In vitro selection and characterization of hepatitis C virus serine protease variants resistant to an active-site peptide inhibitor

Hepatitis C virus NS5A is a direct substrate of casein kinase I-alpha, a cellular kinase identified by inhibitor affinity chromatography using specific NS5A hyperphosphorylation inhibitors

The hepatitis C virus encodes a single polyprotein that is processed by host and viral proteases to yield at least 10 mature viral proteins. The nonstructural (NS) protein 5A is a phosphoprotein, and experimental data indicate that the phosphorylation state of NS5A is important for the outcome of viral RNA replication. We were able to identify kinase inhibitors that specifically inhibit the formation of the hyperphosphorylated form of NS5A (p58) in cells. These kinase inhibitors were used for inhibitor affinity chromatography in order to identify the cellular targets of these compounds. The kinases casein kinase I (CKI), p38 MAPK, CIT (Citron Rho-interacting kinase), GAK, JNK2, PKA, RSK1/2, and RIPK2 were identified in the high affinity binding fractions of two NS5A hyperphosphorylation inhibitors (NS5A-p58-i). Even though these kinases are targets of the NS5A-p58-i, the only kinase showing an effect on NS5A hyperphosphorylation was confirmed to be CKI-alpha. Although this finding does not exclude the possibility that other kinase(s) might be involved in basal or regulatory phosphorylation of NS5A, we show here that NS5A is a direct substrate of CKI-alpha. Moreover, in vitro phosphorylation of NS5A by CKI-alpha resulted for the first time in the production of basal and hyperphosphorylated forms resembling those produced in cells. In vitro kinase reactions performed with NS5A peptides show that Ser-2204 is a preferred substrate residue for CKI-alpha after pre-phosphorylation of Ser-2201.

siRNA-resistance in treated HCV replicon cells is correlated with the development of specific HCV mutations

RNA interference (RNAi) has been extremely effective against hepatitis C viral (HCV) gene expression in short-term cell culture. Our aim was to determine whether long-term RNAi might result in HCV-resistant mutants. Huh7 HCV subgenomic replicon cells were transfected with short interfering RNAs (siRNAs). HCV-RNA was quantified by real-time RT-PCR, and HCV NS5A levels were assayed by Western blots using specific antibody. Treatment with HCV-siRNA resulted in a 50% inhibition of HCV-RNA levels compared with pretreatment levels after 4 weeks (P < 0.05). HCV-RNA returned to 85% of pretreatment levels after cessation of HCV-siRNA treatment. Sequencing of the HCV-siRNA target and upstream region was performed on 10 colonies from subcloning using PCR products, each before, during and after siRNA treatment. All colonies except one from HCV-siRNA-treated cells during and after treatment had mutations. There were no mutations in the HCV-siRNA target region following control HBV-siRNA treatment. Subcloned replicon cells containing the point mutations in the target region were found to be resistant to HCV-siRNA inhibitory effects. In conclusion, even after 4 weeks of treatment of replicon cells with HCV-siRNA, HCV-RNA and HCV-NS5A protein expression could not be completely eliminated. HCV replicons isolated during or after treatment were associated with mutations in the siRNA target region, while controls were not.

The alpha isoform of protein kinase CKI is responsible for hepatitis C virus NS5A hyperphosphorylation

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) has been the subject of intensive studies for nearly two decades. Nevertheless, some aspects of the virus life cycle are still a mystery. The HCV nonstructural protein 5A (NS5A) has been shown to be a modulator of cellular processes possibly required for the establishment of viral persistence. NS5A is heavily phosphorylated, and a switch between a basally phosphorylated form of NS5A (p56) and a hyperphosphorylated form of NS5A (p58) seems to play a pivotal role in regulating HCV replication. Using kinase inhibitors that specifically inhibit the formation of NS5A-p58 in cells, we identified the CKI kinase family as a target. NS5A-p58 increased upon overexpression of CKI-alpha, CKI-delta, and CKI-epsilon, whereas the RNA interference of only CKI-alpha reduced NS5A hyperphosphorylation. Rescue of inhibition of NS5A-p58 was achieved by CKI-alpha overexpression, and we demonstrated that the CKI-alpha isoform is targeted by NS5A hyperphosphorylation inhibitors in living cells. Finally, we showed that down-regulation of CKI-alpha attenuates HCV RNA replication.

Resistance of Hepatitis C Virus to Ns3–4A Protease Inhibitors: Mechanisms of Drug Resistance Induced by R155Q, A156T, D168A and D168V Mutations

Background/aims

One of the main issues in the development of antiviral therapy is the emergence of drug-resistant viruses. In the case of hepatitis C virus (HCV), selection of drug-resistant mutants was evidenced by in vitro studies on protease inhibitors (PIs); for example, BILN-2061, VX-950 and SCH-6. Four mutations in the HCV protease (R155Q, A156T, D168A and D168V) have been identified in vitro in the HCV replicon system that confer resistance to BILN-2061 (a reference inhibitor). However, the molecular mechanism of drug resistance is still unknown. The aim of this study is to unravel, using an molecular modelling strategy, the structural basis of such molecular mechanism of HCV resistance to PIs. We focused on protease mutations conferring HCV resistance to BILN-2061 and described for the first time such mechanism at a molecular level.

