Should atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) be subcategorized? Accuracy analysis of Papanicolaou smears using receiver operating characteristic curves and implications for the ASCUS/squamous intraepithelial lesion ratio

We correlated all Papanicolaou test diagnoses over a 6-month period with biopsy results and determined accuracy using receiver operating characteristic curves and biopsy as the "gold standard." Accuracies were calculated using all atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) cases or by eliminating subsets thereof. Retaining the ASCUS category resulted in significantly greater accuracy for the diagnosis of squamous intraepithelial lesion (SIL) on biopsy compared with eliminating it by diagnosing all such cases as negative. Subcategorization significantly improved the accuracy of the test only when all cases were included. The highest accuracy without subcategorization was achieved when ASCUS, favor reactive, cases were diagnosed as negative, but this threshold was significantly less sensitive than including all ASCUS cases. Increasing or decreasing the estimated ASCUS/SIL ratio from 2.4 without subcategorization significantly reduced accuracy. Similar results were obtained when high-grade SIL on biopsy was used as the gold standard. Use of the ASCUS category significantly improves the accuracy of the Papanicolaou test. Eliminating any subset of ASCUS reduces the ASCUS/SIL ratio but also significantly diminishes the sensitivity of the Papanicolaou test.

An analysis of factors that influence the ASCUS/SIL ratio of pathologists

In pursuit of physician-specific performance data in cytology, we have been calculating the ASCUS/SIL (atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance/squamous intraepithelial lesion) ratio of cytopathologists (CPs) and providing confidential feedback every 6 months. At the same time, thin-layer technology was introduced as an alternative to conventional smears. Thus we analyzed factors that may influence the ASCUS/SIL ratio, particularly the effect of periodic feedback on outliers (defined by a professional benchmark). For 3 years, the mean ASCUS/SIL ratio for all CPs decreased significantly from 2.92 to 1.87. There was great variability in the mean ASCUS/SIL ratio among 12 CPs (range, 1.11-5.89). Of the 6 CPs who worked continuously during this time, 2 showed a statistically significant decrease in their ASCUS/SIL ratio, including the CP with the highest ratio; 1 showed a significant increase. The mean ASCUS/SIL ratio did not correlate well with years of CP experience or with individual annual case volume. The ASCUS/SIL ratio of some CPs can decrease significantly over time. Whether it was due to feedback or the introduction of thin-layer preparations could not be determined.

Cytologic diagnosis of gastrointestinal stromal tumor with emphasis on the differential diagnosis with leiomyosarcoma

BACKGROUND

Gastrointestinal stromal tumor (GIST) has only recently been distinguished histologically and immunochemically from morphologically similar neoplasms of the abdomen.

METHODS

The authors reviewed 15 cytologic cases of GIST (14 fine-needle aspiration [FNA] specimens and 1 peritoneal fluid specimen) and compared them with 23 cases of leiomyosarcoma (LMS) arising in the abdomen or pelvis (all FNAs). Immunochemistry (IC) was performed on both the cytologic and subsequent tissue specimens if sufficient specimen was available.

RESULTS

Cytologic samples of GISTs typically showed irregularly outlined clusters of uniform spindle cells that were spread easily without crush artifact. The cells had wispy cytoplasm with long, delicate, filamentous extensions (13 cases; 87%). A prominent vascular pattern was common (9 cases; 60%); pleomorphism (1 case; 7%) was uncommon. The LMSs showed three-dimensional, tightly cohesive, sharply marginated syncytia of spindle cells, often with nuclear crush artifact. The cytoplasm/stroma had a distinct wiry, refractile appearance (21 cases; 91%); delicate filamentous cytoplasmic extensions (5 cases; 22%) and prominent vessels (3 cases; 13%) were less common. LMSs more commonly exhibited pleomorphism (14 cases; 61%). Epithelioid cytomorphology, mitoses, and necrosis occasionally were observed in both tumor types. IC for c-kit (on cytologic material) was positive in 10 of 10 cases of GIST (usually diffuse and strong) and 2 of 19 cases of LMS (focal). CD34 positivity favored GIST (4 of 9 cases) over LMS (1 of 19 cases). Smooth muscle actin was positive in 20 of 20 LMSs (strong and diffuse) and 6 of 10 GISTs (usually focal). Desmin was positive in 12 of 20 LMSs and was only focally positive in 1 of 11 GISTs. Correlation of IC results was excellent between cytologic and tissue specimens.

CONCLUSIONS

Delicate cytoplasmic processes; a prominent vascular pattern; a lack of nuclear pleomorphism; and a c-kit-positive, desmin-negative immunoprofile are characteristic features of GIST and help distinguish these tumors from LMS in cytologic specimens.

Quality assurance in gynecologic cytology. The value of cytotechnologist-cytopathologist discrepancy logs

We describe a simple method for displaying and evaluating the concordance or discordance between cytotechnologists (CTs) and cytopathologists (CPs) on gynecologic cases. The provisional diagnoses made by the CTs and the final diagnoses of the CPs are captured by the laboratory information system; data generated for specified periods are displayed as a 10 x 10 matrix that classifies each possible diagnosis made by the CT and CP into 1 of 10 major categories. Matrices are generated for the entire laboratory and for individual CTs; individual CTs are evaluated based on their deviation from the laboratory average. Three statistical measures are generated: percentage of discordant diagnoses, a kappa statistic, and a weighted measure. During a 2.5-year period, approximately 4,200 cases were referred to a CP for review every 6 months. The median discordance in diagnoses increased during 2 years from 21% to 34%, and the kappa value fell from 0.69 to 0.38. This was attributed primarily to 1 CT, whose performance, as well as that of the entire laboratory, improved after remedial action. Measures of CT-CP diagnostic concordance are a useful and efficient measure of CT performance and can be incorporated into mandatory semiannual performance evaluations.

Malignant epithelioid angiomyolipoma ('sarcoma ex angiomyolipoma') of the kidney: a case report and review of the literature

Malignant epithelioid angiomyolipoma is a recently described rare tumor of the kidney. Its existence has been questioned, however, on the basis of incomplete evidence of malignant behavior, the absence of an associated classic angiomyolipoma component, or the absence of immunoreactivity for HMB-45 in some cases. We describe a case that was HMB-45-positive and arose in association with a classic angiomyolipoma. The patient was treated with a partial nephrectomy. Three years later, she developed rapidly enlarging liver nodules. A fine-needle aspiration of the liver confirmed the presence of pleomorphic epithelioid cells morphologically and immunohistochemically identical to those comprising the primary renal tumor. After two cycles of treatment with doxorubicin, there was a 50% reduction in the size of the tumors with marked improvement in performance status. We believe this case confirms the existence of a malignant epithelioid angiomyolipoma.

