Body-first versus brain-first biological subtyping of Parkinson's disease

Symmetric and Profound Monoaminergic Degeneration in Parkinson's Disease with Premotor REM Sleep Behavior Disorder

Background

Rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder (RBD) may precede or follow motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease (PD). While over 70% of idiopathic RBD cases phenoconvert within a decade, a small subset develops PD after a more extended period or remains nonconverted. These heterogeneous manifestations of RBD in PD prompt subtype investigations. Premotor RBD may signify "body-first" PD with bottom-up, symmetric synucleinopathy propagation.

Objective

Explore brainstem and nigrostriatal monoaminergic degeneration pattern differences based on premotor RBD presence and duration in de novo PD patients.

Methods

In a cross-sectional analysis of de novo PD patients (n = 150) undergoing FP-CIT PET and RBD Single-Question Screen, the cohort was categorized into groups with and without premotor RBD (PDRBD +/-), with further classification of PDRBD + based on a 10-year duration of premotor RBD. Analysis of FP-CIT binding in the striatum and pons, striatal asymmetry, and striatum-to-pons ratios compared patterns of nigrostriatal and brainstem monoaminergic degeneration.

Results

PDRBD + exhibited more severe and symmetrical striatal dopaminergic denervation compared to PDRBD-, with the difference in severity accentuated in the least-affected hemisphere. The PDRBD +<10Y subgroup displayed the most prominent striatal symmetry, supporting a more homogeneous "body-first" subtype. Pontine uptakes remained lower in PDRBD + even after adjusting for striatal uptake, suggesting early degeneration of pontine monoaminergic nuclei.

Conclusions

Premotor RBD in PD is associated with severe, symmetrical nigrostriatal and brainstem monoaminergic degeneration, especially in cases with PD onset within 10 years of RBD. This supports the concept of a "widespread, bottom-up" pathophysiological mechanism associated with premotor RBD in PD.

Estimating motor progression trajectory pursuant to temporal dynamic status of cardiac denervation in Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a multifaceted disease that encompasses diverse clinical phenotypes. The diversity of PD could be subtyped based on the temporal dynamic status of cardiac sympathetic innervation; (1) initially, denervated myocardium (peripheral nervous system-predominant; PNS-predominant), (2) preserved myocardium (central nervous system-predominant; CNS-predominant), and (3) preserved myocardium who developed cardiac sympathetic denervation (CSD) on the subsequent imaging (Converter; delayed cardiac denervation). This study assessed how the cardiac denervation could reflect the pathobiology. We investigated whether this phenotyping could help predict the motor progression trajectory of PD.

METHODS

Cardiac sympathetic innervation was evaluated using initial and sequential 123I-meta-iodobenzylguanidine myocardial scintigraphy and patients were stratified into three groups as above. Motor severity and progression were evaluated in each patient. The association between subtypes and dopaminergic nigrostriatal degeneration was analyzed. The influence of cardiac denervation on motor progression was also investigated.

RESULTS

Among the enrolled 195 patients, 144 PD subjects were defined as PNS-predominant, 16 as Converter, and 35 as CNS-predominant. The most severe nigrostriatal degeneration was observed in the PNS-predominant group and the dopaminergic degeneration was the most asymmetric in the CNS-predominant group. Positive linear trends of nigrostriatal degeneration and its asymmetric degeneration of striatum and globus pallidus were found across the patterns of cardiac sympathetic innervation (PNS-predominant vs. Converter vs. CNS-predominant). It indicated an increasing degree of asymmetric degeneration among the groups. A longitudinal estimation of motor progression revealed distinct cardiac denervation trajectories for each subtype.

CONCLUSIONS

These results implicated that the subtypes of CSD might indicate a predominant origin and spreading pattern of pathobiology.

Cardiac sympathetic "morbidity" might reflect the neurobiology of early Parkinson's disease

BACKGROUND

An appropriate extracranial biomarker that delineates endophenotypes of Parkinson's disease (PD) at an early stage and reflects the neurodegenerative process is lacking. An evaluation of myocardial sympathetic nerve terminals could be a good candidate. This study aimed to explore subtypes of PD patients that showed cardiac catecholaminergic vesicular defect and their characteristics.

METHODS

This study included 122 early drug-naïve PD patients who were followed for approximately 4-5 years. All patients were examined with 18F-N-(3-fluoropropyl)-2beta-carbon ethoxy-3beta-(4-iodophenyl) nortropane positron-emission tomography and 123I-meta-iodobenzylguanidine myocardial scintigraphy. Cardiac scans were reexamined two or three times. Patients were subgrouped into the sympathetic denervated group at the initial scan, those without evidence of denervated myocardium in the first and subsequent scans, and the converters whose myocardium was initially normal but became impaired in the subsequent scans. Cognition in 99 patients was initially assessed with neuropsychological tests. Any associations between cardiac denervation subtypes and presynaptic dopamine transporter densities were investigated. Cognitive status relevant to cardiac sympathetic denervation status was evaluated.