Methods

The structures of drug-resistant NS3 proteases were obtained by mutation of selected residues (R155Q, A156T, D168A and D168V) and the ternary complexes formed between NS3–4A and BILN-2061 were optimized using GenMol software ( www.3dgenoscience.com ; Genoscience, Marseille, France).

Results

Two mechanisms were evidenced for viral resistance to BILN-2061. A ‘direct’ resistance mechanism is based on contacts between the mutated R155Q and A156T protease residues and its inhibitor. In the ‘indirect’ resistance mechanism, the mutated D168A/V residue is not in close contact with the drug itself but interacts with other residues connected to the drug.

Conclusions

These data provide new insights in the understanding of the mechanisms of HCV drug escape, and may allow predicting potential cross-resistance phenomenon with other PIs. This approach can be used as a basis for future rational PI drug design candidates.

Molecular mechanism of a thumb domain hepatitis C virus nonnucleoside RNA-dependent RNA polymerase inhibitor

A new pyranoindole class of small-molecule inhibitors was studied to understand viral resistance and elucidate the mechanism of inhibition in hepatitis C virus (HCV) replication. HCV replicon variants less susceptible to inhibition by the pyranoindoles were selected in Huh-7 hepatoma cells. Variant replicons contained clusters of mutations in the NS5B polymerase gene corresponding to the drug-binding pocket on the surface of the thumb domain identified by X-ray crystallography. An additional cluster of mutations present in part of a unique beta-hairpin loop was also identified. The mutations were characterized by using recombinant replicon variants engineered with the corresponding amino acid substitutions. A single mutation (L419M or M423V), located at the pyranoindole-binding site, resulted in an 8- to 10-fold more resistant replicon, while a combination mutant (T19P, M71V, A338V, M423V, A442T) showed a 17-fold increase in drug resistance. The results of a competition experiment with purified NS5B enzyme with GTP showed that the inhibitory activity of the pyranoindole inhibitor was not affected by GTP at concentrations up to 250 microM. Following de novo initiation, the presence of a pyranoindole inhibitor resulted in the accumulation of a five-nucleotide oligomer, with a concomitant decrease in higher-molecular-weight products. The results of these studies have confirmed that pyranoindoles target the NS5B polymerase through interactions at the thumb domain. This inhibition is independent of GTP concentrations and is likely mediated by an allosteric blockade introduced by the inhibitor during the transition to RNA elongation after the formation of an initiation complex.

VX-950, a novel hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3-4A protease inhibitor, exhibits potent antiviral activities in HCv replicon cells

The NS3-4A serine protease of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is essential for viral replication and therefore has been one of the most attractive targets for developing specific antiviral agents against HCV. VX-950, a highly selective, reversible, and potent peptidomimetic inhibitor of the HCV NS3-4A protease, is currently in clinical development for the treatment of hepatitis C. In this report, we describe the in vitro characterization of anti-HCV activities of VX-950 in subgenomic HCV replicon cells. Incubation with VX-950 resulted in a time- and dose-dependent reduction of HCV RNA and proteins in replicon cells. Moreover, following a 2-week incubation with VX-950, a reduction in HCV RNA levels of 4.7 log(10) was observed, and this reduction resulted in elimination of HCV RNA from replicon cells, since there was no rebound in replicon RNA after withdrawal of the inhibitor. The combination of VX-950 and alpha interferon was additive to moderately synergistic in reducing HCV RNA in replicon cells with no significant increase in cytotoxicity. The benefit of the combination was sustained over time: a 4-log(10) reduction in HCV RNA level was achieved following a 9-day incubation with VX-950 and alpha interferon at lower concentrations than when either VX-950 or alpha interferon was used alone. The combination of VX-950 and alpha interferon also suppressed the emergence of in vitro resistance mutations against VX-950 in replicon cells.

Selection and characterization of replicon variants dually resistant to thumb- and palm-binding nonnucleoside polymerase inhibitors of the hepatitis C virus

Multiple nonnucleoside inhibitor binding sites have been identified within the hepatitis C virus (HCV) polymerase, including in the palm and thumb domains. After a single treatment with a thumb site inhibitor (thiophene-2-carboxylic acid NNI-1), resistant HCV replicon variants emerged that contained mutations at residues Leu419, Met423, and Ile482 in the polymerase thumb domain. Binding studies using wild-type (WT) and mutant enzymes and structure-based modeling showed that the mechanism of resistance is through the reduced binding of the inhibitor to the mutant enzymes. Combined treatment with a thumb- and a palm-binding polymerase inhibitor had a dramatic impact on the number of replicon colonies able to replicate in the presence of both inhibitors. A more exact characterization through molecular cloning showed that 97.7% of replicons contained amino acid substitutions that conferred resistance to either of the inhibitors. Of those, 65% contained simultaneously multiple amino acid substitutions that conferred resistance to both inhibitors. Double-mutant replicons Met414Leu and Met423Thr were predominantly selected, which showed reduced replication capacity compared to the WT replicon. These findings demonstrate the selection of replicon variants dually resistant to two NS5B polymerase inhibitors binding to different sites of the enzyme. Additionally, these findings provide initial insights into the in vitro mutational threshold of the HCV NS5B polymerase and the potential impact of viral fitness on the selection of multiple-resistant mutants.