Extensively keratinized squamous intraepithelial lesions of the cervix are difficult to grade

We tested the hypothesis that extensively keratinized squamous intraepithelial lesions (SILs) are difficult to grade precisely by identifying 100 Papanicolaou smears with a keratinizing SIL that had been originally judged difficult to grade. Of these, 65 were confirmed as low-grade SIL (LSIL) or high-grade SIL (HSIL) on subsequent biopsy. The 65 smears were reviewed independently by 3 cytopathologists who graded each case as LSIL or HSIL (by Bethesda System criteria). The accuracy of the grade was determined by the subsequent biopsy results; accuracy was compared with that of a historic control group of SILs with biopsy follow-up. In the study group, biopsies showed LSIL in 41 cases and HSIL in 24. The mean accuracy for a smear diagnosis of LSIL was 60% for the study group and 92% for the control group. For a smear diagnosis of HSIL, the accuracy was 60% for the study group and 95% for the control group. The overall kappa value for the study group confirmed poor interobserver agreement. Some keratinizing SILs are difficult if not impossible to grade precisely using standard criteria. For such lesions, the diagnosis "SIL, grade cannot be determined due to extensive keratinization" is justified.

Diagnosing lymphoproliferative disorders involving the cerebrospinal fluid: increased sensitivity using flow cytometric analysis

Flow cytometric immunophenotypic analysis (FCA) can be performed to evaluate lymphoid cells in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). We compared this method with conventional cytologic diagnosis to determine its utility. A retrospective comparison of 35 consecutive CSF flow cytometry results with the corresponding cytologic diagnoses was undertaken. Twenty-five of 35 CSFs (71%) were successfully analyzed by flow cytometry. The 10 samples which could not be analyzed were either too old (greater than 3 days) or had an insufficient number of cells. A total of 9 lymphomas was detected: 4 by both flow cytometry and cytology; 2 by cytology alone; and 3 by flow cytometry alone. This represents a 50% increase in the detection of lymphoproliferative disorders in CSF by a combination of flow cytometry and cytology vs. cytology alone. Furthermore, in 3 cases with follow-up where the cytologic diagnosis was "atypical cells of undetermined significance" and the flow cytometric findings were negative for malignancy, the clinical course confirmed a benign pleocytosis in all three. We conclude that flow cytometric analysis markedly improves sensitivity when used in combination with cytology in the evaluation of lymphoid cells in CSF.

Cytologic detection of Toxoplasma gondii tachyzoites in cerebrospinal fluid

We reviewed our case records to see how often Toxoplasma gondii organisms were identified by cytologic evaluation of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). During a 12-year period, 6,090 CSF specimens were examined, and 2 cases (0.03%) showed tachyzoites. Both patients were immunocompromised. One patient underwent lumbar and ventricular taps, and the other underwent only ventricular tap. Organisms were identified in the ventricular specimens but not in the lumbar sample. Both patients were treated, and subsequent ventricular CSF samples were negative. Toxoplasma gondii can be identified by cytologic examination of CSF. Our results confirm prior observations that in patients with obstructive hydrocephalus, tachyzoites are more likely to be found in ventricular rather than lumbar specimens.

Usefulness of ultrasonography in the management of nodular thyroid disease

BACKGROUND

Fine-needle aspiration biopsy is the standard diagnostic test for evaluating possible malignancy in a thyroid nodule.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of routine ultrasonography in the management of nodular thyroid disease.

DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

Multidisciplinary thyroid nodule clinic (endocrinology and radiology).

PATIENTS

Patients with suspected nodular thyroid disease or suspected recurrent thyroid cancer referred between October 1995 and March 1997. All patients had thyroid ultrasonography and ultrasonography-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy of nodules at least 1 cm in maximum diameter.

MEASUREMENTS

Medical records, ultrasonography findings, cytology reports, and histologic reports were reviewed. Ultrasonography findings were compared with the referring physician's findings on physical examination.

RESULTS

223 patients were seen in the clinic. A total of 209 fine-needle aspiration biopsies were performed on 156 patients. Among 50 of 114 patients referred for a solitary nodule, ultrasonography detected additional nonpalpable nodules at least 1 cm in diameter in 27 and determined that no nodules required aspiration in 23. Of 59 patients referred for a diffuse goiter or a multinodular gland, ultrasonography detected discrete nodules at least 1 cm in diameter that required aspiration in 39 and determined that aspiration was unnecessary in 20.

CONCLUSIONS

Ultrasonography altered the clinical management for 63% of the patients (109 of 173) referred to the thyroid nodule clinic after abnormal results on thyroid physical examination.

LSIL biopsies after HSIL smears. Correlation with high-risk HPV and greater risk of HSIL on follow-up

Can the risk associated with a high-grade cervical smear be disregarded when followed by a low-grade biopsy? We examined the distribution of human papillomavirus (HPV) types in such cases to see whether they segregated preferentially with low-risk or high-risk viruses and compared the distribution with that reported in the literature for women with high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSILs) and low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LSILs). We identified 48 cases of HSIL smears with corresponding LSIL biopsy specimens. Biopsy specimens were tested and typed for HPV by polymerase chain reaction amplification with consensus primers followed by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis, and HPVs were scored as low-risk or high-risk types. Thirty-seven cases scored positive for HPV DNA: 2 for low-risk HPV types, 17 for high-risk types, and 18 for types of unknown oncogenicity. The prevalence of high-risk HPV was significantly higher than that of low-risk HPV. There was a higher rate of high-risk HPV than that seen in historic unselected LSIL cases. Cases of HSIL cytology/LSIL histology represent a group distinct from unselected LSILs by virtue of their higher prevalence of high-risk HPV types and, therefore, warrant closer clinical follow-up.

Preclinical feasibility study of NMP179, a nuclear matrix protein marker for cervical dysplasia

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate, in a preclinical feasibility study, the efficacy of NMP179, a monoclonal antibody recognizing a cervical tumor-associated nuclear matrix antigen, for the early detection of high and low grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia.

STUDY DESIGN

In a blind study involving two clinical sites, NMP179 immunocytochemical staining data from 261 cervicovaginal Thin-Prep specimens were evaluated. Assay sensitivity and specificity were calculated based upon a positive threshold of > 10 immunostained cells per case, using cytologic diagnosis as an end point.

RESULTS

Based upon the examination of squamous epithelial cells, NMP179 detected 96.7% of cases with cytologically diagnosed high grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL) and 70.5% of low grade squamous intraepithelial lesions. The antibody also reacted with 29.6% of normal (within normal limits or benign cellular changes) smears.

CONCLUSION

The NMP179 assay detected HSIL with very high accuracy (96.7%). The assay was 79.3% sensitive for the detection of low and high grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (grades 1-3), with a specificity of 70.4%. NMP179 may be an effective marker for the early detection of preneoplastic squamous intraepithelial lesions of the cervix and may be useful as an adjunctive tool for better management of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia.

Cytologic characteristics of abnormal cells in prior "normal" cervical/vaginal Papanicolaou smears from women with a high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion

BACKGROUND

Some cervical/vaginal Papanicolaou (Pap) smears previously diagnosed as normal in women with a high grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL) are found to contain abnormal cells on retrospective review. This study characterized and quantitated such cells in 100 Pap smears.

METHODS

One hundred prior negative Pap smears from 49 women with a newly diagnosed HSIL were rescreened, as were 107 negative Pap smears from 100 women with normal subsequent smears. Cases were assorted randomly so that the rescreener was unaware of the subsequent follow-up.

