Brittle cornea syndrome: recognition, molecular diagnosis and management

Brittle cornea syndrome (BCS) is an autosomal recessive disorder characterised by extreme corneal thinning and fragility. Corneal rupture can therefore occur either spontaneously or following minimal trauma in affected patients. Two genes, ZNF469 and PRDM5, have now been identified, in which causative pathogenic mutations collectively account for the condition in nearly all patients with BCS ascertained to date. Therefore, effective molecular diagnosis is now available for affected patients, and those at risk of being heterozygous carriers for BCS. We have previously identified mutations in ZNF469 in 14 families (in addition to 6 reported by others in the literature), and in PRDM5 in 8 families (with 1 further family now published by others). Clinical features include extreme corneal thinning with rupture, high myopia, blue sclerae, deafness of mixed aetiology with hypercompliant tympanic membranes, and variable skeletal manifestations. Corneal rupture may be the presenting feature of BCS, and it is possible that this may be incorrectly attributed to non-accidental injury. Mainstays of management include the prevention of ocular rupture by provision of protective polycarbonate spectacles, careful monitoring of visual and auditory function, and assessment for skeletal complications such as developmental dysplasia of the hip. Effective management depends upon appropriate identification of affected individuals, which may be challenging given the phenotypic overlap of BCS with other connective tissue disorders.

Functional characterization of bestrophin-1 missense mutations associated with autosomal recessive bestrophinopathy

PURPOSE

Autosomal recessive bestrophinopathy (ARB) is a retinal dystrophy affecting macular and retinal pigmented epithelium function resulting from homozygous or compound heterozygous mutations in BEST1. In this study we characterize the functional implications of missense bestrophin-1 mutations that cause ARB by investigating their effect on bestrophin-1's chloride conductance, cellular localization, and stability.

METHODS

The chloride conductance of wild-type bestropin-1 and a series of ARB mutants were determined by whole-cell patch-clamping of transiently transfected HEK cells. The effect of ARB mutations on the cellular localization of bestrophin-1 was determined by confocal immunofluorescence on transiently transfected MDCK II cells that had been polarized on Transwell filters. Protein stability of wild-type and ARB mutant forms of bestrophin-l was determined by the addition of proteasomal or lysosomal inhibitors to transiently transfected MDCK II cells. Lysates were then analyzed by Western blot analysis.

RESULTS

All ARB mutants investigated produced significantly smaller chloride currents compared to wild-type bestrophin-1. Additionally, co-transfection of compound heterozygous mutants abolished chloride conductance in contrast to co-transfections of a single mutant with wild-type bestrophin-l, reflecting the recessive nature of the condition. In control experiments, expression of two dominant vitelliform macular dystrophy mutants was shown to inhibit wild-type currents. Cellular localization of ARB mutants demonstrated that the majority did not traffic correctly to the plasma membrane and that five of these seven mutants were rapidly degraded by the proteasome. Two ARB-associated mutants (p.D312N and p.V317M) that were not trafficked correctly nor targeted to the proteasome had a distinctive appearance, possibly indicative of aggresome or aggresome-like inclusion bodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Differences in cellular processing mechanisms for different ARB associated mutants lead to the same disease phenotype. The existence of distinct pathogenic disease mechanisms has important ramifications for potential gene replacement therapies since we show that missense mutations associated with an autosomal recessive disease have a pathogenic influence beyond simple loss of function.

