Quantification of Hydrogen Isotopes Utilizing Raman Spectroscopy Paired with Chemometric Analysis for Application across Multiple Systems

Online and real-time analysis of a chemical process is a major analytical challenge that can drastically change the way the chemical industry or chemical research operates. With in situ analyses, a new and powerful understanding of chemistry can be gained; however, building robust tools for long-term monitoring faces many challenges, including compensating for instrument drift, instrument replacement, and sensor or probe replacement. Accounting for these changes by recollecting calibration data and rebuilding quantification models can be costly and time-consuming. Here, methods to overcome these challenges are demonstrated with an application of Raman spectroscopy to monitoring hydrogen isotopes with varied speciation within dynamic gas streams. Specifically, chemical data science tools such as chemometric modeling are leveraged along with several examples of calibration transfer approaches. Furthermore, the optimization of instrument and sensor cell parameters for targeted gas-phase analyses is discussed. While the particular focus on hydrogen is highly beneficial within the nuclear energy sector, mechanisms built and demonstrated here are widely applicable to optical spectroscopy monitoring in numerous other chemical systems that can be leveraged in other processes.

Quantification of Uranium in Complex Acid Media: Understanding Speciation and Mitigating for Band Shifts

In situ and real-time analysis of chemical systems, or online monitoring, has numerous benefits in all fields of chemistry. A common challenge can be found in matrix effects, where the addition of a new chemical species causes chemical interactions and changes the fingerprints of other chemical species in the system. This is demonstrated here by looking at the Raman and visible spectra of the uranyl ion within combined nitric acid and hydrofluoric acid media. This system is not only highly important to nuclear energy, a green and reliable option for energy portfolios, but also provides a clear chemistry example that can be applied to other chemical systems. The application of optical spectroscopy is discussed, along with the application and comparison of both multivariate curve resolution and HypSpec to deconvolute and understand speciation. Finally, the use of chemical data science in the form of chemometric modeling is used to demonstrate robust quantification of uranium within a complex chemical system where potential matrix effects are not known a priori.

In Situ Raman Methodology for Online Analysis of CO2 and H2O Loadings in a Water-Lean Solvent for CO2 Capture

Carbon capture represents a key pathway to meeting climate change mitigation goals. Powerful next-generation solvent-based capture processes are under development by many researchers, but optimization and testing would be significantly aided by integrating in situ monitoring capability. Further, real-time water analysis in water-lean solvents offers the potential to maintain their water balance in operation. To explore data acquisition techniques in depth for this purpose, Raman spectra of CO2, H2O, and a single-component water-lean solvent, N-(2-ethoxyethyl)-3-morpholinopropan-1-amine (2-EEMPA) were collected at different CO2 and H2O concentrations using an in situ Raman cell. The quantification of CO2 and H2O loadings in 2-EEMPA was done by principal component regression and partial least squares methods with analysis of uncertainties. We conclude with discussions on how this simultaneous online analysis method to quantify CO2 and H2O loadings can be an important tool to enable the optimal efficiency of water-lean CO2 solvents while also maintaining the critical water balance under operating conditions relevant to post-combustion CO2 capture.

Development of Online pH Monitoring for Lactic, Malonic, Citric, and Oxalic Acids Based on Raman Spectroscopy Using Hierarchical Chemometric Modeling

Online spectroscopic measurements can be used to provide unique insight into complex chemical systems, enabling new understanding and optimization of chemical processes. A key example of this is discussed here with the monitoring of pH of various acid systems in real-time. In this work the acids used in multiple chemical separations processes, such as TALSPEAK (Trivalent Actinide-Lanthanide Separation by Phosphorus reagent Extraction from Aqueous Komplexes) and oxalate precipitation, were characterized. Raman spectroscopy, a robust optical approach that can be integrated in corrosive processes, was used to follow the unique fingerprints of the various protonated and deprotonated acid species. This data was analyzed using a hierarchical modeling approach to build a consolidated model scheme using optical fingerprints from all weak acids to measure pH associated with any of the weak acid systems studied here. Validation of system performance included utilizing Raman spectroscopy under dynamic flow conditions to monitor solution pH under changing process conditions in-line. Overall, the Raman based approach provided accurate analysis of weak acid solution pH.

