Combinatorial mutagenesis of rapidly evolving residues yields super-restrictor antiviral proteins

The Antiviral Activity of Equine Mx1 against Thogoto Virus Is Determined by the Molecular Structure of Its Viral Specificity Region

Mammalian myxovirus resistance (Mx) proteins are interferon-induced, large dynamin-like GTPases with a broad antiviral spectrum. Here, we analyzed the antiviral activity of selected mammalian Mx1 proteins against Thogoto virus (THOV). Of those, equine Mx1 (eqMx1) showed antiviral activity comparable to that of the human MX1 gene product, designated huMxA, whereas most Mx1 proteins were antivirally inactive. We previously demonstrated that the flexible loop L4 protruding from the stalk domain of huMxA, and especially the phenylalanine at position 561 (F561), determines its antiviral specificity against THOV (P. S. Mitchell, C. Patzina, M. Emerman, O. Haller, et al., Cell Host Microbe 12:598-604, 2012, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chom.2012.09.005). However, despite the similar antiviral activity against THOV, the loop L4 sequence of eqMx1 substantially differs from the one of huMxA. Mutational analysis of eqMx1 L4 identified a tryptophan (W562) and the adjacent glycine (G563) as critical antiviral determinants against THOV, whereas the neighboring residues could be exchanged for nonpolar alanines without affecting the antiviral activity. Further mutational analyses revealed that a single bulky residue at position 562 and the adjacent tiny residue G563 were sufficient for antiviral activity. Moreover, this minimal set of L4 amino acids transferred anti-THOV activity to the otherwise inactive bovine Mx1 (boMx1) protein. Taken together, our data suggest a fairly simple architecture of the antiviral loop L4 that could serve as a mutational hot spot in an evolutionary arms race between Mx-escaping viral variants and their hosts. IMPORTANCE Most mammals encode two paralogs of the interferon-induced Mx proteins: Mx1, with antiviral activity largely against RNA viruses, like orthomyxoviruses and bunyaviruses; and Mx2, which is antivirally active against HIV-1 and herpesviruses. The human Mx1 protein, also called huMxA, is the best-characterized example of mammalian Mx1 proteins and was recently shown to prevent zoonotic virus transmissions. To evaluate the antiviral activity of other mammalian Mx1 proteins, we used Thogoto virus, a tick-transmitted orthomyxovirus, which is efficiently blocked by huMxA. Interestingly, we detected antiviral activity only with equine Mx1 (eqMx1) but not with other nonprimate Mx1 proteins. Detailed functional analysis of eqMx1 identified amino acid residues in the unstructured loop L4 of the stalk domain critical for antiviral activity. The structural insights of the present study explain the unique position of eqMx1 antiviral activity within the collection of nonhuman mammalian Mx1 proteins.

Evolutionary Landscapes of Host-Virus Arms Races

Vertebrate immune systems suppress viral infection using both innate restriction factors and adaptive immunity. Viruses mutate to escape these defenses, driving hosts to counterevolve to regain fitness. This cycle recurs repeatedly, resulting in an evolutionary arms race whose outcome depends on the pace and likelihood of adaptation by host and viral genes. Although viruses evolve faster than their vertebrate hosts, their proteins are subject to numerous functional constraints that impact the probability of adaptation. These constraints are globally defined by evolutionary landscapes, which describe the fitness and adaptive potential of all possible mutations. We review deep mutational scanning experiments mapping the evolutionary landscapes of both host and viral proteins engaged in arms races. For restriction factors and some broadly neutralizing antibodies, landscapes favor the host, which may help to level the evolutionary playing field against rapidly evolving viruses. We discuss the biophysical underpinnings of these landscapes and their therapeutic implications.

Conservation lost: host-pathogen battles drive diversification and expansion of gene families

One of the strongest drivers in evolution is the struggle to survive a host-pathogen battle. This pressure selects for diversity among the factors directly involved in this battle, including virulence factors deployed by pathogens, their corresponding host targets, and host immune factors. A logical outcome of this diversification is that over time, the sequence of many immune factors will not be evolutionarily conserved across a broad range of species. Thus, while universal sequence conservation is often hailed as the hallmark of the importance of a particular gene, the immune system does not necessarily play by these rules when defending against co-evolving pathogens. This loss of sequence conservation is in contrast to many signaling pathways in development and basic cell biology that are not targeted by pathogens. In addition to diversification, another consequence of host-pathogen battles can be an amplification in gene number, thus leading to large gene families that have sequence relatively specific to a particular strain, species, or clade. Here we highlight this general theme across a variety of pathogen virulence factors and host immune factors. We summarize the wide range and number across species of these expanded, lineage-specific host-pathogen factors including ubiquitin ligases, nucleotide-binding leucine-rich repeat receptors, GTPases, and proteins without obvious biochemical function but that nonetheless play key roles in immunity.

