“Altered-self” or “near-self” in the positive selection of lymphocyte repertoires?

Positive selection of lymphocyte repertoires is now recognized as applying to both B and T cells. However, much of the early literature on positive selection focussed on cell-mediated immunity (T cells), which biased consideration of its general biological role. The term "altered-self," which initially captured the idea of self (i.e. MHC) altered by the addition of what was later found to be a peptide fragment, has not proven robust and may now be clouding our understanding. It is recommended that the term "near-self" be reintroduced since it captures the essence of the probable underlying adaptive process-sub-threshold self-reactivity to countermand rapid pathogen mutation.

Somatic mutations in mitochondria: the chicken or the egg?

Somatic mutations of mitochondrial DNA have been detected in various pathologies such as cancer, neurodegenerative diseases, cardiac disorders and aging in general. Now it has been found that patients with rheumatoid arthritis also have a higher incidence of mitochondrial mutations in synoviocytes and synovial tissue compared with patients with osteoarthritis. Furthermore, it has been shown that these mutations possibly result in changed peptides that are presented by major histocompatibility complex II and thus might be recognized as non-self by the immune system. Further studies will show whether these mutations are actually able to trigger autoimmune inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis or whether they must be considered epiphenomena of cellular damage in chronic inflammation.

Surveillance against tumors—is it mainly immunological?

The concept of tumor surveillance was first formulated by immunologists Mcfarlane Burnet and Lewis Thomas, respectively. They assumed that the immune system would recognize precancerous and cancer cells as non-self and reject them. This concept is only valid for virally transformed cells, however. In humans, EBV, HHV-8, and the papilloma viruses are relevant viral agents in this context. Tumors arising without a contribution by these viruses are regarded by the immune system as "self", with possible rare exceptions like melanoma. Immunological attempts to influence them therefore implies the breaking of tolerance, a much more difficult proposition. Multicellular organisms have powerful surveillance mechanisms of a non-immunological nature against potential neoplastic cells that threaten to disrupt the organism. Four distinct categories can be recognized: (1) DNA repair. Deficiency of repair enzymes may lead to multiple tumors and/or to multicancer syndromes. (2) Epigenetic mechanisms are currently emerging as being capable of modulating the incidence of certain tumors. e.g., by determining the stringency of imprinting and by influencing chromatin structure. (3) Intracellular surveillance. DNA damage, illegitimate activation of oncogenes, and other pathological changes may activate one or several apoptotic pathways. (4) Intercellular surveillance. The tissue microenvironment influences the probability of disseminated tumor cell growth. Moreover, appropriate differentiation inducing signals may revert the tumor cell phenotype.

License to heal: bidirectional interaction of antigen-specific regulatory T cells and tolerogenic APC

Naturally occurring CD4(+)CD25(+) regulatory T (T(R)) cells, a component of the innate immune response, which play a key role in the maintenance of self-tolerance, have become the focus of numerous studies over the last decade. These cells inhibit the immune response in an Ag-nonspecific manner, interacting with other T cells. Much less is known about adaptive T(R) cells, which develop in response to chronic antigenic stimulation, and act directly on professional and nonprofessional APC, rendering them tolerogenic and able to elicit the differentiation of CD8(+) and CD4(+) T cells with suppressive activity. In this review, we will discuss data pertaining to the bidirectional interaction between Ag-specific T(R) with APC and their clinical relevance.

Interleukin-4 produces a breakdown of tolerance in vivo with autoantibody formation and tissue damage

B cell susceptibility to Fas-mediated apoptosis is downmodulated by engagement of IL-4 and sIg receptors. IL-4 produces Fas-resistance in both normal and tolerant B lymphocytes and has been associated with autoantibody production in mice expressing heterogeneous B cell receptors. To study the in vivo effects of IL-4 on autoreactive B cells in a more well-defined system, mice triply transgenic for IL-4, soluble HEL and anti-HEL B cell receptors were generated. Anti-HEL/sHEL/IL-4 triple transgenic mice matured normally but accumulated increasing amounts of serum anti-HEL antibodies over time, whereas anti-HEL/sHEL double transgenic mice lacked serum anti-HEL. Autoantibodies in triple transgenic mice were accompanied by gross evidence of renal pathology, characterized by both abnormal histology and marked proteinuria, along with microscopic evidence of immune complex-type hepatic damage. Proteinuria and histopathological changes were also observed in IL-4 transgenic control mice. These results suggest that IL-4 induced a breakdown in tolerance and autoreactive B cell activity manifested by the onset and accumulation of autoantibodies and the development of frank autoimmune disease.