The therapeutic potential of NS3 protease inhibitors in HCV infection

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is a serious cause of chronic liver disease worldwide and afflicts > 170 million people. The HCV-encoded NS3 protease is essential for viral replication and has long been recognised as a prime target for antiviral drugs. However, the peculiar active site structure of this enzyme, a shallow dent on the surface of the protein, has rendered the development of small-molecule inhibitors a highly challenging task. Nevertheless, perseverance and creativity has led to significant progress in this field over the last few years resulting in three compounds that are reported to enter the clinic. The impressive reduction of HCV RNA plasma levels observed with two of these inhibitors (ciluprevir and VX-950) in clinical trials has undoubtedly illustrated the potential of this viral enzyme-targeted drug discovery approach.

Preclinical profile of VX-950, a potent, selective, and orally bioavailable inhibitor of hepatitis C virus NS3-4A serine protease

VX-950 is a potent, selective, peptidomimetic inhibitor of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3-4A serine protease, and it demonstrated excellent antiviral activity both in genotype 1b HCV replicon cells (50% inhibitory concentration [IC50] = 354 nM) and in human fetal hepatocytes infected with genotype 1a HCV-positive patient sera (IC50 = 280 nM). VX-950 forms a covalent but reversible complex with the genotype 1a HCV NS3-4A protease in a slow-on, slow-off process with a steady-state inhibition constant (K(i)*) of 7 nM. Dissociation of the covalent enzyme-inhibitor complex of VX-950 and genotype 1a HCV protease has a half-life of almost an hour. A >4-log10 reduction in the HCV RNA levels was observed after a 2-week incubation of replicon cells with VX-950, with no rebound of viral RNA observed after withdrawal of the inhibitor. In several animal species, VX-950 exhibits a favorable pharmacokinetic profile with high exposure in the liver. In a recently developed HCV protease mouse model, VX-950 showed excellent inhibition of HCV NS3-4A protease activity in the liver. Therefore, the overall preclinical profile of VX-950 supports its candidacy as a novel oral therapy against hepatitis C.

Hepatitis C virus protease gene diversity in patients coinfected with human immunodeficiency virus

The clonal variability of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) protease gene in 24 individuals with HCV genotypes 1a, 1b, 2b, and 3a who were coinfected with the human immunodeficiency virus was evaluated. Within-genotype variability at the nucleotide and amino acid levels ranged from 6.5 to 8.6% and 2.2 to 3.8%, respectively. After adjustments were made for correlation of intrapatient clonal variation, mixed-model analysis indicated that nucleotide and amino acid variability among patients with different genotypes did not differ significantly. However, within individual patients, clonal variability differed by up to 5.3% and 5.8% at the nucleotide and amino acid levels, respectively, and genotype 1a had significantly greater nucleotide variability than other genotypes (P = 0.01). Significant variability exists within HCV protease gene variants at the patient level and could affect the effectiveness of HCV protease inhibitors.

Impact of Naturally Occurring Variants of HCV Protease on the Binding of Different Classes of Protease Inhibitors

HCV drug discovery efforts have largely focused on genotype 1 virus due to its prevalence and relatively poor response to current therapy. However, patients infected with genotype 2 and 3 viruses account for a significant number of cases and would also benefit from new therapies. In vitro studies using two chemically distinct protease inhibitors with clinical potential showed that one, VX-950, was equally active on proteases from all three genotypes, whereas the other, BILN 2061, was significantly less active on genotype 2 and 3 proteases. Naturally occurring variation near the inhibitor binding site was identified based on sequence alignment of the protease region from genotype 1-3 sequences. Substitution of amino acids in genotype 1 based on genotype 2 and 3 has revealed residues which impact binding of BILN 2061. Substitution of residues 78-80, together with 122 and 132, accounted for most of the reduced sensitivity of genotype 2. The most critical position affecting inhibitor binding to genotype 3 protease was 168. Substitution of residues at positions 168, 123, and 132 fully accounted for the reduced sensitivity of genotype 3. Comparative studies of BILN 2061 and a closely related nonmacrocycle inhibitor suggested that the rigidity of BILN 2061, while conferring greater potency against genotype 1, rendered it more sensitive to variations near the binding site. Free energy perturbation analysis confirmed the experimental observations. The identification of naturally occurring variations which can affect inhibitor binding is an important step in the design of broad-spectrum, second generation protease inhibitors.

Mutations conferring resistance to a hepatitis C virus (HCV) RNA-dependent RNA polymerase inhibitor alone or in combination with an HCV serine protease inhibitor in vitro

Compounds A-782759 (an N-1-aza-4-hydroxyquinolone benzothiadiazine) and BILN-2061 are specific anti-hepatitis C virus (HCV) agents that inhibit the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase and the NS3 serine protease, respectively. Both compounds display potent activity against HCV replicons in tissue culture. In order to characterize the development of resistance to these anti-HCV agents, HCV subgenomic 1b-N replicon cells were cultured with A-782759 alone or in combination with BILN-2061 at concentrations 10 times above their corresponding 50% inhibitory concentrations in the presence of neomycin. Single substitutions in the NS5B polymerase gene (H95Q, N411S, M414L, M414T, or Y448H) resulted in substantial decreases in susceptibility to A-782759. Similarly, replicons containing mutations in the NS5B polymerase gene (M414L or M414T), together with single mutations in the NS3 protease gene (A156V or D168V), conferred high levels of resistance to both A-782759 and BILN-2061. However, the A-782759-resistant mutants remained susceptible to nucleoside and two other classes of nonnucleoside NS5B polymerase inhibitors, as well as interferon. In addition, we found that the frequency of replicons resistant to both compounds was significantly lower than the frequency of resistance to the single compound. Furthermore, the dually resistant mutants displayed significantly reduced replication capacities compared to the wild-type replicon. These findings provide strategic guidance for the future treatment of HCV infection.