RESULTS

All 12 Pap smears found to contain atypical mature and immature metaplastic cells belonged to the group with a subsequent HSIL (P = 0.001). In addition, 18 of the 100 previously negative Pap smears (18%) had immature metaplastic cells without nuclear atypia compared with 4 of 107 Pap smears (4%) in the control group (P = 0.0007).

CONCLUSIONS

This study supports the observations of other authors that atypical metaplastic cells, especially those of the immature type, are associated with HSIL. These cells most likely are HSIL lesional cells, which are not easily recognizable as such. Immature metaplastic cells without atypia also were shown to be associated significantly with HSIL in this study. These cells may be unrecognizable lesional cells or a marker of increased risk for HSIL and deserve further study.

Performance characteristics of rapid (30-second) prescreening. Implications for calculating the false-negative rate and comparison with other quality assurance techniques

Rapid (30-second) prescreening of cervicovaginal smears can be used to detect false-negative cases and determine the false-negative rate of primary screening, but the performance characteristics have not been evaluated fully. A test set of 242 cases including 80 originally false-negative cases were rapidly screened by 4 different cytotechnologists on 2 occasions. Intraobserver and interobserver reproducibility were good. Median specificity for each round of observations was 89% (range, 30%-96%). Median sensitivity for all true-positive cases was 78% (range, 63%-97%); for all false-negative cases it was 59% (range, 38%-89%). The relative sensitivity of rapid screening for true-positive and false-negative cases varied with the diagnosis. Rapid screening detected almost the same percentage of false-negative cases of atypical squamous cells of uncertain significance (ASCUS) as true-positive ASCUS cases (median ratio, 1.12; range, 0.72-1.52). The median ratio of false-negative to true-positive ASCUS cases was significantly different than the ratio for low-grade plus high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (0.68; range, 0.50-0.96). Although performance varies between individuals, in this test population the reproducibility, specificity, and sensitivity were good. Because it detects more false-negative cases at a lower cost per case than routine rescreening, rapid prescreening should be considered as an alternative to current quality control measures.

Accuracy and complication rate of brush cytology from bile duct versus pancreatic duct

BACKGROUND

The accuracy and complication rates of brush cytology obtained from pancreaticobiliary strictures have not been fully defined. In this study we compared the accuracy and complications of brush cytology obtained from bile versus pancreatic ducts.

METHODS

We identified 148 consecutive patients for whom brush cytology was done during an ERCP from a database with prospectively collected data. We compared cytology results with the final diagnosis as determined by surgical pathologic examination or long-term clinical follow-up. We followed all patients and recorded ERCP-related complications.

RESULTS

Forty-two pancreatic brush cytology samples and 101 biliary brush cytology samples were obtained. The accuracy rate of biliary cytology was 65 of 101 (64.3%) and the accuracy rate of pancreatic cytology was 30 of 42 (71.4%). Overall sensitivity was 50% for biliary cytology and 58.3% for pancreatic cytology. Of 67 patients with pancreatic adenocarcinoma, sensitivity for biliary cytology was 50% versus 66% for pancreatic cytology. Concurrent pancreatic and biliary cytology during the same procedure increased the sensitivity in only 1 of 10 (10%) patients. Pancreatitis occurred in 11 (11%) patients (9 mild cases, 2 moderate cases) after biliary cytology and in 9 (21%) patients (6 mild cases, 3 moderate cases) after pancreatic cytology (p = 0.22). In 10 patients who had pancreatic brush cytology, a pancreatic stent was placed. None of these patients developed pancreatitis versus 9 of 32 (28%) patients in whom a stent was not placed (p = 0.08). Pancreatic cytology samples obtained from the head of the pancreas were correct in 13 of 18 (72%) cases, from the genu in 7 of 7 (100%) cases, from the body in 5 of 9 (55%) cases, and from the tail in 4 of 7 (57%) cases.

CONCLUSION

The accuracy of biliary brush cytology is similar to the accuracy of pancreatic brush cytology. The yield of the latter for pancreatic adenocarcinoma is similar to that of the former. Complication rates for pancreatic cytology are not significantly higher than the rates for biliary cytology. The placement of a pancreatic stent after pancreatic brushing appears to reduce the risk of postprocedure pancreatitis.

Accuracy and reproducibility of estimating the adequacy of the squamous component of cervicovaginal smears

In the Bethesda System for reporting cervicovaginal cytology results, 1 criterion for smear adequacy is an adequate squamous component. The accuracy of a cytologist's estimate that 10% of the slide is covered by squamous cells, the adequacy threshold, has not been determined. The percentage of the surface of a glass slide covered by squamous cells was independently estimated by 4 cytologists on 2 occasions by microscopic examination of 83 buccal smears prepared to display estimated coverage of 1% to 20% of the slide surface. The accuracy of visual estimates was compared with measurements by the TracCell System. Each observer made a third set of estimates after receiving 5 slides with known coverage. Median coverage by visual estimation ranged from 4% to 25%, but as measured by the TracCell system was 2%. Median estimated coverage was significantly different for 2 of 4 observers between first and second viewings and between all but 1 pair of observers. For all observers, it was significantly higher than the true coverage. A visual estimate of 10% coverage corresponded to a true median coverage of 3%. When provided with a physical standard, the median estimated coverage by 3 of 4 observers was not statistically different from the true coverage, and interobserver kappa values improved. Unaided visual estimation of the adequacy of squamous cell coverage is neither reproducible nor accurate. What most cytologists consider "adequate" coverage represents only 3% coverage. The availability of a physical standard dramatically increases reproducibility and accuracy.

Nontyrosine crystalloids in fine-needle aspiration specimens of the parotid gland: a report of two cases and review of the literature

Three fine-needle aspiration biopsies from 2 patients with parotid masses yielded large numbers of nontyrosine crystalloids. One patient proved to have a benign cyst that was resected because it did not subside following two fine-needle aspirates. In a second patient, the swelling shrank after a course of antibiotics and fine-needle aspiration/drainage of the cyst. Recognition that crystalloids are associated with benign disease is important and should be considered in the management of these patients. The outcome of the patients studied here and of those previously reported has been benign. Conservative management of patients with parotid masses that contain nontyrosine crystalloids is indicated.

Negative predictive value of imaging-guided abdominal biopsy results: cytologic classification and implications for patient management

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to assess the negative predictive value of imaging-guided abdominal biopsy results and correlate it with cytology classification, lesion size, needle gauge, and cancer history.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was performed of 100 patients with proven diagnoses who had undergone imaging-guided abdominal biopsies showing no cells that were malignant or suspicious for malignancy. Specimens were classified as normal or benign, nondiagnostic, or atypical. Negative predictive value was calculated for each cytologic category, lesion size, needle gauge, and cancer history. Logistic regression analysis was performed to allow us to identify predictors of false-negative results.