Highly-potent, synthetic APOBEC3s restrict HIV-1 through deamination-independent mechanisms

The APOBEC3 (A3) genes encode cytidine deaminase proteins with potent antiviral and anti-retroelement activity. This locus is characterized by duplication, recombination, and deletion events that gave rise to the seven A3s found in primates. These include three single deaminase domain A3s (A3A, A3C, and A3H) and four double deaminase domain A3s (A3B, A3D, A3F, and A3G). The most potent of the A3 proteins against HIV-1 is A3G. However, it is not clear if double deaminase domain A3s have a generalized functional advantage to restrict HIV-1. In order to test whether superior restriction factors could be created by genetically linking single A3 domains into synthetic double domains, we linked A3C and A3H single domains in novel combinations. We found that A3C/A3H double domains acquired enhanced antiviral activity that is at least as potent, if not better than, A3G. Although these synthetic double domain A3s package into budding virions more efficiently than their respective single domains, this does not fully explain their gain of antiviral potency. The antiviral activity is conferred both by cytidine-deaminase dependent and independent mechanisms, with the latter correlating to an increase in RNA binding affinity. T cell lines expressing this A3C-A3H super restriction factor are able to control replicating HIV-1ΔVif infection to similar levels as A3G. Together, these data show that novel combinations of A3 domains are capable of gaining potent antiviral activity to levels similar to the most potent genome-encoded A3s, via a primarily non-catalytic mechanism.

Tick-transmitted thogotovirus gains high virulence by a single MxA escape mutation in the viral nucleoprotein

Infections with emerging and re-emerging arboviruses are of increasing concern for global health. Tick-transmitted RNA viruses of the genus Thogotovirus in the Orthomyxoviridae family have considerable zoonotic potential, as indicated by the recent emergence of Bourbon virus in the USA. To successfully infect humans, arboviruses have to escape the restrictive power of the interferon defense system. This is exemplified by the high sensitivity of thogotoviruses to the antiviral action of the interferon-induced myxovirus resistance protein A (MxA) that inhibits the polymerase activity of incoming viral ribonucleoprotein complexes. Acquiring resistance to human MxA would be expected to enhance the zoonotic potential of these pathogens. Therefore, we screened a panel of 10 different thogotovirus isolates obtained from various parts of the world for their sensitivity to MxA. A single isolate from Nigeria, Jos virus, showed resistance to the antiviral action of MxA in cell culture and in MxA-transgenic mice, whereas the prototypic Sicilian isolate SiAr126 was fully MxA-sensitive. Further analysis identified two amino acid substitutions (G327R and R328V) in the viral nucleoprotein as determinants for MxA resistance. Importantly, when introduced into SiAr126, the R328V mutation resulted in complete MxA escape of the recombinant virus, without causing any viral fitness loss. The escape mutation abolished viral nucleoprotein recognition by MxA and allowed unhindered viral growth in MxA-expressing cells and in MxA-transgenic mice. These findings demonstrate that thogotoviruses can overcome the species barrier by escaping MxA restriction and reveal that these tick-transmitted viruses may have a greater zoonotic potential than previously suspected.

Thogotovirus infections are known to cause isolated human fatalities, yet the zoonotic potential of these tick-transmitted pathogens is still largely unexplored. In the present study, we examined if these viruses are able to escape the interferon-induced human MxA, thereby overcoming the human innate antiviral defense. Mx proteins constitute a class of interferon-induced antiviral effector molecules that efficiently block the intracellular replication of many viruses. Here, we studied the MxA sensitivity of various thogotovirus isolates and identified two amino acid residues in the viral nucleoprotein that caused resistance to MxA. One of these exchanges was sufficient to enable an otherwise MxA-sensitive thogotovirus to fully escape MxA restriction without causing any fitness loss. Our study explores the interplay of thogotoviruses with the innate antiviral host defense and sheds light on their zoonotic potential.

RTP4 Is a Potent IFN-Inducible Anti-flavivirus Effector Engaged in a Host-Virus Arms Race in Bats and Other Mammals

Among mammals, bats are particularly rich in zoonotic viruses, including flaviviruses. Certain bat species can be productively yet asymptomatically infected with viruses that cause overt disease in other species. However, little is known about the antiviral effector repertoire in bats relative to other mammals. Here, we report the black flying fox receptor transporter protein 4 (RTP4) as a potent interferon (IFN)-inducible inhibitor of human pathogens in the Flaviviridae family, including Zika, West Nile, and hepatitis C viruses. Mechanistically, RTP4 associates with the flavivirus replicase, binds viral RNA, and suppresses viral genome amplification. Comparative approaches revealed that RTP4 undergoes positive selection, that a flavivirus can mutate to escape RTP4-imposed restriction, and that diverse mammalian RTP4 orthologs exhibit striking patterns of specificity against distinct Flaviviridae members. Our findings reveal an antiviral mechanism that has likely adapted over 100 million years of mammalian evolution to accommodate unique host-virus genetic conflicts.