RESULTS

This study found that cross-sectional comparisons of presynaptic monoamine transporter availability with a predefined order of cardiac denervation groups revealed parallel degeneration. A quadratic correlation between cardiac catecholamine capacity and cognition was observed. This association was interpreted to reflect the early neurobiology of PD.

CONCLUSION

An observed cardiac catecholaminergic gradient was to mirror the central neurobiology of early PD.

Oral Health as a Risk Factor for Alzheimer Disease

In patients with Alzheimer's disease pathophysiological changes of the brain that initiate the onset of Alzheimer's disease include accumulation of amyloid-β plaques and phosphorylation of tau-tangles. A rather recently considered risk factor for the onset of Alzheimer's disease is poor oral health. The aim of this systematic review of the literature was to assess the potential association(s) of oral health as a risk factor for the onset of Alzheimer's disease. After a systematic search of Pubmed, Embase and Web of Science. A total of 1962 studies were assessed, of which 17 studies demonstrated possible associations between oral health diseases and Alzheimer's disease. 4 theories could be distinguished that describe the possible links between oral health and the development or onset of Alzheimer's disease; 1) role of pathogens, 2) role of inflammatory mediators, 3) role of APOE alleles and 4) role of Aβ peptide. The main common denominator of all the theories is the neuroinflammation due to poor oral health. Yet, there is insufficient evidence to prove a link due to the diversity of the designs used and the quality of the study design of the included studies. Therefore, further research is needed to find causal links between oral health and neuroinflammation that possibly can lead to the onset of Alzheimer's disease with the future intention to prevent cognitive decline by better dental care.

Clinical subtypes in patients with isolated REM sleep behaviour disorder

Patients with Parkinson's disease (PD) show a broad heterogeneity in clinical presentation, and subtypes may already arise in prodromal disease stages. Isolated REM sleep behaviour disorder (iRBD) is the most specific marker of prodromal PD, but data on clinical subtyping of patients with iRBD remain scarce. Therefore, this study aimed to identify iRBD subtypes. We conducted comprehensive clinical assessments in 66 patients with polysomnography-proven iRBD, including motor and non-motor evaluations, and applied a two-step cluster analysis. Besides, we compared iRBD clusters to matched healthy controls and related the resulting cluster solution to cortical and subcortical grey matter volumes by voxel-based morphometry analysis. We identified two distinct subtypes of patients based on olfactory function, dominant electroencephalography frequency, amount of REM sleep without atonia, depressive symptoms, disease duration, and motor functions. One iRBD cluster (Cluster I, late onset-aggressive) was characterised by higher non-motor symptom burden despite shorter disease duration than the more benign subtype (Cluster II, early onset-benign). Motor functions were comparable between the clusters. Patients from Cluster I were significantly older at iRBD onset and exhibited a widespread reduction of cortical grey matter volume compared to patients from Cluster II. In conclusion, our findings suggest the existence of clinical subtypes already in the prodromal stage of PD. Future longitudinal studies are warranted that replicate these findings and investigate the risk of the more aggressive phenotype for earlier phenoconversion and dementia development.

Are LRRK2 mysteries lurking in the gut?

Gut-brain axis and inflammation are two hot topics in Parkinson's disease (PD). In this setting, the leucine-rich repeat kinase 2 (LRRK2) gene, which encodes the eponym protein, has attracted much attention. LRRK2 is not only the gene most commonly associated with Parkinson's disease but also a susceptibility gene for Crohn's disease (CD), thereby suggesting that it may sit at the crossroads of gastrointestinal inflammation, Parkinson's, and Crohn's disease. In contrast to the accumulated data on LRRK2 in the central nervous system (CNS), research on LRRK2 in the digestive tract is still in its infancy, and the scope of the present review article is therefore to review existing studies on LRRK2 in the gastrointestinal tract in both physiological and pathological conditions. In light of current data on LRRK2 in the gastrointestinal tract, we discuss if LRRK2 could be or not regarded as a molecular link between gut inflammation, Parkinson's disease, and Crohn's disease, and we suggest directions for future research.

