2016 Comprehensive Update of the Banff Working Group on Liver Allograft Pathology: Introduction of Antibody-Mediated Rejection

The Banff Working Group on Liver Allograft Pathology reviewed and discussed literature evidence regarding antibody-mediated liver allograft rejection at the 11th (Paris, France, June 5-10, 2011), 12th (Comandatuba, Brazil, August 19-23, 2013), and 13th (Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, October 5-10, 2015) meetings of the Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology. Discussion continued online. The primary goal was to introduce guidelines and consensus criteria for the diagnosis of liver allograft antibody-mediated rejection and provide a comprehensive update of all Banff Schema recommendations. Included are new recommendations for complement component 4d tissue staining and interpretation, staging liver allograft fibrosis, and findings related to immunosuppression minimization. In an effort to create a single reference document, previous unchanged criteria are also included.

Rapamycin Interferes With Postdepletion Regulatory T Cell Homeostasis and Enhances DSA Formation Corrected by CTLA4-Ig

Previously, we demonstrated that alemtuzumab induction with rapamycin as sole maintenance therapy is associated with an increased incidence of humoral rejection in human kidney transplant patients. To investigate the role of rapamycin in posttransplant humoral responses after T cell depletion, fully MHC mismatched hearts were transplanted into hCD52Tg mice, followed by alemtuzumab treatment with or without a short course of rapamycin. While untreated hCD52Tg recipients acutely rejected B6 hearts (n = 12), hCD52Tg recipients treated with alemtuzumab alone or in conjunction with rapamycin showed a lack of acute rejection (MST > 100). However, additional rapamycin showed a reduced beating quality over time and increased incidence of vasculopathy. Furthermore, rapamycin supplementation showed an increased serum donor-specific antibodies (DSA) level compared to alemtuzumab alone at postoperation days 50 and 100. Surprisingly, additional rapamycin treatment significantly reduced CD4(+) CD25(+) FoxP3(+) T reg cell numbers during treatment. On the contrary, ICOS(+) PD-1(+) CD4 follicular helper T cells in the lymph nodes were significantly increased. Interestingly, CTLA4-Ig supplementation in conjunction with rapamycin corrected rapamycin-induced accelerated posttransplant humoral response by directly modulating Tfh cells but not Treg cells. This suggests that rapamycin after T cell depletion could affect Treg cells leading to an increase of Tfh cells and DSA production that can be reversed by CTLA4-Ig.

Neutralizing BAFF/APRIL with atacicept prevents early DSA formation and AMR development in T cell depletion induced nonhuman primate AMR model

Depletional strategies directed toward achieving tolerance induction in organ transplantation have been associated with an increased incidence and risk of antibody-mediated rejection (AMR) and graft injury. Our clinical data suggest correlation of increased serum B cell activating factor/survival factor (BAFF) with increased risk of antibody-mediated rejection in alemtuzumab treated patients. In the present study, we tested the ability of BAFF blockade (TACI-Ig) in a nonhuman primate AMR model to prevent alloantibody production and prolong allograft survival. Three animals received the AMR inducing regimen (CD3-IT/alefacept/tacrolimus) with TACI-Ig (atacicept), compared to five control animals treated with the AMR inducing regimen only. TACI-Ig treatment lead to decreased levels of DSA in treated animals at 2 and 4 weeks posttransplantation (p < 0.05). In addition, peripheral B cell numbers were significantly lower at 6 weeks posttransplantation. However, it provided only a marginal increase in graft survival (59 ± 22 vs. 102 ± 47 days; p = 0.11). Histological analysis revealed a substantial reduction in findings typically associated with humoral rejection with atacicept treatment. More T cell rejection findings were observed with increased graft T cell infiltration in atacicept treatment, likely secondary to the graft prolongation. We show that BAFF/APRIL blockade using concomitant TACI-Ig treatment reduced the humoral portion of rejection in our depletion-induced preclinical AMR model.

BAFF is increased in renal transplant patients following treatment with alemtuzumab

Alemtuzumab is a monoclonal antibody that depletes T and B cells and is used as induction therapy for renal transplant recipients. Without long-term calcineurin inhibitor (CNI) therapy, alemtuzumab-treated patients have a propensity to develop alloantibody and may undergo antibody-mediated rejection (AMR). In pursuit of a mechanistic explanation, we analyzed peripheral B cells and serum of these patients for BAFF (Blys) and BAFF-R, factors known to be integral for B-cell activation, survival, and homeostasis. Serum BAFF levels of 22/24 alemtuzumab-treated patients were above normal range, with average levels of 1967 pg/mL compared to 775 pg/mL in healthy controls (p = 0.006). BAFF remained elevated 2 years posttransplant in 78% of these patients. BAFF-R on CD19(+) B cells was significantly downregulated, suggesting ligand/receptor engagement. BAFF mRNA expression was increased 2-7-fold in CD14(+) cells of depleted patients, possibly linking monocytes to the BAFF dysregulation. Addition of recombinant BAFF to mixed lymphocyte cultures increased B-cell activation to alloantigen, as measured by CD25 and CD69 coexpression on CD19(+) cells. Of note, addition of sirolimus (SRL) augmented BAFF-enhanced B-cell activation whereas CNIs blocked it. These data suggest associations between BAFF/BAFF-R and AMR in alemtuzumab-treated patients.

