Genetic fusion of three tandem copies of murine C3d sequences to diphtheria toxin fragment B elicits a decreased fragment B-specific antibody response

B cell targeting by molecular adjuvants for enhanced immunogenicity

INTRODUCTION

Adjuvants are critical components of vaccines to improve the quality and durability of immune responses. Molecular adjuvants are a specific subclass of adjuvants where ligands of known immune-modulatory receptors are directly fused to an antigen. Co-stimulation of the B cell receptor (BCR) and immune-modulatory receptors through this strategy can augment downstream signaling to improve antibody titers and/or potency, and survival in challenge models.

AREAS COVERED

C3d has been the most extensively studied molecular adjuvant and shown to improve immune responses to a number of antigens. Similarly, tumor necrosis superfamily ligands, such as BAFF and APRIL, as well as CD40, CD180, and immune complex ligands can also improve humoral immunity as molecular adjuvants.

EXPERT OPINION

However, no single strategy has emerged that improves immune outcomes in all contexts. Thus, systematic exploration of molecular adjuvants that target B cell receptors will be required to realize their full potential as next-generation vaccine technologies.

Complement regulation of T-cell alloimmunity

Complement proteins are generated both by the liver (systemic compartment) and by peripheral tissue-resident cells and migratory immune cells (local compartment). The immune cell-derived, alternative pathway complement components activate spontaneously, yielding local, but not systemic, production of C3a and C5a. These anaphylatoxins bind to their respective G-protein-coupled receptors, the C3a receptor and the C5a receptor, expressed on T cells and antigen-presenting cells, leading to their reciprocal activation and driving T-cell differentiation, expansion, and survival. Complement deficiency or blockade attenuates T-cell-mediated autoimmunity and delays allograft rejection in mice. Increasing complement activation, achieved by genetic removal of the complement regulatory protein decay accelerating factor, enhances murine T-cell immunity and accelerates allograft rejection. Signaling through the C3a receptor and the C5a receptor reduces suppressive activity of natural regulatory T cells and the generation and stability of induced regulatory T cells. The concepts, initially generated in mice, recently were confirmed in human immune cells, supporting the need for testing of complement targeting therapies in organ transplants patients.

Immune cell-derived C3a and C5a costimulate human T cell alloimmunity

Emerging evidence indicates that complement provides costimulatory signals for murine T cells but whether complement impacts human T cells remains unclear. We observed production of complement activation products C3a and C5a during in vitro cultures of human T cells responding to allogeneic dendritic cells (DC). Both partners expressed the receptors for C3a (C3aR) and C5a (C5aR) and C3aR- and C5aR-antagonists inhibited T cell proliferation. Recombinant C3a/C5a promoted CD4(+) T cell expansion, bypassed the inhibitory effects of CTLA4-Ig, and induced AKT phosphorylation, the latter biochemically linking C3aR/C5aR to known T cell signaling pathways. Lowering DC C3a/C5a production by siRNA knockdown of DC C3 reduced T cell alloresponses. Conversely downregulating DC expression of the complement regulatory protein decay-accelerating factor increased immune cell C3a/C5a and augmented T cell proliferation, identifying antigen presenting cells as the dominant complement source. Pharmacological C5aR blockade reduced graft versus host disease (GVHD) scores, prolonged survival, and inhibited T cell responses in NOD scid γc(null) mouse recipients of human peripheral blood mononuclear cells, verifying that the mechanisms apply in vivo. Together our findings unequivocally document that immune cell-derived complement impacts human T cell immunity and provide the foundation for future studies targeting C3aR/C5aR as treatments of GVHD and organ transplant rejection in humans.

DENV-2 subunit proteins fused to CR2 receptor-binding domain (P28)-induces specific and neutralizing antibodies to the Dengue virus in mice