Resistance of hepatitis C virus to the host antiviral response

The majority of acute hepatitis C virus (HCV) infections progress to a chronic state. The interactions between the virus and host antiviral defense systems play a pivotal role in determining the outcome of acute infection, yet the virus encodes numerous strategies to thwart innate cellular antiviral responses, which represent the first line of defense against invading pathogens. Some of these strategies include the blockade of pathogen-associated molecular patterns, interferon regulatory factor and interferon (IFN) signaling pathways. These interactions are hypothesized to contribute to failure of IFN therapy during chronic infection. The genetic heterogeneity of HCV may also trigger host responses to varying degrees. The intracellular mechanisms that control acute infection and antiviral resistance during chronic infection may be similar. This review summarizes key intracellular virus–host interactions during acute and chronic infection and provides a perspective for the future of HCV research.

Mutations conferring resistance to SCH6, a novel hepatitis C virus NS3/4A protease inhibitor. Reduced RNA replication fitness and partial rescue by second-site mutations

Drug resistance is a major issue in the development and use of specific antiviral therapies. Here we report the isolation and characterization of hepatitis C virus RNA replicons resistant to a novel ketoamide inhibitor of the NS3/4A protease, SCH6 (originally SCH446211). Resistant replicon RNAs were generated by G418 selection in the presence of SCH6 in a dose-dependent fashion, with the emergence of resistance reduced at higher SCH6 concentrations. Sequencing demonstrated remarkable consistency in the mutations conferring SCH6 resistance in genotype 1b replicons derived from two different strains of hepatitis C virus, A156T/A156V and R109K. R109K, a novel mutation not reported previously to cause resistance to NS3/4A inhibitors, conferred moderate resistance only to SCH6. Structural analysis indicated that this reflects unique interactions of SCH6 with P'-side residues in the protease active site. In contrast, A156T conferred high level resistance to SCH6 and a related ketoamide, SCH503034, as well as BILN 2061 and VX-950. Unlike R109K, which had minimal impact on NS3/4A enzymatic function, A156T significantly reduced NS3/4A catalytic efficiency, polyprotein processing, and replicon fitness. However, three separate second-site mutations, P89L, Q86R, and G162R, were capable of partially reversing A156T-associated defects in polyprotein processing and/or replicon fitness, without significantly reducing resistance to the protease inhibitor.

A genotype 2b NS5B polymerase with novel substitutions supports replication of a chimeric HCV 1b:2b replicon containing a genotype 1b NS3-5A background

HCV diversity suggests that evaluation of HCV inhibitors for broad genotypic efficacy is warranted. The replicon system enables cell-culture compound efficacy evaluation against an active replication complex, and a functional replicon dependent upon a genotype 2b polymerase would augment existing cell-culture efficacy studies that are presently limited to genotype 1a, 1b, and 2a replicons. We made a chimeric Neo(r) 1b:2b replicon where genotype 2b NS5B was inserted into a genotype 1b NS3-5A background and transfected replicon RNA to generate Neo(r) cell lines. All cell lines contained novel substitutions within NS5B which were subsequently engineered into the parental 1b:2b replicon and shown to enhance replication to various degrees. A single NS5B M31I substitution enhanced replication to levels sufficiently robust to quantify sensitivity to HCV inhibitors in a transient replication assay. The M31I 1b:2b replicon was similarly sensitive to an active-site nucleoside inhibitor of NS5B as genotype 1b replicons, but was insensitive to two non-nucleoside inhibitors which were otherwise efficacious against the genotype 1b replicons. This work describes a novel HCV replicon sustained by a genotype 2b polymerase that is sufficiently robust for quantifiable analysis in a transient replication assay, and demonstrates its utility in characterizing anti-HCV compounds for cross-genotypic efficacy.

Binding site characterization and resistance to a class of non-nucleoside inhibitors of the hepatitis C virus NS5B polymerase

The virally encoded NS5B RNA-dependent RNA polymerase has emerged as a prime target in the search for specific HCV antivirals. A series of benzimidazole 5-carboxamide compounds inhibit the cellular RNA replication of a HCV subgenomic replicon and we have advanced our understanding of this class of inhibitors through a combination of complementary approaches that include biochemical cross-linking experiments with a photoreactive analogue followed by mass spectrometry analysis of the enzyme. A novel binding site has been localized for these inhibitors at the junction of the thumb domain and the N-terminal finger loop. Furthermore, the isolation and characterization of resistant replicon mutants that co-localize to this region distinguished this class of compounds from other non-nucleoside NS5B inhibitors that bind to distinct allosteric sites. Resistant mutations that emerged with the benzimidazole 5-carboxamide and related compounds were found at three amino acid positions in the thumb domain: Pro(495) with substitutions to Ser, Leu, Ala, or Thr; Pro(496) substitutions to Ser or Ala; and a V499A substitution. Mutations at each of these positions conferred different levels of resistance to this drug class: the Pro(495) changes provided the greatest shifts in compound potency, followed by moderate changes in potency with the Pro(496) substitutions, and finally only minor shifts in potency with V499A. Combinations that include the benzimidazole 5-carboxamide polymerase inhibitors and compounds that bind other sites or other HCV targets, including HCV protease inhibitors, are complementary in cell culture models of HCV RNA replication at suppressing the emergence of resistant variants. This novel class of compounds and unique binding site expand the diversity of HCV antivirals currently under development and offer the potential to improve the treatment of chronic HCV infection.

