Mine tailings composition in a historic site: implications for ecological restoration

Geochemical analyses of metal(loid) fractions do not predict plant uptake behavior: Are plant bioassays better tools to predict mine rehabilitation success?

Management of metal(loid) tailings at historic sites presents environmental hazards usually requiring rehabilitation to mitigate pollution risks. Strategies employed include capping or establishing vegetation directly, which requires tailings assessments to determine suitable rehabilitation approaches. Assessments are typically geochemical analyses, but plant based approaches may provide a more accurate measure of revegetation success although they are often limited to germination indices. This study uses the plant bioassay (Rhizotest™) with common geochemical assessment to predict plant uptake of metal(loid)s and the subsequent likely rehabilitation success. Pb/Zn tailings from five legacy sites within the UK and Ireland were characterized for pH, EC, water soluble and CaCl₂-extractable content and aqua regia extractable content. Uptake of Sb, As, Cd, Cu, Ca, Mg, Mn, Zn, Pb was determined in shoots and roots of Lolium perenne. Total Zn, Pb, Sb, Cd and As in tailings ranged from 694 to 2683 mg kg^-1, 1252 to 8072 mg kg^-1, 14 to 148 mg kg^-1, 1.3 to 44 mg kg^-1 and 1.3 to 45 mg kg^-1, respectively. The only correlation found between total and water soluble or CaCl₂-extractable metal(loid) contents was for Cd, where r = 0.8 for total and CaCl₂-extractable fractions. Limited uptake and translocation risk was identified for major contaminants Zn and Pb in most tailings samples but in some cases exceedance of phytotoxic threshold values occurred that was not reflected in geochemical analysis. Crucially, although total Cd and Sb content was relatively low (< 20 mg kg^-1) in some tailings, elevated plant content for some samples highlights phytotoxic risk from minor elements. Results indicate that screening based on geochemical content is not sufficiently predictive of metal(loid) phytoavailability to reliably inform mine rehabilitation strategies. We therefore strongly recommend that geochemical analyses are supplemented with plant based bioassay to plan mine tailings revegetation and reduce risk of wider ecosystem metal(loid) transfer.

Afforestation may influence changes in tailing heaps in a long time

A soil and plant survey was carried out in a tailing heap afforested 30 years ago to gain information about the changes in the tailing and metal uptake by plants. A poor development of Technosol was found. It was observed accumulation of OM spatio temporarily. Metal concentrations in the soil profile varied between plots. Extractable Pb concentrations ranged from 0.4 to 2.9%; extractable Cd varied 9.7-46% of the total concentration. PCA analysis shows DTPA-Zn and DTPA-Cu, Na, K, and OM have the widest concentrations range between soil layers. Casuarina equisetifolia and Pennisetum clandestinum formed a pristine uniform litter layer, whereas Eucalyptus camaldulensis did not form a litter layer. Casuarina equisetifolia has a higher population density (756 p ha^-1) compared to Populus nigra (528 p ha^-1) and E. camaldulensis (621 p ha^-1). Pennisetum clandestinum grew successfully and covered the tailing, but Cd and Pb concentrations were above the domestic animal toxicity limits, 0.5 and 10 mg kg^-1, respectively. Populus nigra absorbed more Zn than Casuarina equisetifolia and Eucalyptus camaldulensis. Trees species did not accumulate high foliar Cu and Zn concentrations, but Pb (47.7-124.3 mg kg^-1) and Cd (5.7-26.8 mg kg^-1) concentrations are over those reported for mature leaf tissues. HighlightsPennisetum clandestinum formed soil cover on remediated plots.Casuarina equisetifolia was efficient in forming a litter soil horizon.Trasdescantia fluminensis accumulated Pb.Populus nigra accumulated Zn and Cd from the tailing heap.

