extracellular protons and lactate accumulation, by means of cotransporting them (extracellular protons and lactate) into the cytosol. At this point, there exists a considerable controversy about how lactate reaches the mitochondrial matrix: the first hypothesis proposes that lactate is converted into pyruvate in the cytosol, and afterward, pyruvate enters into the mitochondria; the second alternative considers that lactate enters first into the mitochondria, and then, is converted into pyruvate. In this study, lactate transport and metabolization into mitochondria is shown to be feasible, as evidenced by means of respirometry tests with isolated active mitochondria, including the depletion of lactate concentration of the respirometry assay. Although the capability of lactate metabolization by isolated mitochondria is demonstrated, the possibility of lactate being converted into pyruvate in the cytosol cannot be excluded from the discussion. For this reason, the calculation of the metabolic fluxes for an HEK293 cell line was performed for the different metabolic phases observed in batch cultures under pH controlled and noncontrolled conditions, considering both hypotheses. The main objective of this study is to evaluate the redistribution of cellular metabolism and compare the differences or similarities between the phases before and after the metabolic shift of HEK293 cells (shift observed when pH is not controlled). That is from a glucose consumption/lactate production phase to a glucose-lactate coconsumption phase. Interestingly, switching to a glucose and lactate cometabolization results in a better-balanced cell metabolism, with decreased glucose and amino acids uptake rates, affecting minimally cell growth. This behavior could be applied to further develop new approaches in terms of cell engineering and to develop improved cell culture strategies in the field of animal cell technology.

The components of shear stress affecting insect cells used with the baculovirus expression vector system

Insect-based expression platforms such as the baculovirus expression vector system (BEVS) are widely used for the laboratory- and industrial-scale production of recombinant proteins. Thereby, major drawbacks to gain high-quality proteins are the lytic infection cycle and the shear sensitivity of infected insect cells due to turbulence and aeration. Smaller bubbles were formerly assumed to be more harmful than larger ones, but we found that cell damage is also dependent on the concentration of protective agents such as Pluronic®. At the appropriate concentration, Pluronic forms a layer around air bubbles and hinders the attachment of cells, thus limiting the damage. In this context, we used microaeration to vary bubble sizes and confirmed that size is not the most important factor, but the total gas surface area in the reactor is. If the surface area exceeds a certain threshold, the concentration of Pluronic is no longer sufficient for cell protection. To investigate the significance of shear forces, a second study was carried out in which infected insect cells were cultivated in a hollow fiber module to protect them from shear forces. Both model studies revealed important aspects of the design and scale-up of BEVS processes for the production of recombinant proteins.

Current good manufacturing practice in plant automation of biological production processes

The production of biologicals is subject to strict governmental regulations. These are drawn up in current good manufacturing practices (cGMP), a.o. by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. To implement cGMP in a production facility, plant automation becomes an essential tool. For this purpose Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES) have been developed that control all operations inside a production facility. The introduction of these recipe-driven control systems that follow ISA S88 standards for batch processes has made it possible to implement cGMP regulations in the control strategy of biological production processes. Next to this, an MES offers additional features such as stock management, planning and routing tools, process-dependent control, implementation of software sensors and predictive models, application of historical data and on-line statistical techniques for trend analysis and detection of instrumentation failures. This paper focuses on the development of new production strategies in which cGMP guidelines are an essential part.

CO(2) in large-scale and high-density CHO cell perfusion culture

Productivity in a CHO perfusion culture reactor was maximized when pCO(2) was maintained in the range of 30-76 mm Hg. Higher levels of pCO(2) (> 150 mm Hg) resulted in CHO cell growth inhibition and dramatic reduction in productivity. We measured the oxygen utilization and CO(2) production rates for CHO cells in perfusion culture at 5.55×10(-17) mol cell(-1) sec(-1) and 5.36×10(-17) mol cell(-1) sec(-1) respectively. A simple method to directly measure the mass transfer coefficients for oxygen and carbon dioxide was also developed. For a 500 L bioreactor using pure oxygen sparge at 0.002 VVM from a microporous frit sparger, the overall apparent transfer rates (k(L)a+k(A)A) for oxygen and carbon dioxide were 0.07264 min(-1) and 0.002962 min(-1) respectively. Thus, while a very low flow rate of pure oxygen microbubbles would be adequate to meet oxygen supply requirements for up to 2.1×10(7) cells/mL, the low CO(2) removal efficiency would limit culture density to only 2.4×10(6) cells/mL. An additional model was developed to predict the effect of bubble size on oxygen and CO(2) transfer rates. If pure oxygen is used in both the headspace and sparge, then the sparging rate can be minimized by the use of bubbles in the size range of 2-3 mm. For bubbles in this size range, the ratio of oxygen supply to carbon dioxide removal rates is matched to the ratio of metabolic oxygen utilization and carbon dioxide generation rates. Using this strategy in the 500 L reactor, we predict that dissolved oxygen and CO(2) levels can be maintained in the range to support maximum productivity (40% DO, 76 mm Hg pCO(2)) for a culture at 10(7) cells/mL, and with a minimum sparge rate of 0.006 vessel volumes per minute.A = volumetric agitated gas-liquid interfacial area at the top of the liquid, 1/mB = cell broth bleeding rate from the vessel, L/minCER = carbon dioxide evolution rate in the bioreactor, mol/min[CO(2)] = dissolved CO(2) concentration in liquid, M[CO(2)](*) = CO(2) concentration in equilibrium with sparger gas, M[CO(2)](**) = CO(2) concentration in equilibrium with headspace gas, MCO(2)(1) = dissolved carbon dioxide molecule in water[C(T)] = total carbonic species concentration in bioreactor medium, M[C(T)](F) = total carbonic species concentration in feed medium, MD = bioreactor diameter, mD(I) = impeller diameter, mD(b) = the initial delivered bubble diameter, mF = fresh medium feeding rate, L/minH(L) = liquid height in the vessel, mk(A) = carbon dioxide transfer coefficient at liquid surface, m/mink (infA) (supO) = oxygen transfer coefficient at liquid surface, m/min.