Natural killer cell education in mice with single or multiple major histocompatibility complex class I molecules

The ability of murine NK cells to reject cells lacking self MHC class I expression results from an in vivo education process. To study the impact of individual MHC class I alleles on this process, we generated mice expressing single MHC class I alleles (K^b, D^b, D^d, or L^d) or combinations of two or more alleles. All single MHC class I mice rejected MHC class I–deficient cells in an NK cell–dependent way. Expression of K^b or D^d conveyed strong rejection of MHC class I–deficient cells, whereas the expression of D^b or L^d resulted in weaker responses. The educating impact of weak ligands (D^b and L^d) was further attenuated by the introduction of additional MHC class I alleles, whereas strong ligands (K^b and D^d) maintained their educating impact under such conditions. An analysis of activating and inhibitory receptors in single MHC class I mice suggested that the educating impact of a given MHC class I molecule was controlled both by the number of NK cells affected and by the strength of each MHC class I–Ly49 receptor interaction, indicating that NK cell education may be regulated by a combination of qualitative and quantitative events.

Cytotoxic T-cells specific for natural IgE peptides downregulate IgE production

Immunoglobulin E (IgE) plays a central role in IgE-mediated immediate type hypersensitivity. Since production of IgE depends on Th2, efforts to block IgE production and control allergic reactions include tolerization of Th2 or deviating development of Th2. We hypothesized that cytotoxic T lymphocytes targeting natural IgE peptides/MHC I complexes can eliminate IgE-producing cells and inhibit centrally IgE production. CTL to self-IgE peptides were elicited in mice immunized with nonameric p109-117, p113-121, and p103-141 (CHepsilon2 domain), which encompass both peptides with an OVA helper peptide (OVAp restricted for H-2d/b) in liposomes and presented by dendritic cells (DC). CTL from BALB/c lysed IgE peptide-pulsed P815 target as well as IgE-producing 26.82 hybridomas (H-2d). Natural tolerance to self-IgE peptides was tested in IgE sufficient (IgE +/+) as well as IgE-deficient (IgE -/-) 129/SvEv mice (H-2b). Comparable magnitude of CTL responses was observed in both strains immunized with p109-117 or p103-141 concomitantly with CD4 T-cell costimulation. CTL from 129/SvEv lysed not only IgE peptide-pulsed EL-4 but also IgE-producing B4 hybridomas (H-2b). This observation strongly suggests a correspondence of epitope of immunogenic peptide to that of physiologically processed IgE peptides presented on IgE-producing cells. Moreover, CTL were generated in 129/SvEv, immunized with the recombinant antigenized antibody in liposomes encompassing p107-123, p109-117, and p113-121 expressed in CDR3 of VH62/human gamma1. Polyclonal IgE production was inhibited by coincubation with MHC I-restricted CTL in vitro. Furthermore, antigen-specific IgE responses were inhibited in mice, immunized with p109-117 and p103-141 while IgG responses were not suppressed. Since IgE peptide sequences of CHepsilon2 are ubiquitous to all murine IgE heavy chain, peptides made as such can serve as a universal IgE vaccine to prevent allergy for a myriad of allergens in rodents. This observation suggests that similar human IgE peptides should be identified and employed to downregulate human IgE production.