Challenges and successes in developing new therapies for hepatitis C

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) will continue to be a serious global health threat for many years to come because of the chronic nature of the infection, its high prevalence and the significant morbidity of the resulting disease. Recently, a small number of molecules have produced encouraging results in proof-of-concept clinical trials. At the same time, preclinical evidence is accumulating that development of resistance will eventually limit the efficacy of new drugs. Thus, combinations of multiple agents will be required to treat chronic HCV infection.

Isatoribine, an agonist of TLR7, reduces plasma virus concentration in chronic hepatitis C infection

Immune-based therapy is the mainstay treatment for chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection but causes multiple side effects and achieves durable viral clearance in only approximately 50% of patients. Most new investigational anti-HCV compounds are direct-acting antivirals for which durability of response and risk of viral mutations and resistance are not yet known. Therefore, continuing discovery and development of new immune-based treatments is desirable. Toll-like receptors (TLRs) are pathogen recognition receptors that initiate the innate immune response. The responsiveness of HCV or other ongoing chronic systemic infections to treatment with a selective TLR agonist has not been reported. Isatoribine is a selective agonist of TLR7. In a proof-of-concept study, we found that once-daily 7-day treatment with intravenous isatoribine 800 mg caused a significant (P = .001) reduction of plasma HCV RNA (mean, -0.76; range, -2.85 to +0.21 log(10) units) in otherwise untreated patients (n = 12) who were chronically infected with HCV. Viral load reduction occurred in patients infected with genotype 1 as well as non-genotype 1 HCV. The reduction of viral load was correlated with induction of markers of a heightened immune antiviral state, including 2'-, 5'- oligoadenylate synthetase levels in whole blood. This treatment was well tolerated, with a low frequency of mild to moderate adverse events. In conclusion, systemic administration of the selective TLR7 agonist isatoribine resulted in dose-dependent changes in immunologic biomarkers and a statistically significant antiviral effect with relatively few and mild side effects.

In vitro studies of cross-resistance mutations against two hepatitis C virus serine protease inhibitors, VX-950 and BILN 2061

VX-950 is a potent, small molecule, peptidomimetic inhibitor of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3.4A serine protease and has recently been shown to possess antiviral activity in a phase I trial in patients chronically infected with genotype 1 HCV. In a previous study, we described in vitro resistance mutations against either VX-950 or another HCV NS3.4A protease inhibitor, BILN 2061. Single amino acid substitutions that conferred drug resistance (distinct for either inhibitor) were identified in the HCV NS3 serine protease domain. The dominant VX-950-resistant mutant (A156S) remains sensitive to BILN 2061. The major BILN 2061-resistant mutants (D168V and D168A) are fully susceptible to VX-950. Modeling analysis suggested that there are different mechanisms of resistance for these mutations induced by VX-950 or BILN 2061. In this study, we identified mutants that are cross-resistant to both HCV protease inhibitors. The cross-resistance conferred by substitution of Ala(156) with either Val or Thr was confirmed by characterization of the purified enzymes and reconstituted replicon cells containing the single amino acid substitution A156V or A156T. Both cross-resistance mutations (A156V and A156T) displayed significantly diminished fitness (or replication capacity) in a transient replicon cell system.

Inhibitory effect of 2'-substituted nucleosides on hepatitis C virus replication correlates with metabolic properties in replicon cells

Nucleosides have been widely used in the treatment of viral diseases, but relatively few have been identified as inhibitors of hepatitis C virus (HCV). The modified ribonucleosides, 2'-C-methyl-adenosine and 2'-O-methyl-cytidine, are potent inhibitors of HCV replication which specifically target the NS5B polymerase. Herein, a more extensive characterization of the effect of these compounds upon HCV replication in subgenomic replicons is reported. A highly selective antireplicative effect induced by the nucleosides in replicon-containing cell lines was maintained during an exponential growth period with potencies which paralleled the reduction of both positive- and negative-strand RNA replication. Moreover, the inhibitory effect closely correlated with the intrinsic metabolic properties of differing replicon clonal lines. Interestingly, while 2'-C-methyl-adenosine elicited similar inhibitory potencies in different cell lines, 2'-O-methyl-cytidine was found to be inactive in one replicon cell line tested, although the corresponding triphosphates comparably inhibited the in vitro activity of replication complexes isolated from these cells and the activity of NS5B polymerase using synthetic templates. The lack of antireplicative effect, attributed to poor intracellular conversion of the 2'-O-methyl-cytidine nucleoside to the active 5'-triphosphate, was reversed using a monophosphate prodrug. Thus, although replicon cells are useful for evaluating the effect of inhibitors upon HCV replication, these findings have important implications for their use in the identification and characterization of nucleosides and other chemotherapeutic agents requiring cellular metabolism.