Biallelic mutation of BEST1 causes a distinct retinopathy in humans

We describe a distinct retinal disorder, autosomal-recessive bestrophinopathy (ARB), that is consequent upon biallelic mutation in BEST1 and is associated with central visual loss, a characteristic retinopathy, an absent electro-oculogram light rise, and a reduced electroretinogram. Heterozygous mutations in BEST1 have previously been found to cause the two dominantly inherited disorders, Best macular dystrophy and autosomal-dominant vitreoretinochoroidopathy. The transmembrane protein bestrophin-1, encoded by BEST1, is located at the basolateral membrane of the retinal pigment epithelium in which it probably functions as a Cl(-) channel. We sequenced BEST1 in five families, identifying DNA variants in each of ten alleles. These encoded six different missense variants and one nonsense variant. The alleles segregated appropriately for a recessive disorder in each family. No clinical or electrophysiological abnormalities were identified in any heterozygotes. We conducted whole-cell patch-clamping of HEK293 cells transfected with bestrophin-1 to measure the Cl(-) current. Two ARB missense isoforms severely reduced channel activity. However, unlike two other alleles previously associated with Best disease, cotransfection with wild-type bestrophin-1 did not impair the formation of active wild-type bestrophin-1 channels, consistent with the recessive nature of the condition. We propose that ARB is the null phenotype of bestrophin-1 in humans.

Mapping of deletion and translocation breakpoints in 1q44 implicates the serine/threonine kinase AKT3 in postnatal microcephaly and agenesis of the corpus callosum

Deletions of chromosome 1q42-q44 have been reported in a variety of developmental abnormalities of the brain, including microcephaly (MIC) and agenesis of the corpus callosum (ACC). Here, we describe detailed mapping studies of patients with unbalanced structural rearrangements of distal 1q4. These define a 3.5-Mb critical region extending from RP11-80B9 to RP11-241M7 that we hypothesize contains one or more genes that lead to MIC and ACC when present in only one functional copy. Next, mapping of a balanced reciprocal t(1;13)(q44;q32) translocation in a patient with postnatal MIC and ACC demonstrated a breakpoint within this region that is situated 20 kb upstream of AKT3, a serine-threonine kinase. The murine orthologue Akt3 is required for the developmental regulation of normal brain size and callosal development. Whereas sequencing of AKT3 in a panel of 45 patients with ACC did not demonstrate any pathogenic variations, whole-mount in situ hybridization confirmed expression of Akt3 in the developing central nervous system during mouse embryogenesis. AKT3 represents an excellent candidate for developmental human MIC and ACC, and we suggest that haploinsufficiency causes both postnatal MIC and ACC.

Left-sided embryonic expression of the BCL-6 corepressor, BCOR, is required for vertebrate laterality determination

Oculofaciocardiodental (OFCD) syndrome is an X-linked male lethal condition encompassing cardiac septal defects, as well as ocular and dental anomalies. The gene mutated in OFCD syndrome, the BCL-6 corepressor (BCOR), is part of a transcriptional repression complex whose transcriptional targets remain largely unknown. We reviewed cases of OFCD syndrome and identified patients exhibiting defective lateralization including dextrocardia, asplenia and intestinal malrotation, suggesting that BCOR is required in normal laterality determination. To study the function of BCOR, we used morpholino oligonucleotides (MOs) to knockdown expression of xtBcor in Xenopus tropicalis, thus creating an animal model for OFCD syndrome. The resulting tadpoles had cardiac and ocular features characteristic of OFCD syndrome. Reversed cardiac orientation and disorganized gut patterning were seen when MOs were injected into the left side of embryos, demonstrating a left-sided requirement for xtBcor in lateral determination in Xenopus. Ocular defects displayed no left-right bias and included anterior and posterior segment disorders such as microphthalmia and coloboma. Expression of xtPitx2c was shown to be downregulated when xtBcor was depleted. This identifies a pathway in which xtBcor is required for lateral specification, a process intrinsically linked to correct cardiac septal development.

Intrafamilial phenotypic variability in families with RDS mutations: exclusion of ROM1 as a genetic modifier for those with retinitis pigmentosa

OBJECTIVES

To identify suspected RDS mutations in families in which different people have been identified with either generalised retinal dystrophy or macular dystrophy.

METHODS

Two families with a retinal dystrophy were extensively phenotyped and blood was taken for mutation analysis of the RDS (all) and ROM1 (retinitis pigmentosa patients only) genes.