RESULTS

Overall negative predictive value was 67%. Other negative predictive values were normal or benign result, 78%; nondiagnostic result, 66%; and atypical result, 29%. Negative predictive value was greater when the lesion was large (> or =3 cm) (p = .031). Logistic regression analysis allowed us to predict a 9.3% chance of a false-negative result for a specimen of normal or benign cytology that was taken from a large lesion in a patient with no cancer history but an 87% chance of a false-negative when a specimen of atypical cytology was taken from a small (<3 cm) lesion in a patient with a cancer history.

CONCLUSION

Imaging-guided abdominal biopsy specimens containing atypical cells should be viewed with caution. In patients without cancer, if a lesion is large and the specimen contains normal target organ or benign cells, the likelihood of a false-negative result may be low enough that imaging surveillance at appropriate intervals may be sufficient.

Adenocarcinoma in situ in cervical smears with a small cell (endometrioid) pattern: distinction from cells directly sampled from the upper endocervical canal or lower segment of the endometrium

Adenocarcinoma in situ (AIS) with small, endometrioid cells in cervicovaginal smears, is a source of false-negative diagnoses because of the difficulty in distinguishing these cells from endometrial cells of the lower uterine segment or benign cells from the upper endocervical canal. This study was designed to elucidate the most useful criteria for this distinction. Three observers blinded to the actual diagnoses reviewed 29 preselected cases (AIS, 17; benign, 12) that had originally caused diagnostic difficulty. Each observer made a diagnosis and evaluated 15 preselected diagnostic criteria. All 3 observers agreed on the correct diagnosis in 19 (66%) of 29 cases, and at least 2 observers agreed on the correct diagnosis in 27 (93%) of 29 cases. No case was misdiagnosed by all 3 observers. The most useful criteria for the diagnosis of AIS are a predominance of groups with marked crowding, focal feathering, nuclear hyperchromatism with coarsening of chromatin, and occasional mitotic figures. Sheets of cells, endometrial tubules, and endometrial stroma favor a benign diagnosis. Although 12 (14%) of 87 possible diagnoses were erroneous, well-preserved, small, endometrioid AIS cells can be identified correctly on cervical smears and distinguished from epithelium from the lower uterine segment and high endocervical canal in most cases using the aforementioned criteria.

Qualifying the cytologic diagnosis of "atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance" affects the predictive value of a squamous intraepithelial lesion on subsequent biopsy

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate whether different qualifications of a cytologic diagnosis of "atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance" predict a greater or lesser likelihood of cervical pathology.

DESIGN

Comparison of different cytologic qualifications of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance with the frequency of significant cervical disease as documented by tissue biopsy.

PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING

Four hundred, fifty-two consecutive Papanicolaou smears showing atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (diagnosed by nine cytopathologists) in women who had undergone cervical biopsy within the previous 90 days at Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Mass (January-June 1995).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

The histopathologic diagnosis of squamous intraepithelial lesion of the cervix.

RESULTS

The 452 smears were qualified as "favor reactive" (22%), "not otherwise specified" (42%), "favor squamous intraepithelial lesion" (29%), and "favor high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion" (6%). High-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions and total squamous intraepithelial lesions were pathologically confirmed by cervical biopsy in 3.6% and 6% of the favor reactive smears, in 11% and 21% of the not otherwise specified smears, in 12% and 30% of the favor squamous intraepithelial lesion smears, and in 53% and 59% of the favor high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion smears. Significant associations were seen between a favor reactive smear and a benign finding on cervical biopsy (94%, P = .04) and between a favor high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion smear and a biopsy that showed a high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (53%, P = .00001).

CONCLUSIONS

Qualifying atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance stratifies women into different risk groups for squamous intraepithelial lesion. It is reasonable for physicians to make patient management decisions based, at least in part, on such qualifications.

Automation in cytology: a survey conducted by the New Technology Task Force, Papanicolaou Society of Cytopathology

Despite the overwhelming interest in the development of several computer based technologies in the last several years, the role of automation in cytology has remained controversial. The potential of these technologies in the reduction of false negative results in pap smears is well recognized. However, there is still remarkable confusion as how to incorporate automation in the routine practice of cytology. This prompted the New Technology Task Force of the George Papanicolaou Society of Cytopathology to design a survey to seek the opinion of those engaged in cervicovaginal cytology screening regarding the value of automation in cytology. In 1996, a ten question survey was sent to 1800 cytopathology laboratories throughout the nation. The response rate was 23% (416/1800). The responders represented laboratories varying from those with less than 5,000 pap smears to those with over 100,000 cases per year. The majority of the responders did not believe that automation is essential for cervicovaginal cytology. This was evidenced by the fact that only 12% of the laboratories were engaged in automated cytology and predominantly used it for quality control measures. The inability of small laboratories to absorb the extra expense involved in the integration of automated cytology in their practice, particularly in the current era of managed care was a major concern. There was also concern about the potential for compromise of patient care by the drive for corporate profits and the dissemination of wrong information to the public and physicians. Suggestions most frequently proposed included appropriate patient and physician education about the merits and pitfalls of the pap smear, and also endorsing an affordable universal fee for pap smears. Rescreening for all pap smears, reassessing the benefits of automation in cytology and development of the standards were other proposals. Partnership with larger cytology laboratories, creation of "cytology consortiums" with shared resources to provide regionalized automated rescreening services were also strongly suggested. This survey clearly indicates the need for further evaluation of automation in cytopathology and a focused attention to various issues surrounding cervicovaginal cytology screening.

A more accurate measure of the false-negative rate of Papanicolaou smear screening is obtained by determining the false-negative rate of the rescreening process

BACKGROUND

The false-negative rate (FNR), or fraction, of Papanicolaou (Pap) smear screening has been proposed as a useful quality assessment measure. The FNR should account for the FNR of the rescreening process itself. The authors measured the FNR of the rescreening process by rescreening a set of abnormal smears.

METHODS

A randomly selected group of negative (150) and abnormal (91) smears were rescreened in a blinded fashion. A diagnosis of atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASCUS) or worse was used as a positive (abnormal) result. All discrepancies were confirmed by consensus review. The true FNR of screening Pap smears was calculated as: true FNR = calculated FNR/(1-FNR of rescreening).

RESULTS

When rescreened, 17 originally negative cases were interpreted as ASCUS and 5 as unsatisfactory. Twenty-three originally abnormal cases (22 ASCUS and 1 low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion) were interpreted as negative. After consensus review, only 1 of the originally negative cases was believed to be ASCUS and 1 unsatisfactory; 18 of the 23 originally abnormal cases were believed to be rescreening errors and 5 of the 23 originally abnormal cases were believed to be false-positives. The FNR of Pap smear screening as traditionally calculated was 6.1%, which was slightly less than the laboratory's usual FNR. The FNR of review screening was 20.9%. The true FNR of Pap smear screening was 7.8% and the false-positive rate was 0.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

The FNR of rescreening is not insubstantial. It can and should be measured by rescreening abnormal smears, and when taken into account yields a more accurate measure of the FNR of Pap smear screening.

Receiver operating characteristic curves for analysis of the results of cervicovaginal smears. A useful quality improvement tool

OBJECTIVES

To assess the value of receiver operating characteristic curves (ROCs) as a tool for improvement in the evaluation of cervicovaginal smear results.