Iodine and Carbonate Species Monitoring in Molten NaOH-KOH Eutectic Scrubber via Dual-Phase In Situ Raman Spectroscopy

Molten hydroxide scrubbing of off-gas vapors is a potential process to improve safety during the operation of generation IV molten salt nuclear reactors (MSRs). MSRs produce off-gases that can be vented by the reactor core and treated via off-gas scrubbers. Molten hydroxide scrubbers focus on capturing volatile iodine radionuclides, and they can also be used to capture aerosols and particulates and to neutralize acidic species. The performance of these scrubbers depends on the chemical interactions of the scrubbing medium with the off-gas species. Knowledge of the concentration and speciation of scrubbed or target species, as well as process and environmental interferents, can enable advanced operation of MSR off-gas treatment systems. Optical online monitoring is an excellent technology to provide this information in real time, while limiting the need for operators to interact with radioactive samples through hands-on interrogation. Raman spectroscopy can provide crucial chemical information on the state of the molten eutectic during treatment in the molten phase, as well as the gas phase. In this work, Raman spectroscopy is used to detect iodine species, specifically iodate, in the molten phase of a NaOH-KOH eutectic and to construct a calibration curve of the Raman signal of those species. Additionally, a carbonate interferent is followed from the gas phase to the liquid phase as a basis for reaching a Raman-aided mass balance of the molten hydroxide eutectic scrubber system.

Microfluidic In-Situ Spectrophotometric Approaches to Tackle Actinides Analysis in Multiple Oxidation States

The study and development of present and future processes for the treatment/recycling of spent nuclear fuels require many steps, from design in the laboratory to setting up on an industrial scale. In all of these steps, analysis and instrumentation are key points. For scientific reasons (small-scale studies, control of phenomena, etc.) but also with regard to minimizing costs, risks, and waste, such developments are increasingly carried out on milli- or microfluidic devices. The logic is the same for the chemical analyses associated with their follow-up and interpretation. Due to this, over the last few years, opto-microfluidic analysis devices adapted to the monitoring of different processes (dissolution, liquid-liquid extraction, precipitation, etc.) have been increasingly designed and developed. In this work, we prove that photonic lab-on-a-chip (PhLoC) technology is fully suitable for all actinides concentration monitoring along the plutonium uranium refining extraction (plutonium, uranium, reduction, extraction, or Purex) process. Several PhLoC microfluidic platforms were specifically designed and used in different nuclear research and development (R&D) laboratories, to tackle actinides analysis in multiple oxidation states even in mixtures. The detection limits reached (tens of µmol·L^-1) are fully compliant with on-line process monitoring, whereas a range of analyzable concentrations of three orders of magnitude can be covered with less than 150 µL of analyte. Finally, this work confirms the possibility and the potential of coupling Raman and ultraviolet-visible (UV-Vis) spectroscopies at the microfluidic scale, opening the perspective of measuring very complex mixtures.

Combined Raman and Turbidity Probe for Real-Time Analysis of Variable Turbidity Streams

Real-time and in situ process monitoring is a powerful tool that can empower operators of hazardous processes to better understand and control their chemical systems without increased risk to themselves. However, the application of monitoring techniques to complex chemical processes can face challenges. An example of this is the application of optical spectroscopy, otherwise capable of providing detailed chemical composition information, to processes exhibiting variable turbidity. Here, details on a novel combined Raman spectroscopy and turbidimetry probe are discussed, which advances current technology to enable flexible and robust in situ monitoring of a flowing process stream. Furthermore, the analytical approach to accurately account for both Raman signal and turbidity while quantifying chemical targets is detailed. This new approach allows for accurate analysis without requiring assumptions of stable process chemistry, which may be unlikely in applications such as waste cleanup. Through leveraging Raman and turbidity data simultaneously collected from the combined probe within chemometric models, accurate quantification of multiple chemical targets can be achieved under conditions of variable concentrations and turbidity.