Analysis of primate renal allografts after T-cell depletion with anti-CD3-CRM9

BACKGROUND

FN18-CRM9 is a CD3-specific immunotoxin that is capable of depleting CD3+ T cells. Pretreatment of rhesus monkeys with this agent before transplantation can induce donor-specific tolerance and "split tolerance" to renal allografts.

METHODS

Heterotopic renal transplants were performed on monkeys that received posttransplant FN18-CRM9. Histological and immunohistological staining, as well as analysis of the intragraft cytokine profile by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction, was performed on percutaneous allograft biopsies.

RESULTS

Experimental monkeys had significant prolongation of allograft survival. Although an interstitial, mononuclear cell infiltrate was seen in all of the renal transplants, there was minimal evidence of acute cellular rejection. Histological evidence of alloantibody-mediated damage was detected 3 to 5 months after transplantation in the monkeys treated with FN18-CRM9. Immunohistology demonstrated the reappearance of CD3+ and CD4+ T cells, as well as CD20+ B cells, in the grafts. Cytokine analysis demonstrated expression of interferon-gamma. An intact anti-donor IgG response was seen.

CONCLUSION

Treatment of monkeys with FN18-CRM9 immediately after transplantation significantly prolongs renal allograft survival. Allograft biopsies demonstrate a lack of acute cellular rejection; however, alloantibody-mediated graft damage and rejection occur, with an intact anti-donor IgG response. The intragraft expression of the interferon-gamma may reflect this ongoing humoral rejection. These data suggest that even a brief period of T-cell allosensitization may lead to humorally mediated allograft damage. Efforts to achieve tolerance with posttransplant FN18-CRM9 will require modification of the protocol to deplete T cells before allosensitization exposure or to supplement the posttransplant immunomodification strategy.

Results of the double-blind, randomized, multicenter, phase III clinical trial of Thymoglobulin versus Atgam in the treatment of acute graft rejection episodes after renal transplantation

BACKGROUND

Thymoglobulin, a rabbit anti-human thymocyte globulin, was compared with Atgam, a horse anti-human thymocyte globulin for the treatment of acute rejection after renal transplantation.

METHODS

A multicenter, double-blind, randomized trial with enrollment stratification based on standardized histology (Banff grading) was conducted. Subjects received 7-14 days of Thymoglobulin (1.5 mg/kg/ day) or Atgam (15 mg/kg/day). The primary end point was rejection reversal (return of serum creatinine level to or below the day 0 baseline value).

RESULTS

A total of 163 patients were enrolled at 25 transplant centers in the United States. No differences in demographics or transplant characteristics were noted. Intent-to-treat analysis demonstrated that Thymoglobulin had a higher rejection reversal rate than Atgam (88% versus 76%, P=0.027, primary end point). Day 30 graft survival rates (Thymoglobulin 94% and Atgam 90%, P=0.17), day 30 serum creatinine levels as a percentage of baseline (Thymoglobulin 72% and Atgam 80%; P=0.43), and improvement in posttreatment biopsy results (Thymoglobulin 65% and Atgam 50%; P=0.15) were not statistically different. T-cell depletion was maintained more effectively with Thymoglobulin than Atgam both at the end of therapy (P=0.001) and at day 30 (P=0.016). Recurrent rejection, at 90 days after therapy, occurred less frequently with Thymoglobulin (17%) versus Atgam (36%) (P=0.011). A similar incidence of adverse events, post-therapy infections, and 1-year patient and graft survival rates were observed with both treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

Thymoglobulin was found to be superior to Atgam in reversing acute rejection and preventing recurrent rejection after therapy in renal transplant recipients.