Domain III (DIII) of the dengue virus (DENV) envelope (E) protein induces strong neutralizing type-specific antibodies. In addition, a region near the fusion loop in domain II (DII) induces the production of cross-reactive antibodies with neutralizing potential. Thus, this study aimed to generate DENV-2 recombinant fusion proteins (i.e., rEII*EIII and rEII*EIII/NS1*) either alone or fused to 3 copies of P28, the minimum CR2-binding domain of the complement protein C3d. The 4 recombinant proteins were generated in a Drosophila melanogaster Schneider 2 (S2) cell system. The expression and secretion of the recombinant proteins were confirmed in vitro using immunofluorescence (IF) and western blot (WB) analyses. Human dengue immune serum samples recognized recombinant proteins. The immunogenicity of the 4 proteins in BALB/c mice was analyzed using ELISA, and the results revealed that the induced specific antibody response was higher in the groups of mice immunized with the P28 fusion proteins. Interestingly, although the 4 recombinant proteins were able to elicit high levels of neutralizing antibodies in BALB/c mice; no adjuvant effect was observed in terms of neutralizing antibodies in the groups immunized with proteins containing P28. Thus, ELISA and PRNT50 assays may evaluate different epitopes and responses, where ELISA showed a wider response that did not always correlate with neutralization. Furthermore, the elicited antibodies were able to recognize the immobilized E glycoprotein of DENV. All mice vaccinated with the DENV-2 recombinant proteins showed induction of higher levels of IgG1 antibodies than of IgG2a antibodies.

A vaccine directed to B cells and produced by cell-free protein synthesis generates potent antilymphoma immunity

Clinical studies of idiotype (Id) vaccination in patients with lymphoma have established a correlation between the induced anti-Id antibody responses and favorable clinical outcomes. To streamline the production of an Id vaccine, we engineered a small diabody (Db) molecule containing both a B-cell-targeting moiety (anti-CD19) and a lymphoma Id. This molecule (αCD19-Id) was designed to penetrate lymph nodes and bind to noncognate B cells to form an antigen presentation array. Indeed, the αCD19-Id molecule accumulated on B cells in vivo after s.c. administration. These noncognate B cells, decorated with the diabody, could then stimulate the more rare Id-specific B cells. Peptide epitopes present in the diabody linker augmented the response by activating CD4(+) helper T cells. Consequently, the αCD19-Id molecule induced a robust Id-specific antibody response and protected animals from tumor challenge. Such diabodies are produced in a cell-free protein expression system within hours of amplification of the specific Ig genes from the B-cell tumor. This customized product can now be available to vaccinate patients before they receive other, potentially immunosuppressive, therapies.

Enhanced immunogenicity of pneumococcal surface adhesin A (PsaA) in mice via fusion to recombinant human B lymphocyte stimulator (BLyS)

Background

B lymphocyte stimulator (BLyS) is a member of the tumor necrosis factor superfamily of ligands that mediates its action through three known receptors. BLyS has been shown to enhance the production of antibodies against heterologous antigens when present at elevated concentrations, supporting an immunostimulatory role for BLyS in vivo.

Methods

We constructed a fusion protein consisting of human BLyS and Pneumococcal Surface Adhesin A (PsaA) and used this molecule to immunize mice. The immunostimulatory attributes mediated by BLyS in vivo were evaluated by characterizing immune responses directed against PsaA.

Results

The PsaA-BLyS fusion protein was able to act as a co-stimulant for murine spleen cell proliferation induced with F(ab')₂ fragments of anti-IgM in vitro in a fashion similar to recombinant BLyS, and immunization of mice with the PsaA-BLyS fusion protein resulted in dramatically elevated serum antibodies specific for PsaA. Mice immunized with PsaA admixed with recombinant BLyS exhibited only modest elevations in PsaA-specific responses following two immunizations, while mice immunized twice with PsaA alone exhibited undetectable PsaA-specific serum antibody responses. Sera obtained from PsaA-BLyS immunized mice exhibited high titers of IgG1, IgG2a, IgG2b, and IgG3, but no IgA, while mice immunized with PsaA admixed with BLyS exhibited only elevated titers of IgG1 following two immunizations. Splenocytes from PsaA-BLyS immunized mice exhibited elevated levels of secretion of IL-2, IL-4 and IL-5, and a very modest but consistent elevation of IFN-γ following in vitro stimulation with PsaA. In contrast, mice immunized with either PsaA admixed with BLyS or PsaA alone exhibited modestly elevated to absent PsaA-specific recall responses for the same cytokines. Mice deficient for one of the three receptors for BLyS designated Transmembrane activator, calcium modulator, and cyclophilin ligand [CAML] interactor (TACI) exhibited attenuated PsaA-specific serum antibody responses following immunization with PsaA-BLyS relative to wild-type littermates. TACI-deficient mice also exhibited decreased responsiveness to a standard pneumococcal conjugate vaccine.