DESIGN

We reviewed the results of cervicovaginal smear interpretation for 1 year by 10 different cytopathologists working in the same laboratory (total number of cases, 45,356) and compared them with results of histologic evaluation of corresponding biopsies (n = 2090, 4.6%), the latter taken to be the gold standard. Receiver operating characteristic curves were generated for the laboratory as a whole and for individual cytopathologists.

RESULTS

Analysis of these receiver operating characteristic curves was surprisingly informative. They showed that cytopathologists with different diagnostic thresholds could be distinguished from each other. A difference in diagnostic threshold could be distinguished from a difference in diagnostic accuracy.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that while receiver operating characteristic curves for cervicovaginal smear interpretation have limitations, the results can be used for quality improvement.

Frequency of tumor diathesis in smears from women with squamous cell carcinoma of the cervix

OBJECTIVE

To determine the prevalence of tumor diathesis (TD) in cervicovaginal smears from patients with squamous cell carcinoma (SQC).

STUDY DESIGN

We reviewed all the cervical smears obtained no more than one year before a biopsy diagnosis of SQC. Patients who underwent irradiation to the cervix before the smear was taken were excluded from the analysis. The smears were rescreened by both authors, and the presence and extent of TD were recorded.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight smears from 19 patients with SQC fulfilled the study criteria. TD was seen in 15 of the 28 smears (54%). There was a positive correlation between the presence of TD and the depth of invasion.

CONCLUSION

Although an important criterion of malignancy, TD is absent from some cases of SQC, particularly those that invade < 5 mm. A definite distinction between an intraepithelial lesion and a shallow invasive cancer may not be possible on cervicovaginal smears.

Fine-needle aspiration of the adult kidney

BACKGROUND

Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) of the adult kidney is an excellent diagnostic tool in the appropriate clinical setting. The indications, cytologic criteria, and therapeutic implications of renal FNA may be changing.

METHODS

A review of the English language literature concerning the indications, utility, and criteria for renal FNA was performed.

RESULTS

The indications for renal FNA are changing as radiologic imaging allows better assessment of cystic lesions and incidentally identifies an increasing percentage of renal lesions. Cytologic criteria and pitfalls for the diagnosis of a wide variety of benign and malignant lesions have been delineated and refined. The increasing use of partial rather than radical nephrectomy for some renal lesions suggests that accurate distinction between these lesions may have important therapeutic implications.

CONCLUSIONS

Renal FNA provides important information that can affect the management of patients with renal masses.

Fine needle aspiration biopsy of idiopathic retroperitoneal fibrosis

OBJECTIVE

To report three cases of idiopathic retroperitoneal fibrosis (IRF) diagnosed by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy and confirmed by histologic examination. To our knowledge, this is the first report on the FNA findings in IRF.

STUDY DESIGN

Specimens were obtained under computed tomographic guidance using the standard technique. Half the smears were ethanol fixed and stained with Papanicolaou stain, and the other half were air dried and stained with Diff-Quik. A cell block was prepared in all cases.

RESULTS

Similar findings were seen in all three cases. The predominant elements were fibrous tissue and inflammatory cells, which occasionally occurred together but often were separate. The inflammatory cells were predominantly small lymphocytes, with occasional plasma cells, histiocytes and neutrophils. Smears from one case showed the inflammatory component only, but the cell block in all three cases showed both elements. The diagnosis of IRF was suggested in two of the three cases. All patients underwent laparotomy for diagnostic confirmation, and two had therapeutic resection of the lesion. Histologic material reflected the FNA findings, showing hyalinized fibrous tissue and an inflammatory cell infiltrate consisting of lymphocytes, plasma cells, histiocytes and neutrophils. No infection, arteritis or malignancy was present.

CONCLUSION

Although the FNA picture is nonspecific, in combination with clinical and radiologic findings it is highly suggestive of a diagnosis of IRF. A presumptive diagnosis allows a rational approach to further evaluation and therapy, which, in most cases, is an exploratory laparotomy with ureterolysis.

The role of cytologic evaluation of pleural fluid in the diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma

STUDY OBJECTIVE

Treatment of malignant mesothelioma (MM) at an early stage results in increased survival. Cytologic examination of pleural effusions is one of the first diagnostic techniques attempted in these patients. The objective of this study was to define the role of cytologic examination of pleural fluid in facilitating early diagnosis.

DESIGN

The medical records and cytologic slides of patients with pleural MM were reviewed.

SETTING

Medical records were reviewed from two institutions: a large general hospital and a cancer hospital.

PATIENTS

Twenty-nine patients ranging in age from 32 to 81 years (mean, 59 years) met the study criteria.

INTERVENTIONS

All patients had at least one cytologic pleural fluid examination.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

The median time from initial symptoms to the diagnosis of MM was 8 weeks for all patients. For patients with a positive or suspicious cytologic result, the median was 4 weeks, and in those with a negative cytologic result, it was 12 weeks. The overall sensitivity of cytologic examination for the diagnosis of MM was 32%. Cytogenetic analysis of pleural fluid had a sensitivity of 56%, and was positive in 1 case in which results of cytologic examination were negative. Patients in whom the time from presentation to diagnosis was greater than 1 year all had negative cytologic results followed by long periods without further workup, despite a history of exposure to asbestos.

CONCLUSIONS

A positive or suspicious cytologic result was associated with a decreased median time to diagnosis. Unfortunately, the sensitivity of cytologic examination for a diagnosis of MM was only 32%. Until better diagnostic techniques are developed, we recommend immediate pleural biopsy in patients in whom MM is suspected and cytologic evaluation of pleural fluid gives negative results.

Cytologic findings in thyroid nodules after 131I treatment of hyperthyroidism

Findings in seven cytologic specimens obtained with fine-needle aspiration biopsy were described in three patients in whom thyroid nodules developed after iodine 131 treatment of hyperthyroidism. In two patients, the presence of large bizarre cells with hyperchromatic nuclei, coarse chromatin, and prominent nucleoli suggested the possibility of malignancy, and in particular, anaplastic carcinoma. These bizarre nuclear changes were diffuse in one patient and focal in the other. In the third patient, nuclei with chromatin clearing, grooves, and nuclear pseudoinclusions suggested papillary carcinoma. At follow-up, lesions were benign in all three patients. We conclude that nuclear changes suggestive of either anaplastic carcinoma or papillary carcinoma may be seen in thyroid nodules after 131I treatment. Clues to the benign nature of these nodules include architectural arrangement of cells in cohesive clusters and flat sheets; presence of lymphocytes, histiocytes, colloid, cytoplasmic vacuoles, and Hürthle cells; and a clinical history of treatment with radioactive iodine.

