Recurrent infections in partial complement factor I deficiency: evaluation of three generations of a Brazilian family

We report here on the evaluation of a factor I-deficient Brazilian family (three generations, 39 members) with strong consanguinity. The complete factor I-deficient patients (n = 3) presented recurrent respiratory infections, skin infections and meningitis; one of them died after sepsis. They presented an impaired total haemolytic activity (CH50), low C3, low factor H and undetectable C3dg/C3d. Partial factor I deficiency was detected in 16 family members (normal low cut-off value was 25 microg/ml). Respiratory infections were the most common clinical occurrence among partial factor I-deficient relatives. Two of them were submitted to nephrectomy following recurrent urinary tract infections. An additional two heterozygous relatives presented with arthritis and rheumatic fever. Apparently, patients with partial factor I deficiency are also at higher risk for recurrent infections. Vaccination against capsulated bacteria and the eventual use of prophylactic antibiotics should be considered individually in this patient group.

Complement factor I deficiency associated with recurrent infections, vasculitis and immune complex glomerulonephritis

Here we report complement factor I deficiency in an 11-y-old girl from a consanguineous Turkish family, who presented with recurrent pyogenic infections, vasculitic eruptions and immune complex glomerulonephritis. A moderately low C3 level together with the clinical picture suggested a deficiency affecting regulation of complement activation. Analysis of haemolytic activity revealed absence of alternative pathway activity and subsequent analysis showed no detectable factor I (<2%) together with a low level of factor B and a moderately low level of factor H, indicating consumption secondary to the factor I deficiency. Factor I inhibits complement activation beyond C3 by cleavage of C3b in the presence of cofactors. Complement factor I deficiency is frequently associated with recurrent pyogenic infections mainly affecting the upper and lower respiratory tract, or presenting as meningitis or septicaemia, while rheumatic disorders have not been a prominent feature. The patient's sister also suffered from recurrent pyogenic infections and had a low C3 level clearly suggesting the same deficiency.

Complement factor I deficiency associated with recurrent meningitis coinciding with menstruation

BACKGROUND

Complement (C) factor I deficiency is a rare immunodeficiency state frequently associated with recurrent pyogenic infections in early infancy. This deficiency causes a permanent uncontrolled activation of the alternative pathway resulting in massive consumption of C3.

PATIENT

A 23-year-old woman with monthly recurrent meningitis episodes, mostly in the perimenstrual period, since August 1999. Previously, at age 16 years, she had meningococcal sepsis, also coinciding with menstruation.

OBJECTIVES

To study the patient and her family to elucidate the molecular defects in the pedigree and to evaluate her clinical evolution.

RESULTS

We describe clinical, immunological, and treatment follow-up during this period. First, we characterized the existence of a total complement factor I deficiency defined by undetectable levels by enzyme immunosorbent assay. This total deficiency was also found in her sister. Her parents and brother had approximately half of the normal levels. In addition, the patient had very low levels of C3; factor B; and an important reduction of factor H, properdin, C5, C7, and C8 complement components. Additional studies in the patient's sera evidenced high levels of immune complexes containing C1q and immunoglobulin (Ig) G, as well as C3b/factor H, C3b/properdin, C3b/IgG, and properdin/IgG complexes. Treatment with prophylactic antibiotics, antiestrogen medication, plasma infusions, or intravenous immunoglobulin has been unsuccessful in avoiding consecutive meningitis episodes.

CONCLUSION

For the first time to our knowledge, these data present an unusual relationship between meningitis episodes and menstruation in factor I immunodeficiency.

Deficiency of human complement factor I associated with lowered factor H

Deficiencies of factor I and/or factor H result in an increased consumption of C3 and higher susceptibility to recurrent infections. Here we describe a case of human factor I deficiency and lowered factor H levels. C3 concentration was 50% lower than normal, the classical pathway-dependent hemolytic activity was reduced to almost 30% of normal, and alternative pathway-dependent activity was completely absent. The killing by peripheral leukocytes of Candida albicans treated with deficient serum and the production of complement-dependent chemotactic factors were reduced in the proband's serum when compared with normal serum. Finally, we observed that C3 antigen present in the proband's serum has a different electrophoretic mobility than native C3 (most likely C3b), confirming the deregulation of complement activation due to the lack of regulatory proteins factors I and H. The impaired complement system described in this case, the first of its kind described in a Chile, explains the higher susceptibility to infections found in the proband.