Measuring Nd(III) Solution Concentration in the Presence of Interfering Er(III) and Cu(II) Ions: A Partial Least Squares Analysis of Ultraviolet-Visible Spectra

Optical spectroscopy is a powerful characterization tool with applications ranging from fundamental studies to real-time process monitoring. However, it can be difficult to apply to complex samples that contain interfering analytes which are common in processing streams. Multivariate (chemometric) analysis has been examined for providing selectivity and accuracy to the analysis of optical spectra and expanding its potential applications. Here we will discuss chemometric modeling with an in-depth comparison to more simplistic analysis approaches and outline how chemometric modeling works while exploring the limits on modeling accuracy. Understanding the limitations of the chemometric model can provide better analytical assessment regarding the accuracy and precision of the analytical result. This will be explored in the context of UV-Vis absorbance of neodymium (Nd³⁺) in the presence of interferents, erbium (Er³⁺) and copper (Cu²⁺) under conditions simulating the liquid-liquid extraction approach used to recycle plutonium (Pu) and uranium (U) in used nuclear fuel worldwide. The selected chemometric model, partial least squares regression, accurately quantifies Nd³⁺ with a low percentage error in the presence of interfering analytes and even under conditions that the training set does not describe.

On-Line Raman Measurement of the Radiation-Enhanced Reaction of Cellobiose with Hydrogen Peroxide

Production of a chemical feedstock as a secondary product from a commercial nuclear reactor can increase the economic viability of the reactor and enable the deployment of nuclear energy as part of the low-carbon energy grid. Currently, commercial nuclear reactors produce underutilized energy in the form of neutrons and gamma photons. This excess energy can be exploited to drive chemical reactions, increasing the fraction of utilized energy in reactors and providing a valuable secondary product from the reactor. Gamma degradation of cellulosic biomass has been studied previously. However, real-time, on-line monitoring of the breakdown of biomass materials under gamma radiation has not been demonstrated. Here, we demonstrate on-line monitoring of the reaction of cellobiose with hydrogen peroxide under gamma radiation using Raman spectroscopy, providing in situ quantification of organic and inorganic system components.

Quantification of Raman-Interfering Polyoxoanions for Process Analysis: Comparison of Different Chemometric Models and a Demonstration on Real Hanford Waste

The Hanford site represents a complicated environmental remediation challenge, remaining from the production of nuclear weapons. Over 100 million gallons of liquid radioactive waste of unknown composition will be chemically processed and vitrified, but the varying chemical composition and highly radioactive nature of the waste preclude the implementation of more developed, offline technologies to determine the composition. The only practical approach to waste treatment will require the significant utilization of real-time, chemometric modeling approaches. Although chemometric approaches have been applied to the analysis of Hanford waste, the models developed were highly tank-specialized, and limited discussion was provided on how models fared with interfering signals. As the tank waste is largely composed of oxoanions, which tend to have interfering Raman spectra, the general question was posed as to what chemometric approach is best suited to accurately quantify analytes in the presence of interfering signals. This was carried out by examining the ability of classical least square (CLS), principal component regression (PCR), partial least square (PLS), and locally weighted regression (LWR) to quantify NO₃^- and CO₃^2- using their bands around 1050 cm^-1. For all samples, the PLS-based model was found to be the most efficient approach from a model building and application perspective.