Drosophila melanogaster S2 cells for expression of heterologous genes: From gene cloning to bioprocess development

In the present review we discuss strategies that have been used for heterologous gene expression in Drosophila melanogaster Schneider 2 (S2) cells using plasmid vectors. Since the growth of S2 cells is not dependent on anchorage to solid substrates, these cells can be easily cultured in suspension in large volumes. The factors that most affect the growth and gene expression of S2 cells, namely cell line, cell passage, inoculum concentration, culture medium, temperature, dissolved oxygen concentration, pH, hydrodynamic forces and toxic metabolites, are discussed by comparison with other insect and mammalian cells. Gene expression, cell metabolism, culture medium formulation and parameters involved in cellular respiration are particularly emphasized. The experience of the authors with the successful expression of a biologically functional protein, the rabies virus glycoprotein (RVGP), by recombinant S2 cells is presented in the topics covered.

Estimation of rates of oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide evolution of animal cell culture using material and energy balances

Material and degree of reductance balance equations are used to estimate the rates of oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide evolution of animal cell cultures. Lumped compositions, molecular weight and reductance degree of cellular protein, monoclonal antibody, biomass and amino acid consumption (excluding glutamine and alanine) are found to be relatively constant for different hybridoma cell lines and may be used as regularities. The calculated rates of oxygen uptake and carbon dioxide evolution agree well with experimental values of several different cultures reported in the literature. This simple method gives the same results as calculated on the basis of a detailed metabolic reaction network.

Adaptation of the "Dynamic Method" for measuring the specific respiration rate in oxygen transfer systems through diffusion membrane

Monitoring the specific respiration rate (Q(O2)) is a valuable tool to evaluate cell growth and physiology. However, for low Q(O2) values the accuracy may depend on the measurement methodology, as it is the case in animal cell culture. The widely used "Dynamic Method" imposes serious difficulties concerning oxygen transfer cancellation, especially through membrane oxygenation. This paper presents an improved procedure to this method, through an automated control of the gas inlet composition that can minimize the residual oxygen transfer driving force during the Q(O2) measurement phase. The improved technique was applied to animal cell cultivation, particularly three recombinant S2 (Drosophila melanogaster) insect cell lines grown in a membrane aeration bioreactor. The average measurements of the proposed method reached 98% of stationary liquid phase balance method, taken as a reference, compared to 21% when the traditional method was used. Furthermore, this methodology does not require knowledge of the volumetric transfer coefficient k(L)a, which may vary during growth.

On-line monitoring of respiration in recombinant-baculovirus infected and uninfected insect cell bioreactor cultures

Respiration rates in Spodoptera frugiperda (Sf-9) cell bioreactor cultures were successfully measured on-line using two methods: The O(2) uptake rate (OUR) was determined using gas phase pO(2) values imposed by a dissolved oxygen controller and the CO(2) evolution rate (CER) was measured using an infrared detector. The measurement methods were accurate, reliable, and relatively inexpensive. The CER was routinely determined in bioreactor cultures used for the production of several recombinant proteins. Simple linear relationships between viable cell densities and both OUR and CER in exponentially growing cultures were used to predict viable cell density. Respiration measurements were also used to follow the progress of baculoviral infections in Sf-9 cultures. Infection led to increases in volumetric and per-cell respiration rates. The relationships between respiration and several other culture parameters, including viable cell density, cell protein, cell volume, glucose consumption, lactate production, viral titer, and recombinant beta-galactosidase accumulation, were examined. The extent of the increase in CER following infection and the time postinfection at which maximum CER was attained were negatively correlated with the multiplicity of infection (MOI) at multiplicities below the level required to infect all the cells in a culture. Delays in the respiration peak related to the MOI employed were correlated with delays in the peak in recombinant protein accumulation. DO levels in the range 5-100% did not exert any major effects on viable cell densities, CER, or product titer in cultures infected with a baculovirus expressing recombinant beta-galactosidase.