Intrinsic Tolerance in Autologous Collagen-Induced Arthritis Is Generated by CD152-Dependent CD4+ Suppressor Cells

Collagen-induced arthritis is a mouse model of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and is commonly induced after immunization with type II collagen (CII) of a non-mouse origin. T cell recognition of heterologous CII epitopes has been shown to be critical in development of arthritis, as mice with cartilage-restricted transgenic expression of the heterologous T cell epitope (MMC mice) are partially tolerized to CII. However, the mechanism responsible for tolerance and arthritis resistance in these mice is unclear. The present study investigated the regulatory mechanisms in naturally occurring self-tolerance in MMC mice. We found that expression of heterologous rat CII sequence in the cartilage of mice positively selects autoreactive CD4(+) T cells with suppressive capacity. Although CD4(+)CD25(+) cells did not play a prominent role in this suppression, CD152-expressing T cells played a crucial role in this tolerance. MMC CD4(+) T cells were able to suppress proliferation of wild-type cells in vitro where this suppression required cell-to-cell contact. The suppressive capability of MMC cells was also demonstrated in vivo, as transfer of such cells into wild-type arthritis susceptible mice delayed arthritis onset. This study also determined that both tolerance and disease resistance were CD152-dependent as demonstrated by Ab treatment experiments. These findings could have relevance for RA because the transgenic mice used express the same CII epitope in cartilage as humans and because autoreactive T cells, specific for this epitope, are present in transgenic mice as well as in patients with RA.

T cell homeostasis in tolerance and immunity

The size of the peripheral T cell pool is remarkably stable throughout life, reflecting precise regulation of cellular survival, proliferation, and apoptosis. Homeostatic proliferation refers to the process by which T cells spontaneously proliferate in a lymphopenic host. The critical signals driving this expansion are "space," contact with self-major histocompatibility complex (MHC)/peptide complexes, and cytokine stimulation. A number of studies have delineated an association between T cell lymphopenia, compensatory homeostatic expansion, and the development of diverse autoimmune syndromes. In the nonobese diabetic mouse model of type 1 diabetes, lymphopenia-induced homeostatic expansion fuels the generation of islet-specific T cells. Excess interleukin-21 facilitates T cell cycling but limited survival, resulting in recurrent stimulation of T cells specific for self-peptide/MHC complexes. Indeed, data from several experimental models of autoimmunity indicate that a full T cell compartment restrains homeostatic expansion of self-reactive cells that could otherwise dominate the repertoire. This review describes the mechanisms that govern T cell homeostatic expansion and outlines the evidence that lymphopenia presents a risk for development of autoimmune disease.

MRL/Mp CD4+,CD25- T cells show reduced sensitivity to suppression by CD4+,CD25+ regulatory T cells in vitro: a novel defect of T cell regulation in systemic lupus erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the hypothesis that loss of suppression mediated by peripheral CD4+,CD25+ regulatory T cells is a hallmark of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).

METHODS

Mice of the MRL/Mp strain were studied as a polygenic model of SLE. Following immunomagnetic selection, peripheral lymphoid CD25+ and CD25- CD4+ T cells were cultured independently or together in the presence of anti-CD3/CD28 monoclonal antibody-coated beads. Proliferation was assessed by measuring the incorporation of tritiated thymidine.

RESULTS

While MRL/Mp CD4+,CD25+ regulatory T cells showed only subtle abnormalities of regulatory function in vitro, syngeneic CD4+,CD25- T cells showed significantly reduced sensitivity to suppression, as determined by crossover experiments in which MRL/Mp CD4+,CD25- T cells were cultured with H-2-matched CBA/Ca CD4+,CD25+ regulatory T cells in the presence of a polyclonal stimulus.

CONCLUSION

Our findings highlight a novel defect of peripheral tolerance in SLE. Identification of this defect could open new opportunities for therapeutic intervention.

Regulatory T cell lineage specification by the forkhead transcription factor foxp3

Regulatory T cell-mediated dominant tolerance has been demonstrated to play an important role in the prevention of autoimmunity. Here, we present data arguing that the forkhead transcription factor Foxp3 acts as the regulatory T cell lineage specification factor and mediator of the genetic mechanism of dominant tolerance. We show that expression of Foxp3 is highly restricted to the subset alphabeta of T cells and, irrespective of CD25 expression, correlates with suppressor activity. Induction of Foxp3 expression in nonregulatory T cells does not occur during pathogen-driven immune responses, and Foxp3 deficiency does not impact the functional responses of nonregulatory T cells. Furthermore, T cell-specific ablation of Foxp3 is sufficient to induce the identical early onset lymphoproliferative syndrome observed in Foxp3-deficient mice. Analysis of Foxp3 expression during thymic development suggests that this mechanism is not hard-wired but is dependent on TCR/MHC ligand interactions.