Raman Spectroscopy Coupled with Chemometric Analysis for Speciation and Quantitative Analysis of Aqueous Phosphoric Acid Systems

Complex chemical systems that exhibit varied and matrix-dependent speciation are notoriously difficult to monitor and characterize online and in real-time. Optical spectroscopy is an ideal tool for in situ characterization of chemical species that can enable quantification as well as species identification. Chemometric modeling, a multivariate method, has been successfully paired with optical spectroscopy to enable measurement of analyte concentrations even in complex solutions where univariate methods such as Beer's law analysis fail. Here, Raman spectroscopy is used to quantify the concentration of phosphoric acid and its three deprotonated forms during a titration. In this system, univariate approaches would be difficult to apply due to multiple species being present simultaneously within the solution as the pH is varied. Locally weighted regression (LWR) modeling was used to determine phosphate concentration from spectral signature. LWR results, in tandem with multivariate curve resolution modeling, provide a direct measurement of the concentration of each phosphate species using only the Raman signal. Furthermore, results are presented within the context of fundamental solution chemistry, including Pitzer equations, to compensate for activity coefficients and nonidealities associated with high ionic strength systems.

On-Line Monitoring of Gas-Phase Molecular Iodine Using Raman and Fluorescence Spectroscopy Paired with Chemometric Analysis

Molten salt reactors (MSRs) have the potential to safely support green energy goals while meeting baseload energy needs with diverse energy portfolios. While reactor designers have made tremendous strides with these systems, licensing and deployment of these reactors will be aided through the development of new technology such as on-line and remote monitoring tools. Of particular interest is quantifying reactor off-gas species, such as iodine, within off-gas streams to support the design and operational control of off-gas treatment systems. Here, the development of advanced Raman spectroscopy systems for the on-line analysis of gas composition is discussed, focusing on the key control species I_2(g). Signal response was explored with two Raman instruments, utilizing 532 and 671 nm excitation sources, as a function of I_2(g) pressure and temperature. Also explored is the integration of advanced data analysis methods to enable real-time and highly accurate analysis of complex optical data. Specifically, the application of chemometric modeling is discussed. Raman spectroscopy paired with chemometric analysis is demonstrated to provide a powerful route to analyzing I_2(g) composition within the gas phase, which lays the foundation for applications within molten salt reactor off-gas analysis and other significant chemical processes producing iodine species.

Enabling Microscale Processing: Combined Raman and Absorbance Spectroscopy for Microfluidic On-Line Monitoring

Microfluidics have many potential applications including characterization of chemical processes on a reduced scale, spanning the study of reaction kinetics using on-chip liquid-liquid extractions, sample pretreatment to simplify off-chip analysis, and for portable spectroscopic analyses. The use of in situ characterization of process streams from laboratory-scale and microscale experiments on the same chemical system can provide comprehensive understanding and in-depth analysis of any similarities or differences between process conditions at different scales. A well-characterized extraction of Nd(NO₃)₃ from an aqueous phase of varying NO_{3^- (aq)} concentration with tributyl phosphate (TBP) in dodecane was the focus of this microscale study and was compared to an earlier laboratory-scale study utilizing counter current extraction equipment. Here, we verify that this same extraction process can be followed on the microscale using spectroscopic methods adapted for microfluidic measurement. Concentration of Nd (based on UV-vis) and nitrate (based on Raman) was chemometrically measured during the flow experiment, and resulting data were used to determine the distribution ratio for Nd. Extraction distributions measured on the microscale were compared favorably with those determined on the laboratory scale in the earlier study. Both micro-Raman and micro-UV-vis spectroscopy can be used to determine fundamental parameters with significantly reduced sample size as compared to traditional laboratory-scale approaches. This leads naturally to time, cost, and waste reductions.