Cytology of metastatic adenocarcinoma of the prostate in pleural effusions

Malignant pleural effusions due to prostatic carcinoma are rare. We examined the cytologic and clinical presentations of 14 malignant pleural effusions caused by prostate cancer. These cases represented 2.3% of all positive pleural effusions at our institution. All patients (n = 10) had high grade, high stage tumors, including three with small cell anaplastic carcinoma. Three cases had clinically documented metastases to pleura, and in two cases, metastases were documented at autopsy. Most tumor cells had large nucleoli and were arranged in small, loosely cohesive groups. Fluids due to the small cell type of prostate carcinoma often contained a mixture of cells similar to those seen in small cell carcinoma of other sites such as the lung, as well as cells resembling the more typical type of prostate cancer. Prostatic specific antigen and prostatic acid phosphatase were positive in less than 50% of these malignant effusions. We conclude that prostatic carcinoma in pleural effusions occurs most commonly in high grade, high stage tumors and has a characteristic cytologic appearance. Negative staining for PSA and PAP does not rule out a prostatic source for malignant cells in effusions.

Bethesda classification of cervicovaginal smears: reproducibility and viral correlates

Fifty-five cervicovaginal smears from women with squamous intraepithelial lesions (SILs) were independently evaluated on two separate occasions by four cytopathologists using a binary classification system (the Bethesda system). Smears were categorized as low-grade (LSIL) or high-grade (HSIL) using previously published criteria. All women had subsequent cervical biopsies containing human papillomavirus (HPV) DNA amplified with the polymerase chain reaction and typed by restriction fragment polymorphism analysis. Three or more observers agreed on classification in 49 of 55 cases (87%); unanimous diagnoses were rendered in 31 cases (56%). Interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility ranged from fair to near-excellent (kappa values 0.40 to 0.63; 0.63 to 0.74, respectively). HPV types included HPV 16 (27%), 18 (7%), 31 (9%), 35 (4%), 39 (4%), 6 (10%), 11 (2%), novel types (30%), and multiple types (4%). High-risk HPV types (16, 18, 31, 35, and 39) were significantly associated (P = .03) with consensus HSIL diagnoses (agreement of three or more observers). This was primarily because of the strong association of HPV 16 with HSIL (P = .001). After excluding HPV 16, the other high-risk HPV types (18, 31, 35, and 39) were no longer significantly associated with consensus HSIL diagnoses (P > .5). Conversely, LSIL diagnoses were significantly associated with non-high-risk HPV types (all HPV types except 16, 18, 31, 35, and 39; P = .006). Binary cytological classification of cervicovaginal SILs is reproducible among cytopathologists. Such classification correlates well with most low-risk HPV types and with the prototypic high-risk HPV 16 but not with other high-risk HPV types.

Novel fluorescence in situ hybridization approaches in solid tumors. Characterization of frozen specimens, touch preparations, and cytological preparations

Fluorescence in situ hybridization has emerged as an extremely important tool for detection and characterization of nonrandom chromosome aberrations in cancer. Fluorescence in situ hybridization assays have been very reliable in cytogenetic tumor preparations, but have been more unpredictable in archival, paraffin-embedded specimens. We describe novel approaches for detection of chromosome aberrations in frozen tumor specimens, touch preparations, and cytological preparations. These approaches are both simple and reproducible, with minimal case-to-case variation in hybridization efficiency or hybridization signal quality. We demonstrate potential applications of these novel approaches by evaluating: 1) significance of normal karyotypes in malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors; 2) p15/p16 copy number in prostate cancer; and 3) clonal chromosome 3p deletion in cytological preparations of pleural fluid from patients with mesothelioma.

Applications of flow cytometric DNA analysis to diagnostic cytology

Flow cytometry is a rapid method for measuring DNA content. Its high sensitivity and specificity in detecting transitional cell carcinomas in bladder washings should make it a routinely applied adjunct to cytology once universal laboratory standards are firmly established. Diagnostic and prognostic information on solid tumors can be obtained at least as reliably on fine-needle aspirations as on surgically resected specimens. At the present time, the sensitivity of FCM in the evaluation of effusions, peritoneal washings, and CSF is relatively low, and although in some cases malignant cells in these specimens that are missed by conventional cytology are detected by FCM, the number of such cases is small. Investigation continues into the application of FCM to the screening of cervical specimens.

Cytologic/histologic correlation for quality control in cervicovaginal cytology. Experience with 1,582 paired cases

For quality-control purposes, federal regulations require cytology laboratories to compare Papanicolaou smear and cervical biopsy reports, if available, and determine the cause of any discrepancies. The authors reviewed 56,497 cervicovaginal smears, of which 1,582 (2.8%) had a subsequent cervical biopsy or endocervical curettage within 2 months. A total of 175 discrepancies (11%) were identifed, and biopsies and smears from these cases were reviewed at a weekly conference. In the majority of cases, the diagnosis of the smear and biopsy was confirmed on review, and the discrepancy was attributed to sampling error (n = 159; 91%). Six cases (3.4% of all discrepant cases) were errors in cytologic diagnosis. Five of these were interpretation errors, and one case was a screening error. There were 10 errors in the evaluation of cervical biopsies (5.7% of all discrepant cases): five biopsies were undercalled, and five were overdiagnosed as a squamous intraepithelial lesion. The results of testing for human papillomavirus DNA by in situ hybridization were helpful in arbitrating some diagnositic disagreements.

Evaluation of a new slide-based laser scanning cytometer for DNA analysis of tumors. Comparison with flow cytometry and image analysis

DNA measurements generated by a new automated slide-based cytometer, the laser scanning cytometer (LSC), were compared with those produced by commercial flow cytometry (FCM) and image analysis (IA) devices. Laser scanning-cytometric analysis was performed by scanning alcohol-fixed, propidium iodide-stained tumor imprints with a 5-microns spot laser beam. Fifty-three malignant tumors (51 breast carcinomas and 2 lung carcinomas) were studied. Ploidy concordance rates for FCM versus LSC, IA versus LSC, and FCM versus IA were 96%, 91%, and 91%, respectively. Statistically significant agreement between methods was determined by linear regression analysis of DNA indices. Synthesis-phase fractions generated by FCM and LSC also were comparable, as demonstrated by linear regression (r = .83). Mean coefficients of variation for the LSC compared favorably with those for FCM and IA. The few discrepancies in ploidy status between methods could be explained by sampling error, the presence of possible near-diploid aneuploid populations that could not be effectively resolved by one or another modality, and the visual selection bias with IA when small aneuploid cell populations were present. The LSC shares many useful features with FCM, including automation, accuracy of quantitation, rapidity, and generation of reliable information regarding cell proliferation (synthesis-phase fraction). In addition, it has some of the advantages of IA, such as minimal tissue requirement, no need for special preparation, and the potential for visual selection of the cells measured. The LSC holds great promise for use in the clinical laboratory because of these combined characteristics.

