Exploring antibody polyspecificity using synthetic combinatorial libraries

High Throughput Chemistry in Drug Discovery

This chapter outlines the evolution of high throughput chemistry from its origins in the genome revolution of the early 1990's to its current practice as an integral tool in drug discovery, via the concept of the large “universal library” to the practice of small targeted arrays for structure–activity relationship generation. The technologies developed as part of this evolution are also outlined including early ACT peptide synthesisers and other automated and non-automated devices for both solid-supported and solution-based approaches. Finally, the chapter outlines several case studies of the application of high throughput synthesis to drug discovery.

The primary antibody repertoire represents a linked network of degenerate antigen specificities

In this study, germline Abs were used to select clones from a random dodecapeptide phage-display library. This revealed a much greater heterogeneity of binders than could be obtained with mutated daughter Abs that presumably had been selected in vivo by nominal Ag during active immune responses. We demonstrate that the pluripotency of germline Abs can subsequently be optimized by binding interactions that correlate with thermodynamic changes indicative of structural adaptations at the interface. This singular feature confers on each Ab a distinct window of Ag specificities, where the entropic space explored constitutes a thermodynamic signature of that particular Ab. Combining site plasticity may facilitate overlaps in such windows, with independent Abs converging onto common determinants with near identical binding affinities. In addition to providing for an amplified recognition potential, this networking of individual spectra of Ag specificities simultaneously facilitates the rapid recognition of Ag. Importantly, it also ensures that the primary response is composed of Abs with a high degree of "evolvability."

Solid phase synthesis of mixture-based acyclic and heterocyclic small molecule combinatorial libraries from resin-bound polyamides

The development of soluble mixture-based heterocyclic combinatorial libraries derived from amino acids and peptides is described. Starting with a "toolbox" of various chemical transformations, including alkylations, reductions, acylations, and the use of a variety of bifunctional reagents, the "libraries from libraries" concept has been expanded to encompass the development of more than fifty positional scanning combinatorial libraries each composed of tens of thousands of low molecular weight acyclic and heterocyclic compounds.

DiSSiMiL: Diverse Small Size Mini-Libraries applied to simple and rapid epitope mapping of a monoclonal antibody

Methods for screening protein-protein interactions are useful in protein science and for the generation of drug leads. We set out to develop a simplified assay to rapidly test protein-protein interactions, with a library of 400 pentapeptides comprising the 20 natural amino acids at two variable positions followed by three glycines (NH2-X1X2GGG). The library was used to identify the epitope of monoclonal antibody (mAb) 10D11 directed against the HOXD4 protein. Three pentapeptide 'hits' were selected (VYGGG, PWGGG and WKGGG) from direct binding assays screening for pentapeptide-mAb interactions; and from assays using pentapeptides in solution to competitively block HOXD4-mAb interactions. Alignment of the three 'hit' pentapeptides to the HOXD4 sequence predicts the mAb 10D11 epitope as NH2-VYPWMK. Synthesis of NH2-VYPWMK hexapeptide confirmed this prediction; and an alanine scan of HOXD4 ablated binding by mAb 10D11 when amino acids in the putative epitope were mutated. We propose that these simplified but diverse libraries can be used for rapid epitope mapping of some mAbs, and for generating lead small peptide analogs that interfere with receptor-ligand or other protein-protein interactions, or with enzymatic activity.