RESULTS

A novel p.Trp94X mutation in RDS was found in all three affected members of a two-generation family that was associated with retinitis pigmentosa in the son, pattern dystrophy in the daughter and fundus flavimaculatus in the mother. In the second family, the proband with retinitis pigmentosa carried a p.Arg220Trp mutation. The mother, who was unavailable for mutation screening, had adult vitelliform macular dystrophy. No ROM1 mutations were found in those with retinitis pigmentosa in either family.

CONCLUSION

Mutations in RDS can be associated with an intrafamilial variation in retinal disease. The phenotypes range from Stargardt-like macular dystrophy to classic retinitis pigmentosa.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Intrafamilial phenotypic variation may be due to the presence of environmental or genetic modifying factors. The presence of a modifying-sequence change in the coding region of ROM1 for two people with retinitis pigmentosa from two families with intrafamilial variation in RDS mutation phenotype has been excluded in this study.

Evidence of genetic heterogeneity in MRCS (microcornea, rod-cone dystrophy, cataract, and posterior staphyloma) syndrome

PURPOSE

To present the detailed phenotype of a subject with MRCS (microcornea, retinal dystrophy, cataract, and posterior staphyloma) syndrome and to investigate the underlying molecular genetic basis.

DESIGN

Interventional case report.

METHODS

Clinical examination, electrophysiologic assessment, B-scan ultrasonography, and mutation screening of the gene VMD2. The protocol of the study was approved by the local ethics committee and informed consent was obtained.

RESULTS

A 12-year-old boy was identified with bilateral microcornea, rod-cone dystrophy, congenital cataracts, and posterior staphylomata associated with high myopia (MRCS). Mutation screening failed to identify disease-causing sequence variants in VMD2, the gene associated with MRCS syndrome. All previous subjects have had pathogenic VMD2 sequence alterations.

CONCLUSIONS

We present a further report of the MRCS syndrome and provide evidence in support of genetic heterogeneity in this phenotype.

Developmental and Tissue Expression ofXenopus laevis RPGR

PURPOSE

The present study examined the developmental and tissue expression of the retinitis pigmentosa GTPase regulator (RPGR) gene in Xenopus laevis.

METHODS

The cDNA for X. laevis RPGR (XRPGR) was isolated from adult eye mRNA by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) and rapid amplification of cDNA ends. The deduced peptide sequence was aligned with RPGR orthologues. Gene expression was examined by whole-mount in situ hybridization and RT-PCR. The localization of XRPGR in X. laevis photoreceptor cells and XTC-2 cells was determined by immunostaining.

RESULTS

The XRPGR(ex1-19) isoform encodes a protein of 727 amino acids containing an RCC1 domain and a C-terminal isoprenylation anchorage motif. It shares 33% to 41% amino acid identity with human, mouse, and dog RPGR. The C-terminal exon of the alternatively spliced RPGR(ORF15) isoform is also conserved across species. XRPGR is expressed at the earliest stages of X. laevis development and persists into adulthood, where expression is highest in the eye. XRPGR is expressed in presumptive eye fields (stages 18 to 22), becoming largely restricted to the central retina (stages 28 to 40). XRPGR protein colocalizes with beta-tubulin at the X. laevis ciliary axoneme and with gamma-tubulin at centrosomes in XTC-2 cells.

CONCLUSIONS

XRPGR is widely expressed throughout development but shows highest expression after the appearance of the eye primordium and persists in the eye into adulthood. The data are consistent with XRPGR expression in a single microtubular organelle-the centriole or basal body and associated ciliary transitional zone found in modified sensory cilia of photoreceptors and motile cilia.