Cytogenetic analysis of effusions from malignant mesothelioma. A diagnostic adjunct to cytology

Most patients with malignant mesothelioma (MM) present with an effusion, but distinguishing malignant from reactive mesothelial cells by conventional cytology may be difficult. We investigated the possibility of identifying clonal cytogenetic aberrations in pleural or peritoneal fluid from 10 patients with a clinical suspicion of MM. Direct metaphase harvests and short-term cultures were performed on fresh fluid. Clonal cytogenetic aberrations indicative of malignancy, with findings previously reported in association with mesothelioma, were found in all patients; these included del(1p), del(3p) and del(22q). Cytologic examination of the effusions showed malignant cells consistent with MM in 5 patients and atypical mesothelial cells suggestive of MM in 4. In one case the cytology of several samples of pleural fluid was within normal limits. Subsequent histology confirmed the diagnosis of MM in 9 of the 10 patients; medical complications precluded tissue biopsy in the 10th. We conclude that the cytogenetic analysis of effusions may be a useful and reliable adjunct to cytology in the diagnosis of MM.

Nasal scrape cytology in the diagnosis of Wegener's granulomatosis. A case report

Wegener's granulomatosis (WG) is a potentially fatal disease in which early diagnosis and administration of immunosuppressive agents is essential to successful treatment. The disease is characterized by necrotizing and granulomatous inflammation and vasculitis of the respiratory tract and kidney. The variety of clinical presentations often makes the diagnosis difficult. We present a case of WG in a 24-year-old male in whom the diagnosis was first suggested after cytologic examination of a nasal scrape for sinusitis. The smears showed numerous neutrophils and occasional multinucleate histiocytic giant cells. Reactive epithelial cells from the respiratory mucosa were also present. No organisms were identified on Gram or acid-fast stain. Considering the clinical setting, the diagnosis of WG was suggested. Subsequent renal biopsy revealed necrotizing and crescentic glomerulonephritis, and the patient was successfully treated with cyclophosphamide. This case illustrates a rapid and noninvasive method by which the diagnosis of WG may be suspected early in the course of the disease.

Impact of positive findings at image-guided biopsy of lymphoma on patient care: evaluation of clinical history, needle size, and pathologic findings on biopsy performance

PURPOSE

To analyze the effect of findings at image-guided biopsy of abdominal lymphoma (IGBL) on patient care and define the key determinants of clinical success.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective, bi-institutional study was performed in 102 patients with positive or suspicious IGBL findings (93 patients with non-Hodgkin and nine patients with Hodgkin lymphoma). The proportion of patients treated on the basis of IGBL findings only was calculated and correlated with 10 determinants, including history of lymphoma, biopsy technique, needle size, immunocytochemical findings, and tumor grade.

RESULTS

Overall, 73 patients (72%) were treated on the basis of biopsy findings only, including 41 (91%) of 45 patients with a history of lymphoma and 32 (56%) of 57 patients with no such history (P < .01). No difference in findings existed when three needle-size groups were compared (P > .50).

CONCLUSION

Whenever findings were positive, IGBL provided enough tissue to enable treatment in most patients. Fine needles were just as likely as larger needles to enable both determination of tumor grade and treatment.

ThinPrep Processor. Clinical trials demonstrate an increased detection rate of abnormal cervical cytologic specimens

The authors compared the accuracy of conventionally prepared smears and smears prepared by an automated, fluid-based, thin-layer processing device in the detection of cytologic abnormalities. A total of 3218 patients from five centers took part in this study, in which a single cervical sample was split into a matched pair. The conventional smear was made in the routine fashion; the remainder of the cells on the sampling device were rinsed into a transport-fixation fluid. A slide was then prepared from the solution using the thin-layer processor. Diagnostic findings identified on the two preparations were compared in a blinded fashion, and a discrepancy resolution procedure was used to eliminate screening differences. Overall, there was a high correlation in the diagnoses of the two methods. For low-grade or more severe disease, the thin-layer method resulted in a 13% increase in the rate of detection, as compared with the conventional Papanicolaou smear technique.

Chromatin texture measurement by Markovian analysis. Use of nuclear models to define and select texture features

The use of nuclear grade as a prognostic indicator in breast cancer has been limited by its poor interobserver reproducibility. Automated cell classification using digital image analysis is one approach to this problem. Nuclear chromatin distribution, an important feature used in nuclear grading, can be quantitated with texture analysis. Markovian analysis is one method of analyzing texture features that is available in a commercially available image analysis system, the CAS-100. In order to select optimal Markovian features for use in nuclear grading of breast cancer, 16 nuclear models were created with computer graphics that demonstrated specific components of nuclear chromatin pattern, such as granularity, contrast, symmetry, peripheral chromatin clumping, and number and shape of nucleoli. These models were analyzed on the CAS-100 image analysis system using software capable of measuring 22 Markovian texture features at 20 levels of pixel resolution (grain). We were able to show that Markovian analysis performed well in discriminating between degrees of chromatin granularity (finely vs. coarsely clumped), amount of contrast (vesicular change), thickness of peripheral chromatin and number of nucleoli. Of the 22 Markovian features, 10 were selected as optimal for discriminating between the above chromatin patterns. Similar optimal Markovian features were found when measurements were performed on captured images of breast cancer cells. The use of these selected Markovian texture features may allow a more rational approach to the use of image analysis for cell classification.

A new look at cervical cytology. ThinPrep multicenter trial results

The objective of this study was to compare the sensitivity of a new test method with the smear method for detection of neoplasia of the uterine cervix. The new procedure, the ThinPrep process, is an automated, fluid-based technique for the collection and preparation of exfoliated and aspirated cytologic specimens. A single sample from each patient was split and prepared both with the smear and test methods. The diagnostic results from the two slides were compared in this blind study. Among a total of 2,655 patients, diagnoses concurred in 92% of cases and were within one diagnostic level of each other 98% of the time. The ThinPrep method facilitated the detection of more low-grade lesions (P less than .001, McNemar's test). In addition, the test method decreased the number of ambiguous interpretations. The ThinPrep method appears to improve the cervical cytologic smear quality by the harvest of a random and reproducible sample, with a reduction in artifacts. The new method improves the sensitivity of the cervical cytologic screening test.

Hodgkin's disease presenting as an enlarged thyroid gland. Report of a case diagnosed by fine needle aspiration

An unusual case of Hodgkin's disease (HD) in a 36-year-old woman that was diagnosed by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy of a neck mass believed clinically to be diffuse goiter is reported. The aspirate was composed mainly of dispersed lymphocytes; admixed with these were occasional large mononuclear cells with round-to-oval nuclei and prominent nucleoli. Binucleated variants of the large cells were interpreted as Reed-Sternberg cells, suggesting the diagnosis of HD. Subsequent to the FNA biopsy, radiologic examinations demonstrated an enlarged mediastinum, and incisional biopsy of the neck mass confirmed the diagnosis of HD. This case emphasizes the value of FNA biopsy as a rapid and reliable procedure, even in the unusual but established clinical presentation of HD as a diffuse neck mass.