Changing the antigen binding specificity by single point mutations of an anti-p24 (HIV-1) antibody

The murine mAb CB4-1 raised against p24 (HIV-1) recognizes a linear epitope of the HIV-1 capsid protein. Additionally, CB4-1 exhibits cross-reactive binding to epitope-homologous peptides and polyspecific reactions to epitope nonhomologous peptides. Crystal structures demonstrate that the epitope peptide (e-pep) and the nonhomologous peptides adopt different conformations within the binding region of CB4-1. Site-directed mutagenesis of the fragment variable (Fv) region was performed using a single-chain (sc)Fv construct of CB4-1 to analyze binding contributions of single amino acid side chains toward the e-pep and toward one epitope nonhomologous peptide. The mutations of Ab amino acid side chains, which are in direct contact with the Ag, show opposite influences on the binding of the two peptides. Whereas the affinity of the e-pep to the CB4-1 scFv mutant heavy chain variable region Tyr(32)Ala is decreased 250-fold, the binding of the nonhomologous peptide remains unchanged. In contrast, the mutation light chain variable region Phe(94)Ala reduces the affinity of the nonhomologous peptide 10-fold more than it does for the e-pep. Thus, substantial changes in the specificity can be observed by single amino acid exchanges. Further characterization of the scFv mutants by substitutional analysis of the peptides demonstrates that the effect of a mutation is not restricted to contact residues. This method also reveals an inverse compensatory amino acid exchange for the nonhomologous peptide which increases the affinity to the scFv mutant light chain variable region Phe(94)Ala up to the level of the e-pep affinity to the wild-type scFv.

Dissection of bacteriophage lambda site-specific recombination using synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries

A wide variety of tools have been used to dissect biochemical pathways, inhibitors being chief among them. Combinatorial approaches have made the search for inhibitors much more efficient. We have applied such an approach to identify hexapeptides which inhibit different steps in a site-specific recombination reaction mediated by the bacteriophage lambda integrase protein. Integrase's mechanism is still incompletely understood, in large part because several pathway intermediates remain hard to isolate. Integrase-catalyzed recombination is very efficient, but if blocked, it is highly reversible to substrates; this combination makes some intermediates exceedingly transient. We have used synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries to screen for hexapeptides that affect the recombination pathway at different stages, and have identified two families of peptides: one probably blocks DNA cleavage, the other may stabilize the Holliday junction intermediates. These peptides do not resemble parts of integrase or any of the other helper functions in the pathway. The deconvolution of hexapeptide libraries based both on inhibition of an enzymatic reaction as well as on accumulation of reaction intermediates is a novel approach to finding useful tools for dissecting a biochemical pathway.

Epitope discovery using bacteriophage display: the minimum epitope of an anti-IRBP antibody

The purpose of this study was to determine, using random peptide library (RPL) technologies, the minimal epitope requirements of the mouse monoclonal anti-interphotoreceptor-retinoid-binding protein antibody, H3B5. This previously characterized antibody is used as an example to examine whether RPL's offer a relatively easy and rapid route to obtaining detailed epitope mapping data.A pentadecamer random peptide library (RPL) displayed on the major coat protein (gene 8) of filamentous bacteriophage (F88-4-15) was used as a target for selection by the anti-IRBP monoclonal antibody, H3B5. Three rounds of library selection were performed, and 90 of the resultant RPL clones were examined for affinity to H3B5 by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). DNA sequencing of ELISA positive clones provided sequence of the region encoding the random peptide. After three rounds of selection of the RPL, 76.7% of clones examined interacted with H3B5, 17.7% did not show significant binding and 6.6% bound to control antibody also. The essential elements of the peptide epitope were determined by sequence comparison of 24 clones to be the four amino-acid sequence (Aspartic or glutamic acid)-Proline-Arginine-(Leucine, Isoleucine or Valine). This motif [(D/E) PR (L/I/V)] is in agreement, but at greater resolution, than previous synthetic peptide studies where the motif AASEDPRL was identified. Other motifs were found which bound to H3B5 but did not share primary structure similarities (peptidomimetics). Selection from a RPL has rapidly defined the minimal requirements for the H3B5 epitope in fine detail. Such a process offers great potential for investigating antibody-antigen interactions and core sequences of an epitope, and enables the identification of motifs in other proteins which may be recognized by the antibody, providing information on possible cross-reactivity.