Mutational resilience of antiviral restriction favors primate TRIM5α in host-virus evolutionary arms races

Host antiviral proteins engage in evolutionary arms races with viruses, in which both sides rapidly evolve at interaction interfaces to gain or evade immune defense. For example, primate TRIM5α uses its rapidly evolving 'v1' loop to bind retroviral capsids, and single mutations in this loop can dramatically improve retroviral restriction. However, it is unknown whether such gains of viral restriction are rare, or if they incur loss of pre-existing function against other viruses. Using deep mutational scanning, we comprehensively measured how single mutations in the TRIM5α v1 loop affect restriction of divergent retroviruses. Unexpectedly, we found that the majority of mutations increase weak antiviral function. Moreover, most random mutations do not disrupt potent viral restriction, even when it is newly acquired via a single adaptive substitution. Our results indicate that TRIM5α's adaptive landscape is remarkably broad and mutationally resilient, maximizing its chances of success in evolutionary arms races with retroviruses.

A Rapidly Evolving Polybasic Motif Modulates Bacterial Detection by Guanylate Binding Proteins

Cell-autonomous immunity relies on the rapid detection of invasive pathogens by host proteins. Guanylate binding proteins (GBPs) have emerged as key mediators of vertebrate immune defense through their ability to recognize a diverse array of intracellular pathogens and pathogen-containing cellular compartments. Human and mouse GBPs have been shown to target distinct groups of microbes, although the molecular determinants of pathogen specificity remain unclear. We show that rapid diversification of a C-terminal polybasic motif (PBM) in primate GBPs controls recognition of the model cytosolic bacterial pathogen Shigella flexneri By swapping this membrane-binding motif between primate GBP orthologs, we found that the ability to target S. flexneri has been enhanced and lost in specific lineages of New World primates. Single substitutions in rapidly evolving sites of the GBP1 PBM are sufficient to abolish or restore bacterial detection abilities, illustrating a role for epistasis in the evolution of pathogen recognition. We further demonstrate that the squirrel monkey GBP2 C-terminal domain recently gained the ability to target S. flexneri through a stepwise process of convergent evolution. These findings reveal a mechanism by which accelerated evolution of a PBM shifts GBP target specificity and aid in resolving the molecular basis of GBP function in cell-autonomous immune defense.IMPORTANCE Many infectious diseases are caused by microbes that enter and survive within host cells. Guanylate binding proteins (GBPs) are a group of immune proteins which recognize and inhibit a variety of intracellular pathogenic microbes. We discovered that a short sequence within GBPs required for the detection of bacteria, the polybasic motif (PBM), has been rapidly evolving between primate species. By swapping PBMs between primate GBP1 genes, we were able to show that specific sequences can both reduce and improve the ability of GBP1 to target intracellular bacteria. We also show that the ability to envelop bacteria has independently evolved in GBP2 of South American monkeys. Taking the results together, this report illustrates how primate GBPs have adapted to defend against infectious pathogens.

APOBEC3C Tandem Domain Proteins Create Super Restriction Factors against HIV-1

As a part of the innate immune system, humans encode proteins that inhibit viruses such as HIV-1. These broadly acting antiviral proteins do not protect humans from viral infections because viruses encode proteins that antagonize the host antiviral proteins to evade the innate immune system. One such example of a host antiviral protein is APOBEC3C (A3C), which weakly inhibits HIV-1. Here, we show that we can improve the antiviral activity of A3C by duplicating the DNA sequence to create a synthetic tandem domain and, furthermore, that the proteins thus generated are relatively resistant to the viral antagonist Vif. Together, these data give insights about how nature has evolved a defense against viral pathogens such as HIV.

Humans encode proteins, called restriction factors, that inhibit replication of viruses such as HIV-1. The members of one family of antiviral proteins, apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing enzyme catalytic polypeptide-like 3 (APOBEC3; shortened here to A3), act by deaminating cytidines to uridines during the reverse transcription reaction of HIV-1. The A3 locus encodes seven genes, named A3A to A3H. These genes have either one or two cytidine deaminase domains, and several of these A3s potently restrict HIV-1. A3C, which has only a single cytidine deaminase domain, however, inhibits HIV-1 only very weakly. We tested novel double domain protein combinations by genetically linking two A3C genes to make a synthetic tandem domain protein. This protein created a “super restriction factor” that had more potent antiviral activity than the native A3C protein, which correlated with increased packaging into virions. Furthermore, disabling one of the active sites of the synthetic tandem domain protein resulted in an even greater increase in the antiviral activity—recapitulating a similar evolution seen in A3F and A3G (double domain A3s that use only a single catalytically active deaminase domain). These A3C tandem domain proteins do not have an increase in mutational activity but instead inhibit formation of reverse transcription products, which correlates with their ability to form large higher-order complexes in cells. Finally, the A3C-A3C super restriction factor largely escaped antagonism by the HIV-1 viral protein Vif.

Mx genes: host determinants controlling influenza virus infection and trans-species transmission

The human MxA protein, encoded by the interferon-inducible MX1 gene, is an intracellular influenza A virus (IAV) restriction factor. It can protect transgenic mice from severe IAV-induced disease, indicating a key role of human MxA for host survival and suggesting that natural variations in MX1 may account for inter-individual differences in disease severity among humans. MxA also provides a robust barrier against zoonotic transmissions of avian and swine IAV strains. Therefore, zoonotic IAV must acquire MxA escape mutations to achieve sustained human-to-human transmission. Here, we discuss recent progress in the field.