Glomerulonephritis in a patient with complement factor I deficiency

Complement factor I deficiency is known to be associated with recurrent pyogenic infections. The patient described here had recurrent attacks of otitis, sinusitis, and bronchopneumonia since childhood. At the age of 24 years, he had an acute episode of systemic vasculitis with purpura, but no nephritis. A factor I deficiency was diagnosed when he was 36 years old. Because of the uncontrolled activation of the alternative pathway of complement, several other components were depleted, in particular C3, which explained the predisposition for pyogenic infections. A progressive loss of renal function accompanied by proteinuria and hematuria started after the age of 40 years. Renal biopsy showed a focal segmental glomerulonephritis (GN) with glomerular deposits of immunoglobulins and complement C3 and C4 fragments. The glomerular podocytes showed an almost complete loss of complement receptor 1 (CR1; CD35). The expression of CR1 was very low on erythrocytes, as well. Thus, CR1, the most efficient cell-bound cofactor for the inactivation of C4b/C3b by factor I, appears to be consumed when factor I is missing. Although this is the first report of factor I deficiency associated with GN, it is unlikely that the development of the nephritis was fortuitous because GN has been found in many other diseases characterized by uncontrolled activation of the alternative pathway.

Complement factor I deficiency in a family with recurrent infections

Factor I deficiency causes a permanent, uncontrolled activation of the alternative pathway resulting in an increased turnover of C3 and consumption of factor B, factor H and properdin. Factor I deficiency is clinically associated with recurrent bacterial infections already in early infancy, mainly affecting the upper and lower respiratory tract, or presenting as meningitis or septicemia. We here report on a Brazilian family (n = 9) with known consanguinity, where in 3/7 children, suffering from chronic otitis, meningitis, and respiratory infections, a complete factor I deficiency was recognized. One of the patients died after fulminant sepsis. Hemolytic activity of the alternative pathway was not detectable in the patients' sera due to decreased plasma concentrations of C3, factor B and properdin. As a consequence of factor I deficiency, C3b could not be metabolized with the result that no C3-derived split products (C3dg/C3d) were detectable in the patients' sera. In vitro reconstitution with purified factor I restored the regulatory function in the patients' sera with the subsequent cleavage of C3b to C3c and C3dg. Factor H levels were decreased in all patients' sera and found to be tightly complexed with C3b resulting in a modified electrophoretic mobility. Upon factor I reconstitution, factor H was released from C3b regaining its beta 1 electrophoretic mobility. Complement-mediated biological functions like opsonization of bacteria, chemotactic activity and phagocytosis in these patients were impaired. The parents (cousins, 2nd degree) and 3/4 siblings had significantly reduced factor I plasma levels without further alteration in their complement profile. 3 of these obviously heterozygously deficient family members suffered from recurrent bacterial infections of different frequency and severity.

Complement-activating ability of leucocytes from patients with complement factor I deficiency

Previous studies from this laboratory have shown that normal peripheral blood B cells are capable of activating complement via the alternative pathway (AP), that the activation is associated with complement receptor type 2 (CR2) expression, and that erythrocytes at normal blood levels partially inhibit the activation. The purpose of the present study was to investigate whether factor I (FI) deficiency, which leads to continued formation of the AP convertase (C3bBb) resulting in the consumption of factor B and C3 and large scale generation of C3b fragments, affects the phenotype and/or function of the patients' B cells. Using flow cytometry, peripheral blood leucocytes (PBL) from two FI-deficient patients were investigated for expression of complement receptors and complement regulatory proteins, in vivo-deposited C3 fragments and in vitro complement-activating ability. CR1 levels on B cells were significantly lower in FI-deficient patients than in normal individuals, whereas CR2 levels were found to be reduced, although not to a significant extent. CR1 levels on monocytes and polymorphonuclear leucocytes (PMN) were found to be normal or slightly raised. All leucocyte subpopulations were found to be covered in vivo with C3b fragments. AP activation on B cells from FI-deficient patients in homologous serum was significantly reduced compared with that for normal individuals, whereas no in vitro activation was seen in autologous serum. In addition, the in vivo-bound C3b fragments were degraded to C3d,g when the patients' PBL were incubated in homologous serum containing EDTA. Finally, the patients, erythrocytes failed to exert any inhibition on AP activation in homologous serum.