Use of glucose consumption rate (GCR) as a tool to monitor and control animal cell production processes in packed-bed bioreactors

For animal cell cultures growing in packed-bed bioreactors where cell number cannot be determined directly, there is a clear need to use indirect methods that are not based on cell counts in order to monitor and control the process. One option is to use the glucose consumption rate (GCR) of the culture as an indirect measure to monitor the process in bioreactors. This study was done on a packed-bed bioreactor process using recombinant CHO cells cultured on Fibra-Cel disk carriers in perfusion mode at high cell densities. A key step in the process is the switch of the process from the cell growth phase to the production phase triggered by a reduction of the temperature. In this system, we have used a GCR value of 300 g of glucose per kilogram of disks per day as a criterion for the switch. This paper will present results obtained in routine operations for the monitoring and control of an industrial process at pilot-scale. The process operated with this GCR-based strategy yielded consistent, reproducible process performance across numerous bioreactor runs performed on multiple production sites.

Oxygen supply for CHO cells immobilized on a packed-bed of Fibra-Cel® disks

Packed-bed bioreactors (PBR) have proven to be efficient systems to culture mammalian cells at very high cell density in perfusion mode, thus leading to very high volumetric productivity. However, the immobilized cells must be continuously supplied with all nutrients in sufficient quantities to remain viable and productive over the full duration of the perfusion culture. Among all nutrients, oxygen is the most critical since it is present at very low concentration due to its low solubility in cell culture medium. This work presents the development of a model for oxygenation in a packed-bed bioreactor system. The experimental system used to develop the model was a packed-bed of Fibra-Cel disk carriers used to cultivate Chinese Hamster Ovary cells at high density ( approximately 6.1 x 10(7) cell/mL) in perfusion mode. With the help of this model, it was possible to identify if a PBR system is operated in optimal or sub-optimal conditions. Using the model, two options were proposed, which could improve the performance of the basal system by about twofold, that is, by increasing the density of immobilized cells per carrier volume from 6.1 x 10(7) to 1.2 x 10(8) cell/mL, or by increasing the packed-bed height from 0.2 to 0.4 m. Both strategies would be rather simple to test and implement in the packed-bed bioreactor system used for this study. As a result, it would be possible to achieve a substantial improvement of about twofold higher productivity as compared with the basal conditions.

Monitoring of temperature effects on animal cell metabolism in a packed bed process

Animal cell (Chinese Hamster Ovary) concentration was determined on-line in a packed bed process using dielectric spectroscopy. This enabled the evaluation of the effect of temperature on specific metabolic rates during 3 months of continuous culture. The effect of low cultivation temperature on cell growth and metabolism was monitored, and the data were used for process development. At 37 degrees C cells grew exponentially with a specific growth rate of 0.038 d-1 and specific glucose uptake and lactate production rates increased continually. Reduction of the temperature to 33.5 degrees C resulted in a lowering of these metabolic rates while having no effect on cell proliferation. Subsequent reduction of the temperature to 32 degrees C resulted in stabilization of the cell concentration at a high density (3.6 x 10(7) cell per mL of packed bed). In addition, the specific production rate of the protein of interest increased by a factor of 6 compared to the value at 37 degrees C. During the stationary phase at 32 degrees C, all other specific metabolic rates could be controlled to low and constant levels.

Advances in animal cell recombinant protein production: GS-NS0 expression system

The production of recombinant proteins using mammalian cell expression systems is of growing importance within biotechnology, largely due to the ability of specific mammalian cells to carry out post-translational modifications of the correct fidelity. The Glutamine Synthetase-NS0 system is now one such industrially important expression system.Glutamine synthetase catalyses the formation ofglutamine from glutamate and ammonia. NS0 cellscontain extremely low levels of endogenous glutaminesynthetase activity, therefore exogenous glutaminesynthetase can be used efficiently as a selectablemarker to identify successful transfectants in theabsence of glutamine in the media. In addition, theinclusion of methionine sulphoximine, an inhibitor ofglutamine synthetase activity, enables furtherselection of those clones producing relatively highlevels of transfected glutamine synthetase and henceany heterologous gene which is coupled to it. Theglutamine synthetase system technology has been usedfor research and development purposes during thisdecade and its importance is clearly demonstrated nowthat two therapeutic products produced using thissystem have reached the market place.

Measurement of volumetric (OUR) and determination of specific (qO2) oxygen uptake rates in animal cell cultures

Oxygen is a key substrate in animal cell metabolism. It has been reported that the oxygen uptake rate (OUR) is a good indicator of cellular activity, and even under some conditions, a good indicator of the number of viable cells. The measurement of OUR is difficult due to many different reasons. In particular, the very low specific consumption rate (0.2 x 10(-12) mol cell h-1), the sensitivity of the cells to variations in dissolved oxygen concentration and the difficulty to provide oxygen without damaging the cells are problems which must be taken into account for the development of OUR measurement methods. Different solutions based on an oxygen balance on either the liquid phase or around the entire reactor, and with a variable or stable concentration of dissolved oxygen have been reported. The accuracy of the OUR measurements and the required analytical devices are very different from method to method.