Nuclear Imaging Data-Driven Classification of Parkinson's Disease

BACKGROUND

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a heterogeneous neurodegenerative disorder characterized by motor and nonmotor symptoms. Several features have prognostic importance and have been used as key indicators for identifying clinical subtypes. However, the symptom-based classification approach has limitations with respect to the stability of the obtained subtypes.

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to identify subtypes of PD using nuclear imaging biomarkers targeting the cardiac sympathetic nervous and nigro-striatal systems and to compare patterns of cortical morphological change among obtained subtypes.

METHODS

We performed unbiased hierarchical cluster analysis using 123 I-metaiodobenzylguanidine cardiac scintigraphy and 123 I-N-(3-fluoropropyl)-2β-carbomethoxy-3β-(4-iodophenyl) nortropane single photon emission computed tomography data for 56 patients with PD. We compared clinical characteristics and the patterns of cortical atrophy in the obtained clusters.

RESULTS

Three clusters were identified and showed distinct characteristics in onset ages and dopamine-replacement therapy and deep brain stimulation requirements. According to the characteristics, clusters were classified into two subtypes, namely, "cardio-cortical impairment (CC)" and "dopaminergic-dominant dysfunction (DD)" subtype. The three clusters were named according to subtype and time since onset in which 14 patients were classified as "early DD," 25 as "advanced DD," and 17 as "early CC." Compared with the early DD subtype, the early CC subtype showed parietal-dominant diffuse cortical atrophy and the advanced DD subtype showed left-side predominant mild cortical atrophy.

CONCLUSIONS

Nuclear imaging biomarker-based classification can be used to identify clinically and pathologically relevant PD subtypes with distinct disease trajectories. © 2023 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Considering REM Sleep Behavior Disorder in the Management of Parkinson's Disease

Rapid eye movement (REM) sleep behavior disorder (RBD) is the result of the loss of physiological inhibition of muscle tone during REM sleep, characterized by dream-enacting behavior and widely recognized as a prodromal manifestation of alpha-synucleinopathies. Indeed, patients with isolated RBD (iRBD) have an extremely high estimated risk to develop a neurodegenerative disease after a long follow up. Nevertheless, in comparison with PD patients without RBD (PDnoRBD), the occurrence of RBD in the context of PD (PDRBD) seems to identify a unique, more malignant phenotype, characterized by a more severe burden of disease in terms of both motor and non-motor symptoms and increased risk for cognitive decline. However, while some medications (eg, melatonin, clonazepam, etc.) and non-pharmacological options have been found to have some therapeutic benefits on RBD there is no available treatment able to modify the disease course or, at least, slow down the neurodegenerative process underlying phenoconversion. In this scenario, the long prodromal phase may allow an early therapeutic window and, therefore, the identification of multimodal biomarkers of disease onset and progression is becoming increasingly crucial. To date, several clinical (motor, cognitive, olfactory, visual, and autonomic features) neurophysiological, neuroimaging, biological (biofluids or tissue biopsy), and genetic biomarkers have been identified and proposed, also in combination, as possible diagnostic or prognostic markers, along with a potential role for some of them as outcome measures and index of treatment response. In this review, we provide an insight into the present knowledge on both existing and future biomarkers of iRBD and highlight the difference with PDRBD and PDnoRBD, including currently available treatment options.

Mood disturbances in Parkinson's disease: From prodromal origins to application of animal models

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a complex illness with a constellation of environmental insults and genetic vulnerabilities being implicated. Strikingly, many studies only focus on the cardinal motor symptoms of the disease and fail to appreciate the major non-motor features which typically occur early in the disease process and are debilitating. Common comorbid psychiatric features, notably clinical depression, as well as anxiety and sleep disorders are thought to emerge before the onset of prominent motor deficits. In this review, we will delve into the prodromal stage of PD and how early neuropsychiatric pathology might unfold, followed by later motor disturbances. It is also of interest to discuss how animal models of PD capture the complexity of the illness, including depressive-like characteristics along with motor impairment. It remains to be determined how the underlying PD disease processes contributes to such comorbidity. But some of the environmental toxicants and microbial pathogens implicated in PD might instigate pro-inflammatory effects favoring α-synuclein accumulation and damage to brainstem neurons fueling the evolution of mood disturbances. We posit that comprehensive animal-based research approaches are needed to capture the complexity and time-dependent nature of the primary and co-morbid symptoms. This will allow for the possibility of early intervention with more novel and targeted treatments that fit with not only individual patient variability, but also with changes that occur over time with the evolution of the disease.