Absolute Band Intensity of the Iodine Monochloride Fundamental Mode for Infrared Sensing and Quantitative Analysis

Iodine monochloride (ICl) is a potential off-gas product of molten salt reactors; monitoring this heteronuclear diatomic molecule is of great interest for both environmental and safety purposes. In this paper, we investigate the possibility of infrared monitoring of ICl by measuring the far-infrared absorption cross section of its fundamental band near 381 cm^-1. We have performed quantitative studies of the neat gas in a 20 cm cell at 25, 35, 50, and 70 °C at multiple pressures up to ∼9 Torr and investigated the temperature and pressure dependencies of the band's infrared cross section. Quantitative measurements were problematic due to sample adhesion to the cell walls and windows as well as reactions/possible hydrolysis of ICl to form HCl gas. Effects were mitigated by measuring only the neat gas, using short measurement times, and subtracting out the partial pressure of the HCl(g). The integrated band strength is shown to be temperature independent and was found to be equal to 9.1 × 10^-19 (cm²/molecule) cm^-1. As expected, the temperature dependence of the band profile showed only a small effect over this limited temperature range. We have also investigated using the absorption data along with inverse least squares multivariate methods for the quantitative monitoring of ICl effluent concentrations under different scenarios using infrared (standoff) sensing and compare these results with traditional Beer's law (univariate) techniques.

Sensor Fusion: Comprehensive Real-Time, On-Line Monitoring for Process Control via Visible, Near-Infrared, and Raman Spectroscopy

On-line monitoring based on optical spectroscopy provides unprecedented insight into the chemical composition of process streams or batches. Amplifying this approach through utilizing multiple forms of optical spectroscopy in sensor fusion can greatly expand the number and type of chemical species that can be identified and quantified. This is demonstrated herein, on the analysis of used nuclear fuel recycling streams: highly complex processes with multiple target and interfering analytes. The optical techniques of visible absorbance, near-infrared absorbance, and Raman spectroscopy were combined to quantify plutonium(III, IV, VI), uranium(IV, VI), neptunium(IV, V, VI), and nitric acid. Chemometric modeling was used to quantify analytes in process streams in real time, and results were successfully used to enable immediate process control and generation of a product stream at a set composition ratio. This represents a significant step forward in the ability to monitor and control complex chemical processes occurring in harsh chemical environments.

Reimagining pH Measurement: Utilizing Raman Spectroscopy for Enhanced Accuracy in Phosphoric Acid Systems

Measurement of pH is an integral component of chemical studies and process control; however, traditional pH probes are difficult to utilize in harsh or complex chemical systems. Optical spectroscopy-based online monitoring offers a powerful and novel route for characterizing system parameters, such as pH, and is well adapted to deployment in harsh environments or chemically complex systems. Specifically, Raman spectroscopy combined with chemometric analysis can provide an improved method of online p[H⁺] measurement. Multivariate curve resolution (MCR) analysis of Raman spectra can be utilized to determine speciation as a function of p[H⁺], and the MCR scores assigned to each species can be used to calculate p[H⁺]. Subsequent chemometric modeling can be used to correlate spectral response to p[H⁺]. This was demonstrated with phosphoric acid, a chemical system known to challenge traditional pH probes. Raman spectra exhibit clear changes with pH due to changing speciation, and chemometric modeling can be successfully utilized to correlate those fingerprints to p[H⁺]. With the use of this approach, p[H⁺] of the phosphoric acid system can be accurately measured without foreknowledge of system conditions such as ionic strength.

Online Monitoring of Solutions Within Microfluidic Chips: Simultaneous Raman and UV-Vis Absorption Spectroscopies

Microfluidics is an appealing analytical tool in the global effort to close the nuclear fuel cycle. Using a microfluidic chip permits the analysis of greatly reduced sample volumes compared to what is necessary for traditional analytical methods. There is a commensurate reduction in disposal volume and cost. The development of novel sensors is necessary to take full advantage of the microchip configuration, where optical-spectroscopy-based approaches offer a powerful route to characterize chemical composition. This study uses simultaneously applied UV-vis and micro-Raman spectroscopies adapted to function on the microscale to analyze in situ both the Nd³⁺ (UV-vis-active) and HNO₃ (Raman-active) concentrations in the same sample. An adjustable translation platform was designed to hold the micro-Raman probe above and perpendicular to the chip face and the UV-vis probe in the plane of the chip. These complimentary spectral techniques when processed through multivariate partial least-squares (PLS) models gave an accurate picture of the widely varying solution concentrations as a function of time for each solution component. Solution matrix effects can drastically alter analyte signatures as measured by both UV-vis absorbance and Raman spectroscopy. PLS methods successfully modeled these spectral changes and accurately measured concentrations of components of interest within the microfluidic chip.