Recent developments in target identification against hepatitis C virus

Chronic hepatitis C is a leading cause of liver cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma worldwide. Recent progress in the understanding of the molecular virology of hepatitis C has allowed the identification of novel antiviral targets. Moreover, in vitro and in vivo model systems have been developed that allow the systematic evaluation of new therapeutic strategies. Exciting results from proof-of-concept clinical studies have now been reported for a specific hepatitis C virus serine protease inhibitor. These and other novel antiviral strategies may complement existing therapeutic modalities in the future.

Genetic heterogeneity of the NS3 protease gene in hepatitis C virus genotype 1 from untreated infected patients

NS3 protease is essential for hepatitis C Virus (HCV) replication, and is one of the most promising targets for specific anti-HCV therapy. Its natural polymorphism has not been studied at the quasispecies level. In the present work, the genetic heterogeneity of the NS3 protease gene was analyzed in 17 HCV genotype 1 (5 subtypes 1a and 12 subtypes 1b) samples collected from infected patients before anti-viral therapy. A total of 294 clones were sequenced. Although the protease NS3 is considered to be one of the less variable genes in the HCV genome, variability of both nucleotide and amino acid sequences was found. In variants belonging to 1a and 1b subtypes, 224 and 267 of 543 positions showed one or more nucleotide substitutions, respectively. Forty and 74 of the 181 NS3 amino acid positions showed at least one mutation in HCV-1a and HCV-1b isolates, respectively. Most substitutions were conservative. This substantial polymorphism of the NS3 protease produced by HCV-1a and HCV-1b suggests that, despite the numerous functional and structural constraints, the enzyme is sufficiently flexible to tolerate substitutions.

Genetic diversity and evolution of hepatitis C virus--15 years on

In the 15 years since the discovery of hepatitis C virus (HCV), much has been learned about its role as a major causative agent of human liver disease and its ability to persist in the face of host-cell defences and the immune system. This review describes what is known about the diversity of HCV, the current classification of HCV genotypes within the family Flaviviridae and how this genetic diversity contributes to its pathogenesis. On one hand, diversification of HCV has been constrained by its intimate adaptation to its host. Despite the >30 % nucleotide sequence divergence between genotypes, HCV variants nevertheless remain remarkably similar in their transmission dynamics, persistence and disease development. Nowhere is this more evident than in the evolutionary conservation of numerous evasion methods to counteract the cell's innate antiviral defence pathways; this series of highly complex virus-host interactions may represent key components in establishing its 'ecological niche' in the human liver. On the other hand, the mutability and large population size of HCV enables it to respond very rapidly to new selection pressures, manifested by immune-driven changes in T- and B-cell epitopes that are encountered on transmission between individuals with different antigen-recognition repertoires. If human immunodeficiency virus type 1 is a precedent, future therapies that target virus protease or polymerase enzymes may also select very rapidly for antiviral-resistant mutants. These contrasting aspects of conservatism and adaptability provide a fascinating paradigm in which to explore the complex selection pressures that underlie the evolution of HCV and other persistent viruses.

Reduction of hepatitis C virus NS5A hyperphosphorylation by selective inhibition of cellular kinases activates viral RNA replication in cell culture

Efficient replication of hepatitis C virus (HCV) subgenomic RNA in cell culture requires the introduction of adaptive mutations. In this report we describe a system which enables efficient replication of the Con1 subgenomic replicon in Huh7 cells without the introduction of adaptive mutations. The starting hypothesis was that high amounts of the NS5A hyperphosphorylated form, p58, inhibit replication and that reduction of p58 by inhibition of specific kinase(s) below a certain threshold enables HCV replication. Upon screening of a panel of kinase inhibitors, we selected three compounds which inhibited NS5A phosphorylation in vitro and the formation of NS5A p58 in cell culture. Cells, transfected with the HCV Con1 wild-type sequence, support HCV RNA replication upon addition of any of the three compounds. The effect of the kinase inhibitors was found to be synergistic with coadaptive mutations in NS3. This is the first direct demonstration that the presence of high amounts of NS5A-p58 causes inhibition of HCV RNA replication in cell culture and that this inhibition can be relieved by kinase inhibitors.

A 7-deaza-adenosine analog is a potent and selective inhibitor of hepatitis C virus replication with excellent pharmacokinetic properties

Improved treatments for chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection are needed due to the suboptimal response rates and deleterious side effects associated with current treatment options. The triphosphates of 2'-C-methyl-adenosine and 2'-C-methyl-guanosine were previously shown to be potent inhibitors of the HCV RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) that is responsible for the replication of viral RNA in cells. Here we demonstrate that the inclusion of a 7-deaza modification in a series of purine nucleoside triphosphates results in an increase in inhibitory potency against the HCV RdRp and improved pharmacokinetic properties. Notably, incorporation of the 7-deaza modification into 2'-C-methyl-adenosine results in an inhibitor with a 20-fold-increased potency as the 5'-triphosphate in HCV RdRp assays while maintaining the inhibitory potency of the nucleoside in the bicistronic HCV replicon and with reduced cellular toxicity. In contrast, while 7-deaza-2'-C-methyl-GTP also displays enhanced inhibitory potency in enzyme assays, due to poor cellular penetration and/or metabolism, the nucleoside does not inhibit replication of a bicistronic HCV replicon in cell culture. 7-Deaza-2'-C-methyl-adenosine displays promising in vivo pharmacokinetics in three animal species, as well as an acute oral lethal dose in excess of 2,000 mg/kg of body weight in mice. Taken together, these data demonstrate that 7-deaza-2'-C-methyl-adenosine is an attractive candidate for further investigation as a potential treatment for HCV infection.