The chemistry and toxicity of discharge waters from copper mine tailing impoundment in the valley of the Apuseni Mountains in Romania

Copper mining generates large quantities of waste, tailings, and acid outflows causing long-term environmental impacts and potential threats to human health. Valea Şesei is the largest tailing impoundment in Romania, created by flooding the valley (known as Valea Şesei) of the Metalliferous Mountains (a division of the Apuseni Mountains) with copper mining waste. The present study (i) estimated the total volume of tailings in this area; (ii) screened the concentration of 65 elements (rare earth and platinum group elements, alkali metals and alkali earth metals, transition and post-transition metals and metalloids) and cyanide concentrations in wastewater samples collected from tailing impoundment; (iii) evaluated the toxicity of these water samples using five in vitro bioassays employing human cells isolated from healthy donors and a short-term (1 h) exposure model. The sampled waters were highly acidic (pH 2.1-4.9) and had high electrical conductivity (2.80-15.61 mS cm^-1). No cyanides were detected in any sample. Water samples collected from the stream (AMD) inflowing to the tailing impoundment were characterized by the greatest concentrations of alkali metals, alkaline earth metals, transition and post-transition metals, metalloids, rare earth elements, and noble metal group. At other sites, the elemental concentrations were lower but remained high enough to pose a relevant risk. The greatest magnitude of in vitro toxic effects was induced by AMD. Observed alterations included redox imbalance in human neutrophils followed by lipid peroxidation and decreased cell survival, significant aggregation of red blood cells, and increased prothrombin time. The study highlights that Valea Şesei is a large sink for toxic elements, posing environmental and health risks, and requiring action to prevent further release of chemicals and to initiate restoration of the area.

Application of magnetic methods for assessment of soil restoration in the vicinity of metallurgical copper-processing plant in Bulgaria

Copper ore mining and processing are among the most harmful anthropogenic influences for the environment and they are a subject of international and national law regulations. Recultivation of areas influenced by mining and processing industry is commonly applied and monitored in order to restore as much as possible the natural environment. In this study, environmental magnetic methods are applied in order to assess the degree of soil restoration in terms of soil development, after remediation of waste dump from Cu-processing plant. Soils developed under birch forest stands of different age (5, 15, and 25 years) as well as raw waste material were sampled along depth down to 20-30 cm. Variations in magnetic parameters and ratios obtained (magnetic susceptibility, frequency-dependent magnetic susceptibility, anhysteretic remanence (ARM), isothermal remanence (IRM), ARM/IRM_100mT) suggest the presence of magnetic enhancement in the upper 0-15 cm, the thickness of this layer varying depending on the age of the forest stand. Magnetic mineral responsible for this enhancement is of magnetite type, while waste material contains a large amount of hematite, as evidenced by coercivity analysis of IRM acquisition curves and thermal demagnetization of composite IRM. Magnetic grain-sized proxy parameters suggest that magnetite particles are coarser, magnetically stable, while no or minor amount of superparamagnetic grains were detected at room temperature. A well-defined linear regression between the topsoil magnetic susceptibility and the approximate age of the forest stand provides an indication that the magnetic enhancement is of pedogenic origin. It is concluded that the observed magnetic enhancement of recultivated soils studied is linked to a combined effect of pedogenic contribution and possible additions of industrial ashes as a liming agent for soil restoration.

Vegetation successfully prevents oxidization of sulfide minerals in mine tailings