Defective central tolerance induction in NOD mice: genomics and genetics

The genetic determinism of type-1 diabetes in NOD mice likely involves complementary defects in central T cell tolerance induction and peripheral immunoregulation. To study the contribution of the NOD genetic background to central tolerance, we followed the behavior of BDC2.5 clonotype thymocytes in fetal thymic organ cultures (FTOC). The NOD genetic background encodes a quantitative deficiency in the ability to delete these self-reactive thymocytes and to divert them to the CD8alphaalpha lineage. In genetic analyses, comparing NOD and B6.H2g7 FTOCs, the NOD defect incorporated the influence of several loci (notably ones on chr1 and 3). Microarray analyses assessing FTOCs from the same two strains argued that the NOD abnormality reflects the combined effects of turning down the gene expression program that provokes apoptosis and turning on a new program promoting cell survival. Intersection of the data from the two approaches points to a small set of attractive candidate genes.

Thymic transcription of neurohypophysial and insulin-related genes: impact upon T-cell differentiation and self-tolerance

The thymus is the unique lymphoid organ responsible for the generation of a diverse repertoire of T lymphocytes that are competent against non self-antigens while being tolerant to self-antigens. A vast repertoire of neuroendocrine-related genes is transcribed in the nonlymphoid cellular compartment of the thymus (thymic epithelial cells, dendritic cells and macrophages). The precursors encoded by these genes engage two types of interactions with developing T cells (thymocytes). First, they are not processed in a classical neuroendocrine way but as the source of self-antigens that are presented to pre-T cells by the major histocompatibility complex proteins of the thymus. This presentation could be responsible for the establishment of central T-cell self-tolerance to neuroendocrine functions. Second, they also deliver signal ligands that are able to bind to neuroendocrine-type receptors expressed by thymocytes. This interaction activates several types of intracellular signalling pathways implicated in the developmental process of T lymphocytes. Several experimental arguments support a role for thymic dysfunction as a crucial factor in the development of organ-specific autoimmune endocrinopathies, such as 'idiopathic' central diabetes insipidus and type 1 diabetes mellitus. The rational use of tolerogenic neuroendocrine self-antigens for the prevention/treatment of autoimmune endocrinopathies is currently under investigation.

Utilizing regulatory T cells to control alloreactivity

Effective resetting of the immune system cannot be achieved by non-specific immunosuppression. Instead, novel strategies aim at harnessing the body's natural tolerance mechanisms to rectify an Ag-specific response without disturbing other immune functions. Fine-tuning of the balance between Ag-specific effector and regulatory T (Tr) cells is a promising strategy that requires detailed understanding of the differentiation and expansion pathways of the relevant Tr cell subsets. Here we review recent developments regarding the control of alloreactivity by induction and expansion of Tr cells. T-cell activation in the presence of tolerogenic APC and cytokines leads to the induction of Tr cells, which can mediate tolerance through cytokine-dependent and/or contact-dependent mechanisms. Better understanding of the mechanisms of immune regulation mediated by Tr cells may enable fine-tuning of specific immune responses and pave the way for novel therapeutic approaches.

A new self: MHC-class-I-independent Natural-killer-cell self-tolerance

A fundamental tenet of the immune system is the requirement for lymphocytes to respond to transformed or infected cells while remaining tolerant of normal cells. Natural killer (NK) cells discriminate between self and non-self by monitoring the expression of MHC class I molecules. According to the 'missing-self' hypothesis, cells that express self-MHC class I molecules are protected from NK cells, but those that lack this self-marker are eliminated by NK cells. Recent work has revealed that there is another system of NK-cell inhibition, which is independent of MHC class I molecules. Newly discovered NK-cell inhibitory receptors that have non-MHC-molecule ligands broaden the definition of self as seen by NK cells.