Conclusion

This study identifies covalent attachment of BLyS as a highly effective adjuvant strategy that may yield improved vaccines. In addition, this is the first report demonstrating an unexpected role for TACI in the elicitation of antibodies by the PsaA-BLyS fusion protein.

Reviewers

This article was reviewed by Jonathan Yewdell, Rachel Gerstein, and Michael Cancro (nominated by Andy Caton).

Immune adjuvants in early life: targeting the innate immune system to overcome impaired adaptive response

The neonatal phase is a transitory period characterized by an absence of memory cells, favoring a slow adaptive response prone to tolerance effects and the development of Th2-type responses. However, when appropriately stimulated, neonates may achieve an immune response comparable with adult counterparts. One strategy to stimulate the immunological response of neonates or children in early infancy has been to explore natural or synthetic ligands of cell receptors to stimulate innate immunity. The use of adjuvants for activating different cell receptors may be the key to enhancing neonatal adaptive immunity. This review highlights recent advances in the emerging field of molecular adjuvants of innate immune response and their implications for the development of immunotherapies, with particular focus on the neonatal period.

Differential effects of C3d on the immunogenicity of gene gun vaccines encoding Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium berghei MSP1(42)

The complement fragment C3d mediates B-cell activation via simultaneous engagement of the B-cell receptor and CD21 by antigen/C3d conjugates. Several studies demonstrated the potential of C3d as a molecular adjuvant for vaccination. In this work, C3d exerted differential effects on humoral immune responses after gene gun immunization of mice with plasmids encoding the malaria blood stage antigen MSP1(42) depending on the nature of the protein (Plasmodium falciparum vs. Plasmodium berghei MSP), the localization of the C3d moiety (C-terminal vs. N-terminal), and the presence of putative N-glycosylation sites. No improvement of protective efficacy by C3d attachment or mutation of glycosylation sites could be demonstrated by in vitro parasite growth inhibition assays or in vivo blood stage parasite challenges. Our data underscore the controversial role of C3d as molecular adjuvant.

Expression and purification of the immunogenically active fragment B of the Park Williams 8 Corynebacterium diphtheriae strain toxin

The construction of a hexahistidine-tagged version of the B fragment of diphtheria toxin (DTB) represents an important step in the study of the biological properties of DTB because it will permit the production of pure recombinant DTB (rDTB) in less time and with higher yields than currently available. In the present study, the genomic DNA of the Corynebacterium diphtheriae Park Williams 8 (PW8) vaccine strain was used as a template for PCR amplification of the dtb gene. After amplification, the dtb gene was cloned and expressed in competent Escherichia coli M15 cells using the expression vector pQE-30. The lysate obtained from transformed E. coli cells containing the rDTB PW8 was clarified by centrifugation and purified by affinity chromatography. The homogeneity of the purified rDTB PW8 was confirmed by immunoblotting using mouse polyclonal anti-diphtheria toxoid antibodies and the immune response induced in animals with rDTB PW8 was evaluated by ELISA and dermonecrotic neutralization assays. The main result of the present study was an alternative and accessible method for the expression and purification of immunogenically reactive rDTB PW8 using commercially available systems. Data also provided preliminary evidence that rabbits immunized with rDTB PW8 are able to mount a neutralizing response against the challenge with toxigenic C. diphtheriae.

C3d adjuvant activity is reduced by altering residues involved in the electronegative binding of C3d to CR2

The final degradation product of the complement protein C3, C3d, has been used as a molecular adjuvant to various antigens. Chimera proteins of the antigen and multiple copies of C3d were developed to test the adjuvant effect of this molecule. The main mechanism by which C3d enhances the immune response is interaction with CR2. In vitro studies showed that the avidity of C3d for CR2 is affected by residues located at the interacting surface (e.g. 170N) as well as by residues located in other areas. The role of the latter residues has been proposed to depend on the electrostatic nature of the C3d-CR2 interaction, where the charges of the whole molecules are responsible for their binding. C3d is primarily a negatively charged molecule, while CR2 is a positive one. Previous experiments demonstrated that elimination of a positive charge (K162A) in C3d enhanced its avidity for CR2, while elimination of negative charges or addition positives ones (D163A, N170R, respectively), impaired the avidity for CR2. Despite the extensive in vitro research, the role of these residues in the adjuvant effect of C3d is unclear. To study the role of residues at the interacting and non-interacting surface of C3d on the adjuvanticity, single as well as a double residue substitutions were engineered in the murine C3d (R162A, D163A, N170R and D163A-N170R) gene. Two copies of these mutant molecules were fused to HIV-1 Env(gp120) and the proteins were tested for their avidity to bind CR2 (sCR2). Later, these DNA constructs were tested in mice to determine their adjuvant capability. Mutation at residue 162 (R162A) neither enhanced nor impaired the avidity of Env(gp120)-C3d(2) for sCR2 in vitro. Mutations at residues D163A and N170R, on the other hand, reduced the binding affinity of Env(gp120)-C3d(2) for sCR2. Furthermore, these mutations synergized and abolished the interaction of C3d for CR2. The data correlated with the adjuvant capability of these molecules in the mouse model. In summary, residues that alter the electronegative status of C3d (D163A and N170R) impair the binding of chimera proteins to CR2, reducing the adjuvant activity of this molecule.