The oxidization of metal sulfide in tailings causes acid mine drainage. However, it remains unclear whether vegetation prevents the oxidization of metal sulfides. The oxidization characteristics and microbial indices of the tailings in the presence of various plant species were investigated to explore the effects of vegetation on the oxidization of sulfide minerals in tailings. The pH, reducing sulfur, free iron oxides (Fed), chemical oxygen consumption (COC) and biological oxygen consumption (BOC) were measured. Key iron- and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria (Acidithiobacillus spp., Leptospirillum spp. and Thiobacillus spp.) were quantified using real-time PCR. The results indicate that vegetation growing on tailings can effectively prevent the oxidization of sulfide minerals in tailings. A higher pH and reducing-sulfur content and lower Fed were observed in the 0-30 cm depth interval in the presence of vegetation compared to bare tailings (BT). The COC gradually decreased with depth in all of the soil profiles; specifically, the COC rapidly decreased in the 10-20 cm interval in the presence of vegetation but gradually decreased in the BT profiles. Imperata cylindrica (IC) and Chrysopogon zizanoides (CZ) profiles contained the highest BOC in the 10-20 cm interval. The abundance of key iron- and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria in the vegetated tailings were significantly lower than in the BT; in particular, IC was associated with the lowest iron- and sulfur-oxidizing bacterial abundance. In conclusion, vegetation successfully prevented the oxidization of sulfide minerals in the tailings, and Imperata cylindrica is the most effective in reducing the number of iron- and sulfur-oxidizing bacteria and helped to prevent the oxidization of sulfide minerals in the long term.

Sustainable Remediation of Legacy Mine Drainage: A Case Study of the Flight 93 National Memorial

Pollution from mining activities is a global environmental concern, not limited to areas of current resource extraction, but including a broader geographic area of historic (legacy) and abandoned mines. The pollution of surface waters from acid mine drainage is a persistent problem and requires a holistic and sustainable approach to addressing the spatial and temporal complexity of mining-specific problems. In this paper, we focus on the environmental, socio-economic, and legal challenges associated with the concurrent activities to remediate a coal mine site and to develop a national memorial following a catastrophic event. We provide a conceptual construct of a socio-ecological system defined at several spatial, temporal, and organizational scales and a critical synthesis of the technical and social learning processes necessary to achieving sustainable environmental remediation. Our case study is an example of a multi-disciplinary management approach, whereby collaborative interaction of stakeholders, the emergence of functional linkages for information exchange, and mediation led to scientifically informed decision making, creative management solutions, and ultimately environmental policy change.

Field-scale study of the influence of differing remediation strategies on trace metal geochemistry in metal mine tailings from the Irish Midlands

Mine tailings represent a globally significant source of potentially harmful elements (PHEs) to the environment. The management of large volumes of mine tailings represents a major challenge to the mining industry and environmental managers. This field-scale study evaluates the impact of two highly contrasting remediation approaches to the management and stabilisation of mine tailings. The geochemistry of the tailings, overlying amendment layers and vegetation are examined in the light of the different management approaches. Pseudo-total As, Cd and Pb concentrations and solid-state partitioning (speciation), determined via sequential extraction, were established for two Tailings Management Facilities (TMFs) in Ireland subjected to the following: (1) a 'walk-away' approach (Silvermines) and (2) application of an amendment layer (Galmoy). PHE concentrations in roots and herbage of grasses growing on the TMFs were also determined. Results identify very different PHE concentration profiles with depth through the TMFs and the impact of remediation approach on concentrations and their potential bioavailability in the rooting zone of grass species. Data also highlight the importance of choice of grass species in remediation approaches and the benefits of relatively shallow-rooting Agrostis capillaris and Festuca rubra varieties. In addition, data from the Galmoy TMF indicate the importance of regional soil geochemistry for interpreting the influence of the PHE geochemistry of capping and amendment layers applied to mine tailings.

Assessing metal transfer to vegetation and grazers on reclaimed pyritic Zn and Pb tailings

A study of the concentrations of zinc and lead in an engineered soil capping system overlying sulphide mine tailings was undertaken. Tailings geochemistry, soil cover and vegetation were monitored over a 4-year period, and a cattle grazing demonstration exercise was conducted over a 1-year period. Whilst the tailings had a relatively high pyrite content and demonstrated oxidation, a circum neutral pH was observed for the duration of the study period due to the high dolomitic content. No evidence of metal mobility into the soil cover and vegetation was observed over the monitoring period. Relatively high Zn herbage content is attributed to the glacial till component of the soil cover. Similarly, no evidence of metal transfer to grazing cattle was observed through blood and tissue analysis with Zn content not significantly different from control animals. Pb tissue content was below limit of detection.