Two distinct forms of soluble MHC class I molecules synthesized by different mechanisms in normal rat cells in vitro

Rat soluble MHC class I synthesis was studied at both RNA and protein levels to determine whether multiple forms of soluble MHC class I molecules are produced by different mechanisms. RT-PCR and sequencing of MHC class I transcripts identified an alternatively spliced nonclassical MHC class I gene product, lacking both exon 5 and 6, in both spleen and liver. Immunoprecipitation and SDS-PAGE identified two distinct soluble MHC class I proteins in both splenocyte- and hepatocyte-culture supernatants. The 36Kd classical soluble MHC class I protein (RT1.Aa) was precipitated by both allele-specific (MN4.91.6, R3/13, R2/15S) and pan-reactive (OX18) mAbs. The 39Kd non-RT1.A soluble MHC class I protein was precipitated only by OX18. The production of soluble RT1.Aa was inhibited by a metalloproteinase inhibitor, but not by serine/thiol protease inhibitors. None of these protease inhibitors interfered with the soluble non-RT1.A production, suggesting that it might be derived from an alternatively spliced MHC class I transcript. The soluble non-RT1.A was always associated with beta2m. However, soluble RT1.Aa molecule was cleaved in beta2m-free form and was reassociated with beta2m in culture supernatants. Thus two soluble MHC class I molecules, classical (36Kd RT1.Aa) and nonclassical (the alternatively spliced transcript), were produced from rat cells. Alternative splicing led to the nonclassical soluble MHC class I synthesis. Proteolytic cleavage by metalloproteinase led to the classical soluble MHC class I synthesis.

Expression of naked plasmid DNA injected into the afferent and efferent vessels of rodent and dog livers

A variety of reporter genes within plasmid constructs were injected into the afferent and efferent vessels of the liver in mice, rats, and dogs. Efficient plasmid expression was obtained following delivery via the portal vein, the hepatic vein, and the bile duct. The use of hyperosmotic injection solutions and occlusion of the blood outflow from the liver substantially increased the expression levels. Combining these surgical approaches with improved plasmid vectors enabled uncommonly high levels of foreign gene expression in which over 15 microg of luciferase protein/liver was produced in mice and over 50 microg in rats. Equally high levels of beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) expression were obtained, in that over 5% of the hepatocytes had intense blue staining. Expression of luciferase or beta-Gal was evenly distributed in hepatocytes throughout the entire liver when either of the three routes were injected. Peri-acinar hepatocytes were preferentially transfected when the portal vein was injected in rats. These levels of foreign gene expression are among the highest levels obtained with nonviral vectors. Repetitive plasmid administration through the bile duct led to successive events of foreign gene expression. The integration of these findings into laboratory and clinical protocols is discussed.

Naked DNA delivered intraportally expresses efficiently in hepatocytes

Naked plasmid DNA in hypertonic solutions was injected intraportally in mice whose hepatic veins were transiently occluded. High levels of luciferase expression and beta-galactosidase expression in 1% of the hepatocytes throughout the entire liver were achieved using 100 micrograms of the respective plasmid vector. Two days after the intraportal injection of 100 micrograms of pCMVGH, the mean hGH serum concentration was 65 ng/ml +/- 26 (n = 7) which is approximately 50-fold above normal baseline levels. These unprecedented levels of foreign gene expression from naked plasmid DNA document the ability of parenchymal cells in vivo to take up naked DNA following intravascular delivery.

The influence of dose and dose rate of total lymphoid irradiation in the rat cardiac allograft model

Immunosuppression generated by total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) may be of use in solid organ transplantation. We have investigated the use of TLI in the rat cardiac allograft model. Lewis rats received TLI from a cobalt-60 machine. The daily dose was 1.25 Gy and treatments were administered 4 days per week. We performed experiments to assess the effect of dose rate upon graft survival. The dose rate was varied by changing the source to animal distance and by using a lead attenuator. Cardiac allografts from each ACI donor rat were transplanted to the recipient Lewis rat's abdomen utilizing microvascular surgical technique. Heart graft survival times (GST) were monitored by direct palpation of the cardiac impulse. Immune function was measured by an activity index of the mixed lymphocyte reaction. In the absence of any immunosuppression there was a mean GST of 6.9 +/- 0.3 days. When a graft was placed the day following completion of TLI, there was an increase in GST as the total TLI dose was increased. Mean GST (+/- S.E.) following 5, 10, and 15 Gy were 12.3 +/- 1.3, 14.5 +/- 1.3, and 25.5 +/- 1.1 days, respectively. Following 20 Gy, GST decreased because of irradiation induced pulmonary toxicity and host death. When 3.5 weeks were allowed to elapse between the completion of TLI and transplantation, GST were less than those seen with equivalent doses of TLI and early transplantation. Mean GST following 5, 10, and 15 Gy and a delayed transplant were 7.2 +/- 0.1, 10.7 +/- 1.2, and 19.0 +/- 3.5 days, respectively. We tested the effect of dose rate upon GST.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)