Fusion of C3d with hemagglutinin enhances protective immunity against swine influenza virus

H1N1 and H3N2 are the dominant subtypes causing swine influenza in China and other countries. It is important to develop effective vaccines against both H1N1 and H3N2 subtypes of swine influenza virus (SIV). We examined the effects of a DNA vaccine expressing an influenza HA fused to three copies of murine complement C3d in mice. Plasmids encoding soluble HA (sHA), complete HA (tmHA), or a soluble fused form of HA (sHA-mC3d3) were constructed from the H3N2 subtype of SIV. The immune response was monitored by an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assays, and virus neutralization tests. Analysis of antibody titers indicated that immunization with HA-mC3d3 resulted in higher titers of anti-HA antibodies and higher antibody affinities, compared with serum from mice immunized with sHA or tmHA. Furthermore, the C3d fusion increased the Th2-biased immune response, by inducing IL-4 production. Splenocytes from mice immunized with sHA-mC3d3 produced about three-fold more IL-4 than did splenocytes from mice immunized with sHA or tmHA. Seven days post-challenge with homologous virus (H3N2), no virus was isolated from the mice immunized with HA-expressing plasmids. However, 10 days post-challenge with heterologous virus (H1N1), only mice immunized with sHA-mC3d3 had no virus or microscopic lesions in the kidneys and cerebrum. In conclusion, C3d enhanced antibody responses to hemagglutinin and protective immunity against SIV of different subtypes.

The distinct effects of three tandem repeats of C3d in the immune responses against tumor-associated antigen hCGbeta by DNA immunization

Several examples have shown that C3d3, when fused to a corresponding antigen, had a strong adjuvant effect on certain specific antibody production. In a previous study, we attempted to prove that this was the case of the human chorionic gonadotrophin beta chain (hCGbeta)-induced immunity following DNA vaccination. However, we found that C3d3 when fused to hCGbeta inhibited rather than enhanced the antigen-specific immune response. In the present study, using hCGbeta DNA vaccine preparations, we demonstrated that C3d3 inhibited the antigen-specific humoral antibody response and several other immune responses, such as the hCGbeta specific lymphoproliferation. Such inhibitory effects of C3d3 were not related to the expression level of the target protein, the gender of the test mice, or the vector used. Contrastingly, C3d3 fused with the envelope protein of hepatitis B virus (PreS2/S) used as a control system resulted in the enhancement of both humoral and cell-mediated antigen-specific immune responses against HBV-preS2/S, which was consistent with other groups' adjuvant-effect findings. We further showed that the mechanisms involved in the inhibitory effect of C3d3 might be possible due to impairing the function of antigen presenting B lymphocytes and reducing the expression of transcription factors (T-bet and GATA-3) and cytokine IL-4. Collectively, unlike its usual expected adjuvant function, the fusion of C3d3 with the tumor-associated antigen hCGbeta was found to inhibit both humoral and cell-mediated antigen-specific immune responses. These findings indicate that research concerning tumor immune escapes and vaccine designs require further extensive attention.