Sensitivity of NS3 serine proteases from hepatitis C virus genotypes 2 and 3 to the inhibitor BILN 2061

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) displays a high degree of genetic variability. Six genotypes and more than 50 subtypes have been identified to date. In this report, kinetic profiles were determined for NS3 proteases of genotypes 1a, 1b, 2ac, 2b, and 3a, revealing no major differences in activity. In vitro sensitivity studies with BILN 2061 showed a decrease in affinity for proteases of genotypes 2 and 3 (K(i), 80 to 90 nM) compared to genotype 1 enzymes (K(i), 1.5 nM). To understand the reduced sensitivity of genotypes 2 and 3 to BILN 2061, active-site residues in the proximity of the inhibitor binding site were replaced in the genotype-1b enzyme with the corresponding genotype-2b or -3a residues. The replacement of five residues at positions 78, 79, 80, 122, and 132 accounted for most of the reduced sensitivity of genotype 2b, while replacement of residue 168 alone could account for the reduced sensitivity of genotype 3a. BILN 2061 remains a potent inhibitor of these non-genotype-1 NS3-NS4A proteins, with K(i) values below 100 nM. This in vitro potency, in conjunction with the good pharmacokinetic data reported for humans, suggests that there is potential for BILN 2061 as an antiviral agent for individuals infected with non-genotype-1 HCV.

Mutations conferring resistance to a potent hepatitis C virus serine protease inhibitor in vitro

BILN 2061 is a novel, specific hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3 serine protease inhibitor discovered by Boehringer Ingelheim that has shown potent activity against HCV replicons in tissue culture and is currently under clinical investigation for the treatment of HCV infection. The poor fidelity of the HCV RNA-dependent RNA polymerase will likely lead to the development of drug-resistant viruses in treated patients. The development of resistance to BILN 2061 was studied by the in vitro passage of HCV genotype 1b replicon cells in the presence of a fixed concentration of the drug. Three weeks posttreatment, four colonies were expanded for genotypic and phenotypic characterization. The 50% inhibitory concentrations of BILN 2061 for these colonies were 72- to 1,228-fold higher than that for the wild-type replicon. Sequencing of the individual colonies identified several mutations in the NS3 serine protease gene. Molecular clones containing the single amino acid substitution A156T, R155Q, or D168V resulted in 357-fold, 24-fold, and 144-fold reductions in susceptibility to BILN 2061, respectively, compared to the level of susceptibility shown by the wild-type replicon. Modeling studies indicate that all three of these residues are located in close proximity to the inhibitor binding site. These findings, in addition to the three-dimensional structure analysis of the NS3/NS4A serine protease inhibitor complex, provide a strategic guide for the development of next-generation inhibitors of HCV NS3/NS4A serine protease.

Resistance profile of a hepatitis C virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase benzothiadiazine inhibitor

Recently, a benzo-1,2,4-thiadiazine antiviral agent (C(21)H(21)N(3)O(4)S; compound 4) was shown to be a potent, highly specific inhibitor of the primary catalytic enzyme of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) replicase complex. In this study, we selected for resistance to confirm the mechanism of action for compound 4 in HCV replicon cells. As expected, spontaneous mutations or fluidity in the HCV polymerase (NS5B) coding sequence occurred upon routine passage of the HCV replicon cells in the absence of compound 4. After 1 month of culture in the presence of 10 microM compound 4, or 20 times the 50% inhibitory concentration of the replicon, replicon cells were almost 20-fold less susceptible to compound 4. Twenty-one NS5B cDNA clones were generated from the resistant replicon cells. Five mutations in the 21 NS5B clones were present at frequencies higher than that of control replicon cells, and no clone contained more than a single mutation within the polymerase gene. RNA-dependent RNA polymerase studies using purified recombinant NS5B containing these single point mutations allowed the identification of residue 414 as sufficient for biochemical resistance to compound 4. Further, the contribution of this residue to confer cell-based resistance to compound 4 was validated using a stable recombinant mutant replicon cell line which harbors a methionine-to-threonine change at residue 414. The potential for additional mutations in other nonstructural genes of HCV to contribute to the resistance profile of compound 4 is discussed.

Inhibition of the subgenomic hepatitis C virus replicon in huh-7 cells by 2'-deoxy-2'-fluorocytidine

2'-Deoxy-2'-fluorocytidine (FdC) is a potent inhibitor of the hepatitis C virus RNA replicon in culture, and FdC-5'-triphosphate is an effective inhibitor of the NS5B polymerase. Dynamic profiling of cell growth in an antiviral assay showed that FdC caused cytostasis due to an S-phase arrest. These observations demonstrate that FdC treatment is affecting both a viral target and a cellular target.