DNA/RNA content and proliferative fractions of colorectal carcinomas: a five-year prospective study relating flow cytometry to survival

In our prospective study, flow cytometric analysis of cellular DNA and RNA content was performed on unfixed fresh specimens of colorectal adenocarcinoma taken from 176 patients. Of the 176 tumors, 113 (64%) were aneuploid. There was no correlation between aneuploidy and tumor stage, grade, location, or size. After a median follow-up of 5.6 years, no correlation between DNA or RNA content and patient survival was found. DNA content alone was not an independent prognostic factor when the colorectal carcinomas were segregated by curable and incurable stages. However, normal mucosa, diploid tumors, and aneuploid tumors showed progressively higher proliferation and higher RNA and DNA indices. Proliferative fraction--defined as the percentage of cells in S + G2 and M phases of the cell cycle--was significantly related to ploidy and to Dukes' stage. Despite these correlations, we did not detect a significant influence of proliferative fraction on survival when patients were segregated above or below the mean proliferative fraction for all tumors. More accurate methods of identifying the proliferative fraction of tumor cells are currently being pursued. While the role of flow cytometry in the evaluation and management of patients with colorectal carcinoma is still undefined for a number of other cellular parameters, it seems unlikely that DNA index, RNA index, or the proliferative fractions calculated from the DNA histogram, will, of themselves, represent independent prognostic factors.

The effect of tumor size and tumor cell DNA content on the survival of patients with stage I adenocarcinoma of the lung

Tumor size at resection and flow cytometric (FCM) DNA distribution of 93 pathologically confirmed AJC Stage I adenocarcinomas of lung were compared with survival. All lung cancers had been treated by lobectomy and mediastinal lymph node dissection at this Institution, and the pathology of all cases was reviewed. Median tumor size was 2.5 cm. FCM DNA assays were carried out on the formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tumor tissue. Seventy-nine (85%) of the tumors were aneuploid and 14 were diploid. There was no significant difference in survival between patients with diploid and aneuploid tumors. The DNA index, proliferation fraction, and fraction of aneuploid cells also had no effect on survival. However, patients with tumors smaller than 3 cm in diameter had a significantly better prognosis than those with larger tumors. Thus, in Stage I adenocarcinoma of lung, tumor size but not cellular DNA content distinguishes subgroups with favorable versus unfavorable prognosis.

Detection of DNA abnormalities by flow cytometry in cells from cerebrospinal fluid

To evaluate the diagnostic utility of flow cytometry (FCM) as compared to cytology, DNA and RNA content of cells were measured in 233 samples of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) from 147 patients with solid tumors or lymphomas and 17 controls with nonmalignant disorders. All control specimens were normal. Twenty-eight samples were abnormal: 20 showed an aneuploid peak and 8 an increased number of cells with DNA content in the S and G2M phases of the cell cycle. Of these 28, cytologic results were positive in 18, suspicious in 3, and negative in 7. All but one of the suspicious and negative cases had confirmatory laboratory and/or radiographic evidence of leptomeningeal metastasis within one week of FCM examination. Cytologic results were positive in eight samples negative by FCM. Compared with cytology, the sensitivity of FCM was 69% and the specificity 95%. Abnormal DNA content by FCM can be a useful adjunct to cytologic examination.

Monitoring endoscopic treatment of superficial bladder carcinoma by postoperative urinary cytology

Transurethral resection was the only modality of treatment in 39 patients with long-standing, recurrent, superficial bladder carcinoma. Postoperative urinary cytology was performed within 3 days of each endoscopy. Tumor recurrence was defined by the presence of a positive biopsy or visible papillary tumors on followup cystoscopic examination. Tumor recurred in 38 patients (97.4 per cent) and 1 patient (2.6 per cent) has remained free of disease 74 months following transient positive postoperative cytology. Among the 38 recurrences 15 (39.5 per cent) were positive, 3 (7.9 per cent) suspicious and 20 (52.6 per cent) negative at the postoperative cytological examination. The interval to recurrence did not differ significantly among the 3 groups. The failure of a negative postoperative cytology study to predict a durable response to treatment by transurethral resection reflects the polychronotopic nature of superficial bladder tumors in this select patient population and suggests the need for adjuvant therapy.

Monitoring intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guerin treatment of superficial bladder carcinoma by postoperative urinary cytology

We studied 51 patients with superficial bladder carcinoma who had been treated with transurethral resection of all gross tumor followed by intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guerin weekly for 6 weeks. Within 72 hours of either the first or second quarterly cystoscopic surveillance examination after bacillus Calmette-Guerin therapy, a conventional cytology study was obtained. Of these patients 8 (15.7 per cent) had positive, 9 (17.6 per cent) suspicious and 34 (66.7 per cent) negative postoperative cytology studies. Subsequent tumor recurrence was defined as a positive biopsy or visible papillary tumors on cystoscopic examination. All 8 patients with a positive postoperative cytology study had tumor recurrence at a median interval of 4 months. Of the 9 patients with a suspicious study 7 (77.8 per cent) had recurrent tumor at a median interval of 7 months and 2 (22.2 per cent) had no evidence of disease at 16 and 19 months, respectively. Of the 34 patients with a negative postoperative cytology study 13 (38.2 per cent) had tumor recurrence after a median interval of 4 months and 21 (67.8 per cent) had no evidence of disease after a median of 25 months. The tumor recurrence rate in patients with a positive or suspicious postoperative cytology study was significantly greater than that of patients with a negative study (p equals 0.001, Fisher's exact test). Postoperative cytology appears to be a significant prognostic indicator following transurethral resection and intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guerin treatment of superficial bladder carcinoma.

The sensitivity of flow cytometry compared with conventional cytology in the detection of superficial bladder carcinoma

Three groups of patients with superficial bladder carcinoma were studied: 110 patients had carcinoma in situ (TIS), 54 had noninvasive papillary transitional cell carcinoma (TA), and 64 had transitional cell carcinoma infiltrating the lamina propria (T1). One to six conventional cytologic examinations per patient (mean 2.8) were obtained during the 24 hour period before biopsy. For all tumor categories combined, the sensitivity was 49%, 54%, 62%, and 66% for one, two, three, and four cytologic examinations per patient, respectively. Cytologic sensitivity varied according to tumor category; it was greater in the TIS and T1 categories than in the TA category. To compare with the cytologic results, a subset of 103 patients had bladder irrigation performed immediately before the biopsy which was subsequently analyzed by flow cytometry. The sensitivity of a single flow cytometric examination for all tumor categories combined was 78%. As with the cytologic examinations, the sensitivity of flow cytometry varied with tumor category; it was greater in TIS and T1 categories than in the TA category. The sensitivity of one flow cytometric examination was superior (binomial test, P less than or equal to 0.05) to that of one or two cytologic examinations for TA tumors and to that of one, two, or three cytologic examinations for TIS, T1, and all tumor categories combined. Only three of 103 patients had their cancers detected by cytologic examination and not by flow cytometry.

Flow cytometric analysis of primary adenocarcinoma of the bladder

The flow cytometric findings of bladder irrigation specimens from 4 patients with histologically confirmed primary adenocarcinoma of the bladder are reported. Cells in specimens from 3 patients showed deoxyribonucleic acid aneuploidy and a simultaneous preoperative urinary cytology study was positive. One patient had normal flow cytometry studies, whereas preoperative cytology results were suspicious. These findings indicate that at least some, perhaps most, primary adenocarcinomas of the bladder have abnormalities of deoxyribonucleic acid content. Flow cytometry should be of value in detecting and monitoring these cases, as it is for epidermoid (urothelial) carcinomas.