Protective DNA vaccination against myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein is overcome by C3d in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Complement receptor 2 (CR2) and its physiological ligand, C3d, known for its molecular adjuvant property on the immune response, exhibit opposite effects with regard to autoimmunity. Although CR2 has been implicated in maintaining self-tolerance, recent studies reported a role for C3d signaling to CR2 in tolerance breakdown to self-antigens and the initiation of inflammatory autoimmune pathologies. In the present study, we have investigated the effect of C3d in a model of tolerogenic DNA vaccination encoding the myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG-DNA) which protected mice from the induction of an experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE). We show that fusing two or three copies of C3d to MOG overcomes the protective effect of DNA vaccination. Multimeric C3d was able to revert the unresponsiveness state of specific T cells induced by MOG-DNA, independently of a modification in the Th1/Th2 cytokine pattern. Interestingly, the adjuvant effect of C3d was not sufficient to boost the anti-MOG antibody response after DNA vaccination. These findings suggest that C3d might be involved in self-tolerance breakdown and could contribute to the pathogenesis of central nervous system autoimmune disorders.

Low doses of antigen coupled to anti-CR2 mAbs induce rapid and enduring IgG immune responses in mice and in cynomolgus monkeys

The complement system and B cell complement receptor 2 (CR2), specific for C component C3dg, play important roles in both the innate and adaptive immune response. We used hapten and protein conjugates of anti-CR2 mAbs as models for C3dg-opsonized antigens and immune complexes to examine the handling of and immune response to these reagents in mice and in non-human primates (NHP). Mice immunized and boosted i.v. with only 100 ng of Alexa 488 rat anti-mouse CR1/2 mAb 7G6 had strong IgG immune responses to the Alexa 488 hapten and to rat IgG, compared to very weak immune responses in mice treated with a comparable isotype control; larger doses of Alexa 488 mAb 7G6 did not increase the immune response. A vaccine constructed by cross-linking anthrax protective antigen to mAb 7G6 proved to be effective at low doses in generating sufficiently high titer serum IgG antibodies to neutralize anthrax lethal toxin in vitro and to protect mice from i.v. challenge with anthrax lethal toxin. When biotinylated HB135, a mouse mAb specific for human CR2, was injected i.v. into NHP, the probe manifested the same initial marginal zone B cell binding and subsequent localization to follicular dendritic cells as we have previously reported for comparable experiments in mice. Moreover, i.v. immunization of NHP with 1 microg/kg of Alexa 488 mAb HB135 promoted an IgG immune response to the Alexa 488 hapten and to mouse IgG. Taken together, these results demonstrate the efficacy of using anti-CR2 mAbs as antigen carriers for i.v. immunization with small amounts of antigens without adjuvant.

Cloning of a gene fragment encoding bovine complement component C3d with expression and characterization of derived fusion proteins

The gene fragment coding for bovine C3d gene (boC3d) was cloned and expressed as a component of fusion proteins destined for use in vaccine studies in cattle, and for in vitro experiments. This fragment of complement protein C3 (C3d) has been shown to enhance B cell responses when complexed with antigen. Three potential vaccine constructs were engineered to contain one, two or three boC3d units linked to a fragment of the leukotoxin of Mannheimia haemolytica A1, an economically important pathogen of cattle that causes a fibrinous pneumonia in calves. A recombinant biotinylated boC3d protein (for use in in vitro studies) was generated by endogenous biotinylation in Escherichia coli by means of the BirA holoenzyme synthetase. All recombinant proteins incorporated polyhistidine tags and were purified by nickel-agarose chromatography, then analyzed by SDS-PAGE and Western immunoblot. The identity of boC3d was confirmed by mass spectrometry, since monoclonal antibodies to boC3d were not available. To date, published research into the adjuvant activities of C3d has been limited to experiments in mice and rabbits, using antigens unrelated to diseases occurring naturally in these species. The boC3d fusion proteins expressed in this study will provide the basis for immunization trials in cattle and studies of receptor binding and cell activation of bovine lymphocytes.

Complement 3d: from molecular adjuvant to target of immune escape mechanisms

C3d is a fragment of the complement factor C3 and is generated in the course of complement activation. When bound to antigen in single or multiple copies, the B cell receptor and complement receptor 2 become co-crosslinked resulting in decreased or increased B cell responses depending on the valence of the antigen-C3d construct. When antigen-C3d constructs are used for the purpose of generating a protective immune response (vaccines), they may either enhance the expected response or suppress it depending on the nature of the antigen. Various pathogens use C3d to evade the immune system by inhibiting complement activation, invading and homing in host cells or masking immunogenic areas of pathogen proteins. Therefore, future vaccination strategies for infectious diseases and cancer employing C3d as a molecular adjuvant need to be carefully evaluated before choosing a target antigen in order to take advantage of the adjuvant effect of the complement component while avoiding potential vaccine complications associated with immune escape mechanisms.