RPGR ORF15 isoform co-localizes with RPGRIP1 at centrioles and basal bodies and interacts with nucleophosmin

The ORF15 isoform of RPGR (RPGR(ORF15)) and RPGR interacting protein 1 (RPGRIP1) are mutated in a variety of retinal dystrophies but their functions are poorly understood. Here, we show that in cultured mammalian cells both RPGR(ORF15) and RPGRIP1 localize to centrioles. These localizations are resistant to the microtubule destabilizing drug nocodazole and persist throughout the cell cycle. RPGR and RPGRIP1 also co-localize at basal bodies in cells with primary cilia. The C-terminal (C2) domain of RPGR(ORF15) (ORF15(C2)) is highly conserved across 13 mammalian species, suggesting that it is a functionally important domain. Using matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry, we show that this domain interacts with a 40 kDa shuttling protein nucleophosmin (NPM). The RPGR(ORF15)-NPM interaction was confirmed by (i) yeast two-hybrid analyses; (ii) binding of both recombinant and native HeLa cell NPM to RPGR(ORF15) fusion proteins in vitro; (iii) co-immunoprecipitation of native NPM, RPGR(ORF15) and RPGRIP1 from bovine retinal extracts and of native HeLa cell NPM and transfected RPGR(ORF15) from cultured cells and (iv) co-localization of NPM and RPGR(ORF15) at metaphase centrosomes in cultured cells. NPM is a multifunctional protein chaperone that shuttles between the nucleoli and the cytoplasm and has been associated with licensing of centrosomal division. RPGR and RPGRIP1 join a growing number of centrosomal proteins involved in human disease.

Inherited eye disease: cause and late effect

Molecular genetics has provided relatively few insights into late-onset eye disorders, but epidemiological data indicate that genetic factors are important in some late-onset eye disorders that cause major health burdens. Much clinical genetic research is based on the belief that developmental and late-onset disorders are not necessarily the result of defects in different genes, but are often caused by different mutations in the same collection of genes. Thus, mutations that either abolish or radically change gene function might cause early-onset disorders, whereas more-subtle changes in gene expression might underlie late-onset diseases. We present arguments and examples that indicate that this principle might be a fruitful guide to investigating the causes of late-onset eye disorders.

Mutations of VMD2 splicing regulators cause nanophthalmos and autosomal dominant vitreoretinochoroidopathy (ADVIRC)

PURPOSE

To investigate the genetic basis of autosomal dominant vitreoretinochoroidopathy (ADVIRC), a rare, inherited retinal dystrophy that may be associated with defects of ocular development, including nanophthalmos.

METHODS

A combination of linkage analysis and DNA sequencing in five families was used to identify disease-causing mutations in VMD2. The effect of these mutations on splicing was assessed using a minigene system.

RESULTS

Three pathogenic sequence alterations in VMD2 were identified in five families with nanophthalmos associated with ADVIRC. All sequences showed simultaneous missense substitutions and exon skipping.

CONCLUSIONS

VMD2 encodes bestrophin, a transmembrane protein located at the basolateral membrane of the RPE, that is also mutated in Best macular dystrophy. We support that each heterozygous affected individual produces three bestrophin isoforms consisting of the wild type and two abnormal forms: one containing a missense substitution and the other an in-frame deletion. The data showed that VMD2 mutations caused defects of ocular patterning, supporting the hypothesized role for the RPE, and specifically VMD2, in the normal growth and development of the eye.

Delineation of Cohen syndrome following a large-scale genotype-phenotype screen

Cohen syndrome is an autosomal recessive condition associated with developmental delay, facial dysmorphism, pigmentary retinopathy, and neutropenia. The pleiotropic phenotype, combined with insufficient clinical data, often leads to an erroneous diagnosis and has led to confusion in the literature. Here, we report the results of a comprehensive genotype-phenotype study on the largest cohort of patients with Cohen syndrome assembled to date. We found 22 different COH1 mutations, of which 19 are novel, in probands identified by our diagnostic criteria. In addition, we identified another three novel mutations in patients with incomplete clinical data. By contrast, no COH1 mutations were found in patients with a provisional diagnosis of Cohen syndrome who did not fulfill the diagnostic criteria ("Cohen-like" syndrome). This study provides a molecular confirmation of the clinical phenotype associated with Cohen syndrome and provides a basis for laboratory screening that will be valuable in its diagnosis.