Exploring immunological specificity using synthetic peptide combinatorial libraries

The definition of epitopes for human B and T cells is fundamental for the understanding of the immune response mechanism and its role in the prevention and cause of human disease. This understanding can be applied to the design of diagnostics and synthetic vaccines. In recent years, the understanding of the specificity of B and T cells has been advanced significantly by the development and use of combinatorial libraries made up of thousands to millions of synthetic peptides. The use of this approach has had four major effects: first, the definition of high affinity ligands both for T cells and antibodies; second, the application of alternative means for identifying immunologically relevant peptides for use as potential preventive and therapeutic vaccines; third, a new appreciation of the requirements for TCR interactions with peptide-MHC complexes in immunogenicity; fourth, the establishment of new principles regarding the level of cross-reactivity in immunological recognition.

Detection of human antibodies using "convergent" combinatorial peptide libraries or "mixotopes" designed from a nonvariable antigen: application to the EBV viral capsid antigen p18

We have previously described the use of synthetic combinatorial "convergent" libraries, or "mixotopes" as immunogens or as antigens to represent naturally hypervariable sequences. The success of this approach suggests that such a mixture of closely related peptides could, at least in part, conveniently represent a nonvariable epitope during its multiple interactions with an antibody population. To address this possibility, we have designed from a non-variable immunodominant peptide of the EBV-viral capsid antigen of 18 kD (VCAp18) a series of three mixotopes containing from 65,000 to 16 million combinatorial sequences. The reactivity of VCAp18 and its three derived mixotopes was examined in ELISA towards a collection of 74 human sera from documented EBV-negative or EBV-positive donors, and analyzed in terms of sensitivity and specificity. Following the observation that the two least degenerated mixotopes could improve the sensitivity of detection of some sera of low reactivity for VCAp18, we decided to combine each mixotope with the VCAp18 peptide. In the case of the least degenerated mixotope in combination with VCAp18, sensitivity and specificity for immunoenzymatic EBV-serodiagnosis, were enhanced to 100%. Our results suggest that synthetic "convergent" combinatorial peptide libraries or "mixotopes," designed from nonvariable antigens, could be useful adjuncts to an antigenic single-sequence peptide in immunoenzymatic serodiagnosis.

All-D peptides recognized by an anti-carbohydrate antibody identified from a positional scanning library

Monoclonal antibodies recognize antigens with high affinity and specificity, but the structural basis for molecular mimicry remains unclear. It is often assumed that cross-reactive antigens share some structural similarity that is specifically recognized by a monoclonal antibody. Recent studies using combinatorial libraries, which are composed of millions of sequences, have examined antibody cross-reactivity in a manner entirely different from traditional epitope mapping approaches. Here, peptide libraries were screened against an anti-carbohydrate monoclonal antibody for the identification of peptide mimics. Positional scanning libraries composed of all-l or all-d hexapeptides were screened for inhibition of monoclonal antibody HGAC 39.G3 binding to an antigen displaying N-acetyl-d-glucosamine (GlcNAc) residues on a polyrhamnose backbone. Inhibitory activity by mixtures from the all-d hexapeptide library was greater than the activity from the all-l libraries. The most active d-amino acid residues defined in each of the six positions of the library were selected to prepare 27 different individual hexapeptides. The sequence Ac-yryygl-NH2 was specifically recognized by mAb HGAC 39.G3 with a relative affinity of 300 nM when measured in a competitive binding assay. The contributions to overall specificity of the residues of the all-d peptide (Ac-yryygl-NH2) in binding to mAb HGAC 39.G3 were examined with a series of truncation, l and d-amino acid substitution, and retro analogs. Dimeric forms of the all-d peptide were recognized with tenfold to 100-fold greater affinities relative to the monomer. The all-d peptide was found to inhibit mAb HGAC 39.G3 binding to an anti-idiotype antibody with approximately 1000-fold greater affinity than GlcNAc. As demonstrated here, the study of immune recognition using combinatorial chemistry may offer new insights into the molecular basis of cross-reactivity.