Thymic cortical epithelium induces self tolerance

Because of its role in positive selection, the ability of cortical epithelium to induce tolerance is controversial. On the one hand, experiments with transplanted thymuses showed that the recipients were functionally tolerant of all the antigens expressed by the cells of those thymuses, including cells of the cortical epithelium. On the other, the keratin 14 (K14) transgenic mouse strain, which expresses MHC class II on cortical epithelium under the control of the K14 promoter, does not seem to be tolerant of the transgenic MHC molecule. Here we tested whether the lack of tolerance in the K14 mouse might be more apparent than real. We found that K14 mice are indeed completely tolerant of K14 cortical thymic epithelium, whereas they remain reactive to tissues that express the same MHC allele under normal genetic control. These results establish the ability of cortical epithelium to induce central tolerance, and impinge on several of the models concerning positive selection of newly developing T cells.

Natural regulatory T cells and self-tolerance

The adaptive immune system allows individual organisms to mount defensive reactions against unanticipated pathogens by developmentally creating a diverse repertoire of clonally distributed receptors capable of recognizing a multitude of antigens and then expanding as effector cell populations those that can recognize molecules from the pathogens. To function properly, the system must deal with the problem of randomly generated receptors that can recognize self components. Most solutions to this self-tolerance problem are cell intrinsic and involve the deletion or inactivation of autoreactive cells. However, an extrinsic form of dominant tolerance has been demonstrated that takes the form of CD4(+) regulatory T cells. This perspective discusses why such a mechanism might have evolved and the problems it presents for self-non-self discrimination.

CD8+ T cell immunity against a tumor/self-antigen is augmented by CD4+ T helper cells and hindered by naturally occurring T regulatory cells

CD4(+) T cells control the effector function, memory, and maintenance of CD8(+) T cells. Paradoxically, we found that absence of CD4(+) T cells enhanced adoptive immunotherapy of cancer when using CD8(+) T cells directed against a persisting tumor/self-Ag. However, adoptive transfer of CD4(+)CD25(-) Th cells (Th cells) with tumor/self-reactive CD8(+) T cells and vaccination into CD4(+) T cell-deficient hosts induced autoimmunity and regression of established melanoma. Transfer of CD4(+) T cells that contained a mixture of Th and CD4(+)CD25(+) T regulatory cells (T(reg) cells) or T(reg) cells alone prevented effective adoptive immunotherapy. Maintenance of CD8(+) T cell numbers and function was dependent on Th cells that were capable of IL-2 production because therapy failed when Th cells were derived from IL-2(-/-) mice. These findings reveal that Th cells can help break tolerance to a persisting self-Ag and treat established tumors through an IL-2-dependent mechanism, but requires simultaneous absence of naturally occurring T(reg) cells to be effective.

A well adapted regulatory contrivance: regulatory T cell development and the forkhead family transcription factor Foxp3

The random generation of antigen receptors in developing lymphocytes results in a considerable risk of autoimmunity. Regulatory T cells (T(reg) cells) act in a dominant, trans-acting way to actively suppress immune activation and maintain immune tolerance. Here, we discuss the principal advances in our understanding of the molecular mechanisms of T(reg) cell development and function with particular emphasis on the forkhead transcription factor Foxp3. Accumulating evidence suggests that T(reg) cells represent a dedicated T cell lineage and that Foxp3 functions as the T(reg) cell lineage specification factor. The aggressive early-onset lymphoproliferative syndrome resulting from Foxp3 deficiency identifies T(reg) cells as vital mediators of immunological tolerance to self and Foxp3 as the mediator of the genetic mechanism of dominant tolerance.