In Situ Spectroscopic Analysis and Quantification of [Tc(CO)3]+ in Hanford Tank Waste

The quantitative conversion of nonpertechnetate [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ species in nuclear waste storage tank 241-AN-102 at the Hanford Site is demonstrated. A waste sample containing the [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ species is added to a developer solution that rapidly converts the nonemissive species into a luminescent complex, which is detected spectroscopically. This method was first demonstrated using a [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ sample of nonwaste containing matrix to determine a detection limit (LOD), resulting in a [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ LOD of 2.20 × 10^-7 M, very near the LOD of the independently synthesized standard (2.10 × 10^-7 M). The method was then used to detect [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ in a simulated waste using the standard addition method, resulting in a [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ concentration of 1.89 × 10^-5 M (within 27.7% of the concentration determined by β liquid scintillation counting). Three samples from 241-AN-102 were tested by the standard addition method: (1) a 5 M Na adjusted fraction, (2) a fraction depleted of ¹³⁷Cs, and (3) an acid-stripped eluate. The concentrations of [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ in these fractions were determined to be 9.90 × 10^-6 M (1), 0 M (2), and 2.46 × 10^-6 M (3), respectively. The concentration of [Tc(CO)₃]⁺ in the as-received AN-102 tank waste supernatant was determined to be 1.84 × 10^-5 M.

In Situ Quantification of [Re(CO)3]+ by Fluorescence Spectroscopy in Simulated Hanford Tank Waste

A pretreatment protocol is presented that allows for the quantitative conversion and subsequent in situ spectroscopic analysis of [Re(CO)₃]⁺ species in simulated Hanford tank waste. In this test case, the nonradioactive metal rhenium is substituted for technetium (Tc-99), a weak beta emitter, to demonstrate proof of concept for a method to measure a nonpertechnetate form of technetium in Hanford tank waste. The protocol encompasses adding a simulated waste sample containing the nonemissive [Re(CO)₃]⁺ species to a developer solution that enables the rapid, quantitative conversion of the nonemissive species to a luminescent species which can then be detected spectroscopically. The [Re(CO)₃]⁺ species concentration in an alkaline, simulated Hanford tank waste supernatant can be quantified by the standard addition method. In a test case, the [Re(CO)₃]⁺ species was measured to be at a concentration of 38.9 μM, which was a difference of 2.01% from the actual concentration of 39.7 μM.

Development and testing of a novel micro-Raman probe and application of calibration method for the quantitative analysis of microfluidic nitric acid streams

To simplify and improve the safety of reprocessing nuclear fuel, the Micro-Raman technique was applied at the microfluidic scale with a view toward the on-line spectroscopic measurement of radioactive solutions.

Multivariate Analysis for Quantification of Plutonium(IV) in Nitric Acid Based on Absorption Spectra

Development of more effective, reliable, and fast methods for monitoring process streams is a growing opportunity for analytical applications. Many fields can benefit from online monitoring, including the nuclear fuel cycle where improved methods for monitoring radioactive materials will facilitate maintenance of proper safeguards and ensure safe and efficient processing of materials. Online process monitoring with a focus on optical spectroscopy can provide a fast, nondestructive method for monitoring chemical species. However, identification and quantification of species can be hindered by the complexity of the solutions if bands overlap or show condition-dependent spectral features. Plutonium(IV) is one example of a species which displays significant spectral variation with changing nitric acid concentration. Single variate analysis (i.e., Beer's Law) is difficult to apply to the quantification of Pu(IV) unless the nitric acid concentration is known and separate calibration curves have been made for all possible acid strengths. Multivariate or chemometric analysis is an approach that allows for the accurate quantification of Pu(IV) without a priori knowledge of nitric acid concentration.