Gray Matter Volume Loss in Proposed Brain-First and Body-First Parkinson's Disease Subtypes

BACKGROUND

α-Synuclein pathology is associated with neuronal degeneration in Parkinson's disease (PD) and considered to sequentially spread across the brain (Braak stages). According to a new hypothesis of distinct α-synuclein spreading directions based on the initial site of pathology, the "brain-first" spreading subtype would be associated with a more asymmetric cerebral and nigrostriatal pathology than the "body-first" subtype.

OBJECTIVE

Here, we tested if proposed markers of brain-first PD (ie, higher dopamine transporter [DaT] asymmetry; absence of rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder [RBD]) are associated with a greater or more asymmetric reduction in gray matter volume (GMV) in comparison to body-first PD.

METHODS

Data of 255 de novo PD patients and 110 healthy controls (HCs) were retrieved from the Parkinson's Progression Markers Initiative. Structural magnetic resonance images were preprocessed, and GMVs and their hemispherical asymmetry were obtained for each of the neuropathologically defined Braak stages. Group and correlation comparisons were performed to assess differences in GMV and GMV asymmetry between PD subtypes.

RESULTS

PD patients demonstrated significantly smaller bilateral GMVs compared to HCs, in a pattern denoting stage-dependent disease-related brain atrophy. However, the degree of putaminal DaT asymmetry was not associated with reduced GMV or higher GMV asymmetry. Furthermore, RBD-negative and RBD-positive patients did not demonstrate a significant difference in GMV or GMV asymmetry.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings suggest that putative brain-first and body-first patients do not present diverging brain atrophy patterns. Although certainly not disproving the brain-first/body-first spreading hypothesis, this study fails to provide evidence in support of it. © 2022 The Authors. Movement Disorders published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Bidirectional Relationship Between Sleep Disturbances and Parkinson's Disease

Parkinson's disease (PD) is the second most common neurodegenerative disease after Alzheimer's disease (AD). Both diseases share common clinical and pathological features: the gradual progression of neurological and psychiatric symptoms caused by neuronal dysfunction and neuronal cell death due to the accumulation of misfolded and neurotoxic proteins. Furthermore, both of them are multifactorial diseases in which both genetic and non-genetic factors contribute to the disease course. Non-genetic factors are of particular interest for the development of preventive and therapeutic approaches for these diseases because they are modifiable; of these, sleep is a particularly intriguing factor. Sleep disturbances are highly prevalent among both patients with AD and PD. To date, research has suggested that sleep disturbances are a consequence as well as a risk factor for the onset and progression of AD, which implies a bidirectional relationship between sleep and AD. Whether such a relationship exists in PD is less certain, albeit highly plausible given the shared pathomechanisms. This review examines the current evidence for the bidirectional relationship between sleep and PD. It includes research in both humans and animal models, followed by a discussion of the current understanding of the mechanisms underlying this relationship. Finally, potential avenues of research toward achieving disease modification to treat or prevent PD are proposed. Although further efforts are crucial for preventing the onset and slowing the progress of PD, it is evident that sleep is a valuable candidate target for future interventions to improve the outcomes of PD patients.

Clinical and imaging evidence of brain-first and body-first Parkinson's disease

Braak's hypothesis has been extremely influential over the last two decades. However, neuropathological and clinical evidence suggest that the model does not conform to all patients with Parkinson's disease (PD). To resolve this controversy, a new model was recently proposed; in brain-first PD, the initial α-synuclein pathology arise inside the central nervous system, likely rostral to the substantia nigra pars compacta, and spread via interconnected structures - eventually affecting the autonomic nervous system; in body-first PD, the initial pathological α-synuclein originates in the enteric nervous system with subsequent caudo-rostral propagation to the autonomic and central nervous system. By using REM-sleep behavior disorder (RBD) as a clinical identifier to distinguish between body-first PD (RBD-positive at motor symptom onset) and brain-first PD (RBD-negative at motor symptom onset), we explored the literature to evaluate clinical and imaging differences between these proposed subtypes. Body-first PD patients display: 1) a larger burden of autonomic symptoms - in particular orthostatic hypotension and constipation, 2) more frequent pathological α-synuclein in peripheral tissues, 3) more brainstem and autonomic nervous system involvement in imaging studies, 4) more symmetric striatal dopaminergic loss and motor symptoms, and 5) slightly more olfactory dysfunction. In contrast, only minor cortical metabolic alterations emerge before motor symptoms in body-first. Brain-first PD is characterized by the opposite clinical and imaging patterns. Patients with pathological LRRK2 genetic variants mostly resemble a brain-first PD profile whereas patients with GBA variants typically conform to a body-first profile. SNCA-variant carriers are equally distributed between both subtypes. Overall, the literature indicates that body-first and brain-first PD might be two distinguishable entities on some clinical and imaging markers.