The molecular basis of hereditary complement factor I deficiency

The molecular basis of hereditary complement factor I deficiency is described in two pedigrees. In one pedigree, there were two factor I-deficient siblings, one of whom was asymptomatic and the other suffered from recurrent pyogenic infections. Their factor I mRNA was analyzed by reverse transcription of fibroblast RNA followed by amplification using the polymerase chain reaction. Both siblings were homozygous for the same transversion (adenine to thymine) at nucleotide 1282 in the cDNA. This mutation causes histidine-400 to be replaced by leucine. The altered histidine is a semi-conserved residue within the serine proteinase family, although no function has been ascribed to it. The proband of the second pedigree studied was found to be a compound heterozygote. One allele had the same mutation as the first family, the second allele had a donor splice site mutation that resulted in the deletion of the mRNA encoded in the fifth exon (a low-density lipoprotein receptor domain) from its transcript.

Hereditary complement factor I deficiency

We describe four cases (from three families) of hereditary factor I deficiency, bringing the total number of cases now reported to 23. In one family there are two affected siblings: one has suffered recurrent pyogenic infections; the other is asymptomatic. In the second family, the patient had recurrent pyogenic infections and a self-limiting vasculitic illness; in the third family, the patient suffered recurrent pyogenic and neisserial infections. All four patients had markedly reduced concentrations of C3 in the serum (family 1 propositus: 28%; family 1 asymptomatic sibling: 15%; family 2: 31%; and family 3: 31% normal human serum) which was in the form of C3b. Low IgG2 levels may occur in primary C3 deficiency, and a reduction in IgG2 concentration to 1.14 g/l (normal: 1.30-5.90 g/l) was found in the patient from family 2. Using radioligand binding assays, we demonstrated increased binding of C3b to erythrocytes in a patient with factor I deficiency. This C3b could not be cleaved by autologous serum but could be cleaved by normal serum or purified factor I. We review and compare the published cases of C3, factor H and factor I deficiency.

Differential susceptibility of immune complexes to release from the erythrocyte CR1 receptor by factor I

This study was designed to explore the role of Factor I in the release of immune complexes (IC) from human erythrocytes (E). The interactions between E and IC constructed with murine monoclonal antibodies were examined using, as a complement source, autologous plasma, plasma depleted of Factor I by > 90%, or Factor I-depleted plasma reconstituted with purified Factor I. Striking differences were observed in the interactions between E and different types of IC in Factor I-depleted plasma. The release of IC constructed with IgG1, IgG3, IgM or IgA antibodies was abolished by Factor I depletion whereas IC containing IgG2a or IgG2b antibodies were still released from E in Factor I-depleted plasma. Moreover, when IC containing IgG2a antibodies were incubated briefly in Factor I-depleted plasma, under conditions in which the IC were bound but not released, and then resuspended in the presence or absence of Factor I, as little as 5% of the normal physiologic level of Factor I released the IC from E. Thus, IC containing IgG2a antibodies appear to be exquisitely susceptible to release from E by Factor I. Additional differences in the susceptibility of IC containing IgG1, IgG3, IgM or IgA antibodies to release from E were revealed when Factor I-depleted plasma was reconstituted with Factor I. Under these conditions, the relative susceptibility of IC to release was: IC containing IgG1 or IgA antibodies > IC containing IgM antibodies > IC constructed with IgG3 antibodies. While isotype was critical in determining susceptibility to release, some clonotypic differences between isotype-matched pairs of IC were also evident. Differences in IC release from E by Factor I may reflect antibody matrix-mediated differential susceptibility of IC-bound C3b and/or C4b to cleavage by Factor I and may have implications for immunoregulation, host effector cell mechanisms and the pathophysiology of IC diseases.

Complement factor I deficiency with recurrent aseptic meningitis

Patients with deficiency of the complement regulatory protein factor I typically present with systemic pyogenic bacterial infections, including meningitis. We report a novel case with total deficiency of factor I in serum and plasma; the patient experienced nine consecutive episodes of aseptic meningitis within a 2-year period. There was no history of previous bacterial sepsis. Aseptic meningitis recurred despite attempted penicillin prophylaxis. Each episode resolved rapidly without sequelae, with or without antibiotic treatment. Serum complement profiles showed persistently low levels of C3, factor B, and factor H and undetectable factor I protein. Family complement studies could not be performed. Except for a minimally increased titer of antinuclear antibody, no other immunologic abnormality was detected. Results of an oral ibuprofen challenge were negative. We conclude that deficiency of factor I may predispose to aseptic, as well as pyogenic bacterial, meningitis.