Chapter 22. Non-HIV antiviral agents

This chapter focuses on non-HIV antiviral agents. The development of antiviral agents to treat non-HIV infections is largely focused on therapies for the treatment of chronic hepatitis infections B and C. Nucleoside analog continue to be the mainstay of Hepatitis B Virus (HBV) therapeutics. The first small molecule inhibitor of Hepatitis C Virus (HCV), the NS3 protease inhibitor BILN-2061, entered phase 2 clinical trials, producing a striking reduction in viral load in treated individuals. The development of the HCV replicon system and its application to screening for antiviral agents provided tangible benefit with the disclosure of mechanistically and structurally diverse HCV inhibitors. Adefovir dipivoxil has been approved in the United States and the European Union for the treatment of HBV, providing a second small molecule antiviral to add to lamivudine (3TC) and the injectable protein IFNα as the only approved agents for treating HBV infection. The chapter also provides details of the inhibitors of hepatitis B and C virus, the inhibitors of simplex virus and human cytomegalovirus, the inhibitors of respiratory viruses and the inhibitors of West Nile virus and Papilloma virus.

Characterization of the inhibition of hepatitis C virus RNA replication by nonnucleosides

The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is necessary for the replication of viral RNA and thus represents an attractive target for drug development. Several structural classes of nonnucleoside inhibitors (NNIs) of HCV RNA polymerase have been described, including a promising series of benzothiadiazine compounds that efficiently block replication of HCV subgenomic replicons in tissue culture. In this work we report the selection of replicons resistant to inhibition by the benzothiadiazine class of NNIs. Four different single mutations were identified in separate clones, and all four map to the RNA polymerase gene, validating the polymerase as the antiviral target of inhibition. The mutations (M414T, C451R, G558R, and H95R) render the HCV replicons resistant to inhibition by benzothiadiazines, though the mutant replicons remain sensitive to inhibition by other nucleoside and NNIs of the HCV RNA polymerase. Additionally, cross-resistance studies and synergistic inhibition of the enzyme by combinations of a benzimidazole and a benzothiadiazine indicate the existence of nonoverlapping binding sites for these two structural classes of inhibitors.

In vitro resistance studies of hepatitis C virus serine protease inhibitors, VX-950 and BILN 2061: structural analysis indicates different resistance mechanisms

We have used a structure-based drug design approach to identify small molecule inhibitors of the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS3.4A protease as potential candidates for new anti-HCV therapies. VX-950 is a potent NS3.4A protease inhibitor that was recently selected as a clinical development candidate for hepatitis C treatment. In this report, we describe in vitro resistance studies using a subgenomic replicon system to compare VX-950 with another HCV NS3.4A protease inhibitor, BILN 2061, for which the Phase I clinical trial results were reported recently. Distinct drug-resistant substitutions of a single amino acid were identified in the HCV NS3 serine protease domain for both inhibitors. The resistance conferred by these mutations was confirmed by characterization of the mutant enzymes and replicon cells that contain the single amino acid substitutions. The major BILN 2061-resistant mutations at Asp(168) are fully susceptible to VX-950, and the dominant resistant mutation against VX-950 at Ala(156) remains sensitive to BILN 2061. Modeling analysis suggests that there are different mechanisms of resistance to VX-950 and BILN 2061.

Mechanism of action and antiviral activity of benzimidazole-based allosteric inhibitors of the hepatitis C virus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase

The RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is the catalytic subunit of the viral RNA amplification machinery and is an appealing target for the development of new therapeutic agents against HCV infection. Nonnucleoside inhibitors based on a benzimidazole scaffold have been recently reported. Compounds of this class are efficient inhibitors of HCV RNA replication in cell culture, thus providing attractive candidates for further development. Here we report the detailed analysis of the mechanism of action of selected benzimidazole inhibitors. Kinetic data and binding experiments indicated that these compounds act as allosteric inhibitors that block the activity of the polymerase prior to the elongation step. Escape mutations that confer resistance to these compounds map to proline 495, a residue located on the surface of the polymerase thumb domain and away from the active site. Substitution of this residue is sufficient to make the HCV enzyme and replicons resistant to the inhibitors. Interestingly, proline 495 lies in a recently identified noncatalytic GTP-binding site, thus validating it as a potential allosteric site that can be targeted by small-molecule inhibitors of HCV polymerase.

Characterization of resistance to non-obligate chain-terminating ribonucleoside analogs that inhibit hepatitis C virus replication in vitro

The urgent need for efficacious drugs to treat chronic hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection requires a concerted effort to develop inhibitors specific for virally encoded enzymes. We demonstrate that 2'-C-methyl ribonucleosides are efficient chain-terminating inhibitors of HCV genome replication. Characterization of drug-resistant HCV replicons defined a single S282T mutation within the active site of the viral polymerase that conferred loss of sensitivity to structurally related compounds in both replicon and isolated polymerase assays. Biochemical analyses demonstrated that resistance at the level of the enzyme results from a combination of reduced affinity of the mutant polymerase for the drug and an increased ability to extend the incorporated nucleoside analog. Importantly, the combination of these agents with interferon-alpha results in synergistic inhibition of HCV genome replication in cell culture. Furthermore, 2'-C-methyl-substituted ribonucleosides also inhibited replication of genetically related viruses such as bovine diarrhea virus, yellow fever, and West African Nile viruses. These observations, together with the finding that 2'-C-methyl-guanosine in particular has a favorable pharmacological profile, suggest that this class of compounds may have broad utility in the treatment of HCV and other flavivirus infections.