[Receptor selection and B cell immune tolerance]

The immune system of mammalian has developed sophisticated mechanism to deal with diverse unknown antigens by random rearrangement of V, D and J antigen gene fragments. The immune self-tolerance is the mechanism to avoid self-destruction by the gene rearrangement generated autoreactive lymphocytes. Until recently it was believed that autoreactive lymphocytes are either deleted or rendered unable to respond by the supposed cell or clone selection mechanism. However, recent findings from a number of laboratories suggest instead of cell selection but receptor selection plays an essential role in immune self-tolerance. Receptor selection is carried out by secondary or nested rearrangement of antigen receptor gene fragments, and can occur at different stages of lymphocyte differentiation. Furthermore, secondary rearrangement of receptor gene also plays an important role in shaping immune response after the interaction of receptor with antigen by altering its specificity.

Single nucleotide polymorphisms as a prerequisite for autoantigens

It is still elusive why certain self proteins induce an autoimmune response. One immunological hypothesis is that only modified or altered self-proteins may become a target. Thus, we asked whether such alterations may actually be genetic polymorphisms that can be revealed by analyzing sequence variability in the known human autoantigens. Indeed, we found autoantigens to contain significantly more single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) than other human genes do. Our finding may offer an explanation for autoimmune responses through allogeneic exposure. Besides other contributing factors in autoimmunity, SNP may represent an essential prerequisite for the primary induction of an autoimmune response.

An affinity/avidity model of peripheral T cell regulation

We show in these studies that Qa-1-dependent CD8+ T cells are involved in the establishment and maintenance of peripheral self tolerance as well as facilitating affinity maturation of CD4+ T cells responding to foreign antigen. We provide experimental evidence that the strategy used by the Qa-1-dependent CD8+ T cells to accomplish both these tasks in vivo is to selectively downregulate T cell clones that respond to both self and foreign antigens with intermediate, not high or low, affinity/avidity. Thus, the immune system evolved to regulate peripheral immunity using a unified mechanism that efficiently and effectively permits the system to safeguard peripheral self tolerance yet promote the capacity to deal with foreign invaders.

Naturally arising Foxp3-expressing CD25+CD4+ regulatory T cells in immunological tolerance to self and non-self

Naturally arising CD25(+)CD4(+) regulatory T cells actively maintain immunological self-tolerance. Deficiency in or dysfunction of these cells can be a cause of autoimmune disease. A reduction in their number or function can also elicit tumor immunity, whereas their antigen-specific population expansion can establish transplantation tolerance. They are therefore a good target for designing ways to induce or abrogate immunological tolerance to self and non-self antigens.

Cutting edge: TLR ligands are not sufficient to break cross-tolerance to self-antigens

Cross-presentation of peripheral self-Ags by dendritic cells (DC) can induce deletion of autoreactive CTL by a mechanism termed cross-tolerance. Activation of DC by microbial TLR ligands is thought to result in adaptive immunity. However, activation of tolerogenic DC may cause autoimmunity by stimulating instead of deleting autoreactive CTL. To investigate this scenario, we have monitored the response of autoreactive CTL in specific for the transgenic self Ag, OVA, expressed in pancreatic islets of RIP-mOVA mice injected with ligands of TLR2, 3, 4, and 9. This somewhat enhanced proliferation and cytokine production, and moderately reduced the CTL number able to induce autoimmunity. Nevertheless, physiological CTL numbers were deleted before disease ensued, unless specific CD4 T cell help was provided. In conclusion, DC activation by TLR ligands was insufficient to break peripheral cross-tolerance in the absence of specific CD4 T cell help, and triggered autoimmunity by stimulating the early effector phase of autoreactive CTL only when their precursor frequency was extremely high.

Peripheral Tolerance of CD8 T Lymphocytes

Whereas high-avidity recognition of peptide-MHC complexes by developing T cells in the thymus results in deletion and promotes self-tolerance, such recognition by mature T cells in the periphery results in activation and clonal expansion. This dichotomy represents the basis of a dilemma that has stumped immunologists for many years, how are self-specific T cells tolerized in the periphery? There appear to be two important criteria used to achieve this goal. The first is that in the absence of inflammatory pathogens, tolerance is promoted when T cells recognize antigen presented by quiescent dendritic cells (DCs) expressing low levels of costimulatory molecules. A second critical factor that defines "self" and drives tolerance through deletion, anergy, or suppression is the persistence of antigen.