Characterization of antigen-antibody interactions using single substitution analogs and mixture-based synthetic combinatorial libraries

In an effort to use monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) as selective probes for early detection of breast cancer, the specificities of a number of antipeptide mAbs have been studied at the individual amino acid level using single substitution peptide analogs and peptide combinatorial libraries. In this study, the mapping results are presented for mAb172-12A4, which was raised against the haptenic peptide LGSGAFGTIYKG(C), corresponding to residues 138-149 of the oncogene v-erbB. This peptide is homologous with a region in epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and human oncogene c-erbB-2, and contains the ATP binding motif that is common among protein kinases. The substitution profile of this interaction correlated well with the results from the screening of hexa- and decapeptide positional scanning libraries. Based on the results of this mAb's specificity for the antigenic determinant (-AFGTIYK-), proteins that have sequence homology were found from a database search of human sequences. Thirty-two unique peptide sequences, a majority of which was from protein kinases, were synthesized and tested for recognition by mAb 172-12A4. Eleven peptides had activities that differed from the original peptide by less than an order of magnitude, and the activities for 29 of the 32 (90%) could be accurately predicted based on the individual substitution analog results. While both epitope mapping approaches address the amino acid level of mAb specificity, positional scanning libraries offer an advantage of identifying the positional importance of each antigenic determinant residue without any prior knowledge of the mAb's specificity. The fine specificity mapping of peptide-specific mAbs using the synthetic tools illustrated here will be useful for the development of immunodiagnostics that detect cancer-related proteins in clinical samples.

Combinatorial chemistry: from peptides and peptidomimetics to small organic and heterocyclic compounds

Modified dipeptides have been used successfully for the generation of a variety of small organic and heterocyclic combinatorial libraries, including linear urea, polyamine, hydantoin, thiohydantoin, cyclic urea, cyclic thiourea and bicyclic guanidine. The synthesis and screening results for a number of these libraries are described. The solid phase synthesis of heterocyclic compounds such as diazepine and thiomorpholinone are also described.

Combinatorial search for diagnostic agents: Lyme antibody H9724 as an example

Two peptide libraries, Ac-MXXXXXBBRM and Ac-VXXXXXBBRM, were constructed on TentaGel solid support to search for ligands that bind tightly with the H9724 Lyme antibody. By using an on-bead ELISA, approximately 120 ligands were selected as candidates for further study. Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization mass spectrometry analysis of the candidate ligands indicated a high rate of occurrence of certain amino acids at the randomized positions. On the basis of the initial screening results, a small library was designed and iteratively synthesized. Subsequent library screenings led to the identification of four peptides, Ac-PQEEGX-NH2 (X = R, K, A, D), that showed specific affinity to the antibody. This combination of solid-phase screening and iterative synthesis is an effective strategy for rapid identification of ligands that bind tightly with disease-specific antibodies and should be applicable, at least in principle, to other ligand-receptor systems. This combinatorial library approach can also be a useful tool for the discovery of novel diagnostic agents.

Molecular basis for the binding promiscuity of an anti-p24 (HIV-1) monoclonal antibody

Multiple binding capabilities utilized by specific protein-to-protein interactions in molecular recognition events are being documented increasingly but remain poorly understood at the molecular level. We identified five unrelated peptides that compete with each other for binding to the paratope region of the monoclonal anti-p24 (HIV-1) antibody CB4-1 by using a synthetic positional scanning combinatorial library XXXX[B1,B2,B3,X1,X2,X3]XXXX (14 mers; 68,590 peptide mixtures in total) prepared by spot synthesis. Complete sets of substitution analogs of the five peptides revealed key interacting residues, information that led to the construction of binding supertopes derived from each peptide. These supertope sequences were identified in hundreds of heterologous proteins, and those proteins that could be obtained were shown to bind CB4-1. Implications of these findings for immune escape mechanisms and autoimmunity are discussed.